The Fiamengo File - December 17, 2015


SFU Feminists -The Fiamengo File Episode 19

Because It's 2015 - The Fiamengo File Episode 18 Father Christmas - The Fiamengo File Episode 20

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

132.61

Word count

2,257

Sentence count

85


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiomingo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:15 My theme today is, this is what feminist logic looks like.
00:00:20 A recent controversy over a campus men's rights discussion reveals the megalomania
00:00:26 of revolutionary feminism and the intolerance it tends to produce.
00:00:32 A little over a week ago, a group of students at Simon Fraser University in
00:00:36 Vancouver, British Columbia wrote an open letter
00:00:39 critical of the Simon Fraser Advocacy for Men and Boys Club,
00:00:44 which had brought in Men's Rights Dynamo Karen Strawn on November 8, 2015.
00:00:50 Her talk, Toxic Masculinity and Toxic Femininity,
00:00:55 addressed the manner in which men and women both engage at times in destructive forms of gendered
00:01:01 behavior. The phrase toxic femininity responds to the feminist formulation of the now widely used
00:01:07 phrase toxic masculinity, which implies that manhood, only manhood, is culturally damaging.
00:01:15 Right on cue, the feminist students who call themselves the Communication Graduate Caucus
00:01:21 and the Gender, Sexuality, and Women's Studies Student Union felt it necessary to raise an
00:01:26 objection, and their letter seeks to convince the Advocacy for Men and Boys Club that if they
00:01:32 are, quote, serious about improving life for men and boys, they, quote, might want to learn from
00:01:39 feminists who they claim have been working to make the world a better place for men for a long time.
00:01:47 I was going to say that their letter represents a new low in feminist hypocrisy,
00:01:52 but I'm not sure new lows are possible at this point. Perhaps it's safer to say that in every
00:01:58 sentence from that so generous offer to counsel the AMB in effective activism, to their humble
00:02:06 recognition that, quote, feminist movements are not immune from critique, the letter is a definitive
00:02:13 expression of feminist psychological projection in which unpleasant aspects of one's own group
00:02:19 behavior are projected onto another group. As such, it is well worth examining with some care.
00:02:26 As many of you may know, Karen Strawn has herself posted a video with a point-by-point rebuttal of
00:02:32 the open letter, which I highly recommend. As much as possible, I'm going to avoid repeating
00:02:37 the points Karen's already made, simply adding a few of my own about this revealing document.
00:02:44 The main thrust of the open letter is the now standard double-pronged attack by feminists
00:02:50 against any attempt, no matter how measured, non-partisan, and ideologically inclusive,
00:02:57 to think outside of the feminist framework about the problems facing men and boys today.
00:03:02 First, the predictable feminist MO employed in the letter is to question the integrity
00:03:09 and sincerity of men and boys advocates, stating that their real intent is to attack women.
00:03:16 This is a simple, logical fallacy, often called the appeal to motive, where an argument is
00:03:22 dismissed without engaging with its substance through an unverifiable allegation about intentions.
00:03:28 It's out of order.
00:03:30 Second, feminists typically argue, as do our letter writers, that anti-feminist advocacy is wrong because feminism addresses male problems too, not just women's.
00:03:41 This often involves the fallacy of single cause in which feminists claim that the problems of men are caused by patriarchy and other factors related to patriarchy, capitalism, the military-industrial complex, and so on.
00:03:56 factors that feminism seeks to dismantle and that in this way feminism is working for male good.
00:04:03 If feminism is already working for male good according to this line of thought then attacking
00:04:09 feminism actually harms men and boys. It's a perfect circle of feminist logic that enables
00:04:16 our letter writers to claim the moral high ground even as they issue veiled threats to the advocacy
00:04:23 for Men and Boys Club, that if they don't get with the feminist program, the feminist program
00:04:28 will be gunning for them. Unfortunately, it's not an empty threat, as I'll discuss in a moment.
00:04:35 Now it's worth noting the plethora of logical fallacies in the letter, which suggest a group
00:04:42 mindset so accustomed to hearing its claims echoed back with no real debate that it is unable to
00:04:49 reason according to the basic rules of argument. Let me mention just a small sample of the open
00:04:56 letter's glaring sleights of hand. One that I've begun to suspect is a staple in the feminist style
00:05:03 of argument is the false dilemma, where only two usually equally unpalatable choices are named,
00:05:11 as when the feminists magnanimously offer AMB the option either to accept feminist theories claim
00:05:18 that masculinity is the real problem facing men, or admit themselves liars and woman-haters.
