The Fiamengo File - October 08, 2015


Kampus Kangaroo Kourt - The Fiamengo File Episode 9

Feminism Wants Your Soul - The Fiamengo File, Episode 8 Masculinity Studies by Michael Kimmel - The Fiamengo File Episode 10

Episode Stats


Length

12 minutes

Words per minute

138.38

Word count

1,676

Sentence count

70


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:19 My message is for mothers of sons who are starting or returning to university classes
00:00:24 this month.
00:00:26 question. Is your son safe on campus? Do you know what kind of sexual assault
00:00:32 policy is in place at his school? Specifically, do you know what procedures
00:00:38 have been adopted for dealing with the complaint of rape or sexual harassment
00:00:42 against your son? Do these procedures include due process and the presumption
00:00:48 of innocence? Does it matter to you? For feminist mothers in particular, I would
00:00:53 ask, are you happy with the idea that your son could be found guilty of rape and expelled from
00:00:59 his school, according to the feminist doctrine that a woman's word is sufficient, that women
00:01:04 never lie about rape? The United States Department of Justice recently issued a press release
00:01:10 announcing funding in the amount of $8.5 million to reduce sexual assault, domestic violence,
00:01:17 dating violence, and stalking on college campuses. Here is part of what the press release states.
00:01:26 Recipients of the grant money are required to conduct mandatory prevention and education
00:01:31 programming for all incoming students and to train campus law enforcement and all members
00:01:37 of campus disciplinary boards to respond effectively. Campuses can use funds to develop
00:01:43 and adopt policies and protocols that prioritize victim safety and hold offenders accountable.
00:01:51 There's a list of schools at the bottom of the press release that have accepted the funding.
00:01:56 To be fair to the schools, it should be said that they're under intense pressure from the
00:02:01 government, as are universities in Canada, to institute such policies and procedures.
00:02:07 If they don't do so, they risk serious sanction. In other words, this is a mess that is not
00:02:13 necessarily of the university's own making, though it has certainly been
00:02:17 capitalized upon by feminist activists and their allies within the university
00:02:22 system. There are a couple of things to note about the press release. First, we
00:02:27 have the reference to mandatory prevention and education programming
00:02:31 for all incoming students. We've seen what that looks like already at
00:02:36 prestigious universities such as Columbia U, which has a mandatory sexual
00:02:41 respect and community citizenship initiative not only for incoming students but for all
00:02:47 undergrad and graduate students what are these prevention and education programs all about
00:02:54 well they all begin from the premise that rape rather than being a relatively rare crime carried
00:03:00 out by deviants and deplored by all right-thinking people is a widespread male behavior part of rape
00:03:07 culture. According to these programs, rape is the way men assert power over women in a society of
00:03:14 structural social inequality. Although not all men rape, all men benefit from rape, according to this
00:03:21 theory, by keeping women in a state of fear. The message of these sessions is that in any
00:03:28 sexual encounter the woman is a potential victim, even if she appears to give her consent. The man
00:03:36 always at least potentially guilty if she was drinking alcohol if she regrets the sexual
00:03:42 experience afterwards and even if she didn't enthusiastically consent at every stage
00:03:51 the message of such programs is that male sexuality is by definition linked to violence
00:03:57 and subjugation female sexuality in contrast is to be celebrated and protected
00:04:03 These programs are a powder keg of unproven assumptions,
00:04:08 victim fantasies, and blatant male vilification.
00:04:12 Perhaps your son is resilient enough to shrug off the flagrant bigotry
00:04:16 of such indoctrination sessions,
00:04:19 though the rising suicide rate and incidence of mental illness
00:04:23 amongst college-age men suggest that many are being adversely affected
00:04:28 by all this shaming and blaming.
00:04:31 But what happens if your son actually becomes a subject of a complaint to a university tribunal
00:04:37 on a charge of non-consensual sex? Here things become very Orwellian very fast.
00:04:46 Notice how the State Department describes the purpose of its policies and procedures,
00:04:52 which is to, quote, prioritize victim safety and hold offenders accountable.
00:04:57 Note that there is no presumption of innocence here. So if you thought impartial judgment,
00:05:04 the judicious weighing of evidence, or the protection of the rights of the accused would
00:05:08 matter to such university bodies, you would be wrong. This is an initiative of the Office of
00:05:15 Violence Against Women, after all, where women are assumed to be victims the moment they make
00:05:20 a complaint and where the men complain about must, by extension, be the offenders to be
00:05:26 held accountable. There is reference in the press release to be sure to training for those who will
00:05:32 make judgments affecting your son's standing at college. But this won't be legal training. These
00:05:39 people are not lawyers and they know nothing about how to investigate a criminal charge,
00:05:45 conduct interviews, weigh evidence, examine and cross-examine witnesses, and so on.
00:05:51 The emphasis is on prioritizing victim safety. In other words, the victim will not be rigorously
