The Fiamengo File - November 05, 2015


Women In The Military - The Fiamengo File Episode 13

Do Women Want Equality? -- The Fiamengo File Episode 12 Great Men Under Siege - The Fiamengo File Episode 14

Episode Stats


Length

9 minutes

Words per minute

135.26

Word count

1,330

Sentence count

45


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:18 My theme today is, Can we be honest about inequality?
00:00:23 In last week's video, I mentioned John Gormley's question to his female Facebook friends,
00:00:28 women want to be treated equally and i noted that the question of women's capacities physical and
00:00:35 intellectual has become a forbidden subject in polite society today leading to much dishonesty
00:00:41 and double talk as i contemplated my answer to john's question i thought immediately of two
00:00:48 areas in which i could not be held to the same standard as men strength and physical courage
00:00:55 I'm long past the gym-going days, but when I did used to do weight training 15 years ago before I
00:01:01 realized it made me bulkier rather than trimmer, it didn't take acute powers of observation to
00:01:06 note that even men who are thinner and lighter than I were significantly stronger. Although
00:01:13 there are a few remarkably strong women, in general women are not as strong as men.
00:01:18 which leads the focus of my talk today women in traditionally all-male occupations particularly
00:01:25 the military over the past few years there's been a lot of talk in canada and the united
00:01:31 states about the position of women in the armed forces and it's one of the public conversations
00:01:39 in which the flagrant hypocrisy of mainstream feminist orthodoxy is starkly revealed two years
00:01:46 ago, the Canadian military was held up to much public scrutiny for failing to meet its gender
00:01:52 and race targets. Having tried and been unable to bring women to 25% of military personnel,
00:02:00 and worried that the Canadian Human Rights Commission might impose conditions on the
00:02:05 forces to meet these targets, the Defence Department requested of the Canadian government
00:02:10 that the gender target be reduced to 17.6% as a more manageable goal.
00:02:17 Well, the politically correct press immediately voiced an aggrieved protest.
00:02:23 The Huffington Post's Rachel DeCoste called the statement by the Canadian forces,
00:02:29 quote, a stunning admission of failure.
00:02:32 And she claimed, with a great sense of having clinched the argument,
00:02:36 that, quote, the Canadian forces are essentially giving up on including the majority of the people
00:02:42 they claim to be defending. Note the snideness of that phrase, claim to be defending, as if those
00:02:51 mostly rural and small-town white guys who have died in Afghanistan don't really deserve our
00:02:56 gratitude because not enough women like DeCoste have been encouraged to join up. DeCoste assumes
00:03:03 without any reasons that it is inarguably a good thing that a military force be representative of
00:03:10 the people it claims to be defending well i can maybe see that argument being applied only maybe
00:03:18 in a field like teaching where it may be good for kids other things being equal to have teachers who
00:03:24 are representative of the national population but in the military nonsense there are all sorts of
00:03:32 people who are not represented in the canadian military the very old children pregnant women
00:03:38 people with disabilities and a lot of wusses like me who literally can't bear the sight of blood
00:03:44 who couldn't carry a fallen soldier from the battlefield or engage with enemy combatants if
00:03:50 my life depended on it defending a population has nothing to do with representing that population
00:03:58 in the ranks and it would be disastrous if it did more on this later decost's bedrock assumption
00:04:07 like that of many other feminist commentators is that the canadian military is keeping a lot
00:04:12 of qualified and willing women out of its ranks mainly by its failure to clean up the supposedly
00:04:19 rampant problem of sexual harassment and abuse that makes the military so unwelcoming for women
00:04:26 Of course, these are the same people who claim that university campuses are insidious rape
00:04:31 cultures, and that sure isn't keeping female students away. The question of women's fitness
00:04:37 for the military is never raised by DeCoste, though from any logical point of view it would
00:04:43 seem unavoidable. Women comprise roughly 14% of the Canadian military, and of these only a very
00:04:51 small fraction are in combat roles. In other words, in the area that most fundamentally reflects the
00:04:59 Armed Forces' purpose to defend and protect Canadians, women account for only a tiny percentage.
00:05:07 A mere glance at the number of casualties in the Afghanistan conflict points up the reality of what
00:05:13 Lacoste and her feminist friends would call patriarchal privilege. Male deaths in combat
00:05:19 vastly outnumber those of women. Of the 158 soldiers who have been killed to date, only three
00:05:26 of them, or less than two percent, were female. So why are women so poorly represented on the front
00:05:33 lines? Because most women can't do the job, don't want to do the job, and in cases where they can
00:05:41 do it can't do it as well as men. In 2012, a Post media report tried to deny this fact, arguing that
00:05:50 Canadian women were taking an equal role in the Afghan conflict. The evidence brought forward
00:05:57 for this preposterous claim was the sad death of Captain Nicola Goddard, killed in a Taliban ambush,
00:06:05 the first Canadian female soldier killed in a combat role. Make no mistake, I honour Nicola
00:06:13 Goddard's sacrifice. She's a more courageous woman than I, and I admire her love for her country and
00:06:19 her incredible service. But it still has to be said, a woman getting killed on the battlefield
00:06:26 proves nothing about women's military ability overall, despite the exaggerated statement that,
00:06:33 quote, the Afghan mission proved once and for all that women can tackle any job as well as their
00:06:40 male counterparts. The article went on to admit that more military women than men suffer from
00:06:47 post-traumatic stress disorder and depression, but the author explained these away as owing to
00:06:54 the additional pressure women experienced in the military, quote, due to their minority status
00:07:01 and stereotyping. We're to believe that the stress of stereotyping is worse even than that
00:07:07 of being targeted by an enemy trying to kill you. Well, none of this was true, and a recent
00:07:15 American study has demonstrated a big disparity in women's and men's battlefield ability.
00:07:21 The U.S. Marine Corps examined over a year the impact of female integration on combat readiness
00:07:28 and found conclusively that women cannot match male performance.
00:07:34 Male units were faster, more effective, and able to evacuate casualties in less time.
00:07:40 Overall, the study concluded all male squads performed better than mixed groups in 69% of the tasks evaluated.
00:07:50 Women performed notably less well in their use of every individual weapon system,
00:07:56 And in addition, women had higher injury rates than men.
00:08:02 So in terms of women's own well-being as well as the overall effectiveness of the
00:08:06 fighting force, its ability to kill enemies, and save wounded comrades, the study showed
00:08:14 that the presence of women in combat units has a negative impact.
00:08:19 This isn't about an ideal of egalitarianism, a desire to have a military force that looks
00:08:26 like the wider population. This is the serious business of not putting military forces personnel
00:08:33 in harm's way. This is about winning rather than losing wars. The fact that ability isn't the first
00:08:42 thing everybody mentions when discussing women in the armed forces demonstrates how deeply the rot
00:08:48 of feminist egalitarianism has eaten into the fabric of our society.
00:08:55 I, for one, don't want to live in an egalitarian society. I want to live in a merit-based society.
00:09:03 I want exceptional women to have the chance to succeed, to contribute their gifts. But I do not
00:09:10 want a fake equality established by government dictate. And I'm tired of hearing from women and
00:09:17 their feminist allies about how we have to do more to make sure women succeed.
00:09:24 Men have always paid the bigger price and contributed more as a class to the protection
00:09:30 and technological development of civilization than women. And in the tolerant, humane society
00:09:37 we created in the West, men often allowed women to forget that fact.
00:09:42 It is appropriate and just for women to remember it.