The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast - October 04, 2026


Follow Whatever Glitters In The Corner

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Why You Read Their Eyes First Peterson Admits He Got This Wrong

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 55 minutes

Words per minute

145.61

Word count

16,882

Sentence count

722

Harmful content

Misogyny

10

sentences flagged

Toxicity

66

sentences flagged

Hate speech

35

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Tired of your car insurance rate going up even with a clean driving record?
00:00:04 You're not alone.
00:00:05 That's why there's Jerry, your proactive insurance assistant.
00:00:09 Jerry compares rates side-by-side from over 50 top insurers and helps you switch with ease.
00:00:14 Jerry even tracks market rates and alerts you when it's best to shop.
00:00:17 No spam calls, no hidden fees.
00:00:20 Drivers who save with Jerry could save over $1,300 a year.
00:00:24 Switch with confidence.
00:00:25 Download the Jerry app or visit jerry.ai slash wire.
00:00:30 what's that what's that and a warm new york welcome
00:00:37 thank you thank you it's so nice of you it's so good of you to be here tonight i know that
00:00:48 of all the people in the world who are blessed with opportunities to spend their time any way
00:00:52 they might choose you people are at the top of the list and i understand that you had many other
00:00:59 options for tonight's entertainment night really don't know what the hell you're doing here but
00:01:03 but i definitely i definitely appreciate the fact that you're here i'm going to tell you a story
00:01:10 it's it's one of the world's great stories it's a masterpiece of compression and depth
00:01:18 i've returned to it dozens of times in my lectures hundreds of times in my thinking
00:01:27 there's almost no limit to what can be discovered in it
00:01:31 even though it's only a few paragraphs long
00:01:33 it's hard to account for that precisely
00:01:37 although I'll try to account for that a little bit tonight
00:01:39 and to explain how such a thing can even be possible
00:01:43 that a story a few paragraphs long can be
00:01:46 in some ways inexhaustible
00:01:48 it doesn't exactly seem possible
00:01:57 You know, everything's inexhaustible in some ways, right?
00:02:02 Because everything is connected to everything else.
00:02:06 And if you love someone deeply, a child or your wife or your husband, a parent, sibling,
00:02:15 you can understand all of humanity as a consequence of that relationship.
00:02:22 if you investigate anything deeply enough you start to understand how it's connected to everything
00:02:28 and so everything that attracts your interest and is worthy of pursuit is a portal to the infinite
00:02:39 that's actually what the story of the burning bush means is a very good thing to know
00:02:45 and it's a good way of introducing the Cain and Abel story because
00:02:49 which is the story I'm going to tell you tonight
00:02:52 the Cain and Abel story
00:02:55 is a bottomless well of
00:02:56 revelation
00:02:57 and
00:02:59 it's a pointer
00:03:04 towards
00:03:05 the source of all
00:03:08 revelatory wisdom
00:03:10 in the story of Exodus
00:03:14 when Moses encounters
00:03:18 the burning bush
00:03:19 in some ways he's just an ordinary man now he has a strange parentage
00:03:26 he's the son of hebrew slaves and the adopted son of egyptian aristocrats and so that marks
00:03:35 him out in some ways is special he's a combination of what's lowest and what's highest but apart
00:03:41 from that when we encounter moses in the story of exodus at the time of the burning bush
00:03:47 he's just an ordinary man he actually has a relatively low status occupation he's a shepherd
00:03:54 now he has two wives and he's getting along with them fine and his he he has a good relationship
00:04:01 with his father-in-law whose name is jethro who's a very good man and he loves his wife and wives
00:04:07 and being a shepherd was a challenging occupation in ancient times
00:04:14 which is why the shepherd is a
00:04:18 icon of heroism
00:04:20 a shepherd has to
00:04:22 make his way with his wits
00:04:26 out in the wilderness
00:04:28 the wilderness of that time was characterized by
00:04:32 genuine danger
00:04:35 the not least of which were wolves and lions
00:04:39 and so if you're going to be a shepherd
00:04:41 you had to be the sort of man who could
00:04:44 live by his wits on the land
00:04:46 and who could protect
00:04:48 vulnerable, highly
00:04:50 edible
00:04:50 creatures from
00:04:53 predation and so
00:04:55 Moses is no pushover
00:04:58 but
00:04:59 he has an ordinary life
00:05:02 and then
00:05:04 something extraordinary
00:05:05 offers itself to him
00:05:07 okay, so
00:05:09 it's worthwhile understanding that
00:05:11 to understand how something
00:05:14 transcendent
00:05:18 offers itself to you.
00:05:22 Something magical.
00:05:24 What's something magical?
00:05:25 Something magical occurs in your life when
00:05:28 after you encounter it,
00:05:30 you play by a new set of rules.
00:05:33 That's the magic.
00:05:34 So, if you encounter someone
00:05:36 who lives in a world of conceptualization
00:05:39 that's radically different
00:05:40 than your current
00:05:41 world,
00:05:44 And what they can do looks magical to you, because not knowing their rules, not having their skills,
00:05:54 they're able to do things and perceive things in a way that's just not accessible to you.
00:06:00 Now and then in your life, you meet someone who transforms you profoundly.
00:06:05 That can happen in a relationship.
00:06:07 It often happens when you meet someone that you love or that you deeply admire.
00:06:11 Or someone who serves as a mentor, for example.
00:06:15 They're like a visitor from another kingdom.
00:06:17 And that new kingdom might be the kingdom that you would like to occupy.
00:06:21 If only you knew the rules.
00:06:26 Imagine that as you move through your life.
00:06:29 You transform sequentially.
00:06:31 There's really no end to that.
00:06:32 The amount that you can change.
00:06:33 The amount that you can develop.
00:06:36 Imagine that there's something in common.
00:06:39 among all the experiences
00:06:41 that magically transform you
00:06:43 from the smallest level
00:06:45 of magical transformation
00:06:46 to the cataclysmically transformative.
00:06:50 There are times in your life
00:06:51 where you have an experience
00:06:53 and you're not the same afterwards.
00:06:55 And that can be brutal,
00:06:56 although sometimes it can be very positive
00:06:58 or often it's both.
00:07:01 Moses is out
00:07:02 conducting himself as a shepherd
00:07:05 and he and something attracts his attention okay so that's the first thing to understand
00:07:14 you can be going about your business and something can attract your attention now this is a mystery
00:07:24 because we like to think that we're in control of our experience but that's truly wrong there are
00:07:33 some things that we're in control of but there's lots of things we're not in control of
00:07:37 for example you can fall in love with someone in a catastrophic way and that can easily happen to
00:07:44 you in some ways despite yourself you can find yourself foolishly entangled in a in an affair
00:07:50 let's say and if you escape from that unscathed which is highly improbable you could easily look
00:08:00 back and think especially if you got tangled up with the wrong person what the hell happened to
00:08:06 me and what happened to you is that the things that beckon to you have an autonomy this is a
00:08:16 very strange thing so let me make a reference to something else back in the late 1800s
00:08:25 Friedrich Nietzsche
00:08:27 the German philosopher announced that
00:08:29 announced the death
00:08:32 of God and what he meant by that was that
00:08:34 the unquestioned
00:08:35 faith that was
00:08:37 present in the West in relationship
00:08:39 to what we held highest
00:08:41 had become
00:08:42 intellectually
00:08:44 had become
00:08:46 was demolished
00:08:48 intellectually
00:08:50 God died
00:08:52 this was not something Nietzsche was pleased about
00:08:54 He thought that the consequence of that would be the rise of a murderous nihilism
00:09:00 and the emergence of ideologies of resentment like communism that would kill tens of millions of people.
00:09:10 When what's held highest disappears, new forces emerge to compete for that position of dominance.
00:09:19 Nietzsche's
00:09:22 diagnosis of that
00:09:27 and then offering of a cure
00:09:29 was that because there was no longer
00:09:30 anything of transcendent
00:09:33 divinity
00:09:35 we would have to 0.86
00:09:37 create our own values
00:09:39 we'd have to take on to ourselves
00:09:42 the burden of
00:09:47 generating
00:09:49 Meaning itself.
00:09:55 All of existential philosophy, in some ways, came out of that idea.
00:09:58 That human beings had to take on the burden of creating the meaning in their life themselves.
00:10:04 And that if we stepped forward, we could do that in a manner that would enable us to thrive,
00:10:10 despite having severed our connection with heaven, let's say.
00:10:14 it didn't take very long before the psychoanalysts
00:10:18 generated the most profound critique
00:10:23 of that proposition
00:10:25 Freud first and then Carl Jung
00:10:29 who was a real student of Nietzsche
00:10:30 both Freud and Jung noted that
00:10:34 you can't create your own values
00:10:37 because you're not in control of yourself
00:10:38 you're not the sort of creature that
00:10:42 can just tell yourself what to do.
00:10:45 You know that.
00:10:46 You're no more obedient to you
00:10:49 than anyone else around you is obedient to you.
00:10:52 You can have all the good intentions in the world,
00:10:54 but that doesn't mean you're going to follow them.
00:10:55 People make resolutions to improve themselves constantly,
00:11:01 and sometimes people do that,
00:11:02 but it's equally likely that you'll wander off in some direction
00:11:06 that's not only not the direction you decided was appropriate,
00:11:09 but really contrary to it you're a place you're a playhouse of demons that's one way of thinking
00:11:17 about it you're a war of competing proclivities and motivations and they have an autonomy you can
00:11:25 fall under their sway this certainly happens when you fall in love it's like well when what's
00:11:30 happening when you fall in love exactly when you're when you find yourself attracted to someone
00:11:34 Well, there's a sexual element, but it isn't exactly that that feels to you as something you've decided to do.
00:11:43 What it feels like is you encounter someone who's unbearably attractive, right?
00:11:47 It's the motive force of their attraction appears to you as something external.
00:11:55 It's certainly not under your control. 1.00
00:11:57 You can make an absolute bloody fool of yourself. 1.00
00:12:00 In fact, it's highly likely that you will. 1.00
00:12:02 despite your best efforts.
00:12:08 So you can see that with love.
00:12:10 You can see that with sexual attraction.
00:12:12 But you can also see it in a more mundane way,
00:12:16 arguably, with what you're interested in.
00:12:19 Like, you have to discover what you're interested in.
00:12:25 And maybe that makes itself manifest in your life
00:12:27 at a very early age.
00:12:28 I've interviewed many people who've been very successful in their life,
00:12:34 and asked them about how it was that they came to know what they were interested in.
00:12:39 Jocko Willink's a good example of that.
00:12:41 Jocko Willink is a Navy SEAL.
00:12:43 Very tough guy.
00:12:45 He's about four feet thick.
00:12:46 He looks like two Joe Rogans compacted together.
00:12:51 And he said he knew he wanted to engage in mayhem from the time he was three.
00:12:56 like that was
00:12:58 that was there for him
00:13:00 it called to him
00:13:01 and it's frequently the case that
00:13:03 there are things in our lives
00:13:05 that call to us
00:13:06 one of the definitions of God
00:13:08 that permeates the
00:13:10 biblical library is that
00:13:13 God is the source of all the things
00:13:15 that call to you
00:13:16 and here's a way of understanding that
00:13:20 there's going to be times in your life
00:13:21 where you're interested in one thing
00:13:23 and that'll lead you somewhere
00:13:24 and then when you get there
00:13:25 you'll be interested in something else. And so that interest changes, right? But the fact that
00:13:30 something's interesting, the fact that something interesting is calling to you, is stable across
00:13:37 your transformations. And what that implies is that there's a spirit of transformation
00:13:44 operating behind all the particular things that interest you, that guide you forward.
00:13:50 carl jung believed that that was the same thing as the instinct to develop here's a way of thinking
00:13:58 about that as you're imagine you as a child or imagine your own children you know they get
00:14:03 interested in something they want to make a new friend they want to go to school they get
00:14:08 interested in a new toy and that interest motivates them to develop new skills and new ways of looking
00:14:15 at the world. And as a consequence, they become more than they are. And so you can see that
00:14:23 interest as the manifestation of the instinct that impels them towards development. And you
00:14:28 want to encourage that. You're generally pretty happy if your child takes an intense interest in
00:14:33 a sport, let's say, or a hobby, or a friendship for that matter. Because if they do that diligently,
