The Fiamengo File - March 24, 2020


Coronavirus: More Men Die, Women Most Affected - The Fiamengo File Episode 116

Feminists Slander Australian Firefighters and All Men - The Fiamengo File Episode 114 Should Feminists Have the Right to Vote - TFF Episode 117

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

133.44

Word count

1,525

Sentence count

52

Harmful content

Misogyny

20

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Some friends have written me recently that one of the very few upsides to the coronavirus, 0.70
00:00:06 if there might be any, could be a ceasefire in feminist attacks on men. Discussions of
00:00:13 male privilege and gendered power imbalances may well seem out of place during a worldwide
00:00:20 health crisis. So far, unfortunately, that doesn't seem to be the case. In fact, a profusion
00:00:27 of articles and news stories have recently informed us that when it comes to COVID-19,
00:00:33 as with any health scare, natural disaster, armed conflict, or economic crisis, women are most
00:00:40 affected. Most of these articles stress the necessity of a gendered analysis of the virus.
00:00:57 in other words, an analysis of how men and women are differently affected, but then go on
00:01:02 predictably to focus entirely on women and to say next to nothing about men, except to admit at the
00:01:10 outset sometimes that men are far more likely to die from the virus than women. Reports out of
00:01:18 China and Italy indicate that of those killed by the virus, an alarmingly high number are male,
00:01:25 up to 70% in Italy. This isn't unusual, apparently, in coronavirus-type outbreaks.
00:01:33 In 2003, as the New York Times reports, the death rate from SARS in Hong Kong was 50% higher for men
00:01:41 than women. The Times cited Dr. Deborah Birx, the coronavirus response coordinator for the White
00:01:48 House, saying that the gender gap in deaths is once again about twice as high for men. She was
00:01:55 even quoted in the Washington Post as saying that this was a, quote, concerning trend. She followed 0.99
00:02:02 that up, though, with a bit of a non sequitur saying, quote, this should alert all of us to
00:02:08 continue our vigilance to protect Americans who are in nursing homes, end quote. Perhaps it is so
00:02:14 unusual to single out men as deserving of vigilant care that the words American men just couldn't
00:02:23 roll off her tongue. I've tried in vain to imagine a scenario in which a global pandemic was causing
00:02:31 women to die in much higher numbers than men and have that not be a front page news item and the
00:02:39 major focus in all articles. It's very hard to visualize a raft of articles at such a time
00:02:46 written by men arguing that really it was men we should think about most. But that's what we have
00:02:53 from our feminist journalists in articles with titles like Helen Lewis's The Coronavirus is a 1.00
00:03:00 disaster for feminism which declared melodramatically that quote across the world 0.72
00:03:05 women's independence will be a silent victim of the pandemic, end quote. And there is Lara Owens,
00:03:12 coronavirus, five ways virus upheaval is hitting women in Asia, which found it grossly unfair that 0.55
00:03:19 among other things, women were having to stay at home playing games and watching films with their
00:03:25 kids while their husbands continued going to work. And we've had Courtney Conley's how women could be 1.00
00:03:32 uniquely impacted by the coronavirus, which was angry about the demands on women working in
00:03:38 health care and in the home. And there was Lucia Graves' women's domestic burden just got heavier 0.95
00:03:45 with the coronavirus, targeting women's so-called unpaid labor. And also Claire Wenham et al.'s
00:03:52 COVID-19, the gendered impact of the outbreak, which saw the virus affecting many areas of
00:03:59 gendered power imbalance, and many others too predictable to mention. Sometimes these articles
00:04:07 do offer a quick explanation for the gendered death gap, the reasons most often given being
00:04:13 that men are more likely than women to be smokers and that women have a stronger natural immune
00:04:18 response against such infections. I have yet to read an article on gendered impacts that paused
00:04:26 over men's higher mortality rate, lamented it, quoted anybody distressed about it,
00:04:33 or suggested that special measures might be taken to protect men. I have yet to see a feminist 0.80
00:04:41 journalist suggesting women could take over most activities involving potential exposure 0.93
00:04:46 given women's greater immunity. I have yet to see a feminist article worrying about the men
00:04:53 who face risks in their jobs. Instead, the articles move with jaw-dropping indifference
00:04:59 about men to discuss what are glibly called the secondary impacts or the social impacts of the
00:05:06 virus on women, sometimes meaning, as it turns out, the inconveniences and possible career
00:05:12 implications for them. Many of these impacts are speculative and short-term and hardly compare in
00:05:20 severity to dying. The most serious is that women comprise the majority of health care workers and 1.00
