The Fiamengo File - January 22, 2020


Science Goes To DIE at UC-Berkeley - TFF Episode 112

Feminism's Only Standards Are Double Standards - TFF Episode 111 The #MeToo Trial Of The Century - The Fiamengo File Episode 113

Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

124.9

Word count

1,972

Sentence count

67

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Most academics do not criticize the holy doctrine of diversity.
00:00:07 But a recent article in the College Fix reports that a lawyer named Daniel Ortner
00:00:11 is considering suing the University of California at Berkeley
00:00:15 for forcing job applicants to assent to what he calls the equivalent of loyalty oaths.
00:00:30 Applicants for many positions at UC Berkeley and elsewhere are required to demonstrate their allegiance to social justice,
00:00:39 the principle that wealth and opportunities should be redistributed from members of so-called oppressor groups,
00:00:46 mainly white men, to members of so-called oppressed groups, mainly women and people of color.
00:00:53 On a page titled Berkeley Diversity, the university states that, quote,
00:00:58 at a time when access and inclusion are unequal, end quote. The university is committed to, quote,
00:01:05 closing opportunity gaps for our most marginalized groups, end quote.
00:01:12 The article about the possible lawsuit is well worth reading for what it shows about the explicit
00:01:17 intention of many university departments to weed out white male applicants from job searches in
00:01:24 order to increase racial and gender diversity. This process has been going on for decades and
00:01:31 it could be argued that the diversity statement, which allows candidates to clarify how they are
00:01:36 marginalized, is merely a more subtle instrument in the now well-entrenched and richly funded
00:01:42 social justice project. But a close look at the instructions concerning diversity statements
00:01:49 shows that another equally important purpose is to purge all non-left-wing individuals from college
00:01:56 campuses. Take a look at a job advertisement for a professor position in the astronomy department
00:02:03 at UC Berkeley, and it soon becomes clear that the ad is far less focused on academic qualifications
00:02:11 than on demonstrated commitment to the principles of diversity, inclusion, and equity, or DI for short.
00:02:20 Although the word excellence does appear in the job ad,
00:02:25 it is mentioned in such a way as to be closely linked to ideological conformity.
00:02:31 We are told that, quote, diversity, equity, and inclusion are core values at UC Berkeley
00:02:37 and the Department of Astronomy.
00:02:39 Our department strives for excellence by fostering a community of faculty, students, and staff
00:02:47 who share our commitment to these values, end quote. One might ask why a commitment to these
00:02:56 values, whether they're admirable or not, would have anything to do with excellence in astronomy
00:03:03 research. No argument is made in support of that statement and no argument will be made. It's an
00:03:11 article of faith. The job ad says nothing about whether there are other core values of UC Berkeley,
00:03:18 nothing about a commitment to scientific objectivity or academic freedom or the
00:03:24 unfettered pursuit of knowledge. Instead, it assures readers that the university is
00:03:30 responsive to family needs of faculty, end quote. And it mentions that, quote, applications from
00:03:36 women and candidates in other underrepresented groups are especially encouraged, end quote.
00:03:43 It also stresses that the University of California is an equal opportunity, affirmative action
00:03:50 employer. So far, so predictable. This is nothing we haven't known about for decades. But the
00:03:58 advertisement doesn't stop there. It goes much further in various hyperlinked pages to make
00:04:04 clear how extensively the diversity mandate governs the entire hiring process. It explains
00:04:13 in a document outlining the position requirements that all candidates for the astronomy position
00:04:19 must submit a quote statement on your contributions to diversity, equity, and inclusion, including
00:04:26 information about your understanding of these topics your record of activities to date and
00:04:32 your specific plans and goals for advancing equity and inclusion if hired at berkeley end quote
00:04:42 in a linked document prospective job candidates are informed that their diversity statement will
00:04:48 be evaluated in three main areas one the candidates ability to articulate diversity concepts including
00:04:56 their command of demographic data related to diversity in higher education two their track
