The Fiamengo File - June 11, 2018


This Is Feminist Policing - TFF episode 82

The Legal Devaluation Of Men's Lives - TFF Episode 81 The End of Judicial Impartiality: Feminists Come for Judges - TFF 83

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

140.15

Word count

1,605

Sentence count

53

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
00:00:00 In the wake of various high-profile sexual assault cases in Canada and the United States, 0.83
00:00:05 feminist advocates have demanded that police and courts believe survivors. At least one
00:00:12 police services unit has publicly complied. And that's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:18 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa. 1.00
00:00:32 For years, the police service has been a prime target of feminist activism with the goal 0.68
00:00:36 of radically transforming how officers respond to sexual assault allegations.
00:00:42 feminist success in shifting the declared emphasis of the police force has been near total the police
00:00:50 force is now a body that openly encourages women to make allegations even in the absence of any
00:00:57 evidence and repeats feminist talking points about how women rarely lie about rape all of this and
00:01:05 Moore is clearly displayed on the new website of the Toronto Police Unit, which serves Canada's
00:01:13 largest city. And I think it would be unreasonable to assume that the Toronto Police Service is any
00:01:18 different from any other North American police force. Now, before I start looking at the website,
00:01:22 I want to acknowledge Libby Telford, an advocate for the falsely accused and wrongly convicted of 0.59
00:01:29 sex crimes. Libby was the one who drew this site to my attention and offered a critique of its
00:01:36 biases and blind spots, and so I'm relying here on many of her insights while also adding my own
00:01:42 perspective. Of course, anything that's inaccurate or oversimplified in my analysis is my own
00:01:48 responsibility, and I encourage you to correct me where I'm wrong since I'm far from an expert on
00:01:53 police procedure or the law. The Toronto Police Service website provides an introductory video,
00:02:00 which I think everybody should watch, which states that the police service offers a quote
00:02:04 survivor-centered approach to sexual assault investigation that places priority on the
00:02:09 quote emotional and physical well-being of those impacted by sexual violence.
00:02:16 The Toronto Police Service recognizes that survivors of sexual assault are reluctant to
00:02:22 initial contact with police and report incidents of sexual violence. Our mission
00:02:28 is to investigate every case, ensuring personal and community safety, and to
00:02:33 provide those impacted by sexual violence with community resources. We are
00:02:38 just one agency in a circle of support. We work together in order to provide the
00:02:44 best possible outcomes for those impacted by sexual violence. But many
00:02:50 people do not know about the options available to them. With that in mind, Project Guide
00:02:56 took shape. It focuses on providing resources in a survivor-centered approach that places
00:03:02 priority on the emotional and physical well-being of those impacted by sexual violence. To make
00:03:08 sure we got it right, we spent two years engaged with numerous community service providers
00:03:12 and advocacy groups. Now, here are the chilling use of the feminist phrase 0.83
00:03:18 survivor-centered, which, of course, accepts an unproven claim as if it were reality,
00:03:25 and the emphasis on the police unit's responsibility to offer emotional support
00:03:30 rather than conduct fact-based investigations. These show, in my opinion, the clear impact
00:03:35 of the advocacy groups the police force says it has consulted, and the result of the years-long
00:03:42 consultation is that the website has a great deal to say about the services for and respect due to
00:03:49 survivors and absolutely nothing to say about the services for and respect due to the accused.
00:03:58 In fact, one could be forgiven for concluding that the various advocacy groups consulted
00:04:03 didn't think of the accused at all, except to equate accused with guilty. The website
00:04:10 has a whole section on so-called rape myths, one of which assures readers that women don't often
00:04:16 lie about rape, but instead, in fact, quote, deny or minimize sexual assault, and that quote,
00:04:23 the rate of false reporting is very low. There's no actual figure given for what is considered a
00:04:32 low rate. There's no source for the statement, and there's no recognition that even if it could
00:04:38 be determined that the rate of false reporting is very low. Even if that could be conclusively
00:04:46 determined, the consequence of a false report, as it is called, the consequence is serious enough
00:04:53 that belief should never be a given. There should never be, in my opinion, a bias in favor of the
00:04:59 so-called survivor. But the website demonstrates an egregious bias over and over again. In the
00:05:07 section on reporting to the police, the website also tells us that, quote, although both women
00:05:11 and men can be victims of domestic violence, the overwhelming majority of this violence involves
00:05:17 men abusing women. And again, we aren't given any source for this statement, and we're not told what
