The Fiamengo File - April 26, 2020


Does Anybody Actually "Believe Women?" - The Fiamengo File Episode 119

How Feminists Lie About Domestic Violence - The Fiamengo File Episode 118 Why the US Women’s National Soccer Team Lost its Feminist Lawsuit - The Fiamengo File Episode 120

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

127.99

Word count

2,867

Sentence count

128

Harmful content

Misogyny

27

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

14

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Over the past few years, we've heard a lot about believing women, a phrase that any sane person 1.00
00:00:09 should find ridiculous, and that, as it turns out, even the most committed feminist ideologues
00:00:15 can't explain. 0.64
00:00:27 Does anybody really believe claims of harassment, discrimination, and sexual assault without
00:00:34 evidence?
00:00:36 During the Senate confirmation hearings for Brett Kavanaugh's Supreme Court nomination,
00:00:42 the believers were out in angry and tearful force, waving placards, standing in solidarity
00:00:49 with Kavanaugh's child-voiced accuser, and even accosting a senator in an elevator in
00:00:55 a show of fervor that made up in shrill intensity what it lacked in reason. But Kavanaugh, a well
00:01:03 respected conservative judge, had his defenders too, many of them women who didn't believe the
00:01:10 woman. In the case of fallen Hollywood mogul Harvey Weinstein, there was a near universal
00:01:18 chorus of denunciation as Hollywood starlets joined with conservatives to believe his accusers
00:01:26 even as the extraordinary thinness of the legal case against him was revealed in court.
00:01:33 More recently, when the accused was Joe Biden, evangelical zeal to believe suddenly dropped
00:01:41 away, and even Me Too actress Alyssa Milano discovered a newfound respect for due process
00:01:48 in light of the assault allegation against Biden by former staffer Tara Reid. None of that is
00:01:55 surprising, because ideologues are always willing to crucify an enemy while giving a pass to one
00:02:01 of their own. The exact same thing happened back in 1994 when Paula Jones accused Bill Clinton of 0.88
00:02:09 sexual harassment while his feminist allies yawned and looked the other way such is the nature of
00:02:17 political alliances and little is to be gained from cries of hypocrisy what remains interesting
00:02:25 about believe women is the idea itself not its inconsistent and partisan application
00:02:33 Believe Women, unlike pay equity, the glass ceiling, emotional labor, or any of the other
00:02:41 feminist rallying cries, is the true core of the feminist credo in all its bigoted certitude.
00:02:51 Believe Women doesn't pretend to have any evidence to show why it is reasonable. It can't 1.00
00:02:58 legitimately point to any circumstance in the present or the past when believing women was a
00:03:05 self-evidently logical principle. It is nothing less than a raw assertion of the will to faith
00:03:12 in female moral superiority. The fact that it could exist at all as a political slogan, 0.85
00:03:22 let alone one behind which millions of women and men have rallied, is a remarkable sign
00:03:29 of the anti-male irrationality of our time. Let's consider some of the reasons feminists 0.93
00:03:37 give for believing women when they attempt a coherent defense of it. In this video,
00:03:43 I'll look at detailed explanations by two feminist journalists. Both of them wrote 1.00
00:03:50 in the aftermath of the forced retirement of Chris Matthews, MSNBC journalist who was pushed
00:03:56 out of his job as host of the show Hardball, at least partly because he failed to believe women.
00:04:04 Before we get to the articles, let's take a look at the exchange that signaled the beginning of
00:04:09 the end for Matthews. It started with his questioning of former presidential candidate
00:04:15 Elizabeth Warren following the Democratic presidential debate of February 25th about why
00:04:22 she believed a woman who had, in 1997, brought a lawsuit against Mike Bloomberg, one of Warren's 0.92
00:04:30 rivals. The accusing woman had alleged that Bloomberg had pressured her to have an abortion
00:04:36 while she was an employee at his company in 1995. She said that he had told her to kill it
00:04:43 after she informed him of her pregnancy.
00:04:47 She ultimately settled her lawsuit in 2000
00:04:49 with no admission of guilt from Bloomberg,
00:04:53 who denies her allegation.
00:04:55 Here we have the classic,
00:04:57 he said, she said conflict
00:04:59 in which a man has paid off a woman
00:05:01 to make her lawsuit go away.
00:05:04 Who's telling the truth?
00:05:06 All we know for certain
00:05:08 is that if the woman had herself said, 0.99
00:05:11 kill it, to her doctor, 0.84
00:05:13 She'd be hailed as a heroine of the pro-choice movement and invited to speak at women's marches, 0.99
