The Fiamengo File - April 16, 2018


The Ugly Face Of Carceral Feminism - TFF episode 78

Then They Came For The Poets - TFF episode 77 Can A License Plate Promote Rape? TFF episode 79

Episode Stats


Length

12 minutes

Words per minute

145.23

Word count

1,850

Sentence count

23

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Should a man be sent to jail and have to register as a sex offender for 10 years because at age
00:00:07 18 he had an underage girlfriend who sent him nude photos of herself?
00:00:12 That's my subject on today's Fiumengo File.
00:00:24 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:28 Vox magazine recently published an article that caught my eye with the title,
00:00:32 Me Too Must Avoid Carceral Feminism. Carceral feminism refers to feminist reliance on the 1.00
00:00:40 state to punish men for what feminists call sexual violence. And the author of the article,
00:00:46 Alex Press, warns feminists that, quote, directing the movement's energy into the criminal justice 0.99
00:00:52 system doesn't build the power we need to stop sexual violence. It allies us with a system that 1.00
00:00:59 is incompatible with liberation." Now, read selectively, this might seem to acknowledge
00:01:05 that the criminal justice system treats accused men badly. But as you read on, you realize that
00:01:11 the author's argument is not that the criminal justice system goes too far in punishing men for
00:01:18 sexual misconduct, but that it doesn't go far enough to empower women and redistribute wealth.
00:01:25 So there isn't any compassion for men in that article. But what about the very large number
00:01:31 of men going to jail for behavior they never imagined to be criminal and didn't intend to
00:01:38 be harmful? Feminists are big on calls to keep women out of prison, but the same concern is 1.00
00:01:46 very rarely extended to men. Perhaps the most obvious discrepancy in how men and women are
00:01:52 judged is evident in statutory rape cases. If a man has a sexual relationship with an underage
00:02:00 girl, there is outrage and calls for jail time. But when an adult woman has a sexual relationship
00:02:06 with an underage boy, there is rarely outrage, even when there is clear abuse of authority as
00:02:12 in cases involving female teachers which we've seen quite a few of recently a good example of
00:02:19 leniency for female perpetrators is provided by the case of lisa lavoie a 24 year old massachusetts
00:02:27 teacher who seduced her eighth grade male student back in 2009 the two were found in a motel room
00:02:34 after the boy's parents had reported him missing notably the parents of the boy had already
00:02:41 complained to the school about the inappropriate relationship that the teacher was having with
00:02:46 their son but the school didn't think it was serious and nothing was done they didn't even
00:02:51 bother to talk to the teacher until three days later when the parents filed a missing persons
00:02:57 report and even after ms lavoie was arrested the president of the school board was still talking
00:03:04 about the sexual relationship between the two in very benign terms calling it a quote bond
00:03:11 that had developed through after school social interaction and we're also told in the newspaper
00:03:16 report that the boy was quote unharmed after the motel incident i cannot imagine an eighth grade
00:03:25 girl whose male teacher took her to a motel room for sex being pronounced unharmed by news media
00:03:34 ms lavoie eventually pleaded guilty to three counts of statutory rape and in 2011 she was
00:03:41 sentenced to probation time no jail time an illuminating window into cultural attitudes is
00:03:48 provided by the judge's very sympathetic statement that he didn't think ms lavoie would re-offend
00:03:55 because her motivation was quote not sexual gratification but quote concern for the boy's
00:04:03 emotional well-being truly it is impossible to imagine that being said about a 24 year old man
00:04:12 who had a sexual relationship with an eighth grade girl in his class the teacher didn't have to
00:04:18 register as a sex offender because of this very positive apprehension of her conduct and i should
00:04:24 imagine i should mention that a year later ms lavoie was found guilty of violating her parole
00:04:29 conditions after she re-established a sexual relationship with a boy and at that point she
00:04:34 was sentenced to 18 months in jail but prior to that only probation more recently in december 2017
00:04:44 a 34 year old woman in lagrange georgia was found not guilty of statutory rape despite testimony by
00:04:52 three teenagers that she took them to a lake access point bought them alcohol supplied them
00:04:57 with marijuana and had sex with a 13 year old boy when he was incapacitated and she had admitted to
00:05:04 the incident in a text message with one of the other teenagers and she had failed a polygraph
00:05:09 test administered by the police but it seems the jury couldn't find it in their hearts to convict
00:05:15 her finding her guilty of a misdemeanor charge instead more recently still a 26 year old middle
00:05:22 school teacher in florida will stand trial after having a months-long sexual relationship with a
00:05:28 14 year old male student she sent the student nude photos of herself and picked him up at his home
00:05:34 for sex she is charged with lewd and lascivious battery which is equivalent to statutory rape
00:05:41 but it remains to be seen if she will be given any jail time we are a society that has always found
00:05:47 it very difficult to send women to jail for comparative purposes i want to turn to a recent
00:05:54 case in canada that has generated outrage at the supposedly lenient treatment of a convicted
