The Fiamengo File - June 14, 2018


The End of Judicial Impartiality: Feminists Come for Judges - TFF 83

This Is Feminist Policing - TFF episode 82 Why Can't We Hate Men - TFF episode 84

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

123.37

Word count

1,472

Sentence count

45

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
00:00:00 It was said to be a test of the political power of the Me Too movement, the campaign to recall
00:00:06 Judge Aaron Persky for his supposedly lenient sentence in the Brock Turner Stanford University
00:00:12 sexual assault trial. Now, Persky has been removed from the bench and replaced by a woman,
00:00:18 and it's my subject on today's Fiumengo File.
00:00:30 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:34 A writer for the Independent newspaper called the June 5th Recall Vote for Santa Clara County
00:00:40 Judge Erin Persky, quote, an enormous victory for women's rights, end quote.
00:00:47 And she said she hoped that as a result, more judges will, quote, follow their hearts and
00:00:52 use the power of the bench to help create a society in which we can all feel safe, end quote.
00:00:59 All that is except any man accused of sexual assault. It doesn't seem to occur to the writer
00:01:05 of the article that the first and only duty of a judge is to uphold the rule of law,
00:01:11 not to attempt to implement a political vision. But in the world many feminists are bringing about, 1.00
00:01:19 every judge who sentences a man in a sexual assault case will have to look over his shoulder.
00:01:25 The recall of Judge Persky is apparently the first of its kind in over 80 years,
00:01:32 though it's perhaps not the last. It was led by a feminist sociologist and professor of law
00:01:39 at Stanford University named Michelle Dauber, who is reputedly a close family friend of the 0.92
00:01:46 complainant and someone who, protected by academic tenure and presumably a strong supporter of it,
00:01:52 never has to worry about the popularity or lack thereof of her ideas and actions her website boasts
00:02:00 of her active involvement in bringing college and university policies into compliance with title
00:02:06 9 the crazed federal law now under review that has created so much misery and unfairness for
00:02:16 college males in cases of sexual assault allegations her well-organized campaign
00:02:23 to take down judge persky amassed over a million dollars in financial backing
00:02:30 and resulted in a vote with close to 60 percent in favor of the recall all in a society that
00:02:38 supposedly condones sexual violence against women for his failure to implement feminist
00:02:47 sentencing principles persky's career is effectively over he's not only lost the
00:02:54 position as judge that he filled without scandal for 15 years but he has had his pension taken away
00:03:02 and his chances of future employment severely diminished he'll be remembered probably for the
00:03:09 rest of his life as the biased patriarch who cared more about a privileged white swimming champion
00:03:17 than the poor vulnerable girl who was assaulted it's a good bet that very few who contributed
00:03:25 money and voted for the recall have actually waded through the court case documents in the
00:03:32 brock turner sexual assault trial which tell a very different story from what is regularly reported
00:03:39 about the early morning hours of january 18th 2015 when brock turner and the passed out woman
00:03:47 were discovered at about 1 a.m outside a stanford university fraternity house
00:03:54 though most commentators state as fact that turner quote sexually assaulted an unconscious woman end
00:04:02 quote this is actually an interpretation only the accuser herself claims not to remember anything
00:04:12 about this event and the two so-called witnesses actually saw very little ultimately it is simply
00:04:20 not possible to say with reasonable certainty whether turner took advantage of an obviously
00:04:26 incapacitated woman in order to assault her which i admit is possible or whether those two young
00:04:34 people both under the influence of a lot of alcohol went together consensually to make out
00:04:40 and fell to the ground in their drunken state. I encourage everyone who cares about the truth
00:04:46 to read all the documents which are available online. The little that we know for sure is that
00:04:53 the woman in this case spoke to her boyfriend on the phone just minutes before the incident
00:04:59 in question. She spoke to him for 10 minutes according to police records from about 18 minutes
00:05:05 after midnight to 1228, though she didn't remember speaking to him after the fact.
00:05:15 Her failure of memory raises the possibility that during the period encompassing the alleged assault,
00:05:21 she was not passed out but, quote, blacked out. In other words, functional, partying and talking
