00:00:23Pre-order it today at newchristendompress.com slash longhouse.
00:00:26And as a thank you for pre-ordering, you'll get 10% off automatically.
00:00:30We'll also be signing the first thousand copies, so pick yours up today.
00:00:36As many of you know, Dan, Eric, and I met with Douglas Wilson, Nate Wilson, Joe Rigney,
00:00:42Toby Sumter, and several other men from Moscow, Idaho last week.
00:00:45That meeting arose because the elders of our church sent a nine-page letter to the elders
00:00:51of Christ Church detailing our concerns with Pastor Wilson's involvement in and handling
00:00:56of the Joel Webb and Tobias situation, as well as his use of the May blog to damage the reputation
00:01:02of other faithful pastors, including Joel Webb. Our goal in this was to clarify motives and actions
00:01:09taken by Doug and to give him a chance to respond before we said anything publicly.
00:01:14Our desire was to promote peace if possible. Sadly, before and after our meeting, Doug continued to
00:01:21attack the character of Joel, Stephen Wolf, Eric, and others whom he called pastorally inept in a
00:01:28May blog for failing to properly police what he calls Dankanons and for engaging in Revoice for
00:01:34Nazis. More on that later. Doug confirmed in the meeting that he does in fact believe those charges
00:01:40are true. Yesterday, Doug released another blog post stating that, quote, much like Revoice attempted
00:01:47to keep the door of flamer sympathy cracked open in the PCA, the leadership in Ogden continues to
00:01:54conduct a sympathetic bromance with the cancers of racial spite, malice, vainglory, and pagan
00:02:01tribal hate. We believe these charges are reckless, uncharitable, and false. The bottom line is that
00:02:09we simply don't agree about the greatest needs of the hour, a fact which became clear over the
00:02:14course of our lengthy conversation. While Doug and his friends believe that one of the greatest
00:02:19threats to the conservative movement right now is alleged anti-Semitism and Nazism, we believe it
00:02:25to be, on a much more significant scale, the subversion of our historically Christian and
00:02:31Protestant American culture with the slow rot of Gramsian Marxism. Doug and his friends believe
00:02:38that Jews in America, a notoriously left-leaning and left-voting bloc, who turned out for Kamala
00:02:44Harris in the November election in numbers ranging from 70 to even 80 plus percent, depending on which
00:02:50surveys you believe, are fed up with liberalism and teetering on the brink of conversion to
00:02:56conservative politics. They believe that the deep state is desperately trying to prevent this from
00:03:01happening by fomenting anti-Semitic rage within the conservative movement. We simply disagree
00:03:08that this is a likely course of future events. We don't see Jews in America suddenly turning
00:03:14from deeply ingrained political action, like their support of transgenderism, LGBTQ, open borders,
00:03:21free pornography, government censorship of social media, and all the rest, to the politics of
00:03:27Christian conservatism, let alone Christian nationalism. This to us seems like magical
00:03:33thinking on a near absurd level. Even worse, it's not just that we disagree with the likelihood of
00:03:39this outcome. It seems rather that anyone acting on the sincerely held belief that this is a highly
00:03:45likely outcome in the near future is in grave danger of being subverted, of living under a
00:03:50leftist gaze, tailoring their actions to ingratiate themselves with one of the most liberal groups in
00:03:56America. Has this kind of tactic worked in the past? Let's test this thinking with a recent
00:04:02example. 83% of Black voters punched their ticket for Kamala Harris in the 2024 presidential
00:04:09election. This is consistent with their voting patterns in the previous three elections and
00:04:14beyond. Over this time period, a huge amount of energy on the right was spent supporting DEI
00:04:20programs, hunting down white racism, and virtue signaling to the black vote. Just a few examples0.59
00:04:27of this would include Alabama Governor Robert Bentley's 2017 authorization to remove a plaque
00:04:34commemorating Jefferson Davis from an Alabama courthouse, Republican Governor Tate Reeves'
00:04:392020 legislation retiring the Mississippi state flag for its inclusion of the Confederate battle
00:04:45emblem and Mitch McConnell's support for an initiative to rename military bases previously
00:04:51named after Confederate heroes. Did this turn the tide for black voters? Did they suddenly begin to
00:04:57vote Republican, softened by our national self-flagellation? Of course not. And politicians
00:05:04on the right who tried to pander to the black vote in this way only ended up aiding and abetting0.60
00:05:09in the creation of a culture where men like Daniel Penny and Kyle Rittenhouse would be dragged
00:05:15through show trials for the crime of being white men in America who tried to do their duty.
00:05:21Here's the problem with this tactic. To embrace witch hunts for racism and anti-Semitism
00:05:26is to embrace the left's frame from the outset. All it serves to accomplish is the enforcement
00:05:33of leftist cancel tactics on the right. So to summarize, Doug, Nate, and others in Moscow
00:05:39are convinced that the deep state is attempting to prevent Jews from teaming up with conservatives.
00:05:45Because of this, they believe it's very important to leverage public statements and media to attempt to show how much we all hate anti-Semitism, how much we all agree with their definitions of what that means in the first place,0.79
00:05:57and otherwise make sure everyone knows that we think all those people noticing things are probably feds sent by the deep state to keep the Jews liberal.
00:06:07This belief is driving their online anti-Semitism witch hunt.0.54
00:06:11We don't share that belief, and so we have behaved accordingly.
00:06:15Rather than accepting this leftist framing, we've instead opted to do what is often the most potent action one can take when faced with idols and their attendant blasphemy laws.
00:06:27False gods hate it when you make fun of them.
00:06:30Now, none of this, of course, means that our behavior amounts to anything like a sympathetic bromance with the cancers of racial spite, malice, vainglory, and pagan tribal hate.0.54
00:06:40That is slanderous nonsense, which we reject with prejudice.
00:06:45As just one example from a recent piece of alleged evidence of our raging anti-Semitism,
00:09:05Because I shared this video and think it made it an important point about our culture and the battles of our time,
00:09:10I'm Nickabrick, the black dwarf who wants to resurrect ghouls and witches in necromantic ceremony.0.93
00:09:17I am allied with Jew-killing demon Santas.0.94
00:09:20While it might seem like the charity is about as dried up as it could possibly be at this point,0.97
00:09:25Doug ends with a dark prophecy over our little town, church, and publishing house.
00:09:30Quote, within a few years, Ogden will have either fully succumbed and been torn apart by the poison they are currently declining to resist, or by God's grace, they will eventually stand and fight and triumph over this toxic nonsense.
00:09:43In the latter case, if and when that time comes, we will rejoice to have gained wiser and more battle-tested allies.
00:09:49end quote. It's hard to resist the conclusion that to Moscow, unless we agree with them on
00:09:56their read of the political landscape, their theory of the Jewish vote, their definition of
00:10:01anti-Semitism, the propriety of sharing or not sharing campy white boy summer memes, basically
00:10:06all of their views all the way down the line, then we are poison drinking naves teetering at the edge
00:10:12of the abyss. We are deep state stooges feasting on toxic nonsense. The only solution is to flee0.97
00:10:19to the safety of their positions on all these things. The simple problem is that we don't agree
00:10:24with that either. We think there's plenty of room for nuance, disagreements, and all the rest
00:10:30on basically all of these issues. We don't begrudge Moscow for their read, even if we think
00:10:35it's off. I literally don't care if Doug never wears pit vipers or chuckles at a white boy summer0.91
00:10:40meme. Such a thing doesn't keep me up at night. So if I might make a simple request at the end of
00:10:45these introductory remarks. It would be something like this. How about we agree to disagree without
00:10:51the name calling and prophecies of doom? We recorded the episode that follows prior to our
00:10:56meeting in Moscow. We had withheld its release in hopes that the tactics and issues we describe
00:11:02in what follows would be effectively addressed in private. In fact, our hope was that our concerns
00:11:07would be allayed and subsequently that the episode need never be released at all. We believe we were
00:11:13fair and charitable in the episode, particularly in contrast to the name calling and frankly wild
00:11:18accusations of the aforementioned May blog. If you followed us throughout this escalating war
00:11:24of accusations, epithets, debates over anti-Semitism, and all the rest over the last
00:11:29months, you know that we've tried hard to avoid unnecessary brother wars. This hasn't been easy
00:11:34as accusations and epithets have been publicly attached to our names by several prominent
00:11:40leaders, but in consultation with our session, it seemed necessary to exercise patience. However,
00:11:47in light of these continued and very much public attacks on our good names,
00:11:51we believe it necessary to release the episode now. In what follows, we hope you'll discover that,
00:11:57much to the disappointment of our assigned federal agents,
00:12:00we are neither Nazis nor men content to live under the leftist gaze.
00:14:12As for the meaning of 322, it is said to be the date of Demosthenes' death, 322 BC,
00:14:18a man known for his brilliant intellect and political savvy.
00:14:22The society also worships Eulogia, the goddess of eloquence.
00:14:27Its members, known as Bonesmen, have been connected to various conspiracy theories,
00:14:32largely because they have always formed an interconnected network of America's most powerful elites.
00:14:38Bonesmen alumni include men like Buckley, George H.W. Bush, John Kerry,
00:14:43and many others who have occupied roles in the State Department, White House, Judiciary, and CIA.
00:14:50In 1951, Buckley signed on at the Central Intelligence Agency and worked in Mexico.
00:14:56While at the CIA, he published God and Man at Yale, and later The Road to Jenin, which told of a communist conspiracy to obtain world domination.
00:15:06In 1954, Buckley wrote another book, this time defending Joseph McCarthy and his purge of communists.
00:15:13Then, a pivotal moment that would shape the landscape of conservative politics for decades.
00:15:19In 1955, Buckley founded National Review, a right-wing journal with tremendous influence on the elite ruling class.
00:15:28Because of his work at National Review, Buckley would become a conservative icon.
00:15:33Later, in 1962, Buckley's column On the Right would appear in more than 200 newspapers nationwide.
00:15:40He would also serve as host of the PBS television show Firing Line in the late 1960s.
00:15:46He supported Barry Goldwater and later launched Ronald Reagan into the political stratosphere.
00:15:52Buckley met Reagan before he had entered politics and helped jumpstart his political career,
00:15:57first as governor of California, then for the presidency.
00:16:01Buckley's career was not without controversy, as he weaved together powerful relationships
00:16:06between an elite class of politicians, statesmen, and the intelligence community.
00:16:11For example, on September 18th, 1976, a Chilean foreign ambassador was killed in a car bomb.
00:16:19Several of George H.W. Bush's agents were connected to the assassination.