00:14:40 the consequence of that will be that they're highly motivated which is a lovely thing to see
00:14:46 in your children but also that they'll become more than they are and so you can think of the
00:14:51 the calling as the manifestation of the spirit that calls you to develop that's what happens
00:15:00 to Moses so he's out there on the desert plain taking care of his sheep and something attracts
00:15:07 his attention and it's not a forest fire something that you could you couldn't ignore
00:15:15 at all it's not something absolutely overwhelming it's more like a gesture or an invitation that's
00:15:23 a good way of thinking about it an invitation it's something that glitters and gleams in the
00:15:29 corner of your eye that pulls you towards something new that compels you or invites you to step off
00:15:37 the beaten track and when you step off the beaten track that's when you're new somewhere new you go
00:15:42 somewhere new and that's when you develop and so your interest is one of the things that
00:15:46 pulls you off the beaten track towards
00:15:49 towards the new land you could inhabit if you became the new person you could become
00:15:56 so called peterson academy peterson academy peterson academy it's called peterson academy
00:16:03 Peterson Academy if you want an actual education with hand-selected professors from top universities
00:16:09 around the world bringing the best professors together making sure they're not censored in
00:16:14 any way giving them the audience and the remuneration and appreciation they deserve
00:16:17 and you were true to your word you gave me absolute intellectual autonomy I have had it
00:16:21 through every course we figure we can offer people a high quality university level education for
00:16:26 under $2,000 well congratulations Jordan it's honestly brilliant can't wait to enroll myself
00:16:31 I'll be doing that straight after this.
00:16:34 Fangio.
00:16:40 When God comes to Abraham,
00:16:42 Abraham is about 70 when this happens.
00:16:46 He's a rich, he's the son of rich parents.
00:16:49 And what that means is Abraham could just lull around the tent
00:16:52 and has for seven decades, failure to launch.
00:16:57 And there's no reason for him to leave
00:16:58 because all his needs are gratified.
00:17:03 And you might say, well, if all your needs are gratified,
00:17:06 then why do anything?
00:17:08 And that's a very good question for rich and privileged people.
00:17:13 And the answer to that is something like,
00:17:15 all your needs aren't gratified by having your needs gratified.
00:17:19 The need for difficulty, for example, the need for challenge,
00:17:22 the need for development, the need for play, the need for adventure.
00:17:28 Those might arguably be the most profound need, so to speak.
00:17:35 God comes to Abraham as the calling to adventure.
00:17:39 God comes to Abraham and says, look, you've been hanging around your tent there, buddy, for 70 years.
00:17:46 It's getting kind of ugly.
00:17:50 Leave your zone of comfort.
00:17:53 Leave your father's tent.
00:17:55 Leave your family.
00:17:56 Leave your community. 1.00
00:17:56 leave everything you know and venture out into the world in all its catastrophe and abraham commits
00:18:04 to that he agrees to that and he also agrees to make the sacrifices along the way that enable his
00:18:12 transformation as he pursues his adventure that's really what the story of abraham is about and god
00:18:18 makes him a deal which is a very interesting deal it's unbelievably worth knowing it's like the
00:18:24 secret to life, in a way. God says, if you commit yourself wholeheartedly to the spirit
00:18:34 of adventure, and you make the necessary sacrifices along the way, as you're called upon
00:18:41 to transform, you'll turn into who you most deeply are. And the consequence of that will
00:18:47 be that you're a blessing to yourself, so that's a good deal, that your reputation will
00:18:55 expand, your name will become known, but not in a narcissistic and shallow manner, you'll
00:19:02 become known as, you'll become known for the same reason that people who are capable and
00:19:10 competent and productive and generous and hospitable are known.
00:19:13 so you'll earn your reputation
00:19:17 it's the opposite of narcissism
00:19:19 and the fact that your reputation will expand
00:19:22 will increase your opportunities
00:19:23 obviously
00:19:24 but it'll increase them
00:19:26 and this is the next step
00:19:28 it'll increase them in a manner
00:19:31 that makes itself manifest in two ways
00:19:34 first is there's some reasonable probability
00:19:37 that you'll establish something permanent
00:19:39 so Abraham is offered the opportunity to father nations
00:19:43 So, the idea is that if he follows the calling to opportunity, that the consequence of that
00:19:54 will be that his children and grandchildren and great-grandchildren, he'll establish the
00:20:00 pattern that radically increases the probability that his descendants will be numerous and
00:20:09 successful right and that's in keeping with the impetus to adventure and then this is the capper
00:20:17 god says and if you do all that you'll do it in a way that's a blessing to everyone else
00:20:20 and so there's a vision of like a multi-dimensional harmony and it's a very optimistic idea so imagine
00:20:28 that you threw caution to the wind let's say although not wisdom and and intelligence and
00:20:34 you said, well, I'm going to pursue adventure, the adventure that calls to me with no holds
00:20:40 part, what will happen? The offer is, well, you'll be way better for yourself. More than
00:20:47 you can even imagine. But, that will happen in a way that will expand your reputation
00:20:53 in a valid manner, that will increase the probability that you'll do something worthwhile
00:20:57 and permanent, and you'll do it in a way that's very, very useful and good for everyone else.
00:21:01 and so what the offering there is that
00:21:06 that courage to allow yourself to unfold and develop
00:21:12 which is probably what you want more than anything else anyways
00:21:16 because that's where all the adventurous joy in life is
00:21:19 that's identical if it's made manifest properly
00:21:22 to the pattern that sets the world in order socially
00:21:26 across the largest possible span of time
00:21:29 And then you might think, well, how could it be any other way?
00:21:32 Like, you know perfectly well with your children,
00:21:34 you want to encourage your children to develop and to become competent,
00:21:39 radically competent, so that they can live in the world without having to depend on you,
00:21:43 so that they can go out and encounter all the catastrophes of the world head-on,
00:21:47 and not only manage, but thrive.
00:21:51 You assume that if they did that in the best possible manner, that that would be good for them,
00:21:55 and that they'd have friends in consequence of that
00:21:59 and that they'd increase their probability of actual accomplishment and success
00:22:04 and that it would be good for everyone else.
00:22:08 And the alternative hypothesis would be something like,
00:22:11 well, if you followed the calling of adventure, 0.97
00:22:15 you'd be a deceitful, self-serving narcissist
00:22:18 and that instinct would set you at cross-purposes with everyone else.
00:22:23 and that just seems it just seems unlikely like how likely is it that the spirit that calls you
00:22:29 to become all you are isn't the same spirit that aligns us communally and socially across
00:22:35 the longest possible span of time it's sort of like a definition of an adaptation
00:22:41 if we weren't structured in that manner the best of us would produce the worst possible social
00:22:50 outcome well no obviously okay so moses goes and investigates the burning bush and
00:22:59 why is it a burning bush well everything alive is on fire
00:23:07 so it's it's life heightened that's a good way of hallucinogenically heightened it's the spirit
00:23:20 Because fire is an agent of transformation and something that's alive is burning, but staying the same at the same time
00:23:27 There's no difference between that metabolism and I would say in some ways you're most alive when you're most on fire
00:23:35 Right so that the the process of weirdly enough you're you're who you are most deeply when you're 1.00
00:23:41 Transforming as brutally as you can manage and so that's what Moses encounters he encounters the the spirit of 0.97
00:23:49 of what calls you to attend that transforms you.
00:23:54 And he investigates that.
00:23:56 Okay, so how does that roll out in your life?
00:23:59 Well, to the degree that you pursued anything genuinely in your life,
00:24:06 something called to you and you followed it.
00:24:09 You became fascinated by something, right?
00:24:11 Which means it grabbed you and you locked onto it.
00:24:15 You entered into a relationship with that thing that fascinated you.
00:24:18 And that took you down a pathway, and the pathway deepened as you investigated, didn't it?
00:24:25 And you learned more and more as a consequence of your commitment to it,
00:24:28 and the consequence of that was that you transformed.
00:24:32 Now, Moses does that to the ultimate degree.
00:24:36 Like Abraham, he's fully committed, and what happens to Moses is that the voice of God itself reveals itself to him.
00:24:43 And this is a definition.
00:24:45 so the idea is that if you attended without reservation in good faith and with courage
00:24:52 to those things that compelled you forward and you committed to that investigation that you would
00:24:59 look into the structure of reality so deeply that the underlying spirit that animated everything
00:25:05 would become known to you and you might say well i don't believe that it's like it's not so obvious
00:25:12 what we believe and what we don't believe, we know perfectly well that the best moments
00:25:17 in our life occur as a consequence of taking something like a calling with all due seriousness.
00:25:24 And we understand not only that that devoted serious attention does broaden our capacity
00:25:34 to understand and deepen our souls and our understanding of the world, but also makes
00:25:41 us more compelling to other people. One of the things, if you're talking to someone or
00:25:51 interviewing them, and you want the conversation to light on fire to be a transforming conversation,
00:25:59 you can ask people what they're interested in. And if you listen, they'll start telling
00:26:05 you, and when they start telling you, they light up. Everyone knows what that means.
00:26:09 and they get extremely interesting.
00:26:12 And, you know, if you can find out what someone loves,
00:26:15 which is what you do for someone that you do love,
00:26:18 is you find out what they love and you encourage that,
00:26:23 then the best of them comes out and they become charismatic.
00:26:31 So when Moses, when God reveals himself to Moses,
00:26:35 God tells Moses that now he's to become a leader.
00:26:39 And Moses says, well, I don't think so.
00:26:42 I'm slow of tongue.
00:26:43 Moses has, he's not a good communicator.
00:26:46 Maybe he has a speech impediment.
00:26:47 We don't really know.
00:26:48 But communication isn't his forte.
00:26:51 And God basically says to him two things.
00:26:53 First, that's your problem.
00:26:56 Like, you're called upon to resist tyranny and to lead yourself and your fellow man away from slavery,
00:27:05 no matter what your inadequacies.
00:27:07 and then god also says people will listen to you because you will tell them that you're coming in
00:27:14 my name and you might say well what does that mean well imagine the circumstances in your life where
00:27:22 people have listened to you now you can imagine that happening in two ways you're manipulating
00:27:27 them you're selling them something you're lying i mean selling in the you know manipulative manner 1.00
00:27:32 where you offer junk to idiots to take advantage of them. 1.00
00:27:36 That isn't what I mean. 1.00
00:27:38 I mean, imagine how effective you are as a model
00:27:44 when what you're offering to people in your communication
00:27:48 is a revelation of that which you find most deeply meaningful.
00:27:53 People will listen to you then
00:27:54 because the best of you is revealing itself
00:27:57 in a way that helps them reveal the best in them.
00:28:00 you certainly do that as a parent if you have any sense
00:28:03 it's often in those familial relationships that the best of us can make itself manifest
00:28:08 sometimes the worst too, but you get my point
00:28:12 is that insofar as you're capable of making an account of how what you've been
00:28:18 what you're committed to has transformed your life
00:28:22 and you do that honestly, people are going to listen to you
00:28:25 now it's kind of strange that that's the case
00:28:28 But, you know, when you hear someone speak, you can tell the difference, usually.
00:28:33 This can be game.
00:28:34 But you can tell the difference between when they're genuine and interesting.
00:28:37 And those two things really are very closely aligned.
00:28:40 And when they're false and dull.
00:28:42 And false is almost always dull.
00:28:45 Genuine is almost always compelling, even if it's inarticulate.
00:28:49 You know, you meet people now and then who are of stellar moral character,
00:28:52 but can't really make much of an argument.
00:28:54 But that doesn't, you still listen to them.
00:28:55 there's still something about the way they conduct themselves that's compelling
