00:11:37You don't have to know for certain whether Bloomberg lied about this particular incident
00:11:42to recognize the absurd aspects of the exchange.
00:11:47Neither Matthews nor Warren had been present for the alleged kill it,
00:11:52but Matthews immediately defaulted to believing Bloomberg, or at least defaulted to being
00:11:58perplexed by the idea that Warren didn't, end quote. This isn't true. Matthews never said that
00:12:07he believed Bloomberg, but he was perplexed, and rightly so, that Elizabeth Warren could believe
00:12:14the woman and make that the basis of a serious accusation in the absence of sure knowledge.
00:12:20Hess doesn't seem to consider that the choice isn't whether to believe or disbelieve.
00:12:27One can simply say, I don't know what happened, but I don't want to support a system in which men are punished without credible evidence of wrongdoing.
00:12:39Hess obviously doesn't care about the innocent accused, as she makes clear in the rest of her article.
00:12:45For her, it's all predictably a feminist victim story.
00:12:54These qualities, being in power and seeming like a good dude, these are supposedly the qualities that caused Chris Matthews to believe Michael Bloomberg, aren't evidence of innocence.
00:13:08They're the exact ingredients that historically allowed harassment to go unchecked, end quote.0.99
00:13:14Notice here the neat reversal typical of feminist illogic. The very thing that has supposedly1.00
00:13:21enabled men to exercise unjust power becomes the evidence for why men should be punished
00:13:29without evidence. It's a false premise grounding a classic fallacious syllogism that goes something
00:13:37like, powerful men have abused power, Bloomberg is a powerful man, therefore Bloomberg abused his
00:13:45power. Notably, Hess doesn't have any evidence that women were consistently disbelieved in the
00:13:53past in relation to claims of sexual assault, and it isn't true, as even a very little research
00:13:59will show. Improper Advances, Rape, and Heterosexual Conflict in Ontario, 1880-1929
00:14:08is a book by feminist historian Karen Dubinsky. While taking an avowedly feminist perspective on
00:14:16the material, which is rape and other trials, it still offers some useful information to non-feminist
00:14:22researchers, including the fact that in the 19th century in Canada, as well as in the United States
00:14:28in Britain, women or their fathers could have men prosecuted both criminally and in civil court,
00:14:36not only for forcible rape, but also for seduction, a crime with various definitions,
00:14:42the most common involving sexual intercourse accompanied by a promise of marriage, later
00:14:48reneged on. In other words, a man could go to jail not only for raping a woman, but for convincing0.71
00:14:56her to have sex with him with the promise of marriage. Dubinsky notes that in the sample that0.97
00:15:02she examined over a period of decades, guilty verdicts were obtained in from 38% to 56%
00:15:11of rape trials, not inconsiderable. Criminal prosecutions for seduction resulted in guilty
00:15:19verdicts in from 9% to 35% of criminal cases and an astounding 90% of civil prosecutions.0.80
00:15:30Such conviction rates show that over a century ago, juries were often sympathetic to women
00:15:36claiming to have been badly treated by men and that a woman's word often landed a man in prison
00:15:43or forced him to make financial recompense.0.99