00:05:27 They say, quote, if you want to work alongside feminist efforts to build a more just world
00:05:34 while focusing on boys and men, we support that. But if your activism continues to spread
00:05:42 lies and misinformation about women and feminism," then they don't approve, obviously.
00:05:49 Well, with such a false dilemma, they deliberately preempt the possibility of any good-faith,
00:05:54 non-feminist discussion of men's issues. Notice also the outrageous question-begging here.
00:06:02 What lies? No lies have been proven or even alleged in the letter. I suppose it is the lie
00:06:09 that feminism doesn't help men, but that's not a lie, but an argumentative claim that many
00:06:15 anti-feminist activists, including Karen Straughan, have supported meticulously and logically.
00:06:22 Another widely recognized fallacy employed in the open letter is the guilt by association charge
00:06:28 as when the writers opine that, quote, the rise of what has been framed as men's rights activism
00:06:34 on university campuses is sadly in line with other conservative reactionary groups, e.g.
00:06:41 white supremacist student groups. Actually, the attempt to discredit a movement, not by attacking
00:06:49 its documented claims, but by falsely aligning it with other groups deemed unacceptable is, quote,
00:06:54 sadly in line with dishonesty in argument. Equally dishonest and manipulative is the use
00:07:03 of a false equivalency, as when the letter writers deplore the AMB group's use of, quote,
00:07:09 the language of liberty and free speech to both discredit the experiences and voices of
00:07:16 marginalized groups and commit coordinated campaigns of terror against them when members
00:07:22 of those groups speak out. The link supposedly proving the coordinated campaign of terror
00:07:29 takes us to an article about the unproven anonymous threat made online against feminists
00:07:35 at the University of Toronto last September. A threat which may just as well have been posted
00:07:41 by a feminist as by a disgruntled men's rights activist and which was investigated by police
00:07:46 and found to be not credible. But that isn't even the main point. The point is that defining
00:07:53 free speech used to discredit an ideological adversary as in any way equivalent to a coordinated
00:08:01 campaign of terror is entirely illegitimate. It conveniently suggests that any criticism of
00:08:08 feminists or other marginalized groups can, depending on who's launching the criticism,
00:08:14 be deemed terror. Yes, I know, that's exactly what these groups want, to outlaw any discrediting of
00:08:21 their claims. So much for rational debate amongst the intellectual elite. Well, I've only scratched
00:08:28 the surface, but I hope enough to show how this letter is a textbook illustration of the typical
00:08:33 logical fallacies that first-year university students are supposed to learn to avoid.
00:08:39 Of course, it's difficult to argue well, especially in the heat of the moment. I know I don't always
00:08:44 succeed in debate. But this letter, posted a full month after the offending talk by Karen,
00:08:51 and presented as a joint effort, was presumably the result of collective deliberation with
00:08:56 sufficient time to craft and reconsider. That it is so muddled suggests, in my opinion,
00:09:03 something about the arrested intellectual development induced by the feminist worldview.
00:09:08 Now, let me turn to the explicit content and context of the letter with a focus on one
00:09:15 of the final assertions of the writers, the one that essentially justifies the whole attack
00:09:20 and provides its rationale.
00:09:23 Here the writers refer with a dramatic flourish to the hostile climate in which women are
00:09:29 forced to go about their studies at Simon Fraser University.
00:09:33 That climate, they say, is one in which, quote, women are always already dealing with intolerable
00:09:39 levels of institutionalized sexism in the form of discrimination, harassment, and violence.
00:09:47 By the way, I love that always already, the little nod to the deconstructionist philosopher
00:09:53 Jacques Derrida, master of linguistic obfuscation.
00:09:57 I suppose his phrase was brought in
00:10:00 to give a sophisticated intellectual frisson to the piece.
00:10:04 Well, out of all the dubious claims in the letter,
00:10:08 this statement about intolerable levels
00:10:11 of institutionalized sexism may be the most preposterous,
00:10:16 appearing without a single example, link, statistic,
00:10:19 or reference.
00:10:21 Consider a few facts.
00:10:23 Simon Fraser University,
00:10:24 like every other university in Canada,
00:10:27 has a gender imbalance that favours women.
00:10:30 At the undergraduate level as of fall 2014,
00:10:34 women outnumbered men by a ratio of 54 to 46.
00:10:40 And if we remove the figures
00:10:42 for the Faculty of Applied Science,
00:10:44 which is the only faculty where men still
00:10:47 significantly outnumber women,
00:10:49 if those figures are removed from the undergraduate total,
00:10:52 The number is a more striking 59 percent women to 41 percent men.
00:10:59 In education, which certifies the teachers who will shape the learning environments of