00:05:18 but that's another matter. Back to Chris Matthews. The exchange between him and Elizabeth Warren has
00:05:25 been billed as a case of Matthews attacking Warren, though his tone is quite measured,
00:05:31 and she is the one who raised her voice, shifted in her chair, and became visibly agitated. Here it is.
00:05:39 I believe that the former mayor of New York said that to a pregnant employee. 0.99
00:05:44 Well, pregnant employee sure said that he did. 0.99
00:05:47 Why shouldn't I believe her? 1.00
00:05:48 I'm just really tired of this world.
00:05:50 This one is personal for me.
00:05:51 It really is.
00:05:52 But you believe that he's that kind of person who did that.
00:05:56 Pregnancy discrimination is real.
00:05:59 And we have gone on and on and on where people say, I can't really believe the woman. 1.00
00:06:05 Really? 0.99
00:06:06 Why not? 0.99
00:06:08 Warren made it clear that she believed the accuser and disbelieved Bloomberg mainly because the accuser was a woman
00:06:16 and because, as she said, quote, pregnancy discrimination is real, as if that proved anything about the particular case.
00:06:25 Some might find this a less than rational basis for belief, and some might even find it a revelation of worrisome anti-male prejudice,
00:06:34 but it was good enough for many of Warren's supporters.
00:06:38 According to Warren, there are plenty of reasons why Bloomberg would lie and no discernible reasons
00:06:44 why his accuser would. It doesn't seem to occur to her that easy money and the desire to harm
00:06:51 are all too human motivations on abundant display in everyday life.
00:06:56 Matthews didn't proffer these possible reasons, he simply repeated his question
00:07:01 about the basis for Warren's belief, but that was apparently too much for the Believe Women crowd.
00:07:09 Howls of indignation erupted from the expected quarters after the interview.
00:07:14 Shawna Thomas, president of a women's advocacy group, said that Matthew's refusal to believe
00:07:21 women and history of sexual harassment make it clear that he is not fit to continue to cover
00:07:28 this election journalist and activist lauren duca called matthew's line of questioning insane
00:07:36 and tweeted indignantly that quote he actually cannot wrap his head around believing women end
00:07:42 quote the interview so infuriated another journalist named laura bassett that she decided
00:07:50 to disclose her own allegation against Chris Matthews that he'd sexually harassed her in 2016
00:07:58 by asking her before an interview, why haven't I fallen in love with you yet? Which she admitted
00:08:06 probably didn't meet the legal definition of sexual harassment, but nonetheless undermined
00:08:12 her ability to do her job well. Tsk, tsk. So the writing was on the wall for Matthews 1.00
00:08:20 with a clear message for all men. Support Me Too accusations unquestioningly or find
00:08:28 yourself the target of one. Matthews' career came to an inglorious end.
00:08:34 Chris Matthews' humiliation came in the same week that Harvey Weinstein was found guilty of
00:08:43 sexual assault allegations in a case without a shred of solid evidence to convict and plenty
00:08:49 of evidence to support the defense claim of consent. Believing women was on the rise. 0.56
00:08:57 And yet some feminists seemed ill at ease. In lengthy and sometimes convoluted expositions,
00:09:04 two feminist journalists attempted to explain why Believe Women was not the Orwellian statement
00:09:11 of blind faith, it seemed to some of us. One of these was prominent feminist Monica Hess,
00:09:19 the first gender editor for the premier feminist newspaper, The Washington Post. 0.99
00:09:24 Her defense was titled, Believe Women Doesn't Mean Women Never Lie, It Means Accepting That
00:09:32 men sometimes do too." The title would appear to signal a major stepping back from feminist 0.97
00:09:40 certainty. If women do lie, then how can we generally believe them? Hess claimed that we 0.99
00:09:48 have, quote, nothing to fear from the Me Too tagline and seemed to suggest that the past
00:09:54 two and a half years of Me Too rhetoric has simply been an unfortunate misunderstanding.
00:10:02 Let's get this straight. When crowds of angry women have stood outside courthouses where 1.00
00:10:08 sexual assault trials were taking place, holding signs saying, we believe you, that didn't 0.99
00:10:15 mean they refused to consider the defendant's case. When anonymous lists like the shitty 0.98
00:10:21 men media list were published, it didn't mean that the men named were shitty. It just 0.97
00:10:29 meant we should entertain the possibility? At this point in Hesse's essay, it's really hard to know
00:10:35 where she's going. And she goes further in her attempt to reassure the skeptical. Consider it
00:10:43 this way, she quips. If you say you love dogs, does it mean you hate cats? If a fundraiser vows to
