The Fiamengo File - March 28, 2020


Should Feminists Have the Right to Vote - TFF Episode 117

Coronavirus: More Men Die, Women Most Affected - The Fiamengo File Episode 116 The Feminist Whisper Network - The Fiamengo File Episode 115, v 2.0

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

122.91

Word count

2,191

Sentence count

66

Harmful content

Misogyny

46

sentences flagged

Hate speech

14

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Recently, a feminist woman published an article in The Atlantic magazine about how angry she
00:00:08 got at her husband because he didn't vote for Elizabeth Warren in the Democratic presidential
00:00:14 race.
00:00:16 Read in the context of centuries-old arguments about women and politics, this particular 0.88
00:00:23 woman's very public meltdown shows us once again the destructive power of an ideology 0.97
00:00:30 that encourages women to be their worst selves. 0.99
00:00:45 The decision by Elizabeth Warren to withdraw from the presidential race led to a chorus 1.00
00:00:50 of lamentation across the land as feminists made clear their belief that the time for a female 0.99
00:00:56 president was long past due it was rehashed on many talk shows that women make better leaders
00:01:04 because they are supposedly more compassionate and more collaborative than men as in the following
00:01:11 clip from the view it's like there's this quote that like where's my jet pack where's my woman
00:01:16 president like why are we still here as americans and i think it's frustrating and for me i'd love
00:01:22 it to be a conservative woman like happy if it's nikki haley or someone like else but i do think 0.63
00:01:26 women traditionally are better leaders in a lot of situations because we're more compassionate
00:01:30 and we don't have to deal there's more collaborative in every country and i think for me i'm just i'm 0.99
00:01:35 35 i'm going to be 36 by the next election or almost yeah 36 next election where's my woman
00:01:40 president i would like a woman to be president in my lifetime maybe you should run the idea that one 1.00
00:01:46 should cast one's ballot at least partially, if not entirely, according to the sex of the candidate 1.00
00:01:52 would, of course, be outrageous if it were said about a man, and feminists do often allege without
00:01:59 evidence that men won't vote for female candidates because of sexism. But somehow it's not considered
00:02:07 sexist to advocate voting for a female candidate because she's a woman, or even, as we'll see,
00:02:12 to suggest that men owe it to women to vote for a female president over 100 years ago when voting
00:02:22 rights for women were being debated across the english-speaking world what are now sometimes 0.59
00:02:28 considered female advantages in politics such as women's touted compassion and people skills
00:02:36 were generally held to be disadvantages. Opponents of extending the franchise to women 0.95
00:02:42 argued that the female temperament, while well-suited for family life and the helping 1.00
00:02:47 professions, didn't equip women to be responsible voters or political leaders.
00:02:54 Women possessed many admirable qualities, the anti-suffragists declared, but in the main, 1.00
00:03:01 they didn't possess the crucial ability to put rational principle above passion or to separate 1.00
00:03:09 self-interest from the common good. It was also alleged that women tended to lack knowledge and 1.00
00:03:16 interest in political matters such as economics and international relations. Writing in the Globe
00:03:23 newspaper in 1885, Canadian journalist Sarah Jeanette Duncan, though she was cautiously in 0.95
00:03:32 favor of woman suffrage, still warned that many women would need to acquire a far deeper 0.99
00:03:38 understanding of public affairs than they possessed at present if they were ever to vote 0.90
00:03:42 intelligently. Like some of those who opposed the vote for women, Duncan believed women were
00:03:48 too easily influenced by personality and feeling rather than rational argument and would be more
00:03:55 likely than men to make political decisions based on the candidate they liked best rather than on
00:04:02 the candidate's political platform. British anti-suffragist and essayist Ethel Harrison
00:04:09 put it more harshly in 1909 when she asserted that, quote, the point of hysterical emotion and
00:04:17 unreason is always nearer with women. Women's nerve force is slighter, she said, and their 0.52
00:04:25 self-restraint less, end quote. Anti-suffragists admitted that, of course, not all women had these
00:04:33 disabilities, just as not all men were paragons of reason, but in general, they insisted on the
00:04:39 reality of intellectual and emotional sex differences. Lord Cromer, a British opponent
00:04:46 of woman suffrage feared that women's much-discussed compassion would lead in the direction of 0.66
00:04:52 socialism, unsustainable government debt, and ever greater expansion of the state.
