Archbishop FIRES Trad Catholic after SPEAKING OUT on Zionism
Episode Stats
Words per minute
172.69054
Harmful content
Misogyny
4
sentences flagged
Toxicity
4
sentences flagged
Hate speech
20
sentences flagged
Summary
Joe Anders, a young man who worked for the Archdiocese of Detroit and was promptly fired after he went on social media and on a show and talked about the case of Carrie Prejean Buller. Now, remember, Carrie, was on our show just the other day defending the Catholic position on Zionism at the Trump Religious Freedom Committee, and then somehow makes a comment from a Catholic perspective and gets removed.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
We're being told that this is the pastoral listening church, as long as you're, you know,
0.80
00:00:05.260
left-wing climate change activist or an immigration activist or a active sodomite.
0.53
00:00:12.960
Well, my friends, welcome to the John Henry Weston Show. We've got with us a young man
00:00:16.920
who worked for the Archdiocese of Detroit and was promptly fired after he went on social media
00:00:23.800
and on a show, in fact, and talked about the case of Carrie Prejean Buller.
00:00:30.220
Now, remember, Carrie Buller was on our show just the other day.
1.00
00:00:34.240
She gave that astounding defense of the Catholic position on Zionism at the Trump Religious Freedom Committee
00:00:47.140
Joe then somehow makes comment, again, from a Catholic perspective and gets removed.
00:00:55.160
And again, I am very thankful to LifeSite team for helping make this story public,
00:01:01.440
letting people know, letting Catholics know what's going on right now with not only my family,
00:01:07.240
but just the church in general, where certain ideas are kind of stamped down because they're bad PR,
00:01:18.800
Let's begin, as we always do, with the sign of the cross.
00:01:20.700
In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. Amen.
00:01:25.520
Tell us, if you will, from the beginning, what exactly happened?
00:01:29.140
So, I took a week's vacation to spend some time with my friend Tim Gordon out in Mississippi.
00:01:36.880
You know, we, obviously, he does his show rules for retrogrades, and we were sitting around watching the Olympics.
00:01:43.120
You know, we were having fun watching curling, and curling's always just a great time.
00:01:50.760
And then we were looking at our phones, and we saw, you know, Carrie Prejean Bowler just lighting up the Religious Liberty Commission
0.57
00:01:59.760
and spitting facts, Catholic teaching, you know, things that we've said a lot in the past.
00:02:07.840
So, Tim's like, we gotta go do an episode on this.
00:02:11.180
And he's like, you're here, you can just sit right next to me, just jump on the rules for retrograde set,
00:02:15.640
and we're gonna defend what she's saying, because it's true.
00:02:20.080
And ultimately, our conclusion in the show was that you can't be a Catholic
0.72
00:02:26.180
and assent to the tenets of Zionism as defined by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance and the American Jewish Congress.
00:02:33.980
For a lot of people, they're gonna wonder, what in the world are you even talking about?
00:02:42.160
The one side of the aisle, I think, is a lot of these people.
00:02:45.420
We would, something Catholics would call heresy.
0.97
00:02:47.380
There's this belief, and I think that the sloganeering that the Zionism and Israel lobby have done
0.66
00:02:54.220
through the past few decades, I think, best sums it up.
00:02:58.080
The first one is that Jews have a right to a homeland.
00:03:10.820
And then the third proposition, and I think this is perhaps the most succinct of it all,
00:03:16.960
And this is what you would have heard on the Religious Liberty Commission.
00:03:19.840
They're saying that if you don't assent to both of those propositions,
0.93
00:03:23.440
that you are an anti-Semite, meaning you hate Jewish people.
0.83
00:03:31.060
In fact, I wish the greatest happiness and joy upon them that they could ever possibly endure.
00:03:35.940
I'm talking about true spiritual joy, as Thomas Aquinas would put it.
00:03:42.340
And I want the Holy Spirit to reside in every Jewish person on earth.
00:03:45.480
Yeah, to become, as Mother Miriam herself, a former Jew, said, a completed Jew,
0.70
00:03:55.340
You know, she did tell me the greatest form of anti-Semitism is to keep Jesus from the Jews.
00:04:01.080
This is what we're called to believe as Catholics.
00:04:03.960
Now, if you were to accept the propositions of the slogans that they're telling you that you have to assent to,
00:04:09.720
you're kind of forced into a very specific position.
00:04:13.060
And that specific position that you're forced into is that, well, by somehow,
00:04:17.780
Jews, through their blood, have a right to the land of Israel.
00:04:21.880
And not just the land of Israel, but the land of Israel as outlined in the Bible.
