The Fiamengo File - February 04, 2020


The #MeToo Trial Of The Century - The Fiamengo File Episode 113

Science Goes To DIE at UC-Berkeley - TFF Episode 112 Feminists Slander Australian Firefighters and All Men - The Fiamengo File Episode 114

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

137.26

Word count

2,048

Sentence count

70

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
00:00:00 In nearly any discussion of the Harvey Weinstein saga, it is a requirement, it seems, to condemn
00:00:08 Weinstein as a, quote, loathsome predator, getting his just desserts, to borrow the words of the
00:00:15 usually measured Kathy Young. The standard refrain about Weinstein is that the sheer 0.89
00:00:21 number of accusations against the once revered movie producer confirms his guilt.
00:00:30 According to Laura Kipnis in a recent article in the New York Times, which argues essentially that
00:00:42 powerless women have little choice but to sleep with powerful men, Weinstein is described as the
00:00:48 quote, universally accepted villain of the Me Too movement, a designation with which Kipnis doesn't
00:00:55 quibble. Many commentators who have never met the man or his accusers are more than happy to weigh
00:01:02 in on his moral and legal guilt. Critic of feminism Christina Hoff Summers referred to
00:01:08 Weinstein in interview as a, quote, predatory monster, claiming to find the stories about him,
00:01:15 quote, well corroborated. For Fox News pundit Tucker Carlson, Weinstein is, quote, a creep and 0.94
00:01:22 a predator. Roger Simon of conservative web magazine PJ Media said that no one could 0.88
00:01:29 characterize Weinstein, quote, as anything but a pig, end quote. And perhaps one of the most 0.97
00:01:35 enthusiastic condemnations came from anti-feminist Andrea Whitberg at the conservative website
00:01:41 American Thinker, who wrote that, quote, there is no question that Weinstein is a brute, 0.99
00:01:46 a sociopathic, manipulative man who bullied women desperate for work to have sex with him, 0.99
00:01:53 end quote. Desperate for work seems, frankly, a bit desperate. I'm almost surprised Widberg 1.00
00:02:01 didn't mention that the women were also starving and clothed in rags, crying out for a bit of bread 0.90
00:02:07 to feed their children and incapable of finding any other work that would have enabled them to 0.99
00:02:12 retain their dignity. Few seem to consider that something can be widely alleged and assumed to be
00:02:19 true while still being false, or at least unproven. Given the mass condemnation of Weinstein, I hope
00:02:27 I may be forgiven for reserving my indignation for other aspects of the scandal. Weinstein may
00:02:34 not be a poster boy for the falsely accused, but a far graver issue, in my opinion, is the takeover
00:02:42 of the American legal system by me to assumptions and the way that such assumptions make it possible
00:02:48 that dubious allegations may result in a man's imprisonment for the rest of his life. This is not
00:02:56 about Weinstein, but about the future of sexual assault prosecutions. Keep in mind, of course,
00:03:02 that I make no claim to legal expertise in the discussion that follows. Despite all the discussion
00:03:11 assuming his guilt, the case against Harvey Weinstein is not very solid. And that in itself
00:03:19 tells us something about this so-called monstrous predator whom everyone thanked and gushed over and
00:03:27 to whom the women flocked for decades. Out of the 100 or so women who have publicly accused him,
00:03:35 Charges relating to only two of the accusers are at present being prosecuted,
00:03:41 though as I'll cover in a few minutes, more than two women are taking the stand to weep about their
00:03:47 abuse. Neither of the two primary complainants can be described as especially credible, given that
00:03:55 both women carried on sexual and affectionate relationships with Weinstein that extended
00:04:01 long after the alleged sexual assaults took place. For my analysis, I'm partly relying on the motion
00:04:08 to dismiss drawn up by Weinstein's former defense counsel and linked below. In the case of
00:04:15 complainant Jessica Mann, a former close friend of hers told the Weinstein defense counsel that
00:04:22 she saw Mann and Weinstein together on multiple occasions in New York City, including after the
00:04:28 alleged assault in March of 2013. According to this witness, Jessica Mann and Weinstein had a
00:04:36 long-term sexual relationship, and she never heard the witness say anything bad about Weinstein. On
