The King's Hall - August 19, 2022


Art, Media, & the New Christendom

Topics
Mentioned
On Christian Nationalism: Interview with Dr. Stephen Wolfe Listener Inquiries: Reforming Ogden, Baptism, & More

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 32 minutes

Words per minute

179.15

Word count

16,617

Sentence count

980

Harmful content

Misogyny

16

sentences flagged

Toxicity

70

sentences flagged

Hate speech

121

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, Brian here with a big announcement from New Christendom Press.
00:00:03 Possibly our most important book yet is now available for pre-order.
00:00:08 It's called The Longhouse, How Feminism Conquered the West and Made Us All Miserable.
00:00:13 And in it, Eric and I take you through the dark history of feminism,
00:00:17 what it's done to everything from politics to church life to the economy,
00:00:21 and what to do about it.
00:00:23 Pre-order it today at newchristendompress.com slash longhouse.
00:00:26 And as a thank you for pre-ordering, you'll get 10% off automatically.
00:00:30 We'll also be signing the first 1,000 copies, so pick yours up today.
00:00:36 What is art?
00:00:38 Some would say that art is communicating beauty.
00:00:42 Some would say that it's an expression of imagination.
00:00:45 And some that art is simply a work that has to be appreciated.
00:00:49 The United States government agreed that art is something that should be appreciated.
00:00:53 So in 1965, President Lyndon B. Johnson formed the National Endowment for the Arts in order to fund artists in their pursuit of making works that have to be appreciated.
00:01:06 One such artist that received a grant through the taxpayer-funded National Endowment for the Arts was artist and photographer Andreas Serrano.
00:01:17 The National Endowment for the Arts has determined that the people of the United States needed to appreciate Mr. Serrano's art.
00:01:26 Mr. Serrano's pictures involve bodily fluid in some way, depicting, for example, blood, sometimes menstrual blood, semen, feces, or human breast milk.
00:01:37 He is also known for his erotic photography and even has a display where he has pictures of corpses.
00:01:43 Mr. Serrano was chosen to receive grants totaling $15,000 in 1986 to produce his art for the American people, paid for by the American people.
00:01:54 In 1987, he unveiled his masterpiece that the government funded.
00:01:58 It was titled His Christ. 0.56
00:02:01 The photograph shows a Catholic crucifix with Jesus on the cross, submerged in a jar of Mr. Serrano's own urine.
00:02:08 In response to the outcry from Christians for the blasphemous photograph, Mr. Serrano had two photographs placed on display at the Smithsonian American Art Museum in Washington, D.C.
00:02:22 One photograph titled Heaven and Hell depicts a bound woman covered in blood behind a Catholic cardinal.
00:02:30 The American Family Association, a Christian organization, wrote the following to the National Endowment for the Arts.
00:02:36 that Mr. Serrano's art is an example of, quote, a deplorable, despicable display of vulgarity.
00:02:43 They continued, this matter does not involve freedom of artistic expression. It does involve
00:02:49 the question of whether American taxpayers should be forced to support such trash. The reply from 0.98
00:02:56 the director of the National Endowment for the Arts was, I think that controversy has always
00:03:03 been endemic to art. That certainly it's been endemic to 20th century art. Even as far back
00:03:10 as Caravaggio, people complained because he painted the virgin too naturalistically with
00:03:16 dirty feet. I think that discussion of obscenity and propriety are endemic to art because art is
00:03:22 always on the cutting edge, and anything that's on the cutting edge is going to offend someone.
00:03:28 So that brings us back to our first question.
00:03:32 What is art?
00:03:34 Is it simply controversial images or entertainment that pushes social norms?
00:03:39 Is it something that comes from human imagination and therefore must be appreciated?
00:03:44 What if art is more than the whims of demon-possessed druggies and drunks?
00:03:48 What if art is actually cosmic warfare, worship, and glory?
00:03:54 The King's Hall Podcast exists to make self-ruled men who rule well and win the world.
00:04:05 Well, welcome to this episode of the King's Hall Podcast.
00:04:08 Dan, thank you so much for that very scenic picture of Piss Christ.
00:04:14 Hey, you know what? I would not search his art.
00:04:18 It's really bad. Have you looked at it?
00:04:19 yeah yeah i mean a lot of it is like erotic when i say that like don't search it yeah don't don't
00:04:25 it sounds quite horrible it's it actually reminds me there was a question in there which is i think
00:04:30 it's a good one to kick us off there was a question what is art and it reminds me of the
00:04:35 great philosopher ron swanson who said it's art anything is anything i also think it's pointless
00:04:42 for a human to paint scenes of nature when they could just go outside and stand in it
00:04:47 anyway please do not misinterpret the fact that i am talking right now as genuine interest
00:04:53 in art and attempt to discuss it with me further end of speech right we have this thing in our
00:04:59 culture where artists especially they're just the woo-woo people yeah crystal rock feather i don't
00:05:03 know what they're doing they just get to make stuff up those are the artists you know what it
00:05:08 is let's just be honest here it's money laundering like let's be let's be real here it's it's democrat
00:05:14 apparatus saying i purchased this modern art it was paint splattered on a canvas for 1.2 million
00:05:21 it was it was money laundering get out of here anyway yeah that's for another episode maybe
00:05:26 yeah i i was gonna go two different routes with our story i went this direction but the other one
00:05:32 was the funding of the the the gays like how much money this uh this national endowment for the arts
00:05:39 is actually funneling into gay organizations is pretty incredible.
00:05:43 It's difficult to compile, though,
00:05:44 because they don't come out and tell you straight away how much.
00:05:48 By the way, the National Endowment for the Arts,
00:05:52 their budget for 2020 was $162 million.
00:05:58 Maybe they want to fund the King's Hall.
00:06:01 You know, let's write them a letter.
00:06:02 Send them the pitch deck.
00:06:05 Well, we got some ideas now from Mr. Serrano.
00:06:08 Yeah, Serrano. 1.00
00:06:08 I think you're supposed to roll the R's 1.00
00:06:12 but I can't 1.00
00:06:12 and he shouldn't
00:06:15 speaking of rolling R's
00:06:18 the title of
00:06:20 this week's show
00:06:21 has no R's in it
00:06:23 it has art isn't it 0.94
00:06:25 no that's like pirate R's 0.77
00:06:28 so we're talking about Christian media
00:06:30 arts and music
00:06:32 and I think as we saw in the cold
00:06:34 open there is this fundamental question
00:06:36 what is art, what is media, what is it for
00:06:38 and we want to unpack that in today's show.
00:06:40 So today we live in a world that is dominated by technology,
00:06:43 and technology has shaped the way that we consume media, including art.
00:06:48 With the advent of the smartphone in 2007, that change has rapidly accelerated,
00:06:53 and we've all experienced that in just a single generation and lifetime.
00:06:57 Similar changes occurred with the advent of radio, TV, and, of course, the Internet.
00:07:02 You guys remember the AOL.com, the discs?
00:07:05 Yeah.
00:07:05 I got 60 minutes.
00:07:07 I got 60 minutes to go online, dial-up speed.
00:07:10 So that I can download Napster.
00:07:12 So I can download.
00:07:13 Oh, I was going on MySpace, actually.
00:07:15 Wow.
00:07:16 Yeah.
00:07:16 Way cooler.
00:07:17 Is that a MySpace?
00:07:19 I didn't know you were alive then.
00:07:20 It's how I flirted with my wife originally.
00:07:22 MySpace. 0.99
00:07:23 MySpace.
00:07:24 Oh, yeah.
00:07:24 She was in my top five.
00:07:26 I don't know. 0.85
00:07:26 Way better than FaceTime. 0.99
00:07:27 I was trying to get with her. 1.00
00:07:28 I was like, I'll put her in my top five. 1.00
00:07:30 I'll put her in my top five.
00:07:31 I'll put some Goo Goo Dolls when you come on, you know, like all the stuff that impresses 0.98
00:07:35 the junior high girl.
00:07:36 Oh, yeah. 0.98
00:07:36 Goo Goo Dolls was where it was at.
00:07:38 All about it.
00:07:38 I don't like where this conversation has gone.
00:07:41 Speaking of where this conversation has gone, according to studies, the average American spends roughly 13 and a half hours per day in exposure to some form of media.
00:07:51 13 and a half hours.
00:07:52 Unreal.
00:07:53 What are you awake for?
00:07:54 Like 16?
00:07:55 Yeah, about.
00:07:57 Right about.
00:07:57 16, 17.
00:07:58 So like, I don't know where the three hours that you're not connected are.
00:08:02 You're eating dinner while you Instagram.
00:08:05 Yeah, you're Instagramming your dinner.
00:08:06 That's what it is.
00:08:07 That is unbelievable.
00:08:08 Driving.
00:08:08 So I would wager pre-2007.
00:08:10 While listening to a podcast.
00:08:11 Pre-2007, that number was probably a lot less.
00:08:14 Oh, yeah, almost guaranteed.
00:08:16 In the TV days, I remember they would say, you know,
00:08:19 the average American watches six hours of TV a day.
00:08:21 Well, that's more than double.
00:08:24 Dang.
00:08:24 So in this episode, we want to ask some fundamental questions
00:08:26 about media, art, music.
00:08:28 Obviously, it's powerful.
00:08:30 Obviously, people are consuming a lot of it.
00:08:32 But we want to ask questions like these, Dan.
00:08:34 What exactly is media? What's the point of it? Is it neutral? And then we'll also examine the
00:08:40 condition of media today, how it's currently being used, how it shows up in the Christian
00:08:44 media space, and what in particular, we'll close by talking about what in particular we can do
00:08:49 with strategy. What should we be doing with media as Christians? If you take everything that we've
00:08:55 talked about Boniface and this whole approach to life post-mill, how would it apply to media? So
00:09:00 we're going to address that. Yeah. So I want to start with this question. Number one, what is
00:09:03 media what is our what is the point of it well first of all media is the pearl plural of medium
00:09:10 so it's just a plural form of a medium which is simply a conduit or mechanism for transfer of
00:09:15 substance from one person or place to another so not like a sorcerer uh medium what's kind of
00:09:21 similar like you're they're they're the conduit they're the conduit medium is the canvas upon
00:09:26 which the necromancy occurs so exactly like witchcraft it actually it's interesting i hadn't
00:09:31 thought about. So yeah, actually, if you work at CNN, you're actually a witch. Well, probably, 0.80
00:09:36 but not because of that. Yeah. So this is a media or medium is, is how we get things like
00:09:44 publication, music, entertainment, TV, books, art, right? So we have to have media to deliver
00:09:49 something. But I think what's often missed is that the medium or the media plural doesn't just
00:09:54 pass along raw data or information. In fact, there was a book that went by this title as well.
00:10:00 The medium is the message.
