The Fiamengo File - October 15, 2015


Masculinity Studies by Michael Kimmel - The Fiamengo File Episode 10

Kampus Kangaroo Kourt - The Fiamengo File Episode 9 The Man-Shaming Project - The Fiamengo File Episode 11

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

119.35

Word count

1,222

Sentence count

48


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiomingo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:29 My theme today is masculinity studies, and my message to men and non-feminist women is
00:00:35 beware. Masculinity studies is almost always the study of men through a feminist lens,
00:00:42 and that's certain to involve an at best limited, at worst, deformed view of men.
00:00:48 The case of masculinity studies as it currently exists disproves the hope that so-called moderate
00:00:55 feminism is salvageable and can be made to accommodate men's issues the fact is that when
00:01:02 you start with false premises women's oppression under patriarchy gender as a social construct
00:01:09 you end up with a bad theory even when some of those working with the theory
00:01:15 have good intentions or at least think they have good intentions recently there was an article
00:01:22 in the new york times entitled a master's degree in dot dot dot masculinity it's a long article
00:01:30 fairly positive about the role of a professor named michael kimmel in the development of
00:01:36 masculinity studies kimmel is the author of among many other books manhood in america a cultural
00:01:45 History, Guy Land, The Perilous World Where Boys Become Men, and Angry White Men, the latter a book
00:01:55 in which he takes pains to disassociate himself from and belittle the men's rights movement.
00:02:02 Now, Kimmel is a superstar in the sphere of high-powered, socially acceptable discussions
00:02:08 of gender. He lectures all over the place, he liaises with government ministries, and he was
00:02:15 the first man to deliver the International Women's Day Lecture at the European Parliament.
00:02:21 He's beloved by big-time activists like Jane Fonda and Gloria Steinem, and when we read
00:02:28 about his version of masculinity studies, we can understand why.
00:02:33 What does it mean to be a man today, according to Michael Kimmel and his feminist friends?
00:02:39 Well, according to the New York Times article, men are in crisis, which is pretty strong language
00:02:46 and a marked contrast to the standard emphasis of feminists on male privilege. But unfortunately,
00:02:54 the list of what constitutes this crisis is not very helpful. Here it is, in part.
00:03:01 mental illness, suicide, terrorism, rape, mass shootings, jetliner crashes,
00:03:10 and young black men being killed by the police.
00:03:14 Well, that list really jumbles together a lot of different kinds of crisis, some of it,
00:03:20 terrorism, rape, and mass shootings, for example, focusing much more on men as perpetrators of
00:03:26 violence than as victims of structural social inequity. So we've got a big problem right there,
00:03:34 but at least the article and Kimmel's work seems to be addressing the fact that men have some
00:03:39 issues worth taking seriously. Unfortunately, the rest of the article makes it clear that
00:03:44 masculinity studies, as Michael Kimmel has developed it at Stony Brook University,
00:03:49 where he founded a centre for the study of men and masculinities, is really classic man-blaming
00:03:56 feminism but with a more exclusive focus on masculinity as a problem needing to be fixed.
00:04:03 Yes, the article actually comes out and says, presumably with Kimmel's endorsement,
00:04:09 that men are the source of most of the world's problems. Here's the quotation.
00:04:13 If we had a better understanding of men, scholars wonder, how many of the world's ills could
00:04:20 we solve, or at least attempt to?
00:04:24 Well, that quotation tells us probably all we need to know about these so-called studies.
00:04:30 But let's look at how it gets there.
00:04:33 The article begins with a cameo of a discussion about the differences between the phrase
00:04:38 good man and real man.
00:04:42 Kimmel gets some men and women together and asks them to tell what they think when they
00:04:46 hear those phrases, good man and real man. Not surprisingly, they have different associations
00:04:54 with these phrases, just as they would if the phrases were good woman and real woman.
00:05:00 The discussion leads Kimmel to proclaim that American men are confused about what it means
00:05:07 to be a man. Well, wait a minute. That's his big point? That American men are confused? Anyone
00:05:17 reading this who has heard for the past 40 years about the problems women face in our society—real,
00:05:23 objective problems like rape and sexual harassment and job discrimination and the wage gap—well,
00:05:30 they're likely going to think if that's men's biggest problem, they don't need a bunch of
00:05:34 university courses to help them with their confusion. It all seems trivial.
00:05:42 Then Gloria Steinem is quoted at the First International Conference on Men and Masculinities,
00:05:48 organized by Kimmel, and here's what she has to say about the study of masculinity. She says,
00:05:55 men's life expectancy increases by three to four years if you eliminate causes of death attributable
00:06:04 to masculinity, such as death from violence, death from speeding, and death from tension-related
00:06:13 diseases. What other movement can offer men three to four more years? She asks.
00:06:21 The quotation seems sympathetic at first, but on second thought we see that what she is saying is
00:06:28 that men are their own worst enemies. Masculinity equals violence. Masculinity equals stupidity in
00:06:35 cars. Even tension-related diseases are caused by masculinity, according to Steinem. The statement
00:06:44 about men's problems, then, is really a nasty slam at masculinity as the source of terminal
00:06:49 illnesses and violent death. And Michael Kimmel's own remarks constantly circle back to the problems
00:06:58 that men purportedly cause in our society, especially rape, rather than to the problems
00:07:05 that they face. In fact, rape as a problem of men that needs to be cured is mentioned no less than
00:07:13 four times in the article once as sexual assault and a great deal of the discussion about masculinity
00:07:21 places a high priority on men becoming more like the ideal partners fathers and political allies
00:07:27 that feminists have always said they need to be by for example taking their fair share in housework
00:07:34 and child rearing the closer we read the more it seems that Kimmel's whole message is that
00:07:40 The male failure to realize that feminism is good for men too is the main source of
00:07:46 men's problems today. The article has not a word to say about any of the structural
00:07:53 problems that men encounter in society. Their lack of equality before the law when it comes
00:07:59 to criminal sentencing, for example, the fact that men receive higher sentences for the exact same
00:08:04 crimes as women, the bias against men in family court, their lack of reproductive rights, the lack
00:08:12 of funding for research on male diseases, the lack of due process in cases of claimed rape and sexual
00:08:18 harassment, and so on. Michael Kimmel says not a word about any of these. He's too busy making nice
00:08:27 with his feminist colleagues and telling men that they're the problem? Well, if masculinity studies
00:08:35 won't look honestly and comprehensively at the systemic problems that men face, the problems
00:08:41 that men themselves are identifying as factors behind mental illness, incarceration rates,
00:08:47 and skyrocketing male suicide, and if it won't own up to the role of feminist thought and activism
00:08:54 in contributing to those problems, then I for one don't believe that it can be a positive force
00:09:00 in the analysis of men's lives. It's a funny kind of advocacy for men that tells men to get
00:09:07 with the feminist program and own up to their role as the source of world evil. And I would
00:09:14 counsel any man I know to avoid it like the plague.
00:09:44 Thank you.