The Fiamengo File - May 09, 2020


Why the US Women’s National Soccer Team Lost its Feminist Lawsuit - The Fiamengo File Episode 120

Does Anybody Actually "Believe Women?" - The Fiamengo File Episode 119 Betsy DeVos Drank the Feminist Kool-Aid - The Fiamengo File Episode 121

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

133.21

Word count

1,384

Sentence count

57

Harmful content

Misogyny

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 The recent ruling on a class action lawsuit by the U.S. Women's National Soccer Team
00:00:08 shines a very bright light on the dishonesty of the team's pay equity claims.
00:00:15 Federal Court Judge R. Gary Klausner, in dismissing the key plank of the women's complaint,
00:00:21 shows how the allegedly simple matter of pay equality is far more complicated than it's
00:00:27 said to be, and that the women's complaint about discrimination was far less about actual injustice
00:00:34 than about the women's own choices.
00:00:47 In Alex Morgan et al. v. United States Soccer Federation, the detailed decision by Judge
00:00:55 Klausner is well worth reading, not only for what it shows about the politics of women's professional
00:01:01 sport, but also for how it highlights the inability or unwillingness of the women's team members to
00:01:09 own their double standards. For those who haven't read the judgment, let me offer a few highlights.
00:01:17 Background first. The women's soccer team was cheered on by many, including fans at the Women's
00:01:24 World Cup final last July 2019 for launching their lawsuit alleging pay discrimination against the
00:01:32 U.S. Soccer Federation. An article from the Associated Press in March of 2019 was unqualified
00:01:40 in applauding the team's decision. It quoted player and co-captain Megan Rapinoe, who bragged
00:01:48 about the team's advocacy, saying, quote, I think a lot of people look to us and our team and the
00:01:54 collective voice that we have and what we've stood for, for inspiration and for power and as an ally
00:02:01 in this broader fight for equality and human rights, end quote. The article went on to report
00:02:09 that the lawsuit, symbolically filed on International Women's Day, asked for more than 0.72
00:02:16 $66 million U.S. under the Equal Pay Act and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.
00:02:24 The only problem with the lawsuit is that equality with men seems to have been the last
00:02:31 thing the women's team members were interested in. 0.96
00:02:35 What they really wanted was the opportunity to earn as much in per-game bonuses as the
00:02:41 members of the men's team while incurring none of the risks involved if they lost or
00:02:48 didn't play.
00:02:50 The women's team claim that they were paid less than members of the men's team is not
00:02:55 only factually untrue, the judge includes their per-game revenue in his decision, but
00:03:02 also ignores significant differences in the contracts each team negotiated.
00:03:08 fact that the women's team members could claim discrimination while knowing that they had
00:03:15 bargained for many benefits not in the men's contract tells us pretty much all we need to
00:03:22 know about their definition of equality. The nub of the issue is that the men's 0.64
00:03:29 national soccer team signed a contract based on pay to play. That means that male players
00:03:35 aren't paid unless they are selected for a particular roster. Players receive no annual
00:03:42 salary. Instead, they receive bonuses based on how well their team does in different matches,
00:03:49 the highest bonuses relating to the FIFA World Cup. The women's team, in contrast, chose not to
00:03:56 negotiate the same contract as the men. Under the women's team contract, team members receive
00:04:03 an annual salary and various benefits such as medical and dental insurance, injury insurance,
00:04:11 child care benefits, maternity benefits, and severance benefits. The judgment written by
00:04:19 R. Gary Klausner provides a remarkable overview of contract negotiations in 2016
00:04:27 showing that the women wanted everything the men were getting, plus much more.
00:04:34 As one of the Soccer Federation negotiators explained to the women at one point,
00:04:39 your proposal is basically for all of the upside of the men's team's collective agreement,
00:04:45 plus the elimination of risk. The men risked not winning, and therefore not collecting the
00:04:54 bonuses. But it seems the women's team couldn't understand or admit that having the same pay per 0.99
00:05:02 game as the men could not reasonably be demanded along with the many other guarantees and benefits 0.75
