The Fiamengo File - December 03, 2015


The Myth Of Sexual Harassment - The Fiamengo File Episode 17

Free Yoga, And Other Crimes - The Fiamengo File Episode 16 Because It's 2015 - The Fiamengo File Episode 18

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

132.69

Word count

1,782

Sentence count

50


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiumingo of the University of Ottawa, and my theme today is the dangerous myth of sexual harassment.
00:00:22 There have been many reports about sexual harassment over the past year, from gripping he-said-she-said dramas involving media personalities like TV star Bill Cosby and the CBC's Gian Gomeschi,
00:00:35 to campus scandals such as the dentistry students at Dalhousie University in Halifax, who use Facebook to joke and fantasize about their female colleagues.
00:00:46 According to the mainstream media, sexual harassment is all around us.
00:00:51 A headline in the Toronto Sun newspaper recently warned that one million Canadians, mostly
00:00:57 women, report that they have been sexually harassed at work.
00:01:02 The report claimed that three out of ten Canadian women have been victimized by workplace harassment
00:01:08 just in the past two years.
00:01:11 That's even worse than the one in four women supposedly sexually assaulted in her lifetime.
00:01:17 sounds like a problem of epidemic proportions requiring tough legislation and extensive public
00:01:24 awareness campaigns and of course that's exactly what prominent feminist activists and lawyers
00:01:30 want us all to believe but if you look at how sexual harassment is defined by the authors of
00:01:37 the toronto sun report and indeed in most workplace harassment policies you will surely be struck by
00:01:44 how outrageously elastic that definition is when i was first learning about feminist social issues
00:01:52 i understood harassment to be a specific kind of threatening behavior involving coercion sexual
00:02:00 harassment as i understood it was when an employer or teacher someone in a position of power extorts
00:02:06 sexual favors by offering something in return in other words i'll give you this contract if you'll
00:02:12 sleep with me i'll look the other way about your drug problem if you'll make nice or you know what
00:02:18 you need to do to get an a in this course but that's not what the study counted or what feminists
00:02:24 call sexual harassment today the study includes actions like charged talk whatever that is and
00:02:33 unwanted sexual advances among the behaviors that can be classed as harassment so you heard that
00:02:39 right charged talk and unwanted sexual advances so if i make a joke in bad taste and i'm a man
00:02:47 of course then i'm a harasser if i ask you out on a date and you say you're busy then i ask you
00:02:54 again a few weeks later and again a week after that not understanding that busy meant busy
00:03:00 forever then according to the definition used in the study i've harassed you but a full 86
00:03:08 percent of respondents in the study indicated that what they experienced never went beyond the verbal
00:03:15 in other words it involved such assaults as jokes suggestive comments even compliments hey julie
00:03:24 that's a gorgeous outfit wow madge i love your hair that way or to cite the famous quip supposedly
00:03:31 uttered by supreme court nominee clarence thomas that ignited a public furor when revealed by his
00:03:37 assistant Anita Hill, who put pubic hair in my coke.
00:03:42 There is no mention in the report of abuse of power. In other words, any comment with
00:03:49 a sexual overtone or undertone is counted as harassment, even simply amongst co-workers
00:03:55 where there is no power imbalance. The study also found that four out of five of the respondents
00:04:01 preferred not to report the incident, with 26% saying the issue was too minor and 21%
00:04:07 saying they didn't think the employer would respond. In effect, simply reading the details
00:04:13 of the report shows up the provocative headline to be a big fudge. As with the now-infamous Mary
00:04:21 Koss-authored rape survey, which using very dubious methodology found nearly every woman
00:04:27 surveyed had been raped so with this so-called study based on misleading questions and the
00:04:33 manipulation of data anyone reading it with an open mind would have to conclude that the sexual
00:04:40 harassment crisis is pure invention except for the men who get the call into the office
00:04:49 the complaint from the co-worker apparently made uncomfortable or unsafe by inappropriate
00:04:56 comments or actions the man can't even remember the man who finds himself in contravention of
00:05:03 his office's workplace safety and respect policy tried found guilty and disciplined or dismissed
00:05:11 without any clear sense of what he did and with no opportunity to defend himself or confront his
00:05:18 accuser. These are the victims of harassment policies we hear almost nothing about.
00:05:26 But Saatchi Curl, the senior vice president of the Angus Reid Institute which conducted the
00:05:30 Toronto Sun study, comes to a different conclusion from the findings. She says it's especially
00:05:37 concerning that more women aren't coming forward to report harassment. For her, that's evidence
00:05:44 not of the trivial nature of the incidents but rather evidence you guessed it of women's oppression
00:05:53 the implication by sachie curl is that workplaces are terrible places for women and they're afraid
00:06:00 to speak out and not at all surprisingly feminist experts at large stoke the flames of concern
00:06:08 kathy laird the executive director of the human rights legal support center
00:06:12 claimed in interview that sexual harassment is quote happening every day and women are afraid
00:06:18 to complain this is the standard story in the same month that the toronto sun published its
00:06:25 inflammatory report on the one million victimized women the toronto star published an article