00:28:58 that's basically what God offers to Moses
00:29:00 he said well if you tell people that you've come in my name they'll listen
00:29:04 well people will listen to you if you tell the truth
00:29:07 so because their souls can discriminate between truth and falsehood
00:29:13 and so
00:29:15 and God tells Moses as a consequence of investigating this burning bush
00:29:22 that he's to go back to his wayward and enslaved people
00:29:28 and free them from tyranny and lead them away from slavery
00:29:32 and traverse the desert and head to the promised land.
00:29:37 And that's what a leader does.
00:29:39 A leader always stands up against tyranny.
00:29:42 Sometimes it's the tyranny of his own soul.
00:29:45 You can tyrannize yourself.
00:29:47 He always stands up against slavery, and the same thing applies there.
00:29:50 You can be a slave to your own convictions. 1.00
00:29:54 You can be a slave to your idiot ideology. 1.00
00:29:57 You can be a slave in your marriage. 1.00
00:29:59 You can be a slave to your children. 0.95
00:30:01 You can be a slave in a totalitarian state.
00:30:04 You're going to have that dynamism of tyrant and slave in your life in all times.
00:30:10 Not the mere archaic biblical.
00:30:13 It's the same thing always.
00:30:14 And a leader is always the person who calls the slaves to adopt responsibility,
00:30:22 the responsibility that's ennobling, and who stands up against the tyrant.
00:30:27 And the injunction in the Exodus story is that if you attend to that which compels you forward,
00:30:37 you'll become the leader that is capable of doing exactly that.
00:30:41 and you know that too because of those times in your life where you've pursued what you've been
00:30:48 interested in without reservation and developed in consequence offers to you a kingdom within which
00:30:56 you're sovereign and a space in which you can speak about what you know in a manner that
00:31:03 compels and invites others.
00:31:06 So,
00:31:07 so that's the burning bush.
00:31:11 The burning bush is what calls you to adventure.
00:31:14 It's not all that calls you to adventure.
00:31:17 But it's one major element of what calls you to adventure.
00:31:20 In the biblical stories,
00:31:22 God is defined as the spirit of adventure.
00:31:26 Right?
00:31:27 This is very much worth knowing,
00:31:29 because modern people don't know where to find God, so to speak.
00:31:33 God comes to you with the offering of meaning
00:31:40 That's a good way of thinking about it
00:31:43 And the place that meaning reveals itself can transform
00:31:47 But the ultimate source of the meaning is constant
00:31:49 When you approach something that's meaningful
00:31:52 You might change enough so that that pursuit
00:31:55 You've exhausted that pursuit so it's no longer meaningful
00:31:59 and something new offers itself as your next destination.
00:32:04 But it's the same thing again.
00:32:07 And it's different for every person,
00:32:09 because what you're interested in isn't going to be what you're interested in.
00:32:12 There might be some overlap, but it's very particularized.
00:32:15 But it doesn't matter, because it's all pointing.
00:32:17 This is the monotheistic hypothesis.
00:32:19 It's all pointing to the same thing.
00:32:22 And so, okay, so what's a burning bush?
00:32:25 In relationship to what I'm going to talk to you about tonight.
00:32:27 The story of Cain and Abel is a burning bush.
00:32:31 It's a story that's been sufficiently interesting
00:32:35 so that people have remembered it and told it
00:32:39 for thousands and thousands of years.
00:32:40 We have no idea for how long.
00:32:43 It's a very, very old story,
00:32:45 and it's very old in its written form,
00:32:47 but the older a story is in the written form,
00:32:51 the more likely it is that it's way older than that in an oral form.
00:32:54 So like a story that's, say, 4,000 years old
00:32:57 is probably a story that's 50,000 years old.
00:33:01 So, partly because the farther you go back in time,
00:33:04 the slower things change.
00:33:06 So, if something exists at any point in the past,
00:33:08 it's very, very likely that it's existed for an immense amount of time.
00:33:12 Okay, so, let's unpack the story of Cain and Abel.
00:33:17 This burning bush.
00:33:19 And let's see where it takes us.
00:33:21 So, Cain and Abel are the first two human beings.
00:33:27 That's a good way of thinking about it.
00:33:28 Now, you might think, well, no, it's Adam and Eve.
00:33:30 It's like, no, not really, because they're made by God.
00:33:33 And so they don't really count.
00:33:34 They're sort of, they're unique.
00:33:39 They're not born.
00:33:42 Cain and Abel are the first two people born after the fall when history starts.
00:33:49 Adam and Eve are made by God, and they live in the Garden of Paradise.
00:33:52 And that's not true for any of you.
00:33:53 and it's not true for Cain and Abel
00:33:56 so in a way, Adam and Eve are your ancestors
00:33:59 insofar as they're the primordial mother and father of all
00:34:03 but in history, in the fallen world
00:34:07 Cain and Abel are the first two human beings
00:34:11 okay, now they're brothers as well
00:34:14 now they establish a pattern
00:34:16 now when Eve gives birth to Cain and Abel
00:34:19 she says, I've gotten a man from God
00:34:22 And the reason she says that is it's a precursor, it's of the same pattern as Mary's proclamation in the Gospels that her son Christ is a consequence of her impregnation by God.
00:34:41 And so what does that mean, at minimum, psychologically?
00:34:44 Well, it means the father, biological father, contributes to reproduction, obviously,
00:34:54 but in some ways very little.
00:34:58 It's not a lot of work, right?
00:35:02 And in a way, you don't have much to do with it.
00:35:05 Like, you didn't create your body.
00:35:07 You didn't generate any of the biological processes that give rise to the baby.
00:35:13 The thing that you actually contribute is 10 million times smaller than the egg.
00:35:20 So that's a lot. 0.96
00:35:21 Actually, the definition of female is that sex which contributes most to reproduction.
00:35:27 That's a deeper definition than even the chromosomal definition.
00:35:31 And so the male contributes something necessary, but most of the work is God and the woman.
00:35:41 right and so that's all
00:35:45 see the man can make up for that as time goes by because he can stick around
00:35:53 that's what joseph does right that's what joseph does in good faith
00:36:00 and that's when his contribution is elevated beyond the merely whimsical let's say or beyond
00:36:07 beyond the realm of immediate gratification.
00:36:10 That's all prefigured in that very
00:36:12 condensed statement
00:36:16 that Eve makes about her gratitude
00:36:21 for having been given her sons.
00:36:26 Her sons are at war.
00:36:29 Okay, why?
00:36:31 Well, Cain and Abel represent
00:36:33 two diametrically opposed patterns of adaptation
00:36:36 to the fallen world okay so what do we know about the fallen world we know that it's a world that
00:36:43 requires sacrifice okay so when adam and eve are chased out of paradise actually when
00:36:49 they fall out of paradise as a consequence of their pride
00:36:53 god tells them that they're going to have to work that the woman's work in large part is going to
00:37:02 be centered around the sacrifices intended upon establishing a relationship with a man which is
00:37:09 by necessity in some manner dependent in contrast to him because she has to make herself vulnerable
00:37:17 in consequence of being a mother that's her fate and that's basically what god tells eve it's like
00:37:25 well you've mucked things up because of your pride you're now in the fallen world
00:37:30 now you're stuck with this man and you're going to be beholden to him he's not saying that's how
00:37:37 it should be he's saying that's how it's going to be and then he tells adam well you're in trouble 0.99
00:37:42 too because as a consequence of your idiocy and your pride not least in agreeing without resistance 0.99
00:37:52 to everything eve offered you and then blaming her for the corruption that emerged as a consequence 0.99
00:37:58 your life is going to your work is going to become painful and difficult and the world won't easily
00:38:06 bring forth its abundance to you so what does all that mean well one of the things it means is the
00:38:14 more prideful and arrogant you are the harder your work's going to be right so and you can imagine
00:38:20 this too you know even if you have a rough job if you were wise enough to have some gratitude for
00:38:28 that and you entered into it in the full spirit of sacrifice and you did your difficult job
00:38:37 without victimizing yourself and with full commitment, first of all, you might be able to
00:38:44 take some joy in that job and a joy that might be commensurate with the transformation of your
00:38:50 attitude. But it might also be the case that to the degree that you could accept your starting
00:38:56 point without bitterness and resentment and you could commit wholeheartedly to the task at hand
00:39:01 that you would start to transform in a way that would take you out of that lowly position very
00:39:08 rapidly i would say in most societies that are reasonably functional and the united states is
00:39:14 probably first and foremost in the world in this regard is that you can start in a pretty miserable
00:39:19 place and if you are careful and you make the proper sacrifices things can get better for you
00:39:27 very very rapidly now to the degree that your society is just and productive and generous and
00:39:34 stable that's increasingly likely but likely your country has done that better than any country's
00:39:40 ever done it and it's certainly in the situation now where you're still doing that better than it's
00:39:45 done anywhere else so okay so adam and or cain and abel they're born into a world where sacrifice
00:39:54 is a necessity okay so now we need to understand what that means because if you want to understand
00:39:59 the western the story of the west and you want to understand the stories upon which the west
00:40:06 itself is predicated you have to understand what sacrifice means because the entire biblical
00:40:11 corpus which is the foundational text of the west is a meta story about sacrifice and it's very hard
00:40:18 for modern people to wrap their heads around this because they don't know what the hell sacrifice
00:40:22 means so when i used to teach at the university of toronto i had a lot of immigrant kids in my
00:40:27 class most of them asians children of first generation immigrants and i would ask them when
00:40:33 i was trying to elucidate this i'd ask them what did your parents sacrifice to get you here and
00:40:39 believe me at least among the asian kids there there wasn't much doubt about that because their 0.99
00:40:45 parents had told them like 8 000 times what they had sacrificed to get them to that damn university 0.98
00:40:51 and part of that informing was screw up and you'll pay for it because we put everything on the line 0.98
00:40:58 for you and that was dead serious and so those kids were often firmly committed in a manner that
00:41:04 Was likely to make them more successful
00:41:07 But they knew what the sacrifice meant
00:41:09 Okay, but what
00:41:09 So
00:41:10 What does it mean that you sacrifice
00:41:12 Or even more than that
00:41:14 What does it mean that that's the pattern of human adaptation
00:41:16 Or even more than that
00:41:18 What does it mean that you sacrifice in relationship to God
00:41:22 Well, those are complicated questions
00:41:24 Well, let's start with sacrifice itself
00:41:26 There's no difference between sacrifice and maturity
00:41:29 Okay, so
00:41:32 You can even think about this
00:41:33 physiologically what happens to you when you mature is that you replace your subjugation
00:41:43 to your short-term self-centered biological whims with the ability to delay gratification
00:41:55 plan for the future and engage in reciprocal play in reciprocal offering so if if you and i are going
00:42:07 to play a game one of the sacrifices i make to play that game is you get to have a turn
00:42:13 and even more profoundly now and then you get to pick the game and so you see among children who
00:42:21 were radically unpopular, that the reason they're unpopular is because they don't ever
00:42:27 let anybody else have a turn, and no one else ever gets to pick the game. It's like my game
00:42:33 or no game, which is one of the claims that's at the heart of the current culture war, by
00:42:38 the way. I am whoever I say I am, and you better not get in my way. It's like, well,
00:42:46 that's all well and good for you, except nobody's going to want to play with you, because
00:42:51 Why would they?
00:42:52 It's like, you're going to run your marriage that way?
00:42:55 It's like, you're just whoever you are in whatever way you want to be at every given second,
00:43:00 and your partner doesn't get a say in the matter.
00:43:03 Well, first of all, you do that for a few years, and you're like,
00:43:07 you're so far away from the straight and narrow path that you're going to be in your own particular form of hell.
00:43:11 Because if you're ruled by nothing else than your immediate whim,
00:43:16 you're going to end up in a place that's brutally miserable and isolated.
00:43:21 Your identity is negotiated all the time.
00:43:24 If you're in communal relationship, if you have a wife or a husband,
00:43:28 if you have children, if you have parents, if you have friends,