00:05:27 thus are, quote, on the front lines of the COVID-19 fight, as one World Economic Forum article put it.
00:05:35 The other frequently repeated complaint, far less onerous, is that women are the primary caregivers 0.99
00:05:41 for children and other relatives, especially elderly relatives, and are thus disproportionately 0.97
00:05:47 burdened by school closures and the pressures of looking after sick parents. These may be true as
00:05:54 far as they go, but they certainly leave a great deal unsaid. My own experience in hospitals has
00:06:01 confirmed that, yes, a majority of nurses are female, and I applaud those who do a tough job
00:06:09 well. But there are many men working in health care too, not least the orderlies, the janitors,
00:06:15 and the ambulance workers, those who get sick people to hospital, transport patients from room
00:06:21 to room, sweep and disinfect and dispose of contaminated materials, and so on. In addition,
00:06:28 of course, many men are surgeons, specialists, and researchers, many of whom will be working
00:06:33 overtime to care for critically ill patients and to develop treatments and cures for the virus.
00:06:40 Until very recently, one could find articles aplenty lamenting the continuing gender imbalances, i.e. the lack of women in various health fields.
00:06:53 The American Medical Association published an article last October, just before COVID-19 was to appear in China, stating that women accounted for only about 45% of recent graduates from medical school and that male physicians far outnumbered women in certain surgical specialties.
00:07:16 A recent survey by the Journal of the American Medical Association was concerned that far more
00:07:22 women than men in medicine opt to work part-time or to shorten their hours. Within six years of
00:07:30 graduating from medical school, in fact, nearly three-quarters of female doctors seek to reduce 0.98
00:07:37 their hours compared to only one-quarter of male doctors. So which is it? Are women burdened in the 0.92
00:07:44 medical field by working too much, as the recent articles claim, or are they burdened by not being 1.00
00:07:51 as fully represented as feminists would like, in which case they would be working even more. 1.00
00:07:57 The situation is always far more complex than the feminist narrative asserts, and feminists 1.00
00:08:03 always seem to find a way to pretend that only women suffer or that only women's contribution 0.99
00:08:10 deserves notice and praise. The other contention about women shouldering the burden of family care
00:08:18 is stated as an uncontested fact, though it is not my experience that only women look after
00:08:25 children and other family members. The statement also neglects to mention that men work outside
00:08:32 the home for far longer hours and shoulder the greater burden of stress, stress-induced illness,
00:08:40 less time off, weaker social contacts, and a significantly shortened lifespan as a result.
00:08:49 A report this year by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development
00:08:54 recently noted that men in every OECD country surveyed spend longer hours in paid work outside
00:09:02 the home than women do, 90 minutes more per day on average, and tend to work in higher stress
00:09:10 positions with knock-on effects for their mental and physical well-being. The coronavirus will 0.95
00:09:16 likely exacerbate these inequalities as well, and you won't hear about them from feminist reporters.
00:09:25 The fact is that men do many of the world's most difficult, dangerous, and necessary jobs,
00:09:31 jobs that kill thousands of men every year and do so for the most part uncomplainingly
00:09:38 and effectively expecting no thanks and mostly getting none men maintain the sophisticated
00:09:46 systems that allow our communities to function the electrical grid the water system the roads
00:09:53 and transportation network. It is overwhelmingly male truckers, for example, usually working 14 0.61
00:10:02 hour days in difficult conditions, who deliver the food and other supplies that we've been
00:10:08 stockpiling over the past few weeks. They're suffering now as a result of measures taken
00:10:15 to control the virus, as the closing of rest areas and restaurants makes it nearly impossible
00:10:21 for many to find places to eat, use facilities, wash and sleep. You won't find a feminist anywhere 1.00
00:10:29 writing about their gendered inequality, though if that's the lens that you prefer, 1.00
00:10:36 gendered inequality is the correct phrase for the hard, sometimes deadly work mainly performed by
00:10:42 men. The simple truth is that sane people aren't or shouldn't be interested in counting up victim 0.90
00:10:51 points and monopolizing public concern for one sex at the other's expense. And the fact that
00:10:58 feminists keep doing it while claiming to care about gender equality is little short of obscene.
00:11:05 In a society where a significant portion of men have always sacrificed themselves for the public 0.57
00:11:12 good, and at a time when a virus is killing men at higher rates than women, it's definitely time
00:11:21 to lay off the poor me narcissistic feminist rhetoric. 1.00