The Fiamengo File - September 17, 2015


The Monstrous Male Gaze - Fiamengo File Episode 6

The Safe Space Ploy – Fiamengo File Episode 5 The University of Toronto, a Feminist Campus - Fiamengo File Episode 7

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

135.97

Word count

1,628

Sentence count

57


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:19 My theme today is the monstrous male gaze.
00:00:23 Stories about the varieties of female violation by that monster man are getting more bizarre
00:00:28 by the day if you're a man commenting on any aspect of a woman's physical appearance speaking
00:00:35 in the wrong tone of voice or brushing against her body all these now rank up there with sexual
00:00:41 assault in the wide spectrum of indignities and outrages that women want men punished for
00:00:49 it really is the case is my friend observing libertarian put it in a recent article the men
00:00:55 can't even look at a woman anymore without it potentially being felt as a sexual assault.
00:01:01 University sexual assault policies frequently define harassment to include nearly any action
00:01:06 known to man. The Ohio State University harassment policy includes staring along with patting and
00:01:16 hugging as offensive actions that can get a man disciplined for sexual harassment.
00:01:23 Yes, you heard that right, staring. We might ask, well, how would the woman know that he was
00:01:30 staring and not just glancing? And how would the woman know he was staring with sexually
00:01:36 predatory intent rather than just trying to figure out whether she was someone he'd known
00:01:40 in high school? The woman's feelings determine all according to received wisdom, and thus there
00:01:48 is no defense the man can make. Recently, Charlotte Proudman, a British lawyer, made
00:01:54 news over her outrage when another lawyer, Alexander Carter Silk, told her that her photo
00:02:00 on LinkedIn was stunning.
00:02:05 You definitely win the prize for the best LinkedIn picture I've ever seen, the man
00:02:09 wrote. Gee, what an outrageously perverted thing to say. Proudman went on the offensive
00:02:16 immediately, refusing to accept Carter Silk's apology and tweeting about his transgression
00:02:23 in so objectifying her. She went as far as to say that his comment constituted sexual
00:02:29 discrimination, though she herself, as it later emerged, has often commented on men's and women's
00:02:36 looks on Facebook, sometimes in the exact same language that Carter Silk used. But, of course,
00:02:43 she's a woman and therefore she cannot, according to the feminist definition, be a sexual predator.
00:02:50 Note to men, by the way, don't apologize in these cases even if you do feel sorry for what
00:02:57 you said or done. It doesn't help you, and in fact it makes things worse for you because it
00:03:03 is perceived as an admission of guilt and it encourages the feminastes to continue persecuting
00:03:10 you and emboldened and confirmed to go after other victims a couple of months ago a similar outrage
00:03:17 over almost nothing gave me reason to reflect on feminist objections to the most trivial male
00:03:23 actions a headline on canada's state-funded online news source the cbc caught my eye women sound the
00:03:32 alarm about Pickup Artist on YouTube site. The story reports on a number of women very upset
00:03:40 over encounters they have had with a man identified as Luke Howard, who approaches women on the street
00:03:46 in Ottawa, engages them in conversation, and then asks for their phone numbers.
00:03:51 As the women discovered later, Howard filmed the encounters with a tiny camera positioned in his
00:03:57 eyeglasses and then posted them on YouTube as examples of pickup techniques men can use to
00:04:03 meet women. The idea, he claimed, was to prove that it's not scary to talk to women. Well,
00:04:11 he couldn't be more wrong. As it turned out, it's very scary indeed for the man because you could
00:04:16 end up with the police knocking on your door to inquire about your predatory and sexist behavior.
00:04:22 I should say about this man's filming of the women without their knowledge that his actions
00:04:27 are, in my opinion, unethical. But worthy of jail time or an inflammatory newspaper report,
00:04:34 I don't think so. He approaches women on public thoroughfares in broad daylight.
00:04:40 They're free to walk away at any time. Nothing he says to them is the least bit threatening.
00:04:46 But judging from the chorus of outrage in the comments after the story from both men and women,
00:04:53 many find him worthy of the harshest opprobrium.
00:04:57 The question of men's advances and women's vulnerability has been with us forever.
00:05:03 In Victorian times, a man couldn't begin speaking to a woman without a formal introduction,
00:05:09 and there were strict rules of etiquette governing what questions he could ask her,
00:05:13 even whether he could call her by her first name, and there were strict
00:05:16 community punishments for violating the rules. Perhaps the Victorians understood more about
00:05:24 male-female relations than modern feminists do. After all, if there is no difference between men
00:05:31 and women, as the feminists tell us, then why are so many women unable to tolerate a look,
