The Fiamengo File - September 24, 2015


The University of Toronto, a Feminist Campus - Fiamengo File Episode 7

The Monstrous Male Gaze - Fiamengo File Episode 6 Feminism Wants Your Soul - The Fiamengo File, Episode 8

Episode Stats


Length

12 minutes

Words per minute

131.06

Word count

1,663

Sentence count

46


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiomingo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:20 My theme today is Feminist Rule on the University of Toronto campus, which was clearly demonstrated
00:00:26 this past week when the Canadian Association for Equality, CAFE for short, was forced to
00:00:32 move a scheduled talk by American journalist Cathy Young off campus.
00:00:38 Cathy Young, an equity feminist, is critical of the totalitarian element in feminism, its
00:00:45 inability to tolerate different points of view, to put it mildly, and its support for
00:00:50 policies that discriminate against men.
00:00:53 As such, Young is not popular amongst those who claim to speak for women.
00:01:00 In recent years, the feminist community at the University of Toronto has had a number
00:01:04 of PR missteps, as groups of frenzied, obscenity-screaming students have been caught on film, disrupting
00:01:12 cafe events and intimidating and harassing those attending.
00:01:17 We had the Warren Farrell talk, the Janice Fiamengo talk, the Paul Nathanson and Catherine
00:01:24 Young talk.
00:01:25 Accepting myself, these scholars are experts in the study of gender, extensively published
00:01:31 and accredited, yet treated as if they were leaders of the Hitler revival movement.
00:01:38 The feminists must have realized that despite the enormous and, in my opinion, undeserved
00:01:43 public sympathy their cause inspires they were beginning to look like the narcissistic bullies
00:01:50 and bigots that they are then an anonymous online threat was made against feminists at
00:01:56 the university of toronto on a public blog now whatever discomfort the threat may have engendered
00:02:03 and i can understand that it would cause some anxiety and fear many campus activists must
00:02:09 also have recognized a golden opportunity the chance to shut down the kathy young talk
00:02:16 all the while enjoying the righteous glow of their faux victimhood so they went into action right away
00:02:24 organizing a mass rally of students professors local politicians and union members in order to
00:02:31 declare that the university of toronto is a feminist campus where the supposedly rampant
00:02:37 misogyny of some backwards types, those who care about men's human rights,
00:02:43 must be stamped out once and for all.
00:03:00 Make no mistake, we need to regard this group as a very serious threat on our campus.
00:03:04 We just want everyone to know that we'll be here every fucking time they do an event.
00:03:12 We're going to do our own events to point out what's wrong with this group, why there are threats, why they shouldn't be allowed on this campus.
00:03:18 So thank you everyone who came out and we'll be doing more of this shit because they're not going to be gone.
00:03:24 It was a win for the feminists, with the upshot being that male and female students who are
00:03:41 interested in hearing Cathy Young speak on campus, which is precisely where talks like Young's should
00:03:47 be held, we'll have to go off campus to hear her. Now how exactly that diminishes the fear and
00:03:55 tension supposedly generated by Young's views isn't clear to me, but it takes the problem
00:04:01 out of the lap of the pusillanimous University of Toronto administration
00:04:06 and it showcases the might of the feminastes. But before I say a bit more about the shameful failure
00:04:14 of the university administration to protect what used to be the bedrock of university life
00:04:20 freedom of inquiry freedom of expression let me take a step back to consider the reaction by the
00:04:27 university of toronto campus community to another attack this time a real one on a university
00:04:35 professor just a year ago in september of 2014 a professor of mathematics named sean you paul was
00:04:45 attacked with a knife by one of his students receiving injuries to wrists thighs and face
00:04:52 requiring hospitalization now i didn't hear about this attack at the time and i'm guessing you may
00:04:59 not have either because the coverage was very low-key and the university response was muted.
00:05:05 There were no public statements, no mass outrage, and no rallies. In fact, reading the news reports,
00:05:12 one has to be alert to figure out that the person who attacked the professor was female,
00:05:18 a student named Xiaoyu Zhu from China. The headline in the CBC News report mentions only
00:05:25 that a gender-neutral math student attacked a gender-neutral professor with a knife.
00:05:32 As we've noted before, when men rather than women are the victims of violence,
00:05:36 their gender isn't news. Only female victims are news, and the only time femaleness is not news
00:05:45 is when the woman is the perpetrator of the violence, as in this case.
00:05:49 Never once in the article about the attack do the words female or woman appear at all. Only the
00:05:57 pesky pronouns give away the game when we are told that the accused is a 21-year-old international
00:06:04 student who is believed to be in her second year. It seems that this student had developed an
00:06:11 obsession with her professor after some kind of misunderstanding, and she began sending him