00:05:04 record as advocates ideally including quote multiple examples of action from undergraduate
00:05:12 through current career stage, end quote, and three, their, quote, concrete goals, plans,
00:05:20 and priorities, end quote, for advancing diversity at UC Berkeley. Candidates are told that, quote,
00:05:26 a typical strong statement is two to three pages in length and includes specific detailed examples
00:05:35 and descriptions, end quote. So this is not about pledging that you are a well-intentioned person
00:05:43 who supports equal opportunities for all, or even that you're an enthusiastic member of the
00:05:48 Democratic Party. This is about showing that you have fully embraced in word and deed the arcane
00:05:56 and often extremely subjective, non-scientific, and even demonstrably false and bigoted theories
00:06:03 of intersectional feminism. Candidates are told explicitly that they should be able to outline
00:06:10 such matters as, quote, new pedagogies and classroom strategies to advance equity and
00:06:18 inclusion, end quote. If that sounds as if perhaps instructors are being encouraged to treat women
00:06:25 and people of color in their classrooms differently, i.e. with greater encouragement
00:06:31 and support than for white men, well, you're not far off base. Candidates are explicitly told
00:06:38 that they will be expected to provide strategies for, quote, mentoring and supporting the advancement
00:06:45 and professional development of underrepresented students or postdocs, end quote. In other words,
00:06:54 to put it crudely, find an African-American woman or the equivalent and promote her like 1.00
00:07:00 crazy. Even candidates' research subjects should preferably have a social justice angle. 1.00
00:07:08 Candidates are encouraged to highlight, quote, research focused on underserved communities,
00:07:14 end quote. A further linked document from the Berkeley Office for Faculty Equity and Welfare
00:07:23 provides copious detail about how a hiring committee should rate applicants for positions
00:07:30 at Berkeley by making the diversity statement their primary evaluative standard. This document
00:07:40 lectures the old fogies in the department that although they may have been hired at a time when
00:07:46 all that mattered was whether or not you knew your science, those days are gone.
00:07:51 While faculty who were hired years ago may not have been evaluated in this way, the document explains, Berkeley is now exclusively interested in hiring excellent contributors to advancing equity and inclusion for all.
00:08:08 end quote. And if you're not sure how a zeal for combating male privilege or promoting female ways
00:08:15 of knowing can aid in understanding the origins of the universe or the lifespan of a quasar, 0.62
00:08:22 that's your problem. This document advises hiring committee members to be unwavering in monitoring
00:08:30 ideological compliance in all prospective candidates, no matter how brilliant the
00:08:36 candidate no matter how extensive their record of scientific achievements no one should be considered
00:08:43 for the job according to this document if they are not politically on board members are explicitly
00:08:50 advised to quote consider creating a cutoff score for the diversity statement quote below which
00:08:59 a candidate would not move forward in the search process berkeley even provides specific examples
00:09:09 of how diversity statements should be scored from one meaning least impressive to five most
00:09:17 impressive and i strongly encourage interested listeners to view this astounding document and
00:09:23 all the hyperlinked pages in their entirety. It is made crystal clear in this document that simply
00:09:30 writing in your application that you treat all people equally, or believe all people have the
00:09:35 capacity to make important contributions to science, that will lead to your rejection from
00:09:41 the application process as insufficiently informed and engaged. To reach the acceptable four to five
00:09:51 high score according to this marxist manual of mind control you will need to quote demonstrate
00:09:57 sophisticated thinking about the under representation of groups in academia and
00:10:01 structural barriers to success eg racism sexism homophobia etc you will also need a robust record
00:10:11 of social justice activism ideally extending back to your undergraduate days and of course you also
00:10:18 need a detailed plan for what you're going to do at Berkeley if hired. The hiring document mentions
00:10:25 that, quote, for example, a new assistant professor may plan to undertake one major activity within