00:16:23And so as director of the CIA, Bush quickly sought to cover up the incident by spreading disinformation.
00:16:30Buckley also took part in the disinformation campaign.
00:16:32In fact, he ran disinformation campaigns for Chilean factions as early as October 1974, according to investigative journalist Donald Freed.
00:16:43He also discovered that Buckley's brother, James, had met with the assassin, Michael Townley, a week before the assassination.
00:37:12Sobern himself was little more than a crude and naked anti-Semite.0.86
00:37:16Podoretz and his wife, Midge, Dector, maiden name Rosenthal, were both Jews.0.79
00:37:21Podoretz's parents immigrated from Poland, present-day Ukraine,
00:37:26and settled into the Jewish New York culture as staunch leftists.
00:37:31He gained acceptance to Harvard, but instead attended Columbia University,
00:37:36and then later the Jewish Theological Seminary of America.
00:37:39He never intended to enter the rabbinate, but his father wanted to ensure that his son was nonetheless conversant in the intellectual tradition of his people as a non-observant New World Jew who treasured the Hebraic tradition, end quote.
00:37:55In other words, outside pressure from Jewish influence and other donors caused Buckley to detonate his relationship and decades-long friendship with Sobrin.
00:38:04Again, he succumbed to the left liberal gaze
00:38:08and burned one of his friends to the ground
00:43:37In 2021, Doug Wilson helpfully described this type of dynamic in his blog post,
00:43:43Kevin DeYoung and the Taxonomy of Conflict.
00:43:45In that article, Wilson describes a scale from one to four,
00:43:49in which fours speak most courageously on cultural hot-button issues,
00:43:53and ones simply agree with the left's framing.
00:43:56The threes are DeYoung Big Eva types, who will be friendly in public discourse with twos,
00:44:01but, and here's the key point, always distance themselves from fours.0.98
00:44:05To the threes, the fours represent the dangerous right that will cause them to lose influence with the twos, normies, which is their main aim.0.92
00:44:13The problem is that by destroying the fours, with whom threes actually have more in common, they also eliminate the people who would actually contribute to a decisive victory for the right.0.91
00:44:24The left, on the other hand, is successful because it doesn't throw its most extreme elements to the wolves.
00:44:30Instead, it sees them as useful tools for advancing its cause.
00:44:34They are the hinge that swings the Overton window left and opens the door for progress by more moderate leftists.
00:44:42Nancy Pelosi had a strong personal distaste for AOC, for example, but never tried to destroy her publicly.
00:44:49Unlike the right, the left embraces a no enemies on the left strategy and is largely victorious because of it.
00:44:55The reformed camp, let's call the majority threes, has often followed the Buckley-esque instinct to distance itself from and or destroy people to its right, fours.
00:45:07Why? Because its goal is to gain approval with the people to its left, twos, the ones who guard access to larger platforms.
00:45:14They always do this while claiming, like Dreher, that they're converting the normies.0.76
00:45:18People to the right, fours, are considered flight risks because their edginess jeopardizes the three's ability to partner with twos.0.95
00:45:25This is why when the TGC crowd talks about winsomeness, they only mean being winsome to their left, not to their right.0.83
00:45:32In their view, danger to their camp basically always comes from the right.
00:45:37This is also why Kevin DeYoung would actively try to create a poisonous gas cloud around Doug Wilson with his article on culture war, Doug Wilson and the Moscow mood.
00:45:48This also helps explain what has been going on in reformed camps for the past few years after COVID.
00:49:46So far, they've pointed to one churchman in Webin's church who, by the way, has said explicitly that he does not hate the Jews
00:49:52and has even repented of previous off-color comments made privately.
00:49:56It's important to note that it was the supposed Revoice for Nazis pastor, Joel Webin, who actually pastored this young man through these issues effectively.
00:50:05Additionally, there was a White Boy Summer video that showed the lighting of the torch from the 1936 Olympics and other Nazi or Nazi-adjacent imagery.
00:50:13While we, too, would offer critiques about some of the images used, it hardly demonstrates a widespread problem or actual ethnic hatred,
00:50:20particularly when most of those who shared it, including me, by the way, didn't even notice the imagery in the first place.
00:50:26In any case, Wilson and James White have made a concerted effort to publicly and relentlessly call out White Boy Summer,0.73
00:50:33or as they call it, variously white boy dumber, white soy bummer, non-meme lords,0.64
00:50:40and even certain pastors like Joel Webin and us.0.95
00:50:43I suppose for allegedly sympathizing with neo-Nazi content, which none of us do, by the way.
00:50:50Eric found himself in the crosshairs for retweeting something Aristotle said
00:50:54about the negative effects of multiculturalism on democracy.
00:50:58Putting a bow on the messaging, Wilson literally lit a prop bridge on fire in his recent No Quarter November video,
00:51:05a bridge emblazoned with a sign reading White Boy Dumber,
00:51:09indicating his apparent desire to burn the bridge once and for all between himself and anyone who enjoys the pit vipers and campy memes of the White Boy Summer crew.0.63
00:51:18Wilson clearly thinks that anti-Semitism is a threat to the Reformed Church and, like cancer, must be cut out.
00:51:25White, for his part, has said that men who traffic in dark MAGA profile pictures,
00:51:30put too much stock in Jewish influence, and entertain alt-right histories of World War II
00:51:34are beyond pastoral shepherding. As I mentioned a moment ago, a big problem embedded in this
00:51:40discussion is that anti-Semitism, like racism, has never been well-defined or demonstrated at
00:51:45a wide scale. Even in the Moscow camp, it's been defined in different but still unsatisfactory ways.
00:51:52In his book, American Milk and Honey, Wilson defines anti-Semitism as, quote,
00:51:57the notion that Jews are uniquely malevolent and destructive in their cultural, economic, and political influence in the world.0.92
00:52:04It is not anti-Semitism to believe that Jews are sinful, but anti-Semitism does believe that Jews are uniquely sinful and particularly destructive, end quote.0.63
00:52:14One problem with this definition of anti-Semitism is that the scriptures themselves speak of the Jews
00:52:19who received God's revelation but rejected it as being particularly hostile to Christ and his kingdom.
00:52:26Paul, for example, told the Thessalonian church that they, quote,
00:52:29suffered the same things from your own countrymen as they did from the Jews
00:52:34who killed both the Lord Jesus and the prophets and drove us out and displeased God and oppose all mankind.0.99
00:52:47The point is that Scripture often speaks of degrees of wickedness with different peoples,
00:53:01and a greater degree of hardened wickedness is ascribed to those who reject God's special revelation.
00:53:07Thus, it is completely inconsistent with Scripture to say that assigning a greater or even unique degree of wickedness to a certain people is sinful.0.99
00:53:16Between Islam, Buddhism, and Judaism, only Judaism blasphemously claims that Jesus is burning in hell in a vat of excrement and that Mary is a harlot.
00:53:26The phrase uniquely malevolent doesn't seem to me to be particularly controversial in light of politically incorrect facts such as this.0.96
01:07:51Our good name and that of our friend Joel has been maligned,
01:07:54and we believe we have a right to give a public defense.
01:07:57When you have good evidence that people are warning about you privately and via whisper campaigns, as well as making claims about you publicly, for example, the one that Eric and I are leaders of a racist and anti-Semitic movement, the only way to clear your name is with a public response, since you can't possibly know how far the whispers have spread and state your case individually to all involved parties.
01:08:20Now, we've done our best to stay out of this publicly
01:26:49I know that as you delve into them on social media, you just you have the sense that you're
01:26:54like, are we walking on thin ice here because culturally it's so unacceptable.
01:27:00So my question for you is, how do you think through?
01:27:02okay does that mean we just shouldn't address those things yeah we certainly have to make value
01:27:07judgments on you know importance level that we put on them but how do you think through that
01:27:14i mean you you do have to be to be quite careful and precise in how you're thinking through some
01:27:21of these things so give you some examples and and um like one of the one of the fallacies i think
01:27:26can come into play that we see played out. We all have to be aware of. You think about the
01:27:32transgenderism and some of the sexual madness and gender madness that's been ascendant in the last1.00
01:27:3920 years. Really, it goes back quite a bit further than that to Gramsci and Marxist strategy to1.00
01:27:46undermine the natural family and kind of slowly march through the institutions to dissolve
01:27:51the christianity of the west to make them a conquerable foe to some modified form of communism
01:27:58or socialism so that's the long play but when you think about what that's been like experientially
01:28:03for us it meant that when you maybe when you're an 11th grader in public school as i was and you
01:28:11you know maybe want to say you want to notice something about the difference between men and
01:28:15women and their strength or something like that and say like you know i really the the air force
01:28:20or the Marines or whatever, they just kind of said, let's open up standards to allow women to0.75
01:28:24serve in combat in certain roles or things like that. And you might want to notice, well, but0.98
01:28:29hang on, women aren't strong in the way men are strong physically. They don't seem to be suited1.00
01:28:34in their nature to combat. Maybe you don't even cite a Bible verse, but you're just, you're just
01:28:38noticing sort of, there's a check in you that knows just, and it's, it's sometimes visible,
01:28:44sometimes invisible, sometimes opaque, sometimes transparent. You know that you've been discipled
01:28:49to be careful about saying something like that out loud and and in that case there really is a0.90
01:28:54blasphemy law operating which is egalitarianism and feminism where we're trying to dissolve all
01:29:00distinctions of hierarchy because hierarchy is highly problematic to a marxist worldview or a
01:29:07worldview that's attempting to flatten everything so it's like you know one big i've said before and
01:29:11all the kansans get mad at me to make everything like one big kansas sorry guys nebraska's flat
01:29:17too one big nebraska um so there's real blasphemy laws operating there um you you can you could give
01:29:23many many examples of this where the blasphemy laws are surrounding an idol or an opposing
01:29:29ideology a god and his opposing ideology now we do need to be careful um though of what i've seen
01:29:36called the youtube comment or fallacy which is that it's basically a two-step argument and it's
01:29:42You know, imagine somebody commenting on YouTube and in the first pane of the meme, they notice whenever I say the truth about such and such subject, everybody gets mad at me.
01:29:53And so then in the second pane, they conclude, and this is fallaciously, they conclude, therefore, anytime anybody is mad at me or pushes back against something I say, I must be right, which is not actually true.
01:30:06You can say something dumb and also have people mad at you or disagree with you.
01:30:10And I bring that up because what that then requires is that we have sobriety when we approach these issues and we have to be thinking in terms of truth.0.92
01:30:17So we talked in the cold open about steel manning your opponents.