00:04:30.220
Now, we all know that's not just the Israel that we know today.
0.66
00:04:36.820
It's parts of Syria and Jordan and all these other parts of the world.
00:04:40.940
Now, we as Catholics believe that existing nations do have some level of right to their own sovereignty right now.
00:04:46.680
We can't say that Israelis, because, you know, the Bible 3,000 years ago assented this land to these people.
0.99
00:04:53.440
We don't believe that that covenant is still in existence.
00:04:56.480
We believe that God granted them that covenant.
00:04:59.360
We believe that the church is the new Israel, that Jesus Christ fulfilled the old covenant on the cross.
00:05:04.940
When we think of Israel in the Old Testament, we see it as a foreshadowing of the Catholic Church.
00:05:11.060
When we think of the chosen people, the Jews, we look at the baptized today.
00:05:16.260
Baptized in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.
00:05:24.220
So to say that we can assent to a blood right or a divine right by the Jewish people to the land of Israel, and I mean the prophesied ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, would simply be un-Catholic.
00:05:42.440
And this, I think, is what got me in hot water with some unsavory people who targeted me and tried to get me fired from the Archdiocese of Detroit.
00:05:52.360
Your details on how you were let go, when you were let go, and what it means for your family, that's truly stunning.
00:06:00.520
We're going to come back to the issue in a second, but people have to realize the gravity of this situation given your own family life.
00:06:08.680
It's extraordinarily disappointing to feel like a orphan in your own diocese.
00:06:17.060
It's bad to feel like your parish is scared to have you.
00:06:22.800
Now, the events that followed up are very strange.
00:06:28.020
Because when, on Tuesday, Shrove Tuesday, actually, this is the craziest part of the story.
00:06:36.880
It felt like it was done with all due disrespect to me and inadvertently my family because, you know, I'm the leader of my family.
00:06:46.680
Now, what they did was on Shrove Tuesday, I get a call from my pastor at the church saying, why is the Archdiocese calling me?
00:06:53.180
They said someone sent screenshots to them of your Twitter.
00:06:58.160
And, you know, no elaboration on what these tweets are.
00:07:10.420
So they said, well, they're putting, I'm putting you on administrative leave until tomorrow.
00:07:14.960
I'm waiting for the Archdiocese to get back to me on next steps.
00:07:22.000
And they tell me, they're like, they're like, you are terminated.
00:07:27.360
If my pastor tells me they are terminating you, I am not the one doing it.
00:07:30.860
They are terminating you effective immediately.
00:07:33.420
And I was like, okay, so you're getting rid of me.
00:07:39.940
My little daughter is due in two months in May.
00:07:44.020
I was like, so are we, is there anything you guys can do?
00:07:50.000
I have Archdiocese, I have an Archdiocese in health care plan.
00:07:53.080
And everybody knows that when you take a job at a church, you take a reduced salary.
00:08:00.580
My health care, they graciously, they would pay for in full.
00:08:04.440
Well, this is, I'm losing that at the end of the month.
00:08:09.060
I have to either go on Medicaid, because this is the United States of America, which
00:08:13.300
is government, welfare, health care, or I have to pay that $1,700 a month premium to
00:08:20.300
cover my family for those months until my daughter's born.
00:08:25.320
And I have no income through this entire process.
00:08:27.860
So I was wondering, I was like, is there anything that they're going to do?
00:08:30.500
They're not going to give me any severance or nothing?
00:08:34.520
And I was like, well, can you at least tell me why this is happening?
00:08:41.020
And he says, the archdiocese has instructed me not to tell you.
00:08:48.260
And apparently they don't, because Michigan's an at-will state, meaning that you can get
00:08:56.280
I'm no lawyer, but I haven't pursued any exploration into that just yet.
00:09:10.620
I find it hard to believe that he wouldn't have told them that my wife is pregnant and
00:09:14.400
And the archdiocese offered nothing, nothing to me.
00:09:24.840
You know, he's just learning to walk right now.
00:09:32.400
And I know they do, with many people, all the time.
00:09:38.860
I can't say that I know that I was fired because of Zionism.
0.87
00:09:43.160
All I can say is that it comes on the heels of the rules for retrograde stuff.
00:09:46.920
It comes on the heels of Carrie Prejean sharing so many of my commentaries talking about how
00:09:54.760
Catholics can't assent to the tenets of Zionism that they're claiming that we have to
0.91
00:10:00.800
And you were given these great hints by your priest who says, what's with these tweets?
00:10:08.960
I believe he came in in maybe March or April of 2025.
