The Fiamengo File - May 01, 2018


Can A License Plate Promote Rape? TFF episode 79

The Ugly Face Of Carceral Feminism - TFF episode 78 Why Do Some Men Hate? - TFF episode 80

Episode Stats


Length

12 minutes

Words per minute

124.13

Word count

1,508

Sentence count

65

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Can a feminist professor of communications make a legitimate case 1.00
00:00:04 that a license plate contributes to rape culture? That's my subject on today's 1.00
00:00:11 Fiamengo File.
00:00:21 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. Over the past 30 years academic
00:00:28 feminism has had a profound impact on educational theory on sexual assault law domestic violence 0.87
00:00:36 research sexual harassment legislation equity hiring policies government programs to advantage
00:00:43 women perceptions of men as privileged and masculinity is toxic and many other areas of
00:00:49 our culture but now it can even affect whether you can put your own name on your license plate
00:00:58 Lorne Graeber is a resident of Nova Scotia, Canada, who first purchased as a gift for his
00:01:05 father back in 1990 a personalized license plate bearing his last name, spelled G-R-A-B-H-E-R.
00:01:16 Over the years, the plate became a symbol of family pride. Lorne had the Graeber plate for
00:01:23 more than two decades and his son troy who lives in alberta also has one but in 2016 the personalized
00:01:31 plate was revoked after somebody complained that it was offensive and officials in the motor
00:01:38 vehicles office of nova scotia agreed that it was since then mr graber has taken the province to
00:01:46 court to fight for his right to retain the plate and the nova scotia government has hired an expert
00:01:51 witness at significant expense, $15,000 according to Graeber's legal team, to produce a lengthy
00:01:58 report arguing that in the era of Donald Trump, the license plate promotes sexual violence against
00:02:05 women and rape culture. The expert is a McGill University professor of communications named
00:02:12 Carrie Rentschler, not wrench her, please note, and not rent her. And this professor specializes
00:02:22 in, you guessed it, feminist theory. Professor Rentschler is no run-of-the-mill feminist scholar 0.99
00:02:28 either. She is the William Dawson Scholar of Feminist Media Studies, which is a distinguished
00:02:34 university position. In her words, it is a, quote, university-funded research chair dedicated to the
00:02:42 study of media and feminist issues in the training of highly qualified personnel in this area, end
00:02:48 quote. Rentschler's report, which is available at the website of the Justice Center for Constitutional
00:02:54 Freedoms, is a textbook example of the remarkable intellectual achievement of academic feminism.
00:03:02 I've been reading feminist BS for many years now, but this howler of a report really may take the 1.00
00:03:09 cake, and I encourage everyone to read it and to marvel that once respectable university scholarship
00:03:16 has come to this. So let me say a few words about the report. It begins by introducing an academic
00:03:24 theory of language in order to make its rather simplistic analysis sound deep. Professor Rentschler
00:03:32 cites a big gun philosopher of language named J.L. Austin, telling us that he, quote, conceptualized
00:03:41 language as speech acts or what he called performatives. Performatives are types of
00:03:48 speech that act in the world and have real world effects. According to Rentschler, this means that
00:03:54 it doesn't matter that Graeber is actually the vehicle owner's name, because at a time when
00:04:02 hashtags commonly join words together to create social media tags, the license plate can be seen
00:04:08 not as a name, but as an injunction or an imperative. Grab her. And this is a speech
00:04:16 act that, according to Professor Rentschler, quote, supports, condones, and encourages
00:04:21 violence against women, end quote. Now, the reference to speech act theory sounds suitably
00:04:28 academic. But there's a slight problem with the reference to J.L. Austin, who did indeed develop
00:04:34 the theory, but didn't equate all speech acts with performatives, as Professor Rentschler states.
00:04:41 Now, if there are any experts in language theory out there, tell me if I'm wrong. I studied Austin
00:04:45 a long time ago, but in my understanding, Austin identified a number of different types of speech
00:04:51 acts of which performatives are only one restricted type. As even a glance at Wikipedia explains,
00:04:59 a performative is a type of speech act in which the locution or the statement actually does what
00:05:07 it says. So, I hereby pronounce you man and wife is a performative. I christen this ship,
00:05:15 the Fiamengo Mengo, I am firing you. I call this meeting to order. These are all performatives
00:05:21 because they literally do what they say. They act in the world and they function in specific,
00:05:27 usually quite formal context in which the person making the statement has the social authority
