00:00:00The legal devaluation of men's lives is a largely unacknowledged, appalling
00:00:07human rights abuse, and it's my subject on today's Fiumingo File.
00:00:21I'm Janice Fiumingo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:24in october of 2017 just as the me too movement was revving up to near universal praise as a
00:00:32necessary corrective on behalf of female sexual assault and harassment victims a 26 year old
00:00:39british woman named rebecca palmer was found guilty of four counts of perverting the course
00:00:45of justice in an unusual decision unusual because it was just she was sentenced to five years in
00:00:53prison for repeated false allegations of rape against a then 20 year old british soldier0.50
00:01:01palmer had had an affair with the man and after he broke it off she had begun an attempt to ruin
00:01:09his life by telling police that he raped her her campaign of lies led to the man's being arrested
00:01:17more than once and held in jail on various occasions. The fact that this woman will serve
00:01:24time in prison is quite remarkable and well-deserved, but the Wiltshire Police Rep's statement to the
00:01:32press is amazing and all too familiar to those of us who follow these kinds of cases. Here's the
00:01:39police rep's predictable comment, quote, Palmer became completely embroiled in her own web of lies1.00
00:01:49and her appalling behavior could really have a negative impact on other victims of rape or
00:01:55sexual assault who may choose not to report it to police for fear that they will not be believed,
00:02:02end quote. This is the classic feminist response in which the real victim of Rebecca Palmer's
00:02:11numerous false allegations is seen to be other women, even though no real women were harmed by
00:02:18Palmer. The man whose character was publicly dragged through the mud for two years, who
00:02:24received multiple police visits, who sweated behind bars, who foresaw his whole life permanently
00:02:32ruined, who dreaded years of incarceration, who had to defend himself against the claims of a
00:02:38determined accuser in an era in which we are continually exhorted to believe accusing women,
00:02:47this man's years-long mental and emotional suffering is of less consequence to the police
00:02:53rep and to the journalist covering the story than the potential hesitation of a hypothetical victim
00:03:00or victims welcome to the upside down world of feminist culture in which ideologues have been1.00
00:03:07so successful in spreading their propaganda that the average man and woman on the street0.94
00:03:12will still tell you that it's a man's world and that women are discriminated against even when
00:03:18the case in question is about a male victim this is a world in which men account for well over 90
00:03:26percent of the prison population and in which women's crimes including murder are consistently
00:03:33treated with remarkable leniency being a man in our era means knowing that you can go to prison
00:03:42for the rest of your life on the uncorroborated molestation claims of a teenage girl and even if
00:03:49your accuser recants her entire story the criminal justice system may well keep you in prison and
00:03:57there won't be a public outcry because we're a culture that's inclined to believe men are guilty
00:04:03Take the terrifying case of a Colorado man named Charles Farrar, who was sentenced back in 2002
00:04:13to 145 years in prison based solely on the testimony of his rebellious stepdaughter,
00:04:23Sasha, who claimed he had molested and sexually abused her for years, from age 11 to 15.
