The Fiamengo File - December 24, 2015


Father Christmas - The Fiamengo File Episode 20

SFU Feminists -The Fiamengo File Episode 19 Female White Knights - The Fiamengo File Episode 21

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

130.84

Word count

1,404

Sentence count

54


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiumingo of the University of Ottawa. My theme today is Father Christmas.
00:00:20 Strolling through the mall the other day, my husband and I were delighted to see Santa Claus greeting enraptured children,
00:00:27 them if they'd been good and what they wanted for Christmas. It reminded me of the many years I'd
00:00:32 had my picture taken with Santa, even when, as a pudgy girl of 11, I was really a bit too big
00:00:37 to sit on Santa's knee. And because I've been thinking so much lately about societal views of
00:00:44 men, it struck me that Santa Claus, or Father Christmas, as he's also known, is one of the few
00:00:49 unequivocally positive models of masculinity left in our culture. He is, in a sense, the eternal
00:00:57 father, connected with the season of hope and family, a benevolent yet authoritative masculine
00:01:05 figure seemingly untainted by feminist scorn. Well, not quite entirely untainted. A quick Google
00:01:14 Search brought up an article claiming that, despite the beard and the deep-voiced ho-ho-ho,
00:01:20 Santa is really a woman. Why? Well, for a variety of reasons, including that men can't or won't
00:01:29 shop and couldn't restrain their gun fingers from shooting the reindeer and mounting their antlers
00:01:35 on the wall. Also, quote, Christmas is a big, organized, warm, fuzzy, nurturing social deal,
00:01:43 the writer declares, and, quote, I have a tough time believing a guy could possibly pull it all
00:01:50 off. Well, it's a joke, of course, but the underlying implication is the common gynocentric
00:01:58 refrain that all things good come from womankind and that men are at best gun-happy bunglers.
00:02:06 Children, though, know intuitively that this isn't so. Their love for Santa and enthusiastic
00:02:13 trust in him seem quite impervious to feminist indoctrination. In fact, a recent video released
00:02:21 by the Anomaly Creative Agency asked children whether a woman could do Santa's job just as
00:02:29 well as Santa, and although some children thought she could, a large majority answered no.
00:02:35 Santa needs to be strong to carry all those presents, they insisted, and to keep order
00:02:41 amongst the elves. A woman Santa would get lost in the sky, and so on. These assertions of Santa's
00:02:49 necessary maleness have been interpreted, not surprisingly, as revealing a shocking gender
00:02:55 bias, even in the very young. And they may indeed reveal that certain conceptions of masculinity
00:03:02 and femininity are surprisingly resistant, even to the hardcore feminist training of our modern
00:03:09 society. But is it really bias or simply a basic recognition on the part of even very small
00:03:17 children that fatherhood and motherhood are distinct, equally valuable, but different
00:03:22 identities? I mentioned that one of the points made in the Santa Must Be a Woman spoof article
00:03:29 is that men are notoriously bad at gift shopping. They go out at the last minute and buy whatever
00:03:37 they first lay their eyes on, so how could a male Santa buy gifts for so many children?
00:03:43 But of course, Santa doesn't buy gifts. He makes gifts in his workshop at the North Pole and
00:03:49 directs the elves there on how to help him. And these are eminently male activities, planning,
00:03:56 building, directing others in a workshop. They express eminently male qualities of authority,
00:04:03 hands-on capability, and generosity. To expand on the children's intuitive recognition, I would say
00:04:10 that Santa has to be a man because with his white beard and twinkling eyes and his deep laugh,
00:04:17 Santa represents trustworthy authority in a way that is quintessentially masculine.
00:04:22 A woman's Santa would not have that same authority.
00:04:27 Women are archetypally figures of nurturing.
00:04:31 Mothers make promises and threats of punishment that they break all the time.
00:04:35 It's an almost unavoidable part of the mothering role.
00:04:39 If you touch that, you'll be going straight to your room, and then the child touches it,
00:04:44 and the mother can't bear to send him to his room, and the child soon learns that that's the way mothers are.
00:04:50 Fathers are different because fathers mean it. Santa is a figure of judgment,
00:04:56 whether you've been naughty or nice. Mothers are not supposed to tote up a child's naughty and
