The Fiamengo File - November 19, 2015


International Men's Day 2015 - The Fiamengo File Episode 15

Great Men Under Siege - The Fiamengo File Episode 14 Free Yoga, And Other Crimes - The Fiamengo File Episode 16

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

126.08

Word count

1,889

Sentence count

53


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Jazz Fiomingo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:19 My theme today is International Men's Day.
00:00:23 About a month ago, an article came out in the Guardian newspaper advocating the end of manhood.
00:00:29 it's another one of the purportedly progressive opinion pieces more and more common lately it
00:00:35 seems that have to be read two or three times to check that they aren't satire they're so
00:00:40 intellectually vacuous and dishonest in this case writer zach stafford alleges that it's quote
00:00:48 time to do away with the concept of manhood altogether because manhood according to
00:00:54 Stafford has produced only, quote, centuries of war, of pillaging, of violence. Men today commit
00:01:01 significantly more violent crime than women, Stafford alleges, and they, well, there wasn't
00:01:08 really much else to his article except that, according to one study, men show anger in the
00:01:13 workplace more than women and, you guessed it, take up too much space on the subway.
00:01:19 Stafford also asserted that there is an endless rape problem on college campuses because men
00:01:25 can't recognize women's humanity. One wonders, how did you get to be so sensitive, Zach?
00:01:31 The article is so foolish that it doesn't really deserve a serious response, except that it
00:01:38 represents a widespread mindset of our contemporary culture, that women have it so bad that men are
00:01:46 to blame for female suffering, and that we'd all be better off if manhood were jettisoned.
00:01:54 Actually, the exact reverse is true. Women as a class have it very good. Men as a class
00:02:02 deserve daily gratitude. And if we could put an end to manhood, by which I'm assuming
00:02:08 Stafford meant traditionally masculine traits such as risk-taking, competitiveness, physical
00:02:14 courage, problem-solving, rationality, self-reliance, daring, and curiosity, if we could put an
00:02:23 end to all that, we'd never cease regretting it.
00:02:26 So, let me suggest just a few ways that manhood so defined, far from being a problem we need
00:02:33 to fix, is a precious resource that we weaken at our collective peril.
00:02:39 Throughout human history, it is true that manhood has been associated with violence.
00:02:47 For millennia, our world was and still is to some extent an extremely dangerous place in which our
00:02:53 species would not have fared well if men had not been willing and able to kill. More remarkably
00:03:01 though, manhood has been distinctively associated with creation. While women contributed to humanity
00:03:09 by bearing and nurturing children, men created environments in which women and children could
00:03:16 survive and thrive. Men codified morality, created art, philosophy, and machines, and
00:03:24 developed ever more sophisticated systems of law and government. Perhaps because the
00:03:30 male role in procreation was invisible, men excelled at creating beauty in paintings by
00:03:37 such masters as Giotto, Cimabui, Leonardo, Michelangelo, Raphael, Caravaggio, Rembrandt,
00:03:44 Monet, and Van Gogh, in the musical masterpieces of Bach, Handel, Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven,
00:03:52 Chopin, Liszt, Verdi, Pacini, Rachmaninoff, Brahms, and Tchaikovsky, and in the literary
00:03:58 classics of Chaucer, Shakespeare, Milton, Swift, Wordsworth, Byron, Shelley, Blake, Dickens,
00:04:06 Tolstoy, Dostoevsky, Proust, Melville, and Hemingway. Astonishing works of intellectual
00:04:13 and spiritual exploration were produced by philosophers such as Plato, Aristotle,
00:04:19 Augustine, Aquinas, John Locke, David Hume, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Adam Smith,
00:04:26 René Descartes, and Immanuel Kant. There's no female list that could come anywhere near to
00:04:34 rivaling this canon of great artists and thinkers and these magnificent developments in creativity
00:04:41 and expression were accompanied by a flourishing of science-based achievements without which our
00:04:47 lives today would be almost unimaginably different from what they are nasty brutish and short as
00:04:54 Thomas Hobbes said and without which there could never have been any feminist movement at all
00:05:00 no freeing improvement in the lives of women to make it possible for women to challenge men
00:05:06 politically or artistically it has been men who sought to unlock the mysteries of the universe
00:05:12 and who found ways to transform the material world into marvelous life-saving inventions
00:05:19 observing the heavens and calculating the relation of planetary bodies nicholas copernicus propounded
00:05:25 the heliocentric universe the great galileo made a plethora of contributions to observational
00:05:31 astronomy and sir isaac newton formulated the laws of motion and universal gravitation
00:05:38 in the realms of medicine and technology men radically altered the culture edward jenner
00:05:45 discovered a vaccine for smallpox gregor mendel made paradigm altering discoveries in genetics
00:05:51 charles darwin shook the world with his theory of evolution louis pasteur discovered pasteurization
00:05:58 as well as life-saving vaccines thomas edison gave us the practical and inexpensive light bulb
00:06:05 alexander graham bell invented the telephone nicola tesla created the radio alexander fleming
00:06:11 discovered penicillin elihu thompson invented the electric welding process charles parson created
00:06:21 powered automobile engine, Giuliano Marconi brought us the wireless telegraph, Wilhelm
00:06:28 Röntgen devised x-rays, and Albert Einstein formulated the theory of relativity.
00:06:35 Feminists will say, well, those inventions and discoveries, and of course I've named only a
00:06:40 tiny, tiny fraction, were made at a time when women were kept out of the various fields of
00:06:46 scientific knowledge and endeavor. But male privilege certainly does not account for the fact
00:06:52 that it is to men that we owe pretty much entirely the present operation and maintenance
00:06:59 of the vast, intricate civilizational system men created. As Janet Bloomfield documented in a
00:07:07 brilliant 2013 article, thank you Janet, if men all decided to stay home for a day,
00:07:16 our whole society would become unlivable, almost immediately.
