00:00:20The Feminist Whisper Network is a strategy of female power consisting of rumor, anonymous1.00
00:00:27complaints, and personal communications designed to savage a man's career and reputation1.00
00:00:34without the necessity of any formal process. Once it becomes known that some kind of
00:00:41misconduct accusation has been made, presto, the man's professional life is effectively ended.
00:00:49Nobody can say how often such sting operations are carried out. Many women and their male
00:00:55enablers have come to believe that formal investigations fail female victims, and therefore
00:01:02they're quite happy to take personal action against accused men. In this video, I will look at three
00:01:09examples from academia in which the presumption of innocence was the first casualty. I've restricted
00:01:16myself to cases that predate the Me Too movement in order to correct the widespread misunderstanding
00:01:22that Me Too's call-out culture represents something new in feminist activism.
00:01:29My first and perhaps most shocking example concerns Vancouver writer and former university professor Stephen Galloway.
00:01:40Galloway was once a member of the Whisper Network before he himself became its victim,
00:01:47ultimately losing his job as professor of creative writing at the University of British
00:01:52Columbia as a result of accusations of sexual misconduct. Once the first accusation was made
00:01:59against him, a groundswell of complaints erupted, all of which were ultimately found to be either
00:02:05unsubstantiated or laughably trivial. In an article, he wrote about how his life and career
00:02:13were devastated for nothing. The former professor first gave a concise outline of how he once
00:02:20participated in a behind-the-scenes gang-up on another man. He reports that, quote,
00:02:27in the spring of 2013, a graduate student came to me to report that she had been sexually
00:02:33assaulted. She texted me seeking support, reluctant to disclose anything for fear of
00:02:39fallout this was my response there will be no fallout i support you 100 percent end quote
00:02:47when the student a woman some years older than galloway told him what had supposedly
00:02:53happened to her he replied quote i will do whatever you wish me to do a very bad idea
00:03:00as it would turn out the graduate student told galloway that a man who was interviewing for a
00:03:06job at their university had once sexually assaulted her she didn't want to formally report
00:03:12the alleged assault but she wished to be sure the man would not be hired for the position
00:03:19galloway notes that he quote reported the incident to the program chair keith millard and he notified
00:03:26the graduate advisor instead of taking the allegation to the dean's office we respected
00:03:31the graduate student's request to keep her complaint confidential. Under Millard's direction,
00:03:38steps were taken by the three of us to ensure that the candidate didn't get the position."1.00
00:03:45Here is the feminist whisper network in efficient action. Long before Me Too, Galloway and his
00:03:54friend Keith Millard and others acted as obedient feminist foot soldiers to deny a man a job0.91
00:04:01opportunity on the basis of a woman's completely unsubstantiated allegation galloway informs us a
00:04:08few sentences later that the woman had a history of such allegations but he acted for her anyway
00:04:16eventually she made a similar accusation against galloway that resulted in the evisceration of his0.95
00:04:23career so much for female powerlessness and male privilege notice how this supposedly vulnerable1.00
00:04:33woman not only seriously blighted a man's career prospects by manipulating a man she was sexually1.00
00:04:40involved with galloway was having an affair with her at the time as he informs us but she also1.00
00:04:46effectively hid her responsibility by having white knights operate on her behalf. The use of male
00:04:54proxies is typical of female relational aggression of this sort. In telling his story, Galloway
00:05:03doesn't comment on his own willingness to do harm to another man, someone who was in retrospect
00:05:10likely falsely accused also, but presumably Galloway is well aware of the irony. Later,
00:05:18he would be abandoned by his close friend Keith Millard and persecuted by most of his colleagues
00:05:25when the same woman some years after the termination of their affair accused him of raping
00:05:31her. Despite the fact that Galloway was ultimately cleared through an independent investigation by a
00:05:38former female judge named Mary Ellen Boyd and paid $167,000 in compensation by the university for
00:05:46the damage done to his reputation, he has not by any means been publicly exonerated. Many feminist
00:05:56activists maintain his guilt and his name is still closely associated with sexual misconduct.
00:06:03At my own university, for example, a literary conference held in May of 2019 referred to the
00:06:10Galloway affair in relation to, quote, a culture of entrenched sexualized violence, end quote.
00:06:18Moreover, the identity of the woman who falsely accused Galloway is still shielded.
00:06:25In a culture of female victimology, facts are irrelevant because a society that believes women is necessarily a society that disbelieves men.0.65
00:06:38The second instance of the Whisper Network performing its malignant work to undermine due process involves an astronomy professor and feminist activist named Carol Mundell, now at Bath University in England.0.63
00:06:55Professor Mundell has been found to have blackballed a junior astronomer, Chris Simpson, who had just been hired as chief scientist to the South African Square Kilometer Array Project.
00:07:16All she had to do was contact the head of science operations at the young man's new workplace to tell him that Simpson had been accused of sexual misconduct and had been suspended while he was under investigation by his former university.