01:30:21You know, we called it the courtesy of specificity, but that's basically just steel manning, which which is a it's for your opponent, but it's also for you, because when you're able to present somebody else's argument in a way you think they would agree with, that is what I'm saying.
01:30:37and then say, okay, and here's why I think you're wrong. Reason, reason, reason, reason, reason.
01:30:43That protects everybody from fallacious emotional kind of reasoning that's steered by the gaze of0.89
01:30:50some God and its attendant blasphemy laws. Now, what's dangerous about that is that it can lead0.93
01:30:56you into some places that are, let's say, politically incorrect, where maybe you start
01:31:02doing this and you're going down a rabbit hole and, uh, you know, all of us who went to public
01:31:08school to, to the previous illustration know what this is like. All of a sudden you're, you're like
01:31:14my, the people who are supposed to be teaching me, they actually don't know what they're talking
01:31:18about. Cause even when I steel man their position, it's nonsense, it's word salad. It doesn't make0.53
01:31:23sense. It's emotional. It's blustering. It's unfair. It's straw man. It's not driven by reason.
01:31:59so there's like landmines all around and it calls for sobriety i think it calls for for care
01:32:03well don't you think there's there's a point here about christians should argue a certain way
01:32:08so doug has made this point in the past like you want to steel man your opponent
01:32:11meaning you put his argument in terms that he would agree with right so you fairly represent
01:32:17this kind of goes to the gas cloud fallacy as you've called it one of the other things i've
01:32:23seen in play um we we've kind of described as like a kafka trap this is a logical fallacy that
01:32:30occurs when someone is accused of something and their defense is used as evidence of their guilt
01:32:36so i actually found this helpful jd hall had posted this on twitter and he said i've seen
01:32:41this argument in woke wars one and and it seems like it's being used again so he says step one
01:32:48call someone a racist bigot or anti-semite step two say whatever you want about them no matter
01:32:53how dishonest because that's how you're allowed to treat racist bigots and anti-semites step three
01:32:58when you're called out for this ask why they're defending racism bigotry and anti-semitism so
01:33:04these are i think variations they're not all the same thing but the kafka trap is a little bit the
01:33:10same way like i know that you're seething with hatred or crackling with envy and and the best
01:33:17way to identify someone who has that envy is they'll deny it so then you're like well if i
01:33:21deny it it just in their in their way they set up the argument well then i'm guilty of it
01:33:26um it seems like brian now asking about the the gas cloud fallacy yeah um why would this be
01:33:33particularly harmful i mean just thinking about christian communities and christian brothers
01:33:38i guess two questions why is it harmful and where have you kind of seen this happen so it's harmful
01:33:44because one of the things that it doesn't allow for is actually robust debate about things that
01:33:49can be somewhat nuanced or have multiple layers to them one of the issues with some of the framing
01:33:54i've seen around as an example around the anti-semitism charges is that um number one
01:34:00the the argument itself we just have to admit as uncomfortable as as it is because of our the
01:34:07wiring we've all received from our cultural upbringing just the stuff in the air um is that
01:34:13arguments about racism and anti-semitism are left framed to begin with yeah you're in stepping into
01:34:21those debates and um treating them as existential threats and as like one of the most serious things0.78
01:34:28that's happening in the world today is there's a bunch of white racists you know going around who0.96
01:34:32we're going to, you know, whatever, destroy everything. That is the leftist frame. It's0.97
01:34:37why we brought up the, you know, remember old Jack, C.S. Lewis, and what he said about fire
01:34:41extinguishers and floods. If you look at our culture today, and you were just to ask on an
01:34:45objective level, what is the biggest, what are, what are some of the biggest problems related to
01:34:50race, ethnos, all of these various tangled nest of problems? What is a bigger problem?
01:34:57white people heritage americans however you want to put it you know being taught to hate themselves0.60
01:35:04and consider themselves as entrenched structurally racist people destroying the world who come from
01:35:11evil people who uh and and that have a kind of privilege that was built on the back of0.98
01:35:17um black evils or is a bigger problem that um white people are likely to in in sinful ways go0.99
01:35:27out and mistreat um blacks latina some other other races or ethnicities out in the world0.96
01:35:34and i would argue that it's not even close the far far bigger problem you just read a book like
01:35:40jeremy carl's unprotected class i got that right right yes yeah something in my head prevalent it
01:35:46It's very prevalent. So one of the problems right now with the poison gas fallacy, the imprecision, is that one of the things it's trying to do is adopt this left-framed gatekeeping of a conversation itself and what you're fundamentally doing.
01:36:02I think I see this a lot out of Doug's work in American Milk and Honey and some of the conversations surrounding this are that what it amounts to is to say you have to adopt my definitions on the definitional level.
01:36:18You have to adopt my arguments or you are very likely one of these anti-Semitic or in danger of being anti-Semitic, black hearted, seething kind of person.
01:36:29And so the tactic is like dropping a big gas cloud that's sort of imprecise and it's defining characteristics over a whole conversation.0.59
01:36:37And the tactic is flee the gas cloud to the only acceptable position in the debate, which is mine.
01:36:45And if you don't, then I'm not saying you're an anti-Semite, but you probably are.
01:36:51So the problem with this is it's not precise enough and it doesn't allow for genuine disagreement on the definitional level to actually say, like, as we did in the cold open, well, hang on.
01:37:03Some of this language on the defining level is it's too it's you're proving too much.
01:37:09Other people have raised these criticisms of his work as well.
01:37:12But I think even like Joe Soberen's point that we talked about was that in the West, one of the defining characteristics of our legal system, I think as it accords with the Ten Commandments and witness bearing, is that we should be precise in defining crimes and sins.
01:37:32But one of the tactics of the left is let's define them very loosely so we have a lot of power to condemn people.
01:37:38and then people go around in this existential dread,
01:38:08I didn't realize there was a Christian position, like an orthodox position, in other words, on a historical narrative.
01:38:15Well, that really makes people, to Brian's point, I think you're like, wow, I really don't want to question too much about the historical narrative.
01:38:24Because it sounds like if I do, I no longer have the quote-unquote Christian position.
01:38:29one of the things that happens is that the further distance you get from an event
01:38:33the more cartoonized often our recollections of it become and this is just not natural you you come
01:38:40to historical or scholarly consensus that's based on the conversations happened for a long time and
01:38:45so people to develop like the crusades are a good example of this one of the reasons we went through
01:38:50them and have gone through many elements of the crusades and saying well the cartoonized version
01:38:56of the crusades that that the west basically adopted in its own self-reflection concerning
01:39:02its christian tradition in history was to say the crusades were unjustified wars of aggression by
01:39:08greedy christians who were just going and destroying peaceful muslims who were just trying0.82
01:39:13to invent calculus and we just wouldn't leave them alone yeah and so we committed atrocities0.98
01:39:19and oh by the way against a lot of jews along the way now christians sin in the crusades but
01:39:25the point is that it's actually a lot more complicated than that and so when you get
01:39:30again with the blasphemy laws attending an idol or some sort of ideological um blasphemy law issue
01:39:37when you start to say things like that about any historical event i'm immediately suspicious i have
01:39:44a red flag going up in my mind saying there's something ideological happening here there's
01:39:50something political and ideological that's less based about the actual truth of the events
01:39:54themselves than about the the utility of this version of events for political reasons today
01:40:03so so to be clear people are like wow they love the nazi you know no that's not the point we're
01:40:09making isn't to all of a sudden assert our own cartoonized version of world war ii that's like
01:40:16Hitler was an unqualified Christian prince and the Nazis were unqualifiedly the good guys and
01:40:22Churchill was just this black-hearted thug who never did anything right and he secretly tortured0.96
01:40:26puppies in his basement. The point is no cartoons anywhere. Let's do the difficult work of history0.97
01:40:34and also just recognize that there's a reason that more than one book is written about any
01:40:40historical event. One of the reasons is because even professional historians disagree about
01:40:44different the nature of different events well that that's why even um you know in very brief
01:40:50research on topics like what is the genetic history of the ashkenazi jews well like a two
01:40:56minutes of google searching and you'll find this is highly debated it can often be very contentious
01:41:02people don't agree so that in and of itself should should kind of be a warning to me when somebody
01:41:08says this must be your position on on the ashkenazi jews and i'm like well but even the
01:41:15geneticists who are many of which are not christians even they don't agree with something
01:41:19like that one one clarification here i think is helpful with an actual example is that when we're
01:41:26when a christian is doing history we want the christian position on a thing really is what
01:41:31truly happened because christians believe in truth yeah we don't want to believe something false
01:41:36but you have to distinguish then between different layers of the christian approach to a thing the
01:41:42ethical approach to something like let's take world war ii christians should all agree um or
01:41:49at least there should be a really robust conversation about the ethics of firebombing
01:41:53civilians right we should not be christians should not be in the business of intentionally
01:41:59murdering women and children in combat okay now that principle i just laid out first of all there's
01:42:04a debate that would happen historically concerning the horror of war and the ethic ethical calculation0.82
01:42:10of that claim the that comes into the crusades world war one world like all of the wars all right
01:42:15but but the the question i would have that would immediately arise from that on a historical level
01:42:20is then let's say that we agree some hypothetical group of christians and pastors or whatever
01:42:25agreed on that ethical claim i just made well then we would be forced to say the allies were
01:42:32therefore extremely wicked and sinful in their approach to the war in firebombing dresden at
01:42:39least at many points and the the axis powers were extremely sinful in their actions in uh rocketing0.50
01:42:48london and blitzkrieg so we could say something like that we could also say as an objective
01:42:54ethical fact that the darwinism that was in the air at that time that affected germany but also0.86
01:43:01So America, England, this absolutely ascendant Darwinism at that time and its child, which is eugenics, led to some absolute evils and atrocities.