00:07:21 Using US Department of Labor statistics as evidence,
00:07:25 she shows that it is almost entirely men
00:07:28 who are the electrical engineers responsible
00:07:31 for our power grid.
00:07:33 It is men who are the electrical plant operators
00:07:36 who keep it running.
00:07:38 It is men who are the water treatment engineers
00:07:40 who make sure that drinkable water comes out of our taps
00:07:44 and that we can flush our toilets.
00:07:47 Men are the aircraft pilots and air traffic controllers
00:07:50 who make travel possible.
00:07:52 They are also the locomotive engineers
00:07:54 who keep the trains running.
00:07:57 Similarly, we owe our telecommunications system
00:08:00 almost entirely to men.
00:08:01 They are the computer systems designers and operators,
00:08:04 the telecommunications installers and repairers.
00:08:08 In addition, men are the air conditioning
00:08:10 and furnace mechanics, the designers, builders,
00:08:12 maintainers of all our household appliances and men are the workers in the entire production
00:08:19 transportation and materials moving occupations as bloomfield notes without men essentially quote
00:08:26 nothing would be built or extracted from the earth and quote nothing would be installed
00:08:33 maintained or repaired male privilege the feminists insist but it isn't so men are the
00:08:41 unsung heroes of our whole system of production distribution and maintenance they're the ones who
00:08:47 do the jobs nobody wants to do the jobs that no feminist laments over women's denied access
00:08:55 throughout history of course men have always been expected to sacrifice their bodies in labor
00:09:00 and to sacrifice their lives in war in return for the misery of most men's lives and their
00:09:06 expendability in their societies they got at least bare respect as men that's now gone men are no
00:09:14 longer respected as men but the reality of little regarded little notice male sacrifice continues
00:09:22 today it is men who do the most dangerous work the hardest dirtiest and least pleasant poorly paid
00:09:29 and most necessary work in the slaughterhouses and in the meat packing and meat preparation plants
00:09:37 in garbage disposal and processing in sewage systems maintenance and repair in recyclables
00:09:44 collection in janitorial work in road maintenance in roof repair and general building repair
00:09:51 in construction work and in the work of construction preparation on farms and in
00:09:56 commercial fishing and logging operations, in firefighting and security work, in technical
00:10:03 repair and maintenance of all sorts, in power plants, in food processing, in long-haul trucking,
00:10:10 in iron and steel work, and in mining. These jobs, which are often difficult and boring and painful,
00:10:18 and are often performed in inclement weather or uncomfortable conditions of noise, heat, muck,
00:10:24 and bad smells involve long hours close contact with heavy machinery and equipment and often
00:10:31 low wages very few women are able to do such work or care to do it and the fact that such almost
00:10:38 exclusively male work involves not surprisingly the highest injury and fatality rate in the north
00:10:44 american workforce is almost never discussed some privilege some power the men who do such work
00:10:52 deserve our respect and gratitude every day. The fact of the matter is that without male ingenuity,
00:10:59 male generosity, and male sacrifice throughout history and in daily life today, all our lives
00:11:06 would be vastly diminished, far poorer, far uglier, far more difficult, and far more dangerous.
00:11:15 Women expect men to go on doing what men have always done, maintaining our transportation
00:11:21 and communication systems protecting us against terrorism and social breakdown finding cures for
00:11:28 disease inventing new technologies building and monitoring our homes and the many products we use
00:11:35 in them making sure we have electricity running water and a functioning sewage system providing
00:11:41 us with an incredible array of foods to eat and technologies to store and prepare them
00:11:46 Increasingly, men's reward for all this is animosity and contempt, and calls for male
00:11:55 removal from the most pleasant and most rewarding jobs where women want to dominate.
00:12:02 This ignorant animus against men starts in the public schools and spreads through higher education,
00:12:10 the entertainment industry, the justice system, and the mass media widely colluded in by both men
00:12:16 and women. I sometimes think that we are in the grip of a mass cultural neurosis so blinding and
00:12:23 severe that only the complete destruction of our civilization will wake us to its dimensions.
00:12:30 There could be no more certain way to guarantee our doom than, as that jackass Zach Stafford
00:12:38 advocates to quote do away with manhood on the contrary we'd better start recognizing and
00:12:46 and applauding it.
00:12:47 After recording this episode,
00:13:17 I learned that at the University of York in England, an International Men's Day event has
00:13:22 been cancelled. Why? Because following an online statement by Adrian Lee, who serves on the
00:13:28 University's Equality and Diversity Committee, a group of feminist students and faculty took offense.
00:13:36 Lee had highlighted barriers to men's equality at the U of York in his statement,
00:13:41 and the students and faculty protested that that was misogynistic. They wrote an angry
00:13:46 group letter and the university quickly cancelled the event in response. That's right. Even on
00:13:53 International Men's Day, the one day out of the 365 when one would think that issues of men might
00:13:59 be honestly addressed, even on that day it is still forbidden to speak the truth.
00:14:06 So what do you call a mindset that holds to its own imaginary truth no matter the evidence to
00:14:12 the contrary? What do you call a mindset that viciously attacks anyone who points to that
00:14:18 evidence? What do you call a theory of the world that insists on male malice, no matter how much
00:14:25 fact-based analysis shows it just isn't the case? I was talking about this with a friend just the
00:14:31 other day and we agreed. You have to call it madness. And when it's a cultural madness so
00:14:38 widespread and with such far-reaching impacts, you wonder how long the culture can continue in
00:14:44 any semblance of health. I'm not optimistic, frankly, about our long-term prospects if we
00:14:50 keep on as we are. But for now, I want to personally thank men for doing what you do
00:14:56 and for being who you are.