00:04:42 the contrary, Mann spoke very highly of him and never told this friend or indicated in any manner
00:04:48 at the time that she had been raped. Mann did not report her alleged sexual assault to the police.
00:04:54 In the case of the only other complainant, Mimi or Miriam Halevy, the situation is not dissimilar.
00:05:01 Again, Weinstein and Halevy maintained a close, cordial relationship long after the alleged
00:05:07 sexual assault, which she claims took place in July 2006. Like the other complainant, Halevy
00:05:13 did not report the alleged sexual assault at the time, waiting 11 years to do so. Also like the
00:05:19 other complainant, Halevi continued to reach out to her friend Harvey in the years following the
00:05:25 alleged incident. Seven months after the alleged assault, she texted him, asking if he had any
00:05:31 time to see her. She also emailed him in 2008 to see it was great to see him in Cannes, concluding
00:05:37 the email, lots of love. In 2009, she wrote expressing sadness that she hadn't seen him in
00:05:42 so long, and so on. In some, then, Weinstein faces serious charges based on two women's allegations,
00:05:51 one in reference to an incident said to have occurred four years before she reported it,
00:05:56 another in reference to an incident said to have occurred 11 years before she reported it.
00:06:01 Both complainants, though now willing and eager, to see Weinstein given a lengthy sentence,
00:06:08 yet maintained a friendly relationship with him for years. Far from seeking to avoid the man they
00:06:16 claim assaulted them, degraded them, and humiliated them, they sought him out.
00:06:23 Notably, in addition to these two, four additional accusers will offer testimony about their alleged
00:06:31 sexual assaults as supporting evidence at the trial, supposedly to establish a pattern of
00:06:37 behavior by Weinstein, though there's nothing particularly distinctive about his behavior for
00:06:44 which evidence of a pattern is necessary. Weinstein is not being prosecuted for crimes
00:06:51 against these other women, and yet their evidence, having nothing to do with the crimes he is being
00:06:57 prosecuted for, will be used to bolster the case against him. Perhaps I have watched too many
00:07:04 episodes of Law and Order. But this strikes me as ludicrously prejudicial and, at the risk of
00:07:12 overstating the case, surreal. One can understand why the prosecution would pursue such a strategy.
00:07:19 It allows the rather weak claims of the two primary complainants, claims that don't rise
00:07:25 to the standard of Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, to be strengthened by the tearful and graphic claims
00:07:31 of four more women on the principle that where there is so much smoke, there must be fire.
00:07:37 Why it was accepted by the judge in the case is beyond me, because under this strategy,
00:07:41 it is quite possible that jury members who do not find the two primary accusers credible
00:07:49 will be led nevertheless to a guilty verdict because of the other testimony, even though
00:07:56 that other testimony concerns alleged crimes, the prosecution isn't even trying to prove.
00:08:03 One of the rights one would hope an accused would have in the United States is the right to be tried
00:08:10 only for the crimes one is charged with. Even if it could be proved that Weinstein did sexually
00:08:19 assault these other women, which I assume it can't be, that doesn't prove he did assault these
00:08:24 particular ones that he's facing in court, and it is nothing but an end run around justice to
00:08:30 pretend that it does. Of course, it's difficult for any man to defend himself against a sexual
00:08:37 assault claim, especially years after the fact. Weinstein's defense team has said that it has
00:08:44 in its possession emails, not only from the two primary complaining witnesses, but also from the
00:08:51 others who are accusing Weinstein and that these emails indicate that far from the fearful coerced
00:08:57 victims they now allege themselves to have been, these women actively pursued relationships with
00:09:05 Weinstein, using him for what he could offer them and even in some cases bragging about their
00:09:11 intimacy with him. That's about the only form of defense Weinstein can make and in my opinion such
00:09:18 emails, if they are as the defense says they are, definitely do raise reasonable doubt.
00:09:26 A woman who writes an affectionate email to the man who raped her does not make a very credible
