The Fiamengo File - February 06, 2020


Feminists Slander Australian Firefighters and All Men - The Fiamengo File Episode 114

The #MeToo Trial Of The Century - The Fiamengo File Episode 113 Coronavirus: More Men Die, Women Most Affected - The Fiamengo File Episode 116

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

129.51

Word count

2,369

Sentence count

56

Harmful content

Misogyny

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Over the past months, wildfires have burned throughout Australia, and thousands of predominantly
00:00:09 male firefighters have risked their lives to help control the flames. 0.96
00:00:15 But rather than take a few months off from its all-out war on men, the feminist blame 1.00
00:00:21 machine kept chugging along. 1.00
00:00:30 In the midst of this hideous and heartbreaking national crisis, a feminist named Shirelle 0.99
00:00:41 Moody announced at a news conference called by Green Party Senator Larissa Waters that
00:00:47 men returning from fighting the fires would abuse their female partners.
00:00:53 She said it was known from research and from the experience of the Black Saturday bushfires
00:00:57 10 years earlier that women were subjected to much harsher much crueller domestic violence
00:01:04 following such disasters women become extremely unsafe when generally the men return home from
00:01:13 the fires and subject them to domestic violence this is not to say that every person on the front
00:01:19 line is a domestic violence perpetrator but certainly research shows and we know from the
00:01:24 the experience of Black Saturday in Victoria 10 years ago, that women are subjected to much
00:01:29 harsher, much crueler forms of domestic violence. And we need to make sure that those women are
00:01:35 looked after once the fires are done. Anger erupted almost immediately. Someone tracked
00:01:43 down the lead researcher on the Black Saturday study who claimed that while her research quote
00:01:48 "...did find an increase in family violence in fire-affected communities, we never narrowed it
00:01:55 down to make any particular findings about firefighters." End quote. And more on this study
00:02:02 in a few minutes. As the anger built, the Green Party senator, who had stood nodding at Sherelle
00:02:08 Moody's side, began vigorously backpedaling, stating that the Greens absolutely do not support
00:02:15 her statement and moody herself was castigated online for her ignorance and her self-righteousness 0.94
00:02:22 of course feminists rarely face serious consequences for their false or grossly 0.91
00:02:27 insensitive comments about men and moody was not forced to resign from her position
00:02:32 with the red heart campaign or even forced to apologize for her crass accusation what is perhaps
00:02:39 most interesting about the fracas though is that to my knowledge no one looked into the so-called
00:02:46 research that moody was referring to by monash university research fellow deborah parkinson who
00:02:53 as already noted said that she did find an increase in domestic violence after black saturday but
00:03:00 didn't narrow it down to firefighters well perhaps we shouldn't be surprised to discover that there
00:03:06 is no quantitative evidence to support the claim for an increase in violence and that the study
00:03:13 does contrary to parkinson's statement put particular emphasis on firefighters i'm going
00:03:21 to delve into parkinson's study shortly but before i do it's worth mentioning that sherelle moody
00:03:26 was not the only feminist during the bushfire crisis to call out australian men as perpetrators
00:03:32 of violence. Just a few days after her accusation, an article published in a journal called The
00:03:39 Conversation made very similar claims. The Conversation is favored by left-wing academics
00:03:46 and describes itself as a blend of, quote, academic rigor and, quote, journalistic flair.
00:03:53 The title of the article, however, is not especially rigorous in telling us that, quote,
00:03:58 domestic violence will spike in the bushfire aftermath and governments can no longer ignore it."
00:04:04 In fact, of course, no one knows that domestic violence will spike in the bushfire aftermath,
00:04:11 and it's irresponsible to claim that it will. But let's look to see if there is any quoted evidence
00:04:18 for the claim about bushfires and violence. The Conversation article links to two feminist works. 0.97
00:04:26 One is about climate change and women's health, looking at water shortages in Australia and their
00:04:32 impacts on rural women, nothing specifically about bushfires and domestic violence.
00:04:38 The other link is to a handbook for service workers to help staff interact with women
00:04:43 experiencing family violence. It is not itself a study of any kind. It does mention studies of
00:04:51 family violence and natural disasters in canada and the u.s but nothing about australia there is
00:04:57 one reference to australia and fires in the article and this is to the same study that
00:05:04 cherelle moody referred to the one by deborah parkinson it was published in the australian
00:05:10 journal of emergency management in 2013 and is titled the hidden disaster violence in the
00:05:18 aftermath of natural disaster. Parkinson also wrote a PhD thesis on this subject, which was
00:05:25 published online in 2017. Both exemplify the serious pitfalls of ideologically driven research.
00:05:36 Parkinson's project, conducted in association with an Australian women's health agency,