00:10:33 the department, conduct outreach to hire a diverse group of students to work in their lab, seek to
00:10:40 mentor several underrepresented students and co-chair a subcommittee or lead a workshop for
00:10:46 a national conference, end quote. One might well wonder how this new hire will be able to contribute
00:10:54 at all to astronomy research at Berkeley, given how busy that person will be organizing anti-racism
00:11:03 workshops and recruiting diverse students for their lab and for collaborative work with other
00:11:08 academics. A friend of mine has informed me that two tiers are being created in astronomy
00:11:14 departments, one for the regular academics, mostly men who pursue astronomy research,
00:11:19 and the other for the social justice warriors who spend their time conducting surveys and
00:11:25 giving talks about diversity. It's also hard reading this document not to notice that the
00:11:31 new hire will be pressured, if not in fact required, to see students and collaborators
00:11:39 not primarily as individuals, whether appropriately talented or not, but as faceless members of
00:11:46 designated groups. Valuable not for their potential as scientists, but for adding a much-needed black 0.78
00:11:53 or brown or female or gender non-conforming face to the lab. Will that improve research excellence
00:12:00 at Berkeley? Will it lay the groundwork for cutting-edge work? I'll leave that to you to
00:12:05 decide. One might ask whether there is any evidence at all for the much-touted connection
00:12:12 between excellence and ethnic and gender diversity. As an astrophysicist friend of mine has noted,
00:12:20 China and Japan are doing pretty well in STEM without any diversity. The moon landing was not 0.95
00:12:26 the product of diversity, and neither were discoveries in electromagnetism, thermodynamics,
00:12:31 quantum physics, or general relativity. One study entitled Ethnic Diversity Increases
00:12:40 Scientific Impact, published in June of 2018, did find that a more ethnically diverse set of
00:12:48 authors had overall about a 10% higher chance of producing a highly cited paper than a team that
00:12:55 was more homogeneous. But it's far from clear that the fact of ethnic diversity was itself
00:13:02 the necessary and sufficient condition for the more cited research. There might well have been
00:13:07 other factors, perhaps that the more ethnically diverse teams had members with larger scientific
00:13:12 networks, which led to the higher number of citations. What we do know is that in the absence
00:13:19 of any scientifically sound evidence of the benefits of racial and gender diversity,
00:13:26 enormous public money and energy are being poured into the social justice vision for the university,
00:13:34 not just at Berkeley or in California as a whole, but all across the Western world as
00:13:41 universities abandon their commitment to individual ability in favor of political correctness.
00:13:47 In 2018, Vanderbilt University's Centre for Teaching website affirmed that, quote, increasingly institutions of higher education are becoming more intentional and programmatic about their efforts to embrace principles of inclusion, equity, justice and diversity throughout campus life, end quote.
00:14:08 And in 2019, the Chronicle of Higher Education repeated that, quote, more colleges are asking scholars for diversity statements, end quote.
00:14:19 A 2019 article by influential astronomer and professor at the Australian National University, Lisa Cooley, in the journal Nature Astronomy, is titled Diversity and Inclusion in Australian Astronomy.
00:14:36 Predictably, the article celebrates the plethora of diversity initiatives, policies, surveys,
00:14:43 reports, and action plans, including many female-only astronomy job positions,
00:14:49 and calls for much more to be done for women and minorities. 1.00
00:14:55 Thirty years ago, senior astronomy professors would have been expected to write articles for 1.00
00:15:00 nature about scientific discoveries. Now, they devote themselves to the new religion and force
00:15:08 others to do the same. How long all of this can continue is far from clear, but the fact is that 0.95
00:15:14 diversity is not a whim of one wacky California college. It is the wave of the future, lavishly
00:15:22 funded, seemingly unstoppable, largely immune to criticism, and determined to sweep away
00:15:27 everything in its path, including the research preeminence and even research soundness of the
00:15:34 scientific institutions of the West. They're popping the corks on the champagne bottles in
00:15:40 South Korea, China, Japan, and India. Perhaps only the lawyers can save us now.