The Fiamengo File - December 19, 2019


Feminists Play Fast and Loose with Data Again - The Fiamengo File Episode 110

Why Are Women Unhappy - The Fiamengo File Episode 109 Feminism's Only Standards Are Double Standards - TFF Episode 111

Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

140.65

Word count

2,192

Sentence count

114

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiomingo.
00:00:04 Imagine the following scenario.
00:00:07 A 16-year-old girl is visiting her boyfriend aged 18 to watch TV.
00:00:12 They've been dating for six months and are madly in love and have talked a lot about going all the way,
00:00:18 but there's never been a perfect time.
00:00:20 Tonight, when her boyfriend opens the door, he's beaming with anticipation and tells her,
00:00:25 my parents won't be back for hours.
00:00:29 The girl wants to tell him that she doesn't really feel ready, but she knows how disappointed he'll
00:00:34 be and she definitely doesn't want to risk losing such a wonderful boyfriend. So although it isn't
00:00:40 really her choice, she agrees to have sex with him for the first time. 0.96
00:00:44 was this girl raped most of us probably wouldn't think so but according to a new study garnering 1.00
00:01:01 a lot of media attention she was the inflammatory headlines tell us that quote one in 16 women
00:01:09 report their first sexual experiences were rape or assault, or even more emphatically from CNN,
00:01:16 for one in 16 U.S. women their first experience with sexual intercourse was rape, study says.
00:01:24 Looking into the study, we can see the dubious manner in which researchers arrived at such
00:01:30 alarming news. The study was published online in the JAMA Journal of Internal Medicine on September
00:01:38 16th, 2019. It analyzed data gathered over six years in three waves of interviews from 2011 to
00:01:47 2017 by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. These were interviews of over 13,000
00:01:55 American women aged 18 to 44. And the study found that 6.5% of the women reported what the
00:02:03 researchers called forced sexual initiation. Extrapolated to the entire U.S. population of
00:02:10 women in that age group, that's more than 3.3 million women found to be victims of forced
00:02:16 sexual initiation. And we'll get to that crucial definition a little later. A range of negative
00:02:22 health and psychological outcomes were reported by these women at higher rates than experienced 0.65
00:02:28 by women whose first sexual experience was not forced. These negative health outcomes included
00:02:34 pelvic inflammatory disease, endometriosis, menstrual problems, general poor physical health,
00:02:40 difficulty completing tasks outside the home owing to a physical or mental condition,
00:02:45 and illicit drug use. The researchers admit that it is impossible to say that forced sexual
00:02:52 initiation caused these other reported problems. There may be no relation at all, or it may be that
00:02:59 women with poor mental health or physical problems are more likely to remember their first sexual
00:03:05 experience negatively. But the researchers dwell on their findings of correlation in a way to
00:03:11 suggest that causation is likely. And they also emphasize the need for, quote, sociocultural
00:03:17 changes to prevent sexual violence. In other words, they're advocating yet more wide-ranging
00:03:25 feminist programs and policies to shame men and empower women. Reports of the study play up the
00:03:34 lurid 1 in 16 number and even extrapolate that number beyond the survey group. The main author
00:03:41 of the study, Dr. Laura Hawks, is quoted in NPR News as saying, quote, it's quite alarming,
00:03:49 and that's just the tip of the iceberg because this study is only including women aged 18 to 44.
00:03:54 You can imagine that if we asked this of women of all ages, the absolute number would be many
00:04:01 millions higher, end quote. Well, actually, that depends on the fertility of one's imagination 0.52
00:04:08 and how one defines many. Because if the absolute number in the 18 to 44 age group is extrapolated
00:04:15 to be about 3.3 million American women, then expanding the survey to include women of all
00:04:20 ages might raise the number by another 2 to 3 million or possibly even a bit more. But it also
00:04:28 might not. And it well might lower the dramatic one in 16 figure, as it is quite possible that
00:04:36 older women who came of age at a time when fewer young people were sexually active would report
00:04:43 fewer incidents of coerced sexual initiation. If you're having sex for the first time with
00:04:48 your fiancé or husband rather than with someone you barely know, you're less likely to define it
