The Fiamengo File - October 10, 2018


So What If Kavanaugh Was At The Party - TFF Episode 90

To Understand Christine Blasey Ford, Take a look at Palo Alto University Avital Ronell - TFF Episode 91

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

125.9

Word count

1,289

Sentence count

47

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Most commentators skeptical of Christine Blasey Ford's testimony against Brett Kavanaugh have
00:00:07 focused on the plentiful gaps, inconsistencies, and total lack of corroboration in her story.
00:00:16 But relatively few have said that even if evidence could be found that something happened between
00:00:22 Kavanaugh and Ford, he should still have been confirmed as a Supreme Court Justice.
00:00:28 And that's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:41 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:44 We are undoubtedly in a believed survivors moment, and even self-proclaimed conservatives,
00:00:52 civil libertarians non-feminists and scientific rationalists have been deeply corrupted by it
00:01:00 regardless of the fact that the presumption of innocence squeaked a win out of the confirmation
00:01:06 hearings overall the trend now is towards punishing more and more men in situations
00:01:13 where it can never be known what really happened what if ford's friend leland had come forward and
00:01:22 said yes i remember that night there was a little party what if she'd said i remember cavanaugh
00:01:29 being there and i remember my friend coming downstairs frantic to get out of that house
00:01:36 she walked out of that house and she walked all the way home and the next day she was a changed
00:01:42 person. And she said to me, something awful happened. He attacked me on the bed and I thought
00:01:48 he was going to kill me. I think it's a safe bet that if this had been the way the story played
00:01:54 out, Kavanaugh's nomination would have been dead in the water. The angry cries of the feminist left
00:02:01 would have seemed incontrovertible. Republicans like Senator Flake and many others would certainly 0.96
00:02:09 have voted against kavanaugh even though the corroboration of the story would still not have
00:02:14 been sufficient to determine guilt beyond a reasonable doubt and that's my point when it
00:02:22 comes to accusations of sexual assault against men we've completely abandoned reasonable doubt
00:02:30 we're at a point where any allegation even one as empty as blasey ford's is taken seriously by
00:02:39 a majority of the population and in which a significant minority is willing to throw out
00:02:44 all safeguards for accused men as radical feminists keep on pushing the idea that women 0.91
00:02:53 should be believed even in the absence of any evidence well it starts to seem reasonable
00:03:01 to believe women if there is just a little evidence and how morally demanding we are when
00:03:08 when the subject is a man's potential violation of womanhood.
00:03:14 Kavanaugh and Ford grew up at a time
00:03:16 when alcohol consumption and wild partying were the norm.
00:03:21 Even the good students from good families drank
00:03:24 to get drunk and engaged in irresponsible sexual behavior,
00:03:28 and the only people who objected at the time,
00:03:31 the religious right, were mocked and derided
00:03:34 by the very same type of people
00:03:36 who profess to be so concerned now.
00:03:40 The former apostles of sexual liberation
00:03:43 are now adamant that we have to inquire
00:03:45 into the murky depths of a man's past attitudes
00:03:49 and expressions and lapses in decorum
00:03:52 as if those tell us anything useful
00:03:55 about his ability now to serve on the Supreme Court
00:03:59 or anywhere else important.
00:04:01 Of course, the upholders of righteousness 0.99
00:04:04 don't believe we should ever delve into a woman's lapses from perfect decorum and chastity when 0.91
00:04:11 she was a teenager. No, no, no. We're only interested in whether the man lapsed or might
00:04:17 have. Now, let's imagine that Kavanaugh was at the party Ford described, and let's explore what
00:04:27 might well have occurred between the two of them, something almost, but not quite as Ford
00:04:34 described it. Now here I'm engaging in extensive hypotheticals, of course, but I hope you'll see
00:04:40 where I'm going with it. I'm not saying that I think this is what actually happened, since
00:04:46 obviously I haven't a clue what, if anything, actually happened. But here goes. Let's say that
00:04:55 15-year-old Ford was a little more drunk at that party than she says she was. Let's say she had 0.98
00:05:01 two beers on an empty stomach and I can understand why she would suppress and misremember how many
00:05:07 beers she had 36 years later. Let's imagine that she flirted a little bit with the 17-year-old 1.00
00:05:14 Kavanaugh before the alleged incident. Let's imagine that she went upstairs with him and his
00:05:20 friend to fool around a bit. Not ever explicitly stated, but you know, they all knew what was going
00:05:26 on roughly. All three would have been laughing. All three were high on youth and music and hormones
00:05:35 and alcohol and maybe even a little marijuana. Then things got somewhat out of control.
00:05:42 Kavanaugh started kissing Ford on the bed thinking that's what she wanted because she'd
00:05:48 been leading him on just before that. Maybe she even responded for a minute or two, kissing him 0.97
00:05:55 back, thinking it was what she wanted, but he was too insistent, too drunk, and she got scared.
00:06:03 She started squirming and objecting, raising her voice in agitation. Maybe he tried to shush her
00:06:11 by touching her mouth, not intending to threaten her and certainly not intending to suffocate her,
00:06:17 but just wanting her to be quiet. His friend jumped on the bed to disrupt the weirdness that
00:06:24 had developed and Ford left the room very frightened. It all happened in just a couple
00:06:30 of minutes, maybe even seconds, though it felt longer to Ford. Neither Kavanaugh nor his friend
00:06:38 thought anything more of it because it was nothing. They went downstairs laughing without
00:06:44 making any attempt to bother the girl further. Kavanaugh never intended to rape her. He wanted
00:06:50 to make out with her and he thought that's what she wanted too. Kavanaugh now doesn't remember
00:06:56 the incident and Ford magnified it into something it wasn't, leaving out her own participation in
00:07:03 what was a common sexual misunderstanding between teenagers. This kind of misunderstanding probably
00:07:11 happens many thousands of times every year at teen drinking gatherings, and I'm not saying
00:07:19 it did happen like this between Kavanaugh and Ford, I'm saying it could have, and that
00:07:24 deciding between my hypothetical version and Ford's version is impossible.
00:07:32 Yes, I realize there is a big difference between clumsy sexual interactions and sexual assault,
00:07:38 but when alcohol hormones youthful perception memory and ideology are all involved especially
00:07:48 after decades have passed it is truly impossible to determine the reality beyond a reasonable doubt
00:07:56 and it is appalling that men should be facing prison or having their careers and reputations 0.98
00:08:04 ruined because a woman magnifies the extent of the discomfort she experienced and i know that
00:08:11 this is happening now and that women are being encouraged to exaggerate their stories of assault
00:08:19 and it looks to me as if it's going to happen even more in the near future and a lot of righteous
00:08:26 people are complicit in it some of my friends believe that we're seeing the last gasps of the
00:08:35 me too movement and that the extreme emotionalism and irrationalism are actually good because
00:08:42 they'll make reasonable people reject me too i hope they're right but i fear they're wrong
00:08:50 wrong. I think something else is happening. I think that no matter how many times feminist
00:08:59 statistics about rape and feminist claims about rape culture, no matter how many times
00:09:06 those are debunked, the feminist message is seeping into our bones that men are bad and
00:09:14 need to be punished, and that women never lie about or even misremember such things.
00:09:22 By sheer persistence and reiteration, the untruths are being accepted, and the burden
00:09:29 of proof is shifting to the accused.
00:09:34 It's a scary time.
00:09:36 Maybe it's already too late to reverse course, but it's definitely time to fight hard for
00:09:42 the rights of accused men, because if we don't hold on to that, we lose everything.
00:10:12 You