00:43:31 you're taking turns and making sacrifices at every second.
00:43:36 And the better you are at that, the better those relationships are going to be.
00:43:41 You know, I mean, it's not a useful thing to turn yourself into a martyr
00:43:46 in relationship to your wife, but it's a very good thing to offer to your children
00:43:53 and your wife and your friends and your community the best that you have to offer.
00:43:59 It's a very good thing to forestall your demand for immediate hedonic self-gratification
00:44:05 for the sake of a higher unity.
00:44:08 when you're disciplining two-year-olds you're not punishing them for being selfish that's not
00:44:18 what you're doing not if you're doing it right what you're doing is freeing them from the
00:44:23 subjugation of their immediate whim so that could be their boisterousness it could be their sorrow
00:44:29 it could be their rage it could be their exhaustion and replacing that with the ability
00:44:37 to regulate their emotions in a manner that allows them to become
00:44:43 the sort of person who's eminently desirable as a friend and partner.
00:44:48 That's the purpose of discipline.
00:44:51 And there's no difference between that and cortical maturation.
00:44:55 Those are the same things.
00:44:56 You're born into the world a warring battleground of short-term motivation and emotion.
00:45:04 That's what a two-year-old is.
00:45:05 There's something fascinating about that.
00:45:07 It's fun to be around two-year-olds because they're so alive, right?
00:45:11 When they're angry, it's like they're 100% angry.
00:45:14 It's kind of a miracle.
00:45:15 They can lay on the ground and kick and hold their breath until they turn blue.
00:45:21 That's, if you ever saw an adult do that, it would take you like five years to recover.
00:45:29 So, and there are forms of adult pathology where the person afflicted is so immature
00:45:34 that they're capable of having that kind of fit of rage it's a terrifying thing
00:45:39 to observe you certainly don't want to see that ever let alone every day people
00:45:45 who are very afflicted by a pathologically prolonged immaturity will
00:45:51 use the threat of that to obtain what they want don't upset your mother
00:45:56 whatever you do don't upset your mother could be your father too but you know
00:46:01 what I mean is that behind that threat is the notion of explosive emotionality wielded as a
00:46:07 weapon. When you help your child mature, you help them substitute the kind of integration that
00:46:14 enables them to regulate all their emotions and their motivations with an eye to the long run
00:46:22 so that they don't do things in the short term that hurt them in the medium to long run,
00:46:27 but also in a manner that makes them eminently desirable socially.
00:46:32 So they can have friends.
00:46:34 That's all sacrifice.
00:46:36 So human beings, when we became aware that we were naked and mortal,
00:46:41 when we became aware that we were subject to pain and death,
00:46:45 when we started to understand that,
00:46:47 when we knew we had a boundary in time,
00:46:50 we started to sacrifice.
00:46:52 And what did we do?
00:46:53 We started to work.
00:46:55 There's no difference between sacrifice and maturity.
00:46:57 But there's also no difference between sacrifice and work.
00:47:01 They're the same concept.
00:47:03 Why?
00:47:03 Well, work is sacrificial.
00:47:05 Well, why?
00:47:06 Well, because when you work, you sacrifice the present for the future.
00:47:10 It's like the definition of work.
00:47:11 It's like you're not doing exactly what you want to do right now at this moment,
00:47:16 because that would be play.
00:47:18 What you're doing instead is foregoing the need for immediate self-gratification
00:47:24 so that things will be better for you in the medium to long term
00:47:29 in a way that's also better for your wife and your kids and your community.
00:47:33 And that's sacrificial.
00:47:34 And there's a certain pain that's associated with it.
00:47:37 People are relieved when it's Friday, you know,
00:47:39 so they can let their hair down a little bit so they're not in harness,
00:47:43 even though it's necessary to be in harness.
00:47:45 We know that our life is sacrificial.
00:47:47 So part of the mystery of our life is, well, how do we conduct ourselves sacrificially in the highest manner?
00:47:53 Which is, what sacrifices are optimally pleasing to God?
00:47:57 It's the same question.
00:47:59 And what does that pattern of optimal sacrifice, how does it appear?
00:48:06 Well, this is exactly the mystery that's presented in the story of Cain and Abel.
00:48:12 So, Cain is an agriculturalist, and Abel is a keeper of, he's a shepherd.
00:48:20 We talked about shepherds already.
00:48:22 He's a shepherd.
00:48:24 And Cain and Abel make offerings to God.
00:48:28 So they both have their jobs, and they both make offerings.
00:48:32 Well, your job is an offering.
00:48:34 Your job is not only an offering, it's a covenantal offering.
00:48:38 It's a contractual offering.
00:48:40 Here's why.
00:48:41 You assume, if you work, that you're banking the consequences of your work in the future.
00:48:48 You're making a contract with the future.
00:48:51 The contract is, if I give up, if I work, if I give up my hedonic self-gratification in the present,
00:48:58 and I invest, let's say, that that will pay off.
00:49:02 Okay, so pay off in what way?
00:49:04 Well, if your society is well-organized, it'll pay off because the deal is that no one will steal what you've worked for.
00:49:17 That's a really hard thing to establish.
00:49:19 Because the default is, well, you have something I don't. 0.99
00:49:22 You took it from me, and it's okay to kill you to get it back. 0.98
00:49:28 Like, that's the fate of mankind almost everywhere, almost always. 0.98
00:49:32 You have to have one sophisticated society before it's default okay that people bank up their wealth.
00:49:39 But if that isn't okay, then you don't have any wealth.
00:49:43 Because if the rule is you have some wealth as a consequence of sacrifice and then you die,
00:49:49 no one is going to work, obviously.
00:49:53 And so you can imagine that that sacrificial covenant is a contractual arrangement with the future and with the community that if you make the proper offering, you'll be rewarded in proportion.
00:50:16 That's your faith in your community.
00:50:18 That's your faith in the future.
00:50:19 Look, we know that as someone's life becomes more radically unpredictable and unstable,
00:50:24 because their community is degenerating,
00:50:27 they'll turn to short-term gratification as a strategy.
00:50:30 And it's because if you can't rely on your community,
00:50:35 you can't store anything of value up.
00:50:37 Why in the world would you make any sacrifices? 1.00
00:50:40 You're just a fool then. 1.00
00:50:42 You sacrifice in the present so you have no short-term gratification, 1.00
00:50:46 but there's no payoff.
00:50:47 well no one's going to do that you want to set up your society so that your
00:50:52 sacrificial offerings are banked and stored the best way to do that by the
00:50:58 way is not in money but in reputation the the best storehouse of wealth for
00:51:07 sacrifice is in your reputation for generosity hospitality and productive
00:51:14 self-sacrifice. Is if people think highly of you, genuinely, then you're protected against every
00:51:22 storm in a way that nothing else can protect you. And that's how what's moral and highest
00:51:30 lines up perfectly with the spirit of the highest possible sacrifice. Okay, so Cain and Abel,
00:51:37 sacrifice. Now, we don't hear much about Cain's sacrifices. We only know that he offers up the
00:51:43 fruits of the soil the story doesn't say much else about that it does say a fair bit about abel's
00:51:48 sacrifice it says that what abel does is he takes the best of the best and he offers that to god
00:51:53 so he has unblemished perfect animals and he takes the cuts of meat from those animals that 0.63
00:52:01 are of the highest quality and then he cuts off the parts of those that are of the highest quality
00:52:09 the fattiest cuts, and he offers them to God. Okay, and so how does he do that? Well, he does
00:52:15 that on an altar. He burns them. Okay, so first of all, the burning. Remember, people are acting
00:52:20 this out, eh? They're trying to grapple with something they don't understand, which is the
00:52:24 spirit of sacrifice. People are learning that they can sacrifice the present for the future,
00:52:29 that they can store value. They're trying to figure out what that means. They do it the way
00:52:35 children do it in some ways. They dramatize it. They play it out. And it's all an attempt to
00:52:39 come to understand it more and more explicitly. It's the dream. It's the dream of the
00:52:47 representation of sacrifice. They offer it to God. They offer Cain, Abel, offers his best to God.
00:52:54 Okay, what does that mean? It means that if you offer your best, you're most likely to be accepted.
00:53:01 That's the deal.
00:53:02 Now, you might be cynical about that.
00:53:05 Say, well, I'm best punished for my virtues.
00:53:07 I've tried very, very hard, and I haven't been accepted.
00:53:09 But let's take that apart a little bit.
00:53:12 Look, if you have a son, and you love him, you don't say to him, ever,
00:53:16 really, even if you're a criminal, although there's some, you know,
00:53:21 deviation from this among criminal subcultures,
00:53:23 you don't say to him, look, kid, here's how you should conduct yourself.
00:53:28 You should lie and cheat and steal whenever you get a chance. 0.97
00:53:30 deceit is your best move forward you should always stab a friend in the back if it's going 0.89
00:53:37 to be useful to you if you're on a sports team hog the glory and distribute the blame
00:53:42 and manipulate and short change at every opportunity okay first of all you'd never 0.67
00:53:49 say that to anyone you love even if you're pretty damn bent and people who are criminal
00:53:55 even at the extremes, are generally not so delusional that they'll teach those lessons
00:54:04 directly to their own children. Now, I understand that, as I said, that you can be so lost that
00:54:09 you'll actually want to corrupt even your own son. But you get my point. No one with the vague
00:54:18 bit of soul left, thinks that the proper lesson for your children is the lesson in the least
00:54:25 possibly desirable sacrifice. What do you tell them instead? You say, well, look, kid,
00:54:31 maybe they're off to play baseball for the first time. You say, look, what do you say?
00:54:39 Do your best. Right? And that's, you want to go watch your child playing a sport, and
00:54:47 you want to see him do his best. And so what does that mean? Okay, what does it mean for him to do
00:54:52 his best? Well, it could mean to be highly skilled, right? Because it'd be fun if you have a child
00:54:58 who's very skilled athletically and is the star on the field. But even if he is the star, there
00:55:05 would have been a period of time where he had to develop that. What you want to see is that your
00:55:09 kid's out there pushing himself so that with each practice he gets better. So he's in this zone of
00:55:15 proximal development right he's beyond his zone of comfort and he's unfolding himself in relationship
00:55:21 to skill but that's not all you want to see in fact it's not even the most important thing you
00:55:26 want to see me you can imagine going to a sports event with your son and he's clearly the star
00:55:33 and uh he never he's playing soccer he never passes the ball even when one of his teammates
00:55:40 is open. He's always trying to hog the glory for himself. If he does score a goal, maybe he scores
00:55:45 three of them and is genuinely the hero of the game. He comes off the field and bitches and 1.00
00:55:50 complains about all the losers on his team, and he wants all the attention. And if you have any 1.00
00:55:55 sense as a parent, you're pretty appalled by that, even if he is the star. And you think, you know,
00:56:03 kid, it doesn't matter whether you win or lose. It matters how you play the game. And that's a
00:56:08 sacrificial piece of advice because what you're basically saying is you're not trying to win this
00:56:14 game kid you're trying to win the game in a manner that makes you most desirable as a play partner
00:56:21 and so what would that mean well what would you want to see for your son you'd want to see
00:56:25 well when he has the opportunity he tosses the ball over to someone else to give them a chance
00:56:30 and i don't mean in the kind of condescending manner i mean in a manner that would help the
00:56:34 team be better across time and you want to see him encouraging people when they push themselves
00:56:40 and you want to see him inviting the people who are less well integrated in the team into the
00:56:47 community and you want to see him emerging as team captain so he's a leader and then maybe if he's
00:56:53 highly skilled and a leader it's like you've got yourself a good deal right and so and then you'd
00:56:59 say, well, he did his best. He offered his best. And Cain, Abel, offers his best. So the
00:57:08 moral injunction in the story of Cain and Abel is that the proper pattern of sacrifice is to
00:57:17 offer your best. Cain doesn't do that. Okay, so what does it mean not to offer your best?
00:57:23 well it's lazy obviously and what does lazy mean it means
00:57:30 it means you're doing less than you could well how's that going to work