00:10:02 So the way that you deliver it and who's delivering it matters significantly.
00:10:06 So one thing we need to be clear about is that media is never ultimately operating in a completely neutral way.
00:10:13 It is always offering a picture of the good life, an understanding of what is good, true, and beautiful, and a way of seeing the world.
00:10:21 And this brings us actually back to the cold open.
00:10:25 Modern art shows beautiful things as disfigured.
00:10:28 though music will show things like cacophony as desirable, even though it sounds heinous.
00:10:34 So I want to ask you guys, what are some other ways that media art or music can be used to
00:10:38 distort reality, lie, or otherwise be used in an unrighteous way?
00:10:49 In 2023, Indigo Sundries became one of our sponsors. At the time, their business was little
00:10:54 more than a side hobby generating a couple hundred dollars a month. But because of their
00:10:57 partnership with us. And because all of you chose to support them, they've grown enough to make it
00:11:01 their full-time livelihood. This is what happens when Christians support Christians. Our communities 0.56
00:11:05 are strengthened and faithful businesses thrive. So if you're a Christian business owner who wants 1.00
00:11:10 to reach thousands of like-minded people and grow your company, we'd love to partner with you.
00:11:14 Email us at advertising at newchristendompress.com.
00:11:18 yeah I think it's interesting when you when you understand media as medium as just a vehicle for
00:11:29 communicating ideas and it's it's it's a medium for externalizing your values externalizing your
00:11:36 message externalizing your goals for society you're trying to influence people to believe
00:11:43 certain things about the good the true and the beautiful and you're trying to promote your
00:11:47 message worldview, your aims for life, what you think people should be living for via media all
00:11:54 the time. And so it really is, I think, first of all, it is essential to the project of this season
00:12:00 of the King's Hall when we're talking about the new Christendom and living, clearing the job site
00:12:08 for our cathedral and then putting the stones on top of each other for this Christendom. You realize
00:12:14 is that media is going to be an inescapable aspect of this project.
00:12:24 And I think even of something that we probably don't think of in terms of media,
00:12:28 but think about Luther and his 95 theses on the Wittenberg Chapel door.
00:12:34 That's media.
00:12:35 I mean, he was communicating a message in a way that was possible publicly.
00:12:39 You can certainly bank on that if Luther had other tools available to him like we do today, he would have communicated his ideas via those mediums.
00:12:50 And so, you know, the first thing I think that we have to get is that it, what you said, 0.99
00:12:55 it's not neutral and Christians have to get that kind of from the gate out there because 0.59
00:13:01 they, we tend to operate oftentimes as if it is.
00:13:07 And as if most media is just, yeah, it's fine.
00:13:11 It's entertainment.
00:13:12 It's just, you know, I watched this sitcom.
00:13:14 It's just, I, you know, helps me relax in the evening, hang out with my family.
00:13:19 But no, the person who made that sitcom, however disconnected it may seem from religious ideology, they're trying to disciple you.
00:13:29 Well, and that it really gets to the power of media.
00:13:31 I've heard people say this.
00:13:32 You probably have as well.
00:13:33 There's no Obergefell without will and grace.
00:13:36 Exactly.
00:13:37 There's not the overturning of, you know, the gay mirage, anti-gay mirage laws unless you have a TV show that is selling. 0.53
00:13:44 look how cool and look how winsome and look how wonderful being a homosexual is in today's
00:13:50 culture and you can go back to the reformation dan as well and you look at you know the press 0.95
00:13:54 the modern printing press yeah the printing press that's really what helped fuel a lot of the
00:13:59 reformation well there were other reformers that came before luther right but but but the lack of
00:14:04 ability to get that message out right yeah in spite so luther it wasn't like a intention of
00:14:09 his to start printing his sermons and things like that. People just did. Actually, the 95 thesis
00:14:15 was supposed to be just like an intramural sort of debate. And it ended up being translated from
00:14:21 Latin into German and printed and eventually got the attention of the Pope. And it took a good 200
00:14:28 years or so for the Gutenberg press to proliferate print materials. I mean, it wasn't like Gutenberg
00:14:37 press and then overnight print materials were everywhere. It really took actually in that time
00:14:41 a few centuries before it was widely practiced that you would have print materials like this.
00:14:47 So you see the way though that as that proliferated through Europe and across the world
00:14:52 that all of a sudden the pace of discourse changed and was influenced by the medium.
00:15:01 So you see that actually as we're approaching this subject as well, it's really important
00:15:05 that Christians understand that the medium itself is going to shape the way the message is
00:15:12 communicated. So I know this is really off base, but in the same way that things changed with those
00:15:17 booklets and sermons being printed and the hierarchy at the time didn't know how to respond
00:15:23 to it adequately, you know, they're just like, well, we'll ban it. Or if you're caught with it,
00:15:27 we'll punish you or whatever. And so they're trying to condemn it like that. In the same way,
00:15:32 we see that, that change, uh, of medium throughout history, even to today, people don't know what to
00:15:38 do with memes, meme communication. People, I mean, older, older folks are really confused at what in
00:15:47 the world you're supposed to do with memes, you know, in a similar way. So did you see Thomas
00:15:52 Acord's tweet about that? I did. Yeah. I'm going to, I want to read it. It was so good. He's
00:15:56 explaining meme warfare in this tweet and uh you know this he says rule number one of meme warfare
00:16:03 don't argue against memes they're rhetorical not factual weapons if you argue you lose rule number
00:16:09 two of meme warfare don't become angry at memes against you or your position if you are react
00:16:15 emotionally you lose rule number three of meme warfare laughter wins like here's an example of
00:16:22 you know you send a meme to like you know my parents generation and they might think that
00:16:27 they're supposed to you know provide a an essay response arguing back and it's like actually a
00:16:33 sternly written letter yes sternly written letter and in in the the the media in the medium of
00:16:40 memery that that's actually doesn't work in fact your opponents the people they won't even read it
00:16:47 they'll make another meme where you're in the midwit middle with your really long dissertation 0.97
00:16:51 and then they'll put the dumb guy in the sage 0.98
00:16:55 on the other side to the bell curve. 0.99
00:16:57 They'll just make the bell curve meme back at you
00:16:58 and then you'll write another one.
00:17:00 You have to understand that the medium
00:17:04 is actually going to influence and affect
00:17:06 how the message gets out.
00:17:07 Well, and I think ultimately,
00:17:08 and we'll get into this in the strategy section,
00:17:10 but as Christians, we ought to be masters of these,
00:17:13 I would argue, of these media, of these medium.
00:17:16 We ought to be able to know how to use it
00:17:18 and use it righteously.
00:17:20 If you're fighting in a meme war,
00:17:21 than know how to use that medium.
00:17:23 The other thing I want to ask, though,
00:17:25 is we look at media.
00:17:27 It can be used for tremendous good
00:17:28 or tremendous evil.
00:17:30 It just so happens in America
00:17:32 that you have leftist, progressive,
00:17:35 Marxist gatekeepers of institutions
00:17:39 like the New York Times.
00:17:40 You have people like this
00:17:41 who are using it
00:17:42 sort of as the propaganda arm of the state,
00:17:44 and it's really horrible.
00:17:46 One example of this,
00:17:48 and this was this week,
00:17:49 Roy Moore,
00:17:50 You remember Judge Roy Moore. He defended in Alabama. He got kicked off the Supreme Court for defending the Ten Commandments and their usage in the courts in Alabama. He refused to rescind them. He actually argued that he was acting as a lesser magistrate. He was removed, stays in politics, writes some books, runs for Senate a few years ago, I think 2017.
00:18:10 One of the political PACs in Alabama runs an ad.
00:18:14 So here we're talking about media. 0.99
00:18:15 They run an ad saying that, yeah, he's such a sexual predator that this mall down the street wouldn't even let him come on the premises because he was such a child predator. 0.89
00:18:25 Well, the only problem with it was it was 100% fabricated. 0.97
00:18:30 Wow.
00:18:31 I didn't know that.
00:18:32 Yep.
00:18:32 Completely fabricated.
00:18:33 It came out this week that it was a complete fabrication.
00:18:36 I think it was Mitch McConnell and their PAC money.
00:18:39 that ran the hit piece on him.
00:18:42 Of course, he loses the election.
00:18:44 He was winning in Alabama.
00:18:46 He ends up losing the election
00:18:48 and is basically forced out of politics at that point.
00:18:53 So what was interesting about this
00:18:55 is people also in another media forum on Twitter,
00:18:58 people like Al Mohler jumped on the bandwagon
00:19:01 and said, yeah, look at this guy.
00:19:02 We can't support him.
00:19:04 They said, look, he's guilty by accusation.
00:19:06 we see the me too movement probably can't happen without twitter yeah or similar mediums yeah yeah
00:19:12 without the quick react social media so again this week uh he won an eight million dollar lawsuit
00:19:18 wow against these people they don't care because they got their candidate in and they've worth
00:19:22 hundreds of millions but here's my point media can be used for bad and for good yeah so as christians
00:19:30 I want to ask this, like, how should we be thinking about media and its usage and the power that it has?
00:19:37 I mean, we've seen at King's Hall, correct me if I'm wrong, you're able to multiply your message pretty exponentially through now really what we're talking about, mass communications.
00:19:47 Yeah.
00:19:49 For the project of this season to be successful, the project of seeing a new Christendom built,
00:19:54 There will need to be thousands and thousands of Christian men and women
00:19:57 who are equipped to stand for the truth of Scripture
00:19:59 against the errors of both the liberal church and the pagan culture.
00:20:04 This is one reason we're so glad to be partnering with our sponsor for this season,
00:20:08 Reformation Heritage Books.
00:20:10 Reformation Heritage Books offers a large selection of helpful
00:20:13 and theologically rigorous resources on everything from biblical theology
00:20:18 to history to blue-collar family discipleship,
00:20:21 The type of library and resources that could make the kind of men and women I just described
00:20:26 grounded in the rich heritage of the Reformed faith.
