The Fiamengo File - October 29, 2015


Do Women Want Equality? -- The Fiamengo File Episode 12

The Man-Shaming Project - The Fiamengo File Episode 11 Women In The Military - The Fiamengo File Episode 13

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

138.73

Word count

1,831

Sentence count

75


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiamengo from the University of Ottawa.
00:00:20 My theme today is, do women want equality?
00:00:24 A few months ago, John Gormley, a men's rights activist in Ireland, asked his female
00:00:29 Facebook friends whether they want to be treated equally to men. A pretty interesting question if
00:00:35 one is honest in one's answer. And I'll tell you my answer in another video.
00:00:40 The question got me thinking about the way equality is evoked in both the men's rights
00:00:46 and feminist camps with both sides claiming it as their goal. Is it the case that the two sides
00:00:53 mean something different when they use the term? Is it even a useful word to describe an
00:00:59 achievable relation between men and women.
00:01:03 From what I have observed, women often claim they want to be treated equally based on a
00:01:08 perception that men are treated better than women.
00:01:13 This is the explicit or implicit assumption in nearly all feminist discourse that the
00:01:18 workplace and society in general is a fair and friendly place if you're male.
00:01:24 What women often mean when they talk about being treated equally then is that they want
00:01:28 be treated well. They want their good qualities recognized and rewarded, their bad qualities
00:01:35 overlooked or understood. With no standard of comparison, because most women don't know or
00:01:42 don't care to know the experience of men, many women perceive any form of unpleasantness in their
00:01:48 work lives as evidence of gender bias, whether it's a critical boss or a poor performance review.
00:01:56 And this is understandable. Most people, given the chance, will prefer to believe
00:02:01 themselves unfairly treated than to admit inadequacy. Add to that the feminist worldview
00:02:08 that male prejudice is the sea in which women are forced to swim, and you've got a lot of
00:02:13 women pumped up about injustice and keen for government to make more laws to combat it.
00:02:19 By the way, what I've always found notable is the manner in which our public discussions
00:02:25 focus on discriminations against women in the workplace and never about the bias that
00:02:32 works in women's favour. If we're going to talk about discrimination, an equally interesting
00:02:38 question is how many women have been unfairly advantaged because of their femaleness, especially
00:02:44 if they're nice-looking women. We've all heard about the sexual harassment that women
00:02:49 don't like but we hear nothing about the way sexual attractiveness advantages women getting them
00:02:56 extra assistance from co-workers special favors from their supervisors time off raises sales
00:03:03 contracts and so on i'd love a survey that questioned women and men about the instances
00:03:09 they've witnessed or experienced of a woman who rose through the ranks at her workplace because
00:03:15 she played on men's lust or chivalry. That's a form of inequality that most women keep quiet about,
00:03:23 just as you don't hear many women complaining about the inequality of hiring practices that
00:03:28 discriminate against men. In fact, many women insist on them. When feminists and the women
00:03:35 who support them use the word equality, they frequently refer to equality of result
00:03:41 rather than equality of opportunity with the claim made that because women are not equally
00:03:46 represented in certain prestigious fields of work they're never worrying of course about janitorial
00:03:53 services or ditch digging but because women aren't equally represented at the top that's
00:03:59 proof that women are being kept out of those top fields there's a lot of talk recently about the
00:04:05 STEM fields—science, technology, engineering, and math—a lot of worry about the under-representation
00:04:12 of women.
00:04:13 Now, even a moment's reflection should reveal that there are likely many reasons why women
00:04:18 are not working in particular fields or showing achievements equivalent to men, ranging from
00:04:24 the free choices they make to their actual capacities in these fields.
00:04:30 But the question of women's capacities has become a forbidden subject in polite society.
00:04:36 And that's really too bad because it means that a great deal of time, energy, and other
00:04:40 resources are being spent in potentially wasteful or even damaging ways, promoting women, formulating
00:04:48 policies to encourage them, and witch-hunting naysayers and truth-tellers.
00:04:55 Recently my attention was drawn by a feminist adversary to a report on a study that she
00:05:01 claimed proved that there is gender bias in STEM.
00:05:06 Now I'm not a social scientist, so I invite anyone listening to this to feel free to tell
00:05:12 me if my analysis of this outrageously weak study is off the mark.
00:05:18 So here goes.
00:05:20 in March 2015 in the Harvard Business Review, the report is titled, The Five Biases Pushing
00:05:29 Women Out of STEM, and it was sponsored by the Association for Women in Science. The
00:05:35 author is Joan Williams, who, with Kathryn Phillips and Erica Hall, set out to discover
00:05:40 whether women's numbers in STEM are low because of women's personal choices or because of
00:05:46 the gender and race biases that they face in science positions.
00:05:51 So they interviewed and surveyed hundreds of female scientists, and the results, they
00:05:56 claim, quote, provide an important picture of how gender bias plays out in everyday workplace
00:06:02 interactions.
00:06:04 It sounds like pretty serious stuff.
00:06:07 But it isn't.
00:06:08 It's a pathetic piece of propaganda masquerading as research.
00:06:13 First, a few words about studies sponsored by organizations with an agenda and authored
00:06:19 by researchers with an agenda.
00:06:22 They tend to produce unreliable results.
00:06:25 They ask questions designed to elicit the answers they are seeking.