01:43:13For example, Hitler's, I think it's the T4 basically extermination eugenics program where he ordered, and this is undisputed, where he ordered the liquidation, the murder of a million basically like mental ward patients in Germany.0.86
01:43:32And they had carried out this to the tune of at least hundreds of thousands by the time some church leaders in Germany within the party actually said, hey, you need to stop doing that.0.74
01:43:42that this is actually just plain murder and then he halted that program at some point so we say
01:43:49that's evil and then we could also say and all of similar programs like that everywhere in the world
01:43:54that they were because of this darwinism in the air all of those were evil and what we've just done
01:44:00is some like not super complex but a little bit more complex than a cartoon version
01:44:05of ethical analysis treating history on its different layers of truth the historical fact
01:44:11the ethical fact and and this is the kind of thing that happens when you don't get emotional
01:44:18and try to shut down the whole conversation with left-coded epithets from the beginning
01:44:23you can then have that conversation where people can get in the same room or they can exchange
01:44:29books articles podcasts whatever and have a robust debate about some of these topics um
01:44:35but when you see that debate can't even be had you're not even allowed to have that debate and
01:44:43anybody having that debate on on any level is an anti-semite or is a racist or is that screams
01:44:51Saul Alinsky Gramsci and Marxist left-coded framing that all right-wing people should agree
01:44:59let's get rid of that let's actually just jettison that whole mode of um exchange of ideas
01:45:08yeah let's at least be able to have a conversation yeah it is really interesting because if you
01:45:12recall doug wilson one of his favorite lines for the last i don't know however long i've been
01:45:17reading him was that um the the war that we're fighting is actually control over the dictionary
01:45:21and so it is really unhelpful when you define anti-semitism as loosely as possible so that
01:45:28even certain fine forms of noticing as, as Yuri Burrito said, uh, are not the same, you know?
01:45:35And so you're actually guilty. What's interesting with this leftist tactic that you were talking
01:45:39about, Brian, is that I actually experienced this firsthand. A lot of us have, especially
01:45:43millennials. I'm graduating from, from college around the 2008, 2009 time period. And for you
01:45:49zoomers, the economy was really bad. That was the housing crisis. Um, it was actually really1.00
01:45:55unemployment numbers were really high. So I'm getting out of college. I have college loans to
01:45:59pay off, you know, and I'm trying to start a household and all this. And I'm in my college
01:46:05classes, business school. I had to take some HR classes, which is quite unfortunate, but I had to
01:46:10take some HR classes and you had affirmative action at the time. So they had certain hiring
01:46:15quotas based on race and gender and things like that, that they had to fulfill. And so even if
01:46:21you graduated with good marks and you had a lot of experience, it didn't necessarily mean that you
01:46:26were going to be the best qualified person for the job because they had to fill their quotas.
01:46:30So that was what I was dealing with at the time. And if you noticed, like I may or may not have
01:46:35at my public university, that that was actually unjust and it was actually a form of racism,
01:46:41you got a lot of pushback. Like, no, I'm not saying anything bad about any of these people
01:46:46that are within the quotas that they have to fill. But don't you think that we should just
01:46:50hire someone based upon their merit for the position and not necessarily just based upon
01:46:55their skin color. And automatically, because of the loose terms that they're able to control the
01:47:00dictionary and to divine things, you're actually a racist for that sort of noticing because you
01:47:06actually have privilege. And we've seen this played out time and time again over the years
01:47:11into this self-loathing that is encouraged and shame for just simply being a white person and
01:47:17the privilege that that you have that you don't even understand why you why you have it but it's
01:47:22because of that you're actually an oppressor that you have the privilege that you have and so you
01:47:26see this this trap that was laid out for us and in that sort of noticing but it's just being
01:47:31reapplied now in this uh in this uh topic of anti-semitism where even certain types of noticing0.66
01:47:38is sinful and you are the nabal you know that that abigail should definitely be warning their
01:47:44pastors against just because you notice like like in the example that that pastor so they gave1.00
01:47:49about this historical narrative being actually history is really complex and so it really is
01:47:55i think a war over the dictionary and so i think that those not not being able to define your terms
01:48:03very tightly but intentionally having the loosest form of a definition you can for a sin
01:48:09is really problematic to the point where you're saying there are certain pastors that need to
01:48:14step down and certain church members that need to be put under church discipline just for laughing
01:48:21at the wrong thing or noticing the wrong thing. Yeah, that's actually an interesting thing. It's
01:48:25in American Milk and Honey. I've seen it on the blog and the Doug has repeated it like in the
01:48:30CrossPolitik episode where he said the problem is Stone Choir. And then he went on to describe
01:48:36joel is revoiced for nazis um which and then the most of the show is actually about joel so it
01:48:43really seems to be a gas cloud kind of attack but what's interesting about this is um you have this
01:48:52dynamic where you're kind of lumping all these things together you're using pretty charged
01:48:57language and then there's as brian said there's always kind of a escape hatch of what didn't
01:49:02specifically say it's kind of like the buckley like why didn't say buchanan was an anti-semite
01:49:07i just said he said and done some anti-semitic things um as you look at uh some of this though
01:49:13brian i do want to specifically ask about the revoice for nazis we talked about that in the
01:49:18episode uh what is revoice first of all what's the the connotation denotation there um and and
01:49:26how do you think that's being used well so revoice was surrounding this whole leftist play to
01:49:32do a gramsian play about homosexuality about sodomy and to basically say that we need to be
01:49:39really tender towards men who are homosexual attracted and we we basically need to say that
01:49:46as long as they're not actually sodomizing one another or carrying out homosexual behaviors
01:49:52sexual behaviors then the desires yeah they could form like a covenant with another man and live0.65
01:49:58with them and have a celibate cuddle friendship. They could have, you know, all of this happening
01:50:04within the PCA. Yeah. It's, it's happening in the PCA and the reform world. And, um, and, and the,
01:50:09the, the key point was that there were some of it was a debate about whether the desire itself,
01:50:14like if you're in that situation and you constantly desire to sodomize another man,
01:50:18um, was, was that actually itself sinful if you resisted the desire and you didn't actually act
01:50:24on it. And we would obviously say, along with the reformed tradition on concupiscence, that
01:50:29the desire itself is sinful and needs to be mortified. And so you absolutely can't be carving
01:50:35out this side B gay, I identify as gay, but I just don't sodomize another man. It's like identifying0.71
01:50:43as a thief or a greedy man. And I just continue to use the label, but I don't actually go and do
01:50:51the thing. I just carve out this space where it's not sinful for me to want to. So the revoice for
01:50:58Nazis tactic is to say that us and Joel Webin are doing that same play with men who are sinfully
01:51:07partial against the Jews or sin in, I guess, some ways that the Nazis did.
01:58:22It's begging the question, of course you're going to conclude someone is a misogynist if you just get to own the dictionary, to Dan's point, about what defines a misogynist in the first place.
01:58:34Instead of defining it in a way that can then actions and words and deeds can be actually examined under the light of reason.
01:58:40so it's an unfalsifiable claim so you have two routes you either say you're right i am a0.50
01:58:46misogynist or you say i'm not and they say a misogynist would say that that's the kafka trap
01:58:51the kafka trap yeah well and especially how uh you think of the term nazi you know brian said0.96
01:58:57in the cold open nobody in our camp nobody that we're affiliated with talk to including the anons0.84
01:59:04it there's a i'm there's tons of crazies out there i'm not saying there's not but the people
01:59:08that we actually know nobody is saying i am a nazi let's resurrect 1940s political party nobody
01:59:15doug said something in the cross politics show that i thought was interesting he said we never
01:59:20want to call somebody a nazi who doesn't call themselves one and he uses the samuel holden
01:59:25video because there was a 1936 the olympics the olympics he said samuel is calling himself a nazi
01:59:31and i'm like no no no no no he's actually not um so because you talked to him and he said i'm not
01:59:37a nazi correct and that's what i mean like i specifically asked because i didn't recognize
01:59:42any of the images in the video i said hey what's the deal with this um and i think the main point
01:59:48from my understanding was uh they were trying to offend the post-war consensus sensibilities they
01:59:54were committed on this on the level of when doug said if you really want to you know make waves
01:59:59make white babies right a while ago doug knew what he was doing or when he said to the you know
02:00:05whatever the crazy jezebel lady i can't remember her name and he used the c word he said they're
02:00:10they're saying to themselves look we're just a bunch of c words um and and i am i don't have i0.92
02:00:15guess the stones of doug to say that word in in public or in private honestly because it's a gross
02:00:20word but what he was doing is he's intentionally outraging the god what we've called what i call
02:00:26a sunday school class once this was an actual sunday school class um wasn't the call i'm calling0.65
02:00:31things gay yeah the virtue of calling these gay because what you're doing is you're looking the0.69
02:00:36idol square in the eyes and you're poking it in both eyes yes and when you poke something in both0.88
02:00:41eyes you know there's going to not going to be like an oh your arguments were persuasive to me
02:00:45they're going to be like outraged and hysterical so there's a tactical thing there where i think
02:00:51um you know you can you can judge the tactics those are they're public actions they're open
02:00:57for public debate. Um, but you have to at least in charity say, Oh, in terms of the play,
02:01:04that's what you were doing when you did this thing. Yes. Uh, the other thing that I think
02:01:09is helpful. We've had a lot of pastoral conversations with people, um, and a lot
02:01:13of really good people, I think who feel caught in the middle. Um, and so people who've come to
02:01:18church, people from afar pastors, again, Brian mentioned this in the cold open, but
02:01:23one of the questions that i get is i wish you guys would just be clear about what you believe