00:04:59 Perhaps it is too soon to say whether those who opposed the vote for women were right or not.
00:05:05 The century that followed the granting of the women's vote saw neither the dramatic change for
00:05:12 the worse feared by the anti-suffragists, nor the dramatic change for the better forecast by the
00:05:19 pro-woman suffragists. But one thing is inarguable. The woman question, as it was then called,
00:05:27 basically the discussion of the role that women should play in public life, including women's
00:05:32 complaints and demands, that remained at the forefront of public debate. So let's look at
00:05:40 the aforementioned article by a fervent female supporter of Elizabeth Warren in order to consider 0.99
00:05:46 the habits of mind of a feminist voter extolling the virtues of a woman president. The article is 0.98
00:05:55 by Ellen O'Connell Wittett, an essayist and lecturer in the writing program at the University
00:06:02 of California at Santa Barbara. It is titled, I Voted for Warren, My Husband Voted for Sanders,
00:06:10 and I feel betrayed. In the subtitle, the aggrieved wife tells us that, quote, voting for a progressive
00:06:19 woman felt like a chance so rare that it caused me to fume at my own husband for making a different
00:06:25 decision, end quote. Notice how forms of the verb to feel appear in both the main heading and the
00:06:34 explanatory subheading, and the emphasis on feeling is sustained throughout this rather
00:06:41 melodramatic and, dare I say, hysterical piece of writing. The husband, it seems, isn't allowed to
00:06:48 feel anything except appropriate male contrition and deference to his angry wife. In a saner time,
00:06:57 one might have expected an article with that kind of title and subtitle to move in a certain
00:07:02 predictable narrative direction, from anger and self-righteousness to self-awareness, as the woman
00:07:10 writer comes to recognize that it is irrational, even perhaps a sign of megalomania, to be mad at
00:07:18 her husband over his vote. But that's not the direction of this essay. In fact, it ends pretty
00:07:26 well right where it began, with the woman in question still licking her wounds and seemingly
00:07:32 unable or unwilling to accept that her husband doesn't exist solely to gratify her imagined
00:07:40 needs. She comes to no epiphany, remaining totally blind to the enormity of her own behavior.
00:07:49 And it's worth noting that the context for her anger is entirely trivial. It's not like the
00:07:55 husband was opposed to the idea of a female president or came to bed wearing a MAGA hat.
00:08:01 On the contrary, Wittet's hubby is a committed, progressive, and a pro-Warren feminist. He merely
00:08:08 made a strategic choice to vote for Bernie. But even this minor difference of opinion in philosophy
00:08:15 and strategy could not be borne by Wittet, who tells the reader in more detail than we need to
00:08:23 know about, quote, tearful conversations and failed attempts to make her husband understand
00:08:30 the necessity of Warren. After they voted, she berated him for refusing to support a woman when
00:08:38 it mattered. She even pressed him to say he regretted his vote and was disappointed he couldn't
00:08:44 even offer her that. It is simply impossible to imagine a man writing about his uncontrollable
00:08:53 anger over his wife's voting choice and getting that published in a highbrow magazine.
00:08:59 Wittitt concludes the article, nursing what she calls her grief, bonding with her equally
00:09:06 aggrieved woman friends and making it clear to her husband in a subtle threat that he had better 1.00
00:09:12 think differently next time so that, quote, whoever the first progressive woman president is, 1.00
00:09:17 my husband and I can vote for her together, end quote. Such stubborn, pointless anger is a clear 0.94
00:09:26 realization of the fears of the anti-suffrage campaigners back in the 19th century who worried
00:09:33 that women were far better at being unhappy about things than at understanding the causes of
00:09:40 problems or knowing how to solve them. Sarah Jeanette Duncan made the point in 1885 that it
00:09:47 was all very well for women to complain passionately about the wrongs of their society, 0.91
00:09:53 but in order for women to participate usefully in public life, as she said,
00:09:59 quote, to ardor they must add acumen, and to sincerity, sagacity, and to disgust with present 0.73
00:10:08 conditions the ability to improve them, end quote. She feared that very few women had or even cared 0.97
00:10:17 to acquire the necessary acumen, sagacity, or ability to understand politics. Even a century
00:10:26 before the suffrage movement, commentators on women's position in society recognized the problem
00:10:33 of women's greater susceptibility to emotion. In 1792, British writer Mary Wollstonecraft,
00:10:42 future wife of political radical William Godwin and future mother of Mary Shelley,
00:10:47 the author of Frankenstein, published her A Vindication of the Rights of Woman.
