The Fiamengo File - April 12, 2020


How Feminists Lie About Domestic Violence - The Fiamengo File Episode 118

The Feminist Whisper Network - The Fiamengo File Episode 115, v 2.0 Does Anybody Actually "Believe Women?" - The Fiamengo File Episode 119

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

126.32

Word count

2,177

Sentence count

86

Harmful content

Misogyny

26

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 If feminists declare something to be well known, it's more than likely a distortion or outright 1.00
00:00:08 false. In this video, I present a startling concrete instance of how feminists deliberately 0.95
00:00:15 disguise the truth about domestic violence. As countries around the world mandate shelter 0.99
00:00:31 in place or lockdown measures in response to COVID-19, we have heard a predictable claim
00:00:37 from feminist activists who allege that violence against women has increased during the pandemic
00:00:43 and that it is exacerbated by the fact that female victims, quote, have no escape from
00:00:48 their abusers during quarantine, end quote. When I say the claim is predictable, I'm not mocking,
00:00:55 I am merely repeating feminists' own words. In a Guardian newspaper article titled Lockdowns 0.99
00:01:03 Around the World Bring Rise in Domestic Violence, we're told that, quote, the increased threat to
00:01:09 women and children was a predictable side effect of the coronavirus lockdowns. 0.99
00:01:15 It's predictable because, according to feminists, pretty much whatever the circumstances, 1.00
00:01:20 violence against women always increases. We're told that, quote, increased abuse is a pattern 1.00
00:01:27 repeated in many emergencies, whether conflict, economic crisis, or during disease outbreaks,
00:01:35 end quote. One suspects that even were there an outbreak of temporary paralysis amongst men we
00:01:42 would hear warnings about the threat of violence against women. At present the claims about COVID-19
00:01:50 are based mainly on reports of calls to domestic violence hotlines, not hard evidence. For the
00:01:57 record, I don't doubt that family violence likely does increase during crises just as most bad
00:02:04 things do such as substance abuse or self-harm but i do not believe that gender-based measures
00:02:11 should be implemented to protect only women and to punish only men in some countries according
00:02:18 to the guardian article men may be evicted from their homes on their spouses say so for the
00:02:25 duration of the lockdown an extraordinarily cruel though not particularly unusual punishment
00:02:33 to read the guardian article and many others one would never know that men are ever victims of
00:02:40 violence an italian trade union for example is quoted as referring to quote female victims of
00:02:47 gender-based violence we learn that the leader of the german green party is gripped by quote
00:02:54 fear for the lives of thousands of women trapped with violent partners while in greece officials
00:03:01 are said to be, quote, stepping up a campaign to help women deal with problems emerging from the
00:03:06 issue of confinement, end quote. Are there no men trapped with violent partners? Well, even the most
00:03:14 ruthless of feminists will admit if pressed that women at least occasionally abuse men, but will 1.00
00:03:20 say that it doesn't compare with male violence against women. In fact, American professor of 0.98
00:03:27 Sociology Marie Strauss has demonstrated conclusively that women initiate and carry out physical assaults on their partners at least as often as men do,
00:03:38 and that although women's violence doesn't so often cause the most severe types of injuries, women do cause substantial physical harm to men, including death.
00:03:50 A report cited last year in the New York Times showed that in the United States in 2017,
00:03:58 men made up 32% of intimate partner homicides. In addition, reports of men's experiences of
00:04:06 domestic violence in the United States, in Norway, Finland, the United Kingdom, Spain,
00:04:12 Canada, and India, to name only a few, are widely available on the internet.
00:04:18 And in 2019, the U.S. National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey found that 36% of men, as compared to 33% of women, had experienced intimate partner violence in their lifetimes.
00:04:36 So it's impossible for anyone to deny on the basis of the evidence that men, too, are at serious risk of domestic violence.
00:04:46 But feminists do deny it, and they have been successfully pushing their denial for so many 0.80
00:04:53 decades that the vast majority of people would be shocked to learn the truth. Feminists do two 1.00
00:04:59 things to avoid having the truth get out. First, they outright misrepresent the findings of studies 1.00
00:05:05 and surveys. And second, they invent special terminology to assert that violence against men,
00:05:11 whether bi men or women, is categorically different, less severe, than men's violence
00:05:17 against women. Let's start by looking at how feminists misrepresent the findings of domestic 0.96