00:05:23 the police consider a, quote, overwhelming majority. In fact, Statistics Canada, the government
00:05:29 collection agency, reports that if you look at survey data, equal proportions of men and women
00:05:36 self-report being victims of spousal violence, but no matter to the police, it seems. Let's look at a
00:05:43 few more specifics from the website. Perhaps most outstandingly, the website defines sexual assault
00:05:50 extraordinarily loosely and expansively. In fact, I think it's impossible to imagine a more elastic
00:05:58 definition. An astonishing video by Jill Witkin, a Crown attorney who has apparently prosecuted
00:06:04 numerous sexual assault cases, states that, quote, any contact made with your body in a sexual
00:06:11 context without your consent may be sexual assault, even if there is, quote, no direct
00:06:18 skin-to-skin contact, end quote. And there does not have to be direct skin-to-skin contact.
00:06:25 It could also mean that someone who hugs or kisses you in a sexual way without your consent
00:06:30 is a sexual assault. If someone touches your clothed buttocks, you can go to the police about
00:06:36 that. If someone hugs you in a sexual way, whatever that means, or brushes up against you in a sexual 0.86
00:06:44 way, whatever that means, you can go to the police about that and expect to be treated as a survivor
00:06:50 and your claim investigated. It is stated numerous times that the police investigate
00:06:55 every reported assault. Even an attempt to touch you, an attempt can be sexual assault,
00:07:05 according to Crown Attorney Jill Witkin. And there doesn't necessarily have to be physical
00:07:12 contact. A sexual assault can include an attempt to touch you or a threat to touch you in a sexual
00:07:19 context without your consent as i've said before when i just run out of things to say the mind
00:07:26 boggles how any man could defend himself against a charge of attempted touching in a sexual manner
00:07:33 or sexual hugging well it's anybody's guess and indeed the entire question of what constitutes
00:07:40 evidence in cases of sexual assault investigation is raised at multiple points on the website with
00:07:47 extraordinary casualness. The message is, it seems, that evidence is great if you have it,
00:07:55 but don't let it stop you if you don't. In the section on reporting to the police, we are told
00:08:01 that, quote, charges will be laid if there is enough evidence to support investigation,
00:08:08 which is a strange statement seeming to suggest that charges can be laid first before an
00:08:14 investigation is conducted if the evidence warrants, but it isn't clear how an officer
00:08:19 can determine whether there's enough evidence without having already investigated. Elsewhere
00:08:24 on the site, however, it is made clear that evidence, while desirable, isn't actually
00:08:30 necessary at all. Again, in the section reporting to the police, prospective accusers are assured
00:08:38 that, quote, in Canada, there is no statute of limitations for sexual offenses, which
00:08:43 means you can report to the police no matter how long ago it happened end quote in other words
00:08:50 all you need is your story and the website goes on to spell out that quote evidence is not
00:08:58 absolutely necessary in conducting an investigation so there it is evidence is not absolutely necessary
00:09:11 As a sidebar, it turns out that even without evidence, an accuser can apply for money
00:09:16 from the Criminal Injuries Compensation Board, which we are told, quote, provides financial
00:09:21 compensation for victims who have been injured by violent crime in Ontario, which includes sexual
00:09:26 assault. Compensation may be awarded even if no charges were laid or if there was no conviction
00:09:33 in a criminal proceeding, end quote. It certainly seems that the Toronto Police Service is going
00:09:40 out of its way to make the lodging of a sexual assault complaint sound as easy and attractive
00:09:47 as possible. Nothing is said about the rights of the accused or about the necessity of vigilance
00:09:55 on the part of investigating officers to determine the credibility of the accuser
00:10:01 and the factual basis of the allegation. There's no message to accusers that a charge of sexual
00:10:08 assault is a very serious charge carrying a very serious penalty, and that frivolous accusations
00:10:14 or accusations in which the passage of time has seriously interfered with memory are a waste of
00:10:20 police resources and a violation of justice. What the website makes terrifyingly clear is that under
00:10:29 the present dispensation, an innocent man can easily be arrested, charged, jailed, and investigated
00:10:37 based solely on a complainant's uncorroborated testimony, perhaps about an incident that occurred
00:10:43 years and years ago, and that our law enforcement officials not only allow it to happen but even
00:10:48 encourage it and encourage misguided or malicious individuals to lodge complaints by assuring them
00:10:59 of the police services eagerness to assist them desire to believe them and willingness to help
00:11:04 them profit we've known this has been going on for a long time but it's never been in my opinion
00:11:12 anyway so overtly stated the police service no longer even pretends to be an impartial body
00:11:21 that investigates crime. It's now a declared arm of the feminist state. 0.63