00:00:00When it was announced by his daughter a few months ago that Jordan Peterson had gone to Russia to be treated for an excruciating dependency on a prescribed anti-anxiety medication, many people responded with sadness and concern.
00:00:18Some others reacted with happiness and satisfaction.
00:00:23This video is about one of the latter examples.
00:00:30most people learned about jordan peterson's condition from a canadian newspaper the national
00:00:42post in an article dated february 7th called jordan peterson's year of absolute hell the
00:00:51comment section while containing its share of well-wishers was also peppered with vaunting
00:00:57declarations clean your room bucko smirked one another pontificated he's probably just malnourished0.97
00:01:06from eating only beef how dumb can a person be to think that is a healthy way to live0.88
00:01:12but then i never thought he was very bright in the first place a professor of medicine and law0.86
00:01:19at the university of ottawa amir ataran tweeted using the hashtag karma quote jordan peterson
00:01:27oracle to gullible young man preacher of macho toughness and hectoring bully to snowflakes
00:01:33is addicted to strong drugs and his brain riddled with neurological damage he deserves as much
00:01:40sympathy as he showed others end quote this professor's tweets were filled with crudely0.81
00:01:46reductive allegations attempting to show that Peterson was a heartless scoundrel, undeserving
00:01:52of compassion despite the near-death severity of his experience. And in the days following,
00:01:58one could find many examples of people taking to social media to crow over a great man brought low.
00:02:05That's the dark side of social media, and not surprising. But when a serious article appears
00:02:12in a supposedly serious magazine doing almost exactly the same thing it's notable in march the
00:02:19new republic published an article titled what happened to jordan peterson by freelance
00:02:25journalist lindsey berstein allegedly responding to the fact that michaela peterson's description
00:02:31of her father's ordeal quote was met with bafflement by doctors and lay people alike end
00:02:38quote. So Bairstein, an award-winning investigative journalist, stepped in to inform us.
00:02:46Purporting to present a medically-based overview of Peterson's condition and treatment,
00:02:51she crafted an intellectualized version of the personal smears that abounded on Twitter,
00:02:57full of false assertions about the nature of Peterson's public statements meant to make him0.98
00:03:03appear a self-deluded self-aggrandizing hypocrite at best an outright dangerous charlatan at worst0.90
00:03:13let me say up front that of course peterson as a very public figure is rightly open to criticism0.97
00:03:19but when the criticism is based on distortions and fabrications it becomes an object lesson in how
00:03:26self-declared thought leaders delude themselves and others about their motives. In the remainder
00:03:33of this video, I'm going to look in some detail at Bairstein's attack on Peterson to show how every
00:03:40major assertion is either unproven and unprovable or outright false. From the beginning, it is
00:03:49obvious that Lindsay Bairstein doesn't wish Peterson well and takes some satisfaction in
00:03:55his apparent fall from the pinnacle he had reached. After telling us that Peterson has been, quote,
00:04:01called the most influential public intellectual in the Western world, end quote, she mentions that
00:04:07he is an exponent of the Jungian concept of the hero's journey, and then in a parenthesis says
00:04:12that, quote, he has described himself without apparent irony as being raised and toughened
00:04:19in the frigid wastelands of northern Alberta, end quote. Well, perhaps the irony was just not
00:04:26apparent to Berstein, but seriously, I'm not sure why she thought it remarkable that Peterson would
00:04:33say this, quote, without irony. Why need he be ironic? Northern Alberta is a harsh land that
00:04:40toughens those who live there, many of them, as Peterson reports, in Twelve Rules for Life,
00:04:45desperate to escape. So is Peterson a tough character? I would say so. Over the last four
00:04:54years, he withstood sustained attack for questioning the wisdom of Bill C-16, the bill
00:05:01introduced by the Canadian government to make gender identity and gender expression protected
00:05:06grounds of discrimination and to compel the use of preferred pronouns. The attack on Peterson
00:05:12included a letter signed by hundreds of his own colleagues at the University of Toronto
00:05:17calling on the university to fire him. As far as I know, he had not a single declared defender
00:05:24among the people he had worked with for decades. He came very close to being fired for questioning
00:05:30a government decree about gender. He was called a transphobe, a queerphobe, a misogynist, and a0.75
00:05:36danger to the safety of marginalized students. Academics all across the world spoke out against
00:05:43him. Journalists and broadcasters put him in their crosshairs. He was baited and interrogated,
00:05:49his every statement scrutinized and taken out of context if possible to imply that he sought a
00:05:55return to the dark ages. Withstanding all that did indeed require toughness of a sort that very
00:06:03few people, especially academics, possess. And he not only withstood, but did so with grace and wit
00:06:11and intellectual virtuosity, routing Channel 4 news presenter Kathy Newman, for one, with a
00:06:19winsome smile. But Bairstein, mentioning none of this, has already left facts behind. She goes on