00:20:30 We'd like to highlight one resource in particular, their Family Worship Bible Guide,
00:20:34 that presents rich devotional thoughts on all 1,189 chapters of the Bible,
00:20:40 including searching questions to promote conversation and to help you in leading your family in such a way
00:20:45 as to say with Joshua,
00:20:46 As for me and my house, we will serve the Lord.
00:20:49 Tap the link in the description of this episode to pick one up today.
00:20:55 One thing that's interesting, you know, as a thought exercise, and people can get this wrong
00:21:00 sometimes, they'll go down lines of reasoning like this. They'll say, like, why don't pastors,
00:21:06 why would a pastor spend 10 or 15 hours a week, sometimes more, you know, depending on their
00:21:11 skill level or what kind of sermons they're preaching, writing a sermon or doing something
00:21:15 like that, when they could be meeting with people, you know, how many people could you meet within 15
00:21:18 hours in the week. Yeah. Sermon is really a form of mass communication. Right. And it sounds
00:21:22 plausible at first. You're like, yeah, that does seem like a bad use of time. But then think,
00:21:26 let's say that you're preaching at a church with a hundred people and you preach an hour long
00:21:31 sermon. Well, you've just done 100 hours of communication. You know, you just talk to
00:21:35 a hundred people. Let's say you do a podcast and you get a thousand people to listen to your hour
00:21:40 long thing. Well, that's a thousand hours of communication that you've just distributed.
00:21:43 let's say that you get a youtube channel that you know like i think of something uh take
00:21:49 apologia you know they they were like the one of the original youtube sensation kind of christian
00:21:56 media media enterprises that really hit it big on youtube one of their they use all those click
00:22:01 baity titles which is pretty funny but they're like the meth the you the mess the youth message
00:22:04 that shocked everybody listen to the end literally no one it has like four million listens and it's
00:22:09 like an hour long. That's 4 million watch hours or something like that on something that
00:22:15 Pastor Jeff Durbin preached once. So when you look at media, one of the things you have to
00:22:22 understand is that definitionally media can function as a force multiplier because of that
00:22:29 phenomena, that math equation where you paint a painting or you put together a play or you
00:22:36 compose a piece of music or you make a building where you, all of these different things that
00:22:41 communicate different aspects of your fundamental system of belief. And everybody that interacts
00:22:47 with that piece of art or media is in conversation with you. And so every person who's walked into
00:22:57 the Sistine Chapel has been in conversation with all of the artists who made the frescoes and the
00:23:03 architects and the builders, they've been in conversation, just looking and interacting with
00:23:08 that object in a way that is powerfully force multiplying. So I think it's important, first of
00:23:15 all, that Christians don't too quickly dismiss media arts and even things like entertainment
00:23:23 as offhand, mainly a waste of time. Well, and I think you're absolutely right. And I think the 0.94
00:23:30 reason that they tend to do this jordan peterson has even talked about this as they stand right
00:23:35 now media theater music anything creative tends to attract people from the left yeah so you can
00:23:43 look at hollywood and spaces like this they're just dominated by the left and we'll unpack this
00:23:48 a little more conservatives are like i'm gonna go start a political think tank and we're gonna
00:23:52 think tank we're gonna crunch the numbers and we're gonna show people the data on inflation
00:23:56 and that's gonna change hearts and minds we're gonna write political articles but my argument
00:24:00 would be, it doesn't have to be that way. Conservatives and Christians in particular here,
00:24:06 we could actually be great storytellers. Absolutely. In fact, we should be. The greatest
00:24:11 stories, I think that, for example, the greatest work of fiction in the English language in the
00:24:17 20th century is The Lord of the Rings. And I think I can say that without any qualification. I
00:24:23 actually don't know. That's my opinion. I would like to hear a contender. Honestly, I can't. I've
00:24:29 actually tried to think when you told me that i was like nah nah but then you think i can't think
00:24:35 of anything in 20th century english speaking like there's some asterisks maybe like twilight
00:24:40 oh my gosh what do i do
00:24:43 anyway make some kind of retching noise in there or something give us some sound effects that
00:24:52 dunks on eric for me but you look at you look at something like that and you begin to understand
00:24:58 that one of the mistakes, the mistakes is endemic to conservatism and often to, you know, by
00:25:06 therefore Christianity because Christians tend to be conservatives, is that we fail to recognize
00:25:11 the sheer power of media and storytelling and things that seem to not be doing anything other
00:25:17 than frivolous things, but they're actually powerfully at work shaping your conception
00:25:22 of what the world is like and ought to be like.
00:25:26 And if you understand that,
00:25:28 then you will immediately conclude
00:25:30 that we should have, 1.00
00:25:34 the world should be awash with Christians 1.00
00:25:36 making sitcoms and movies and documentaries and paintings. 1.00
00:25:41 And doing them well.
00:25:42 And music and doing them fantastic.
00:25:45 It shouldn't just be pagans
00:25:46 who are spending $200 million to make a movie.
00:25:49 Christians should be doing that too.
00:25:50 And I don't mean just movies that are ham-fistedly designed to give the gospel message.
00:25:57 Like a sneaky backdoor sort of thing.
00:25:59 Fireproof.
00:26:00 It's almost like if you trust in Jesus, your team will win all the state championships.
00:26:05 Yeah, and the football team will.
00:26:07 No, we need...
00:26:08 It all gets better, yeah.
00:26:09 We need Christians making films that portray the beauty of love and romantic love in the natural family.
00:26:17 And fatherhood and motherhood.
00:26:19 And, you know, we need we need these kinds of art. And it's it's I was hugely encouraged. You know, the other day I was at Grace Agenda up in Moscow, Idaho. And Jess Hall, the CEO of Canon Press, was sort of sketching out their their vision for the future of their their company.
00:26:35 and one of the things that he mentioned
00:26:38 that they are working on
00:26:39 is actually making sitcoms
00:26:42 and I was like
00:26:44 it's brilliant
00:26:45 it's absolutely brilliant because you know think of how many people
00:26:48 have had their ideas of marriage and family
00:26:49 saved by Saved by the Bell
00:26:51 I haven't actually watched a sitcom
00:26:53 in probably 10 years
00:26:54 there you go
00:26:56 what are some of the ones all the middle aged ladies are watching
00:26:59 even from the family 1.00
00:27:00 you've seen like The Office and Parks and Rec
00:27:03 look how The Office and Parks and Rec
00:27:04 has shaped the way that people talk and joke with each other or even i was even thinking like
00:27:09 it's derogatory now but you look back and you think of like from the 50s leave it to beaver
00:27:13 we still talk about that absolutely yeah which is interesting because people are always dunking on
00:27:19 it and i'm like honestly that would be more ideal than what we have now even if you think about
00:27:25 something sometimes we neglect that architecture isn't is a wing of this kind of conception but
00:27:31 architecture communicates things. You know, I remember a story about some large Christian
00:27:38 speaker was talking about a building that was being made by these sort of postmodernist
00:27:44 architectures, architectures, architects. And they were trying to communicate with the building
00:27:49 what they believed about the world. So they were trying to upend the idea of objective truth and
00:27:55 reality and morality and all these things that reality is infinitely malleable to whatever you
00:27:59 believe they were trying to communicate this. And so the building was like all misshapen and it
00:28:03 looked impossible. And, you know, you get staircases to nowhere and all kinds of stupid 0.99
00:28:07 stuff like that. And what's really funny is, you know, they make this building and they think it's 0.98
00:28:12 communicating their worldview on a level it is, but on the deepest level, they cannot help but
00:28:18 communicate the Christian faith because guess what? The engineers who designed the building
00:28:23 and the inspectors who signed off on it, they still had to do math that God wrote or the building
00:28:28 would fall over yeah that's that's incredible i always think of babel as an illustration of this
00:28:33 that our our worship is going to be reflected in the things we build and so in all of this
00:28:39 discussion it's the old uh van till right that culture is religion externalized henry van till
00:28:45 we could say the same thing about media we could say the same thing about art whatever you create
00:28:50 yeah by way of media and art is going to be a reflection of what you ultimately worship
00:28:54 Yeah, culture is the artifacts of a people.
00:28:58 So before, Brian, you're absolutely right.
00:29:00 Before we dive into what's the status of American media today
00:29:04 and what does it reveal about what we worship,
00:29:07 I want to ask a primary question.
00:29:10 What would be the proper use of media?
00:29:11 Why is art, story, et cetera,
00:29:13 why is it so important that we get this right?
00:29:16 What is it for?
00:29:17 What's the telos of media and art?
00:29:20 So one of the things that before you jump to,
00:29:23 it's tempting and there are ways in which we need to talk about the actual purposes,
00:29:28 things we're trying to accomplish with media. But even prior to that, I think one of the first
00:29:35 things we have to say about media is that it says something about anthropology. It says something
00:29:42 about what a human being is in distinction from other created beings. It says something about
00:29:52 man's status as an image bearer that he goes out and he, wherever man goes, he adorns everything
00:29:59 in a way that, you know, dolphins don't do that. Even, even really highly intelligent animals
00:30:06 compared to other animals, they don't create oil paintings. They don't create beautiful works of
00:30:12 architecture. Or even Abraham, as he's going through the promised land before he's inherited,
00:30:17 of course, everywhere he goes, he builds an altar. Yeah. So he's doing construction projects
00:30:23 everywhere. God has answered and showed up in his life. He, he builds an altar. Yeah. And so when
00:30:29 you look at human beings going out and it's inescapable, human beings just go out and they
00:30:34 create, they, they make beauty, they make art, they make media, they make stories, they make
00:30:38 songs, they make plays across the world, whether you're a native Americans 3000 years ago,
00:30:44 aboriginal peoples in australia you know early germanic peoples romans greeks africans every