00:10:13.600
He has done things that I personally would not have done that I wouldn't personally agree
00:10:21.520
Isn't he the same Weisenberger that went after the traditional Latin mass in his diocese?
00:10:31.420
Isn't he the same Weisenberger who fired Dr. Ralph Martin, Dr. Eduardo Echeverria, and
00:10:43.040
An unbelievable hunt for the most Orthodox people.
0.99
00:10:50.900
Sacred Heart Major Seminary had these paragons of Catholic Orthodoxy.
00:10:58.380
And I purposely use the term Orthodoxy, not tradition, because they're not hardcore trad Latin mass
00:11:09.600
He's, he's like a charismatic leader, except that he was always Orthodox.
0.93
00:11:14.320
So, you know, Dr. Ed Peters, I think he might skew toward the Latin mass, but, but they are
1.00
00:11:19.800
huge names in the Catholic church, all dismissed.
00:11:24.040
So this archbishop has a, uh, a definite animus, you might say, against very faithful Catholics.
00:11:37.120
I'm particularly amazed that an employer could do this to a young family and think they're going
00:11:46.680
There are quite a few opportunities, I think, ahead.
00:11:50.420
I think I've communicated with some of your team about the opportunities that are lying
00:11:54.540
Uh, and I also am co-founding with, um, I think a mutual friend of ours, Father Calvin Robinson,
00:12:02.120
a media organization for catechizing Gen Z with three specific main goals, protecting the
00:12:09.740
American family, protecting the West's heritage and catechizing Gen Z.
0.98
00:12:16.300
And so our goal is going to be putting out content that uplifts these people that, that,
00:12:22.360
that speaks to them in a language that they understand.
00:12:25.400
These young people out here, there are some hungry young Catholics.
00:12:29.480
John Henry, I imagine you've seen so many of them yourself out there that are craving
00:12:35.120
They are craving something that they can go to, to say, I am ready to take on the spiritual
00:12:42.220
I'm ready to take on a world that is going to be hostile to me as a young pro-Western Catholic
00:12:51.380
And I feel as though I have an inheritance that is this church and that my civilization is
00:12:57.140
trying to rob me of that inheritance in many, many different ways, whether it be through,
00:13:02.700
you know, the, whether it be through the excesses of feminism, contraception, abortion, pornography,
1.00
00:13:09.060
any of these issues, immigration, any of these issues that we've seen the church largely fail
00:13:15.320
fail these young men on, that ignore them, push them out, not be synodal, not be pastoral, not be listening to
00:13:24.620
of these people's gripes, of these people's plights, frankly.
00:13:30.400
And in some cases, like in my case, facilitating the plight on these young people.
00:13:35.740
Uh, we're not in the position that we need to be as a church.
00:13:39.480
And I find it ironic that we're being told that this is the pastoral listening church,
00:13:45.960
as long as you're, you know, left-wing climate change activist or an immigration activist or a
00:13:53.780
It seems like in those instances, that, that seems to be the time that seems to be the best time
00:14:00.900
But when it's about correcting, correcting their brother in Christ, and I've told, I've told them this,
00:14:06.220
if the USCCB, the nuncio to the United States, if my archbishop wants to sit down with me and said,
00:14:11.700
you committed a sin, you did something that's wrong, I'm here to guide you,
00:14:14.540
I want to show you that this is not the way to be, I would have been happy to sit down and have that conversation.
00:14:19.720
Unfortunately, they don't want to have that conversation.
00:14:26.720
And I feel like I'm a voice for Gen Z Catholics in that way.
00:14:31.080
I bridge the gap between Millennials and Generation Z.
0.92
00:14:36.760
I am trying to be a voice for them because they are sick of the church ignoring them,
00:14:48.520
Protecting your money doesn't have to be complicated.
00:14:51.280
With stocks, bonds, and crypto, it's easy to feel lost.
00:14:54.340
But gold and silver have been trusted for centuries
00:14:56.760
as a simple, stable store of value in uncertain times.
00:15:00.440
If you would have invested $35,000 in gold at the Millennium,
00:15:04.140
an amount you can give today tax-free to anyone you love,
00:15:14.380
and let us step you through crafting a solution for your family.
00:15:41.660
You know, in college, I had my libertarian phase
00:15:44.140
where it's like, ah, live and let live, you know,
00:16:47.440
And later on, I go to college at the King's College.
00:16:51.960
I was a turning point activist throughout college.
00:17:25.700
I'm three credits short of a minor in theology.
00:18:36.500
But let's say there are some young kids out there