00:06:28saying, quote, his stern ethos of self-help and bootstrapping has made him a darling of the so-called
00:06:36intellectual dark web and a gateway drug for countless budding right-wingers who have stumbled
00:06:42upon one of his lectures on YouTube, end quote. This is a supercilious statement full of snide
00:06:50oversimplifications. It's hard to know where to begin with it. As for, quote, stumbling upon one
00:06:56his lectures on youtube i'd love to know how bearstein came to learn of jordan peterson
00:07:03did she receive some form of telepathic communication a message from the gods perhaps
00:07:09or instead of stumbling did she stride toward his videos having been alerted by her friends1.00
00:07:16that a very bad man was attracting the attention of the contemptible plebs and should be stopped
00:07:23by the righteous elect it's actually not clear how much of peterson's voluminous writing and
00:07:30lectures this author has actually bothered with she seems to be going mainly on hearsay
00:07:37as for example in calling peterson's a quote stern ethos this is a man who has wept numerous times
00:07:47in interviews and videos when he spoke of the literally hundreds of thousands of people who
00:07:52have been touched by his message that their lives matter yes he appeals to the hundreds of thousands
00:07:59of young men in particular as well as others who have been made to feel that their society doesn't
00:08:05like them very much due to their sex and or race he has personally spoken to thousands of people
00:08:12after his talks who have told him how his words of encouragement and sanity gave them the belief
00:08:19that they weren't worthless that seems a lot less stern than the countless workshops and
00:08:26university courses and magazine articles and government programs and political leaders
00:08:31statements advising men to acknowledge their toxic masculinity and their unearned privilege
00:08:38and their propensity to benefit from the rape culture they are supposedly complicit in for
00:08:45some of these men jordan peterson has been literally a lifesaver berstein's full phrase
00:08:53referred to peterson's quote stern message of self-help and bootstrapping and quote one of the
00:08:59most ludicrous of her many mischaracterizations peterson's bestseller 12 rules for life is a
00:09:07combination of philosophical reflection and personal narrative informed by peterson's work
00:09:13in clinical psychology and his study of myth it is hardly a self-help book except in the loosest sense
00:09:22using the bible jung nietzsche dostoyevsky solzhenitsyn and others it seeks to demonstrate
00:09:29that the quest for meaning is still possible and necessary in our age and is the best
00:09:36bulwark against the inevitability of suffering and human evil for many of peterson's followers
00:09:44intellectually nourished on little other than race gender and sexuality and constantly being told
00:09:50that their only significant identity depends on where they find themselves in the pecking order
00:09:57of righteous victimhood or loathsome privilege peterson's prescription for meaning is indeed
00:10:05liberating. How shocking that so many, including university students, had to wait for this man
00:10:13to tell them about it, and how equally shocking that people like Lindsay Bayerstein react to
00:10:20their exhilarated discovery with name-calling and contempt. Such contempt is expressed in
00:10:27her reference to Peterson as a, quote, darling of the so-called intellectual dark web and a gateway
00:10:33drug for countless budding right wingers end quote the sinister implications are laughable
00:10:39we're supposed to assume that after you watch a few jordan peterson videos you're on your way
00:10:43to hitler's final solution it so happens that peterson has never described himself as right
00:10:49wing and it's impossible to describe as right wing the masses of people who have become interested
00:10:55in his ideas they're from all across the political spectrum and many aren't political at all many0.90
00:11:01are simply sick to death of the prissy, moralizing, self-righteous and dishonest pablum that passes for
00:11:09elite opinion today. The basis for Berstein's disdain for right-wingers is, of course, never0.97
00:11:16articulated. She goes on, quote, So it was something of a surprise to learn in early February that
00:11:23Peterson had spent eight days in a medically induced coma at an unnamed clinic in Russia, end
00:11:30quote why was it a surprise or something of one peterson has spoken openly about his battles
00:11:38with depression and anxiety over the years he has never presented himself as invulnerable on the
00:11:44contrary he has consistently made it clear that his interests in psychology and myth are a response
00:11:52to the pain of being as he has experienced it. So, in what sense is it surprising that
00:11:59he would have troubles involving anti-anxiety medication at the time his wife was undergoing
00:12:05cancer treatment? The despicable suggestion is that he presented himself as having all the
00:12:11answers and that his difficulty now somehow proves he never did. Baerstein goes on to gloat
00:12:19that quote dependency goes against the core tenets of peterson's philosophical brand
00:12:25stoicism self-reliance the power of the will over circumstance and environment end quote
00:12:32and she quotes peterson supposedly to prove this no one gets away with anything ever
00:12:37so take responsibility for your own life he is said to have admonished i'm not sure how
00:12:45Advocating responsibility and counseling against dependency are such shocking things.