00:30:50 human distinct they will put art on walls they will scratch in stones they will crush up different
00:30:57 animals and make them into different colored stuff what does that say well that right there
00:31:02 says that human beings are created in the image of god and they're sub creators where god is this 0.55
00:31:10 capital C creator, human beings go out and they reflect God's image, his likeness, by telling
00:31:17 stories and doing all those. And now we need to take those instincts that human beings have by
00:31:23 virtue of their created ontology, their nature, and we then need to turn them towards the ends
00:31:29 for which God created the world. That's where things go wrong is when sin gets into the system,
00:31:36 Human beings don't stop being sub-creators.
00:31:38 They don't stop being artists and storytellers and songwriters.
00:31:42 They just turn and they make piss Christ.
00:31:45 Or they make these blasphemous and evil or truly frivolous and communicate.
00:31:51 Even in the journalism world, I'd say equivalent to piss Christ would be MSNBC, New York Times, you name it.
00:31:59 They're essentially doing the same thing with words.
00:32:01 So, Dan, I want to ask you, if you were to take Brian's principles, and this is your job on a
00:32:06 daily basis, right? Take Brian's principles and you break it down for the blue-collar man.
00:32:12 What does that say? Like, if we're these sub-creators, is that what you called them,
00:32:16 Brian? Yeah, that's right. If you're a sub-creator, how does that play out for,
00:32:20 say you're a journalist, say you're working at a local newspaper or you're working for
00:32:25 the Federalist or whoever, how does being a sub-creator shape your vocation?
00:32:32 Yeah, that's a good question. And so when I think about this, and precision is important here with
00:32:38 some of the things that I'm going to say, because I'm having to navigate like certain Gnostic ideas,
00:32:42 like we're a spark of the divine or some such nonsense. So when I say that we're, 0.79
00:32:48 what was the term you used? We're not recreating. We're sub-creating.
00:32:52 Sub-creating. It's almost as if we are reorganizing and creating back something that something should communicate to people the glory of God.
00:33:04 And so as man is the glory of God, as we work, and as a journalist or as an artist or an architect, what we are doing is communicating back fundamental truths that God built into the universe of what is good, true, and beautiful that can only be right-ordered under those who are spiritually alive, who are given the Holy Spirit, who are in right order with God because those who are not blood-bought, regenerate.
00:33:34 being renewed in their mind are actually disordered. There's something fundamentally
00:33:39 wrong with the unbeliever, with the pagan mind. There's a disorder in their mind and in their 1.00
00:33:45 creation that would prevent them from fully creating something or communicating something
00:33:51 adequately to glorify God, to glorify the creator. That's why in the story I said,
00:33:59 what if art is actually cosmic warfare worship and glory not just like it is warfare worship
00:34:08 and glory but on like a cosmic level like peeking behind the scenes to where you have the kingdom
00:34:14 of darkness and the kingdom of light are actually at war and it's it's it's coming out in mediums
00:34:21 it's coming out on computer screens and in tweets and on newspapers and uh through your ears and on
00:34:28 the TV set. There's actually a cosmic war going on behind the scenes. And so our responsibility
00:34:33 as Christians, as blood-bought people, are to fight that war. And the way that you fight that
00:34:39 is through, in a lot of ways, culture, which is worship, externalized. And so when you're making
00:34:45 things, you should be making them to the glory of God. And that does multiple things. It glorifies
00:34:51 God, not in just some pietistic, warm, fuzzy feelings, but actually in fighting back the
00:34:57 kingdom of darkness. So when someone makes an absolutely beautiful oil painting or tells an
00:35:04 amazing story, what you're doing is you're communicating back the true, the good, and the
00:35:09 beautiful that God has already put into the hearts of, of redeemed men and communicated naturally in
00:35:17 the universe. So when you look at a mountain sunset, you know, and, and then you paint that
00:35:21 And I mean, it, it transcends, you know, your, your current moment in your drab home and you
00:35:28 look at that painting, what it's doing is it's telling you a truth. It's telling you something,
00:35:33 whereas something like the, the art that the gentleman at the beginning of this episode
00:35:39 did is it's actually fundamentally lying to you. It's telling you lies. And so I lost your question
00:35:46 somewhere in my ramblings, but I, I think fundamentally that's what you're talking
00:35:50 about with sub-creation is in a way you're creating back glory that God has revealed.
00:35:56 I think it was really interesting, Dan, because I asked for a blue-collar answer and I got
00:36:00 a Brian answer.
00:36:02 Yeah, you got more.
00:36:03 Which is, it's very interesting.
00:36:05 Let me multiply some more of that in that same vein because we're going to get blue-collar.
00:36:09 We're going to get blue-collar.
00:36:10 Yeah.
00:36:10 We absolutely are.
00:36:11 But built on the foundational theoretical understanding and principle that is important
00:36:17 to stand under your feet.
00:36:18 before you go do anything, you have to understand like what you're standing on, what you're aiming
00:36:21 for. And I'm realizing now that that term sub creator, I actually got, I think it's Lightheart,
00:36:26 Peter Lightheart. He spoke of a sub creator being a created being that also creates because we're
00:36:33 created in the image of God. Humans are therefore created to be sub creators. That's from his
00:36:38 commentary on first and second Kings. But what does that mean? Well, it means that whenever you
00:36:43 go out into the world and you adorn something or you take raw materials and you put it together
00:36:48 in a way that's supposed to be pleasing or communicate beauty or tell a story or any kind
00:36:52 of artistic media sort of enterprise, what you're always doing and what a Christian should, well,
00:36:58 let me start here. What you're always doing is you're speaking and communicating something
00:37:03 either about how the world is, how it ought to be, what's wrong with it, or what you think it
00:37:11 ought to be. And I'm sure there's more you could say, but those are some of the big categories
00:37:15 that art is almost always doing,
00:37:18 which is why it's so powerful,
00:37:20 either in towards glory or towards perdition,
00:37:24 when human beings go and do this artistic endeavor.
00:37:28 Think about what-
00:37:28 What's really good with like sitcoms that you talk about.
00:37:30 Yeah.
00:37:31 Is that you're saying the world ought to be 0.89
00:37:33 like the modern family, 1.00
00:37:34 where there's like the quirky gay people 1.00
00:37:35 and there's like the immodest daughter 1.00
00:37:38 that's always in dating issues 0.99
00:37:41 and there's the dopey husband.
00:37:43 You're saying this is what the world is like.
00:37:45 and should be, or, you know, even think about in the sitcom, a lot of the time you always have like
00:37:50 the token gay couple, and they're always this faithful, basically everything true about the
00:37:56 natural family, but just with a gay couple. And it's communicating that idea that, yeah, gay men,
00:38:02 when they go and get married, it's just like a man and a woman leaving his, you know, man leaving 0.73
00:38:06 his father and mother and holding fast to his wife, as it always has been. They're just making
00:38:10 a house. They just happen to be two men instead of if Christians were to tell the story of true 1.00
00:38:16 reality and actually expose what the gay, especially the male homosexual community is 0.99
00:38:22 actually like, it would be all bathroom meetings and multiple partners and monkey pox. The number 0.99
00:38:29 of people that got monkey pox, according to the surveys, I think that had had more than 20 sexual
00:38:34 partners in the last 60 days or 90. It was huge. So if a Christian went out, again, when Christians
00:38:42 do art, it shouldn't just be this, let's just tell this beautiful story. Let's just show kind
00:38:47 of this, everything's sanitized. Christians should have no problem, provided that we do it in a way 1.00
00:38:54 that is appropriate and not sinful, of portraying even the depths of reality. And I think about
00:39:00 the biblical narrative. 1.00
00:39:03 We're chopping up concubines 1.00
00:39:04 and we have all of the men 1.00
00:39:06 from the oldest to the youngest 0.62
00:39:07 of Sodom coming out 0.99
00:39:08 trying to rape these angels, 1.00
00:39:10 these male angels. 0.99
00:39:11 And, you know,
00:39:12 the scriptures are fully open
00:39:14 about the depths of depravity
00:39:16 in human beings too.
00:39:17 I think it's one of the things
00:39:18 I've actually appreciated.
00:39:19 I know there are people
00:39:20 who think I'm pretty normie
00:39:21 for saying this,
00:39:22 but Focus on the Family forever
00:39:23 has put out Plugged In Online,
00:39:25 which is their evaluation of movies.
00:39:27 And they're actually
00:39:27 usually pretty helpful.
00:39:29 They're helpful.
00:39:29 But one of the things I know Bob Smithhauser has said for a long time is the thing that you're particularly on guard for as a movie critic is when they're trying to make sin seem good.
00:39:40 Right.
00:39:40 And they're trying to make good things seem bad.
00:39:43 So a lot of times, like, if you watch a film or you watch a movie and it's like promiscuity, but it's like, oh, it's happy and it's joyful.
00:39:51 It's happy promiscuity.
00:39:52 Now, there is a way to rightly show it where it's like promiscuity leads to misery and death.
00:39:56 Right.
00:39:57 As does, you know, Proverbs is pretty explicit about where adultery leads as well.
00:40:02 So I think that's part of the question.
00:40:04 Getting back to my original question, Dan, which was about journalists.
00:40:07 How should a journalist be?
00:40:09 That's what your question was, journalists?
00:40:10 Yeah, exactly.
00:40:11 And I was waxing poetic about mountain paintings.
00:40:13 Exactly.
00:40:14 You're talking about, you know, Bob Ross, and I'm talking about, like, what should a journalist do?
00:40:19 And that's my world, right?
00:40:20 As a trained journalist, that's what I'm thinking about.
00:40:22 So here's what I would say to that question, to my own question.
00:40:26 I think a lot of it is, it's a lot of the same answer.
00:40:30 Look, we want to present reality as it is.
00:40:32 That is honoring God.
00:40:33 The things that are good, true, and beautiful, we want to give them airtime.
00:40:36 And the things that aren't, we want to show them as heinous and disgusting because that's what they are.
00:40:40 Exactly.
00:40:40 So in conservative journalism, we've often talked about this issue of like, should I use all the pronouns?
00:40:47 Should I talk about things in the way that the left wants the narrative to be driven?
00:40:52 My answer to those questions is no.