00:05:24 violence studies. One particular study has been repeatedly mentioned by feminists over the last 0.97
00:05:32 decade to emphasize the relationship between crisis situations and violence against women.
00:05:37 This study was called Intimate Partner Violence and Hurricane Katrina, Predictors and Associated Mental Health Outcomes.
00:05:47 Originally published in 2010 in a journal called Violence and Victims,
00:05:52 the study was based on data from a relatively large population-based survey of 445 married or cohabiting persons
00:06:02 living in the 23 southernmost counties of Mississippi at the time of Hurricane Katrina
00:06:08 in 2005. The survey was done two years after the hurricane and it asked participants about
00:06:16 their experiences of intimate partner violence both before and after Katrina. The study found
00:06:23 a 98% increase in violence against women in the aftermath of the hurricane and this sensational 0.76
00:06:31 number has become a favorite go-to statistic for feminist advocates. The 98% increase in violence
00:06:40 against women was mentioned repeatedly, for example, during the recent Australian bushfire
00:06:45 crisis as proof that women's vulnerability skyrockets during crises and that when women's
00:06:53 organizations ask their governments for money during any crisis they better get it
00:07:00 but what the hurricane katrina study actually found is almost never accurately reported and
00:07:07 moreover the truth is not even prominently emphasized by the study authors themselves
00:07:15 here's what the abstract of the study says in part
00:07:18 Quote, reports of physical victimization increased from 4.2% to 8.3% for women,
00:07:27 but were unchanged for men, end quote. So that's where the 98% increase comes from.
00:07:36 It seems straightforward, and I assume that at least some researchers don't even read past the
00:07:41 abstract, delighted to find clear data to justify the feminist narrative. However, when one reads
00:07:48 into the Hurricane Katrina study, one discovers that this 98% increase in violence against women
00:07:56 isn't quite what it seems. According to the study, 11 women, 4.2% of the total surveyed,
00:08:05 had reported physical violence before the hurricane, and 17 women, which is listed as
00:08:12 8.3% of the total surveyed, reported violence after the hurricane. I don't see how that's a
00:08:20 98% increase. To me, it looks like an increase of 54.5%. But I will accept that it's an increase.
00:08:30 With such relatively small numbers, even an increase of two or three accounts of violence would have translated into a very large-sounding percentage increase.
00:08:41 And we don't know much about what kind of violence is being reported.
00:08:45 According to the study, violence could include any of hitting, slapping, shoving, punching, and or throwing objects.
00:08:53 And it's impossible to determine from the survey data the severity of the violence.
00:08:59 throwing a magazine is clearly not of the same magnitude as throwing a heavy glass object just
00:09:05 as a restrained shove doesn't compare to a punch in the face. So, without far more knowledge of
00:09:13 the alleged incidents and their context, it's really impossible to know what to make of the
00:09:18 statistical spike. But even more interesting is the abstract statement about reports of physical
00:09:27 victimization remaining unchanged for men. Most people reading that statement would likely assume
00:09:34 that the number of men reporting violence was lower than the number of women both before and
00:09:39 after Hurricane Katrina. But that would be wrong because the body of the study reveals that
00:09:46 actually the number of men reporting violence was higher than the number of women, a fact never
00:09:53 mentioned in any of the feminist articles and reports I've looked at. The study tells us that
00:09:59 18 men, 11.7% of the total surveyed, reported experiencing physical violence in the six months
00:10:08 before the hurricane compared with 21 men, said to be 10%, following the hurricane. Again, I don't
00:10:16 quite understand the numbers. I'm not sure why the evident increase in the number of men reporting
00:10:23 violence was stated in the abstract to be unchanged. Clearly, 21 men is a higher number
00:10:28 than 18. And it's also not clear to me why the larger number of men reporting physical violence
00:10:34 after the hurricane is represented as making up a smaller percentage. But what is undeniable here
00:10:41 is that the study results completely undermine the feminist narrative of exclusively male
00:10:48 perpetrator and female victim. More men than women reported physical victimization before
00:10:56 Hurricane Katrina, and more men than women reported physical victimization after. And this is a
00:11:02 staggering omission, so much for the gendered impact of natural disasters. For feminists, of 1.00
00:11:11 course, gendered impact is always code for women more affected. And this is the second feminist 1.00
00:11:18 strategy used to buttress outright misrepresentation, the use of elaborate feminist 1.00
