00:00:00Many times in the New and Old Testament, they point out crimes that should be punished by death penalty.
00:00:08For example, premilitated murder causing miscarriage, abortion in the Old Testament, was penalized with the death penalty.
00:00:19Hey, my friends. A lot of Catholics nowadays are confused about the death penalty.
00:00:25because we heard even a month or more ago, Kristen Hawkins, who is the leader, head of
00:00:35Students for Life of America, huge pro-life group, herself a Catholic. She said, and I'll quote it
00:00:40for you because it was so stunning to me when I saw it, but here were her words with regard to
00:00:47death penalty. She said, if you know the Catholic teaching against the death penalty, but still
00:00:54gleefully advocated you are in sin. And it was always my understanding, it's the traditional
00:00:58understanding, that the death penalty is approved by the Church, obviously to be used in just
00:01:06reasons. But I wanted an expert on that, and we've got one here who has done already a deep
00:01:14dive, and that in fact was part of his thesis at university. Monsignor Ricardo Coronado Arasque
00:01:21is a Peruvian canon lawyer who's previously served as judicial victor and chancellor of
00:01:27the Diocese of Colorado Springs, where he also taught canon law to seminarians. He's a former
00:01:32Augustinian and has worked on ecclesial matters, if you will, in both Peru and the United States
00:01:41of America. Welcome, Monsignor Coronado. Thank you very much. Thank you for your kind words to me.
00:01:46So, Monsignor, this thing about the death penalty, we've just had a major pro-life leader in America, Catholic herself, wanting to be faithful to the Church's teaching, having read the Catechism, which was changed, I believe, in 2018 by Pope Francis, and then recently reinforced again and again and again by Leo XIV.
00:02:15So start there, unpack that a little bit for us, because this has become really confusing.
00:02:21I would like to begin to say that traditionally, meaning from the time of the early church,
00:02:29fathers of the church, doctors of the church, have always thought that the death penalty is kind of a self-defense
00:02:37from the greater society, meaning the state, to an issue or to a crime that is difficult to overcome
00:02:45otherwise. It's not only to prevent crimes, but it's also to maintain and sustain the juridical
00:02:55order. So we have two terms here that we have to be careful with. Juridical order and judicial
00:03:02law. There are two different things. The juridical law is what structures the society,
00:03:09what makes possible to have a human dignifying life in any given society at any time. So this
00:03:19is the juridical law. Most of the time, that is reflected in the Constitution, like is the case
00:03:25in the United States, is based on tradition as it is in England.
00:03:32England doesn't have a constitution, doesn't have a written constitution.
00:03:37France does, Spain does, Peru, of course, does.
00:03:41The constitution is like the juridical picture and the mindset which we want to follow and
00:03:49to observe so we can have a human life, a human
00:03:53dignifying life in exile. So when somebody
00:05:25Because for them, the ultimate value is the physical life.
00:05:30For us Christians, the ultimate goal, the ultimate value is salvation.
00:05:36If we lose that perspective, then, of course, everything is horrific, it's bad, especially when we think about the state up to in a way that is going to deprive somebody from physical existence.
00:17:35Juridical order is what people, human beings, need to have a harmonious and peaceful life.
00:17:44If you break that, everybody in that society is at risk because you can be killed, you can be kidnapped, you can be run in so many ways, and the state will be unable to inflict the penalty to restore that harmonious order.
00:19:55But, you know, even under their rule, there were so many abuses.
00:20:00that people committed. They could not control every seat. So that doesn't give me any reason
00:20:06to think that the death penalty is wrong on itself. It's wrong in the way people may apply.
00:20:13So the logistics may be wrong, but the concept of a death penalty is not wrong at all.
00:20:20How then do we have what seems like the opposite in terms of what the catechism says right now?
00:20:27How is it that Leo XIV is basically saying, and it really impacts in America, because obviously in America, they still have the death penalty. And he came and said over and over and over again, that we can't do that. Here's one clip. He just says, if you're not against death penalty, you're not pro-life. Watch.
00:20:52Someone who says I'm against abortion but says I'm in favor of the death penalty is not really pro-life.0.99
00:20:58So someone who says that I'm against abortion but I'm in agreement with the inhuman treatment of immigrants who are in the United States, I don't know if that's pro-life.
00:21:09That's totally wrong. I'm sorry, you know, people can't regard him as God speaking to the world.
00:21:16But wait, he says that he commits a great mistake.
00:21:21How can you say that your in favor of death penalty, which applies only to criminals, is the same as being pro-abortion?0.67
00:21:31I think that's amazing for him to say something like that.
00:21:35Something wrong of that caliber is a big mistake.
00:21:41So he's telling us that for us to be good Catholics, we have to be defending the criminal life as we defend the innocent life in the mother's womb.
00:21:55One of the things that a lot of people will come to know and just say, well, we can't understand exactly what it is, but we just know the Holy Father has said it, therefore we have to just believe it.
00:25:46And the last one to speak his cathedra is Pius XII.
00:25:49No one else has ever done that after him. So, you know, that's why we are ridiculed many times by other Christians. You adore the cult. You know, if he sneezes, then he sneezes in funny. That's, that's ridiculous.
00:26:07So we have there the evidence from the scriptures themselves, from our Lord, his own mouth, the witness of the church throughout the ages, the saints, doctors of the church, all saying it is.0.82
00:26:21Therefore, this catechism change, no matter how much it's banged on the drum by Leo XIV, will not stand, cannot stand.
00:26:30Monsignor Coronado, thank you so much for being with us.
00:26:34Yes, you are not obliged to follow him or the bishops or the whole conference of bishops all together if they cry loud and scream, saying that you will be in a state of mortal sin if you support death penalty.
00:27:41They teach you to obey authority, even the authority is wrong.
00:27:46Thank you so much, Monsignor Coronado, for joining us and bringing to us some clarity on the death penalty, its origins, the true teaching of the church.