The Fiamengo File - May 08, 2018


Why Do Some Men Hate? - TFF episode 80

Can A License Plate Promote Rape? TFF episode 79 The Legal Devaluation Of Men's Lives - TFF Episode 81

Episode Stats


Length

8 minutes

Words per minute

148.29

Word count

1,290

Sentence count

47

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 If incels hate women, why do they care so much what women think of them?
00:00:05 That's my subject on today's Fiumengo File.
00:00:17 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa. Many journalists have moved to pronounce on the
00:00:22 reason why on April 23rd, 25-year-old Alec Manassian drove a van down Yonge Street sidewalks
00:00:29 in Toronto, Canada, killing 10 people and wounding many more. We've been told it's misogyny. Alec
00:00:37 Manassian reputedly posted to an online community that rages against women. An essay in the Canadian
00:00:44 magazine The Walrus, while admitting that we actually know next to nothing about Manassian's
00:00:50 motives, nonetheless used his murderous rampage to ask why there are so many angry young men out
00:00:57 there. Quote, why is a viciously misogynist movement flourishing? The author gives a
00:01:05 tautological response to her question-begging question, because we live in a misogynistic
00:01:10 culture in which men, quote, believe that they should be able to do what they want to women,
00:01:15 end quote. The author's main argument, like many other similar arguments that we've heard recently,
00:01:21 is that the raging young men in the online communities that Manassian purportedly visited,
00:01:29 that they can't stand to see women's achievements in the workplace and that they are furious over
00:01:35 their own lack of sexual success with women. This is a predictably oversimplified and incomplete
00:01:42 thesis. If we're going to take seriously the problem of young men angry enough to kill others 0.52
00:01:48 and themselves, we should at least be honest about their reasons, keeping in mind, of course,
00:01:53 that there are likely many issues at play. But let's take as a given that there is a significant
00:02:00 number of men in our society who are very angry at women. And so let's start with the first reason
00:02:06 that's offered in the Walrus article and elsewhere, men's anger at women's success.
00:02:13 Yes, men are witnessing a transformation of the workplace and the public sphere
00:02:18 generally as women demand and achieve 50% or more representation in many areas that were
00:02:25 formerly majority male. And as women come into these formerly male spaces in academia,
00:02:31 in large corporations, in government offices, even as commentators in the National Hockey League, 0.91
00:02:38 they demand sweeping changes to the culture to make women feel comfortable. Whether the men feel
00:02:44 comfortable is entirely irrelevant to them. And the fact is that women are not moving so visibly 0.92
00:02:52 into many of these spheres because of outstanding talent. They're coming in by government and 0.98
00:02:58 activists dictate through affirmative action measures to hire more women into the civil 1.00
00:03:03 service, to get more women into STEM, to have more women on corporate boards, to have more 1.00
00:03:08 female politicians, and so on. There's very little that's natural and certainly nothing 0.87
00:03:14 gradual about what's been happening. It's been a forced phenomenon in which in the name
00:03:19 of equality, men have been deliberately, legally disadvantaged over the past 30 years, forced
00:03:26 to watch often less qualified women hired and promoted ahead of them while at the same time
00:03:31 told that if they object to the clear injustice, they'll get a lecture on misogyny, if not a 0.96
00:03:37 harassment charge that can result in their dismissal from their job. The author of the
00:03:41 Walrus article mentions Mark Lapine, the killer of women at the Montreal Polytechnic, who explicitly
00:03:46 claimed that he hated feminists for ruining his life before opening fire on female engineering
00:03:52 students. It was said at the time that Lepine, who had applied to the engineering program and 0.99
00:03:57 been turned down, it was said that he was angry that the school was actively seeking to raise
00:04:03 the number of women in the discipline. I don't know if that's ever been confirmed, that there
00:04:07 was a policy in favor of female engineering students, but I certainly wouldn't be surprised 0.93
00:04:11 as equity programs have been in place in academia for decades. Living under a system of overt 1.00
00:04:18 government-sanctioned injustice is not an excuse to kill women, of course. But if we claim to want 1.00
00:04:26 to know what's going on, it's at least worth acknowledging that the festering resentment
00:04:32 of some men has a real, not an imaginary source. Young men's embittered awareness that feminist
00:04:40 activists and their political enablers created a problem of glaring injustice and not only created
00:04:46 it but won't even acknowledge that it exists. That's not going to evaporate with further denials.
00:04:54 The second big issue mentioned by the Walrus author is men's sexual frustration and this is
00:05:01 also a lot more legitimate than is generally acknowledged. There's probably always been a
00:05:08 cohort of men who for whatever reasons have no access to women who are involuntarily celibate.
00:05:14 Studies of human DNA have proved that only a very small percentage of the male population,
00:05:19 actually much smaller than the female percentage, has managed to reproduce throughout human history.
00:05:24 Male sexual frustration has probably always been an issue for societies, but perhaps never
00:05:30 in quite the way it is in ours, where it is both deeply under-acknowledged and,
00:05:37 when it is acknowledged, made a subject of scorn and ridicule. Feminist ideologues tell
00:05:43 us that sex and gender are social constructs and that therefore men's sexual needs aren't real 0.92
00:05:48 needs but merely forms of misogyny masquerading as biology. Men's desire for sexual companionship
00:05:55 is not only not recognized as legitimate but is even as a result of feminist activism now
00:06:01 profoundly stigmatized. Men are scolded publicly for quote objectifying women or for harassing
00:06:08 women, for being sexual predators, or for feeling entitled to sex, for wanting to control women's 0.81
00:06:15 bodies, and so on. Even merely to look at a woman in a certain way, let alone to pursue her, 0.98
00:06:19 to express sexual interest or attraction, is now potentially a firing offense or even a criminal
00:06:25 matter. Men are lectured constantly at school, in the media, at university, in the workplace,
00:06:31 about the toxicity of their sexuality in a way utterly unthinkable if it were done for women.
00:06:38 the distress of such men their loneliness their despair their self-loathing their suicidal rage
00:06:47 this is a problem they know they can't even talk about it's a problem they know can't be helped and
00:06:53 that they'll get no sympathy for and moreover women who can't begin to imagine what such
00:06:59 frustration feels like, mock and despise them for it. I'm not trying to justify the actions 0.96
00:07:07 of an Alec Manassian or to suggest that the women he killed in any way deserved what they got,
00:07:13 but I am saying that men's anger has a real source. Because if you live your whole life
00:07:21 feeling ridiculed and blamed for your sexual urges, and then on top of that you're constantly
00:07:26 told about how you should apologize for your supposed entitlement to women's bodies, which
00:07:31 is the last thing you've ever had, and you hear over and over again that the problem we face today
00:07:37 is male privilege, male advantage, male overconfidence, male indifference to women's
00:07:44 issues, the old boys network, and so on and on. If you keep hearing that, it's not surprising that
00:07:51 you're going to turn off in corrosive bitterness and despair. And to think that the answer is to
00:07:58 keep on going in the direction we've been going, which means more unfair measures to advantage
00:08:04 women over men and more lecturing of men about what misogynist they are. That's just pure
00:08:11 foolishness. We already have an epidemic of men killing themselves. And we have a core of very 0.98
00:08:19 angry young men who believe with some justification that nobody gives a damn about their problems.
00:08:26 These men have lost motivation to contribute anything positive to a society that's made clear
00:08:33 it doesn't care about them. We can keep on telling them that they're just too privileged,
00:08:39 but they probably won't believe it.