00:57:37 if you have any sense you know that your life is impossibly difficult and to to offer what's less
00:57:47 than what's your best is to make the assumption that you are so remarkable that you're going to
00:57:55 be able to establish yourself properly in life with a second-rate effort. Well, you know,
00:58:03 good luck to that because life is impossible and you'll barely get through it unscathed
00:58:11 and won't, actually, even if you do offer your best, and if you're playing a second-rate game,
00:58:19 you haven't got a chance. And then, if you play a second-rate game, there's a lot of things that
00:58:23 go along with that. You have to assume that other people are too stupid to see through that, 1.00
00:58:28 and so then you get arrogant. And you also have to assume that, and you have to lie to yourself, 1.00
00:58:34 so that you don't have to face the unpleasant truth that you're offering less than your best,
00:58:40 And so that makes you delusional.
00:58:43 And then you have to propose and act out the proposition that you're so much the center of things
00:58:51 that you can offer less than your best, and that will even fool God.
00:58:57 Because you're going to get away with it.
00:59:00 And so, well, so that's what Cain does.
00:59:05 And then it doesn't work.
00:59:07 his sacrifice is rejected by god because it's not of the highest quality and so then what happens
00:59:14 well it's exactly what happens in life so what happens if people fail as a consequence of their
00:59:22 second-rate sacrifices well they get unhappy and miserable and bitter and so that's what
00:59:29 happens to cain it says in the story that his countenance falls so he's depressed and embittered
00:59:34 and possessed by rage and vengeful.
00:59:39 And that's just where things get going.
00:59:42 And then he shakes his fist at God and challenges him.
00:59:46 In the story of Job, Job is visited by all the catastrophes of life.
00:59:53 And very unfairly, even by the admission of God,
00:59:58 his businesses collapse, his family's destroyed,
01:00:02 he gets a terrible disfiguring illness,
01:00:04 He's sitting in the ashes, bereft of hope, and then his friends come along and tell him that, well, he deserved what happened to him.
01:00:13 Because nothing happens without a reason, and they're kind of happy about it, you know, in that horrible way that makes bitter people thrilled
01:00:24 when something they respect is destroyed so that they don't have to bear the burden of that ideal.
01:00:31 And Job is so bereft that his wife says to him, 0.90
01:00:37 there's nothing left for you except to shake your fist at God, curse God, and die. 0.94
01:00:44 And why? 1.00
01:00:45 Well, curse God because the world has revealed itself,
01:00:48 the created order has revealed itself as entirely antithetical to anything you might desire.
01:00:53 And there's going to be times in your life where you feel exactly that,
01:00:56 you know, where you're apparently putting in the effort and things have still gone sideways for
01:01:02 you. And it can get to the point where it's so demoralizing that you are unhappy and demoralized
01:01:10 and also angry. And Job takes that on and says, I don't care what happens to me. I'm not going to
01:01:18 lose faith in the essential goodness of my being. And I'm not going to lose faith in the spirit that
01:01:25 gave rise to the created order. No matter what. That's the key issue in the story of Job. No
01:01:33 matter what. There's a moral lesson there, which is you are required to maintain your faith in
01:01:39 yourself and in the essential goodness of the spirit that creates order, regardless of the
01:01:46 circumstances of your life. Not least because if you don't do that, it'll be worse. Because you
01:01:51 could imagine this, you know, imagine everything falls apart around you. You won't have to imagine
01:01:55 that because there'll be times when that happens. But imagine that everything falls apart around you
01:01:59 and unfairly. And then imagine that you let that make you bitter. You say the facts themselves
01:02:05 speak to the necessity for my bitterness. You let that make you bitter. It destroys your faith in
01:02:11 yourself. And it makes you angry about the fact of reality itself. Well then, along with your
01:02:18 suffering, you have the collapse of everything that could conceivably move you forward. And so
01:02:25 you're no better off. You still have all the suffering. Plus, you've lost faith. And so the
01:02:31 hell you were in is way deeper now. The story of Job is the proclamation that you maintain faith
01:02:40 no matter what. That's a hell of a thing to think through. No matter what. Partly because that's
01:02:46 your best bet it's that's not the only reason but it's partly because that is genuinely your best
01:02:53 bet now you know that you admire people who can do this you see people who've been dealt a
01:02:59 miserable blow by fate and they maintain themselves ethically they continue to strive
01:03:07 upward under their unbearable load and you think there's really something to behold there and if
01:03:14 you have any sense, you pray that in similar circumstances, you'd have the nobility to manage
01:03:19 the same. Cain does the opposite. He goes to God and he says, look, buddy, I'm not very happy about
01:03:30 your world. I'm breaking myself in half here, shouldering my load, and nothing's working out
01:03:39 for me. And that Abel of yours, who you seem to favor, he doesn't have to do anything, really. And
01:03:45 the sun shines on him all the time. His life is easy. That's the statement of bitterness.
01:03:54 All success is due to unfair ease. Well, that's what Cain tells God. You accept Abel's sacrifices,
01:04:04 you don't accept mine. That has nothing to do with me. Quite the contrary. There's something wrong
01:04:11 with you. And you know, that's a problem because he's talking to God. And in some ways, it doesn't
01:04:19 even matter if he's right. He's not, but it doesn't matter. It's like, you don't get to question the
01:04:25 moral order. That's what Eve does. That's what Adam does. That's their sin. That's what knocks 1.00
01:04:32 them out of paradise they take they incorporate the fruit of the knowledge of good and evil they
01:04:39 take it onto themselves to define the moral order you don't get to do that that's not within your
01:04:46 purview so to speak as a created entity you're to discover the moral order and abide by it
01:04:53 and but that's not cain's suggestion cain's suggestion is things aren't working out for
01:04:59 me because you, God, made a mistake when you established the foundations of the earth.
01:05:03 Now, that's a hell of a thing to say, right? It's Luciferian in its presumption. Because Cain is
01:05:10 saying, think about that. He's saying that his failures are an indication of a flaw in the
01:05:15 structure of reality itself. There isn't anything more prideful that you could possibly say than
01:05:21 that. Now, you can understand why he might want to say it, because it'd be pretty damn convenient,
01:05:25 pretty convenient if everything
01:05:27 every time everything went wrong for you
01:05:29 was actually God's fault
01:05:30 and that you were actually perfect
01:05:33 in every possible way
01:05:35 and all of your failures were
01:05:37 a direct reflection of the
01:05:39 inadequacy of God
01:05:41 and being itself
01:05:42 you gotta ask yourself like who the hell 0.96
01:05:45 do you think you are? 0.69
01:05:47 well that's exactly the situation
01:05:49 that Cain finds himself in
01:05:50 so he goes to God with all these complaints
01:05:53 and God says
01:05:54 if you did well, you'd be accepted.
01:05:58 Okay, now, you know, you could debate that
01:06:00 because it isn't immediately obvious
01:06:04 that we reap a reward every time we do something right.
01:06:08 But here's something that I decided to experiment with many years ago.
01:06:17 Here's a proposition.
01:06:18 You can tell me what you think about this.
01:06:20 You can think about this.
01:06:21 If you tell the truth, whatever happens to you, in consequence, is the best thing that could happen, even if you can't see it at the time.
01:06:35 Right? So that's a statement of faith.
01:06:38 It's a hypothesis about the way reality is structured.
01:06:42 So, you know, people lie because they don't want to face the consequences of telling the truth.
01:06:46 obviously. When a child lies, it's because he wants to get away with something that he shouldn't get
01:06:51 away with, or he wants to have the world deliver him something he doesn't deserve. Entirely
01:06:57 understandable why people lie. Well, then why not lie? Well, one answer is, even though you're not
01:07:05 wise enough to see it, there is no better pathway forward than the truth. And so God's statement to
01:07:11 Cain, strangely enough, is something like,
01:07:14 you don't have a better deal than doing your best.
01:07:19 There's no alternative to that.
01:07:21 Or, all alternatives to that lead to hell.
01:07:27 When Job is tortured, he gets everything back.
01:07:31 Because he maintains faith.
01:07:33 It takes a while, and it isn't obvious that the fact that he gets everything back justifies the torture.
01:07:39 Right?
01:07:40 It's not an ends justify the means sort of thing.
01:07:43 It's more a reflection of the fact that,
01:07:46 regardless of the circumstances of your life,
01:07:49 you're called upon to offer your best.
01:07:51 Even when things are most dire.
01:07:53 Maybe particularly when they're most dire.
01:07:56 So that's what God tells Cain.
01:07:58 It's like, if you did well, you'd be accepted.
01:08:00 And then he says something.
01:08:02 This is all very subtle in the text.
01:08:04 He says... 0.98
01:08:09 sin crouches at your door like a sexually aroused predatory animal, 0.99
01:08:14 and you invited it in to have its way with you. 0.98
01:08:17 You know, and yet you could say that Cain could excuse his behavior.
01:08:22 He could say, look, God, I know I'm bitter and resentful and miserable and dangerous,
01:08:27 but I've been tortured a lot,
01:08:30 and there's a causal connection between the degree of my misery,
01:08:34 even though it might be someone warranted,
01:08:36 there's a causal connection between how miserable I've been
01:08:39 and how unhappy and bitter and resentful I've become.
01:08:42 I couldn't help it.
01:08:43 Anybody in my situation would have done the same thing.
01:08:46 Okay, so I've met people.
01:08:48 I interviewed a friend of mine, Charles Joseph, on my YouTube channel
01:08:51 who was brutalized in a residential school in Canada
01:08:56 in a manner that brings to mind nothing more than Auschwitz. 0.55
01:09:00 It was absolutely nothing less than Auschwitz.
01:09:02 It was absolutely brutal.
01:09:03 You can't listen to what happened to him without it, like, just taking you out.
01:09:10 And it really hurt him, unsurprisingly.
01:09:13 And he was on the streets for a long time and was an angry guy and no wonder.
01:09:17 But, you know, he decided that he became an artist.
01:09:22 You know, that was his burning bush.
01:09:24 He became a great artist.
01:09:25 He quit drinking.
01:09:26 He got himself off the street.
01:09:28 He's managed to have a family.
01:09:29 He's good to his kids.
01:09:30 He's a good person. 0.99
01:09:31 He had every reason to be every goddamn nightmare you could possibly imagine. 0.99
01:09:37 And with full justification. 0.98
01:09:40 But the thing is, there is no justification for that.
01:09:43 No matter what happens to you, there's no justification.
01:09:46 That's what God tells Cain.
01:09:47 He says, look, you would like to think that the reason that you're unhappy and miserable
01:09:52 and bitter and resentful and fratricidal and murderous
01:09:56 is because your life has been so difficult
01:09:58 That anyone would have been transformed into a monster merely as a consequence of suffering what you suffered
01:10:05 But that's not how it worked at all buddy
01:10:07 You had an option here was the option the temptation to become that way
01:10:14 made itself manifest on
01:10:17 Just outside the door of your house and it made you an offer
01:10:22 which was
01:10:24 Possession by the spirit of murderous resentment and you didn't have to open the door
01:10:31 But you did and you didn't just open the door
01:10:35 You hopped into bed with that beast and you let it have its way with you and
01:10:42 So now I've studied people who've done terrible things and I've had more than a few of them as clients and I
01:10:48 Can tell you if you want to get to a place where you're going to do something truly terrible
01:10:52 terrible like shoot up a high school or an elementary school you're going to spend like
01:10:58 2 000 hours fantasizing about it right you're going to take your bitterness and your resentment
01:11:04 because of your rejection let's say because of your suffering and we could even say that's
01:11:09 warranted you were rejected and you were suffering that's not the point is that along with that
01:11:15 rejection and suffering came a temptation and the temptation was to open the door to the spirit that
01:11:22 would enable you to capitalize on that and then you invite that in and you enter into a creative
01:11:28 union with it and you start to dwell and brood on it and you start to fantasize about your revenge
01:11:35 and you start to presume that you're in a position to judge man mankind and god and you put yourself
01:11:44 in a position where your murderous and then suicidal outburst is the culmination of the