02:01:29about nazism anti-semitism but particularly stone choir and it's interesting because i've made
02:01:35numerous comments about it uh brian's made numerous comments about it i know that um it's
02:01:43like this the gas clouding you've been gas clouded so a lot of times i haven't said anything because
02:01:49number one i've actually never listened to a stone choir podcast um so i'm like well i feel
02:01:56kind of stupid weighing in on a conversation that i'm not an expert in and have no experience experience
02:02:02with how can i possibly denounce it um now i will say i've seen a lot of tweets uh from cory and the0.99
02:02:10other uh is it whoa uh the other hosts i've seen the tweets uh i think one this week was uh hitler
02:02:18hating the jews or attack whatever he said is proof that he was a christian and i read that0.96
02:02:23and i thought that is idiotic um i think that some of the stuff like comparing mixed race children0.99
02:02:31to feces to feces and i read that and i didn't like the reaction in my heart wasn't like you0.99
02:02:36know there's probably some nuanced debate here that could be had i just went like oh yeah whatever
02:02:43whatever we believe not that right so so and to be clear i think in our discussions with some of
02:02:50the pastors in in moscow i was concerned because they're saying hey there's a huge problem and i
02:02:55was like okay maybe there's something i'm missing because in our context this isn't a problem none
02:03:01of the people that i've talked to are you know ready to become nazis or there's no hatred of
02:03:06the jews i don't i'm just not seeing that and we pastor a lot of people it's not hiding under like
02:03:12us not guys we have book groups constantly we have leadership cohorts with you know pretty much all
02:03:17of the men in our church who are you know actively members and involved parish events we've talked
02:03:23about world war ii nazism anti-semitism the jew stuff we've we've talked about these things like
02:03:30to in in the way that you know you get a bunch of nerds together who all play like the same video
02:03:34games or whatever and they're like oh have you know did you see the glitch at you know if you
02:03:39up down left right x y jump you know did you see that and this like our guys are tismed out on a
02:03:44on on all sorts of but you go through the stuff and you're like what do you think about that tweet0.99
02:03:49of cory mahler like oh that was dumb that was stupid yeah well i don't know what he's doing0.68
02:03:55with that like our guys aren't um influenced in the sense of like again you said i i've never0.99
02:04:01listened to even a minute of stone choir podcast um not even one minute not even 10 seconds i've
02:04:07never hit play on a Stone Choir podcast. So it's not as if we haven't discussed some of these
02:04:13things with our guys, but we talked about it in the cold open. If we ask any of our guys,
02:04:18what do you think about this popular conversation that's happening, you know, surrounding Stone
02:04:23Choir and these guys and our stuff and Stephen Wolf and Doug Wilson, all this stuff. Most of
02:04:27them will say like 80 to 95% of them will say some variation of, you know, I really disagreed
02:04:33with this i you know i agreed with this i thought there'd be more nuance here hated that but you
02:04:39know none of them are like yes ich bin ein nazi i don't even know what that means i believe it
02:04:48means i am a nazi okay somebody's gonna cut that uh yes uh you remember when what's his name said
02:04:54i'm a jelly donut ich bin ein berliner i can't remember which president yeah maybe jfk so i
02:05:01think um just providing clarity and and when a honest churchman asks me these questions i will
02:05:08give an honest answer what i am careful to do is not play the public denouncement game just for
02:05:13the sake of it because i think it's a leftist play do you know how i'm sorry i interrupted you
02:05:19i just you know i just interrupted eric it's allowable okay dan i'm really tempted to interrupt
02:05:26do right now on performative denouncements and how they're never, you're never able to satisfy
02:05:31the appetite. Okay. You will always be able to pull up another screenshot of another anonymous
02:05:37account or not anonymous account on X saying something, I'll just say stupid and sinful.1.00
02:05:44And like, well, that was dumb. And I know what they're doing. They're being transgressive.1.00
02:05:49They're being whatever. And you will never get to the bottom of denouncing them because
02:05:55they will keep making that more new ones will keep happening right so our approach to these
02:06:01things has generally been it's not as if our positions are kind of mysterious we are in the
02:06:08habit of recording multi-hour podcasts for years now talking about stuff including controversial
02:06:14stuff where we just tell a well hopefully well-researched historical tale talk about the
02:06:21issues apply them to our current day that's our approach the thing that you're not like the thing
02:06:26you're just not going to find if you want it from us i'm sorry you're not going to find it is
02:06:31constant discernment media uh you know type of tactics constant denouncements and really allowing
02:06:38anybody to steer our denouncements through demands it's just like not going to be a thing that we do
02:06:44and the reason is because it's left coded and if you do it you've just adopted their frame you've
02:06:51said you're right about it you've paid the dangle you've said you're right about how this debate
02:06:55should go you're in charge of it but i've seen other people do this where they're like okay
02:07:00fine i'll denounce them and then they denounce it whatever the thing is and then they're like
02:07:05that wasn't enough it's never enough denounce it again denounce it again so one of the charge
02:07:09against our camp has been why are you riling up the anons and why are you and by which they mean
02:07:16like why is eric you know it was on the may blog this week but you know why why is eric sharing
02:07:22uh white boy summer meme campy memes with 80s synth vibes and you know what i would say to that
02:07:30is i i think it's kind of cool because we like them it's it's not uh nobody in that movement
02:07:37is like again i'm not asking boomers to understand millennial and zoomer humor no like literally not
02:07:43going to do a course it's okay if they don't i don't lose any sleep if james white doesn't
02:07:47understand a meme i like that's right it doesn't bother me at all i still think about it so i i
02:07:51think about that whole conversation and then i think about a the denouncements don't work
02:07:56number two is left coated but then i also think this is a genuine strategic difference pastorally0.71
02:08:02that when I see young men particularly, and by the way, a lot of these Anons are guys with
02:08:09businesses and family men with more than five children and good churchmen and good churches.0.98
02:08:14But let's talk about young men. If I see young men who are interested in this sort of subject
02:08:21matter, I say, well, we're Christians. Let's engage in debate and argumentation. As Brian
02:08:28mentioned earlier let's let's present the cases what i won't do is a left-coded denouncement
02:08:36having never even listened to some of the content wait you're not allowed to even ask that question
02:08:40right the jd hall flat earth example yeah it was a great example explain this because i think jd
02:08:46had a great point and jd hall is probably whatever there's like a whole every anytime on the internet
02:08:50now you mention a person there's like a whole lore where the denouncement thing again you're
02:08:55like, but, but did you know that JD Hall wants sin? You're like, okay, whatever. Um, the whole
02:08:58thing was, it was so, it was a brilliant tweet. He basically said, um, you know, this is how you
02:09:04should deal with subversive or conspiratorial or edge, like fringe conspiracy type of thinking
02:09:10or anything that has the reputation of that. Uh, he's like a guy, you know, ask me, maybe he's in
02:09:15his church or something. Ask, um, Hey, what do you think about the earth? Like, do you think
02:09:19the earth is around? Do you think we've been in space? Do you think like the earth is flat?
02:09:21and jd hall was like you know um no i've but i've never heard what what do you think and he said
02:09:27and then he listened and the guy for like 20 minutes explained why he believes the earth is
02:09:32flat and as one of the hosts of haunted cosmos let me just say that both ben and i have been in
02:09:39these conversations multiple times and instead of 20 minutes it's been two hours of just and we've
02:09:44done the exact same thing jd hall describes which was he listened and then he gave like a couple he
02:09:50was like wow that's that's really dumb and the guy was like well am i in trouble for like could
02:09:56i be in your church and believe that and he was like yeah what does that have to do with anything0.99
02:10:01right you can believe something dumb like you could believe that the browns are the greatest
02:10:05nfl team of all time right you would just be i mean you'd be wrong like the earth isn't flat like0.97
02:10:11we've had these conversations i'm just impressed you used a sports analogy
02:10:15oh everyone knows that i am like i know of the king's hall like very apt to reach for you know
02:10:22it reminds me a lot of um you know that one quarterback that one time for the dolphins
02:10:28yes who am i thinking of you're thinking of to a tag of aloa after the concussion yeah that's
02:10:34that's after i don't even need to say it because everyone knows um yeah so so uh providing clarity
02:10:41for for the good people in the middle who are genuinely wondering like are you guys harboring
02:10:45nazis no are you nazis no are you anti-semites no do you are you avid fans of stone choir we've
02:10:52not listened to it um and then saying okay can you know for for the good people we're going to move
02:10:58on um one of the things i think that's interesting um is with buckley in his story uh jack trotter
02:11:08brought this up right that he had out outside influence upon him ironically by some jewish
02:11:15people to get joe sober and fired so it seems like as wise christians one of the things we
02:11:21ought to do is also think through uh differing motivations we should think through okay could
02:11:28there be political mechanisms at play and this one i want to ask dan um but dan you mentioned
02:11:34something that i thought was really interesting uh james white and we'll get into the timeline by
02:11:40the way in just a minute uh but james white and doug wilson at the end of july july 22nd is the
02:11:45first may blog and then they're dividing line shortly after addressing the meme situation and
02:11:51anti-semitism and oh my gosh there's a huge problem and guess what doug just wrote a book
02:11:56and you know to to his statement i've defined it uh envy and then what do you know i go looking
02:12:01point, I find it. But think about the political situation that's going on in America in July.
02:12:10That's interesting. So I'm going to ask you about that in just a second.
02:12:13It's also interesting that this second wave of attacks publicly came, I mean,
02:12:19on the heels of the presidential election, November 2nd, right? And you would have to
02:12:27kind of at least wonder and say, are these politically motivated, these publicizing of
02:12:33these events? So talk to me first about July. No, those are really interesting questions.