00:05:42 was an attempt to document violence against women after the Black Saturday fires
00:05:46 that ravaged the state of Victoria in southeastern Australia in 2009.
00:05:52 As a feminist, Parkinson was solely interested in male violence against women, taking the standard 0.98
00:05:59 feminist position that domestic violence is, quote, men's violence against women, where women's
00:06:06 violence doesn't equate to men's in terms of frequency, severity, etc. She mentions her reliance 0.62
00:06:12 on the Duluth model of power and control, whereby many non-violent behaviors, such as
00:06:19 controlling finances, are considered to be abuse. Like most feminists, Parkinson seems to have begun 1.00
00:06:28 with her conclusions and fitted her findings into them. Her premises include that men are violent
00:06:35 because of their privilege, that the social construction of masculinity left men unable to
00:06:41 deal with the trauma of the fires and that women are uniquely vulnerable to domestic abuse at all
00:06:48 times and even more so at times of crisis when women's needs are allegedly ignored and male
00:06:56 heroism she puts the word in quotation marks allows their mistreatment of women to go unchecked
00:07:03 her conclusion was that we need to do more to empower women we need disaster planning from 0.72
00:07:09 a feminist perspective we need to socialize men differently of course and especially that we need 0.96
00:07:15 under all circumstances to hold men criminally accountable for their so-called abuse what is
00:07:23 most striking about both the article and the 200 page long doctoral thesis is that parkinson
00:07:29 acknowledges the weakness of her evidence noting that quote no reliable statistics were available
00:07:38 to document the effect of the disaster on domestic violence occurrences neither the existing family
00:07:45 violence services victoria police nor the victoria bushfire case management system could provide
00:07:53 conclusive data confirming the suspicion that few researchers undertake examining gender-based
00:08:00 violence in disasters because it is both methodologically and practically difficult to
00:08:05 study end quote well it is worth pausing over that statement no reliable statistics no conclusive
00:08:16 data so the study author admits from the start that she is proceeding on the basis of no reliable
00:08:24 statistics or documentation so what is the basis of her study parkinson notes that quote after
00:08:33 black saturday there were murmurs of increased domestic violence end quote her research sought
00:08:40 to flesh out these murmurs in the absence of documentation she relied on memories and anecdotes 0.89
00:08:48 amongst a very small interview group as she tells us quote interviews were held with 30 women and
00:08:57 47 service workers in the areas affected by the black saturday bushfires end quote
00:09:03 who were these 30 women and how were they chosen they were women recruited for the study through
00:09:10 advertisements in newspapers flyers and word of mouth in other words 30 women came forward in
00:09:17 response to an invitation to do so this is hardly a representative sampling of the general population
00:09:25 in the bushfire areas. Parkinson acknowledges that the sample is small and explains its size
00:09:32 by speculating about women's, quote, reluctance to come forward, claiming that women have been,
00:09:38 quote, silenced from speaking about the violence they endured. In all, 15 women spoke to her of
00:09:47 personally experiencing abuse after the fires and two spoke of learning of abuse from close family
00:09:53 members. And the service workers also affirmed their sense that there was an increase in reports
00:09:59 of violence. In the absence of documentation, there was no way to measure how much violence
00:10:06 there was after the fires or if and how much it increased. There was also no way to measure
00:10:13 whether or not it increased in severity. Everything in the study is based on impressions
00:10:19 and anecdotes amongst a very small group and with a very broad definition of violence that includes
00:10:27 so-called emotional and psychological abuse moreover because parkinson brought a feminist
00:10:34 perspective to her study she does not report and it's not clear that she ever asked i really doubt
00:10:39 she did whether the women were themselves violent or psychologically and emotionally abusive most of
00:10:47 of the interview responses quoted in her PhD thesis concern heated arguments and yelling,
00:10:54 and I would encourage everyone to take a look at this thesis and to see what counts as evidence
00:11:00 from this feminist perspective. It is astoundingly thin. 0.95
00:11:05 Moreover, as I mentioned earlier, Sherelle Moody was not wrong to have remembered that
00:11:12 the study indicated specifically that firefighters were coming home to abuse their partners because
00:11:18 that's exactly what the study suggests, though indeed it doesn't quantify numbers of firefighters
00:11:25 because it doesn't quantify anything. Here's a direct quotation from Parkinson's study,
00:11:31 quote, some of the women had partners who were firefighters at the front lines of an
00:11:36 unprecedented disaster. Their training would not have been adequate preparation for what they 0.84
00:11:43 faced and the sight of so many injured and burned people. The stress of that day and the following