00:06:17 anonymous emails that were troubling enough to cause him to alert the university administration
00:06:21 and campus police in the days before she attacked him. The precise motive for the assault was never
00:06:28 revealed. Not surprisingly, this attack prompted no campus demonstrations by social justice activists,
00:06:37 no discussion of female violence, no calls for anti-violence training for women students,
00:06:44 no calls for increased protection for male students and teachers.
00:06:49 In reports on the crime, the event is portrayed as isolated and inexplicable.
00:06:56 The main focus of most of the reporting is the role that stress likely played in the student's
00:07:01 behaviour. Reporters even saw fit to comment on you Paul's behaviour as a teacher, whether he gave
00:07:08 tough exams, whether he was approachable or not, the implication being that there had to have been
00:07:13 something in Yu Paul's own actions that caused the, quote, allegedly unprovoked attack.
00:07:20 So widespread is the societal assumption that women do not attack men without reason.
00:07:28 Not a single commentator made any link between the attack and a climate of anti-male hostility
00:07:34 on campus, represented in conferences such as the Feminist Porn Conference in April of 2014,
00:07:41 for example, featuring keynote speaker Lisa Dugan, who has made a career lamenting the
00:07:47 quote, distinctly white male heterosexual form of American citizenship. Not a single commentator
00:07:54 made any link between the attack and the anti-male attitudes that are now a regular part of many
00:07:59 undergraduate programs at the University of Toronto, the reflexive belief that women are
00:08:05 good and innocent, while men are responsible for all the evil of the world.
00:08:10 Now I'm not saying they should have made such a link, I'm just pointing out that
00:08:14 they didn't for comparative purposes.
00:08:18 The seemingly immortal belief in female goodness may have played some role in the outpouring
00:08:23 of online support for the knife-wielding student who continues to this day after spending two
00:08:28 months in a mental facility and ten months in a correctional institute to manifest an
00:08:34 obsession with her former professor and a disturbing lack of remorse for what she did
00:08:42 how different the Saul Alinsky style capitalization on the anonymous threat
00:08:48 against feminists this past week in which all the stops have been pulled out and of course
00:08:54 a link drawn directly by feminist speakers at the rally to quote men's rights misogynists
00:09:00 on our campus. Indeed, feminists lost no time in attributing the online threat
00:09:07 to the, quote, vile and vicious misogyny of MRAs.
00:09:13 Of course, we don't actually know who made the threat—whether it was a male student
00:09:19 disgruntled with the nonsense that passes for knowledge being taught in the disciplines of
00:09:24 sociology and women's studies a genuine killer or a feminist attempting to whip up a frenzy of
00:09:32 victim claims let's not pretend that feminists don't post threats against feminists online to
00:09:39 serve their cause we know they do general threats like these are distressingly common in a time of
00:09:46 social media anonymity remember the kill all men hashtag so popular in the last year which
00:09:53 saw countless women tweeting out their conviction that reducing men to one in four of the population
00:09:59 would solve most of society's problems and defenders of such statements claiming that women
00:10:04 were merely voicing their justified anger about kill all men's happy contemplation of violence
00:10:12 against men nobody in any position of power took the threat seriously as salon magazine sagely
00:10:20 opined nobody really thinks a hashtag is a serious call to genocide unless of course the hashtag
00:10:30 targets women rather than men in the case of the post calling on students to shoot up feminist
00:10:37 professors the police stated that they failed to find a credible threat but nonetheless security
00:10:44 on the University of Toronto campus was stepped up as it should have been. And in a sane world,
00:10:52 that's all that could have been expected. A free society can never be an entirely secure society,
00:11:00 and it is ludicrous to pretend otherwise, as in the manner of the CUPE Union Women's Caucus
00:11:06 member who posted on Facebook, what if we all refused work until the world is safe for women?
00:11:14 Well, what if we all refused work until the world is safe for men?
00:11:19 Either way, nobody would be working any time soon.
00:11:23 Though if it comes to numbers, men are far more often the victims of violence than women.
00:11:28 Regardless, as we have seen, feminists went into an orgy of outrage and defiance over violence against women,
00:11:36 conveniently forgetting if they had ever known the actual violence Professor Sean Uphall experienced this time last year.
00:11:44 And the University of Toronto administration didn't have the integrity to make clear a
00:11:50 commitment to securing the campus for all so that Cathy Young's talk could go ahead
00:11:56 in an atmosphere befitting a university. That's what should have happened. A call for sanity,
00:12:03 a secure room provided where people would be invited to listen to Cathy Young and discuss
00:12:09 her ideas with the histrionics left for political rallies or the nursery room.
00:12:17 Yes, it seems the University of Toronto is indeed a feminist campus, and we're all the poorer for it.
00:12:39 You