The Fiamengo File - January 21, 2016


Female White Knights - The Fiamengo File Episode 21

Father Christmas - The Fiamengo File Episode 20 Feminist Terminology 1: Gender - The Fiamengo File Episode 22

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

141.09

Word count

1,938

Sentence count

50


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Happy New Year!
00:00:22 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa and my theme today is on Being a Female White Knight.
00:00:29 Recently I came across a video by Sandman called Female White Knights, posted on December 15, 2015.
00:00:38 Sandman is a MGTOW philosopher, and for anybody who doesn't know,
00:00:42 MGTOW is a movement in which men go their own way, refusing to allow deference to women to define their identities and goals.
00:00:51 In the video, Sandman warns his MGTOW viewers that female men's rights advocates should be regarded
00:00:58 with a healthy degree of skepticism,
00:01:00 or perhaps best ignored.
00:01:03 They may do some good.
00:01:04 In fact, he readily admits that Karen Strawn's videos
00:01:08 helped to kickstart a lot of his thinking,
00:01:10 but such women are also looking out
00:01:12 for their own self-interests
00:01:14 and are therefore not to be completely trusted.
00:01:17 Sandman notes that ironically,
00:01:19 women have privilege in the manosphere as everywhere else,
00:01:23 and many of them say nothing that male anti-feminists
00:01:27 haven't already said yet are enthusiastically praised for saying
00:01:31 it and end up stealing the spotlight despite the lesser
00:01:35 risk involved in their public statements. Some of these are
00:01:39 youngish women looking for male adulation, Sandman speculates.
00:01:44 Some are looking to hedge their bets in a sense to form
00:01:47 allegiance with the men's rights movement in case feminist
00:01:51 society collapses even sooner than expected. Some of these women
00:01:56 having benefited from feminism for a good part of their lives, are now concerned about their sons
00:02:01 or about their own status in old age. It's nearly impossible, according to Sandman, for women to be
00:02:08 the altruistic allies of men that they claim to be and for which a lot of men have offered
00:02:13 grateful acknowledgement. More serious than women's dubious motives and the undeserved praise that
00:02:20 they receive is the effect of female white knighting on men, especially young men. The
00:02:27 danger, as Sandman sees it, is that these anti-feminist women will convince men in the
00:02:32 MGTOW movement that all hope is not lost, that the long gender cold war of the past 50 to 100
00:02:38 years can be called off, and that all they really need to do is search for an anti-feminist woman.
00:02:45 But this is no different, according to Sandman, from the case of a lion who surprisingly gives
00:02:51 up attacking a herd of zebras and starts defending the zebras, even attacking other lions to do so.
00:02:59 The zebras are ecstatic, of course, thinking they've got a wonderful protector in the lion,
00:03:04 and as a result they get complacent. And in the end this just makes the zebras even more vulnerable.
00:03:12 their lion protector once the other lions have been vanquished will turn on the zebras and
00:03:17 dispatch them with great ease inherent in the analogy is the point sandman goes on to spell out
00:03:25 women might disguise their natures but that nature is always the same to take advantage of men to
00:03:33 prey on them essentially female white knights are still women after all and can help but use
00:03:39 men's advocacy in their own interests it's a compelling argument and an unverifiable one
00:03:46 focusing on such murky regions of the psyche as motive and unconscious desires the sweeping
00:03:53 claim about women's nature cannot be defeated except perhaps by responding with another
00:03:58 sweeping claim which was which is that merely wishing really hard that men can stop wanting
00:04:04 love and approval from women doesn't seem likely to make it happen. It is true in my opinion that
00:04:10 female anti-feminists are given a far easier ride than male ones and that men tend to shower praise
00:04:17 on those few women who publicly call out the injustice of feminism. Those facts in themselves
00:04:25 however do not necessarily mean either that women who want to expose an unjust ideology are
00:04:30 necessarily playing a double game or that male recognition of women's support will weaken the
00:04:36 MGTOW movement unless MGTOW prohibits any friendly feeling of men towards women.
00:04:43 Now without attempting to engage with the overall argument of Sandman, I want to think a bit about
00:04:48 his claim in relation to my own white knighting to explore whether my anti-feminist advocacy is
00:04:55 grounded in self-interest of course if i'm a master of deception as he suggests and everything
00:05:01 i say here should be taken with a grain of salt on one level the claim about self-interest doesn't
00:05:08 fit me that well i'm a middle-aged woman with a secure academic position in a completely feminist
00:05:14 dominated environment i have nothing to gain professionally and some friendships and career
00:05:20 opportunities to lose for breaking with feminism i already have a fantastic super smart and sexy
00:05:28 husband who although supportive of whatever i do would be just as happy if i focus my energies on
00:05:34 other subjects i don't have any children to worry about and although i would love for my friend
00:05:41 steve to profit from his work documenting the misandry of our time i don't expect to make any
00:05:47 money at it i'm not under any illusions about my personal charisma when i speak as an anti-feminist
00:05:54 and actually when i re-watch the few lectures i've given my toes curl at my deer in the headlights
00:06:00 performance so on professional and personal levels my anti-feminism isn't particularly in my interest
00:06:08 but on another level sandman is absolutely right i'm a white knight for men because i want to be
00:06:16 one and I'm doing it for me. I don't want to live any longer in a culture in which I and most people
