The Fiamengo File - December 13, 2019


Why Are Women Unhappy - The Fiamengo File Episode 109

The Women Are Wonderful Effect - The Fiamengo File Episode 108 Feminists Play Fast and Loose with Data Again - The Fiamengo File Episode 110

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

144.01

Word count

1,583

Sentence count

54

Harmful content

Misogyny

24

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 For years I've been hearing that women's happiness is declining in tandem with the
00:00:06 women's movement. Surprise, surprise, you might say. Women have been treated like spoiled
00:00:11 children and that's bound to create misery. But let's explore a bit further by looking
00:00:16 at a report titled The Paradox of Declining Female Happiness by University of Pennsylvania
00:00:22 researchers Betsy Stevenson and Justin Wolfers.
00:00:36 The report is not new, I should mention, having been published in 2008, but it is an extensive
00:00:42 study dealing with multiple life satisfaction surveys, and its findings remain relevant to
00:00:48 the present day when we hear a great deal about what more needs to be done for women to help them
00:00:53 achieve feminist goals. Though it never says so directly, the report certainly suggests that
00:01:00 helping women achieve the goals of the feminist movement is almost certainly the last thing women
00:01:05 need. The overall diagnosis in the report is clear. Women's self-reported happiness and life
00:01:13 satisfaction have been dropping since the 1970s in all areas that the report looked at and across
00:01:21 all demographics and geographical areas with one notable exception which we'll get to in a minute
00:01:26 women's happiness has diminished both in absolute terms in other words in comparison to women of
00:01:32 previous eras and in relation to men and this despite the fact that women have many more life
00:01:38 choices now than in the past and believe they are doing better as a group. The report emphasizes
00:01:45 the seeming paradox of such findings. While labor force outcomes have significantly improved for
00:01:52 women, they're not feeling better about their lives. The one exception to the trend, at least 0.97
00:01:58 as of 2008, is that African-American women have become happier over this period in parallel with
00:02:04 rising happiness amongst African American men. So how could it be that the vast majority of
00:02:11 women, excluding black women, have become less happy since the 1970s? The researchers don't
00:02:18 pretend to have an answer, but they do consider a number of theories, most of them not surprisingly
00:02:24 feminist theories, some of them laugh out loud, obtuse. One such theory is that as women are 0.99
00:02:31 working more outside the home, the total amount of work that women do has increased creating stress.
00:02:38 But the researchers are quick to admit that most time use surveys don't support such an assertion
00:02:44 because women's work in the home has actually decreased as a result of time and labor saving
00:02:49 technology and men are doing a lot more household work than in the past. So the researchers have to
00:02:55 consider refinements on this theory. They mentioned the idea that women have maintained the quote 0.99
00:03:01 emotional responsibility for home and family, end quote. In other words, men may be putting in more 0.55
00:03:08 hours on housework, but the, quote, burden of home production, as they call it, may still be
00:03:14 primarily borne by women. The fact that such a thing cannot possibly be measured makes it an 1.00
00:03:20 attractive theory for feminists, and our researchers mention it with the respect that baseless feminist
00:03:26 theories are usually given. Another theory mentioned by the researchers, also conveniently
00:03:32 unmeasurable, is that men's mix of outside the homework and household responsibilities are more
00:03:39 pleasant than women's. This theory caused tears of laughter to pour down my face. 1.00
00:03:47 All of these explanations partake of a familiar trend in feminist thought, arguing that the
00:03:52 women's movement actually benefited men more than it benefited women. Somehow those pesky men
00:03:58 always work things to their advantage. Also partaking of the men benefit conspiracy theory,
00:04:06 though locating the conspiracy in nature rather than society, is the idea that while it's men's
00:04:12 real wages that have declined since the 1970s, the resulting decline in household income bothers
00:04:19 women more than it bothers men. In other words, both men and women are suffering economically,
00:04:24 but women feel the pain more. Their reasoning is a tad circular. Women are less happy
00:04:30 because they get sad about things more. More interestingly, in my opinion, the researchers
00:04:37 also briefly mentioned two other speculative explanations that have to do with the psychology
00:04:42 of utopian mass movements with their promise of a near-perfect world just on the horizon.
00:04:48 And the researchers suggest that women's decline in life satisfaction may stem from a greater
00:04:55 tendency among women now to compare their lives with men's lives, and also a tendency to measure
00:05:02 their lives against the promises of the feminist movement. I think these latter two possibilities
00:05:08 do make some sense. Women do now tend to compare their lives to those of men more than they once
00:05:15 did when men and women's spheres were more separate, and women have been encouraged to
