00:00:38Some would say that art is communicating beauty.
00:00:42Some would say that it's an expression of imagination.
00:00:45And some that art is simply a work that has to be appreciated.
00:00:49The United States government agreed that art is something that should be appreciated.
00:00:53So in 1965, President Lyndon B. Johnson formed the National Endowment for the Arts in order to fund artists in their pursuit of making works that have to be appreciated.
00:01:06One such artist that received a grant through the taxpayer-funded National Endowment for the Arts was artist and photographer Andreas Serrano.
00:01:17The National Endowment for the Arts has determined that the people of the United States needed to appreciate Mr. Serrano's art.
00:01:26Mr. Serrano's pictures involve bodily fluid in some way, depicting, for example, blood, sometimes menstrual blood, semen, feces, or human breast milk.
00:01:37He is also known for his erotic photography and even has a display where he has pictures of corpses.
00:01:43Mr. Serrano was chosen to receive grants totaling $15,000 in 1986 to produce his art for the American people, paid for by the American people.
00:01:54In 1987, he unveiled his masterpiece that the government funded.
00:02:01The photograph shows a Catholic crucifix with Jesus on the cross, submerged in a jar of Mr. Serrano's own urine.
00:02:08In response to the outcry from Christians for the blasphemous photograph, Mr. Serrano had two photographs placed on display at the Smithsonian American Art Museum in Washington, D.C.
00:02:22One photograph titled Heaven and Hell depicts a bound woman covered in blood behind a Catholic cardinal.
00:02:30The American Family Association, a Christian organization, wrote the following to the National Endowment for the Arts.
00:02:36that Mr. Serrano's art is an example of, quote, a deplorable, despicable display of vulgarity.
00:02:43They continued, this matter does not involve freedom of artistic expression. It does involve
00:02:49the question of whether American taxpayers should be forced to support such trash. The reply from0.98
00:02:56the director of the National Endowment for the Arts was, I think that controversy has always
00:03:03been endemic to art. That certainly it's been endemic to 20th century art. Even as far back
00:03:10as Caravaggio, people complained because he painted the virgin too naturalistically with
00:03:16dirty feet. I think that discussion of obscenity and propriety are endemic to art because art is
00:03:22always on the cutting edge, and anything that's on the cutting edge is going to offend someone.
00:03:28So that brings us back to our first question.
00:07:38I don't like where this conversation has gone.
00:07:41Speaking of where this conversation has gone, according to studies, the average American spends roughly 13 and a half hours per day in exposure to some form of media.
00:12:35I mean, he was communicating a message in a way that was possible publicly.
00:12:39You can certainly bank on that if Luther had other tools available to him like we do today, he would have communicated his ideas via those mediums.
00:12:50And so, you know, the first thing I think that we have to get is that it, what you said,0.99
00:12:55it's not neutral and Christians have to get that kind of from the gate out there because0.59
00:13:01they, we tend to operate oftentimes as if it is.
00:13:07And as if most media is just, yeah, it's fine.
00:17:50You remember Judge Roy Moore. He defended in Alabama. He got kicked off the Supreme Court for defending the Ten Commandments and their usage in the courts in Alabama. He refused to rescind them. He actually argued that he was acting as a lesser magistrate. He was removed, stays in politics, writes some books, runs for Senate a few years ago, I think 2017.
00:18:10One of the political PACs in Alabama runs an ad.
00:18:15They run an ad saying that, yeah, he's such a sexual predator that this mall down the street wouldn't even let him come on the premises because he was such a child predator.0.89
00:18:25Well, the only problem with it was it was 100% fabricated.0.97
00:19:04They said, look, he's guilty by accusation.
00:19:06we see the me too movement probably can't happen without twitter yeah or similar mediums yeah yeah
00:19:12without the quick react social media so again this week uh he won an eight million dollar lawsuit
00:19:18wow against these people they don't care because they got their candidate in and they've worth
00:19:22hundreds of millions but here's my point media can be used for bad and for good yeah so as christians
00:19:30I want to ask this, like, how should we be thinking about media and its usage and the power that it has?
00:19:37I mean, we've seen at King's Hall, correct me if I'm wrong, you're able to multiply your message pretty exponentially through now really what we're talking about, mass communications.
