The Fiamengo File - December 10, 2015


Because It's 2015 - The Fiamengo File Episode 18

The Myth Of Sexual Harassment - The Fiamengo File Episode 17 SFU Feminists -The Fiamengo File Episode 19

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

123.5

Word count

1,821

Sentence count

71


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:17 My theme today is Justin Trudeau's Affirmative Action Cabinet.
00:00:22 Because it's 2015, that was what Justin Trudeau, newly elected Canadian Prime Minister,
00:00:29 quipped when asked why gender equality was so important to him in the selection of his cabinet.
00:00:34 For his 31-member cabinet, Trudeau chose 15 female ministers and 16 male ministers,
00:00:41 the first gender-balanced cabinet in Canadian history.
00:00:46 Well, in an era of three-second sound bites and pithy hashtags,
00:00:50 his comment was a pretty good non-answer to defend a female quota system at the highest level of government.
00:00:57 As far as I can tell, it's received a tremendous amount of good press, for example, with actress
00:01:03 and feminist Emma Watson saying it was the coolest thing she'd seen in a while, and
00:01:08 MSN News calling it the new PM's mic drop moment.
00:01:13 So what does 2015 have to do with choosing cabinet ministers on the basis of sex?
00:01:21 I presume Trudeau meant that a female quota was an idea whose time had come and required
00:01:27 no argument at all. Actually, affirmative action hiring and promotions have been with us for
00:01:34 quite a long time now, though pro-feminist commentators don't dwell on that.
00:01:39 The Employment Equity Act, passed way back in 1986, determined that federally regulated private
00:01:46 companies and crown corporations and later the whole federal public service had to increase
00:01:52 their complement of women and other designated groups the legislation has always been controversial
00:01:59 with people like me arguing that quota hiring violates basic principles of fairness and other
00:02:06 people making the opposite argument that the legislation has never been enforced aggressively
00:02:11 enough whatever one's position on the subject it is hard to deny that a massive and hugely expensive
00:02:20 social engineering program has been ongoing in canada and many other western countries
00:02:26 for decades its purpose being to push the hiring of women and other designated groups to retain them
00:02:34 promote them accommodate their preferences protect them from criticism and competition
00:02:40 demonize elements in the workplace that they don't like, and move them into the highest
00:02:45 decision-making and executive positions as quickly as possible. Now we have Trudeau's
00:02:52 gender-balanced federal cabinet rapturously received by the likes of Elizabeth May,
00:02:58 leader of the Green Party, who wrote a blog column gushing about women's power to quote
00:03:03 change society, and Alex Johnston, advocate for women in business, who interpreted Trudeau's move
00:03:10 as giving the green light to female quotas in the corporate world as well. The eagerness with
00:03:17 which the Trudeau cabinet was hailed may well signal that even as legal and societal barriers
00:03:23 to women fade into the distant past, the feminist agenda is entering a new phase of political
00:03:32 confidence. Anyone expressing doubts about Trudeau's cabinet has been told in no uncertain terms to
00:03:39 keep his feelings to himself, as in the case of the satirical magazine The Beaverton, whose headline
00:03:46 mocked critics as hypocrites. 50% female cabinet leads to 5,000% increase in guys who suddenly
00:03:57 care about merit. How bizarre to live in a society where the question of merit is treated
00:04:05 so flippantly. Why do you assume the women aren't competent is the gotcha feminist fallback
00:04:14 forcing the questioner to prove he isn't a misogynist. Okay, let me put on my grumpy man
00:04:22 hat and pursue this presumably off-limits line of reasoning.
00:04:29 I don't assume the women in Trudeau's cabinet aren't competent.
00:04:34 Though if any of you saw the new Minister of International Trade, Chrystia Freeland's
00:04:40 performance on the Bill Maher show the other night on the topic of Islam, you saw someone
00:04:45 far more comfortable with pious platitudes than with reasoned argument.
00:04:51 I can imagine that it would be tough to debate Bill Maher on any subject, but Freeland's
00:04:56 performance demonstrated a near total inability to move off a fourth-grader level script,
00:05:02 even when the script made her sound as if she didn't actually understand Maher's arguments.
00:05:08 If she's the best Trudeau could find, and she was one of his most high-profile cabinet
00:05:13 appointments, there is reason to be concerned about competence.
00:05:18 But back to the question.
00:05:20 I don't assume the women in Trudeau's cabinet are generally incompetent.
00:05:25 I do assume that they were chosen in some part, likely in large part, not because of
00:05:31 their competence, but because of their sex.
00:05:35 And that's not a good way to select the best.
00:05:39 The numbers alone tell the story.
00:05:42 Out of 184 Liberals elected to the House of Commons this past October 19th, 50 of them
00:05:49 were women, just over one-quarter of the total.
00:05:53 Rather than being able to choose from all of the 184 MPs in his government, Trudeau
00:05:59 could draw from only 27% of them to form the female half of the Cabinet.
00:06:06 It just stands to reason that limiting the pool so markedly will limit the range of talent
00:06:12 and experience one can access. Now, I'm not so naive not to realize that considerations other
00:06:20 than merit alone have always been a part of the selection of cabinet ministers, from regional
00:06:26 representation to the paying off of debts. But factors other than merit have never been
00:06:32 so starkly on display as in this case. Consider it. Under Trudeau, a female MP had just less than
00:06:42 a 1 in 3 chance of being chosen for the cabinet, while a male MP had only about a 1 in 10 chance.
00:06:52 Some gender equality. Isn't it kind of embarrassing for the women? And then to stand up and talk about
