00:00:00Has Trump's Education Secretary, Betsy DeVos, struck a blow for campus fairness, or has0.99
00:00:09she further entrenched anti-male assumptions in Title IX?
00:00:14Join me as I review her defense of the new sexual misconduct rules for U.S. colleges.
00:00:30The revised Title IX regulations have at last been released after years of consultation.
00:00:38And contrary to the uproar surrounding them, they don't represent a dramatic change for colleges dealing with sexual misconduct allegations.
00:00:49Despite Sky is Falling shouts from feminist organizations and a lawsuit by the American
00:00:57Civil Liberties Union, not that much will be different for accuser and accused.
00:01:04The regulations still require colleges to adjudicate sexual misconduct, a task they
00:01:11are woefully ill-equipped to do properly. They still allow tribunals to use the preponderance
00:01:18of the evidence model, which is the lowest possible standard, and they still provide
00:01:23the accuser with the right to appeal a decision by the tribunal, opening the accused to double
00:01:30jeopardy. The sensible amendments, such as narrowing the definition of sexual harassment,
00:01:38allowing accused students to hire lawyers, and mandating that they see written statements of
00:01:44the case against them, while good, amount to little more than tinkering with a disastrously
00:01:51bad structure. I'm currently reading the more than 2,000-page regulations document, but for now,
00:02:00I'll make a few comments on Secretary DeVos' video presenting the guidelines.
00:02:06As I listened to her justify the approach her department has taken, I was dumbfounded by the1.00
00:02:14extent to which feminist presuppositions about rape and justice have influenced even this
00:02:20supposedly non-feminist reformer. DeVos begins by referring to rape as a campus scourge.
00:02:30Two years ago, I made a promise to address the scourge of sexual misconduct on our nation's
00:02:36campuses. Scourge implies a widespread problem having a major impact on students' abilities
00:02:44to pursue education, but it is not clear from reputable surveys that this is actually the case.
00:02:51The National College Health Assessment, a large survey of 26,000 students carried out by the
00:02:58American College Health Association in 2018, found that 3.2% of female students reported
00:03:07experiencing sexual penetration without their consent in the previous year. It's not clear
00:03:13whether all or even most of the survey respondents regarded the non-consensual sex as rape. And it's
00:03:22also not clear whether it occurred at college. Clearly, the figure is not the notorious one in
00:03:30five women often said to be sexually assaulted while in college. Interestingly, male students
00:03:37surveyed reported a higher rate, 3.5% of physical assault. Yet it's difficult to imagine, to say the
00:03:46least, the Secretary of Education announcing a nationwide strategy to enable colleges to deal
00:03:53with the problem of physical assault of male students. Perhaps not coincidentally, when female0.78
00:04:00students were asked about excess drinking, 20.4% reported consuming five or more alcoholic drinks
00:04:10in one sitting just in the previous two weeks, and 2.7% admitted that they had had non-consensual
00:04:18sex while drunk. Such statistics suggest that a great deal of non-consensual sex could be
00:04:26eliminated simply by reducing alcohol consumption amongst college students. But this is not a
00:04:34narrative with any legs for feminist opinion makers or politicians. The emphasis is always0.99
00:04:41on female victimization. DeVos goes on to declare that sexual misconduct is unacceptable.
00:04:50No student's learning journey should include surviving sexual misconduct.
00:04:56No student should be made to feel alone or abandoned by their school.
00:05:01No incident should ever be swept under the rug.
00:05:05And no student or teacher accused should be punished before evidence proves responsibility.
00:05:12This isn't a bad statement, including, as it does, the stipulation that
00:05:16punishment should not precede evidence of responsibility, and more on this later.
00:05:22But the wording, which must have been carefully crafted, is unsettling. Why not say no accused
00:05:29should be punished unless evidence proves responsibility rather than before? The meaning
00:05:36is substantively the same, but the implication is quite different. To say that no accused should be
00:05:40punished before responsibility is proven suggests that guilt will in most cases be found. To say no
00:05:48one should be punished unless responsibility is proven makes a far stronger case for presumption
00:05:54of innocence, which is supposedly the major reform DeVos has made to the regulations.
00:06:00DeVos's stress on the need for evidence is heartening, but it's far from sufficient to
00:06:06reassure those of us who have watched the college campus nightmare. So let's see how she rolls out
00:06:13her vision. Today we announce a final rule that recognizes we can continue to combat sexual0.92
00:06:20misconduct without abandoning our core values of fairness, presumption of innocence, and due process.
00:06:29Our rule empowers survivors like never before. The pain suffered by each survivor due to sexual
00:06:36misconduct can be lasting and profound. Not so great. I would have liked DeVos to pause
00:06:43over her emphasis on presumption of innocence and due process before moving on to the obligatory
00:06:49tribute to empowering survivors. By survivors, of course, and it's a word she uses far too many
00:06:57times, she is referring exclusively to alleged victims of sexual misconduct, not to victims of
00:07:05false allegations. Survivor is a feminist term applied almost exclusively to female accusers0.58
00:07:12in order to make it seem that the accusation must be true. Yet from Emma Salkowitz to Rolling1.00
00:07:19Stone's Jackie, from Crystal Mangum to Nikki Uvino and many more, there have been plenty of high and
00:07:26low-profile instances of false accusations that profoundly damaged innocent men's lives.
00:07:33In the last-mentioned case, for example, college girl Nikki Jovino claimed that two football players from her school raped her at an off-campus party.
00:07:45She later confessed to police that she made up the double allegation because it was the first thing that came to mind after she'd had consensual sex in the ladies' washroom with the two men.
00:07:58She was a real class act, hoping that her story of rape would help her win sympathy from a
00:08:04potential boyfriend. The two men, one of whom testified at her sentencing where she plea
00:08:11bargained for a year in jail, lost their scholarships and their chance to play college
00:08:17football. These horrific stories of lives ruined deserve recognition. These men's pain is also
00:08:26lasting and profound, but we don't hear a word about it from DeVos. Her emphasis is on the horror
00:08:34of sexual violation as she continues. These gross acts are often about control and power.
00:08:43Those who have no control over themselves attempt to exert it over others.
00:08:47Oh gee. From this point early in the presentation, the discussion becomes more and more feminist in
00:08:57its rhetoric and presuppositions. The idea that sexual misconduct is all about control and power0.89
00:09:04rather than desire is purely feminist, invoking the Duluth model of domestic violence and radical0.97
00:09:12feminists such as Andrea Dworkin. In the context of campus sexual misconduct, it nullifies the1.00
00:09:18possibility for a humane, non-ideological understanding of the reality of alcohol-fueled
00:09:25lust, miscommunication, and youthful recklessness. If sexual misconduct is about power and control
00:09:33by a male perpetrator, then the woman has no sexual power of her own and no responsibility
00:09:40for communicating clearly, knowing her own desires, and limiting her alcohol consumption.1.00
00:09:47DeVos's acceptance of unscientific claims signals her capitulation to a feminist paradigm in which
00:09:55the harm to women of male sexuality is taken for granted, as is evident from her discussion about
00:10:02the need for schools to provide immediate assistance to complainants. With our role,
00:10:10If a student is harmed, he or she has control over what happens next.
00:10:15Under our rule, schools must offer survivors help they can't get anywhere else.
00:10:20Although survivors may wish to file a police report or sue in court, Title IX protects
00:10:26their education, separate and apart from what the police or the courts may do.
00:10:31Under our rule, schools must offer free, personalized services that help survivors keep their education