00:06:53Discrimination against men at the same time that feminists have been complaining nonstop that more needs to be done to hire women into all academic fields.
00:07:03And what Strumia found about initial hirings held for male and female scientists being hired out of
00:07:11one job into another at later points in their careers also. On page 14, he showed that female
00:07:18scientists are at whatever stage hired with fewer citations than male scientists. In addition,
00:07:25bias against men extends to the awarding of fellowships also. On page 15 of his presentation,
00:07:32strumia showed that the average number of citations for young male physicists awarded
00:07:39prestigious cern fellowships is about twice the number of citations for female cern fellows so
00:07:47in other words cern fellowships are being awarded regularly to lesser qualified female physicists0.75
00:07:54because they're female. On page 16, Strumia showed that male physicists are more productive,1.00
00:08:03again by a factor of two, than female physicists throughout the whole course of their careers.
00:08:11Why do men outperform women in physics overall? Strumia hypothesizes that the intellectually0.99
00:08:18honest answer is that more men than women have the desire and skills to do very high-level physics.
00:08:27And this is most likely because there are more men clustered at the very highest levels of
00:08:33intelligence, according to the standard deviation models, which is not to say that there aren't
00:08:39women who are brilliant at physics, just not as many as men, because men's IQ distribution is
00:08:46broader and that's what accounts for the fact that there are more men in physics there is no plot
00:08:53against women in fact right now there is a plot so to speak against men so if we care about what
00:09:01is best for physics we should stop pretending at least this is the implication i think of strumia's
00:09:10research. We should stop pretending that heroic measures are needed to guarantee
00:09:15female participation." Well, reaction to Strumia's presentation was swift and harsh. The video of his
00:09:24talk was immediately removed from the CERN website, so we can't watch it to see if it really was,
00:09:30as CERN officials claimed, quote, highly offensive. According to CERN authorities,
00:09:36Strumia stepped over the line of acceptable conduct by naming a person present at the
00:09:43conference, saying that in a competition for a theoretical physics position at the National
00:09:48Institute of Nuclear Physics in Padua, a woman with far fewer citations than he was given the
00:09:55position. In fact, as he showed in his presentation, he had 10 times the number of citations she had.
00:10:03This was interpreted by CERN authorities as an attack, which they stated was, quote,
00:10:10contrary to the CERN code of conduct, end quote.
00:10:15Strumia was immediately suspended from CERN pending an investigation, and his home university,
00:10:21the University of Pisa, has opened an ethics investigation into his conduct.
00:10:27Now, one can disagree about whether Professor Strumia stepped over the line in mentioning
00:10:33this personal factor. Perhaps it was unwise. It definitely gave ammunition to his enemies.
00:10:41In an email he sent to me, Strumia said that he mentioned it in a joking manner. Certainly,
00:10:47in my opinion, his suspension from CERN was excessively punitive, given that much of his
00:10:55talk was pure numbers-based analysis and that the so-called attack appears to have been a simple
00:11:03statement of fact. But the CERN suspension, it wasn't enough for some members of the academic
00:11:11physics community. A public letter condemning Strumia in the strongest of terms, co-authored
00:11:19by 18 mostly US-based physicists, was posted on a website calling itself Particles for
00:11:27Justice, and to date the letter has received thousands of scientists' signatures, and it's
00:11:35I've read a lot of public statements by far-left intellectuals over the last few years, but
00:11:41I think this one might be the most unhinged I've ever seen.
00:11:46It begins with a histrionic assertion that, quote, the humanity of any person, regardless of ascribed identities, is, quote, not up for debate.
00:12:00The clear implication is that Strumia himself, merely by objecting to feminist policy, was actually in some way calling into question the humanity of women or any other people, which he wasn't.
00:12:13I think everyone who signed this letter should be ashamed of such dishonesty.
00:12:19The co-authors of the letter also lament that Strumia used his physics credentials to pretend
00:12:25he had something to contribute to a discussion of gender bias, which isn't his area of expertise.
00:12:31Though, of course, if he had made a plea for more aggressive measures to promote women in physics,
00:12:37they would never have complained that he lacked the credentials to do so.
00:12:41They continued that, quote, those among us who are familiar with the relevant literature know that Strumia's conclusions are in stark disagreement with those of experts, end quote.
00:12:55this is a classic academic feminist mo create a discipline that is based not on scientific
00:13:05methodology but on untestable claims about privilege lived experience intersectionality1.00
00:13:13and unconscious bias then staff the discipline with ideologues who found journals and cite one
00:13:21another in their articles, and then claim that a real scientist has no standing to use quantitative
00:13:29methods to challenge the findings of your fake discipline. Well, in order to show us what only
00:13:37gender experts can see, the letter writers enumerate a series of rebuttals to Strumia's
00:13:45points. Their first and most general criticism is that Strumia, quote, frequently made the basic
00:13:52error of conflating correlation with causation, end quote. Well, this might be a meaningful
00:14:00criticism, but they fail to give a single instance in which it is the case. Where does he do it?
00:14:08Strumia's basic argument is that when feminists claim that something must be done about physics'1.00
00:14:13so-called woman problem, and when it can be shown that less qualified women are being hired in place1.00
00:14:18of more qualified men, then feminist policies are causing discrimination against men in physics.
00:14:25I just don't see where the logical error is. On the other hand, one could certainly argue that
00:14:31the authors of the letter continually confuse correlation with causation. They find that fewer
00:14:38women work in high-level physics, and that fewer women win Nobel Prizes in physics, and they
00:14:46conclude that, therefore, women are discriminated against in physics due to sexism. This is a clear
00:14:53case of correlation, not necessarily involving causation. So, physicists heal thyself.
00:15:02The letter writers also include a personal attack on Strumia's research record in order to suggest
00:15:08that he is a mediocrity, bitter about beating out for a job by a female competitor. For example,
00:15:15they poo-poo his involvement in one experimental paper with thousands of authors claiming that
00:15:22this one paper accounted for almost one-third of his total citations and that his contribution to
00:15:29the paper was likely modest. Well, I call sour grapes. Strumia was included in this very
00:15:37prestigious paper because he worked on the theory of the Higgs boson, a revolutionary concept in
00:15:44understanding how particles acquire mass. It was hardly insignificant. But even if you take away
00:15:52those thousands of citations from that one paper he still has many many more than his competitor
00:16:00and in fact the vast majority of his papers have few authors and are highly cited his h index of
00:16:0982 is knocked down impressive far better than his competitors 28 and yes of course it's true that
00:16:17quality cannot be measured solely by numbers. Strumia himself never claimed it could be,
00:16:23but there is no doubt that in terms of influence as a scientist, Strumia is the superior candidate,
00:16:31and it is astounding that the letter writers try to pretend he isn't. When it comes to specific
00:16:39rebuttals of Strumia's points, the wobbly logic of the letter writers is even more obvious.
00:16:46Responding to Strumia's demonstration that both men and women cite more
00:16:51male-authored papers than female-first-authored papers, the letter writers say that, quote,
00:16:57choice of references is subject to unconscious bias in addition to conscious discrimination.
00:17:04Such unconscious bias is often found at similar levels in both men and women, end quote.
00:17:11So, in other words, when women cite more male-first authored papers than female-first authored
00:17:19papers, bias is still in operation because women can be just as biased as men.