The Fiamengo File - November 12, 2015


Great Men Under Siege - The Fiamengo File Episode 14

Women In The Military - The Fiamengo File Episode 13 International Men's Day 2015 - The Fiamengo File Episode 15

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

129.04

Word count

1,849

Sentence count

59


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. My theme today is the bizarre phenomenon we are
00:00:20 witnessing in which feminist activists mount hugely successful campaigns to belittle and ruin
00:00:27 great men of our time. Many of you will remember the case of Larry Summers,
00:00:33 respected economist, former United States Treasury Secretary, and President of Harvard University,
00:00:40 who in 2006 found himself forced to resign his post as Harvard's President,
00:00:45 not because he misappropriated research funds or lied on his curriculum vitae,
00:00:52 or made a mess of academic program reform, but essentially because he made some politically
00:00:58 incorrect remarks about there being more male geniuses in mathematics than female ones.
00:01:05 He thus set off a firestorm that even repeated apologies and offers of restitution would not
00:01:12 lessen. As I've noted before to those under SJW attack, apologizing never helps.
00:01:19 What exactly had Summers said? Well, he referred to the, quote, difference in the standard deviation
00:01:28 and variability of male and female mathematical intelligence. Summers did not say that men were
00:01:36 generally better than women at math. In fact, he said the opposite. But he said that at the genius
00:01:42 level, there were more men than women. Both the course of history and the results of IQ tests
00:01:49 provide evidence for his statements, which in no way claimed that women cannot or should not work
00:01:55 in STEM, but that perhaps strenuous government-led efforts to equalize female and male numbers
00:02:02 are misguided. Was he incontrovertibly correct? Do IQ tests provide proof of innate intelligence?
00:02:11 Are IQ scores really an ironclad indicator of who can succeed in math and related fields?
00:02:18 These are fascinating questions worth debating, but Summers' fellow academics and the general
00:02:25 media were not the least bit interested in debate or the pursuit of truth. Instead,
00:02:30 it was quickly agreed almost universally that Larry Summers was a sexist pig who thought women
00:02:36 couldn't do math, and ultimately the axe had to fall. Summers surely was not the first such case
00:02:44 of an accomplished and seemingly powerful man drummed out of his position because of
00:02:50 one, in this case, good faith bit of commentary. But his was a very public takedown, and I see his
00:02:57 disgrace a decade ago as the beginning of what has become standard practice in a movement to
00:03:02 put men on permanent notice. No matter how seemingly impeccable their credentials and
00:03:09 status they hold their positions on the sufferance of the feminasty class all it takes to lose
00:03:17 everything is one transgression no matter how trivial and unintentional and no matter how
00:03:23 abjectly repented according to the priestesses of the new religion of our times for even one
00:03:30 small sin depending on who you are of course there is no forgiveness at least with summers
00:03:37 one could understand the fuss the man made a comment about the capacity for genius that he
00:03:43 knew was going to ruffle feathers he made provocative statements without it seems
00:03:48 the intellectual agility or fortitude to pull it off in the 2014 case of the astrophysicist matt
00:03:57 taylor part of the european space agency team that sent a tiny probe four billion miles through
00:04:04 space to land on a comet in that case the outpouring of twitter abuse and anger and feminine
00:04:11 self-pity bore absolutely no relation to any reality matt taylor is by all accounts a classic
00:04:19 man genius incredibly high achieving and somewhat reality challenged like many crazily talented
00:04:27 science nerds he has some of the qualities of an overgrown adolescent with all his mental energy
00:04:33 seemingly focused on that thing that he can really do well cut the man some slack yet he found
00:04:41 himself in the doghouse after he donned a hawaii shirt a female friend had made for him with
00:04:47 images of scantily clad computer game style beauties and what happened after he appeared on
00:04:54 camera wearing that shirt to discuss the achievement of his team was true biopolitical
00:05:00 witch-hunting madness, a deluge of resentment and imbecilic hurt feelings that beggars belief.
00:05:10 Many of the complainants charged that the shirt was a symbol of the purportedly ever-present
00:05:15 sexism keeping women out of science, and as the angry tweets increased in volume and hysterical
00:05:22 conviction, Taylor's supposed sexist insensitivity was made to totally blot out
00:05:29 his achievements in astrophysics. The tone-deaf outrage was perfectly expressed
00:05:35 in a headline in the magazine Verge that at first I took for satire thanks to its absurd moral
00:05:42 equivalency making. I don't care if you landed a spacecraft on a comet, ran the headline,
00:05:49 your shirt is sexist and ostracizing. I couldn't believe it wasn't a joke.
00:05:55 The subheading drove the point home with histrionic emphasis.
00:06:01 That's one small step for man, three steps back for humankind.
00:06:07 Even after Taylor issued a tearfully contrite apology, have I mentioned that apologies don't
00:06:14 help? Even after this genius at the time of his incredible triumph was reduced to a groveling
00:06:21 admission of his big mistake, the gender justice warriors were not satisfied, criticizing the
00:06:28 European Space Agency itself for allowing Taylor to wear a shirt that, quote, demeaned 50% of the
00:06:36 world's population. Likely, there were even calls for shirt police to be on hand from now on to
00:06:44 combat future sartorial microaggression witnessing the savaging of that goofy and super smart man
00:06:53 was sickening but at least matt taylor is still as i understand it doing his work having survived