00:40:53 But I think there's also been an inherent problem with journalism. When I was in journalism school in college, one thing we were told is, listen, as a journalist, your job is to be neutral and to be completely objective.
00:41:07 And what we've realized through the years is even people who think they're objective aren't.
00:41:12 And finally, in more recent times, I had a boss say to me, he said, listen, we all have presuppositions.
00:41:19 Yeah.
00:41:19 it would be better if we just came to the table and said
00:41:22 this is where I'm coming from and this is what I think
00:41:24 is right, true, good, beautiful, whatever
00:41:26 and that's how I'm going to report
00:41:28 so this is a story
00:41:30 from the book Essentialism
00:41:31 but the late writer Nora Ephron, who was a journalist
00:41:34 also famous for movies like
00:41:36 Sleepless in Seattle and When Harry Met Sally
00:41:38 two of Brian's favorites by the way
00:41:40 yeah, two of Brian's favorites
00:41:41 top five for sure
00:41:43 Twilight's up there
00:41:44 she talks about the story in which she had a poignant lesson
00:41:48 from one of her journalism professors
00:41:49 and she said it made her realize. I realized that journalism was not just about regurgitating facts
00:41:56 but about figuring out the point. It wasn't enough to know the who, what, when, where. You had to
00:42:01 understand what it meant and why it mattered. And so my argument from that quote would be
00:42:06 you have to have a Christian worldview. Yeah. You have to understand the narrative that Christ
00:42:12 and the glory of God's redemptive history is pointing at. Absolutely. How could you tell a
00:42:18 story that does any of the things we've just said arts and media are supposed to do, which is to say
00:42:22 what reality is like, to notice what is true about the world that God made, to point out a way that
00:42:29 it's gone wrong and how to fix that, right? How to tell any of these good stories. How can you do
00:42:34 that if you don't actually understand the actual foundational reality of reality? Think about
00:42:44 think about how much of the world is just, did God create just to yell about death, burial,
00:42:50 and resurrection? Yeah. Like how much nature, human relationships, human history, all of these
00:42:58 things, God brought together 10 million strands of stories to tell that story of death, burial,
00:43:05 and resurrection. It reminds me of, I think it's in Notes from a Tilt-A-Whirl where Endy Wilson
00:43:11 is talking about God's exhaustive knowledge of all things. And one of the things that he points
00:43:17 out is that God knows, it might've been death by living. God knows the story, the epic story of
00:43:23 every ant that has ever lived, right? Like there are epic journeys that a carpenter ant has gone
00:43:29 on to save his colony or to, you know, and God knows every single one of them. And most of the
00:43:36 stories that he's written into reality, he's the only one who will know them. They were just there
00:43:43 because he is an interesting and interested God, right? The story of every butterfly that ever
00:43:49 dies and then is reborn, you know, every caterpillar that's ever dies and reborn. God
00:43:53 is telling that story 10 million times over every year. And he notices every one of them,
00:43:59 right? Like the story of God knows the story of how every cubic centimeter of earth,
00:44:05 which earth that can grow things, rich, fertile soil cannot exist without the death and burial
00:44:12 and composting of billions of organisms. If you factor in even bacteria and fungi and all these
00:44:19 things that God worked into the soil cycle so that crops could grow and trees could grow.
00:44:22 And we look at it and we're like dirt and bugs. And God is, he says, I'm telling the story
00:44:30 of all things of death, burial, resurrection, and glory in over and over and over. God doesn't
00:44:36 get tired of this story. How could you tell a true or beautiful story about anything
00:44:41 without knowing that that is what reality is pointed at? And what that means is that if you
00:44:46 do tell such a story, it's because maybe even without knowing it, you stole from the Christian
00:44:52 story. Think about even filmmakers or authors who have tried to intentionally subvert
00:45:00 that like uh what's his name no country for old men cormac mccarthy you know try to tell nihilistic
00:45:08 sort of stories even those you you walk away with a deep sense of wrongness which is a feature of
00:45:17 christianity well that's the target he's trying to hit too yeah yeah is actually trying to grade
00:45:22 against this instinctual idea of of what is right and what is wrong yeah you're right and all it
00:45:28 does is end up saying wow that's wrong that's not how it ought to be no you see that in like
00:45:33 the troubled hero yeah that's so popular today with superheroes the anti-hero and 0.77
00:45:37 yeah exactly yeah dumbledore has to be gay and he has to be all these whatever well i think that
00:45:44 actually in reading cormac mccarthy i always thought i think that's part of his war on grammar 0.81
00:45:49 as well oh yeah it's a war against the structures of western culture of objectivity i mean i'm a fan
00:45:56 because I actually don't know grammar at all.
00:46:00 I mean, it drives me nuts.
00:46:01 It's weird how...
00:46:03 I would rather just not use a period ever.
00:46:06 You read Jane Austen and then you read Cormac McCarthy
00:46:09 and it's like, yeah, no, I choose Jane Austen every time.
00:46:11 I actually just re-listened to Pride and Prejudice
00:46:15 on the way back from Grace and Jim.
00:46:17 That's like double digits in the last two years for him.
00:46:19 Yeah, dude, I'm just saying.
00:46:21 So we've argued that media is important.
00:46:24 We've argued that the people delivering media
00:46:25 are important their hearts and minds right the journalists now i want to ask a simple question
00:46:30 but it can have a variety of answers what's the status of media mainstream media but all media
00:46:36 in america today when you look about what do you see pop popular culture yeah i mean pop culture
00:46:46 so the music the books the music twice had music already movies is what i meant yeah tv all of it
00:46:55 is going to be very aged very quickly and i and i can say that with confidence because my wife and
00:47:05 i like to sometimes take a trip back in time she has like an instagram lady she follows
00:47:11 it's like relive your college days or something like that which isn't that long ago it's like 10
00:47:16 years ago and plays the music and has like the clothing style going out to the club because like
00:47:21 Wow, this is horrible.
00:47:22 That was the, anyway, I want to talk about that.
00:47:24 Yeah, all of it's terrible.
00:47:25 Boots like the fur.
00:47:27 Yep, all of it.
00:47:28 Isn't it her?
00:47:30 Brian was in elementary school.
00:47:31 I don't know how he knows that song.
00:47:33 Because they played it at the school dance.
00:47:34 It was so much of school.
00:47:36 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:47:36 So just looking at a very, very short period of time backwards in history,
00:47:42 you can see that all of this ages very, very quickly.
00:47:46 What is the difference then?
00:47:47 This is, I think, a fascinating subject that we probably don't have time for.
00:47:52 What is the difference between a song or a movie or a story?
00:47:55 Story is probably the easiest one to use in as an example, but music is also really good.
00:48:00 What is the difference between a song that is aged in five years versus a song that's
00:48:05 been around for 500 years?
00:48:07 Or why is Shakespeare still around when movies, you see it once and you're like, oh, gross.
00:48:13 I hope I never see that again.
00:48:14 or like, you know, the big box office hit is not going to be seen in 20 years.
00:48:19 Nobody's going to be interested.
00:48:20 What is the difference between them?
00:48:22 Yeah, I'm going to tie my answer together to something.
00:48:24 I was recently rereading Pat Buchanan's book, The Death of the West.
00:48:28 That book always fascinates me because it was just as poignant,
00:48:32 just as true in 2002 as it is today.
00:48:35 Like if you read that book today, there's not one single thing about it
00:48:38 that's like, oh, yeah, I forgot things were like that.
00:48:41 You would think he was writing about right now.
00:48:43 And I think part of his answer is an answer to your question as well, that really what's going on with media is it's an extension of the Marxist leftist state and regime.
00:48:56 OK, so what they got serious real quick.
00:48:58 Yeah. What they did is they captured the institutions.
00:49:01 Yeah. Herbert Marcuse and the long march through the institutions.
00:49:05 That was all critical theory, by the way, who was seeking to do that.
00:49:09 Well, here we are now where that stuff is in every sphere.
00:49:13 They're teaching critical race theory to kids, social, emotional learning.
00:49:17 Media has been completely, and media institutions have been completely hijacked by the Marxist left.
00:49:22 So now you go on Netflix, which could be a really powerful platform for good things.
00:49:29 And what do you see?
00:49:30 You see like grooming little children.
00:49:33 Groomers, all of them.
00:49:34 Yeah, everybody's a groomer.
00:49:35 So what I want to say is that would be my assessment of media today right now is it's part of the propaganda machine for the status left.
00:49:44 And because that's true, it means that it will not tell stories that have staying power because it's trying to tell an anti-reality story.
00:49:53 Well, they're lies.
00:49:54 It's trying to tell a story that puts forward as true what is not true, right?
00:50:00 So when you look at what makes something like, again, Pride and Prejudice or Shakespeare are actually two really good examples from completely disparate times that are enduring stories or even to come to a modern place, something like Shawshank Redemption, which is a phenomenal film.
00:50:17 Stephen King, right?
00:50:17 Yeah, Stephen King. Actually, Stephen King's books in general, he tends to do this well, even though he has a lot of smut and isn't a Christian and is in some ways telling an untruth about reality. 0.99
00:50:26 but what is it with all those qualifiers but yet he can't help sometimes but tell a good story
00:50:32 because he's stealing from the christian world but what makes those great what makes austin and
00:50:37 shakespeare great what makes shawshank redemption great well one through line is that they all
00:50:42 notice and present these archetypal human beings that we all know exist and they unveil them in a
00:50:49 way that helps you understand the world you live in and people you know today because they're like
00:50:54 mr darcy or they're like elizabeth or they're like you know othello or they're like these
00:51:00 characters in these stories these people are often good artists are often astute observers
00:51:06 of reality and human nature like the foibles and the virtues yeah like a good comedian same a great
00:51:14 example because totally different medium but what makes good comedy is what makes good fiction is
00:51:18 what makes good documentary story they notice things they notice they're good observers of