00:04:31The girl alleged that Farrar had assaulted her hundreds of times and had filmed his abuse of
00:04:38her. The police never did find any film, barely interviewed the girl, and failed to interview
00:04:45many witnesses who could have contradicted her story. Yet, still, the prosecution went ahead
00:04:53and the jury convicted Farrar. Just a few months after that conviction, the then 18-year-old
00:05:01Sasha took back her allegations, saying she'd fabricated the whole thing because she wanted to
00:05:07live with her grandparents in Oklahoma. She even confessed that she'd told one of the prosecutors
00:05:13in the case that it was all a lie on the morning of the trial. But no matter. Multiple judges have
00:05:22upheld Farrar's conviction, and he remains in prison to this day awaiting an appeal for a crime
00:05:30he and his former accuser insist never happened. Yet feminists tell us with a straight face that
00:05:39in cases of sexual assault allegations, we should start by believing the alleged female victim.1.00
00:05:46And of course, it doesn't work the other way round. In cases where adolescent boys are raped
00:05:55by their female teacher, even if the abuse continued for months or years, even if the
00:06:01evidence is rock solid, even if the teacher admits she did it, she will likely be given
00:06:07a slap on the wrist. Earlier this month, May of 2018, a 32-year-old California high school
00:06:15teacher named Samantha Chiota pleaded guilty to three counts of unlawful intercourse with a minor
00:06:22boy. Details about her crime are vague, but it seems that the teacher victimized more than one
00:06:29of her grade nine male students, giving them alcohol and sexually abusing them at her home,
00:06:34but still managed to work out a lenient plea deal involving four years probation, not a day
00:06:42in jail. She will not register as a sex offender and she may even be able to reapply to teach
00:06:48school when her probationary sentence is concluded. Though the victim's grandmother is furious saying
00:06:56she complained to the school about the ongoing abuse and nothing was done about it by the female
00:07:01school principal, Chiada herself seems to think that she has been the victim in the case. In the
00:07:08statement accompanying her plea deal, she did not apologize and did not take responsibility for her
00:07:15crime, but spoke instead of the, quote, long journey that she had ahead of her, saying that
00:07:20although she had not had a chance to tell her side of the story, she would, quote, take what has
00:07:27happened and use the experiences and lessons learned to give back to the community, end quote.
00:07:33In a culture overwhelmingly inclined to see women as innocent, even convicted female sex offenders are allowed to represent themselves as noble victims.
00:07:47Our society has so much sympathy for women, in fact, that it even extends to female murderers.
00:07:56If a woman beats her boyfriend to death in a horrific planned murder, she will probably be able to claim some sort of mental distress as a way of avoiding conviction, likely citing fear of the man to justify her violence.
00:08:15and if she is found not guilty, the case will attract next to no attention because our society
00:08:22doesn't care about men who are beaten to death by women. We figure they must have done something0.73
00:08:29to deserve it. Earlier this year, January of 2018, 32-year-old Anne Norris was found not
00:08:39criminally responsible for the murder of Marcel Reardon in St. John's, Newfoundland.
00:08:46Now, a verdict of not criminally responsible is said to apply in cases where the defendant is
00:08:52unable to appreciate the consequences of their actions or unable to know right from wrong or
00:08:57not in control of their behavior. Ann Norris was sufficiently in control of her behavior
00:09:06to purchase, the day previous to the murder, the hammer that she planned to use to bludgeon1.00
00:09:11Marcel, hitting him so many times in the head that the coroner couldn't tell how many blows0.85
00:09:16there were. And she knew enough about the wrongness of her action to dispose of his
00:09:22body outside her apartment and to throw the hammer into St. John's Harbour in order to hide the
00:09:28evidence. But jurors were responsive to claims that Norris suffers from bipolar disorder and
00:09:34that was enough to get her off. Even the prosecutor in the case expressed sympathy for Norris, saying
00:09:41at the conclusion of the trial that, quote, these are difficult issues with no easy answers, end
00:09:47quote. A man is dead, but that's just a detail in the woman's story of psychological difficulty.
00:09:57No space in the report of the trial was given to personalizing the dead man or to representing the
00:10:04grief and loss of his family and friends in the reports of all these cases and so many more
00:10:13there is a consistent diminishment of the humanity of the men involved and a corresponding
00:10:19enhancement of the humanity of the women such that we are encouraged to imagine the feelings
00:10:26of female perpetrators while we are discouraged from imagining the feelings of the male victims
00:10:34whether they are falsely accused sexually abused jailed or dead the personhood of the men involved
00:10:43is airbrushed out of the picture so that it's difficult to identify with them at all
00:10:50being male in a feminist culture means knowing that your life is worth less than a woman's life
00:10:59That's why I published Sons of Feminism, Men Have Their Say, a book that gives voice to men's experiences, telling what it feels like to be belittled, disliked, dismissed, blamed, falsely accused, and discriminated against under law, all while being expected to apologize for male privilege.0.65
00:11:22The book is dedicated to all the innocent men who have suffered in our gynocentric and feminist society.0.65