00:10:50 eradicate diabetes, does it mean they don't care about cancer anymore? End quote. Well, if all
00:10:57 government funding goes to diabetes and cancer gets none, it does mean that in practice you've
00:11:02 stopped caring about cancer, just as if you take action to punish a man based on an accusation he
00:11:09 denies, you've accepted that his word doesn't count. Hess's benign-seeming analogies obviously
00:11:17 don't do justice to the genuine radicalism of feminist activism, and as she develops her defense,
00:11:23 her lack of intellectual seriousness becomes even more evident.
00:11:29 For Hess, the sting in Matthew's questioning of Warren was that he dared to doubt.
00:11:36 She writes, quote,
00:11:37 You don't have to know for certain whether Bloomberg lied about this particular incident
00:11:42 to recognize the absurd aspects of the exchange.
00:11:47 Neither Matthews nor Warren had been present for the alleged kill it,
00:11:52 but Matthews immediately defaulted to believing Bloomberg, or at least defaulted to being
00:11:58 perplexed by the idea that Warren didn't, end quote. This isn't true. Matthews never said that
00:12:07 he believed Bloomberg, but he was perplexed, and rightly so, that Elizabeth Warren could believe
00:12:14 the woman and make that the basis of a serious accusation in the absence of sure knowledge.
00:12:20 Hess doesn't seem to consider that the choice isn't whether to believe or disbelieve.
00:12:27 One can simply say, I don't know what happened, but I don't want to support a system in which men are punished without credible evidence of wrongdoing.
00:12:39 Hess obviously doesn't care about the innocent accused, as she makes clear in the rest of her article.
00:12:45 For her, it's all predictably a feminist victim story.
00:12:50 As Hess announces glibly, quote,
00:12:54 These qualities, being in power and seeming like a good dude, these are supposedly the qualities that caused Chris Matthews to believe Michael Bloomberg, aren't evidence of innocence.
00:13:08 They're the exact ingredients that historically allowed harassment to go unchecked, end quote. 0.99
00:13:14 Notice here the neat reversal typical of feminist illogic. The very thing that has supposedly 1.00
00:13:21 enabled men to exercise unjust power becomes the evidence for why men should be punished
00:13:29 without evidence. It's a false premise grounding a classic fallacious syllogism that goes something
00:13:37 like, powerful men have abused power, Bloomberg is a powerful man, therefore Bloomberg abused his
00:13:45 power. Notably, Hess doesn't have any evidence that women were consistently disbelieved in the
00:13:53 past in relation to claims of sexual assault, and it isn't true, as even a very little research
00:13:59 will show. Improper Advances, Rape, and Heterosexual Conflict in Ontario, 1880-1929
00:14:08 is a book by feminist historian Karen Dubinsky. While taking an avowedly feminist perspective on
00:14:16 the material, which is rape and other trials, it still offers some useful information to non-feminist
00:14:22 researchers, including the fact that in the 19th century in Canada, as well as in the United States
00:14:28 in Britain, women or their fathers could have men prosecuted both criminally and in civil court,
00:14:36 not only for forcible rape, but also for seduction, a crime with various definitions,
00:14:42 the most common involving sexual intercourse accompanied by a promise of marriage, later
00:14:48 reneged on. In other words, a man could go to jail not only for raping a woman, but for convincing 0.71
00:14:56 her to have sex with him with the promise of marriage. Dubinsky notes that in the sample that 0.97
00:15:02 she examined over a period of decades, guilty verdicts were obtained in from 38% to 56%
00:15:11 of rape trials, not inconsiderable. Criminal prosecutions for seduction resulted in guilty
00:15:19 verdicts in from 9% to 35% of criminal cases and an astounding 90% of civil prosecutions. 0.80
00:15:30 Such conviction rates show that over a century ago, juries were often sympathetic to women
00:15:36 claiming to have been badly treated by men and that a woman's word often landed a man in prison
00:15:43 or forced him to make financial recompense. 0.99
00:15:47 So much for women not being believed.
00:15:51 And by the way, even if women were never believed, 0.96
00:15:55 right up until yesterday,
00:15:57 that wouldn't be a sound reason
00:15:59 that they should be believed without evidence today.
00:16:04 Hess, however, isn't interested in history or logic.
00:16:07 According to her way of thinking, 0.99
00:16:09 justice for women requires that the presumption of innocence
00:16:12 for accused men be replaced by a balance of probabilities approach in which, if it seems
00:16:19 more likely that a powerful guy would try to get away with bad behavior, then he probably did.