00:05:02 nice quotient for the year. That's too stern. Mothers are supposed to forget the child's
00:05:08 naughtiness. A father can judge kindly, but firmly. These are cultural constructs,
00:05:15 you may say our society makes us perceive this way and maybe that's true i'm not saying that
00:05:22 there aren't men who are totally soft with their kids and women who can't be authority figures
00:05:28 yeah we all get that no argument but the qualities and roles are still gendered they seem to be
00:05:35 deep rooted in our psyches and cannot be easily unthought by feminist fiat and this brings us to
00:05:44 the role of real fathers in children's lives.
00:05:48 Recent studies are making it clear just how important fathers are for children.
00:05:53 A massive 2013 report on fatherlessness, led by Sarah McClanahan, examined 47 peer-reviewed
00:06:02 studies on the effects of father absence on children and found very strong correlation
00:06:08 between father absence and emotional and behavioral problems when children are without their fathers
00:06:16 they are overall sadder angrier and more stressed the effects seem to be magnified for boys
00:06:25 as summarized by david auteur and melanie wasserman in another 2013 study a quote growing body of
00:06:33 evidence indicates that the absence of stable fathers has particularly significant adverse
00:06:39 consequences for boys psychosocial development and educational achievement leading to increases
00:06:46 in dropping out of school juvenile delinquency and emotional maladjustment the situation of fathers
00:06:54 exiled from their children's lives as a result of divorce alienation by the mother and an
00:07:00 An unsympathetic family court system is equally disturbing.
00:07:05 In the 2013 book, Divorced Fathers and Their Families, Florence Kraslow provides shocking
00:07:11 case studies of the profound long-term sense of loss and bereavement experienced by divorced
00:07:17 fathers, no longer able to parent their children, made to feel redundant and unwanted, and cut
00:07:25 off from those they love most in the world.
00:07:29 When I first began to speak out against feminism and on behalf of men and boys in the education
00:07:34 system, I received a flood of emails from men who had lost contact with their children
00:07:40 solely because they had had the bad luck to be male in a society that doesn't recognize
00:07:46 fathers' parental rights and believes men to be inessential to children's well-being.
00:07:52 These men live with the pain of that every day, the sense of betrayal and heartache.
00:08:00 There are now a number of groups in our society attempting to make shared parental custody
00:08:05 the norm in cases of divorce, with a lot of opposition from legal and feminist groups.
00:08:12 One day soon, I hope, we will prevail.
00:08:16 Until then, I send out a particular word of support and encouragement to fathers who are
00:08:21 going through the holidays without their children or with very limited access the fact that santa
00:08:29 claus remains such a vibrant icon of the christmas season suggests i trust the durability of our
00:08:36 cultural recognition even an unconscious one of the necessity of fathers
00:08:52 Thanks for watching season one of the Fiamengo file over the past four months.
00:09:09 During that time we've covered issues and personalities including the empathy gap, women
00:09:15 in the military, the monstrous male gaze, our culture of man-shaming, masculinity studies,
00:09:23 the Tim Hunt saga, and many more. By the way, Breitbart Magazine has just reported that Nobel
00:09:30 Laureate Hunt and his wife are now leaving Britain for Japan, thanks to feminist persecution
00:09:36 in large part. Will we see more of such departures by great men in 2016? Stay tuned to the Fiamengo
00:09:45 file we're taking a short break over the holidays and we'll start up again in the new year to
00:09:50 continue our coverage of significant issues regarding feminist and sjw politics on university
00:09:57 campuses in the coming months we'll broadcast an updated text of the rape culture talk i attempted
00:10:04 to deliver that was shut down by a mob of unruly students at the university of ottawa also on the
00:10:10 the Fiamengo file, we will cover campus protest and the victimhood hysteria that has unmoored
00:10:16 rational discourse. We will examine the abridgment of freedom of speech regarding men's issues.
00:10:23 We will consider the disciplining and silencing of men who resist feminist indoctrination.
00:10:30 In other words, we will bring you stories and analyses of the remarkable cultural moment
00:10:35 we're witnessing, in which feminist supremacy and man-blaming have become defining features of our era.