00:05:33 to enact it. Graeber, on the other hand, even if interpreted as an injunction to grab a woman,
00:05:41 which I think is a big if, it doesn't belong to the narrow class of utterances considered
00:05:48 performatives by Austen. So, Professor Rentschler has made an undergraduate-level error of
00:05:56 rather significant proportions, in my opinion. Well, even if we put aside the communication
00:06:04 professor's faulty understanding of language theory, there are logical flaws and passages
00:06:10 of gassy rhetoric aplenty in her claim that Graeber is an offensive statement that, quote,
00:06:16 encourages its recipients to grab or grope female individuals with or without their consent
00:06:23 and contributes to a, quote, hateful and threatening, end quote, rape culture. 0.75
00:06:28 The entire report exhibits the kind of circular reasoning that is typical of feminist theory in
00:06:35 which something that to ordinary people seems a relatively benign or at least neutral or
00:06:41 ambiguous expression is deemed sexist and therefore violent, because it is said to be
00:06:46 an expression of a culture that is sexist and therefore violent, and at the same time is said
00:06:53 to contribute to the sexism and violence of the culture that preexisted it and made it sexist and
00:06:59 violence in the first place. It's a kind of endless chicken and egg dance in which no proof
00:07:06 is ever brought forward either that the culture is sexist and violent in any kind of totalizing
00:07:12 sense or that the individual utterance demonstrably worsens the culture's level of sexism and
00:07:20 violence. Both claims are simply asserted and reasserted with reference to other feminist
00:07:25 theorists who assert and reassert the same thing. This is the classic feminist modus operandi. 1.00
00:07:33 Take an ordinary action or saying, then link it with the violence of rape, 1.00
00:07:39 claim without any evidence that the two things exist on a continuum of sexual violence,
00:07:45 and assert that such sexual violence is both widespread and dangerously under-recognized.
00:07:54 then claim that anyone who fails to see the connection is simply proof of how widespread
00:08:01 the under-recognized problem of sexual violence really is. In a key section of her argument,
00:08:09 Professor Rentschler has the chutzpah to claim that those who don't see the offense of Graeber
00:08:17 are you guessed it rape apologists here's how she phrases this quote
00:08:25 those who find the license plate offensive are likely to be opposed to violence against women
00:08:32 and the expressions that the cultural expression sorry that support it those who do not find it
00:08:38 offensive would in turn be supportive of or would condone violence against women and the cultural
00:08:45 expressions that represent it as legitimate, end quote. This is a classic logical fallacy called
00:08:53 the false dilemma. It's when you say that there are only two alternatives, when in fact there are
00:08:58 more than two. And it's unworthy of any rational person, let alone a professor of communications,
00:09:05 and yet it is stated in the report as if it were some sort of important truth. Give me a break.
00:09:11 Of course, there are other possible and likely responses to the license plate.
00:09:18 In addition to assuming correctly that it is probably somebody's name, one could interpret
00:09:24 it in a positive way, as an injunction to love and admire the woman in one's life.
00:09:31 Grab her and hold her tight.
00:09:34 If you love her, grab her while you have the chance.
00:09:37 Don't let her go, and so on.
00:09:38 If we're going to talk about context, determining the meaning of an utterance, as Professor Rentschler does, well, popular music is full of non-violent references to lovers who want to, quote, grab her attention, swift and quick.
00:09:55 That's the smashing pumpkins. Or grab her hand and spin her round and round. That's R. Kelly,
00:10:03 the song Steppin' Into Heaven. Or, quote, grab your partner and swing her round. That's Conway
00:10:08 Twitty. I mean, there's a long and honorable tradition testifying to love between men and
00:10:15 women that Rentschler, who's fixated on Donald Trump, doesn't even mention. And she can't mention
00:10:21 it, of course, because her entire argument rests on our presumed culture of sexualized violence.
00:10:28 To acknowledge the context of positive expressions involving grab her would be to acknowledge that
00:10:34 we don't live in a culture in which violence against women is widespread and condoned. In
00:10:40 fact, we live in a culture in which women are cherished and in which violence against women
00:10:46 is abhorred. Our culture cherishes women so much that it took only one complaint for the
00:10:54 government of Nova Scotia to ban the license plate. Professor Rentschler's poorly written
00:11:02 piece of feminist claptrap certainly doesn't prove that Graeber promotes violence against women, 1.00
00:11:08 But unfortunately, it strongly suggests that even motor vehicles offices have become feminist 0.99
00:11:16 compliant institutes of mass surveillance. 1.00
00:11:38 Thank you.