00:07:33professor mandel expressed her conviction to simpson's new employer that had the disciplinary
00:07:42hearing been able to conclude which it was not able to conclude it would quote undoubtedly have
00:07:49resulted in his dismissal for gross misconduct end quote there is no way she could have known
00:07:58this. But I guess she's telepathic as well as telescopic and obviously feels no compunction
00:08:05about wrecking a man's career dreams on the basis of allegations she could not possibly have known
00:08:12to be true. She also expressed concern that the head of department at his former university,
00:08:19Professor Michael Bode, had written a letter of reference for Chris Simpson that didn't mention
00:08:25the misconduct allegation, or the investigation. In other words, this feminist busybody was upset1.00
00:08:33that Chris Simpson's superior had not sought to ruin a promising young researcher's career.0.59
00:08:40Isn't it enraging when people write letters of reference based on what is known about a candidate's
00:08:46ability and achievements, not based on corrosive rumors? Professor Mundell's intervention was all
00:08:55about ostensibly protecting women from harm, though it had never been proven that Chris
00:09:01Simpson had ever harmed a woman, and even though there has never been any criminal charge brought
00:09:06against him. Mandel claimed that, quote, Simpson's misconduct is becoming known more widely in some
00:09:15circles, a carefully vague phrase that denotes nothing more than that she was busy participating
00:09:23in a whisper network. Professor Mike Bode, the head of department who had written the positive
00:09:29letter of recommendation for Simpson, was incensed enough to launch a lawsuit against Professor
00:09:36Mundell for libel and slander, but he lost the case as there was insufficient evidence in the
00:09:41judge's view that Mundell's words had caused harm to his reputation. Professor Mundell emerged with
00:09:48her reputation intact, perhaps even with a boost as a protector of women, and Chris Simpson, the
00:09:55junior astronomer, lost the South African position. He did find a job as data process developer at the
00:10:04Gemini Observatory in Hawaii, but that is clearly a step down from being a professor of astrophysics
00:10:10research, and it is unlikely he'll have the chance again to work in academia. Score another point
00:10:18for the devastating whisper network. I suspect that conduct like Professor Mundell's is now
00:10:24far from unusual amongst the powerful women and their male enablers and departments all across0.99
00:10:31Western universities as they work behind closed doors through their official and unofficial0.96
00:10:37communication channels to blacken the reputations of men who have never been found guilty of anything
00:10:44in a court of law. As one writer for Vox magazine phrased it,
00:10:50feminists are working hard to, quote, weaponize the whisper network.0.97
00:10:55A third instance of disregard for the presumption of innocence occurred at the University of Windsor0.99
00:11:02in Ontario, Canada. An article by Canada's public broadcaster in May of 2018 claimed to be about
00:11:10the ethics of non-disclosure agreements, but is equally about the unrelenting determination
00:11:17to ruin a man's career exhibited by one University of Windsor feminist law professor0.56
00:11:24named Julie McFarlane. This case involved a popular tenured law professor at the University1.00
00:11:31of Windsor who was alleged to have played favorites with his students and to have created
00:11:37allegedly a, quote, climate of intimidation and fear. According to an investigation by the
00:11:44journalist who wrote the article, quote, several students, in other words, more than two, said the
00:11:51professor, quote, repeatedly crossed the line of appropriate student-teacher relationships, end
00:11:57quote. Students said he, quote, would befriend students on social media and show up at student
00:12:03parties, end quote. A number of female students claim that things he said made them feel
00:12:09uncomfortable. Well, this is nowhere near sexual assault, but it is certainly enough to get a male
00:12:16professor in big trouble these days. A half dozen professors at his school, including Julie McFarlane,
00:12:24lodged a complaint against him and he was suspended while an investigation was carried out. But this
00:12:30was not enough for Professor McFarlane. She discovered that the man was working part-time
00:12:36at another university while he was being investigated. So she decided to get in touch
00:12:41with people there, despite the fact that the University of Windsor was not authorized to
00:12:46talk about the ongoing investigation, and despite the fact that she had been explicitly told
00:12:52by the president of her university not to contact this man's new employer. But powered by the potent
00:13:00elixir of feminist righteousness, she went ahead anyway, and the man's employment was terminated
00:13:05a few weeks later. The woman's whisper network worked extremely well. Later on, the man was0.70
00:13:13dismissed from the University of Windsor. He filed a grievance against the university, and
00:13:20ultimately he came to a settlement with his former employer involving a non-disclosure agreement.
00:13:26The same feminist professor, seemingly with a deep personal interest in the case, then learned that the man had been hired to teach in the Faculty of Law at a university in Jamaica.
00:13:39She made inquiries there, too, seemingly in order to have him dismissed from that position, though it's not clear what, if anything, occurred as a result.
00:13:50Perhaps the feminist whisper network doesn't extend to Jamaica, at least not yet.
00:13:56Regardless, it seems fair to say that Professor McFarlane wished to make sure that her former colleague, though convicted of no crime and alleged to have done nothing more terrible, it seems, than make romantic overtures to adult women at his university, should never have an academic job again anywhere in the world and had at least some friends and associates who were willing to help make that true.
00:14:26And her conduct is reported in the article as perfectly legitimate.0.54
00:14:34What we see in all these cases is the typical female form of aggression, hidden and indirect,0.96
00:14:42based on behind-the-scenes machinations, often using male proxies, often involving the spreading0.67
00:14:48of rumors rather than the use of formal channels.
00:14:52The primary aim is to avoid having to follow established policies and guidelines and instead
00:14:59to work informally to demonize and punish a particular male target. Female aggressors in1.00
00:15:07these kinds of cases rarely take responsibility for their desire to harm accused men claiming to0.83
00:15:14be concerned with female safety. Such situations can only happen in a culture that has accepted
00:15:22the supposed pervasiveness of male sexual misconduct and female helplessness. It's a
00:15:29culture that believes women never use their sexual power for their own ends, and that believes the
00:15:36alleged protection of women should override basic principles of due process and equality before the
00:15:43law. It's a culture in which men have been more than willing to sell out other men, and in which
00:15:51very few men or women have had the courage to insist on the presumption of innocence.0.90
00:15:58And so long as women's relational aggression and men's misplaced chivalry remain in force,0.96
00:16:06it seems likely that whisper tactics will continue to wreak their devastating havoc.0.98