01:11:52 darkest fantasies produced by your miserable sacrifices and unaccepted sufferings and your
01:12:01 consorting with the devil that you've invited into your soul. And that is how these things work.
01:12:08 And so, that's what God tells Cain.
01:12:12 And Cain is not very happy about that.
01:12:15 Because it's the last thing he wants to hear.
01:12:18 What he wants to hear is,
01:12:19 Sorry, Cain.
01:12:22 This is God speaking.
01:12:24 I obviously made a mistake when I established the foundations of the world.
01:12:28 And you've borne the brunt of that with the misery of your life.
01:12:31 And I'll do everything I can to make it up to you.
01:12:35 And none of this is your fault.
01:12:37 And that isn't what God tells Cain at all.
01:12:39 He says, hey, buddy, this is on you, and you know it,
01:12:44 and you invited it in, and you didn't have to.
01:12:47 And you decided to enter into a creative union
01:12:54 with the heart of darkness itself. 0.99
01:12:56 And that's why you're miserable. 0.52
01:12:58 And Cain, he leaves that conversation. 0.93
01:13:01 He wasn't very happy to begin with.
01:13:03 he's seriously not happy after that conversation
01:13:07 and so then he goes to Abel
01:13:08 and he says
01:13:09 hey bro
01:13:11 let's go out in the field and do some work
01:13:14 you know we'll engage in a productive enterprise together
01:13:17 using his position as his brother
01:13:20 to facilitate that interaction
01:13:23 and he kills Abel
01:13:26 and so what does that mean?
01:13:28 it means that bitterness and resentment kills the ideal
01:13:34 now Cain and Abel are the two patterns of
01:13:37 sapphic official adaptation that characterize humanity
01:13:40 there's in their extreme
01:13:43 there's the all in spirit which is I will do whatever
01:13:47 necessary to aim up I'll offer whatever's
01:13:50 necessary to put things right I'll do my best
01:13:54 in every gesture and every word I'll do that
01:13:57 in good faith with an eye to the future
01:13:59 in a communal spirit
01:14:01 with no holds barred
01:14:03 and the other pattern is
01:14:05 I'll cheat and lie and prevaricate
01:14:09 and manipulate and offer
01:14:11 what's second rate and deceitful
01:14:13 and I'll
01:14:16 trumpet
01:14:17 my bitterness and resentment as a moral
01:14:19 virtue and
01:14:21 I'll develop
01:14:23 the spirit that becomes
01:14:25 the enemy of God and the enemy of what's
01:14:27 good. It's
01:14:29 Christ and Satan in their
01:14:31 nascent forms. And that
01:14:33 pattern is established as the fundamental
01:14:35 pattern of mankind at the beginning
01:14:37 of the biblical narrative. Two
01:14:39 attitudes towards work.
01:14:41 Two attitudes towards sacrifice.
01:14:43 One which leads to
01:14:45 the pathway that Abel
01:14:49 walks on, which is
01:14:50 walking with God
01:14:53 in the garden and proceeding
01:14:55 uphill in the proper
01:14:57 sacrificial attitude and the other is the other is the pathway that leads to you not only killing 0.94
01:15:02 your brother killing your productive successful generous and productive brother because he's
01:15:11 productive and successful and generous to spite him and god even if it involves your own destruction 0.97
01:15:19 or maybe even because it does look you watch these people shoot up high schools and then kill
01:15:24 themselves and you think why didn't you just do the world the favor and reverse
01:15:28 the order and the answer is well that's not the proper dramatic statement because
01:15:33 the proper dramatic statement is something like well i care nothing for
01:15:37 my own life i've already given that up but i'm making the dramatic point about
01:15:45 my resentment and moral superiority a lot more effectively if i take out the 0.58
01:15:49 people you love and then shoot myself as well to show just how little i 0.95
01:15:54 care and you know maybe you can't understand that you should understand it because you need to
01:16:03 because you need to be afraid of that so you don't do it it's understandable why you wouldn't want to
01:16:09 see that and would never want to think that you could approach that kind of conceptualization but
01:16:16 In your most embittered moments, the spirit that motivates that kind of action is there offering itself, offering an invitation to you.
01:16:29 And that's true of everyone.
01:16:31 That's why these two spirits, Cain and Abel, they're you.
01:16:36 Right? In the deepest possible sense.
01:16:40 So, Cain kills Abel.
01:16:45 And then God calls him on it.
01:16:47 And Cain says, am I my brother's keeper?
01:16:49 And the proper answer to that is yes.
01:16:53 But Cain sloughs off his responsibility.
01:16:55 But he also says to God at the same time,
01:16:58 my punishment is greater than I can bear.
01:17:01 Well, why?
01:17:02 Well, if you destroy your own ideal,
01:17:08 well, Cain's bitter because he wants to be able.
01:17:10 in the most fundamental
01:17:14 at the most fundamental level
01:17:17 Cain admires
01:17:20 worships everything Abel represents
01:17:23 and then he goes and destroys that
01:17:25 well if a society turns on those who are
01:17:29 properly sacrificial and successful
01:17:33 the society disintegrates into utter chaos
01:17:36 if you define success itself as
01:17:38 exploitative
01:17:40 or pathological or indicative of the fundamental unjust injustice of the world itself then your
01:17:47 society is doomed if you murder the spirit that represents the best in you what's left for you
01:17:58 there's nothing left for you well that's what happens to cain god says you will now visit the
01:18:04 land of nod you'll now be an inhabitant of the land of nod nod is the land of the wandering
01:18:09 okay so when do you become an inhabitant of the land of the wandering well that's what a psychopathic 0.98
01:18:16 itinerant does the drifter who moves from place to place well why well you know i can screw you
01:18:25 over once but the second time is harder and the third time might be impossible and so if i'm going
01:18:31 to allow the spirit of malevolence and bitterness to take root in me the only way i can survive is
01:18:38 to wander. That's why
01:18:40 the strange loner who moves
01:18:42 from place to place is a literary trope.
01:18:45 If your
01:18:45 sacrifices are second
01:18:48 rate and
01:18:49 your fundamental orientation is
01:18:52 embittered and selfish, 0.97
01:18:54 you're consigned to wandering. 0.99
01:18:57 Okay.
01:19:01 And it's obvious
01:19:02 too, because if you're...
01:19:04 If the pattern of proper sacrifice
01:19:06 is maturity, and it's the
01:19:08 maturity upon which the stability of the future and the community depends. If engaging in that
01:19:13 process of sacrifice is what makes you welcome in the community, rejecting it entirely is going to
01:19:19 make it impossible for you to have a community, for you to have a wife, for you to have a family,
01:19:24 for you to have any friends, for you to be welcome anywhere. Because you've rejected exactly that.
01:19:29 You've rejected the sacrifice that would enable you to become desirable to others. And so of
01:19:35 course you're going to wander. And that is exactly the fate of the criminal psychopath, 0.99
01:19:41 let's say, the bitter criminal psychopath, who thinks he's smarter than everyone else, 0.98
01:19:45 who's always unhappy and miserable, who's shaking his fist constantly in a cynical 0.99
01:19:51 manner about the validity of the created order. Well, that isn't where the story ends.
01:19:59 Cain's descendants
01:20:02 are worse 0.61
01:20:05 than him
01:20:05 so imagine now
01:20:09 that Cain is the
01:20:11 pattern that
01:20:12 punishes the successful
01:20:15 and
01:20:17 rebels against God
01:20:18 the descendants 0.76
01:20:21 of Cain would be the
01:20:22 consequences of that decision
01:20:24 Lamech is one of the 0.98
01:20:29 descendants of cain if you kill if you bother cain he kills you if you bother lamech he kills seven
01:20:41 of you okay so so what does that mean it means that once that pattern of murderous resentment
01:20:48 gets established it spreads you wonder how a society deteriorates that's how it deteriorates
01:20:58 you get that pattern establishing itself.
01:21:02 Then it has children, and the children are worse,
01:21:05 and the grandchildren are worse yet. 1.00
01:21:07 You get a situation like Rwanda, 0.98
01:21:11 where the entire country is overwhelmed with murderous brutality 0.50
01:21:18 in a three-week period, and a million people are brutally decimated.
01:21:24 Societies deteriorate like that all the time.
01:21:27 What's the biblical message in the story of Cain and Abel?
01:21:30 Make second-rate sacrifices.
01:21:33 End up bitter and resentful.
01:21:35 Shake your fist at God.
01:21:37 Invite in the spirit that motivates your desire to destroy everything successful and good. 0.75
01:21:44 Give rise to the children that are genocidal and let everything vanish.
01:21:54 What's the next story?
01:21:56 the flood
01:21:59 well
01:22:04 so that's the story of Cain and Abel
01:22:07 two patterns of sacrifice
01:22:09 right one that leads upward
01:22:11 one that is in keeping
01:22:13 with the proper covenantal relationship
01:22:15 with self
01:22:17 mankind and God
01:22:19 the other that's
01:22:21 prideful bitter
01:22:23 deceitful 0.92
01:22:25 vengeful, murderous, fratricidal, and then genocidal.
01:22:33 And that's the battle between good and evil
01:22:37 that characterizes the narrative landscape
01:22:41 that is the best possible representation of the world that we actually inhabit.
01:22:49 Because the patterns that are portrayed in that narrative representation
01:22:54 are the fundamental patterns of sacrificial adaptation.
01:23:00 And that's the pattern of human being and becoming.
01:23:06 And that's the prescription for a life properly lived.
01:23:10 Offer your best to God.
01:23:12 Or face the consequences.
01:23:16 And so, that's the end of that story.
01:23:22 Thank you very much, everyone.
01:23:24 All right, so Constantine is going to come out.
01:23:37 He's going to...
01:23:38 I brought Constantine along in part to push me on these ideas.
01:23:47 I'm running this tour in part to reintroduce an appreciation for sacred stories.
01:23:54 among the people who are at least listening to this lecture series,
01:23:59 who will read my book.
01:24:01 It's a very contentious enterprise.
01:24:07 Why the story? Why these stories?
01:24:11 What does it mean that we should or do or must believe in them?
01:24:16 Why should we accept that?
01:24:17 Well, Constantine's a good critic, and it's useful to be pushed.
01:24:22 and so he's going to come out
01:24:24 and harass me
01:24:25 and then he's going to
01:24:27 go through the questions
01:24:31 that you all so kindly offered
01:24:32 and we're going to discuss them
01:24:33 and that'll bring the evening
01:24:35 to a close
01:24:36 so that's the plan
01:24:38 come on out sir
01:24:40 hello everybody
01:24:42 thank you
01:24:43 give it up for Jordan
01:24:46 one more time everybody 0.55
01:24:48 all right so harass you say jordan you'd like me to harass you
01:24:57 all right well i agree with everything you said uh by the way jordan invited me along to disagree
01:25:04 with him we've had one show together i haven't landed a glove on him yet but we'll try i agree
01:25:10 with everything you said it was a great lecture about how to live your life what i don't understand
01:25:14 is why you called your tour
01:25:15 We Who Wrestled With God.
01:25:17 Everything you said,
01:25:19 you know,
01:25:20 engage with the challenge
01:25:23 that seeks you out.
01:25:25 Do so with passion.
01:25:27 You know, we can go down the stories.
01:25:29 Everything you said,
01:25:29 sacrifice in the way 0.92
01:25:31 that the parents of the Asian kids did.
01:25:34 All of the things you talked about
01:25:35 is great advice.
01:25:36 But what does that,
01:25:38 you didn't explain in any way
01:25:39 why God is necessary for any of that.
01:25:41 it's great it's great advice as a clinical psychologist you could be sitting here
01:25:47 why is it god up there um i would say most profoundly
01:25:52 when we finally heal the wound that's divided the west say between the enlightenment and the
01:26:00 religious enterprise people will look back and wonder why it ever existed because they'll draw
01:26:07 the same conclusion you did which is well obviously that's true in the biblical corpus
01:26:13 what god is is continually defined so
01:26:19 in the final analysis the god that's presented both in the old and the new testament is ineffable
01:26:28 right his his fundamental nature is unknowable it's conceptualized as something that you have
01:26:34 a relationship with so it's relational but apart from that all you ever see is god's back like
01:26:41 moses does you never get a glimpse of the totality you get hints of the manifestation of the spirit
01:26:50 of the cosmic order in different partial manifestations and what the biblical library
01:26:57 does is walk you through those manifestations and so the story of cain and abel isn't an argument for
01:27:04 the existence of God, exactly.
01:27:06 It's a definition of what constitutes God.
01:27:10 Okay, so God in that story is
01:27:12 the spirit that rewards proper sacrifices.
01:27:18 God is the spirit that punishes deceitful presumption.
01:27:24 and god is this the target of all proper sacrifice those are definitions
01:27:36 they're definitions hold on a second well why is it necessary because the stories
01:27:41 and the met let's say that they're just good metaphors they're good metaphors for teaching