00:26:19And, you know, we need we need these kinds of art. And it's it's I was hugely encouraged. You know, the other day I was at Grace Agenda up in Moscow, Idaho. And Jess Hall, the CEO of Canon Press, was sort of sketching out their their vision for the future of their their company.
00:31:45Or they make these blasphemous and evil or truly frivolous and communicate.
00:31:51Even in the journalism world, I'd say equivalent to piss Christ would be MSNBC, New York Times, you name it.
00:31:59They're essentially doing the same thing with words.
00:32:01So, Dan, I want to ask you, if you were to take Brian's principles, and this is your job on a
00:32:06daily basis, right? Take Brian's principles and you break it down for the blue-collar man.
00:32:12What does that say? Like, if we're these sub-creators, is that what you called them,
00:32:16Brian? Yeah, that's right. If you're a sub-creator, how does that play out for,
00:32:20say you're a journalist, say you're working at a local newspaper or you're working for
00:32:25the Federalist or whoever, how does being a sub-creator shape your vocation?
00:32:32Yeah, that's a good question. And so when I think about this, and precision is important here with
00:32:38some of the things that I'm going to say, because I'm having to navigate like certain Gnostic ideas,
00:32:42like we're a spark of the divine or some such nonsense. So when I say that we're,0.79
00:32:48what was the term you used? We're not recreating. We're sub-creating.
00:32:52Sub-creating. It's almost as if we are reorganizing and creating back something that something should communicate to people the glory of God.
00:33:04And so as man is the glory of God, as we work, and as a journalist or as an artist or an architect, what we are doing is communicating back fundamental truths that God built into the universe of what is good, true, and beautiful that can only be right-ordered under those who are spiritually alive, who are given the Holy Spirit, who are in right order with God because those who are not blood-bought, regenerate.
00:33:34being renewed in their mind are actually disordered. There's something fundamentally
00:33:39wrong with the unbeliever, with the pagan mind. There's a disorder in their mind and in their1.00
00:33:45creation that would prevent them from fully creating something or communicating something
00:33:51adequately to glorify God, to glorify the creator. That's why in the story I said,
00:33:59what if art is actually cosmic warfare worship and glory not just like it is warfare worship
00:34:08and glory but on like a cosmic level like peeking behind the scenes to where you have the kingdom
00:34:14of darkness and the kingdom of light are actually at war and it's it's it's coming out in mediums
00:34:21it's coming out on computer screens and in tweets and on newspapers and uh through your ears and on
00:34:28the TV set. There's actually a cosmic war going on behind the scenes. And so our responsibility
00:34:33as Christians, as blood-bought people, are to fight that war. And the way that you fight that
00:34:39is through, in a lot of ways, culture, which is worship, externalized. And so when you're making
00:34:45things, you should be making them to the glory of God. And that does multiple things. It glorifies
00:34:51God, not in just some pietistic, warm, fuzzy feelings, but actually in fighting back the
00:34:57kingdom of darkness. So when someone makes an absolutely beautiful oil painting or tells an
00:35:04amazing story, what you're doing is you're communicating back the true, the good, and the
00:35:09beautiful that God has already put into the hearts of, of redeemed men and communicated naturally in
00:35:17the universe. So when you look at a mountain sunset, you know, and, and then you paint that
00:35:21And I mean, it, it transcends, you know, your, your current moment in your drab home and you
00:35:28look at that painting, what it's doing is it's telling you a truth. It's telling you something,
00:35:33whereas something like the, the art that the gentleman at the beginning of this episode
00:35:39did is it's actually fundamentally lying to you. It's telling you lies. And so I lost your question
00:35:46somewhere in my ramblings, but I, I think fundamentally that's what you're talking
00:35:50about with sub-creation is in a way you're creating back glory that God has revealed.
00:35:56I think it was really interesting, Dan, because I asked for a blue-collar answer and I got
00:39:29But one of the things I know Bob Smithhauser has said for a long time is the thing that you're particularly on guard for as a movie critic is when they're trying to make sin seem good.
00:40:53But I think there's also been an inherent problem with journalism. When I was in journalism school in college, one thing we were told is, listen, as a journalist, your job is to be neutral and to be completely objective.
00:41:07And what we've realized through the years is even people who think they're objective aren't.
00:41:12And finally, in more recent times, I had a boss say to me, he said, listen, we all have presuppositions.
00:48:35Like if you read that book today, there's not one single thing about it
00:48:38that's like, oh, yeah, I forgot things were like that.