02:12:38And maybe it's just giving someone too much credit. And it could just be that the timing
02:12:42was just happenstance. I don't really know. But what is interesting about the timing of this
02:12:47whole situation that we'll get into is that Joel Webin was made aware of this meme that was sent
02:12:54from his church member back in february yeah and so began working with his this church member uh
02:12:59towards repentance reconciliation you know i'm sure he was examining like where is he standard
02:13:05counseling protocol right you ask a lot of questions try to get down to the root of sin
02:13:10get the facts yeah make sure that you've got a right perspective before you start calling someone
02:13:13to repent or or put them under church discipline and things like that but then i don't know exactly
02:13:19when uh doug wilson and james white received the meme but it was around july i think it was july
02:13:2622nd when doug published his may blog and that just happened to be the day after it was announced
02:13:33that joe biden was stepping down uh from the presidential race it's a few short days after
02:13:39the assassination attempt yes that's right and so politically if you look at polling data which
02:13:45i pulled up on polymarket um you'll see that trump had somewhere around like a 68 chance of
02:13:51winning and that was you know uh kamala had had some percentage points there and joe biden had
02:13:57some percentage points there but it was just really interesting timing that right around the
02:14:02almost pinnacle of trump's lead in the presidential polls that that was published and and then like
02:14:11you said after the election trump wins and then the attacks resume and so and we know now doug
02:14:18has said publicly that one of his main concerns with this was whether or not pete hegseth a crac
02:14:24church member would get confirmed as sec def now i don't know if he was thinking about it back then
02:14:29you would have to ask but yeah certainly there's political thought going into it if it was
02:14:35politically motivated the timing would seem to fit with that theory simply because if you're
02:14:40trying to secure political power for yourself or for your friends or for someone then you would0.99
02:14:46actually have to distance yourself from these problematic elements the fours like we said in0.91
02:14:50our in our cold open the fours that are rabble rousers and speak most courageously to cultural0.92
02:14:56issues you'd have to distance yourself for the sake of political platforming and so it it does
02:15:01make sense as far as the timeline but who knows doug would have to answer for that and that's why
02:15:07another point to clarify there this is why we're trying to be clear direct and offer a falsifiable
02:15:12claim that can be refuted because at that point it becomes really easy for doug to say actually
02:15:17that was just happenstance it was just just timing didn't think about it wasn't a motivation
02:15:23there's actually an easy out uh which is important for a righteous man to be able to defend himself
02:15:29but if it's an unfalsifiable charge then there's no escaping it so that's why just to reiterate
02:15:36it's very important to be direct the the one of the related something that comes to mind is that
02:15:42you can think about it the political dynamics it's not wrong to seek power for you and your
02:15:45friends and try to leverage that power well that's one of the things the right wing actually
02:15:49needs to recover yeah so that's not our criticism we we should be seeking power and leveraging it
02:15:54for righteous ends in the political sphere obviously um it's not obvious to everybody
02:16:00but obviously that's one of the great needs think about somebody though running for like
02:16:04SBC president, maybe in 2018 or whenever. And, um, that person, let's say that they liked Doug
02:16:11Wilson in the past and that Doug Wilson had talked positively about them before. Now that person's
02:16:16running for SBC president, that guy might have a political calculation where he goes, that's not
02:16:21going to help me. I need to denounce Doug Wilson because he's this radical crazy guy. Who's like0.98
02:16:26federal visionist and heretic. And he's, you know, Steven Sittler and all this stuff. And he's got
02:16:31all this baggage so the sbc guy is previously friendly all of a sudden might go you know start
02:16:36criticizing doug um there's a similar temptation too i think for in in moscow this might be a new
02:16:43sensation for them honestly because they've been forced like throughout for a lot most of their
02:16:49lifespan and um but now there's like the embargo is lifted on moscow and they go oh we actually
02:16:56have mainstream like tucker has dug on amazing and and i'm i'm for it i want them to have
02:17:02mainstream influence and but there might be a calculation in there where they go ogden has
02:17:07said a lot of joel webben said a lot of good things about us and like signaled our way and
02:17:11like we shared their stuff maybe once or two there's been a signal you know so i need to make
02:17:16sure that like we put some distance just to say hey other people watching those guys like they're
02:17:23crazy we're not with them and i'm not saying that's their words i'm just saying look at the
02:17:28look at the pattern and just understand that this is this is a part of politics that the the right
02:17:34actually needs to figure out is that there's a reason politics is like you say people are being
02:17:41political it has a certain implication it's because the the art of politics really does
02:17:46include power calculus yeah and image and a image related to association it's important we make it's
02:17:55it's not whether but which you can't escape that that's you're going to have those calculations
02:17:59but we need to be careful that when they're doing them we're doing them righteously and that we're
02:18:04being accurate and i would also say like uh what would actually be helpful so we're sort of doing
02:18:09some post-mortem on a lot of this stuff again we'll get into the timeline in a minute but part
02:18:15of it if if you want to build coalition within your camp and on the right i absolutely think you
02:18:19should um we're not saying this seems to be a misunderstanding of netter where people think
02:18:26that we're saying or it's been doug is attributed to me or somebody else in our camp saying like
02:18:31well eric apparently is fine with all these really you know really actually sinful things
02:18:36happening on the right i'm not fine with them that is completely not what i'm saying but i am
02:18:42saying in a first Corinthians chapter six type way, we ought to prove the viability of our
02:18:47internal polity by proving that we can deal with these things internally in a way that doesn't
02:18:52destroy us in front of the left. Two things. One, I'm not going to give oxygen with 60,000
02:18:57Twitter followers to every passing Anon who says something edgy. That's what he wants me to do.
02:19:02Yes. That's what the Anon wants me to do. Two, when I have relationship with somebody who says
02:19:07something I think is off, first thing I'm going to try to do is actually talk to them.
02:35:06Pastor Webin has confirmed that the church member
02:35:08was not getting drunk while sending text messages to Tobias. Doug also said that what drives this
02:35:14sort of thing is envy. He went on to say on the basis of Paul's argument about the Jew-Gentile
02:35:19relations, quote, I look for envy and sure enough, I see it, end quote. Though he didn't mention Joel
02:35:26in the post by name, several people began asking Joel if this was about his church, given he'd been
02:35:32a speaker at the New Christendom press conference. At the time, Christchurch deacon and cross-politic
02:35:38host, Gabe Wrench, had been attacking White Boy Summer on X. And so naturally, people were starting
02:35:44to connect the dots. On July 31st, James White went on the dividing line to talk about the same
02:35:50meme and a concern with the alleged anti-Semitism it represented. And in that episode, he threatened
02:35:56to start naming names. He also called for church discipline for both the church member and the
02:36:02pastor, whom he said should not be a pastor. James later told Joel that he did not know who
02:36:08the situation was about when he threatened to name names. On August 7th, a Zoom call took place
02:36:14between Tobias, Joel, the church member, and other parties. Unbeknownst to Joel or Tobias,
02:36:20the church member had recorded the call on a separate device. In the call, Tobias made
02:36:25repeated calls for excommunication and or church discipline. He also said that there was a
02:36:31contingent of pastors forming an alliance against Joel, Brian, Eric, Andrew Isker, and Stephen Wolf
02:36:38and that that contingent was made up of James White, Doug Wilson, Joe Boot, and others. The
02:36:45church member from Joel's church repented for any offense he had given as well as previous things
02:36:51he had said about the Jews and the Holocaust. The call ended with Tobias stating that no further
02:36:56action was needed, and that he would talk with Joel and the church member if any further steps
02:37:01were to be taken by him. But on September 13th, Tobias appeared on the Chris Arnzen show,
02:37:08Iron Sharpens Iron. In that episode, Tobias specifically named Joel, Brian Sauvé, and Eric
02:37:14Kahn as pastors leading a racist and anti-Semitic movement in America. He elaborated that Eric had
02:37:21retweeted a quote about Aristotle, which said that multiculturalism was detrimental to a healthy
02:37:27democracy. Tobias said that Eric was supporting, quote, race segregation by retweeting the
02:37:33Aristotle reference. On October 2nd, Joel recorded and released a podcast about the situation.
02:37:40He did so because he was told by Eschatology Matters that they were releasing a podcast with
02:37:44Tobias in which he would be giving his narrative of the situation. Joel's intent was to get ahead
02:37:51of the narrative, which is why he recorded and released the episode. He wanted to reiterate that
02:37:55the church member had repented for past comments, was in good standing with the church, and that
02:38:00Tobias' calls for excommunication and or church discipline were unwarranted. On October 29th,
02:38:07Eschatology Matters posted a video response from Tobias about the whole situation.
02:38:12In the episode, Tobias claimed that he never called for church discipline or excommunication
02:38:17when talking to Joel. It's also important to note that before publishing this video and according
02:38:22to multiple sources close to the situation, Doug Wilson and James White had consulted on a Zoom
02:38:29call with Tobias about what he would be saying in his video recording. When this episode came out,
02:38:36Joe Boot, James White, and Doug Wilson helped promote it on X. The same day, October 29th,
02:38:42Chris Arnzen sent an email to a redacted recipient, and in that email, Chris shared the recent podcast episode from Eschatology Matters with Tobias, and said that he had been in contact with James White and Doug Wilson prior to the date of the email.
02:38:58He wrote, quote, I've been involved in a group discussion with fine men of God like Doug Wilson, James White, and others who all agree that this assessment of Joel Webin is completely accurate, end quote.
02:39:12The assessment, Arzin went on to say, was that, quote,0.58
02:39:15Joel Webin has clearly adopted sinful anti-Semitic views that at best trivialize the Holocaust and at worst deny it completely and contain revisionist understanding of the depth of sin which Hitler and the Nazis were guilty, end quote.
02:39:31The next day, on October 30th, Joel sent the Zoom call recording to Eschatology Matters, who promptly removed Tobias' video.
02:39:40On November 1st, Eschatology Matters issued a full retraction of the video.
02:40:02Our regret isn't only due to the conflict that's brought to the body of Christ,
02:40:05but also because we didn't have all of the facts.
02:40:09There may still be more information needed to resolve it fully.
02:40:13We recognize that our actions led to the unnecessary slander and speculation against a fellow Christian pastor, Joel Webin, and Covenant Bible Church.
02:46:45But for some reason that wasn't satisfactory,
02:46:47And they're just going to use him to essentially show this underlying issue of this horrible envy that's underlining the entire reformed world and just use this poor church member as a spectacle.
02:47:01I mean, it's hard to actually imagine anybody that's been sinned against more than this church member who actually, by Joel's own mouth, saying that he's actually repented of whatever sins he committed.
02:47:15Well, it's interesting, too, because, Brian, one of the things that this whole situation has brought up is, number one, I think the danger of big platforms and a media platform.
02:47:25Obviously, if none of the parties involved had media platforms, we probably wouldn't know about this, and that's probably where it should stay.
02:47:32So one of the dangers could be that you, whether this was the motivation or not, it was certainly a prominent theme in No Quarter November.
02:50:30We think he's been flirting with Nazi stuff, and so here's our argument.0.87
02:50:34Yeah, and maybe, A, we should have gone to him directly.
02:50:37Even if we addressed it publicly, we should have just said, hey, we're critiquing Joel.
02:50:41Yeah, we're critiquing Joel and Joel's views and Joel's—but the specific situation was so mishandled.
02:50:48It's like a pastoral one-on-one type of stuff that when a guy is allegedly sins and you bring him and like Tobias going to Joel and saying, I have a problem with your church member.
02:51:04And then when it was handled and the person repented of whatever and I'm, you know, whatever sin they said they had in their heart or something that should have been the end of it.
02:52:22And one of the things I think, Dan, to me that came out of the timeline was this looks like it was a concerted effort, meaning Doug and James White were involved from the beginning.
02:53:04But then you also have confirmation from Tobias who said in the zoom call that there's a coalition pastors that included James White, Doug Wilson, Jeff Durbin, Joe boot, and others that are being formed that in, in being formed against us.
02:53:23And I can't remember the exact quote, so I'm just going to stop there, but there was a coalition and they are opposed to Ogden.