01:27:46 our children how to behave in the world life is a marshmallow to sacrifice now so that you will
01:27:50 benefit later and the people around you do act in a way that uh enhances your your proper reputation
01:27:58 with other people these are all good lessons why does this have anything to do with god why are
01:28:02 they good lessons because they're practically useful why are they practically useful we
01:28:06 empirically observe that they are because they reflect the fundamental moral order
01:28:11 the well that but that's the what that's the practical answer is that see this is something
01:28:20 that jonathan pageau has helped me more deeply understand is that at some point the fact of
01:28:26 the practicality of the metaphor is a pointer to something that's more than metaphorical
01:28:33 so and it's a weird it's a strange thing because it's partly definitional it's partly metaphorical
01:28:41 but it's it's not it doesn't exhaust itself in the metaphor these are practical lessons because
01:28:47 they most deeply reflect the fundamental nature of reality.
01:28:51 You could also think about that as definitional.
01:28:54 You could think of the fundamental, of fundamental reality as being something like a meaningless
01:28:59 material substrate with a moral order on top of it.
01:29:03 That's one way of looking at it.
01:29:05 The Judeo-Christian, the biblical corpus inverts that, says, no, the moral order is fundamental.
01:29:12 If you conceptualized reality properly, you would see a hierarchy of moral order with something united at its pinnacle.
01:29:21 That you should embody that in every gesture and every word.
01:29:26 And that will put you in alignment with not only the created order that's good, but the spirit that gives rise to the created order that's good.
01:29:39 It's a definition.
01:29:41 It's a proposition about what's most real.
01:29:44 You see, the question you ask comes from the position,
01:29:49 you've already made an axiomatic decision of faith.
01:29:54 Your axiomatic decision is, the meaningless material order is most real.
01:30:00 There's a moral order on top of that.
01:30:02 Well, that's one way of looking at things.
01:30:04 But the problem with looking, one of the problems with looking at it that way is that,
01:30:08 well why does it work it wouldn't work if it wasn't this is a definition of true if it really
01:30:18 works it's true if it's really true it points to that which is deepest now i don't exactly
01:30:27 understand that because to some degree i'm in the same conundrum as most materialist atheists you
01:30:33 know i don't know how to understand the relationship between the 14 billion years that the cosmos
01:30:38 has made itself manifest, and the fact that consciousness has only existed,
01:30:43 well, at least, at maximum, since life itself emerged.
01:30:47 I have no idea how to conceptualize what was there before there was anything conscious.
01:30:51 I don't even know at all what role consciousness itself plays in the cosmic order per se.
01:30:57 But by the same token...
01:30:59 If you have the best possible map
01:31:10 If the map you have is the ultimate treasure map
01:31:14 That's a good way of thinking about it
01:31:16 And if you follow the direction that that treasure map specifies
01:31:22 And it leads you to the treasure
01:31:24 Then not only is it the best possible map
01:31:28 It's the map that best represents the underlying territory.
01:31:33 Sure.
01:31:33 Right.
01:31:34 So the underlying territory would have the moral order built into it,
01:31:37 rather than something that's epiphenomenal.
01:31:40 Even if it's an emergent property,
01:31:42 it'd be a reflection of something even deeper.
01:31:46 Now, I wouldn't say that I understand that completely,
01:31:49 but I would say that your instinct for meaning, for example,
01:31:53 is a pointer in that direction.
01:31:54 Like, it is the case that your attention is captured by markers that move you to the ultimate treasure.
01:32:03 That's how you're set up physiologically.
01:32:06 So even if you're a materialist, for example, you have to contend with the fact that
01:32:10 the evolutionary process itself has shaped you into something that fundamentally perceives the world as a story.
01:32:19 so Pajot
01:32:22 Jonathan Pajot's
01:32:23 objection would be
01:32:24 well
01:32:24 how is the world
01:32:26 not a story
01:32:27 if perceiving it
01:32:28 as a story
01:32:29 is the most
01:32:29 functional possible
01:32:30 mode of perception
01:32:31 because our brains
01:32:34 are quite primitive
01:32:36 in relation to
01:32:37 the reality
01:32:37 that we're attempting
01:32:38 to process
01:32:39 why is
01:32:44 okay
01:32:44 the fact that
01:32:48 I need to tell
01:32:48 myself a story
01:32:49 about this infinite selection of stimuli
01:32:53 and I need to pick out the ones
01:32:55 that I need to tell the story
01:32:56 that helps me in the current moment
01:32:58 does not mean that the world is a story.
01:33:00 It means my primitive brain
01:33:02 is only capable of experiencing it as a story.
01:33:07 Then your presumption is that
01:33:09 your pathway forward to maximal adaptation
01:33:12 is necessarily predicated on something that's false.
01:33:17 So then the metaphysical presumption
01:33:18 underneath that is that in order for you to thrive in the world you are obligated to adopt
01:33:25 a falsehood what is the falsehood well you said that the presumption that there's an implicit
01:33:33 moral order is merely a consequence of let's say our primitiveness we have to there's there's lots
01:33:39 of psychological schools that have taken that tack the terror management theorists believe that for
01:33:44 example, is that life is fundamentally pointless in the final analysis, that everything we
01:33:51 do comes to naught, that the existential reality of that is so cataclysmic that we have to
01:33:58 delude ourselves practically and philosophically into abiding, into inhabiting necessary delusional
01:34:06 fictions in order to reconcile ourselves to the fundamental horror of existence.
01:34:14 And, you know, I can understand why people, I don't think it's true.
01:34:21 My sense is that...
01:34:22 Nor do I.
01:34:22 Okay, okay, okay.
01:34:24 Nor do I.
01:34:24 Okay.
01:34:25 Let me try this a different way and maybe bring it back into the real world.
01:34:28 So one of the things, obviously, you and I have both talked about a lot is the malaise that seems to be affecting the West.
01:34:34 Yeah, that's a good example.
01:34:35 And your argument is that Christianity or Judeo-Christianity, let's say, is the water in which we swim and having removed the water, the fish are now floundering. Is that fair? It's a massive oversimplification.
01:34:51 Sure, that'll do.
01:34:52 but but fair right what if as our good friend louise perry has written in her book the case
01:35:02 against the sexual revolution this is simply a product of the fact that in the 60s we invent
01:35:07 and roll out the pill the pill has massive repercussions on women the way their brain works
01:35:13 the way they choose mates uh and that has a downstream consequence on the family unit the
01:35:20 breakdown of the family and really what we're facing is a crisis of meaning because people 0.98
01:35:25 the thing that gay people meaning which is the reproduction of their genes someone like Dawkins 0.89
01:35:31 might argue right and as a new father I certainly agree with that that's the most meaningful thing
01:35:36 I've ever done what we're facing is a society in which I use the word advisedly the sacred bond
01:35:44 between men and women has been ruptured what's the moral precondition for the invention and
01:35:47 distribution of the pill when does that become allowable more when does it become desirable
01:35:54 under what circumstances that does that become desirable because birth control itself was
01:36:00 illegal many places for a very long time so before you get the pill you get a revolution in ethics
01:36:06 that makes the pill possible and then desirable and then necessary what is that revolution in
01:36:11 your opinion that's what i'm asking you what do you think what i don't know how about um pleasure
01:36:16 without consequence how about pleasure without responsibility how about the deepest possible
01:36:22 pleasure with the least amount possible with the least amount of responsibility possible
01:36:27 how about that as an ethical transformation that makes that makes it even okay to investigate the
01:36:34 pill now look i agree with you by the way that the pill itself has had incalculable an incalculable
01:36:41 effect on our society we know for example that women who are on the pill like men who aren't the
01:36:48 men they would like if they weren't on the pill yeah this is not a trivial problem we know that 0.78
01:36:54 women on the pill like less masculine men facially let's say and and temperamentally
01:37:00 so here's a question for you is the antipathy how much of the antipathy of feminists towards
01:37:09 Masculine men is a consequence of the birth control pill. The answer is
01:37:14 Don't know
01:37:15 We have no idea. I mean
01:37:17 Messing with hormones is like that's a fundamental. That's a fundamental revolution
01:37:22 We have no idea how fundamental we have no idea for example if it's the sort of revolution that destroys the world 0.96
01:37:28 I could easily be because it's equivalent to the fact that women now have control over the reproductive function is equivalent to a 0.87
01:37:36 A revolutionary genetic mutation. 0.72
01:37:40 Okay, but that's not exactly the issue.
01:37:42 The issue is, what moral transformations have to take place before the offering of such a solution becomes morally desirable?
01:37:53 And I would say, we know what happened.
01:37:55 Everyone knows what happened.
01:37:57 What happened when the pill emerged?
01:37:59 Okay.
01:38:00 the family fell apart and that started in the socio-economically marginalized and moved up the
01:38:11 socio-economic hierarchy and now the only people not affected are basically the wealthy who are
01:38:17 married to the same degree that they were in 1960 but all the other classes aren't yeah okay so then
01:38:23 what else what happened well we have the sexual revolution well what was the sexual revolution
01:38:28 The sexual revolution was, you can pursue pleasure of the short-term kind with whoever the hell you want to,
01:38:36 under any conditions whatsoever, at any time and place, and that's not only allowable, but desirable.
01:38:43 Okay, so here's a technical problem with that.
01:38:46 This is very much worth knowing.
01:38:49 So, in the biological community at large, the community of living things that sexually reproduce,
01:38:58 There's a distribution of reproductive strategies on the one end are puffballs and mosquitoes and that's the
01:39:07 Make lots of offspring and invest nothing in them strategy. So a 0.91
01:39:12 mosquito will have millions of
01:39:14 Offspring and all of them die, but like one and so we have a kind of constant supply of mosquitoes, but
01:39:22 the ratio of life to death among
01:39:24 juvenile mosquitoes is very, very low. They all die. Puffballs, same thing. No investment
01:39:34 in offspring, massive production of numbers. On the other end, literally on the other end
01:39:42 are human beings. We produce very few offspring at a very high price and we invest in them
01:39:48 Multi-generationally, so we're high investment. Our reproductive strategy is a high investment sacrificial strategy
01:39:57 Okay, now so we'll establish that just biologically so in order for human beings to propagate themselves. We've adopted a
01:40:05 long-term monogamous child-centered 0.78
01:40:10 Sacrificial multi-generational
01:40:13 Strategy for the rearing of children now if that falls apart children don't do well the clinical literature on that are
01:40:18 It's crystal clear.
01:40:20 Like fatherlessness, for example, it's a catastrophe.
01:40:23 And any clinician who proclaims otherwise is either deluded or deceitful.
01:40:29 Because there's almost nothing documented better in the developmental literature than that.
01:40:34 Okay, why? Well, children are difficult.
01:40:37 It's hard. It takes like 18 years before they can more or less make their way.
01:40:42 Or 40 years.
01:40:44 And it's too much for one person.
01:40:47 especially in their early years, because if you're the mother,
01:40:53 which you will be if you gave birth to the child,
01:40:55 then you're going to be economically compromised in a deadly serious way
01:40:59 for, you know, five months during the pregnancy,
01:41:02 and then for, like, at least four years after that,
01:41:05 and way more than that if you have multiple children,
01:41:08 and so you need someone along to help with that,
01:41:10 and maybe the minimum person you need is the father.
01:41:13 You probably need some, like, friends and grandparents and so forth.
01:41:17 Okay.
01:41:17 So we have this multi-generational sacrificial strategy.
01:41:21 Okay, so now just imagine you take just human beings
01:41:24 and you divide them into two mating strategies.
01:41:28 Short-term zero investment and long-term sacrificial.
01:41:33 Okay, short-term zero investment, that's the one-night-stand crowd. 0.71
01:41:38 Most of them are men. 0.99
01:41:40 Because women pay a much higher price, obviously, for sexual promiscuity. 0.97
01:41:46 now hypothetically the pill eradicates that but and in some ways it does that's 0.92
01:41:51 why we have a sexual revolution but in many ways it doesn't okay that's fine so
