The Fiamengo File - November 26, 2015


Free Yoga, And Other Crimes - The Fiamengo File Episode 16

International Men's Day 2015 - The Fiamengo File Episode 15 The Myth Of Sexual Harassment - The Fiamengo File Episode 17

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

120.96

Word count

1,376

Sentence count

46


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiomingo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:18 My theme today is Yoga Crime and Other Campus Unreason.
00:00:23 I wasn't surprised to learn a few days ago that the University of Ottawa has gained international
00:00:28 attention and a fair bit of laugh-out-loud derision over its admittedly tame version
00:00:34 of the holier-than-thou crusade that has been breaking out across North American university
00:00:39 campuses.
00:00:41 The issue, cultural sensitivity, the catch-all phrase designating white culture's purportedly
00:00:48 pressing need to rethink its arrogant abuse of non-Western peoples, practices, symbols
00:00:55 and belief systems.
00:00:57 In the Ottawa U case, staff at the Centre for Students with Disabilities, run by the
00:01:03 University of Ottawa Student Federation, decided to cancel a free yoga class that Jennifer
00:01:09 Scarfe had been offering since 2008 to anybody who wanted to take it.
00:01:15 Concerns were raised, according to the Student Federation president, over yoga's misuse
00:01:21 by Westerners who practice it in a way that fails to be sufficiently sensitive to its South Asian
00:01:27 cultural contexts. Scarfe, the young woman who has been offering the classes, protested and offered
00:01:35 accommodation in vain. The class could be called mindful stretching, she suggested. It wasn't really
00:01:43 about the teaching of sacred texts, it was about learning to move and breathe. Not good enough,
00:01:50 according to the Student Federation Politburo that oversees ideological purity on campus.
00:01:57 The risk of harm to non-white students from an improperly handled downward-facing dog
00:02:04 required the cancellation of the class while its procedures are reviewed.
00:02:13 So the University of Ottawa Student Federation is taking its place along with other communities
00:02:19 of the righteous in what at least one commentator has called the Jacobin phase of the moral fervor
00:02:26 sweeping college campuses over the past few months. The Jacobins, we recall, were the most
00:02:32 radical of the revolutionary groups who sought to implement the aims of the French Revolution,
00:02:37 no matter the bloody cost. So far, at least, the calls for administrators' heads that we've heard
00:02:44 this past month at Missouri University have been metaphorical rather than literal, but the climate
00:02:50 of allegation has been uncivil to say the least. It began with a number of claims of racism on
00:02:57 campus, and when the university administration failed to react as angry students dictated,
00:03:04 in other words, failed to issue appropriately abject admission of white privilege and failed to
00:03:11 institute far-reaching and costly racial reparations, the aggrieved students launched
00:03:19 a campaign of intimidation that involved the construction of a protesters camp, a hunger
00:03:26 strike by one student, a boycott by black members of the university football program,
00:03:32 the threat of a walkout by faculty in support of the rebels, and angry demands for the resignation
00:03:38 of university president tim wolf in response wolf did resign along with chancellor r bowen lofton
00:03:46 offering apologies self-blame and pious hopes for renewal at the height of the student protest a
00:03:54 university professor named melissa click was caught on film assaulting and calling for muscle
00:04:01 to remove a student journalist attempting to film the student activities you're not doing your job
00:04:07 It's our right to walk forward isn't it? I believe it's my right to walk forward.
00:04:14 Can I talk to you? No you need to get out. You need to get out. No I don't. You need to get out.
00:04:21 I actually don't. All right. Hey who wants to help me get this reporter out of here? I need some muscle
00:04:27 over here. Help me get him out. Click did issue an apology of sorts and resigned from an honorary
00:04:34 position, but though she had threatened a non-white student with physical violence,
00:04:40 there were no calls for her race-based self-castigation or dismissal.
00:04:47 Meanwhile, at Yale University across the country, accusations and intimidation followed an email
00:04:53 sent out by Yale lecturer Erica Christakis, who lives with her husband on campus and with him
00:05:00 overseas student residence life. Christakis wrote an email questioning the enforcement
00:05:06 of moral rectitude at Yale. She was referring to a university statement about offensive Halloween
