The Fiamengo File - June 22, 2017


Teaching Students To Snitch - TFF Episode 68

Shaming Men About Housework - TFF Episode 67 Toxic Masculinity and Suicide - TFF Episode 69

Episode Stats


Length

8 minutes

Words per minute

129.18

Word count

1,095

Sentence count

24

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Should students be encouraged to snitch on one another?
00:00:05 That's my subject on today's Fiumengo File.
00:00:18 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa. It seems that the University of Arizona
00:00:23 wasn't prepared for the negative publicity it received in response to its decision to hire
00:00:29 students to act as campus social justice warriors. Correct that, social justice advocates.
00:00:37 These SJAs will be paid $10 per hour for 15 hours per week for a job that includes
00:00:44 organizing diversity events and also reporting fellow students for so-called bias incidents.
00:00:53 This idea that students would be paid to act as a kind of politically correct
00:00:56 Gestapo brought the University of Arizona some rather unflattering attention. And now the
00:01:02 university is responding, claiming that the subject was blown out of proportion and saying
00:01:07 that the university is going to reconceive the title and some of the responsibilities for the
00:01:12 student jobs. And I actually suspect that reporting of bias will be taken out of the job description.
00:01:19 so maybe that's okay except that it isn't because the university of arizona still encourages students
00:01:27 to snitch on one another it just doesn't pay them for it yes the university of arizona has a bias
00:01:34 incident reporting page where students can not only report an incident if they think they've
00:01:39 been the victim of some form of harassment but they're actually encouraged to report incidents
00:01:44 even if they had nothing to do with them. The webpage says that because we are a community,
00:01:52 each of us has a responsibility for fostering a safe and inclusive environment, and we must take
00:01:57 an active role in reporting incidents. So that's pretty strong language, must take an active role.
00:02:05 And it prompts the question, why? If adults on campus are being seriously harassed or bullied,
00:02:13 shouldn't they take responsibility for reporting it why should anyone else get
00:02:18 involved and what kinds of incidents are we talking about the same web page
00:02:24 informs us that a bias incident that language a bias incident involves the
00:02:30 expression of any quote preformed what would a non preformed opinion be sorry
00:02:37 preformed negative opinion or attitude toward a group of persons based on their
00:02:42 race gender religion disability sexual orientation ethnicity national origin or gender identity
00:02:49 end quote so we're not talking about explicit threats or calls for genocide or gutter racism
00:02:57 we're talking about virtually any negative statement preformed about one or more of the
00:03:03 identified groups the definition couldn't get any more elastic moreover it's not even necessary to
00:03:10 have direct evidence of the so-called bias incident even if someone simply quote becomes
00:03:16 aware of an act of bias that person could and according to the web page should report it
00:03:23 and to make it easier to report incidents even when the details are a little hazy because you
00:03:28 just heard about them from someone else you can make your report anonymously now where else has
00:03:35 it been possible to report someone anonymously for making the wrong kinds of statements well one
00:03:41 place was east germany under communism during the communist period there was a vast unofficial
00:03:48 network of ordinary citizens who regularly informed on one another to the police and to
00:03:54 government authorities neighbors reported on neighbors school kids reported on other kids and
00:04:01 yeah university students reported on their classmates they weren't paid for it but they
00:04:08 still did it and why well for all the motives in the book the usual ones because they were loyal
00:04:16 communists or they did it out of jealousy or revenge or dislike or the hope of preferential
00:04:22 treatment these are all the usual reasons that some mean-spirited or unstable people
00:04:28 want to make others suffer take a look at the u of arizona's online public incident reporting page
00:04:35 and imagine the abundant opportunities for unscrupulous people to wreak havoc you don't
00:04:43 like somebody on campus maybe he's a trump supporter or he's one of those hateful conservative
00:04:49 christians whose mere presence is probably a threat to everybody or she's a men's rights 0.97
00:04:54 activists who mocked your feminist t-shirt, so why not make their life a living hell through 0.97
00:05:00 frequent anonymous reports to the Dean of Students, who is obligated to have every incident 1.00
00:05:06 investigated? I've heard from many students who've been hauled before committees because of anonymous
00:05:12 reports by their fellow students, and obviously not just at the University of Arizona, because the
00:05:19 fact is that this kind of snitching is not only being encouraged there. Bias reporting is also
00:05:25 being encouraged at Harvard University, at Yale, at Duke University, at Princeton, Michigan State,
00:05:34 Emory, the Universities of California, Columbia, Penn State, Cornell, Dartmouth, Brown, Northwestern,
00:05:41 North Carolina, Oregon State, Wellesley, Mount Holyoke, Richmond, Utah, even the University of
00:05:46 Hawaii. It's everywhere. It's fascinating in a ghoulish kind of way to read through the websites
00:05:54 at the various colleges, encouraging students to denounce one another, all in the name of
00:06:00 tolerance and respect. We want to make this an inclusive community for all, they keep saying,
00:06:07 for all that is, except those who are unfortunate enough to be snitched on. The University of
00:06:13 California webpage gushes that, quote, we strive for a campus in a world free of discrimination,
00:06:21 intolerance, and hate. We are equally committed to freedom of expression, critical inquiry,
00:06:27 civil dialogue, and mutual respect, end quote. Come on. How can there be freedom of expression
00:06:35 and critical inquiry when merely stating a negative opinion about a group can bring a visit
00:06:41 from the bias committee this is either pure hypocrisy or pure delusion web pages like the
00:06:51 university of california's go out of their way to affirm that anyone can file a report with no
00:06:56 negative repercussions they say for example the university takes these issues seriously and
00:07:03 expects that they're reported in good faith at no time will action be taken against anyone for good
00:07:11 faith reporting in other words even if you've just got a hunch or a bad feeling about somebody
00:07:20 fire up your computer and make a report don't be shy we won't blame you if it turns out you've
00:07:26 got the wrong person or your information wasn't quite accurate it's all in a good cause
00:07:32 anyone who doesn't see a problem with anonymous reports of so-called bias must either have an
00:07:41 extraordinarily limited imagination or a very rosy view of human nature one thing's for sure
00:07:49 this isn't about diversity or respect and it sure as hell isn't about civil dialogue it's about
00:07:56 scaring and harassing dissenters into submission, and it's changing universities beyond recognition.
00:08:26 You