00:05:36 a compliment, an observation, even a certain tone of voice? Yes, I know the feminist response. It's
00:05:44 because we live in a male-dominated culture in which men use rape and the threat of rape to
00:05:49 control women, and even men who do not rape draw a threatening power from that reality.
00:05:55 Well, the statistics on rape do not bear out that claim, and even if rape were more prevalent than
00:06:03 it is, there is or should be a world of difference between a sexual assault and a compliment or an
00:06:11 admiring glance. What is new about all this fuss and worry is the near-absolute credulity of the
00:06:20 mainstream press and workplace bosses and university leaders about the sexual threat
00:06:26 involved in seemingly non-threatening actions, and the idea that legal punishment
00:06:33 or institutional discipline are necessary responses to female claims of emotional discomfort.
00:06:40 How did we become a society in which a disciplinary tribunal is convened whenever a woman says she
00:06:46 feels creepy? Part of what is going on is the mainstreaming of radical feminist theory,
00:06:53 which was first disseminated in elite academic circles, then spread to the front lines of
00:06:59 feminist activism, and finally found its way into police stations, law courts, and the media.
00:07:05 Anyone who studied feminist theory at graduate school from the 1980s onward read or at least
00:07:13 heard of film theorist Laura Mulvey on the male gaze. This was the idea that in film the normative
00:07:23 viewer and all the relations of looking are implicitly male. The camera eye is symbolically
00:07:30 male and to understand the intended meaning of the film one has to adopt a masculine position
00:07:38 this theory was then extended to other art forms and eventually to culture at large becoming a
00:07:43 foundational idea of feminist theory that all the major institutions of our society are organized
00:07:50 to reflect and perpetuate a male view of the world a world in which men look at women and act on
00:07:58 women and women are passive objects the male gaze then became a shorthand for a technology of power
00:08:06 to consolidate male dominance now whether that was ever true or not it was a satisfying and memorable
00:08:13 way of explaining social relations the feminist assertion became that the male gaze had to be
00:08:20 disrupted. The power to look and to define what one sees had to be taken away from men.
00:08:29 Feminists would never, of course, have admitted that what they wanted was to substitute a female
00:08:34 gaze for the male gaze. No, of course not. That would be to admit wanting power. Instead, they
00:08:40 said they wanted a multitude of ways of looking and ways of returning the gaze, a heterogeneous
00:08:47 and polymorphous exchange of glances, both literally and metaphorically.
00:08:54 In reality, though, having already defined the male gaze as sexually predatory, demeaning,
00:09:00 objectifying, it was impossible to rehabilitate it. There just wasn't room in the feminist utopia
00:09:09 for male looking at all. And we see the results of the feminist discourse very clearly in the
00:09:15 case of our pickup artist and those who object to him whatever the man claims or thought he was
00:09:21 doing doesn't matter he can protest that he loves women all he likes his camera eye is seen as the
00:09:30 gaze of patriarchal power a violation and an assault he's a misogynist who thinks women exist
00:09:38 in public for his consumption one woman tweeted right on script predators are everywhere commented
00:09:46 another a true pig said another and so on the project that laura mulvey and her ilk began in
00:09:54 the 1970s has succeeded perhaps far beyond what the original proponents imagined this then is the
00:10:03 feminist utopia, a world in which men actually cannot look at women except under circumstances
00:10:10 determined by the women. If the men do look in a way the woman decides is unacceptable,
00:10:17 they can be subject to public disgrace, disciplinary proceedings, police visits,
00:10:22 even job loss. In the feminist utopia, women are the only ones allowed to look. In fact,
00:10:30 they are encouraged to look at men to judge their every move. The man has to get used to his every
00:10:36 move being assessed for its potential violation of feminist standards. Even when a woman is not
00:10:43 looking at a man, he knows she might be looking somewhere sometime. French theorist Michel Foucault
00:10:51 talked about the panopticon, a disciplinary regime in which prisoners are aware of themselves as
00:10:58 potentially watchable at all times and thus learn to discipline themselves to monitor their own
00:11:05 behavior and that's what the feminist regime wants to put in place for men the feminist panopticon
00:11:12 an awareness by men that doing pretty much anything a woman doesn't like can get them in serious
00:11:19 life-altering trouble such a situation is bound to make men feel wary uncomfortable uncertain
00:11:26 fearful, even paranoid, and that of course is precisely how feminists want them to feel.
00:11:32 The feminist gaze sees the world through a grotesquely distorted lens,
00:11:39 and the more we allow it to determine law or policies, the more repressive the impact will be.
00:11:56 You