00:51:22 reality and they're interested in the world God made. And so they begin to notice these common
00:51:28 character flaws. And then they sort of put them under a magnifying glass in a character like
00:51:33 the pastor in Pride and Prejudice or, you know, Mr. Collins or Mr. Darcy, who's proud and arrogant 0.98
00:51:41 and sins like a man sins or Elizabeth who gossips and sins like a woman sins or her foolish younger 0.91
00:51:47 sister mary who you know all who telling truths because people are actually like that yes and so
00:51:53 you look at those characters and you say i know these people because they're of students but now
00:51:57 if you tell the story of a faithful gay couple you don't know that person because they're very 1.00
00:52:03 they're hardly ever exist they literally are telling an untruth or a benevolent state as 0.77
00:52:07 communist propaganda tells they don't really exist christendom bible college offers a one-year
00:52:14 certificate in the humanities for students who intend to pursue a degree or for students who
00:52:18 prefer to begin their chosen occupations upon completion of our program. Older students who
00:52:24 never attended college or who went to a college where the humanities were less robust will also
00:52:29 find our program stimulating and suitable. Located steps from the Ohio River and the town of New
00:52:34 Richmond, we're unaccredited in order to remain free to teach as our biblically-minded consciences
00:52:40 demand. As servants of Christ, we won't wear the yoke of the woke. Instead, we stand on the
00:52:47 shoulders of Christianity's giants, not to stew in nostalgia, but to see through the culture wars
00:52:52 fall, for the glorious days of a Christendom still to be built. Our exceptional faculty are
00:52:58 committed to the historic biblical foundations of our faith. Come be a part of Christendom Bible
00:53:04 College. Visit us on the web at ChristendomBibleCollege.org to learn more. While there,
00:53:10 be sure to sign up for our email updates and receive your free three-chapter excerpt
00:53:15 of our very own Dr. Frank J. Smith's new book, Race, Church, and Society.
00:53:24 It's interesting. I have to throw this in there because we're talking about Pride and Prejudice.
00:53:29 We did, for the Hard Man podcast, we did the best books. My wife listened to all of it.
00:53:34 And then she goes, I'm disgusted.
00:53:37 Why?
00:53:38 And I said, Jerry, why are you disgusted?
00:53:40 And she goes, you could not remember the name of Lady Catherine de Bourgh?
00:53:44 De Bourgh.
00:53:45 And I was like, I know we were on Meets Capades.
00:53:47 Such a good character, Lady Catherine de Bourgh.
00:53:50 Such a good character.
00:53:52 She just shows the, like, and actually another thing that makes Shakespeare and Austen and
00:53:59 authors from earlier times so great for us to read now is because we're so we're so
00:54:06 steeped in a culture awash with lies about human nature yeah that you go back and you're like no 0.97
00:54:13 that really is how women tend to sin because she you know both of those shakespeare and austin 0.82
00:54:18 portray female gossip all over the place this is a little off off subject but one of the things
00:54:23 that I am absolutely amazed at with Shakespeare is that he was actually like pop. Yeah. Like
00:54:30 playwright. He would tie into the zeitgeist of the time. He would see like certain things going
00:54:35 on with the monarchy. And then he's like, I'm going to tell a story. And then he would write
00:54:39 a story for the time. Yeah. That time, specific time, what's going on at that time where he is.
00:54:45 And we still read it today. And so like you're saying, it transcends just a moment because
00:54:51 you're actually getting a peek behind the scenes of what are humans like? What is the truth?
00:54:56 And Christians, because Christians have this key, it's like we're looking at a map and Christians 0.91
00:55:03 have the key. We can look at the symbols in the world. It's like our cheat code. Yeah. The
00:55:08 archetypes, the typology that God's built into the world, even in human society. And we can see
00:55:14 what's happening. We can see sin and folly or wisdom and glory, and we can name them and describe
00:55:20 them accurately because we're Christians and we understand the God who made them all.
00:55:25 So this is one of the reasons why historically Christians have made some of the most enduring
00:55:31 and greatest stories of all time. Christians have been the ones who have done that. And so one of
00:55:36 the things that we need to recover is a storytelling, a culture of art and music and
00:55:43 beauty and architecture that tells the truth about the world in its glory and its inglory.
00:55:49 Not like a varnished Christian version, like a Sunday school, yeah, yeah, yeah. 0.87
00:55:53 Like Jesus junk, testaments and whatnot at Lifeway. 0.92
00:55:56 Testaments, yeah. 0.96
00:55:57 Well, speaking of which.
00:55:58 Wall hangings.
00:55:59 Yeah, go ahead.
00:56:00 Speaking of which, this brings me to the next subsection that we're talking about.
00:56:05 Uh-oh, are we going to talk about Christian media?
00:56:06 We're going to talk about Christian media.
00:56:08 So one of the reasons, if I was playing devil's advocate, one of the problems is we're like,
00:56:12 okay, everything you guys say about Christendom sounds great.
00:56:15 And when you describe art or you read, you know, Angels in the Architecture or you read Francis Schaeffer on art or any number of books like this, you think, wow, that's a grand vision.
00:56:25 Yeah. 0.92
00:56:26 Well, speaking of grand visions, let's take a look at what Christian media is producing today.
00:56:31 Go to your annual Christian Broadcasters Association.
00:56:35 Do we have to?
00:56:36 Go to the Christian apps in the app bookstore.
00:56:39 And what's crazy about this is I'm going to ask you a question here.
00:56:42 Okay.
00:56:42 I promise it's not raining forever.
00:56:44 But Christians actually aren't without resources and capital when it comes to media.
00:56:49 There's actually a lot of money wrapped up in Christendom. 0.99
00:56:52 The problem is, and I'm just going to be blunt on this one, the stuff that we produce is absolute garbage. 0.97
00:56:57 Well, it's—I'm—continue. 0.96
00:57:00 Yeah, so when I was growing up, my parents, every now and then, would take me to church, you know, once biannually, every two years or something.
00:57:09 I'd go to church and my friends when we'd go there
00:57:12 they would say hey you know
00:57:13 here's the really cool Christian thing and I was like oh
00:57:16 what is it and they're like watch Facing the Giants
00:57:18 and as a non-believer 0.99
00:57:21 I was like this is the cheesiest gayest thing 0.98
00:57:24 in the world and now I thought there was something 0.97
00:57:26 wrong with me and then I became a Christian and I
00:57:28 watched it again and I was like
00:57:29 I appreciate what the Kendrick brothers
00:57:31 were trying to do but it becomes 0.99
00:57:34 this ham-fisted like my life sucks 0.95
00:57:36 then I get Christ 0.99
00:57:37 and now I win state championships 1.00
00:57:39 and my barren wife has babies. 0.99
00:57:41 And then I go live life in the world 0.99
00:57:43 and I say, yeah, but that's not the way it is.
00:57:47 That's not a representation of reality.
00:57:50 It's cheesy.
00:57:51 It's ham-fisted.
00:57:52 It's not something that goes,
00:57:54 that makes me say internally,
00:57:55 wow, the glory and the power of that story.
00:57:58 Yeah, so I was just going to say 0.96
00:57:59 the reason that Christian media 1.00
00:58:01 and entertainment has sucked 1.00
00:58:03 is because that's what it can make. 0.93
00:58:05 it's a reflection of the culture it's a reflection of the people what's a reflection of how cheesy
00:58:11 shallow and lame christian culture is that's exactly my point if you distilled it down into a
00:58:17 big fast and famous produces that yeah you you distilled it down the culture down in into a 0.98
00:58:23 glass and you took a sip of it that's what it would be it would be cheese flavored garbage well
00:58:27 and and so you see that in other other cultures though as you look at like the the modern art 0.98
00:58:33 like i read about you get piss christ and you get like semen blood human breast milk i'm sorry
00:58:40 you guys have to listen to this this is true no that's what they're doing that's what it is that's 0.89
00:58:43 what yeah that's what demons produce yes christ yeah they that's what they produce and then
00:58:48 slightly better and so they get together and they have their fine wines and they look at the art 0.94
00:58:53 gallery of half naked women covered in blood uh with catholic priests and all of these disgusting 0.58
00:59:00 images. And, and that's the culture that they have. They have a culture of death. They have 1.00
00:59:05 a culture of sexual immorality. They have a culture of demons. And so that's what they're 1.00
00:59:09 going to produce is a culture of demons. And they keep trying to shove it down your throat.
00:59:13 Even looking at like the new Lord of the Rings deal on Amazon, even though people hate it,
00:59:18 they know they're going to watch it. I'm not. They're like, I'm going to shove it down your
00:59:22 throat anyway. Even if you don't like it and you complain, you're still going to watch it
00:59:26 because you have no principles. It doesn't exist. Yeah. I'm going to pretend
00:59:30 Unlike the Hobbit movies that it doesn't exist.
00:59:32 Well, I mean, yeah.
00:59:33 I mean, I'm not going to watch it either.
00:59:35 But my point in general, still, all of these Lord of the Rings fans are going to watch it 0.95
00:59:39 because they're serving up the plate of garbage.
00:59:42 And the people are like, well, it's not what I prefer. 0.64
00:59:44 I guess I have to eat it.
00:59:44 But I'll eat it anyway. 1.00
00:59:46 Instead of having Christians actually make something that's like a 100-proof whiskey, 1.00
00:59:51 like something that's potent and something that's true, 0.99
00:59:53 we satisfy with the garbage that we're served.
00:59:55 And a lot of the time, what it comes down to is that sometimes it's easy to underestimate
01:00:02 the difficulty of making truly great art, truly great storytelling, truly great music,
01:00:12 truly great architecture. These are not easy things. You actually have to have people
01:00:17 who are true craftsmen and true artists in these genres. And even then-
01:00:23 And it's hard as a Christian to exist in them. 0.89
01:00:25 It's still hard.
01:00:26 It's very difficult.
01:00:27 That's why there are...
01:00:28 Gatekeeping makes that really difficult as well.
01:00:29 There are hundreds and hundreds of mediocre and forgettable films
01:00:33 for every one or two or five truly great films.
01:00:39 Like Twilight.
01:00:40 Have you ever been punching the jejunum?
01:00:43 Like Twilight, Eric.
01:00:44 Why do you keep bringing up Twilight?
01:00:45 Eric loves Twilight.
01:00:46 Have you read Twilight?
01:00:47 I've actually never seen nor read it.
01:00:49 I've never seen nor read any of it.
01:00:51 I gather from a distance, it's hypergate.
01:00:53 I only know things about it that people have made fun of.
01:00:55 Like, I think the vampires sparkle.