00:06:00 questioned, her version of events will not be cross-examined, and counter-evidence by the
00:06:06 accused will be regarded with suspicion or even ruled inadmissible. These disciplinary boards are
00:06:14 by definition on the side of the victim, not the accused, and as a result it can all too easily
00:06:21 happen that male students are found guilty with no evidence except the accuser's claim,
00:06:29 and frequently in the face of tangible evidence to the contrary.
00:06:35 In 2013, Judith Grossman, an American lawyer, published in the Wall Street Journal an account
00:06:42 of her son's ordeal at a small New England college. Grossman's son's experience is typical of what
00:06:48 happens to a young man under investigation. He had to appear before a campus tribunal with just
00:06:54 a couple of days notice and without precise details of the charges against him, based on
00:07:00 incidents that had occurred years earlier. He was denied the right to have a lawyer present and was
00:07:06 not allowed to bring counter evidence, details of the relationship, including emails and other
00:07:11 correspondence. He was not allowed to confront his accuser or the witnesses against him who
00:07:17 were friends of the accuser who corroborated her story. Fortunately, in his case, the charges were
00:07:24 dismissed, perhaps at least partially because as a lawyer Grossman was able to coach and assist her
00:07:29 son behind the scenes and to prepare his defense. I expect that she also brought some pressure to
00:07:35 bear on the university administrators. In her article, she recognizes the likelihood that other
00:07:41 young men, less fortunate without her son's support system, would have been found guilty under the
00:07:47 preponderance of evidence model in use by these tribunals. That means that guilt does not have to
00:07:54 be established beyond a shadow of doubt. The tribunal must simply find it more likely than
00:08:00 not that the alleged incident took place. It is staggering to consider how many men
00:08:06 have thus been found guilty of assault merely because it seemed likely. Some of these men
00:08:13 are now coming forward to clear their names, suing the universities for wrongdoing.
00:08:19 Grossman makes a point of stressing her feminist allegiance and how the experience has shaken her
00:08:24 confidence, she says. Until a month ago, I would have expressed unqualified support for Title IX
00:08:31 and for the Violence Against Women Act, but no longer. Well, frankly, I don't know where Grossman
00:08:38 has been living for the last few years, but never mind. It's too bad that it took a charge against
00:08:43 her own son to wake her up, a charge that might have resulted in his life being ruined because of
00:08:49 her misplaced confidence in the feminist movement but at least she's had the good sense to understand
00:08:55 why the new sexual misconduct policies are so egregious not only for her son but for other young
00:09:02 men equally or more vulnerable to a false charge grossman's article suggests the answer to the
00:09:08 question how could it happen that in a few short years such policies could go from being the
00:09:14 triumphalist fantasy of feminist ideologues to the sledgehammer reality of schools all
00:09:21 across North America. It happened because a lot of feminist moms supported Title IX
00:09:28 and its various equality provisions, never thinking about how, in a culture of man-blaming,
00:09:34 they could be so shockingly abused. Some mothers are now speaking out. A group called
00:09:41 Families Advocating for Campus Equality, a small group of California mothers has begun
00:09:47 distributing flyers to young men on campuses, warning them about the bizarre situation that
00:09:53 now exists. The flyers tell students, if she has touched alcohol, do not touch her. The flyers also
00:10:03 advise students to, quote, document and save her consent. Never delete email or text conversations.
00:10:11 Your college will treat you as guilty under current interpretations of federal Title IX, the Flyers state.
00:10:19 Students are advised to consult a lawyer as their school, quote,
00:10:23 will not help you prove your innocence. Prepare to fight for your future, they exhort.
00:10:30 One can only hope that the numbers of these concerned mothers will swell until university administrators can't afford to ignore them.
00:10:38 One can only hope that ashamed before the rising tide of outrage at the injustice being done to men on university campuses,
00:10:47 administrators and government officials will disband their disciplinary boards
00:10:52 and will rethink the whole manner in which claims of sexual assault are handled.
00:10:57 For those of you thinking about your daughters,
00:11:01 worried about the alcohol-fuelled hookup scene on so many university campuses,
00:11:07 Yes, that's a legitimate concern, but there is no security for young women in a biased
00:11:14 and slapdash disciplinary panel inclined to find men guilty.
00:11:20 If your daughter ends up ashamed and confused after one or more sexual encounters with boys
00:11:26 she barely knows, her humiliation and lostness will not be healed by making a false allegation
00:11:32 of rape.
00:11:34 We do young women no favors in encouraging them to take no care for their own sexual
00:11:40 well-being and then to betray others and themselves with self-justifying lies and fabricated innocence.
00:11:49 Ruining the lives of our young men will do nothing to redeem the sexual brokenness and
00:11:54 emotional sterility of our present cultural moment.
00:11:59 So come on moms, get ready to fight for your sons.
00:12:04 You