00:06:32 entitled quote sexual harassment at work a steady problem in ontario this article also insists on a
00:06:40 very wide net definition emphasizing how subtle harassment can be such as the case of get this a
00:06:48 quote boss who hovers and is overly complimentary with sexually tinged comments that leave an
00:06:55 employee uncomfortable and queasy about what might be coming next really hovering complimenting
00:07:04 feeling uncomfortable or queasy. When such subtle behaviours and vague feelings count as sexual
00:07:12 harassment, we can see that the so-called experts are willing to call just about anything by that
00:07:19 name. And the lawyers seem to push the agenda even harder. One Toronto labour lawyer named Kevin
00:07:26 Robinson is quoted as asserting that although there has been some legal progress, there is still
00:07:33 a long, long way to go. Yikes. Robinson's comments are striking for his unquestioning acceptance of
00:07:41 the feminist narrative and his over-eager zeal to pursue complaints. For example, he gives several
00:07:48 reasons why women don't always come forward, one being that they may believe their own actions
00:07:55 contributed to the situation. Remember that one part of even the very elastic definition
00:08:01 of sexual harassment is that it is unwanted sexual advance. So it can't really be harassment
00:08:08 if it was wanted and encouraged, right? Well, even that is way too limiting for the pro-feminist
00:08:15 experts. Robinson notes that women sometimes feel that they, quote, participated in the harassment
00:08:22 in some fashion or encouraged it and feel guilty about it. Not that they should be, he's quick to
00:08:28 point out. So there it is. No matter what the woman may have done to participate in or encourage
00:08:35 the behavior, that's no reason, according to Robison, why she shouldn't make a complaint.
00:08:41 The man is still guilty, even if the woman encouraged and participated in what she is now
00:08:47 calling harassment. What we see in these reports is a very disturbing willingness on the part of
00:08:54 so-called experts to create a false picture of a supposedly widespread problem and to encourage
00:09:01 women to disregard basic common sense and morality in order to launch complaints against their male
00:09:07 colleagues even when their conscience tells them that what happened was at least partially their
00:09:14 own doing or so trivial as to be not worth bothering about. Am I exaggerating? Surely women
00:09:22 know what harassment is? They're not going to bring forward an unjust or untrue complaint?
00:09:29 Well, just recently, two female scholars named Julia Becker and Janet Swim published an academic
00:09:35 paper in the Psychology of Women Quarterly, which calls itself a feminist peer-reviewed
00:09:42 scientific journal. This paper reported extensively on what the two authors called
00:09:48 acts of benevolent sexism, such as men holding doors open for women or offering to take the
00:09:53 wheel on a long automobile trip. Such acts might seem kindly and generous, but they convey a subtle
00:10:00 put-down of women and assumption of male superiority. Consciousness-raising is needed
00:10:06 about such sexism, the two researchers conclude, so that both men and women would be made more
00:10:12 aware of the pervasive nature of gender inequality.
00:10:16 Keep in mind that this wasn't just an opinion piece by two ideologues.
00:10:21 This was an academic study whose publication was given the green light by other academics
00:10:26 with years of university credentials, research experience, and so-called scholarly achievement
00:10:32 behind them.
00:10:34 If even the kindest and most gentlemanly of behaviours can be classed as sexism, we are
00:10:40 dealing with a definitional category without any boundaries at all. I'm not saying all women are
00:10:48 irrational and vindictive, though it seems clear that a significant minority are and now have law
00:10:55 on their side. And when you have ludicrous studies being published as fact, when you create a culture
00:11:03 in which women are told over and over again that they are victims of male evil, that their feelings
00:11:08 are reality and that they owe it to themselves and to other women to come forward with allegations
00:11:13 that will be taken very seriously and when you mix into that the sometimes volatile environment
00:11:20 of workplace politics interpersonal tensions sexual jealousy rivalry insecurity and
00:11:27 misunderstanding you create a recipe for men's lives to be smashed on the altar of political
00:11:34 correctness so what can be done about an imaginary social crisis created by and for feminists that
00:11:44 has now become workplace law with the power to destroy men's careers and social standing
00:11:52 it's really too much to ask of men that they never socialize with their female co-workers
00:11:58 never express any kind of sexual or romantic or even friendly interest even in response to a
00:12:05 woman's overtures. It's a disaster in the making and I'm at a loss because it seems that many women
00:12:14 and many workplace experts, male and female, have enthusiastically implemented the myriad policies
00:12:20 and rules that now stymie and stigmatize natural interaction between men and women in the name of
00:12:27 their utopian design. Only perhaps a flood of big lawsuits against companies by men improperly
00:12:36 dismissed or disciplined might begin to stem this tide. If I were a young man now, I'd get myself a
00:12:45 law degree specializing in labor and employment and prepare to take on this anti-sex, anti-love,
00:12:53 anti-human leviathan. Until we've got an army of anti-feminist lawyers fighting in our corner,
00:13:02 things will only get worse. It's time to take back our offices, classrooms, and boardrooms.
00:13:10 In the name of sanity and common sense, let's make the workplace safe for men.
00:13:23 You