00:11:49 weeks of high alert are unimaginable to those who were not there." Notice that part of this
00:11:57 discussion, the part that explicitly theorizes about firefighter stress and its effects, is
00:12:02 placed in the conditional tense. Their training would not have been adequate. Parkinson quotes
00:12:08 a source named Emma saying that professional firefighters bore, quote, the grief and the loss
00:12:14 and the guilt of their failure to save their community. Emma is quoted as saying, quote,
00:12:19 I could see him reliving those moments where he could have done something differently and saved
00:12:24 a life," end quote. Parkinson, the researcher, also quotes a 2008 study that concludes that
00:12:31 quote, men cope with stress using alcohol abuse and aggression, end quote. So the strong
00:12:38 implication, though it's fudged with the hypothetical phrasing, personal anecdote,
00:12:42 and an unrelated study, definitely still a strong implication is that the men who fought the fires
00:12:48 acted out through violence against their female partners. In other words, Sherelle Moody took
00:12:54 the heat for what Debra Parkinson's study really does say. 1.00
00:13:00 Because Debra Parkinson is a feminist ideologue.
00:13:05 Though she quotes individuals and reports about men's stress, grief, guilt and trauma,
00:13:12 she has not one empathetic word to say for the men whose lives were in some cases permanently
00:13:21 damaged by the Black Saturday fires. On the contrary, she bristles at the suggestion that
00:13:27 any circumstance could make men less culpable for any form of abuse, warning her readers that,
00:13:36 quote, it is imperative to note that there is no watering down of domestic violence after disaster,
00:13:41 either because it was a one-off event or because the perpetrator had a diagnosis of
00:13:47 post-traumatic stress disorder, end quote. Whatever the degree of severity of the so-called abuse,
00:13:55 even if it was a single instance, or even if it was nothing more than a voice raised in anger or
00:14:01 a fist punched into a wall, and more on this in a moment, whatever the circumstances, she warns
00:14:08 with punitive zeal that, quote, violence against women is an abuse of human rights, and this
00:14:15 includes in a post-disaster context where men may be suffering end quote she insists that men always
00:14:23 be held accountable this one study along with her thesis where she fleshed out her findings mainly
00:14:31 with feminist theory has become the basis for the now widely accepted link between black saturday
00:14:37 and violence against women in 2012 an australian daily newspaper called the age accepted parkinson's
00:14:45 findings without question. In 2016, Business Insider published an article called Domestic
00:14:52 Violence Increased After the Black Saturday Bushfires, again accepting the findings without
00:14:57 question. The Age newspaper even quoted without comment one of the women interviewed for Parkinson's
00:15:05 study who told of the so-called abuse she suffered after her husband came home from the inferno.
00:15:12 Listen to this description quoted in the Age newspaper of the woman's so-called victimization.
00:15:42 him, and normally he would have just hugged me right back, but I hugged a statue. Kate said her 0.60
00:15:47 husband became increasingly withdrawn and verbally and emotionally abusive. He began drinking heavily
00:15:54 and later attempted suicide before being diagnosed with post-traumatic stress, end quote. So here is
00:16:03 the domestic violence bogeyman of Deborah Parkinson's study, a man so shattered by the
00:16:10 horror of his experience that he succumbed to alcoholism before attempting suicide and being
00:16:15 diagnosed with post-traumatic stress. His abuse of his wife, an abuse Parkinson classed as a severe
00:16:23 human rights violation for which men must be held criminally accountable, does not seem to have
00:16:29 included any physical violence whatsoever. Moreover, it seems not to have occurred to
00:16:35 Parkinson or to anyone else quoting her research that the evacuation of Kate and her children while
00:16:40 her husband was deployed to battle the fires is hardly a good example of social indifference to
00:16:47 women's well-being parkinson concludes her study by rehearsing the standard feminist talking points
00:16:55 about male privilege and the need for further action to protect women quote the aftermath of
00:17:01 black saturday she says presents australians with the opportunity to see how deeply embedded male
00:17:07 privilege is and how fragile are attempts to criminalize domestic violence end quote
00:17:15 the dehumanization of the men in her research study is complete even if it were documented
00:17:22 that family violence increased after the black saturday fires which it probably did just as i'm
00:17:28 sure did many other dysfunctional and destructive behaviors it is insane to attribute such violence
00:17:35 to male privilege it is also startling to realize that this researcher's primary proposed solution
00:17:44 is the further criminalization of male domestic violence only a researcher with a heart closed
00:17:51 to compassion and a mind closed to common sense would be disappointed over australia's failure
00:18:00 to incarcerate men damaged by the horrors they experienced.
00:18:05 I truly hope that one day people will look back at our time with incredulity
00:18:12 at the hatred and lies that were accepted as academic research.