01:41:56 let's say it doesn't matter because once you have the pill it's okay to engage in
01:42:00 short-term mating strategies the pursuit of pleasure without responsibility
01:42:04 partly because the pill eliminates the consequences so then who cares then let's
01:42:09 party well that was like the 1960s well you know we had an epidemic of sexually
01:42:15 transmitted diseases oops and that was aids in its most severe uh manifestation and that could
01:42:22 have wiped us all out it didn't but that's more good fortune than anything else so you know nature
01:42:28 had its revenge in that regard let's say because the problem with sex is it's a great vector for
01:42:33 the transmission of diseases and that's a major problem but the whole 60s sex party kind of came
01:42:41 to a tawdry end by the mid 70s and everyone more and that went along with the increased
01:42:50 proliferation of pornography and so forth okay so what's wrong with that i mean if we can get
01:42:56 away with it why not do it so how have psychologists addressed this they've looked at the personality
01:43:03 characteristics of short-term haters so imagine you are temperamentally inclined or you teach
01:43:10 yourself to adopt a hedonistic orientation towards sex okay so what does that look like
01:43:17 well we know what it looks like it looks like the dark tetrad so what's the dark tetrad
01:43:24 it's a constellation of personality traits that have to do with the exploitation of self and other
01:43:32 in pursuit of short-term gratification well you might say who cares about that like if you can
01:43:39 obtain pleasure in the short term and there's no consequences because of the pill then
01:43:44 have at her okay fair enough who are these people
01:43:47 they're narcissistic which means they want reputational status without doing any of the
01:43:55 work necessary to obtain it genuinely they're machiavellian which means that they use their 0.87
01:44:01 words for no other reasons than to manipulate for short-term gain they're psychopathic so that's fun
01:44:09 that means they're parasitic predators they'll steal what you have and they'll live off you with
01:44:15 no work and that was the dark triad that was how that was identified first and then the researchers
01:44:21 delved even more deeply into it because they hadn't got to the bottom of hell yet and it turned out
01:44:28 that an additional constellation of personality traits had to be added to that sadistic a sadistic 0.91
01:44:35 person takes positive delight in the suffering of others dark tetrad types preferentially
01:44:43 pursue short-term mating strategies but it's the reverse is true too if you preferentially 0.99
01:44:49 pursue short-term mating strategies that's who you turn yourself into all right so it
01:44:55 could easily be that the pill has produced a breakdown of familial structure an irresponsible
01:45:02 breakdown of familial structure a proliferation of pornography and all sorts of associated
01:45:07 social cataclysms but i would say that in itself is reflective of something even more fundamental
01:45:14 which is a breakdown of the social order that's predicated on the primacy the necessary primacy of
01:45:22 the optimal long-term sacrificial pattern well i don't understand how you made that leap but i
01:45:29 I want to get some audience questions.
01:45:30 And by the way, when you were describing that type of person, 1.00
01:45:33 every woman in the audience is going,
01:45:34 yeah, I've had an ex-boyfriend like that.
01:45:36 Oh, well, the other thing I could tell you in that regard is that,
01:45:40 so these, the men who adopt this pattern,
01:45:44 the narcissistic types,
01:45:46 they're like Gaston in Beauty and the Beast.
01:45:49 So they, I mean that,
01:45:50 that's a representation of this sort of man.
01:45:53 Those men mimic sacrificial competence.
01:45:57 So they're confident, right? 0.60
01:45:59 Now, women look at men to see if they're confident, because they use confidence as a marker for competence. 0.94
01:46:06 But a deceitful, narcissistic psychopath has confidence without the competence. 0.94
01:46:16 And naive women can't tell the difference. 0.99
01:46:20 And so we know that narcissistic psychopaths, dark tetrads, short-term maters, 0.98
01:46:25 are much more successful with naive young women
01:46:28 than with women who've had some maturity and experience
01:46:31 because with maturity and experience,
01:46:33 the women learn to tell the difference
01:46:34 between the tameable beasts and the narcissists.
01:46:40 Jordan, very quickly,
01:46:41 because I do want to get a couple of audience questions,
01:46:43 but just explain to me so that I understand,
01:46:45 if nothing else,
01:46:46 why is it that the technology of the pill,
01:46:49 the sexual revolution,
01:46:50 the dropping testosterone levels in men,
01:46:51 which we see from generation to generation,
01:46:54 Why is that not enough to explain everything that's happening?
01:46:57 Why do you say that the shift in cultural attitude had to come first?
01:47:02 Because you wouldn't have even had the pill as a phenomenon
01:47:04 if we hadn't already decided at a cultural level
01:47:08 that we could prioritize short-term sexual gratification over everything else.
01:47:11 But that probably wouldn't have been how it was perceived at the time. 0.73
01:47:15 It was like, here's this new technology that gives women autonomy.
01:47:17 Yeah, I know. Yes and no. 1.00
01:47:19 look there was some notion and perhaps some warranted notion that wouldn't it be a wonderful
01:47:24 thing if people could plan their families intelligently right and i think we're still
01:47:30 sorting that out you know because i could understand my wife used birth control we use
01:47:36 birth control i can understand why that's desirable so there was that there was well
01:47:42 wouldn't it be good if we could if we could plan our lives out more particularly and you can
01:47:48 And understand why people think that's a good idea.
01:47:51 Whether or not it's a good idea is a different question.
01:47:53 Because another idea is, if you could choose to have children, would you?
01:48:00 And the answer appears to be no, because we're way below replacement in terms of production
01:48:09 of children in the West.
01:48:11 And some of that, part of that's partly because, well, when's a good time to have children?
01:48:16 And the answer is, well, never is a good time, obviously.
01:48:19 And also, you know, should you bring a child into a world such as this?
01:48:24 And at least that's sufficiently disputable to forestall the decision.
01:48:32 So perhaps it was a good idea for that choice to open up, but it's not self-evident that
01:48:36 it was a good idea.
01:48:37 But at the same time, there were all sorts of social currents making themselves manifest
01:48:42 in the early 60s that were tilting us hard in the direction of a much more hedonistic society.
01:48:47 And it wasn't many decades before that that birth control, per se, was illegal.
01:48:53 And part of that was, and I'm not saying it should have been, that's not my point,
01:48:56 you had to have a conjunction of the notion that the pursuit of sexual pleasure
01:49:03 without responsibility, per se, was at least allowable and perhaps even desirable
01:49:08 before even research on the pill could have taken place.
01:49:13 There had to be a transformation in moral view
01:49:14 before the technology could possibly make itself manifest.
01:49:18 To be continued.
01:49:21 One person enjoyed that. Great.
01:49:29 Christina says,
01:49:30 what is your favorite verse in the Bible and why?
01:49:33 Make this one quick because I want to get a couple more in.
01:49:37 Okay.
01:49:38 probably the truth will set you free.
01:49:44 That's a good one.
01:49:45 Yeah.
01:49:49 Can I explain why briefly?
01:49:51 It's your show, man.
01:49:55 You can do whatever the hell you want.
01:49:58 Well, if you imagine that,
01:50:01 if what's true
01:50:05 most accurately represents
01:50:07 if true words most accurately
01:50:12 map the territory well how could you
01:50:13 possibly be more free than that
01:50:15 I mean you're going to run into
01:50:18 the fewest possible obstacles
01:50:19 now that could easily not be none
01:50:22 right because
01:50:23 getting through life without running into obstacles
01:50:26 you can just give that up
01:50:27 but in terms of optimized
01:50:30 strategy it could easily be that just the truth is the best and I think that's true
01:50:37 one of the things you see in the story of Abraham too is that there's an insistence this kind of
01:50:43 builds in the biblical corpus overall there's an insistence that the call to adventure and
01:50:50 the truth are the same thing that's part of the monotheistic hypothesis hypothesis the logos that
01:50:56 gives rise to the created order at the beginning
01:50:58 of time is the spirit of
01:51:00 truth. And it's, the spirit
01:51:02 of truth is deemed identical to
01:51:04 the spirit of adventure, right?
01:51:06 So, this, the
01:51:08 accumulation of the stories
01:51:10 builds up a portrait of the unified
01:51:12 of the unified
01:51:16 character that sits at the pinnacle of the moral
01:51:18 hierarchy.
01:51:20 Truth most accurately maps the
01:51:22 territory and provides the most
01:51:24 adventurous journey forward.
01:51:26 well that is free that's the right kind of freedom see the thing about telling the truth
01:51:32 this is a wonderful thing to understand is you don't know what's going to happen
01:51:36 like you're not calculating and you might think well what if i don't get what i want it's like
01:51:42 what the hell do you know like how many times have you got what you wanted and that didn't work out
01:51:47 for you because your aim was off to walk to have the spirit of truth guide your words is
01:51:56 It's to follow the spirit where it listeth.
01:52:01 It's to go where truth takes you.
01:52:04 And there's kind of no burden in that.
01:52:07 Because you can just say what you think.
01:52:10 And then you can see what happens.
01:52:12 And God only knows what will happen.
01:52:14 But at minimum, it's going to be a surprise.
01:52:17 And sometimes it'll be troublesome.
01:52:19 But that usually turns out to be troublesome in an extremely useful way.
01:52:23 so it's a very good deal
01:52:26 if you know that truth and adventure
01:52:28 are the same thing
01:52:29 that's a really useful thing
01:52:30 if you just take that away from this lecture
01:52:33 then that's well worth the ticket price
01:52:35 let's say
01:52:35 here's one
01:52:42 I wish more people were asking Jordan
01:52:44 I think you probably do as well
01:52:46 how do you know when you're ready to get married
01:52:48 that's easy
01:52:51 your girlfriend thinks it's time
01:52:54 so the answer is the time to get married is right now you look you know yeah right well you never
01:53:05 you never know like how in the world are you going to know that you don't know your
01:53:10 your girlfriend and even if you do you don't know what she's going to be like when she's your wife
01:53:15 like that's a whole different universe and so you know your your your your commitment to be married
01:53:23 is a it's a flinging yourself off the cliff in faith i'm dead serious about that it's like 0.93
01:53:31 you you you take this person that's foolish enough to pick you and you link yourself together and you
01:53:38 leap off the edge and you say something like maybe we can play intelligently together on the way down 0.95
01:53:45 and do you know what's going to happen well you know what's going to happen when you hit the
01:53:49 bottom do you know what's going to happen well no you don't ever know what's going to happen
01:53:55 in any of the major decisions you take in your life this is partly why there's such an emphasis
01:53:59 for example in the biblical stories on faith it's like you take every decision that's
01:54:06 cataclysmic in your life in good faith it's the same when you have kids it's the best and worst
01:54:11 decision you'll ever make and marriage is certainly like that and then you might say well
01:54:16 maybe there are some things you could have faith in that would increase the probability that your
01:54:23 fateful journey forward would be desirable and productive and i would say well yes you know
01:54:29 you should have faith in the truth for example you know you're if you ground your marriage in truth
01:54:37 then you'll set up the dynamism between you
01:54:42 that enables you to radically adapt
01:54:46 to the transforming circumstances
01:54:48 that are unpredictable
01:54:50 that will constitute your life, right?
01:54:52 And you can't compute that beforehand
01:54:54 because life really is unpredictable.
01:54:56 A future genuinely is unpredictable.
01:54:58 It's not reducible to a set of...
01:55:00 There's no set of rules that you can use
01:55:03 to compute the future.
01:55:04 you have to dance with it
01:55:07 and if you're going to dance with your wife
01:55:09 on the edge of the abyss in truth
01:55:11 then
01:55:12 the utility of the truth is
01:55:15 she brings her best to the conversation
01:55:17 and you bring your best
01:55:18 and the exchange of information
01:55:20 that that commitment enables
01:55:23 makes you both
01:55:24 wiser and more resilient
01:55:26 than either of you would be alone
01:55:28 and that's your best bet
01:55:30 and
01:55:30 it's better
01:55:35 to just get on with it.
01:55:41 Well, young man, you've got your
01:55:43 marching orders.
01:55:45 Dr. Jordan Peterson, everybody.
01:55:49 Thank you, sir.
01:55:55 Thank you, everyone.