The Fiamengo File - June 15, 2017


Shaming Men About Housework - TFF Episode 67

Preview: Shaming Men About Housework - TFF Episode 67 Teaching Students To Snitch - TFF Episode 68

Episode Stats


Length

8 minutes

Words per minute

141.52

Word count

1,221

Sentence count

38

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Should men be shamed for not doing housework?
00:00:05 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:16 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:20 In the vast enterprise of man-blaming,
00:00:24 my example today is not the most outrageous,
00:00:27 but it's still blatantly unfair and shockingly dishonest.
00:00:33 A new study just released by the Australian Institute of Family Studies
00:00:37 has found that in two-parent households with a stay-at-home dad,
00:00:41 the working mom still does a lot of the housework.
00:00:45 And this news has been trumpeted in newspapers with the usual message 1.00
00:00:51 that women have a raw deal. 1.00
00:00:54 The headline at the Mail Online said, 1.00
00:00:57 Stay-at-home dads are leaving nearly half the household chores to their working wives.
00:01:03 And a subtitle informs us that dads spent only slightly more time on housework than their working partners.
00:01:11 Tsk, tsk.
00:01:12 And other papers scolded stay-at-home dads not pulling their weight around the house.
00:01:18 According to the study, dads spent 28 hours on housework per week on average compared to their
00:01:25 working wives who spent 23 hours on housework. What an image, eh? The slothful dad lazing around
00:01:33 at home while his poor, harried wife spends all day at the office and still must do a lot of the
00:01:39 cleaning up and childcare. But there's a lot more to the story than the papers are telling us about,
00:01:45 So let me touch on a few points. As a minor side note, let me say that like so many of these so-called
00:01:52 scientific studies, the data leaves much to speculate about. It's not entirely clear how
00:01:56 the data was gathered. For example, I'm assuming it was through self-reporting and is therefore
00:02:02 subject to the usual issues of bias and misrepresentation that are always a factor in such
00:02:07 cases. Women have been told by feminists for over 40 years that they're oppressed when it comes to 1.00
00:02:14 housework, so it's quite possible that they might overestimate the hours they put in.
00:02:19 And perhaps men, generally just not as interested, might underestimate their hours. Or perhaps men
00:02:25 are simply more efficient in their use of time or less particular about some tasks, thus needing
00:02:31 fewer hours to do the same kinds of jobs. Hard to know, but putting that aside, even accepting
00:02:38 that the numbers are perfectly accurate and that they show us a picture of men doing less housework
00:02:44 in situations in which their female partners are working full-time, they're staying at home.
00:02:48 Well, one thing we have to keep in mind is that this scenario accounts for only 4% of all families
00:02:55 in the country that was surveyed. It's hardly representative of the majority or even a significant
00:03:00 minority of family arrangements. And what is really astounding is what the reports of the
00:03:08 study leave out. This is data that could have been used to draw some very different conclusions about
00:03:15 male and female workloads. If we look at the stats for two-parent households in which both father and
00:03:23 mother are working, and this is an arrangement that accounts for 65% of families in Australia,
00:03:29 so it's obviously a lot more representative. If we look at those stats, we notice something that
00:03:35 the mad at dad reports didn't even mention a vast disparity in the hours worked outside of the home
00:03:45 by male and female partners. In these cases, the father averaged 50 hours per week of paid work,
00:03:55 while the mother is putting in a much more humane and far less taxing 31 hours per week on average.
00:04:02 In other words, the father is contributing 62.5% of the couple's total paid work time while his
00:04:09 partner contributes only 37.5% of that total. So is this a case of the patriarchy preventing the
00:04:17 woman from working long hours or is it a choice that she has made to find a type of work that
00:04:23 allows her a relatively comfortable life and the ability to parent her children without excess
00:04:28 stress is one partner being lazy one partner being taken advantage of it's hard to say
00:04:35 but certainly nowhere in the reports do we hear the complaint that in households where
00:04:42 the paid work is shared women are leaving it to men to do the lion's share
00:04:49 so we might expect to find in these scenarios where both man and woman are working that the
00:04:55 woman's lighter input into work outside the home is made up by all the housework that she does right
00:05:03 but no while the woman in this scenario is working 19 hours on average less per week than
00:05:11 her male partner she's not working 19 hours more at housework the man in this case is putting in
00:05:19 about 15 hours per week on housework and she's putting in 26 meaning that in total paid and
00:05:26 unpaid he's doing 65 hours of work per week and she's doing 57. remember this is the scenario for
00:05:33 65 percent of two-parent households now the guy doesn't look like such a slouch of course nothing
00:05:41 is said in these reports about the kinds of work the sexes are doing whether the man's 51 hours
00:05:48 might be of a very tiring sort working in construction say or with heavy machinery or
00:05:53 appliance repair or running his own business or any of the many other types of work that men
00:05:57 regularly do that leave a man exhausted by dave's day's end while the average woman is working in
00:06:04 an office or teaching or doing something less physically demanding i'm not saying that's true
00:06:10 in all cases but i'm saying it's a crucial factor in understanding men's and women's work
00:06:16 At home, there may similarly be a division of labor that favors the woman who works indoors,
00:06:23 doing relatively light tasks such as cooking and dusting while her husband shovels the snow,
00:06:29 repairs the roof, and builds the garage. As we all know, an hour and a half of shoveling snow
00:06:35 is hardly equivalent to an hour and a half of folding laundry. But imagine the outcry.
00:06:41 if this were the slant that all the major papers took, that women are consistently leaving it to 0.98
00:06:48 their male partners to do the unpleasant and heavy physical work at home. And yet tell me
00:06:54 if that isn't the case. Actually, what the tables show most clearly is that whether men are the
00:07:03 sole breadwinners or whether they are in a situation where both partners are working,
00:07:08 men tend to work a lot more outside the home than their female partners, and that even in cases where
00:07:15 the man is at home, women just don't put in those long hours. In the scenario in which the woman is 0.99
00:07:22 sole breadwinner, she works an average of only 35 hours per week. Instead of shaming and castigating 1.00
00:07:31 men for their presumed sins of omission when it comes to housework shouldn't we recognize and
00:07:38 maybe even heaven forbid praise men for working so hard men's labor powers our economies keeping
00:07:47 our societies inventive and competitive prosperous and practically efficient in 96 percent of two
00:07:56 parent households men do the majority of work outside the home and men consistently do the
00:08:03 type of work that women don't or won't do headline new study shows that men continue to do most of
00:08:12 the world's work and we all benefit from it it's not a headline i'm expecting anytime soon
00:08:20 own.