The Fiamengo File - October 22, 2015


The Man-Shaming Project - The Fiamengo File Episode 11

Masculinity Studies by Michael Kimmel - The Fiamengo File Episode 10 Do Women Want Equality? -- The Fiamengo File Episode 12

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

143.77

Word count

1,993

Sentence count

71


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:18 My theme today is man-shaming.
00:00:21 I'm not the first person to notice that in the past couple of years we've been inundated
00:00:25 with videos and public service campaigns calling out men for unacceptable behaviour.
00:00:31 There's quite a substantial list of do-not-dos. Don't respond to a sexual invitation from a
00:00:37 drunken woman. Don't express any approval for a woman's looks by whistling or complimenting
00:00:43 her as she walks by. Don't even say hello to her on the street. Don't hug a co-worker,
00:00:49 touch her on the shoulder, stand too close or look at her too frequently.
00:00:54 and when you're sitting on the subway be sure to keep your knees pressed close together.
00:00:59 It seems that no matter how men express their heterosexual maleness there's a feminist
00:01:05 influence campaign to tell them it's wrong. Let me mention just a few.
00:01:11 Starting in 2013 there was a popular anti-rape poster campaign widely celebrated in the mainstream
00:01:18 media called Don't Be That Guy, designed by a coalition of women's groups in conjunction with
00:01:24 the RCMP, Canada's Federal Police Force. The posters show various scenarios in which sexual
00:01:31 assault can occur, with an unwavering focus on men's guilt and responsibility.
00:01:38 Just because you helped her home doesn't mean you can help yourself, crudely runs one of the
00:01:44 messages underneath an image of a drunken girl being assisted to a taxi by a guy one of the
00:01:51 images shows a woman passed out with a man standing over her reaching for his pants zipper
00:01:58 according to the website of one of the project partners the campaign pinpoints men's supposed
00:02:05 quote sense of entitlement in regards to sex and access to women's bodies
00:02:11 In other words, ordinary men are so morally deficient and callow that they don't realize
00:02:18 that an unconscious woman is not a sexual partner. Such men who use women as objects,
00:02:25 who don't care if they're unwilling or incapacitated, need to be lectured,
00:02:31 hectored, given a public dressing down, after which presumably they'll start treating women
00:02:37 with respect and love. It's a strange way to go about encouraging male tenderness, isn't it,
00:02:44 to insist on their stupidity and thuggishness. The fact that the RCMP, which is supposed to
00:02:52 impartially investigate charges of sexual assault, is involved in a campaign convinced of male
00:02:58 depravity is just one very worrisome aspect of this poster series. Moving now into the realm of
00:03:07 public theater we have also seen a variety of anti-cat-calling videos purporting to demonstrate
00:03:13 what a misogynistic environment sidewalks are for women. A number of these videos turned out to be
00:03:20 staged by actors rather than the candid windows onto reality they pretended to be, a fact that
00:03:26 has not lessened their popularity among those who believe in their deeper truth. In one Peruvian
00:03:32 video that went viral, street harassers are tricked into catcalling their own mothers,
00:03:37 who are done up in make-up and wig disguises. When their sons make sexual remarks, the angry
00:03:43 mamas reveal their true identities and berate their sons for their lack of respect. It's
00:03:49 all fake, but many viewers loved the message. If you wouldn't do it to your mother, why
00:03:55 would you do it to any other woman? It's a question with a very obvious answer. Men
00:04:00 tend to feel and express sexual interest in women who are not their mothers but this is a fact
00:04:06 seemingly lost on many of those applauding the video's don't you dare message in another video
00:04:13 a man possibly an actor with what sounds like a bronx accent and seemingly of italian heritage
00:04:19 is mocked during an interview for his neanderthal views on catcalling which he thinks is a way to
00:04:26 compliment women at one point viewers are invited to bellow with holier-than-thou laughter at his
00:04:32 admission that the sounds he makes to express his admiration are similar to the sounds he makes to