00:16:26 In any case, with a so-called power imbalance, benefit of the doubt should go to the female
00:16:32 accuser. Speaking of the Harvey Weinstein trial, for example, Hess shows us how balance of 0.51
00:16:38 probabilities thinking works, including how details of the accusation get reshaped or
00:16:44 eliminated in order to arrive at the foregone conclusion of male guilt. She says, quote,
00:16:51 which scenario was more likely that an egomaniacal Hollywood producer with unlimited power might
00:16:58 abuse his power and then lie about it when the accusations threatened to disrupt his empire, 0.90
00:17:03 or that multiple women who had never met one another would concoct similar stories of rape
00:17:11 spanning several decades and then go public because they were eager to be accused of being 0.78
00:17:17 promiscuous opportunists who slept their way into their careers." I've published a video
00:17:24 about the accusations against Weinstein, so I won't rehearse that here, except to point out
00:17:28 that it's far from clear these multiple women had quote never met one another and that in any case
00:17:34 there was no need to meet when they could easily read about other women's accusations and that
00:17:38 there are obvious reasons such as the promise of money from civil lawsuits why women would come
00:17:45 forward with their claims and far from being criticized for promiscuity or opportunism these
00:17:52 women encountered a great deal of public sympathy. But Hesse's is the typical feminist scenario based
00:17:59 on anti-male assumptions. A man with power abuses his power and then lies about it, of course.
00:18:05 None of what Weinstein offered in his defense, the emails from the women expressing affection
00:18:11 and the desire to see him again after these alleged rapes, none of that is considered
00:18:15 relevant or even mentioned. The women are always powerless, their only goal being a painful justice. 1.00
00:18:23 As if to drive home the cookie-cutter formula of Hess's argument in the same week that Hess's 1.00
00:18:31 essay appeared in the Washington Post, another feminist journalist, Rebecca Traister, writing
00:18:37 for a women's magazine called The Cut, made nearly the exact same argument in the same way,
00:18:43 and at even greater length, beginning, like Hess, by admitting up front that, quote,
00:18:48 we know that women can and do lie, end quote. So what does believe women mean, according to Trayster?
00:18:56 Well, at first she tells us that it means merely that, quote, we should encourage women to speak
00:19:00 more and listen to them more seriously when they talk, end quote. But it soon becomes evident
00:19:07 that Trayster's designs on public credulity are far more ambitious than that. Ultimately,
00:19:14 like Hess, Trayster wants nothing less than mass payback for an alleged and unprovable
00:19:23 historical wrong. Believing women, she tells us, quote, is a long overdue corrective to the benefit
00:19:33 of the doubt that powerful men are given over and over and over again, end quote. Here is our
00:19:40 faulty feminist syllogism once more. Powerful men have abused their power. Bloomberg is a powerful 1.00
00:19:47 man. Therefore, Bloomberg abused his power. And the female syllogism, powerless women have been
00:19:53 abused. This woman was powerless. Therefore, she was abused. Well, what about the liars and the 1.00
00:20:01 opportunists? What happened to that payout collected by Bloomberg's accuser? What happened
00:20:06 to women's fallen humanity? All forgotten, obviously, in the heady call for social justice, 1.00
00:20:14 aka collective punishment of men. So to sum it up, both writers allege that believe women doesn't
00:20:25 mean we should automatically believe women. Instead, it means we should believe them when
00:20:30 feminists say they are believable, mainly in situations in which men have power. And according
00:20:36 to feminists, that's nearly any situation at all. In fact, I can't think of a situation in which a 1.00
00:20:41 man doesn't have power. So believe women doesn't really mean believe women, except when it does. 0.97
00:20:49 And thus we come full circle to the incoherence of believe women as a core concept for a political 0.57
00:20:56 and social movement, a phrase that even its own proponents don't believe and can't defend.
00:21:04 But the question remains, if even its own self-appointed spokespersons admit that the
00:21:10 phrase doesn't mean what it says and can't be made to mean anything reasonable, why does
00:21:16 anybody believe it or claim to? What is its persuasive power that such a wide swath of
00:21:24 world leaders, politicians, journalists, academics, pundits, lawyers and police officers pay obeisance
00:21:31 to it at least some of the time.
00:21:35 The appeal of the idea, mystical and redemptive, obviously lies beyond reason itself.
00:21:54 Thank you.