00:05:20 believe that their lives are much more difficult than men's without actually knowing much about
00:05:25 men's difficulties. Relatedly, women tend to compare the actual state of their lives with
00:05:31 their various disappointments and difficulties to the promises of freedom and empowerment held
00:05:37 out by the feminist movement, and they find that the feminist dream hasn't been fulfilled in their
00:05:44 lives. Men, unlike women, tend not to compare their lives to those of women, and men have little
00:05:51 expectation of utopian perfection. Now, the researchers don't explore these hypotheses in
00:05:57 any detail, and in general, they shy away from speculating about the impacts of the women's
00:06:02 movement. However, it seems it would be hard for any honest analyst looking at the study to avoid
00:06:08 the conclusion that the women's movement has been a failure. What else can one say about a movement
00:06:16 that, while attaining many of its stated goals, has utterly failed to achieve happiness or even
00:06:22 basic satisfaction for those it claims to advocate for? Feminists themselves, of course, have all 0.99
00:06:29 sorts of ways of explaining this apparent paradox, most of the explanations having to do 1.00
00:06:34 with the persistence of supposed male privilege and conveniently always leading to calls
00:06:39 for more to be done for women. But these excuses can work only so long after a certain number of 0.92
00:06:45 years during which all the measurable goals of feminism are being fulfilled, greater sexual 1.00
00:06:51 freedom, greater workplace choices, higher wages. The caveat that feminism is not materially 1.00
00:06:57 benefiting women can simply no longer be maintained. The almost inevitable conclusion
00:07:02 that arises, not mentioned in the report, must be that feminism has not helped women to be happier
00:07:08 and that more feminism may well lead to even greater female unhappiness. Rising wages, sexual 1.00
00:07:16 freedom, the ability to abort one's children without compunction, the ability to divorce one's 0.98
00:07:22 husband and still live off his earnings, the ability to act like a slut and be applauded for 0.75
00:07:28 it none of these are having a good impact on women in fact quite the opposite it's worth noting also
00:07:33 that according to the report even women who are not pursuing a career accessing abortion divorcing
00:07:40 their husbands or in other ways living the life encouraged by feminism also report declining 0.93
00:07:46 happiness feminism has affected the very cultural air all women breathe now in the final paragraph
00:07:54 of the report the authors quote a researcher named ed dieener who raises a significant issue
00:08:01 they quote him to the effect that quote objective conditions such as health comfort virtue or or
00:08:09 wealth are quote notably absent end quote from subjective well-being being in good health for
00:08:17 example has some role to play in happiness but one can be miserable despite being in good health
00:08:23 But the word that jumped out at me from Diener's list was virtue, a word that is otherwise entirely
00:08:30 missing from this report and from most modern considerations of happiness. It wasn't so for
00:08:37 most philosophers of happiness until our own era. For the ancient Greeks and for Christian
00:08:43 philosophers, for example, happiness was not a particular kind of feeling, but a particular sort
00:08:49 of life, governed by reason and ethical practice. And previous generations of women were taught
00:08:57 that happiness related directly to virtue, and that virtue consisted in living for others, 0.71
00:09:03 in being chaste, being a helpmeet to one's husband, devoting oneself to one's children,
00:09:09 or in some other manner pursuing a good life as a nun or a healer, a mystic or a scholar. 1.00
00:09:16 Feminism deliberately turned such an idea on its head. 0.97
00:09:20 Chastity, fidelity, self-sacrifice, and goodness were, according to feminism, 1.00
00:09:24 the way men prevented women from pursuing their own desires. 1.00
00:09:30 Feminism was all about self-fulfillment, 0.99
00:09:32 and rejecting the traditional markers of female virtue was considered good in itself. 0.67
00:09:38 So in the years since the 1970s,
00:09:41 any discussion of female goodness has essentially been ruled out of bounds.
00:09:47 While men have always been measured against a standard of the good man, this is one who
00:09:53 supports his family, including his wife, defends justice, protects the weak, defeats evil,
00:09:59 the ideal of the good woman has become a pre-1960s relic. Ask a feminist what a good woman is, 0.68
00:10:07 she will either laugh scornfully and refuse to answer or say that a good woman fights against 1.00
00:10:13 patriarchy. In other words, she'll give you an oppositional identity with no positive content. 1.00
00:10:20 The real problem with feminism, as this report suggests, is that it destroyed the positive 1.00
00:10:27 content of womanhood and replaced it with useless anger. Traditional philosophers have always been 1.00
00:10:35 divided as to whether being virtuous is sufficient for happiness, but they were agreed that without
00:10:42 virtue, happiness was impossible. In being opposed to virtue, feminism has undermined the sources of 1.00
00:10:50 real happiness for women, and more feminism will undoubtedly lead to even greater bitterness and 1.00
00:10:58 and dissatisfaction. 1.00