01:00:58 Dumbledore?
01:00:59 Whatever.
01:00:59 Anyway, so when you look at that, 1.00
01:01:02 what Christians often want to do 0.83
01:01:05 is they want to treat these artistic and media endeavors 0.94
01:01:08 as sort of taco shells to put a worldview into
01:01:13 and just serve to people.
01:01:14 Can I add to that?
01:01:16 Yeah, go ahead.
01:01:16 While you're there,
01:01:17 it's like they're viewing the movie
01:01:19 like a cheesy veneer to a gospel tract.
01:01:22 Exactly.
01:01:22 It's the paper you printed on. However, that's not actually the way that this works.
01:01:27 Or good stories in general.
01:01:28 Anybody who's ever attempted to create a poem, a story, a song, a piece of art, literature,
01:01:36 you know how hard it is. You know how true, like God has to give talent and then you have to
01:01:43 cultivate it to a fine edge in the company of other people who'll be honest with you about
01:01:49 your work and give you like this is very difficult stuff and so when what christians want to do i
01:01:53 even when you ask this question i pulled up the wikipedia page christian media and it says
01:02:00 christian media sometimes referred to as inspirational faith and family or simply
01:02:03 christian is a cross-media genre that features a christian message or moral and that is so
01:02:09 perfect because what a lot of christian you know quote-unquote christian artistic endeavors are
01:02:15 is they're basically trying to just package some kind of moral story. 0.96
01:02:20 But it's like trinkety junk.
01:02:22 And they treat the medium as packaging.
01:02:25 Yeah.
01:02:25 That's the problem.
01:02:27 You actually can't do that because the media must be excellent and beautiful
01:02:32 and done with skill or it won't actually communicate the message you want it to.
01:02:38 And so what we need partly is, and actually there are people
01:02:43 who are doing a good job of recovering some of these things.
01:02:46 And it does, you know, another thing is that it takes millions and millions
01:02:49 and millions of dollars to make a great film a lot of the time.
01:02:51 Not all films, but it really does take a lot of money to do these things. 0.95
01:02:56 And Christians generally look at the periods of history 0.79
01:02:59 where the Christians were the one producing the most glorious of everything. 0.92
01:03:04 It was a time when the bulk of the money in those industries
01:03:08 were going to produce those things.
01:03:11 Well, when you think about even something like what we do,
01:03:13 with with podcasting i've had people ask me well why don't you have a tv studio like joe rogan
01:03:18 yeah we would love to you can make checks can be made payable checks made payable but i think what
01:03:25 you're finding is it's the same thing when i started well seriously if you want to give money
01:03:28 we have a venmo too yeah yeah send your tax deductible contributions too but i think a big
01:03:36 part of it is something that we've we've been hammering on and again i found this out with
01:03:39 the hard man podcast is is look if you want to produce genuinely biblical christian content just
01:03:45 authentic good celebrating good true beautiful all that good stuff a you're going to be hated
01:03:51 by the culture b even a lot of christians are willing to support you know netflix or whatever
01:03:58 else but then when you have guys you know going on a limb and saying like hey we need to you know
01:04:04 we need to do this good quality media venture,
01:04:08 it genuinely is hard because we don't have $200 million, most of us, to deal with.
01:04:14 My argument, though, is when you look, okay,
01:04:17 you had guys behind Walden Media who gave hundreds of millions of dollars
01:04:22 to produce Narnia.
01:04:24 Yeah. 1.00
01:04:25 Well, what that tells me, Christian guys, 1.00
01:04:27 what that tells me is there's money there, 0.93
01:04:30 but this goes back to things we've talked about in the past.
01:04:33 A lot of that money is going to Ben Shapiro.
01:04:35 A lot of money is going to the Daily Wire 0.88
01:04:38 and the celebration of gay marriage. 1.00
01:04:40 Yeah, and the first thing that they do
01:04:42 when you give money to this conservative group
01:04:46 is they go and they make, again,
01:04:50 they make sometimes excellent, I'm sure, media
01:04:52 that is absolutely at war with reality.
01:04:54 Yeah. 1.00
01:04:54 Because they're not Christians.
01:04:56 Well, even think about, I think it was Daily Wire, 1.00
01:04:58 they try to make a Western and like Gina Carano is the hero. 0.92
01:05:01 oh yeah they were just getting like canceled actors like butch like overly masculine like
01:05:08 strong feminine woman who's tougher than the guys they're trying to show like look conservatives
01:05:12 are pro-women too but they instead they just continue propping up the narrative of being
01:05:17 pro-women by saying women are basically men right who says i'm gay you are gay again they're just at
01:05:22 war with reality so you look at you know the state of christian media but uh and one of the problems
01:05:29 is that Christians often want to treat the medium cheaply because they view the medium as sort of
01:05:37 unimportant packaging to the message. So to the Christian, they would say, even if it's super
01:05:42 cheesy and poorly made, I want this Christian media to go out. And so we're going to, you know, 0.98
01:05:47 we're going to raise 50 grand and we're going to make a documentary or whatever.
01:05:50 Not understanding that really, truly to make a lot of like the most glorious Christian art,
01:05:56 it's going to take tens of millions of dollars for some of it. But then the other thing that
01:06:00 I think happens is that on the other hand, you get people who notice who are total wolves and 0.71
01:06:07 not Christians. And they look out and they notice, you know what? There are actually a whole lot of 0.92
01:06:11 Christians in this country and they all have jobs and money and I want their money. So then they 1.00
01:06:17 make the lowest common denominator, megachurchianity, mass appeal, Christian Jesus junk. 0.92
01:06:24 and they do it to make money yes yeah so you see this a lot with musicians actually oh yeah with
01:06:30 like the gospel singers you had carrie underwood and i i think britney spears even even got her
01:06:36 start what is a gospel singer and then on made no made the move into you know popular culture
01:06:44 the civil wars girl oh the singer joy beth williams joy williams started as a christian
01:06:51 artist some of the more recent music that's what you should go listen to the worship song song by
01:06:55 random action verb band which is a parody of christian worship but it's like you know i could
01:07:01 write i guarantee you i could write a chris thomlin song in 10 minutes i'll describe the
01:07:07 chord progression g2 d suspended c2 e minor d every seventh conductor being connected by a
01:07:16 non-reversible tremie pipe to the differential girdle spring on the up end of the gram meters.
01:07:21 See, you know, and then you just, you sing like things that, you know, God set us on fire. You
01:07:27 are our desire. Your name is holy. Come and fill me. With guacamole. With guacamole. You know,
01:07:35 you just, and you look at that and you go, compare that to dawn. Compare that to Paradise Lost.
01:07:42 compare that to some of the christian poetry that is in our inheritance and it was not easy to make
01:07:52 someone labored and spent spent their life and their energy laboring to create beautiful words
01:07:58 to describe this world that god made well because in part they believed that it was a noble task
01:08:02 yeah whereas fundamentally when you again you boil down uh modern christianity the medium doesn't
01:08:10 matter. Only the very root of the message, which is I need to sneak in a gospel presentation.
01:08:16 Your decisionism. Exactly. So it doesn't matter. Why would you spend $200 million on a movie
01:08:22 when you just want to tell as many people as possible that Jesus loves you?
01:08:26 There was actually a movie I watched. I downloaded it last minute while getting on an airplane.
01:08:30 It had Robert Duvall. So I thought, oh, it's good. It's like a golf movie.
01:08:34 It's like the cheesiest Christian movie of all time. Oh no. 1.00
01:08:37 This guy, like, you know, he's putting his life back together and, like, it's all, like, small town.
01:08:42 You know, it's like a Hallmark movie.
01:08:44 Yeah.
01:08:44 And then he gets to, like, this golf tournament and, like, the final hole, he goes to hit the shot.
01:08:49 And the movie ends before the ball drops in the hole.
01:08:53 And it's like, to find out more, go to da-da-da-da.
01:08:56 No!
01:08:57 And I was like, well, how did it end?
01:08:59 It was a bait and switch?
01:09:00 I go to that site and it's like, you're probably wondering how this movie ends.
01:09:05 Well, have you accepted the Lord Jesus Christ into your life?
01:09:07 Click yes, and we'll show you the end.
01:09:08 And I was like, gosh dang it, I want to see the end of this movie.
01:09:11 And there was no end to the movie.
01:09:13 Oh, that's cold. 0.70
01:09:14 It was disgusting.
01:09:15 That's super cold. 1.00
01:09:16 People are converting to Buddhism because of that.
01:09:17 Well, it's the same thing as like the people that leave the tips of a $100 bill, but it's a fake.
01:09:23 It's just like you probably thought you just got really rich.
01:09:26 Well, you know what will make you eternally rich?
01:09:28 The Lord Jesus Christ.
01:09:30 Well, you're actually still poor, though. 0.99
01:09:33 Sucks to be you. 0.99
01:09:34 sucks to be you thanks for filling my water up so promptly though whenever i drank it all 0.99
01:09:38 so here's the other why are they southern brian i'm assuming i'm assuming i'm just assuming that's 0.93
01:09:44 very bible belt you know like you know that actually reminds me speaking of accents this
01:09:48 is like way back to an earlier point but the whole thing where people think i'm just going to tell the
01:09:52 story objectively neutrally yeah it's like saying you're going to talk without an accent
01:09:57 you always have an accent you just think yours is normal anyway i just that's actually a really
01:10:03 That's a really good point.
01:10:04 That's a really good point.
01:10:05 So one of the things, we're talking about Christian media still at this point.
01:10:10 One of the articles I've written on the Hard Men podcast,
01:10:13 well, it's actually at ericahn.com.
01:10:14 We'll provide links in the show notes. 0.94
01:10:17 Shameless plug.
01:10:18 It's titled How the Christian Media Industry is at War with Men. 0.99
01:10:21 Now, this is interesting because we've talked about what's chintzy and crappy 0.71
01:10:25 and all that stuff with Christian media. 0.99
01:10:27 So we're talking about things like, you know, K-Love and Passion Conferences
01:10:31 with louis giglio and you know a lot of that stuff but even in the christian reformed world
01:10:37 you've got the gospel coalition and you've got a lot of stuff in that space which people like
01:10:42 paul maxwell i think argued well they're actually at war with christianity too and so uh one of the
01:10:49 things they pointed out with people like tim keller recently endorsing a book titled biblical