00:11:03 girls and boys, women outnumber men by a staggering ratio of 80 to 20.
00:11:11 In the health sciences, where decisions about health policy and funding priorities are made,
00:11:16 the breakdown of women to men is 72% women, 28% men.
00:11:23 Although the faculty is not gender balanced,
00:11:26 women are making steady progress
00:11:27 and are, as we know, heavily favored
00:11:29 by employment equity policies.
00:11:32 In a situation of such marked female student preponderance,
00:11:36 two questions arise.
00:11:38 How is it that institutionalized sexism continues to exist,
00:11:43 especially with feminism the major theoretical framework in most faculties.
00:11:48 Moreover, if the situation is indeed intolerable, as the letter writers claim,
00:11:54 why do these faculties continue attracting so many women, their numbers increasing nearly every year?
00:12:01 I find the feminist claim unjustified and highly unlikely.
00:12:06 The historical evidence all points in the other direction, in fact,
00:12:10 that Simon Fraser's gender imbalance has created a situation of female privilege and
00:12:16 arrogant unconcern regarding the experiences of its minority male population. Just a few years
00:12:23 ago in 2012, an attempt to open a men's centre, a space for men to meet in a male-positive
00:12:29 environment, ignited vociferous resistance and was eventually put on hold. The SFU Women's
00:12:36 Centre, in contrast, has been in uncontested operation since 1974, subsidized by student
00:12:43 fees, including male student fees, of course, which pay for this women-only space, with
00:12:49 its couches and chairs, its fully equipped kitchen, and its free sanitary pads, condoms,
00:12:54 tea, and coffee. In a video created by SFU feminists and preserved by Jonathan Taylor,
00:13:01 host of Boys and Men in Education, various students opined at length about why a men's
00:13:07 centre was not only unnecessary but a waste of resources and a danger. This video is well worth
00:13:14 watching. The feminist students expressed their views that the centre would become a highly
00:13:20 masculinised space, a heteronormative space, that it would not take into account the experience of
00:13:26 marginalized men, would not be trans-inclusive, would make victimized men feel unsafe, and would
00:13:31 end up being just another boys club, a place to celebrate, heaven forbid, hegemonic masculinity.
00:13:40 One woman in perhaps the most overtly Twilight Zone moment of the video dismissed the men involved
00:13:45 in the proposal for the Centre because they had, quote, no experience of being a subordinate
00:13:52 or marginalized men. How ironic to watch these feminist women and men pronouncing with such
00:13:59 confident disdain on men's failures of inclusivity and sensitivity. At present, nothing has come or
00:14:07 seems likely to come of the men's center idea, and a recent article in the student newspaper
00:14:12 The Peak lectured any man foolish enough to think of re-entering the debate that for such a center
00:14:17 to be, quote, successful, non-sexist, non-racist, and unprejudiced, it must not, quote, exist solely
00:14:25 in opposition to existing feminist frameworks, but should rather look critically at the structures
00:14:31 of masculinity they've been taught. It sounds an awful lot like the open letter to the AMB
00:14:37 lecturing men's advocates on appropriate and inappropriate forms of activism.
00:14:42 So let me get this straight. Women outnumber men overall on campus and vastly outnumber them in
00:14:51 every faculty except the sciences. An attempt by men in 2012 to set up a men's center was
00:14:58 decisively quashed by feminist students who felt perfectly comfortable dictating to men on campus
00:15:04 about what they were allowed to think and how they were allowed to organize and were powerful enough
00:15:10 that their views prevailed. All spoke of masculinity in negative and contemptuous terms
00:15:17 and referred to the men trying to organize the centre without any sympathy or understanding.
00:15:24 A few years later, the newly formed AMB Club was similarly schooled in the kinds of theories
00:15:30 and practices it should adopt if it wants feminist approval. We know that feminist power
00:15:37 on university campuses is so strong that, as has happened at Ryerson University just recently,
00:15:43 men's clubs can be denied the accreditation and funding that every other club receives on campus
00:15:49 simply because they are not feminist. And yet, these same ideologues claim that
00:15:57 women are the ones who experience, quote, intolerable levels of institutionalized sexism,
00:16:04 and men the ones who need to re-educate themselves out of their blinding privilege.
00:16:11 The mind boggles. If institutionalized sexism exists, when the choices, claims to equal status,
00:16:21 and self-identity of one sex are controlled and defined by the other, when one sex acts with
00:16:29 impunity to discredit, devalue, and demean the other, then SFU is indeed rife with institutionalized
00:16:38 sexism, and the authors of the open letter stand condemned by their every word.
00:16:59 You