00:12:51But the fact is that Peterson's philosophy is not one of, quote, stoicism, self-reliance and the power of the will over circumstance and environment, end quote.
00:13:02his philosophy might include these qualities as ideals to strive for when possible and desirable,
00:13:09but Peterson has never argued that the power of the will is all that is required to overcome pain
00:13:17or disaster. On the contrary, he is deeply aware of the opposite as innumerable examples from 12
00:13:25rules for life could illuminate. On page 216 of the book, for example, he states that, quote,
00:13:33even well-lived lives can, of course, be warped and hurt and twisted by illness and infirmity
00:13:41and uncontrollable catastrophe. Depression, bipolar disorder, and schizophrenia, like cancer,
00:13:49all involve biological factors beyond the individual's immediate control.
00:13:57The difficulties intrinsic to life itself are sufficient to weaken and overwhelm each of us,
00:14:05pushing us beyond our limits, breaking us at our weakest point. Not even the best-lived life
00:14:12provides an absolute defense against vulnerability, end quote. Here is a clear refutation of
00:14:20Bayerstein's main point in the article that Peterson advocates so-called bootstrapping,
00:14:27and it is an excellent illustration of Peterson's compassion for human suffering and awareness of
00:14:33its power to break us all. To suggest, as Bayerstein does, that he was a faker who pretended
00:14:39to be Superman in order to attract followers is an outrageous distortion. The rest of the article
00:14:48takes a deep dive into Peterson's health problems and treatment decisions, the purpose of which is
00:14:54not entirely clear given that neither Bayerstein nor the various health professionals she claims
00:15:00to have consulted actually examined Peterson or were given access to details of his diagnosis
00:15:06and treatment. But the point of the long, rather purient exegesis seems to be twofold. First,
00:15:14to suggest that Peterson made mistakes in his choices about treatment because of his alleged
00:15:20bootstrap philosophy. And second, to suggest that Peterson can't be trusted in anything he says
00:15:27because he proved unable to deal reasonably with his medication dependency. Here is the nub
00:15:34of Bayerstein's argument. She says, quote, based on interviews with medical professionals
00:15:41and a close reading of various statements that Michaela Ann Peterson himself have made on
00:15:47podcasts and social media, it is clear that Peterson ended up in Russia after an extended
00:15:53battle to wean himself of clonazepam. And it seems likely that Peterson, a self-proclaimed
00:16:02man of science succumbed to the lure of a quack treatment with devastating consequences end quote
00:16:10the author's unprovable but damning contention is that peterson got himself into his predicament
00:16:19because he couldn't treat his problems simply as physical he needed to act the hero of his own
00:16:27favored myths. One of the big issues in Berstein's article is the possibility that Peterson became
00:16:35psychologically addicted to, not simply physically dependent on, the anxiety medication he had been
00:16:42prescribed. Even while admitting that there is no evidence that he was so addicted, she keeps
00:16:50insinuating that he may have been and that, of course, he and his family would hide the fact.