00:06:31 If you go looking for stories of women facing what they perceive to be sexist discrimination,
00:06:36 the chances are very good, almost guaranteed in fact, especially in a culture that actively
00:06:41 encourages women to see sexist discrimination everywhere, chances are good you'll find it.
00:06:47 If the researchers had asked questions probing in a gender-neutral fashion how the respondents
00:06:52 had been mentored and assisted in their careers, they might have been able to present a very
00:06:58 different picture of science work. But that's not what these researchers sought out.
00:07:03 For the first area of bias, researchers asked women about how they felt treated in terms of
00:07:12 their competence and expertise. The result was pretty predictable.
00:07:19 Two-thirds of the women interviewed and two-thirds of the women surveyed reported having to prove
00:07:24 themselves over and over again. Their successes discounted, their expertise questioned.
00:07:30 People just assume you're not going to be able to cut it, was one representative comment.
00:07:37 Significantly, men were not asked about their experience, whether
00:07:41 their successes were discounted, their authority needing to be proved over and over again.
00:07:47 And that fact raises serious questions about the meaning of the women's responses.
00:07:52 Frankly, I'm a bit surprised that a far higher percentage of survey respondents
00:07:56 didn't report having their successes discounted, closer to 100%. And if men had been surveyed,
00:08:03 I would expect similarly high rates of complaint. Who hasn't felt, especially in a competitive,
00:08:10 high-achieving environment, that their successes were downplayed, that they had to prove themselves?
00:08:16 This is an aspect of the human condition, to feel neglected. It may well be that women,
00:08:22 for a variety of reasons are even more sensitive to it. But regardless of why women perceive that
00:08:29 they have to prove themselves, the perception is not proof of bias. Moreover, what can't be
00:08:36 factored into the survey is the all-important question of competence itself. Perhaps women
00:08:41 felt they had to prove themselves because they hadn't yet proved themselves. Perhaps their
00:08:47 authority and expertise were questioned because they deserved to be questioned.
00:08:52 In an era of widespread affirmative action hiring, in which universities and other institutions are
00:08:59 under intense pressure to hire women ,
00:09:05 it makes sense that at least some of the women hired are not top-notch. I know one is not
00:09:10 supposed to say that, but it is almost invariably true nonetheless.
00:09:17 The other categories of bias are equally, if not more, dubious. In the second, women
00:09:22 perceive that they must walk a tightrope between traditional feminine behaviour in some aspects
00:09:28 of their demeanour and masculine behaviour in others.
00:09:33 In the third category, women who have children perceive that the children were felt to be
00:09:37 a barrier to their professional commitment in the fourth category women perceived that other women
00:09:43 were mean to them presumably because of the sexism those other women had experienced
00:09:50 and in the fifth category many women especially women of color felt socially isolated
00:09:56 now i could go into a lot of detail about each of these presumed categories of bias but i'll merely
00:10:01 focus on one thing that stands out above all the others. Aside from the fact that there is no
00:10:08 comparative data on men's experiences, it is surely significant that there is no comparative
00:10:13 data for women in non-STEM occupations and fields. Would women in the social sciences,
00:10:20 in business, in the arts, in the helping professions, and in government offices
00:10:25 not also report perceptions of bias. What woman doesn't feel, to choose just one category, that
00:10:33 her commitments as a mother are sometimes or often in conflict or perceived to be in conflict with
00:10:39 her commitment to her profession? What woman doesn't sometimes feel that other women are
00:10:45 harder on her than male colleagues or bosses? An interesting issue, perhaps suggesting that
00:10:51 getting more women into such positions won't necessarily improve the experience of women,
00:10:56 but we won't go there. Do women not often feel pressured to accentuate their femininity? Do
00:11:03 women of colour not report social alienation in other fields? I strongly suspect that women
00:11:09 surveyed even in fields where they predominate would offer a similar assessment of bias given
00:11:15 that such bias is perceived to be rampant throughout our entire society. So why is it
00:11:21 that STEM fields continue to have low numbers of women while others do not? The matter of bias
00:11:27 cannot be the determining factor, as this researcher so definitively claims it is.
00:11:34 The whole exercise, in fact, looks more and more like one in which the conclusions were determined
00:11:40 long before the first female scientist began giving her predictable answers, designed to
00:11:46 call for yet more aggressive affirmative action hiring protocols that will likely result in
00:11:52 even more women feeling that their competence is often called into question.
00:11:57 Until we can be honest about women's choices, their work preferences, and their intellectual
00:12:04 capacity, we will continue to circle this issue of bias for many years to come.
00:12:10 For the feminist researchers and for the various diversity consultants and human resources advisors
00:12:15 who will be paid to study and make recommendations about increasing women's numbers in STEM,
00:12:22 this is a great blessing, but for the rest of us, it's pointless. Until we can admit that equality
00:12:29 of outcome is not necessarily a desirable or justly achievable goal yet another generation
00:12:37 of men will compete in unequal hiring competitions with women and yet another generation of women
00:12:43 will be encouraged to see themselves as victims of injustice even as they undertake careers for
00:12:49 which they may be unsuited or ill-qualified so let's do what we can to foster equality of access
00:12:57 and let the outcomes take care of themselves.