00:06:24 submit to lies about women's victimization and male privilege. It feels crazy and sick.
00:06:33 I particularly don't want to live in a society in which every time I open a newspaper I have to
00:06:38 suppress a roar of disgust because there's yet another womanly demand for special privileges
00:06:46 or government-sponsored perks, or more complaints, jealousies and resentment directed at men.
00:06:53 Just the other day, it was an article by Leah McLaren, a columnist at the Globe and Mail,
00:06:57 one of Canada's national newspapers, about how women should be paid for what she called women's
00:07:04 quote, emotional labour. Things like sending thank you cards or ordering something online
00:07:11 for her child. That's emotional labour, which she says is the next feminist frontier. Pretty soon,
00:07:19 it seems, feminists will be marching in the street to demand that men's tax dollars fund
00:07:24 doulas and birthing coaches to help women grunt and pant their way through such heroic exertions
00:07:30 as phoning a neighbour to thank her for loaning a cup of sugar. I feel a wave of nausea coming on
00:07:38 just thinking of it you see i'm at the point where i can hardly bear to read newspapers without fear
00:07:44 of apoplectic fit i definitely don't want to span the next 20 or 30 years or however much longer i
00:07:51 have left on this earth in a society that gives women permission really encourages women almost
00:07:57 mandates them to be at their worst selfish hypocritical superficial amoral mean-spirited
00:08:04 manipulative, and vindictive. It's not good for my self-respect as a woman.
00:08:11 I don't want to live in a culture that turns women into raging children, supposedly
00:08:16 too scared to attend an astronomy conference or even walk down the street for fear of sexual
00:08:22 harassment, but not too scared to lecture men on their evil, berate them, slander them, belittle
00:08:30 them and call for yet more laws and policies to make their lives more difficult, in addition to
00:08:36 the discrimination they already face in hiring, employment, family court, health care, reproductive
00:08:43 rights, educational opportunities, government services, military conscription, etc.
00:08:49 I fear it's all turning me into a raving misogynist, and that can't be good for my mental health.
00:08:56 I don't want to spend the remainder of my teaching career watching the girls in my classes
00:09:02 become ever more inclined to blame every personal failure or ordinary life setback or challenge on
00:09:08 quote institutionalized sexism, while the boys become ever quieter, more apathetic,
00:09:15 more unsure of themselves, more awkward, apologetic, ashamed, sad, angry, and adrift.
00:09:21 It's painful and infuriating to witness, and I suspect that one day soon I might go ballistic
00:09:28 and launch into a gynophobic tirade in my class that will lead to my being forced to take a series
00:09:34 of sensitivity workshops and issue a public apology. On the other hand, when I see or hear
00:09:40 about guys being guys, whether that's working in a science lab or on a construction site,
00:09:47 doing amazing stunts on their bicycles or guitars, fixing things, telling jokes, playing sports,
00:09:54 teaching classes, parenting their children, being masculine. I like their energy and I
00:10:00 want it in the world, whether that has anything to do with me personally or not.
00:10:05 Furthermore, it's definitely in my self-interest to live in a sane world, a world in which the
00:10:12 most talented, capable, and hard-working people, often men as it turns out, are in charge. A world
00:10:19 that holds me and other women to a standard of achievement rather than giving us top jobs and
00:10:25 special perks just because we're women. I want all the perks done away with, for good, because they're
00:10:32 a moral hazard to me and to all women. Most fundamentally, I don't want to live in a world
00:10:39 that makes me so disgusted and repulsed by the behavior of my own sex that it forces me to wonder
00:10:45 whether I'm really a selfish narcissistic monster too. There sure do seem to be a lot of nasty
00:10:54 narcissists out there enabled by a society gone mad over poor woman hysteria. When I read that
00:11:03 a recent American survey found that 44% of college women don't believe a nod of agreement is
00:11:11 sufficient to count as sexual consent. In other words, that a woman who nodded to the boy she's
00:11:17 making out with can later claim she was raped. When I read about cases such as that involving
00:11:24 Cassandra Kennedy who lied about her father sexually abusing her to punish him and only
00:11:30 admitted her lie after her father spent nine years in jail and nothing is going to happen to her
00:11:37 because you guessed it if she were punished it might prevent other liars from coming forward
00:11:43 to put their innocent fathers in jail when i read about a woman tiffany stevens getting off with a
00:11:50 probationary sentence for paying a man to kill her husband and who still retains custody of their
00:11:58 child. When I see a statement by a wealthy woman named Diane Smith-Gander, CEO of a company called
00:12:05 Transfield in Australia, stating with relish that well-qualified men will simply have to
00:12:12 lose their jobs to make it possible for all government boards to have 50% female representation,
00:12:18 when she has the nerve to say of the men they're not going to want to lose their gig, and that's a
00:12:23 sad and sorry thing but that's just the way it is when i read this and so much more i am sickened
00:12:32 and humiliated and almost totally turned off by the female half of humanity thank god for
00:12:40 karen and daphne and janet and others ultimately i just don't want the horror of seeing men
00:12:49 crippled in the way feminism has crippled them. I can't be who I want to be in the world if that's
00:12:56 being done to men. So I guess I do want to use men in the men's movement for my own interests.
00:13:05 Whether it's through MGTOW or men's rights, it's up to you. But yes, I definitely want you to take
00:13:12 back your lives and power and your pride for me because I will enjoy that selfishly.
00:13:42 You