00:16:54She even takes the fact that Michaela joked about the likelihood that Peterson's enemies
00:17:00would pile on the idea of a psychological addiction as a kind of evidence that perhaps
00:17:06it was true. The entire argument rests on misdirection and insinuation. At one point,
00:17:14again trying to push the image of Peterson as a false prophet, Bayerstein implies that he has
00:17:19consistently underestimated the reality of addiction she says quote dependence and addiction
00:17:27are health issues not character defects and if you pressed peterson on that point he'd probably agree
00:17:35however that message is a tough sell to many of peterson's fans who are drawn to his macho
00:17:41image and his personal story of triumph over adversity end quote the inaccuracy here either
00:17:50deliberate or from ignorance is staggering you wouldn't have to push peterson to admit that
00:17:58dependency and addiction are health issues and he doesn't cultivate a macho image or claim to
00:18:05have triumphed over adversity here he is on page 125 of 12 rules for life talking about the human
00:18:13condition with compelling honesty and compassion for human frailty he says quote why do people
00:18:21take drugs not a mystery it's why they don't take them all the time that's the mystery why do people
00:18:30suffer from anxiety that's not a mystery how is it that people can ever be calm there's the mystery
00:18:37we're breakable and mortal a million things can go wrong in a million ways end quote and on page 149
00:18:45he went on to emphasize that quote human control is limited susceptibility to despair disease aging
00:18:54and death is universal in the final analysis we do not appear to be the architects of our own
00:19:01fragility end quote it becomes evident that beyerstein has created a straw man of jordan
00:19:08peterson solely it seems to delight in knocking it down in most of the rest of the article
00:19:15beyerstein attempts to provide a medical analysis of peterson's condition and his treatment choices
00:19:22to show that Peterson made bad decisions because he couldn't bear to face his drug dependency
00:19:28honestly. The possibility that Peterson attempted in good faith to follow the medical advice of
00:19:35North American doctors and ultimately found them unable to help him is never seriously
00:19:42considered in the article, though it is the most likely explanation. Only one doctor is quoted in
00:19:48the entire Bear Steen piece, Dr. Olivera Bogunovic at Boston's McLean Hospital.
00:19:54And she, of course, can do no more than speak generally about benzodiazepine dependence,
00:20:00admitting that not all sufferers successfully undergo gradual withdrawal, the program at her
00:20:06hospital, and that a small percentage of people do suffer from a paradoxical reaction of precisely
00:20:14the sort Michaela described, meaning that rather than lessening their anxiety, the medication
00:20:21profoundly increases it, leading to unbearable discomfort, as Michaela described.
00:20:27This doctor's statements make it clear that there is nothing particularly baffling about the story
00:20:33Michaela told about her father, as was stated by Berstein near the beginning of the article.
00:20:39When, near the end of the article, Berstein takes the opportunity to deride Michaela's
00:20:47motives and to conclude that Peterson was his own worst enemy, it's no longer necessary to
00:20:52take seriously contentions that are based on nothing other than malignant speculation.
00:20:59Quote, Michaela is essentially weaving her own hero's journey, says Berstein, into her father's
00:21:06ordeal, one in which she brought him to a far-flung clinic that had the guts to do what
00:21:12Western doctors wouldn't. It's a tale that burnishes her brand as a wellness influencer
00:21:18and shoves aside awkward questions about whether the treatment harmed Peterson, end quote.
00:21:25Given that neither Baerstein nor the single medical doctor she quoted can prove or even
00:21:31plausibly allege that Peterson was harmed rather than helped by his treatment, this is rather an
00:21:37unfair charge. When Berstein ends her article by declaring Peterson's story a sad one, I have
00:21:45trouble believing that she felt even one jot of sadness as she wrote it. She remains committed
00:21:51to her mischaracterization of Peterson right up to the last statement, which is, quote,
00:21:57if Peterson's sad story has a moral, it's that a drug problem is neither a dragon to be slain
00:22:03nor a sin to be ashamed of. It's a mundane health problem that should be treated scientifically
00:22:08without heroics, end quote. Well, it must feel good to sit back with no real knowledge of the
00:22:15case and with no personal distress about the suffering involved to speculate and sermonize
00:22:21about the decisions made by two people caught up in the pain, fear, panic, and uncertainty
00:22:27of a horrific physical reaction to a medication. Ironically, though Baerstein claims that illness
00:22:35is physical, not moral, the implication throughout her article is that Peterson has been morally
00:22:42exposed as a fake shaman and that the story of his health woes and possible addiction
00:22:48should put an end to the respect he has won. It won't do that because Bairstein doesn't know
00:22:55enough to begin to make her case and has not done justice to Peterson's real message in 12 Rules for
00:23:02Life. Her article is bad enough that, in my opinion, it's ripe for a defamation lawsuit.0.77
00:23:10Most people are prone to the vice of taking pleasure in the suffering of someone they
00:23:15dislike. I'm guilty of it too. Some of us, though, recognize the vice for the despicable thing it is
00:23:22and fight against it with our better natures. As Peterson advises in Twelve Rules for Life,
00:23:29it's useful to, quote, become aware of your own insufficiency, your cowardice, malevolence,
00:23:36resentment, and hatred, end quote. If Berstein had read and taken to heart Twelve Rules for Life,
00:23:43She might have thought better of the article that revealed her own malignant ill-wishing.