00:10:53 Here, she proposed that female emotionalism should and would diminish when women were
00:11:00 properly educated to the same degree as men. She argued that men and women were equally capable 1.00
00:11:08 of rational judgment and self-control, and she blamed men for encouraging women's sentimental 0.54
00:11:16 excesses. In the decades that followed, women's educational opportunities expanded significantly
00:11:24 as universities and the professions were open to them. But the revolution in female psychology 1.00
00:11:32 that Wollstonecraft had spoken about failed to materialize. Why was that?
00:11:40 Put simply, at the same time that women became more active outside the home than ever before 0.66
00:11:47 in the West, freed by male-invented technology to enter public life to a degree formerly impossible,
00:11:54 Rather than embracing Wollstonecraft's prescription, many feminist leaders promoted the idea that women were more emotional than men and that this was a good thing, something to be defended and promoted in all areas of life, including the political, as we saw in the clip from The View, where media personality Meghan McCain was applauded for asserting that women are more compassionate than men
00:12:24 and that being compassionate is a key quality for a U.S. president.
00:12:30 One hundred years earlier, Canadian feminist Nellie McClung had argued that women voters 1.00
00:12:36 would make the world a better place because of women's compassionate nature. 0.96
00:12:43 She said, quote, the woman's outlook on life is to save, to care for, to help. 1.00
00:12:51 Men make wounds and women bind them up, end quote.
00:12:58 In the heyday of the second wave feminist movement, in books such as In a Different Voice, published in 1982 by feminist moral philosopher and New York University professor Carol Gilligan, 1.00
00:13:14 feminists argued that women developed as moral agents differently from men. Gilligan, for example, 0.96
00:13:22 claimed that female morality didn't rely on rational principle, but rather on relationships 1.00
00:13:29 and feeling, and that the result was an equally valuable, if not more valuable, way of being in 0.99
00:13:36 the world. This is a notion with a long, complex history that goes at least as far back in English
00:13:42 thought as the romantic revolution of the later 18th century when philosophers argued about the
00:13:49 kinds of wisdom that feeling can bring. Jane Austen had tackled the issue squarely in her 1811 novel
00:13:58 Sense and Sensibility, in which she demonstrated through her character Marianne how the romantic
00:14:05 elevation of feeling above all else actually reduces empathy for others by encouraging
00:14:14 selfish excess and preoccupation with self. Deliberately rejecting the message of Austin
00:14:21 that such feeling had to be controlled, rejecting that message, the message of other traditional
00:14:28 moralists, radical theorists claimed that those whose feelings were strongest were better than
00:14:36 other people. And at its most extreme, this idea adopted into feminism gave permission to women 0.89
00:14:43 to be emotional bullies, as is the woman in the article about Elizabeth Warren. And as are many
00:14:52 feminist activists who march and demand and petition and cry Me Too as if their feelings
00:15:00 justify all. To return to the article, Wittitt makes it clear that she's more than willing to
00:15:11 cause days of grief in her marriage, maybe weeks or months of grief over a small difference of
00:15:17 political opinion and isn't at all ashamed of that. What kind of woman has the gall to admit
00:15:24 and even boast about her unreasonable behavior? Answer, a woman who believes that as a woman she 1.00
00:15:32 has been wronged by the world and that her husband, and by extension all men,
00:15:36 owe her recompense because of being born male. Feminists like Wittet stand as a striking 0.56
00:15:47 refutation of Mary Wollstonecraft's argument back in 1792 that as women gained more rights and 1.00
00:15:54 became less dependent on men and more highly educated, their intellectual and rational powers
00:16:00 would come to dominate over their emotional natures.
00:16:06 Wollstonecraft would be deeply alarmed by the self-indulgent and destructive nonsense 1.00
00:16:12 that passes for women's activism today. 1.00
00:16:16 In sum, feminism does women and men no favors in encouraging the weaknesses of female nature, 1.00
00:16:25 women's resentment self-pity and lack of self-restraint to become celebrated elements 1.00
00:16:32 of female behavior and in pretending that emoting is a sign of goodness 1.00
00:16:42 in fact it is nothing more than a recipe for rancor and dysfunction in both family life and 1.00
00:16:49 politics. I take little satisfaction in doubting that Wittet and her husband will ever vote
00:16:57 together for a progressive woman president because unless each is willing to make profound
00:17:03 changes in their behavior, their marriage may well not last long enough.
00:17:19 Thank you.