00:05:29 and not appearing particularly incapacitated, in which case Turner could not have been expected
00:05:35 to know that she was legally incapable of consenting, and in which case she wouldn't
00:05:40 remember whether she consented or not. No one saw her leave the frat party with Turner,
00:05:49 so no one can say whether she went with him willingly or was taken by him in her helplessly
00:05:55 intoxicated state. The two witnesses who came upon them at about 12.55 a.m. offer only a partial and
00:06:05 in my opinion not particularly persuasive account though everything hangs on their observations.
00:06:12 They said they saw Turner and the woman on the ground in a dark location near the frat house as
00:06:18 they rode by on their bicycles. It was not exactly the most reliable vantage point to provide
00:06:24 objective testimony. Both reported that initially they thought Turner and the woman were having sex
00:06:31 and they didn't think much of that. Note, it was later established that Turner was fully clothed
00:06:36 and never had sex with the woman, so the witnesses were in this instance mistaken in what they
00:06:42 thought they saw. They claimed that as they continued bicycling and looked again, it seemed
00:06:48 to them that the girl wasn't moving and this is what prompted them to stop bicycling and confront
00:06:53 Turner. They yelled at him and chased him down when he, not that surprisingly, ran from them.
00:06:59 The crucial issue that no one can answer with any certainty is whether the girl
00:07:06 passed out between the time the cyclists first looked and thought everything seemed okay,
00:07:12 and when they looked again. Turner claims that the woman was rubbing his back with both hands
00:07:18 and seemed to be enjoying herself and that he never had any intention of trying to rape her.
00:07:24 The high level of uncertainty regarding the accuser's behavior and level of consciousness
00:07:31 are more than enough, in my opinion, to raise reasonable doubt.
00:07:37 But we live in a culture in which we are constantly told that good people believe women
00:07:44 when they claim to have been assaulted. And we tend to act on the principle that any incident
00:07:50 that leaves a woman feeling vulnerable and violated must be avenged. So it's not surprising,
00:07:58 therefore, that the jury found Turner guilty. And it was then the judge's role to sentence him.
00:08:03 And Judge Persky followed sentencing guidelines. And he found that Turner had no prior convictions,
00:08:13 had many, many outstanding character references, expressed what the judge believed to be genuine
00:08:22 remorse, though not acceptance of guilt, was under the influence of alcohol at the time,
00:08:29 had already had his life irreparably damaged by extensive and vicious media attention and the
00:08:36 loss of his swimming career, and would be severely affected, unreasonably so, the judge felt,
00:08:43 by the six-year prison term that the prosecution team recommended.
00:08:49 For all these reasons, Judge Persky found that a sentence of six months in a county jail
00:08:55 followed by three years probation and lifetime registration as a sex offender were appropriate.
00:09:02 It's not exactly a picnic.
00:09:04 An investigation by an independent commission found that Persky had done nothing wrong
00:09:11 and he had shown no evidence.
00:09:13 of bias. But as we know, his sentencing decision wasn't good enough for the advocates of so-called
00:09:22 women's rights. These advocates are outraged any time a man is found not guilty of an allegation
00:09:30 or is given what they consider to be a light sentence. These champions want all accusers to
00:09:37 be believed and all accused to be harshly punished, especially if they are seen to be privileged white
00:09:43 men and even if what they've allegedly done is subject to reasonable doubt. These advocates want
00:09:51 all men to live with the knowledge that they are just one accusation away from incarceration.
00:09:59 They call on more women to come forward with accusations so that more men can be harshly
00:10:04 punished and more men can live with the fear this is their version of a society in which quote
00:10:13 everyone can feel safe since everyone refers in their minds only to women
00:10:21 the blow that the recall delivers to judicial impartiality probably can't be exaggerated
00:10:30 It's almost inevitable that the next judge ruling in a sexual assault case
00:10:37 will think of Aaron Persky, and the next one, and the next.
00:10:43 Knowing that the career you've built over years or decades hangs in the balance,
00:10:50 wouldn't nearly anyone knowing that be tempted to err on the side of feminist harshness? 0.93
00:10:55 this, and that's surely what the recall intended.
00:11:25 Thank you.