The Fiamengo File - October 01, 2015


Feminism Wants Your Soul - The Fiamengo File, Episode 8

The University of Toronto, a Feminist Campus - Fiamengo File Episode 7 Kampus Kangaroo Kourt - The Fiamengo File Episode 9

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

130.57

Word count

1,350

Sentence count

44


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiomengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:23 A message to men on university campuses.
00:00:27 Feminism wants you.
00:00:29 wants you to think that it's your friend but it's not at first it will come on really sweet
00:00:36 it'll tell you that patriarchy hurts men too the gender roles under patriarchy are restrictive and
00:00:43 damaging and that feminism cares about men's issues it offers you peace a way out of the
00:00:52 constant blame you're not violent and hateful so why should you be lumped in with those other guys
00:00:58 who are violent and hateful. Feminism offers you redemption. Become a feminist and you won't be
00:01:17 accused anymore. In essence, it offers you a get out of masculinity free card. And it tells you
00:01:25 that you don't have to give up anything to be a feminist.
00:01:29 All you have to believe is what you already do,
00:01:32 that women are as fully human as you are and deserve a fair shake in life.
00:01:37 It's an offer you can't refuse.
00:01:41 But feminism lies, because that's not all it really asks of you.
00:01:47 It actually asks you to give up a lot.
00:01:50 fundamental rights and freedoms perhaps most especially equality before the law and freedom
00:01:56 of expression but even more than that it asks you to give up something immeasurably precious
00:02:06 your thinking and feeling self your integrity really your soul because it makes you lie
00:02:16 to yourself and others the prime example you have to say that you have privilege
00:02:23 an unfair advantage just because you're male.
00:02:53 I am a white, heterosexual male, so I personally feel that I enjoy a lot of the privilege that
00:03:00 a lot of people in this room, in this country, in this world do not.
00:03:02 I feel on a conscious and subconscious level that I have benefited from being a white male.
00:03:06 I'm white, I'm male, straight, I'm temporarily able-bodied, and I'm socially acceptable body size,
00:03:13 so I just like to check my privilege first.
00:03:15 And that means that all the achievements of men in the past and present are not really
00:03:23 legitimate and you can't take pride in them.
00:03:26 The amazing accomplishments in science and medicine, in engineering and astrophysics,
00:03:33 in political philosophy and technology, in painting, music, and literature, all those
00:03:40 things that male curiosity inspired, that male ingenuity created, that male dedication
00:03:46 and brilliance made possible.
00:03:49 You can't take pride in them because they weren't fairly earned.
00:03:53 Similarly, all the sacrifices men have made for women and children, the blood, sweat and
00:04:00 tears demanded by every society throughout human history, male deaths in war, debilitating
00:04:07 work, past and present, the acceptance of constant danger in police and firefighting
00:04:13 positions, for example, male overrepresentation in the most degrading and poorly remunerated
00:04:19 positions in our society, like garbage collection, for example. These are ignored or explained
00:04:26 away the fault of the patriarchy which feminists will somehow make all better, and they can
00:04:31 never be used to object to the primary article of faith of feminism that men
00:04:36 have privilege in this system. Even in cases where you can see that you
00:04:41 obviously don't have privilege in applying for positions that privilege
00:04:45 women applicants, in family court where men lose custody of their children, in
00:04:50 domestic abuse cases where the police always arrest the man even when he's the
00:04:55 one being abused, even with such cases you still have to keep repeating the male
00:05:00 privilege mantra and repeating that mantra is a hazard to your mental and
00:05:06 emotional health if you come to believe it it requires your shame as a man it
00:05:14 requires that your primary allegiance become anti-male and if you don't fully
00:05:21 believe it but you repeat it anyway for the good of women you might think or for
00:05:26 that peace that feminism offers, well, that destroys you, too, in a different way.
00:05:33 British writer Theodore Dalrymple has a brilliant insight about the purpose of propaganda,
00:05:40 whether communist or, in this case, feminist. The purpose of propaganda, he argues,
00:05:46 is, quote, not to persuade or convince, nor to inform, but to humiliate. And therefore,
00:05:54 But the less it corresponds to reality, the better.
00:05:57 When people are forced to remain silent, when they are being told the most obvious lies,
00:06:03 or even worse, when they are forced to repeat the lies themselves, they lose their self-respect,
00:06:10 their wholeness as human beings.
00:06:13 And that is what feminism does to the men it claims to welcome into its ranks.
00:06:21 A poignant case came across my desk a few months ago, news that yet another university
00:06:27 student union, in this case the University of Durham, has denied the right of male students
00:06:32 to form a campus club.
00:06:35 Discussions by men at universities about their experiences as men are verboten all across
00:06:40 the English-speaking world.
00:06:42 The details of this case are all too familiar to those of us who have watched these fascistic
00:06:48 student bodies deny club status to men's groups or men's centres. Recently here in Canada,
00:06:55 we've had cases at the University of Toronto, at Ryerson University, at Simon Fraser University,
00:07:02 an attempt narrowly defeated at Queen's University, just to name a few in the last two years.
00:07:08 In this case at Durham University in Durham, England, a young man named Adam Frost tried
00:07:14 to organize a Men's Issues Society after a friend of his committed suicide. He was trying
00:07:20 to understand what happened, and in researching male suicide he was horrified by the number of
00:07:26 young men who are killing themselves and by the paucity of resources to help them. So he thought
00:07:32 that the Durham Male Human Rights Society could advocate around issues that too often push men
00:07:38 to take their own lives. I don't want to belabor the obvious here, but it is really breathtaking
00:07:46 to try to wrap one's head around the craven indifference to male life that we see here on
00:07:53 the part of the student union. Imagine a reverse case of a young woman stunned by the death of
00:07:59 her female friend being told that a group to help other young women avoid suicide was
00:08:04 not something the Student Union could endorse. In this case, Big Sister Student Union disallowed
00:08:11 the club by saying that it could form, but only as a subsidiary branch of, get this, the Feminist
00:08:18 Society. Well, the Feminist Society's own charter states that it's not interested in catering to the
00:08:24 needs of men, but that was what the union decided would be appropriate for Adam Frost's club. Adam
00:08:31 Frost didn't think that was what he wanted. Well, in addition to everything else that is
00:08:36 poignant about this case, I was struck by Adam's clarification that he's not an enemy of feminism.
00:08:43 He said, I'm not interested in waging ideological war against feminism and want to distance myself
00:08:49 from those MRAs and misogynists who seem to spend a disproportionate amount of time bashing feminism.
00:08:58 he just wants to do something for men's mental health well adam you seem like a very nice and
00:09:04 smart fellow but on this one point you are naive and misinformed you may be uninterested in waging
00:09:12 ideological war against feminism but the fact is that feminism is already waging ideological war
00:09:18 against you you don't get to choose and the fact that you link men's rights activism with misogyny
00:09:25 and want to distance yourself from both shows how deeply enthralled to feminist ideology you already
00:09:31 are and how successfully it has invaded your mind what you may discover in time is that mras who
00:09:39 attack feminism are doing so not out of pointless churlishness but because they've come to understand
00:09:45 precisely what you don't want to admit that in order to pursue men's human rights it is necessary
00:09:52 to oppose an ideology that blames and marginalizes men, an ideology that couldn't care less
00:09:59 about male suicide and all the other issues you were denied the opportunity to address.
00:10:05 Welcome to the vicious world of feminist-dominated campus politics.
00:10:10 I wish Adam all the best and trust that he will learn that one of the first rules of effective
00:10:15 advocacy is know your enemy.