The Fiamengo File - September 10, 2015


The Safe Space Ploy – Fiamengo File Episode 5

The Empathy Gap - Fiamengo File Episode 4 The Monstrous Male Gaze - Fiamengo File Episode 6

Episode Stats


Length

8 minutes

Words per minute

122.6

Word count

1,089

Sentence count

49


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiomengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:19 My theme today is Repressive Tolerance, a paradoxical phrase at the heart of much campus
00:00:25 politics today.
00:00:29 That's not the phrase we hear, though.
00:00:31 The buzz phrase on university campuses used to shame and exclude heretics is safe space.
00:00:39 Whether protesting an abortion debate, an anti-feminist talk, or any discussion of race
00:00:44 or Islam that doesn't toe the politically correct line, students and the administrators
00:00:49 who kowtow to them evoke the ideal of the university as a safe space for marginalized
00:00:56 students. In other words, a place where ideas that are hateful or intolerant or disturbing
00:01:02 to the so-called marginalized are prohibited. Note that writer about marginalized students.
00:01:09 There's no attempt to make the campus an intellectually safe space for all. If you're
00:01:16 disturbed by the killing of unborn children, if you object to gay marriage, or if you love
00:01:22 the Jewish state of Israel, university campuses are inevitably going to be uncomfortable places
00:01:28 for you and nobody in the higher echelons cares at all.
00:01:32 The irony, of course, is that pro-life students, for example, really are marginalized at universities,
00:01:39 their views ruled impermissible on a regular basis, but you won't find many university
00:01:44 presidents standing up for their right to an offense-free learning environment.
00:01:50 Hey! Don't touch me! And she just, and she just pushed my sister as well. I don't care!
00:01:57 You're going to hurt yourself. Don't touch me!
00:02:01 Can you please go with me? Don't take me!
00:02:05 Stop it!
00:02:20 At many Canadian universities, in fact, pro-life demonstrators are singled out for especially
00:02:35 harsh treatment merely for showing what abortion looks like.
00:02:40 Anyone who has spoken to the self-designated guardians of morality amidst the student body
00:02:46 knows that the fight about safe spaces isn't really about safety at all, but about power.
00:02:54 The so-called marginalized are a bold and belligerent lot who have been spectacularly
00:03:01 successful in terrorizing their opposition with no cost to themselves. They regularly deface
00:03:08 public property, prevent others from assembling, shout, harass, scream obscenities, and generally
00:03:15 make a public nuisance of themselves and in return are treated with kid gloves by campus
00:03:21 security and university leaders who dare not even condemn their uncivil and often illegal
00:03:29 behaviour. Their play-acting vulnerability in order to bully others with impunity, the
00:03:36 whole charade fuelled by the ecstasy of their self-righteousness. And they are following
00:03:43 a time-honoured script authored by that guru of the Frankfurt School, Herbert Marcuse,
00:03:52 whose essay, Repressive Tolerance, should be required reading for anyone attempting
00:03:57 to understand campus politics today.
00:04:01 What campus feminists and other radicals learned from Marcuse was to pay lip service
00:04:07 to tolerance – tolerance for the oppressed, that is – while working actively to make
00:04:13 sure that their ideological opponents are not tolerated at all.
00:04:20 And this makes sense, after all.
00:04:22 If you believe that you have the absolute truth and that your enemies are completely
00:04:26 wrong and that you live in a society of massive injustice, well, in that case, there's no
00:04:33 good in tolerating error.
00:04:37 It merely leads to more error and more mass injustice.
00:04:42 The enemies must be liberated from their error and their damaging preconceptions.
00:04:49 The damaging ideas need to be wiped out.
00:04:52 Thus, it doesn't help to point out to these radicals that they are inhibiting freedom
00:04:57 of expression.
00:04:58 You see, they don't care, because freedom of expression is not a good for the feminists
00:05:04 and their cultural Marxist allies.
00:05:06 Power is the good when it is in their hands,
00:05:10 the power to suppress wrong ideas
00:05:13 and to re-educate the masses.
00:05:17 We invited you to educate yourself.
00:05:19 Yeah, so I just wanted to listen to him.
00:05:21 I just wanted to see what this guy is
00:05:22 and what he's talking about, but now I can't get him.
00:05:25 Two of my friends committed suicide
00:05:27 and I want the peace of understanding why that happened.
00:05:30 What I have to ask on that, and I'll ask you,
00:05:32 is why this space to talk about that they're like feminism for example offers lots of spaces to talk
00:05:38 about mental health issues talk about depression both in men women and people who don't identify
00:05:41 within the binary it's not particularly shocking that young people revolutionary students get a big
00:05:50 rush out of censoring others most of us would agree that there is in many of us that totalitarian
00:05:58 desire to outlaw those we don't like. The mature among us recognize that it's a desire that should
00:06:05 be resisted. That Puritan longing to burn heretics has always been most evident in the young.
00:06:15 But what about the university administrators? Why can't they stand up to students, the student
00:06:23 thought police and say to them, this campus is not about safety, it's about learning. Deal with
00:06:31 your issues elsewhere and come here ready to engage in intellectual combat. They should,
00:06:38 but they can't. They can't because many of them are, it has to be said, moral cowards and because
00:06:45 at some level they believe in the students' rhetoric about social justice. Many of them
00:06:51 were once campus radicals or at least admirers of campus radicals and they know that a significant
00:06:58 number of their colleagues are hip young progressivists or aging hippies many of whom
00:07:04 find in social justice ideology a far more comforting source of meaning in their lives than
00:07:12 their traditional disciplines offer them the administrators may not feel strongly about the
00:07:19 particular issue riling the students whether it's transgender washroom rights or affirmative
00:07:25 consent policies to prevent rape but they are committed to the talk of safety for the marginalized
00:07:35 far more unfortunately than to the pursuit of knowledge and herein lies the real source
00:07:43 of our malaise the widespread collapse of commitment to the disinterested pursuit of
00:07:50 knowledge just isn't sexy anymore very few academics even believe in such a thing
00:07:57 so-called knowledge is just power being expressed and it's hard to keep on believing in knowledge
00:08:04 in the face of such compelling abstractions as anti-racism or empowerment of sexual minorities
00:08:10 who could oppose those in favour of cold facts. Ultimately, of course, every politically correct
00:08:19 safe space will be found to be not safe enough, requiring yet another round of show trials,
00:08:27 tearful apologies, and expulsions from the community of the just. And in the end,
00:08:34 one can only hope it will ultimately become clear that safety can never be built on ignorance and
00:08:42 lies until then those of us who care about the core mission of the university can only watch
00:08:49 its slow-motion collapse with horrified disbelief.