00:05:10 the women were asking for and which the men didn't have. In one communication with the Soccer
00:05:16 Federation, the women spelled out their demand angrily, articulating their sense of legal right 0.64
00:05:23 to get more than the men. They wrote, quote, first, to be clear, we want the same pay-per-game 1.00
00:05:33 compensation as the men's national team. This is a legal requirement, and we should not even have
00:05:40 to bargain for the U.S. Soccer Federation to comply with the law. However, this does not mean
00:05:47 we want every aspect of the men's national team system or agreement, which is independent of the
00:05:56 equal pay for equal work requirement, end quote. In other words, they wanted all the good things
00:06:03 that the men were getting in their agreement, but wanted that separate from all the risks the men
00:06:08 were taking to get the good things. I propose that this in a nutshell is the classic feminist
00:06:14 position on nearly everything gender-related over the last 50 years, in which women want what men
00:06:20 have earned and sacrificed and risked for, but don't want the risks or sacrifices or uncertainty. 0.90
00:06:29 Essentially, the women became irate over the fact that had they played under the men's agreement 1.00
00:06:37 with its big potential bonuses, they would have made more money than they did because of their
00:06:43 numerous victories, including last year's FIFA Women's World Cup. But they didn't know that when
00:06:49 they were negotiating their agreement at a time when, as the judge points out, they, quote,
00:06:53 explicitly rejected the terms they now seek to retroactively impose on themselves, end quote.
00:07:03 The women's position is we opted for security so that no matter how we performed or even 1.00
00:07:08 whether we performed at all, we would still be paid and would have a rich benefits package. But 1.00
00:07:14 now we are claiming sexism because we would have been compensated better if we had been willing to
00:07:20 risk more from the beginning, which we weren't. But we're trusting a feminist judge will see things 1.00
00:07:26 our way. Well, the judge didn't see it their way this time, but the women's soccer team is going 1.00
00:07:33 to keep on trying. The same author who wrote glowingly about their claim last year has
00:07:39 published another article telling of their court setback titled, What's Next for U.S. Women's
00:07:46 Soccer Team? This article says very little about the grounds for Judge Klausner's decision,
00:07:52 calling his judgment instead a surprising loss and emphasizing that the players have vowed to
00:08:00 appeal. The article focuses on the many voices raised in support of the women from tennis legend
00:08:07 Billie Jean King to presidential candidate Joe Biden. Even the U.S. men's national soccer team
00:08:14 put out a statement of support. The previously quoted Megan Rapinoe appearing on Good Morning
00:08:20 America said she was shocked by the judge's decision and gave a garbled summation of its
00:08:27 unfairness the very simplicity of which suggests the ease with which women can often win over a 0.95
00:08:34 gullible public she said quote if i earn one dollar every time i play and a man earns three dollars
00:08:42 just because i win 10 games and he only wins three games so i made 10 and he made nine dollars
00:08:49 i'm not sure how that's me making more money though the judge was never so facile as to make
00:08:57 that weak argument. And of course, she also conveniently neglected to mention the substantial
00:09:04 monetary value of the insurance and guaranteed salary and maternity benefits that she and her
00:09:09 team chose instead of the bonus structure. A lawyer named Hampton Dellinger is mentioned in
00:09:16 the article, suggesting that the women's team may ultimately triumph, stating that he didn't think
00:09:23 Judge Klausner's, quote, first word was necessarily going to be the last word, end quote. The strong
00:09:30 implication was that enthusiastic public sentiment and the unrelenting conviction of the women
00:09:37 themselves may well be enough to bring a favorable judgment in the future. Here we see the power of 0.99
00:09:45 the women's lobby with its relentless complaints, allegations, false statistics, and appeals to 0.90
00:09:53 male chivalry. In the end, it may not matter what the facts show about the contract these women 0.87
00:10:01 negotiated so long as the team can find the right judge on the right day. Then the women may get 0.99
00:10:08 their 66 million dollars in compensation and their place in the history books as the champions of a 1.00
00:10:16 movement having nothing whatsoever to do with equal pay. Or maybe not.