00:09:33 witness. The prosecution's answer to the Weinstein defense is predictable, me-too-fudgery of the first
00:09:42 order. Just because a woman maintained a close relationship with a man doesn't mean he didn't
00:09:49 rape her, the prosecution claims. This is the theory of female rape trauma, and it has just
00:09:55 enough emotional plausibility to paper over its counterintuitiveness and total unverifiability.
00:10:04 A so-called expert forensic psychiatrist and feminist professor at Temple University 0.97
00:10:11 named Barbara Ziv, also not coincidentally a witness for the prosecution in the Bill 0.79
00:10:17 Cosby trial, has already testified that every expectation people have of how a rape victim
00:10:25 should behave is actually a rape myth. What might look like proof of consent to the unsophisticated
00:10:31 eye is actually a coping mechanism on the part of victims, a way of dealing with the experience by
00:10:38 pretending it didn't happen. Ziv is reported to have testified that, quote, sometimes women will
00:10:45 have subsequent contact with the perpetrator because they can't really believe that this
00:10:49 happened to them. They're hoping that this is just an aberration, end quote. Ziv claimed on the
00:10:56 witness stand that having evaluated thousands of sexual assault victims and perpetrators during
00:11:02 her 20 years of experience, she believes that there are, quote, over 100 behaviors victims can
00:11:10 exhibit in response to abuse, end quote. In other words, almost no behavior by an alleged victim
00:11:18 can be taken as evidence that she consented. Any behavior, whether it be pursuing the man or
00:11:26 telling friends how happy she is, anything can be explained as an attempt to normalize the alleged
00:11:32 assault or to minimize its harm. Quote, there are a whole range of behaviors, none of which tells you
00:11:39 whether a sexual assault occurred, she explained unhelpfully. One might well ask how Barbara Ziv
00:11:49 knows that the victims she spoke with were actually victims if no behavior can determine
00:11:58 whether or not a sexual assault occurred? How does she know that her theory of rape myths
00:12:04 isn't based on actual rape myths by alleged victims who lied, misremembered, told only half
00:12:12 truths or fantasized their experiences. Probably only a feminist could develop a theory in which 1.00
00:12:20 the very actions most likely to indicate that an assault did not take place are the very same 1.00
00:12:29 actions claimed to be coping methods for an assault. Ziv tells us that, quote, many sexual
00:12:36 assault victims don't immediately report the abuse and often reach out to their assailants
00:12:42 after the attack. Even more pointedly, she says, a vast majority of victims go back with their
00:12:51 attacker trying to pretend the assault never happened by pursuing a sexual affair with their
00:12:57 rapist so ziv would have us believe in other words that many alleged victims regularly lie lie to
00:13:07 themselves to their friends and family to the alleged attacker telling themselves and the world
00:13:14 that nothing happened yet we are to believe that when they come forward years sometimes decades
00:13:21 after the fact joining a mob of accusers that then and only then can we be sure they're telling
00:13:29 the whole truth. Of course we must take their word on faith since there are no behaviors that
00:13:35 can reliably indicate truth or falsehood. But if you believe that there's really no point to
00:13:43 testimony at a trial at all except to give Weinstein's accusers a public forum for whipping up
00:13:50 even more hatred than already exists against Weinstein and perhaps that is mainly what this
00:13:56 trial is about. Entirely gratuitous testimony about Weinstein's alleged physical deformities,
00:14:03 sexual impotence and personal repulsiveness seems designed for no other purpose than to shame him.
00:14:11 Perhaps he'll be made to strip down naked in the courtroom while those present roar with 0.94
00:14:16 disdainful laughter. The fact that such empty theorizing as Ziv's is now considered authoritative
00:14:24 and is quoted with respect by pretty much every news source covering the trial gives us some
00:14:30 indication of feminism's terrifying success in the realm of psychological theory. 1.00
00:14:36 If we really care about seeing a loathsome predator get his just desserts, it would make
00:14:42 sense to ensure that he is convicted in an evidently fair trial. Whichever way things
00:14:49 turn out for Weinstein, it's not a great moment for American justice.