00:06:01 male sexual offender in which many members of the public can't wait for this young man to be locked
00:06:09 up in january of 2018 now 21 year old connor new router pled guilty to one count of sexual
00:06:20 interference when he was 18 with a 13 year old girl and he was sentenced to 90 days in jail
00:06:28 what was most galling to the 70 000 plus people who have signed a petition about this case
00:06:37 was that connor's sentence was delayed until after he could complete his academic semester
00:06:43 at the university of calgary according to my understanding of the law it isn't that unusual
00:06:49 for a sentence of less than two years to be delayed for a variety of reasons reasons but
00:06:56 those who signed the petition to have connor expelled from the university of calgary felt
00:07:02 this was yet another example of the courts acting as quote the epitome of white male privilege end
00:07:08 quote one of the women who signed the petition lamented that quote this man is a convicted 0.88
00:07:16 violent sexual predator whose chosen prey is children that he has been able to use his
00:07:22 enrollment at the university of calgary to shield himself from his heinous crimes is nothing short 0.97
00:07:28 of appalling end quote another claimed it was quote sick they are letting him continue living 0.98
00:07:35 his life after raping someone end quote another said that she was quote sick and tired of perverts 0.98
00:07:42 going free he should be castrated not expelled end quote another alleged that quote unless we 0.99
00:07:49 are in a competition with the u.s for the most sexual assaults on a campus rapists have no 0.87
00:07:56 business in our schools it's about time that connor learned what no means end quote
00:08:05 well as is likely common with petitions the mob fury is based on many misrepresentations and
00:08:16 complete ignorance of the facts of the case i should note by the way that because of measures
00:08:21 to protect the identity of the girl in the case the facts we do have are somewhat sketchy but
00:08:28 we do know that connor newrouter is not a quote violent sexual predator whose chosen prey is
00:08:36 children he didn't rape the girl in this case and there is no evidence at all of any prior history
00:08:43 with underage girls he and the 13 year old that he was involved with never had sex and although
00:08:50 there is mention of his once putting his hands around the girl's neck it just the context of
00:08:55 that action isn't clear and it doesn't seem to have caused harm or been seen as a threat
00:09:01 the majority of what happened between 18 year old connor and the 13 year old girl
00:09:07 was virtual it took place through texts something called snapchat they actually met only a handful
00:09:17 of times. New Router was a big fish in the little pond of Kamloops, BC. He was a good-looking hockey
00:09:24 player hoping to make a break into the big leagues, and the girl was, as far as I can tell, infatuated
00:09:30 with him. Thirteen-year-old girls have always been enamored of older teenage boys, and vice versa.
00:09:40 Was this relationship abusive? It's hard to say from what we know. What is clear is that Connors
00:09:47 primary crime was as the headline of the Vancouver Sun newspaper put it to quote
00:09:53 obtain sexual photos of the victim end quote that's a slightly misleading way
00:10:00 of saying that new router requested and received nude photos from the girl in
00:10:06 other words she sent them to him this is not quite the equivalent of a violent
00:10:12 rape according to the reports that i read new router at one point threatened to show the photos
00:10:18 to others if the girl told about their relationship as she was threatening to do mutual blackmail it 0.99
00:10:24 seems in blackmail in which one of the parties the girl clearly had all the moral and legal power on
00:10:31 her side and at one point in the whole affair a friend of the girl a 14 year old began sending
00:10:39 nude photos of herself to connor also supposedly in an attempt to quote distract him from her friend
00:10:47 it seems the two girls were competing for the attention of a local sports hero
00:10:53 i just don't see any evidence that connor new router constitutes a danger to the public if
00:10:58 anything judging from the vicious bloodlust on evidence in that petition members of the public
00:11:04 are the danger to new router and by extension to all accused young men it is really shocking to
00:11:13 see the depth of hatred unleashed by new router's delayed sentence and to witness tens of thousands
00:11:20 of ordinary people whipped into a fury of obscenities and calls for castration merely
00:11:27 because a young man had an underage girlfriend who sent him nude photos he is going to jail
00:11:34 he will register as a sex offender for 10 years and that's not enough for them what would be
00:11:40 enough the death penalty that he'd be torn limb from limb in some kind of public spectacle
00:11:48 i guess so as one male commentator said reading from his feminist script
00:11:52 quote justice should be victim-centered particularly with reference to sex offenses
00:11:59 another agreed saying we need to take sexual assault seriously men be warned in other words
00:12:07 carceral feminism lock up all the men no matter what they did or didn't do compassion for girls
00:12:16 and women none for boys or men read the new router petition and get a glimpse of how hideous it is 0.89
00:12:29 Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed this video, please support us on Patreon. If even
00:12:35 half of our subscribers gave us $1 per month, we'd be well on our way to creating more
00:12:40 and better content. And don't forget to subscribe to us on Studio Brulee.