00:04:37 call his dog commentators on the video jubilate over the proof positive of his dehumanization of
00:04:44 women but it isn't proof i've been known to use the same terms of endearment and tone of voice
00:04:50 for my husband David and my two cats, Nandor and Stanislav, and that doesn't prevent me from
00:04:56 knowing the difference and treating each appropriately. David understands the difference
00:05:01 too. Another viral video showed a woman walking through the streets of New York City and being
00:05:07 catcalled 108 times over a period of 10 hours, edited down to a purportedly representative
00:05:14 two-minute clip. Frankly, I found the video revealing not for the horror of the male behavior,
00:05:21 but for the mildness of much of it, and this was the worst the videographer could find after 10
00:05:26 hours of filming. The video sparked acrimonious debate, not so much because the harassment did
00:05:33 not seem particularly heinous or even mildly unpleasant, including quite a few God bless yous,
00:05:39 hello beautifuls and how you doings. Rather there was acrimony because many of the so-called
00:05:45 harassers in the video were Latino or black men, prompting social justice critics, especially in
00:05:51 Slate magazine, to accuse the white videographer of editing out the white catcallers and forcing
00:05:57 his apologetic confirmation that yes, there were catcallers of all backgrounds. There are a lot
00:06:04 of problems with the politically correct script here. Whether catcalling might have significant
00:06:11 cultural components, whether a two-minute edited clip accurately conveys the average
00:06:16 female experience on New York streets, and whether harassment by white men is really
00:06:21 more worthy of condemnation than that by Latino and black men, these remain significant unanswered
00:06:27 questions once again it's the general idea that appeals men with power are oppressing women and
00:06:35 they need to be made to stop one article in the christian science monitor titled nyc candid cat
00:06:45 call video how can we make our son stop details in toe cringing detail how a mother who watched
00:06:52 the video, plans to start lecturing her son, who's not yet two, about objectifying women
00:06:59 so that when he attends preschool, he'll not go there with the thought in his head,
00:07:04 quote, that girls are there to be looked at. One can only imagine the confusion,
00:07:10 shame, and anger such lectures are likely to produce in the poor little guy.
00:07:16 Moving from videos to public service announcements, last winter we had the
00:07:20 anti-man-spreading campaign, which sought to discourage men from taking up too much space
00:07:25 on the subway by sitting with their knees apart. Dude, Stop the Spread posters were put up by the
00:07:32 Metropolitan Transportation Authority around New York City. No similar campaigns targeted women who
00:07:40 pile their packages around them, block exit ways with their baby carriages, or have gained so much
00:07:46 weight that they need two seats to accommodate their humongous thighs. Only the male sitting
00:07:51 habit was the focus.
00:07:53 And though a few commentators responded with appropriate ridicule, the fact that such campaigns
00:07:58 can be thought up and implemented in the first place tells us a great deal about the institutional
00:08:03 mindset of our culture and its enthusiasm for targeting one particular segment of North
00:08:10 American citizens.
00:08:12 Frankly, I find these campaigns more than just annoying or irritating or silly.
00:08:18 They're evidence of a deep cultural sickness, in my opinion. They seem to aim at nothing less
00:08:24 ultimately than the end of masculinity altogether, or certainly at the end of unselfconscious male
00:08:30 comfort in their own skins. Can women really find it so intolerable to sit next to a man with legs
00:08:37 akimbo or to hear an appreciative comment on the street or to take responsibility for their own
00:08:42 sexual behavior is this the world these women really want to live in where an appreciative
00:08:48 glance a wolf whistle a gesture of unconstrained masculine at easeness all disappear from the world
00:08:55 while the women themselves the slut walkers the we can dress however we like campaigners insist
00:09:01 on their right to skin-tight, boob-popping, ass-hugging provocation.
00:09:08 In my opinion, this movement to outlaw masculinity has very little to do with female safety and