00:48:41You would think he was writing about right now.
00:48:43And I think part of his answer is an answer to your question as well, that really what's going on with media is it's an extension of the Marxist leftist state and regime.
00:49:54It's trying to tell a story that puts forward as true what is not true, right?
00:50:00So when you look at what makes something like, again, Pride and Prejudice or Shakespeare are actually two really good examples from completely disparate times that are enduring stories or even to come to a modern place, something like Shawshank Redemption, which is a phenomenal film.
00:50:17Yeah, Stephen King. Actually, Stephen King's books in general, he tends to do this well, even though he has a lot of smut and isn't a Christian and is in some ways telling an untruth about reality.0.99
00:50:26but what is it with all those qualifiers but yet he can't help sometimes but tell a good story
00:50:32because he's stealing from the christian world but what makes those great what makes austin and
00:50:37shakespeare great what makes shawshank redemption great well one through line is that they all
00:50:42notice and present these archetypal human beings that we all know exist and they unveil them in a
00:50:49way that helps you understand the world you live in and people you know today because they're like
00:50:54mr darcy or they're like elizabeth or they're like you know othello or they're like these
00:51:00characters in these stories these people are often good artists are often astute observers
00:51:06of reality and human nature like the foibles and the virtues yeah like a good comedian same a great
00:51:14example because totally different medium but what makes good comedy is what makes good fiction is
00:51:18what makes good documentary story they notice things they notice they're good observers of
00:51:22reality and they're interested in the world God made. And so they begin to notice these common
00:51:28character flaws. And then they sort of put them under a magnifying glass in a character like
00:51:33the pastor in Pride and Prejudice or, you know, Mr. Collins or Mr. Darcy, who's proud and arrogant0.98
00:51:41and sins like a man sins or Elizabeth who gossips and sins like a woman sins or her foolish younger0.91
00:51:47sister mary who you know all who telling truths because people are actually like that yes and so
00:51:53you look at those characters and you say i know these people because they're of students but now
00:51:57if you tell the story of a faithful gay couple you don't know that person because they're very1.00
00:52:03they're hardly ever exist they literally are telling an untruth or a benevolent state as0.77
00:52:07communist propaganda tells they don't really exist christendom bible college offers a one-year
00:52:14certificate in the humanities for students who intend to pursue a degree or for students who
00:52:18prefer to begin their chosen occupations upon completion of our program. Older students who
00:52:24never attended college or who went to a college where the humanities were less robust will also
00:52:29find our program stimulating and suitable. Located steps from the Ohio River and the town of New
00:52:34Richmond, we're unaccredited in order to remain free to teach as our biblically-minded consciences
00:52:40demand. As servants of Christ, we won't wear the yoke of the woke. Instead, we stand on the
00:52:47shoulders of Christianity's giants, not to stew in nostalgia, but to see through the culture wars
00:52:52fall, for the glorious days of a Christendom still to be built. Our exceptional faculty are
00:52:58committed to the historic biblical foundations of our faith. Come be a part of Christendom Bible
00:53:04College. Visit us on the web at ChristendomBibleCollege.org to learn more. While there,
00:53:10be sure to sign up for our email updates and receive your free three-chapter excerpt
00:53:15of our very own Dr. Frank J. Smith's new book, Race, Church, and Society.
00:53:24It's interesting. I have to throw this in there because we're talking about Pride and Prejudice.
00:53:29We did, for the Hard Man podcast, we did the best books. My wife listened to all of it.
00:56:00Speaking of which, this brings me to the next subsection that we're talking about.
00:56:05Uh-oh, are we going to talk about Christian media?
00:56:06We're going to talk about Christian media.
00:56:08So one of the reasons, if I was playing devil's advocate, one of the problems is we're like,
00:56:12okay, everything you guys say about Christendom sounds great.
00:56:15And when you describe art or you read, you know, Angels in the Architecture or you read Francis Schaeffer on art or any number of books like this, you think, wow, that's a grand vision.
00:57:00Yeah, so when I was growing up, my parents, every now and then, would take me to church, you know, once biannually, every two years or something.
00:57:09I'd go to church and my friends when we'd go there
01:15:55One of the instincts that has suffused certain corners of Reformed Christendom, of Reformed Christianity, is a skepticism about adorning and arts.