02:53:31well specifically eric and brian so thankfully i'm in dan's clean dan is i am hey but i think
02:53:37the other comment that was made uh by tobias was joel you had the option to choose better men
02:53:42and instead you chose that's right you could have losers in ogden yeah that's right look i mean
02:53:48sympathetic yeah yeah look at us you could have partnered with doug wilson and with james white
02:53:54but instead you chose isker and wolf and the ogden guys so this seems like another potential danger
02:54:00though brian is uh like turf warfare yeah and all this we have uh been really clear i think in our
02:54:06intention with a lot of this uh as you said we've we've promoted moscow we've promoted a lot of other
02:54:12material from across the spectrum lots of people yeah we don't we have actively tried to fight
02:54:18this instinct to be ruthlessly territorial and instead to say hey it's a big pie christendom
02:54:25wins when we have multiple platforms and multiple voices doing let's be honest very different work0.75
02:54:30like it's not a zero-sum game you know james white is doing apologist stuff with muslims that's very
02:54:36different than what we're engaged in doug has his sphere joel has his we tend to look at it as
02:54:42i'm not in competition with canon press absolutely not no we want to support them we've enjoyed a lot
02:54:49of the stuff that they put out but what could be the danger of seeing it as just a ruthless game
02:54:54of territorialism we need to not give in to the now i want to circle back to something in a minute
02:54:59but we need to get not give in to the the territorialism the zero-sum game the fixed
02:55:04pie of glory as we've put it before like that if right response gets a lot of youtube people
02:55:11and whatever then that means someone else can't succeed too like i actually want all of the
02:55:18churches involved to flourish i want lots of different publishing houses to arise guys that
02:55:24came to our conference even you know recently and they were like hey we're doing a a publishing
02:55:30house like a lot of what we're doing is basically we just looked at what you guys did and we're
02:55:34doing all that same stuff and we were actually happy to share a lot of trade secrets like here's
02:55:39how we've done it we want you to be successful yeah great let here's some here's some tips
02:55:43we've promoted everything from ezra institute to canon and all these things and and where i see
02:55:48people doing good work i'm my inclination is to go great job keep it up love it one thing i did
02:55:54want to circle back to yeah is i want to head off like because we're saying we're not saying
02:56:01but tobias claimed that there was this sort of conspiratorial we're going or just coalition of
02:56:07men behind the scenes who were saying we need to we need to address some of these things and with
02:56:11ogden and these guys okay what we're not saying is like with group chats gc's for me but not for
02:56:16thee yeah all of us are in group chats with guys where we talk about stuff happening in the reformed
02:56:22world or like what do you think about this thing james white said or what do you think about this
02:56:26thing canon did or what do you what you know i just saw your episode guys let's talk about it
02:56:31let's talk about john harris or like we're all in group chats with a lot of different men um from
02:56:36across the Reformed world, one of the main group chats I'm in, it's got Baptists, Presbyterians,
02:56:42it's got all sorts of guys, and we talk about stuff all the time. And if you were in it,
02:56:48you could tell based on posting in social media that we're all talking about something,
02:56:53and then all of us are posting our various thoughts on something. You can even coordinate
02:56:58things in a group chat where you say, we have this concern, how do we address it?
02:57:01all of that is licit feel totally free to do that i'm not saying that pastor wilson and james white
02:57:08and tobias reeman schneider and whom these guys can't have a group chat where they say hey do you
02:57:13think this issue is an issue too how should we address it the main thing i the problem i have
02:57:17is just coming back and saying someone in that chat should have said whoa whoa whoa whoa not this
02:57:24if we disagree with joel let's just go disagree with joel great do you guys have any evidence of
02:57:30like yeah here's a link to where joel said this or where brian and eric said this here's a tweet
02:57:35um let's analyze it i'm gonna do a podcast about it you write about it i actually don't care if
02:57:40people do that no gc's for me and not for thee no that's not what we're saying every gc's for
02:57:45all of the these you can all have gc's have fun talk be friends shape culture form coalitions
02:57:54totally great i just want to make sure we're arguing christianly yeah i think that's that's
02:57:59really good uh one of the other things that we promised we would answer and it's related i think
02:58:03to the timeline is the question of why we didn't why we're not going to sign the antioch declaration
02:58:08a lot of the people uh collaborate collaborators and then people around it have said things like
02:58:14well all this drama has nothing to do with the antioch declaration
02:58:18um so we'll start with dan do you think that's true and and how did it frame kind of how we're
02:58:23thinking about the document i think that the timeline and the antioch declaration are tangled
02:58:28together this is why we why we said in the cold open that we were not going to sign the anti-act
02:58:34declaration one of the points was that because you can't untangle it from the timeline because
02:58:39the contributors are the same just maybe by chance as the people who are in this supposed
02:58:47faction or or group that's coming against us and it's not a consensus document like they claim
02:58:54And so it's really hard to untangle it from the timeline.
02:58:58And so even some of the pressure that was received privately to sign it, maybe it was genuine from motives that were completely righteous.
02:59:08But within the timeline of events and with everything that's going around with the information that we've received, even that still feels like a coercion to actually participate in this, to just capitulate on our principles, quite honestly.
02:59:26Yeah, I refuse to treat Tobias as an authoritative voice as a result of all of this on a collaborator and a document that I would support, just on that level.
02:59:38On the content level, I thought the document, the statement was convoluted and unclear and included many non sequitur type of issues.
02:59:49Aristotle was a good example of that, the Aristotle stuff or whatever it was.
02:59:52uh i i read through it and i thought for a document that's aiming for clarity
02:59:56it really needed to be written in a more journalistic or a theological style instead
03:00:02of like a drunk chesterton and then lastly um i didn't mean that to be like that's genuinely
03:00:10what it came across it was like did a drunk chesterton write significant portions of this
03:00:15because that's kind of like it's trying to be quippy it's like that's not where you it's not
03:00:19where you go a quippy, you know? Well, I think, yeah. And to your point, I think in documents
03:00:23like this, you want more of that old Westminsterian, like almost dry systematic theology that's really
03:00:31crystal clear and, you know, footnoted and like, it's a space for systematized thought, not for
03:00:39right. And one of the criticisms that was responded to is like, oh, it's really hard
03:00:43to understand. And so one of the contributors said, well, you know, just because you don't
03:00:48have a good grasp of the english language doesn't mean that it's hard to understand it's like
03:00:52no actually it's it's not the words that i have a hard time with it's the way that they're arranged
03:00:57that makes things unclear yeah you need more stephen wolfian the way he he writes in case
03:01:04for class systematic it's systematic and the last problem i have um we we talked about it but just
03:01:10to make it very clear is that for a document like this that's aiming to bring people together
03:01:15lest it be a poison gas clouding of everybody else and saying flee to my exact position
03:01:20or you're an anti-semite it ought to have been a document that was collaborated on by multiple
03:01:26different views um because the whole point of a consensus document is to bring people together
03:01:33usually from disparate camps well and even doug said on that cross politic episode at the end of
03:01:39november was that it wasn't necessarily well this is reading between the lines he didn't say this
03:01:44he's uh if it was a consensus document then this wouldn't be true what he said which is
03:01:49this document was really like a line in the sand to figure out where people aligned totally so it's
03:01:54not a consensus document and if you want a line like again the clarity thing if you want a line
03:01:58in the sand then it needs to be a line and not a series of squiggles so so that's a lot of the
03:02:04the issue there there was another one later that was like the natural affection statement that was
03:02:08more clear but at that point it was like look we're just not going to play the whole statement
03:02:13game just gonna keep being positive about what we believe engage with these issues and also
03:02:19um like there's there's not there doesn't need to be a rush to like figure out every single thing
03:02:26to where everybody agrees all the time right away when there's dispute people can have different
03:02:32emphases one of the things that steven wolf said on the panel at our conference that was really
03:02:36i thought compelling and insightful um he was talking about the criticism that like some guys
03:02:42just seem obsessed with the jews and they seem obsessed with whatever and he basically just said
03:02:46look people are allowed to be interested in things stop jesus juking yeah like people could be
03:02:51interested in golf and talk a lot about that or they could be interested in like pol pot and talk
03:02:54a lot about that or they could be interested in some is whatever that's fine it doesn't mean
03:02:58they're idol idolaters about that thing that's a tgc coded argument right like you're if you love
03:03:05your wife and you think a lot about your kids and you're you're an idolater and it's like
03:03:09it just the whole thing came across to me as um a strong arm political play to attempt to force
03:03:18consensus draw a line in the sand that's fine if you want to draw a line and say this is what i
03:03:22believe and i don't want anybody um on my team who is not within this circle i've just drawn
03:03:28but again draw a circle not a series of squiggles yeah it does seem like it was really trying to
03:03:34solidify the tribe who's on my team who's not on my team in this zero-sum game that's just the
03:03:40appearance maybe it could be wrong but if that's the case one of the dangers of a zero-sum game
03:03:45philosophy as you enter into the especially the christian world is that when you fight then it's
03:03:51not actually to come to truth right it's actually not to come to truth it's it's to gain whatever
03:03:57it is you want and so james i think this is really apt as far as what could be going on
03:04:02James says, what causes fights and quarrels among you?
03:04:34And I think also one of the questions that would arise, the document, the timeline, and sort of the players involved, you mentioned the churchmen.
03:04:44One of the things that could be a real problem here is it seems like the distrust among pastors and their people could actually go up.
03:04:51I was in an exchange, which Doug screenshotted and put in a May blog, but I think he's from Canada.
03:04:57a young guy was, you know, arguing with me repeatedly on multiple posts, you know, a nuns
03:05:05need, they need to, in their handle, they need to have their pastor's contact information and they
03:05:11need to submit, you know, basically he needs to have complete oversight over. Even like access
03:05:19to the account with the password so that he can edit any tweets he doesn't like. Yeah. I mean,
03:05:23it's just gotten to this level and i called it like the last thing pastors need to be
03:05:28is social media hall monitors like we're busy we have a lot of real issues to care for and if a guy
03:05:36wants to go on x and talk about like flat earth or whatever it is um i'm like i don't have really
03:05:42time to actually monitor all of that so it seemed like kind of a ridiculous play but i'm just curious
03:05:48if you see the potential that this erodes trust even further between pastors and their people
03:05:54yeah you you have real real problems where like again the caricature is that well then people are
03:06:01just allowed to sin and you don't care about it right your flog is like well obviously not
03:06:05um you really do have guys who are sinning in their speech will give an account for every
03:06:11careless word we speak and that includes what we write online of course and so when it you know if
03:06:17if we had an issue with a church member and and they were sinful in their speech in whatever
03:06:21direction we would address it with them in a appropriate way pastorally and that sort of thing
03:06:27um the the this the hidden play though in the whole thing is like therefore if a non seem to
03:06:34be on your team and they're sinning um you you're then their position becomes a part of your
03:06:40position and you're responsible that's the play that i just we we need to reject out of hand and
03:06:44say no we've already talked about that um but i'm against people sinning i know this is going to be
03:06:50really strong i'm against people sinning and so i uh would would of course want to address sin
03:06:58wherever it lies but the thing is there's nothing special necessarily about social media that
03:07:04wouldn't apply to why wouldn't i as a pastor um want to monitor all their conversations at work
03:07:11or in private or with their friends because at that point i mean we're social media yeah is
03:07:17included but it's like do i need to go through every bank statement from all of our people and
03:07:21we talk to our people again like about all of these issues even just narrow it down to all
03:07:25these issues we talk to our guys all the time about this stuff i know where they all stand
03:07:30because shepherds ought to know the state of their flock and know their souls keep a watch over them
03:07:35Hebrews 13, seven and 17, just go see those passages. So we're doing that. We're shepherding
03:07:41our people. Um, we're trying to like, people can hide stuff, whatever, but we're doing that.