00:05:13 costumes, such as feathered headdresses or turbans, which students were instructed
00:05:19 not to wear for fear of causing hurt. In her response, Christakis, mistakenly assuming that
00:05:26 there was any room for intellectual disagreement on the subject noted that quote American universities
00:05:32 which were once safe spaces for transgression quote have become places of censure and prohibition
00:05:41 that was enough to bring a deluge of censure and calls for her personal prohibition
00:05:48 in one scenario Christakis's husband Nicholas Christakis was filmed surrounded by a crowd of
00:05:55 students, one of whom berated him at length for his failure as headmaster. Between the shrieks
00:06:01 and curses, the student can be heard lecturing Christakis that it was his duty to create a safe
00:06:08 space, not an intellectual space. She screams at him that he's disgusting and she hopes he doesn't
00:06:14 sleep at night.
00:06:44 an intellectual fee it is not do you understand that it's about creating a home here you are not
00:06:51 doing that you're supposed to be our advocate you should not sleep at night we're out we are
00:06:57 disgusting so much for rational discourse at one of the top ivy league schools in america
00:07:06 now much has already been written about this latest stage of social justice totalitarianism
00:07:12 with its public shaming sessions and more than two minutes of hate. Here I will add just one item.
00:07:20 Those wishing to understand the theoretical source of the present outbreak may wish to
00:07:25 consult a book by Brazilian Paulo Freire titled Pedagogy of the Oppressed, which was first published
00:07:33 in Portuguese in 1968 and translated into English in 1970. Widely studied in teacher training
00:07:41 programs in North America, the book initiated what has come to be called critical pedagogy
00:07:48 and has had an enormous malign influence on schools and universities across the West.
00:07:54 In my opinion, it accounts in large measure for the willingness of so many faculty members and
00:08:00 administrators not only to placate, but even to cheer on and encourage student actions designed
00:08:07 to disrupt classes and create a climate of mob rule on campus. As its title suggests,
00:08:14 Pedagogy of the Oppressed claims to be a work about teaching, but it has almost nothing to
00:08:20 say about the issues one normally associates with classroom instruction, like course content,
00:08:26 methods, evaluation. Instead, it is a book about revolution, and its core argument is that the
00:08:33 people need above all to be made aware of their condition as the oppressed. According to Frere's
00:08:41 theory, traditional teaching which sees students as vessels to be filled with the oppressor's
00:08:47 knowledge merely reproduces relations of inequality. The
00:08:55 people don't really need to learn anything except the fact of their unjust subordination
00:09:01 and the anger and determination to smash it the role of the sympathetic teacher then is
00:09:07 to work with the people to foment revolutionary consciousness to do anything less is to be on the
00:09:14 side of the oppressor as frere famously summed it up quote no pedagogy which is truly liberating
00:09:23 can remain distant from the oppressed by treating them as unfortunates and by presenting for their
00:09:29 emulation models from among the oppressors. The oppressed must be their own example in the
00:09:36 struggle for their redemption. Thus, in the situation we are witnessing, and many more I
00:09:42 haven't mentioned, what appear to be time-wasting antics that distract from learning, what appear
00:09:50 to be counterproductive acts of insubordination and thuggishness on the part of students,
00:09:55 misguided and willfully distorting declarations by student leaders or craven gestures of
00:10:01 conciliation and anti-intellectual complicity on the part of teachers and administrators
00:10:07 all make sense in frarian terms as necessary resistance what we are witnessing on university
00:10:14 campuses across north america is not by accident or incidentally about the rejection of reason and of
00:10:21 the western intellectual inheritance its central object is to destroy the past and remake the
00:10:29 present through the practice of the raised fist ceaseless disruption unprovable claims of abuse
00:10:36 whimsical acts of repression like the cancelling of yoga grandstanding incivility threats name
00:10:43 calling persecution white self-hatred and groupthink and all of it applauded and catered to
00:10:50 too, by the intellectual elite. Thanks to Paulo Freire and his many followers, we have
00:10:57 front row seats at the collapse of the Western University coming soon to a campus near you.
00:11:20 You