00:04:55 as coerced. But given that the survey did not include women in other age groups, it is highly
00:05:02 irresponsible of the lead researcher to be asking us to imagine the, quote, many millions more women
00:05:09 likely to have been sexually coerced. And it is also highly irresponsible to speak as if the study
00:05:15 shows us anything definitive about numbers of women raped, because it doesn't. It shows us
00:05:22 the number of women who reported, emphasis on reported, that their first sexual experience
00:05:28 was not their choice. And we'll get to what that really means in a minute. It's not much of a
00:05:34 stretch to guess that Dr. Laura Hawks is a feminist. Her study and the articles written about it 0.92
00:05:42 contain the typical misrepresentations and slippery wording we have come to expect of
00:05:47 feminist approaches to counting female victims, which almost always seek many millions more.
00:05:56 Now, before I get to the actual survey data, I want to mention one other thing.
00:06:03 Perhaps not incidentally, the study notes that, quote, response rates for the survey
00:06:08 ranged from 67% to 73% for the included years, end quote, which is another way of saying
00:06:16 that the non-participant rate, in other words, the percentage of women who declined to answer
00:06:22 the questions was between 28% and 33%. Now, experts disagree about the significance of
00:06:30 non-response rates, but certainly some researchers are emphatic that any response lower than around
00:06:38 80% should raise alarm bells. For example, Stephen Ciro et al. note in a paper published in 2006 for
00:06:46 the Association for Information Systems journal that non-response significantly impacts the degree
00:06:53 to which one can make accurate inferences from the survey data. They confirm that an 80% response is
00:07:00 the gold standard. But even with that, they stress, still means that one in five didn't respond.
00:07:08 So with a response rate of 67% for one of the waves of this survey, we're looking at
00:07:14 one in three women not answering the questions. It's a relatively high non-response rate, and it
00:07:23 does raise some question about the representativeness of those women who did answer.
00:07:28 But putting that aside, far more serious is the methodology of the survey, specifically
00:07:35 the survey question about sexual initiation and the follow-up questions, which employ an overly
00:07:42 broad definition of coerced sex. So let's look. Respondents were initially asked,
00:07:50 would you say that this first vaginal intercourse with a male was voluntary or not voluntary? That
00:07:57 is, did you choose to have sex of your own free will or not? Then if they answered no to that
00:08:06 question, women were asked follow-up questions about what the researchers are calling the quote
00:08:11 method of sexual coercion, even though it hasn't been established that coercion, which is normally
00:08:18 defined as threat or force, was used at all. And many of the methods named aren't necessarily
00:08:26 coercive in any way. Here are the follow-up questions about the so-called methods of
00:08:32 coercion. Quote, were you given alcohol or drugs? Did you do what he said because he was bigger
00:08:38 than you or a grown-up and you were young? Were you told that the relationship would end if you
00:08:44 didn't have sex? Were you pressured into it by his words or actions, but without threat of harm?
00:08:53 Were you threatened with physical harm or injury? Were you physically hurt or injured?
00:09:00 Were you physically held down? Participants could report more than one type of coercion.
00:09:08 Well, at least half of these questions aren't about coercion at all, and we'll come back to
00:09:15 them shortly. But even without those follow-up questions muddying of the waters, there are a
00:09:22 number of obvious reasons why someone who was not coerced might still answer no to the loaded
00:09:29 question, did you choose to have sex of your own free will? Now, most basically, the language of
00:09:37 the question is simply not clear. The question assumes that any limit on freedom is coercion,
00:09:44 but it isn't. You can choose to do something and consent to it, even if it wasn't an entirely
00:09:51 free choice. If my friend wants to order Thai food, and I reluctantly agree, even though I
00:09:58 don't want Thai food, I could certainly say quite accurately that eating Thai food wasn't my choice,
00:10:04 but I still consented to it. And it would be ridiculous to claim after the meal that my
00:10:09 eating the food was coerced, even if my friend pleaded with me to consent to it. We consent to
00:10:16 things all the time that we didn't choose because life is full of trade-offs and negotiated