03:07:47And we're not doing it under a cloud of ignorance where we're just, well, if I ask them about their
03:07:52views on this stuff, then I'll have to find out what it is and maybe correct them. It's more that
03:07:57we're already having all these conversations with these folks. And the second thing is I do want to
03:08:02be careful about the scope of pastoral authority and say that it's to the flat earth thing it is
03:08:08not within the realm of my pastoral authority to discipline someone for holding a wrong view about
03:08:13the shape of the earth now if they were doing certain things like saying the bible flat earthers0.54
03:08:20do this the bible demands that you be a flat earther and if you're not you're a heretic and0.69
03:08:25they were starting to be schismatic in the church we would address that right if if somebody was
03:08:29saying like so you're saying if they laugh at the wrong meme you know like a flat earth meme
03:08:35then they're not even a christian that sort of thing yeah we don't have authority to say that
03:08:39you know if someone said all of a sudden they were spouting stuff about like i you know want to
03:08:45genocide jews or whatever then you know it's just like there's a there's a distinction that we need
03:08:51to make between people's views of lots of things and my pastoral authority yeah i think that that
03:08:58also is a repeated theme um with american milk and honey is that doug will refer to things like
03:09:04this is the christian position on your view of the holocaust um or going back to the antioch
03:09:10declaration um they said this isn't like a creedal document like you can be a christian and not
03:09:16believe these things maybe some of this is just being careful with speech but later toby had said
03:09:21well i mean i look at the document this is just boilerplate orthodoxy i'm like whoa whoa whoa
03:09:26whoa, whoa, whoa. Your view on Aristotle is a matter of orthodoxy. Well, I think that's actually
03:09:31missing the point on what this, to your point, the scope of pastoral authority.
03:09:37And the problem is that your view on Aristotle, that's not the claim of the document. It's that
03:09:42if you think that you would be contrary to the document, if you thought that Aristotle was the
03:09:47picture of the ideal man, not Jesus Christ. Now, of course you'd be outside Christian0.99
03:09:52orthodoxy if you thought that. But the problem with that being included in a statement like this
03:09:56is again the implication is that there are people who are saying this and they happen to be all our
03:10:01opponents on all this stuff it's it's a subtle implication particularly eric khan well yeah
03:10:07i mean so that's the implication a lot of these people so the problem is that okay yeah when you
03:10:12when you take things totally out of their context as absolute truth statements yes aristotle is not
03:10:18surpassing the lord jesus christ as the model of the ideal man um of you know of course but nobody
03:10:25said that but no but don't but to say that in a statement implies that there's a widespread need
03:10:30to correct this erroneous view and what it does is it just in a very ham-fisted and rhetorically
03:10:36unsophisticated way it associates people who are positive about aristotle with that view that no
03:10:45one holds which ironically would end up refuting nsa since they've hosted talks about how to use
03:10:51aristotle and it was actually funny because it was right afterwards like colin redimer was at nsa
03:10:56talking about what christians can glean from aristotle so of course you could always retreat
03:11:00to like i wasn't saying that you can't like aristotle look we like aristotle but the point
03:11:05is if you include in your statement a refutation of a position nobody holds you're actually doing
03:11:11something you're saying something in a plausibly deniable way that is you know it's it's just it's
03:11:17not helpful. Yeah. That's the problem. Yeah, I think that's great. One of the other questions
03:11:22we wanted to answer is what kind of Christian nationalism, what brand of Christian nationalism
03:11:26are we promoting? And I guess just to kick us off, it would be the Canon Press published
03:11:34Stephen Wolfian kind of classical two kingdoms, reformed Christian nationalism. So Brian,
03:11:43I guess if you want to expand on that, first of all, do you agree with that?
03:11:46yeah yeah so this is one of the questions that in terms of like okay positively though ogden guys
03:11:52what are you actually promoting are you with all of the worst are you do you agree with the 10
03:11:56worst things i could find an onset on twitter we're like no let's just say positively here's
03:12:01what we would defend and the ideas that we're kicking around and thinking through and in
03:12:06debating and all this is like generally yeah what what dr wolf wrote in the case for classical
03:12:12Christian Nationalism, published by Canon Press. That's a pretty good summation of the kind of
03:12:17Christian nationalism that we are interested in promoting and discussing, and even expanding,
03:12:24which is why we invited Stephen to come out to our conference last June. And we were very careful
03:12:30about asking him, we would like you to give this talk addressing this question, the failure and
03:12:36danger of multicultural pluralism, this kind of thing, and what we should build instead,
03:12:40because we were interested in his ideas and we wanted him to expand them into another question,
03:12:46not just rehash the book, but give us. And he took an extraordinary amount of time and put
03:12:52together a very helpful lecture over an hour of, of well-reasoned discussion on this question.
03:13:00So what kind of Christian nationalism are we promoting? Well, one reason you shouldn't try0.99
03:13:06to nuke Ogden is if you're Moscow is because it's the thing you published. That's the thing that we're,0.85
03:13:10promoting. So, so maybe there are other wings of Christian nationalism that have other
03:13:15views and maybe they find some of those problematic or something, but it really does
03:13:20come back to like, if, if you end up denouncing us, what you're denouncing is Dr. Wolf.
03:13:25Yeah, I think that's helpful. And then, and then also I would say at the conference,
03:13:29what was a great benefit, at least to me, I mean, it probably was to you guys as well,
03:13:33but having steven wolf there and dr rigney being able to talk through uh some of these issues white0.53
03:13:41boy summer we were talking about we talked about everything yeah and i hitler the nazis white boy
03:13:47summer i thought what was really helpful was when we were talking to dr rigney especially about this
03:13:53he was like oh well if that's what you believe like that's great that's cool i'm cool with white
03:13:57boy summer what you're saying yeah we we had you know probably hours of conversation with some
03:14:03combination of all those guys and all of them at different points including joel and uh we what
03:14:09was interesting is that as we discussed it it was pretty much like hey what what do you guys think
03:14:12about this like you know is hitler a christian prince no okay we don't think so either what
03:14:16about and we pretty much agreed on almost all of these there's probably nuances and different
03:14:22or undeveloped thoughts that develop more later but pretty much in those conversations it was like
03:14:27oh yeah cool same team yeah well that's that's cool like um i i joked to the to those guys at
03:14:35one point like you know that you're you've you've run into the like the far wall of the right wing
03:14:40when you're denying the holocaust happened but you think it should have you know like that that's the
03:14:45level but none of us have seriously ever promoted anything to that effect nobody there so um if if0.84
03:14:52anybody needed clarity i don't think they really did i think we've been pretty clear on all this
03:14:57stuff from the beginning um but it's pretty like it's kind of a letdown of an answer because we're
03:15:04not like transgressive edgelords at the end of the day we're kind of like boring guys entering
03:15:12middle age who are interested in a lot of this stuff right yeah i think uh something from
03:15:18christian nationalism that i think's helpful steve it it was controversial because of how
03:15:23we've all been hardwired theologically to think about the pastor's role.
03:15:27But one thing Stephen said was, I'm not an expert on all things theological, systematic
03:16:40If you don't believe a certain historic narrative outside of the death, burial, resurrection of Jesus Christ, outside of King David and the events that happened, you know, surrounding King David or if Samson existed or, you know, Adam and Eve, like those things are, are, that is orthodoxy.
03:16:59The formation of Israel, World War II, like those things are not in the realm of orthodoxy.
03:17:06I mean, you could have something that's just an absolute, complete lie that there's evidence of, and you could be convinced, and somebody is believing a lie.
03:17:42You know, an example would be, you know, what if there's a lot of Christians in Palestine, Palestinian Christians.
03:17:47Imagine you were to make the position that no Palestinian Christians can be Christians, really, unless they agree with what Dennis Prager believes about the state of Israel.
03:17:58It would just be an a priori absurd position to take.
03:18:01and a lot of it when it's stated very positively and very confidently without people thinking
03:18:06through some of these issues like concretely you can go oh yeah that's right if you don't
03:18:11agree with that you know basically you're not a christian but then when you start like i i don't
03:18:16want i don't think we're the guys who are known for being like we need a ton of nuance all the
03:18:21time but you know like let's actually have some nuance when we're talking about whether someone
03:18:24is inside or outside of the faith i think that's a pretty important question yeah yeah i think so
03:18:29A final question that we'll address, what do we hope will be the result of an episode like this?
03:18:36Brian, you mentioned certain areas for repentance would be nice.
03:18:40I think for my money, just to start that off, I would say, you know, okay, we've addressed Tobias on this privately, but it would be nice to have a retraction and repentance on, you know, calling us leaders of an anti-Semitic racist movement in America.
03:19:58Let's talk about it directly so that everybody can stop sort of proxy warring and shadow warring and shadow boxing.
03:20:04We're just going to say all the stuff we've been thinking and talking about and have it open to correction or debate.
03:20:12I would love to see these kinds of debates continue in that spirit with a with a more surgical approach to who I am anathematizing on one edge to just disagreeing with on another like that sort of thing.
03:20:24Yeah, I think making careful distinction. I think also and we would love to be a part of this, but getting some of these guys together to debate positions rather than kind of the rhetoric, I think, that's lobbed from afar, the mischaracterization of positions.
03:20:40So, for example, I would love to see Dr. Boot and Stephen Wolf talk about theonomy versus the classical two kingdoms.
03:20:50Let's have a long-form thing where we actually go through the positions, relying less, I think, on instantaneous rhetorical devices on Twitter because these are actually important discussions.
03:26:46Every single one of them, I could list manifold areas of theological,
03:26:51cultural disagreement about significant things even.
03:26:55And yet there's nothing inconsistent with holding those and saying,
03:26:59Lord, please bless this church in this other state,
03:27:02Please bless this church near us that they would be strengthened in faith, that they would be refined by the Lord.
03:27:09Like, we can do that, and I want even people who are interested and invested in some of these things to be able to do that, to have permission from us.
03:33:01Make sure that one of the variables that you include in your calculation is Christian unity across disputes like this, because this isn't the first one.
03:33:10It's certainly not going to be the last one that all of us occasionally have to pull the sword from our scabbard and do some jousting, even with brothers and friends.
03:33:19So you don't joust with a sword, but you know what I'm talking about.
03:33:22So I'd encourage you guys, whatever you do, do it with all of your might for the glory of the Lord, for the sake of his people.
03:33:29Give your life for your brothers and for the Lord, and you won't go astray.