00:09:13 a great deal to do with decades of feminist grievance-stoking and self-pity, culminating
00:09:19 in this multi-pronged institutional assault.
00:09:23 In 1988, feminist theorist Sandra Lee Bartke wrote an article about women's social position
00:09:30 using the ideas of French post-structuralist Michel Foucault to explain how it was that women
00:09:36 in the late 20th century West were technically free and yet still profoundly and seemingly
00:09:44 willingly constrained in a variety of ways, ranging from the way they moved and sat and
00:09:49 interacted with others, to their tendency to smile more than men, and to spend a great deal
00:09:55 of time and energy making their bodies conform to ideals of feminine beauty.
00:10:01 No matter who they were or what they did with their lives, they were always aware of themselves,
00:10:05 according to Bartke, as bodies on display. Foucault's theory, developed in his book Discipline
00:10:11 and Punish, was that modern regimes had moved away from what he called the power of the sovereign,
00:10:18 brute power, often haphazardly applied, to a far more subtle, widespread, and effective
00:10:24 micro-power that resulted in individuals who willingly monitored and disciplined themselves,
00:10:30 becoming what he called docile bodies. Though Foucault wasn't particularly interested in
00:10:36 women's experiences, Barthke saw his theory as particularly applicable to the modern woman whose
00:10:43 body became docile as a result of the micro-regulation of her gestures, her posture,
00:10:48 her movements, her facial expression, her tone of voice. What made women regulate themselves?
00:10:56 Well, nothing and everything, the whole culture. That's how modern power operates. Everything
00:11:03 about men, in contrast from the way they stood and positioned their bodies to their assertive,
00:11:08 unconstrained behaviour in public spaces, bespoke their less regulated, gendered selves.
00:11:15 and Bartke didn't like that. Bartke's is an entirely social constructivist view of womanhood.
00:11:23 She never considers that there might be biological dimensions to differences in female behaviour and
00:11:29 psychology. And the feminist movement has taken a strictly constructivist approach to social
00:11:36 change over the years. And what that change has amounted to is a deliberate, institutionally
00:11:41 enforced reversal of sex roles following Bartke's list of grievances almost to a tee such that now
00:11:50 it's men who experience greater and greater restrictions on what they can say and do while
00:11:56 women demand and achieve ever greater freedoms without consequences in dress and behaviour.
00:12:03 Some men, of course, continue to get a pass on traditionally masculine behaviour
00:12:07 if they are approved by women or are beyond the reach of their enforcement mechanisms.
00:12:13 But a majority of men experience a steady erosion of their autonomy and freedom,
00:12:19 such that they're not even sure now whether it's okay to touch a co-worker on the shoulder
00:12:23 or give her a compliment, let alone ask her out on a date.
00:12:27 And they'd better keep their knees together.
00:12:30 Why do men go along with this?
00:12:33 I'm sure there are a variety of reasons.
00:12:35 because they love women and want to please them, because the demands come as appeals to equality
00:12:41 and justice, perhaps because they just don't know how to begin to oppose such a multifaceted
00:12:48 societal program of stigmatization. If you speak out against any of it, your resistance becomes
00:12:55 proof that you're a rape apologist scum or something like that. I myself am dumbfounded by
00:13:02 the increasing inhumanity of feminist claims and by the seemingly widespread public acquiescence to
00:13:09 them. Can it really be the case that the majority of women want to live in a culture in which men
00:13:14 are cowed and marginalized, emasculated, and perpetually on the defensive? Is that a good
00:13:20 culture for women? Is it a culture that will thrive, that will procreate, that will raise
00:13:26 well-adjusted children that will work and build and invent and discover and heal and adapt and
00:13:33 prosper? I don't think so. It's a culture that leads women to fantasize about victimhood and men
00:13:40 to disengage from a world that constantly tells them they're no good. Let's get real. Most women
00:13:47 Men are not victims, and most men are good.