00:11:25 terminology to create a totally gynocentric lens on the world. When you see a phrase like 1.00
00:11:32 gender-based violence, know that you have entered a twilight zone of obfuscation and denial.
00:11:41 According to a Canadian government website, gender-based violence is, quote,
00:11:46 violence that is committed against someone based on their gender identity, gender expression, or perceived gender, end quote.
00:11:57 Only someone trained in gender studies could have written this meaningless statement,
00:12:03 which implies that the violence is somehow caused by the fact of the person's gender,
00:12:09 a claim that is conveniently both totally unverifiable and unfalsifiable. What is implied
00:12:16 here and in the discussion that follows is that violence, when it is directed against women as
00:12:22 well as against members of LGBTQ groups, isn't ordinary violence. It's only ordinary violence
00:12:30 when it is directed against heterosexual men. According to feminist reasoning, women and these 0.90
00:12:36 certain others are particularly vulnerable to violence because they are culturally denigrated, 0.97
00:12:43 objectified, othered, or believed to need to be controlled. So, similar to the phrase
00:12:50 rape culture, the phrase gender-based violence seems to indicate that violence against women
00:12:57 should concern us more than violence against men because it is culturally condoned or even
00:13:04 approved. The fact that it is singled out for special attention on a government website
00:13:10 would seem to imply the opposite, that far from being condoned, it is particularly hated. But
00:13:17 this form of reasoning doesn't seem to strike the feminist mind. And at the same time as claiming 1.00
00:13:23 that violence against women is especially horrible because it is based on gender, while
00:13:29 violence against heterosexual men is supposedly neutral and non-discriminatory, perhaps even
00:13:36 necessary. Feminist advocates also assert that women are more severely affected by violence
00:13:43 than men, both physically and psychologically. For example, in a 2013 study of violence against
00:13:51 women in the aftermath of the Black Saturday bushfires in Australia, university researcher
00:13:57 Deborah Parkinson, clarified the feminist point of view, explaining that, quote,
00:14:03 domestic violence is men's violence against women, where women's violence does not equate
00:14:11 to men's in terms of frequency, severity, consequences, and the victim's sense of safety
00:14:19 and well-being, end quote. This is a jaw-dropping piece of special pleading, and two types of
00:14:27 claims prop up its sickening double standards. First, that men's violence against women is an
00:14:35 entirely different order of violence than violence against men, much more severe, apparently. And
00:14:41 second, that women are also more affected by men's violence psychologically and emotionally.
00:14:47 Well, the first claim is flat-out contradicted by empirical studies.
00:14:53 The National Coalition Against Domestic Violence, for example, has published a fact sheet stating
00:15:00 that one in seven men, quote, have been victims of severe physical violence, e.g. beating,
00:15:08 burning, strangling by an intimate partner, end quote.
00:15:13 We don't know if all that violence was committed by a female intimate partner, of course, but we 0.79
00:15:18 can safely conclude that the vast majority of it was. It is nonsense to suggest that a woman's 0.97
00:15:25 burning or strangling of her partner doesn't count as severe. The second claim that men are
00:15:31 less hurt psychologically or emotionally by the violence they experience is morally incoherent
00:15:38 to the point of absurdity. How could such a claim ever be proved? It may well be the case
00:15:45 that men don't express their response to violence in the same ways that women do,
00:15:50 or that they experience the violence differently, perhaps ignoring and denying it. But to conclude,
00:15:57 therefore, that men's well-being isn't affected by severe violence? It's simply immoral. Only a
00:16:04 belief that men are actually not quite human could justify such reasoning. But that's what feminists 0.94
00:16:11 seem to believe, and that's certainly what they get away with. And it's long past time that these 1.00
00:16:18 researchers and advocates were forced to answer for their dishonesty and their bigotry.
00:16:26 In conclusion, reliable studies show that men are physically assaulted in the home at approximately
00:16:33 the same rate as women, and that a not insignificant portion of men, though a smaller portion than
00:16:39 women, experience severe abuse and death. And yet feminists around the world, as shown
00:16:46 clearly in the Guardian article and elsewhere, don't consider men worthy of concern and 0.94
00:16:53 tell lies to justify their indifference. And the only thing more repugnant than that
00:16:59 is the very large number of non-feminist men and women who have allowed such dangerous ideologues 1.00
00:17:08 to take control of journalism, policing, and the judiciary. 0.98