00:07:01 his valley of humiliation the same cannot be said for nobel prize winning scientist sir timothy hunt
00:07:08 whose life will never be the same after he was forced to resign in June of 2015 from his honorary
00:07:15 position at the University College London and from the Royal Society Biological Sciences Awards
00:07:21 Committee. The 72-year-old Hunt's offence was about equivalent to Taylor's, a mild,
00:07:27 self-deprecating joke about his, quote, trouble with girls, made as a toast at a science journalist
00:07:35 conference luncheon after the joke about how he was always falling in love with girls or having
00:07:41 them fall in love with him in the lab and how they cried when criticized he went on to say
00:07:47 quote now seriously science needs women and you should do science despite all the obstacles
00:07:55 and despite monsters like me so it was actually kind of a feminist speech bowing to the woman
00:08:03 as victim theme and paying homage to women's putatively heroic contributions to science,
00:08:09 which are actually, let's admit it, in no way comparable to men's contributions.
00:08:13 But regardless, no amount of pro-woman rhetoric by Sir Tim could make up for that initial joke,
00:08:20 the reference to girls crying when they're criticized in the lab, which was quickly tweeted
00:08:25 across social media by one woman, Connie St. Louis, a City College London instructor,
00:08:31 with a puffed up cv about her achievements in journalism and a supersized sense of feminist rage
00:08:39 who disseminated a part of hunt's luncheon toast only a part the bad part as an example of
00:08:46 shocking misogyny befuddled and desperately sorry have i mentioned the uselessness of apologies
00:08:55 Hunt went like a lamb to the slaughter, prostrating himself abjectly before a
00:09:01 largely unsympathetic media and dutifully resigning from his post at University College London,
00:09:08 while a sanctimonious spokesperson for the college declared that its ultimate concern
00:09:14 was for gender equality and support for women in science.
00:09:18 The great goddess be praised. Women across the globe who had ever lit a Bunsen burner or poured
00:09:26 a beaker of chemical fluid took to Twitter to announce sarcastically that they had cried only
00:09:31 five times that day and had fallen in love only twice, thus showing what plucky spirits they were
00:09:38 and how wittily they did battle with the patriarchal likes of Sir Tim.
00:09:42 Amidst the sharpening of knives and the very loud patting of feminist backs, the actual
00:09:49 achievement of Sir Timothy was almost entirely lost.
00:09:53 So he won a Nobel Prize.
00:09:56 Pfeh.
00:09:57 Let's just consider it for a moment.
00:10:00 The 2001 Nobel Prize webpage explains the significance of Hunt's findings, pointing
00:10:06 out that his research was, quote, important in understanding how chromosomal instability
00:10:12 develops in cancer cells, and explaining that, quote, the findings may in the long term open
00:10:19 new principles for cancer therapy. Yes, it's that dramatic, that cliched. Tim Hunt has
00:10:28 made a significant contribution to the cure for cancer, but we don't want his kind around
00:10:34 our research labs. Hunt's discovery of how cell division is regulated is the kind of
00:10:41 once-in-a-lifetime achievement that all the affirmative action hiring and special scholarships
00:10:47 and tiptoeing around women's feelings cannot replicate. And in himself, Hunt is a supreme
00:10:54 example of the innovation, creative thinking and dedicated hard work that epitomizes Western
00:11:01 cultural progress advanced largely by men it must be said though with worthy contributions from a
00:11:08 number of women when a brilliant man's benefactions to the human race are outweighed by a simple
00:11:16 self-deprecating joke we are witnessing a powerfully malevolent force in ascendance so can
00:11:23 that force be countered can we change a cultural climate that sees individual men as disposable
00:11:31 while still demanding that men in general step up to provide cures for cancer and to help us understand the universe.
00:11:39 Here are my prescriptions for what they're worth, indebted to Vox Day's book, SJW's Always Lie.
00:11:49 First, good men and good women too have to stop apologizing for trivial or non-existent mistakes.
00:11:59 Don't accept the version of yourself that your neurotic and vindictive enemies foist upon you.
00:12:06 Don't think for a moment that these enemies who aim at your personal destruction can be appeased
00:12:12 or reasoned with. You don't have to feel ashamed because you spoke your mind or made a mild joke
00:12:18 or offended a bunch of humorless zealots. Laugh it off. Believe in yourself. There's no guarantee
00:12:25 that you won't be destroyed anyway, but at least you'll go down with dignity and your example may
00:12:31 inspire others. Second, don't resign under pressure. Get a lawyer, learn your rights. Don't sign any
00:12:40 confidentiality agreements that will force you to remain silent as your employer forces you out.
00:12:46 And don't expect that powerful companies or institutions or government bodies will act
00:12:51 fairly by you or will even care about your side of the story. Assume from the beginning that no one
00:12:58 in a position of power will step in to help you, so be prepared to help yourself and defend your
00:13:04 position and hold your head up high. Finally, if you witness a social media mobbing, don't sit back
00:13:12 and feel relief that it isn't you. If you're in a position to do so, in other words, if you have a
00:13:18 secure source of livelihood please get involved express your contempt for campaigns to destroy
00:13:25 good people over minor or non-existent transgressions show up the attack strategy for
00:13:32 the puerile and emotionally retarded revenge project that it is and defend merit wherever
00:13:39 you see it don't be cowed by the self-righteousness of the feminastes think for yourself and stop
00:13:47 being afraid. Ultimately, the future of our civilization depends upon protecting men like
00:13:54 Matt Taylor and Tim Hunt from the forces that would destroy us all.
00:14:17 You