00:10:22 compromises. And sex is no different. In fact, sex may be one of the biggest areas of negotiation
00:10:28 and trade-off between men and women. Moreover, it's also possible that a respondent could answer 0.70
00:10:35 no to the question about whether she chose to have sex, because feminists have been claiming 1.00
00:10:40 for at least the last 10 years that the only sex that isn't coerced involves what feminists call 1.00
00:10:46 affirmative consent, which they often define as an enthusiastic yes and active participation. 0.58
00:10:54 but actually many women and some men for that matter are silent and passive during sex
00:11:02 preferring to say nothing. To complicate things further, first-time sex can involve lots of
00:11:09 insecurity, uncertainty, fear, emotions that seem anything but affirmative but lack of enthusiasm
00:11:18 doesn't equate to coercion. But perhaps most seriously, the researchers don't distinguish
00:11:26 at all between persuasion and coercion. One can be persuaded to have sex because everybody else
00:11:34 seems to be having it, because one's partner expresses impatience, because one's partner
00:11:39 expresses love, or for many other reasons. If a man says, please honey, do it for me, and his
00:11:45 girlfriend says, okay, I'll do it for you. Well, she's allowed her boyfriend to persuade her.
00:11:51 Ludicrously, the researchers might well count her as having been coerced or raped. Let's look again 0.92
00:11:58 at the worst of the follow-up questions on the so-called methods of coercion. Quote,
00:12:05 were you given alcohol or drugs? This is a misleading question. It doesn't distinguish
00:12:12 between having a tranquilizer slipped into your drink without your knowledge and willingly gulping
00:12:16 down a few glasses of wine to get in the mood. You can be given drugs against your will, but you can
00:12:22 also be given them because you asked for them. Did you do what he said because he was bigger than you
00:12:31 or a grown-up and you were young? This awkwardly phrased question stretches the idea of coercion to
00:12:38 an unhelpful extent. It takes the biological fact that the average male is bigger than the average
00:12:43 female, also that the average female tends to be attracted to an older male and vice versa, 0.67
00:12:49 and turns these into tools of coercion. But they're only coercive if they involve threats of harm. 0.82
00:12:58 Were you told that the relationship would end if you didn't have sex? This is a leading question
00:13:05 on the matter of coercion. Being told the relationship would end without sex could be
00:13:09 a simple statement of fact. Hey Marge, I've waited long enough. More commonly, it would be a form of
00:13:16 verbal manipulation, and men and women verbally manipulate one another with these kinds of
00:13:21 emotional threats all the time. It's the other person's choice, still, whether to give in to
00:13:27 that manipulation or not, but either way, it's not coercion. Were you pressured into it by his
00:13:34 words or actions, but without threat of harm. As I've already said, the question conflates
00:13:40 coercion, which involves force or threat, with a whole range of forms of persuasion, such as
00:13:47 flattery, promises, arguments, expensive gifts, sulking, and so on. Some of these may be unethical
00:13:55 or immoral, sure, but they're far from criminal. A woman who consents to verbal pressure that 0.99
00:14:03 didn't involve any threat of harm wasn't coerced. She was persuaded. Not surprisingly, over 50%
00:14:10 of the women listed as coerced in this study were coerced by this kind of verbal pressure.
00:14:23 The final three questions in this list more clearly indicate force and or threat, but even
00:14:28 they have their ambiguities. Were you physically hurt or injured is a very broad question that
00:14:33 could refer to accidental injury such as vaginal tearing that can easily occur in consensual sex.
00:14:39 Were you physically held down? Might be answered, yes, he was on top of me. It's not clear that
00:14:44 coercion is involved there either. Significantly, the researchers never asked if the respondents
00:14:52 said no or indicated in any other manner that they didn't wish to have sex. Why did they not
00:15:00 ask that question, the question that is widely understood to most clearly indicate the fact of
00:15:05 rape? I think it was because they weren't really interested in getting an accurate account of rape
00:15:11 victims in the United States. So I have to conclude that based on all of these problems,
00:15:17 it is impossible to trust the 1 in 16 figure put forward by Dr. Laura Hawks and quoted by
00:15:23 mainstream news sources. Not surprisingly, the survey has no data at all on male victims
00:15:31 of sexual coercion, but that's another story altogether.