00:07:00 how hard it is to be a woman in politics? It's also not irrelevant to note that of the 388
00:07:08 Liberal candidates who stood for election on October 19, only 30 percent, 104 out of 388,
00:07:18 were women. If less than one-third of those Liberal candidates willing and able to contest
00:07:24 the election in the first place were women, why do women deserve to make up half of the cabinet?
00:07:32 But supporters of the Trudeau Gender Balance Cabinet don't bother with arguments about
00:07:37 numbers and fairness. That's so 20th century. Instead, they assert as fact two conveniently
00:07:46 unfalsifiable assertions. One, that imposed gender equality is good for women, and two,
00:07:54 that it's good for the country. On the good for women front, proponents emphasize that the
00:08:01 positive message of a gender-balanced cabinet is worth any number of male grumbles.
00:08:07 Even after decades of legislation outlawing discrimination against women,
00:08:12 after decades of affirmative action policies promoting the hiring of women,
00:08:17 after 30% of women were cabinet ministers in the bad old days of Stephen Harper,
00:08:23 still we're told women face barriers to participation in politics.
00:08:28 Where the claim has no statistical support, as demonstrated empirically in the major economic
00:08:34 study out of MIT recently that found that women born after 1975 significantly outpaced
00:08:41 their male peers in post-secondary accreditation, employment rates,
00:08:46 occupational stature, and real wages, no matter, the arguers resort to the
00:08:52 intangible, that ineffable something in the air, the noxious whiff of patriarchal
00:08:59 bias, everywhere felt, though nowhere grasped. That, we're told, must still be
00:09:06 countered on the second argument that a gender balance cabinet is good for the country the
00:09:13 evidence is even thinner gender equality is good for society we're told because women are good
00:09:22 they bring insights to government that men don't bring greater concern for women and children
00:09:28 a willingness to talk rather than go to war, etc. This would seem a non-starter premise for a
00:09:36 movement dedicated to the claim that there are no significant intellectual and other occupation
00:09:41 related differences between men and women, but pro-woman sentiment is always, it seems, in season.
00:09:50 Earlier feminists celebrated women's special qualities too. For example, Canadian suffragist
00:09:56 nelly mcclung claimed that extending the vote to women would bring an end to war and other social
00:10:02 injustices obviously it didn't but the implicit appeal to female moral superiority is a time
00:10:10 honored feminist theme when convenient okay but even if one or both of the good for women and
00:10:21 good-for-the-country arguments were valid, which I don't believe they are, their valinity could
00:10:28 never, in my opinion, counterbalance the serious and lasting harms of sex-based cabinet selection
00:10:36 and affirmative action hiring generally, which are also harms to women and harms to country.
00:10:44 Obviously, some women are advantaged materially by promotion based on sex.
00:10:51 They're rewarded with high-paying jobs, power, and influence that they likely
00:10:55 wouldn't have received under a purely merit-based system. That's nice for them.
00:11:01 But the practice of requiring gender equality is, in the long run, bad for women.
00:11:09 because it contributes to a consciousness, often subliminal and repressed, of inferiority
00:11:16 on the part of women, who are condemned always to suspect that their positions were not fairly
00:11:22 earned. Furthermore, in order to deny the realization of unfair advantage, women are
00:11:29 encouraged in the false belief, tenaciously asserted, that society owes them their special
00:11:37 opportunities and rewards—a belief requiring lifelong grievance-mongering and refusal of
00:11:43 responsibility that trap many women in emotional adolescence forever.
00:11:49 Of course, emotional adolescence is where a lot of women are happy to stay, and it can be an easy,
00:11:55 comfortable existence. Not so for the men who recognize that the society largely built
00:12:03 by their sex is now stacked against them that their ambitions must be sacrificed on the altar
00:12:12 of women's progress elizabeth may actually admits this explicitly in her blog post she's okay with
00:12:19 it what a profound betrayal and then the question has to come to men why keep on contributing brains
00:12:28 inabilities, hard work, and decency to a society that responds with accusation and discrimination,
00:12:36 that shouts with laughter when you object, that yawns at evidence of male alienation, depression,
00:12:43 or suicide. Many men are already dropping out, giving up on career, marriage, and family
00:12:50 altogether. And although this may seem good for feminists in the short term, it's ultimately a
00:12:56 disaster as anybody should recognize who knows how much our society depends on the creative and
00:13:02 material contributions of men. I said earlier that judging from the swooning reception of Trudeau's
00:13:11 2015 Female Quota initiative, we're now in the triumphalist phase of female privilege.
00:13:19 What many of us hoped back in the 1980s might be a radical but temporary measure
00:13:25 is being made into a permanent, never-to-be-questioned feature of our society.
00:13:31 And this is, of course, how utopian movements like feminism always operate.
00:13:37 No matter what is done for women, no matter how many special perks and rewards, there will always
00:13:42 be some way to claim—doesn't have to be a logical way—that more is needed. Yet another study will
00:13:50 find that girls still don't feel confident in their maths abilities or still aren't happy with
00:13:57 their bodies. Some of these studies will suggest that merely 50% representation in cabinet and
00:14:04 corporate boards and everywhere else isn't actually good enough. Why not 60% or 70%?
00:14:13 Why not an all-female cabinet? Why not all-female CEOs? Why not an all-female world? After all,
00:14:24 it'll soon be 2016.
00:14:42 You