01:10:54 critical theory oh he wrote the forward to it does it is it is the subtitle sucks no or doesn't
01:11:03 exist it's basically he's trying to show i think uh from reading the uh sort of the back cover so
01:11:09 to speak uh he's trying to jive critical theory with a biblical worldview which of course is 0.94
01:11:15 ridiculous you've got christianity today they're openly feminist they just hired an openly feminist 0.97
01:11:22 woman. I mean, whatever. Russell Moore. 1.00
01:11:25 I repeat myself. Eric getting us
01:11:28 in trouble every time. Every time. Getting us
01:11:30 in trouble. Once again, direct
01:11:32 your emails to eric.
01:11:34 the con man at
01:11:36 manmail.com
01:11:38 Yeah, but try that.
01:11:40 See if it works. I don't know. I'm just assuming.
01:11:42 So we've got all these Christians. Hard manmail.com 1.00
01:11:44 Don't go there.
01:11:46 I don't know if it exists. Don't try it.
01:11:48 You got all these outlets who are supposed
01:11:50 to be pro-Christian crossway recently talking about the idolatry of motherhood right all pushing
01:11:56 a pro-left anti-biblical sexuality marxist open borders anti-white message so i think even in in
01:12:04 that sector of christendom most people feel like hey they're at war with us and you'd actually be
01:12:09 right so i want to close with really a question about strategy yeah yeah and the question is can 0.88
01:12:17 Christians win? And if so, how? What should our strategy be? If we were to take this Boniface
01:12:23 option, King's Hall approach, and then apply it to media, what would that look like for us?
01:12:32 Well, one thing to understand first is that we are in the early days still of this massive,
01:12:41 massive technological transformation that has happened. And Christians, and I'm talking about 0.59
01:12:46 the internet, digital media, all these things. Digital currencies. Crypto is king. Bitcoin. 0.74
01:12:52 Anyway, historically, Christians have been the ones who have grabbed onto these new technologies.
01:12:58 The Bible is the first thing printed on the Gutenberg press, right? Christian literature
01:13:02 explodes through that. Christians in the early medieval times and prior are the ones who are 0.98
01:13:08 preserving the thought of the West in monasteries and preserving these written works, even of
01:13:16 Greeks and Greek philosophy and Roman philosophy and things like that. So Christians ought to be 0.99
01:13:21 looking at this moment where we have these new technologies. And I even mean cutting-edge
01:13:26 technologies like now we have artificial intelligence translation, artificial intelligence
01:13:32 narration, and things like that. Jess Hall, again, the CEO of Canon Press, was talking about this in
01:13:37 his talk at the Grace Agenda Men seminar. We saw those pictures too, even floating around social
01:13:42 media, like the AI kingdom of heaven pictures. Oh yeah. Yeah. They're stunning. So you see what
01:13:48 human ingenuity is doing. Humans taking dominion and creating culture, technology, and things like
01:13:54 that that can be used for evil, but also they can be used for tremendous good. And so Christians 0.99
01:14:00 shouldn't be like, oh, you know, the internet, the social media is that once again with Southern 0.93
01:14:06 accent. Southern accent. You know, they're, they're, they're the, the, the, you and your
01:14:09 fancy foothball friends, you know, they're, they're of the devil. No, we should actually 0.84
01:14:12 be saying, how can we, how can we go and conquer these mediums? How can we go and make the best
01:14:19 podcasts, the best audio books, the best films, documentaries, because we're Christians, we need
01:14:26 to ban electricity. Then no one can watch the foothball. But what Christians often do is they
01:14:33 they artificially narrow and limit the scope of what kind of endeavors they're aiming for. 0.93
01:14:40 So they say, oh, podcasts, let's make 50,000 reformed bro theology podcasts, which is really
01:14:49 a meta thing for me to say on a reformed bro theology and culture podcast.
01:14:55 But you know what else we should be doing? We should be making the best fictional storytelling
01:15:01 podcasts i thought you were gonna say music true we should be making the greatest music we should
01:15:07 be making you know that's i mean so like the theoborough podcast world yeah i actually
01:15:13 wouldn't put us there uh because i was just being self-deprecating which is kind of effeminate so
01:15:18 i'm sorry yeah good don't apologize you didn't do anything wrong brian real men never i'm getting
01:15:23 i'm getting hoisted on my own petard john wayne oh man a little shakespeare a petard right for you
01:15:29 Yeah, wasted by his own petard. 0.79
01:15:32 A lot of sexual innuendo in Shakespeare, by the way, but go on.
01:15:35 Yes, I want to ask a question, though.
01:15:38 You look at what's going on in Reformed circles, 1.00
01:15:41 and I wonder, too, why are they so bad at culture so many times? 1.00
01:15:45 And what I mean is, it's like, unless we're talking about theology works
01:15:49 or our favorite Baptist preacher, we have nothing to say to anything.
01:15:53 Well, think about this.
01:15:55 One of the instincts that has suffused certain corners of Reformed Christendom, of Reformed Christianity, is a skepticism about adorning and arts.
01:16:13 Everything should be beauty.
01:16:14 Well, the Puritan instinct.
01:16:16 Yeah, and there are directions that the Puritans took that.
01:16:20 It should be drab.
01:16:21 Where I understand, I absolutely understand the instinct, and I understand the principles they were operating on.
01:16:27 I don't want to one-dimensionalize them.
01:16:28 These were serious men, serious thinkers who built serious Christian culture.
01:16:33 And at the same time, I think that there were areas where they overreacted to things they were seeing
01:16:38 and ended up throwing out some of the things that they ought to have actually been creating with excellence,
01:16:47 things like beauty and art.
01:16:49 So I think that's certainly...
01:16:50 It's like an ascetic instinct.
01:16:52 Yeah, there's an ascetic instinct in Christian faith.
01:16:56 You know, but one of the things that I think might be driving it to be charitable
01:16:59 is that Christians think we live in serious times where people are dying and going to hell.
01:17:08 And we have the gospel of the kingdom of God.
01:17:11 So why wouldn't we make everything we do be just 100% completely transparently about that?
01:17:20 And anything we do, it should drive always to a gospel presentation and altar call.
01:17:26 I get the thought process that leads you there, but what you end up doing because you're operating
01:17:32 on a thin anthropology, you're failing to recognize that human beings are not brains
01:17:39 on a stick. Human beings are not just USB drives that you plug into a hard drive, give a gospel
01:17:43 presentation. Human beings are embodied souls within the world. They have all these senses
01:17:49 that God has given them. And all of this beauty and sounds and tastes and smells and stories and
01:17:55 longings and hopes, they're supposed to be, as Lewis described, like sunbeams coming through a
01:17:59 hole in the garden shed that makes you want to put your eye to that hole and follow the light
01:18:05 up to the sun. God is the creator of all good things. And so I think Christians can sometimes
01:18:10 be too quick to try and sum up everything in gospel presentation and bald theology 0.50
01:18:18 and failed to recognize that one of the most powerful ways
01:18:21 to actually teach theology and to evangelize the world
01:18:26 is through indirect means and through beauty
01:18:30 and through the shaping of the hopes and longings of people.
01:18:32 In the same way, God could have just revealed himself,
01:18:34 kind of like a bad sci-fi book,
01:18:38 where the guy, he does world building,
01:18:40 and he's like, here's a rock planet.
01:18:42 It's all rock, and there's just crustaceans,
01:18:44 and there's a storm that goes around it.
01:18:46 And that's the, that's the world really boring and uninteresting. Right. But God didn't make a
01:18:52 world like that, nor are people like that. You're talking about Brandon Sanderson? I did.
01:18:56 Wow. Okay. All right. Actually the world building was more interesting,
01:19:00 but he fundamentally believes a lie. He's Mormon. Yeah. Yeah. He, he, he believes a lie that he made 1.00
01:19:04 a Mormon universe, that this world isn't that interesting. So he had to make a lie, but anyway, 0.72
01:19:08 we can get into that in a different, different episode. But the point is people aren't like
01:19:12 that either people aren't just like a one-dimensional so we live on like a there's
01:19:16 actually like this spiritual plane and that's all that we all that we are i mean none of the
01:19:22 none of these uh theo bros that you know we're just throwing in like a buck them in a bucket
01:19:27 live like that either they don't just their entertainment isn't like well i i'm just going
01:19:32 to read jonathan edwards that's my entertainment no these guys watch the office like they go to
01:19:38 work they they like other things like cigars and i don't know what else they like right but but
01:19:44 they're more complex than that too to where a story shouldn't just always dive down into the
01:19:49 one thing and that's a gospel presentation for decisionism because we found also that that's
01:19:55 not effective because that's not how good god designed actually uh the winning of men's hearts
01:20:00 wasn't through just like oh here's a here's a thesis you know here's your problem here's the
01:20:05 solution. Make a decision. Two propositions and a conclusion. Correct. Right. I'm pretty sure I
01:20:10 mentioned this before, but somewhere Peter Lightheart has an article about this where
01:20:14 like a lot of Protestant evangelicals in the way they make movies is very conversionistic.
01:20:19 Yeah. Like everything's bad. You get saved. Everything's good. Right. And it tended to be 1.00
01:20:24 that Scorsese and others Catholics were the ones who understood the sanctification that 1.00
01:20:28 like a Christian could have a real depth of depravity. The complexity. Yeah. There's a lot 1.00
01:20:33 of complexity and a lot of layering so i think that's a huge part of it so i think we'll close
01:20:37 with this we we really have a couple strategies i think when it comes to how do we engage with
01:20:42 media number one is that we fundamentally we just abandon the institutions or we recapture them yeah
01:20:49 i think there's you know that's that's one strategy you can either go one one of two ways on
01:20:53 that i think in the short term that recapturing say like the new york times is not going to happen
01:21:01 No.
01:21:02 Not going to happen. 0.98
01:21:03 Like, Indy Wilson has a show on Netflix.
01:21:05 Right.
01:21:05 Yeah.
01:21:06 Hello, Ninja.
01:21:08 Hello, Ninja.
01:21:09 That's right.
01:21:09 I think you can, we almost have to do what Marcuse was doing in the 70s, which is a long, slow march through the institutions.
01:21:16 Like, you're going to have to infiltrate and be subtle and do those things.
01:21:20 I think people should be doing that.
01:21:22 Yeah, so I know you're summarizing, but with Hello, Ninja, it's very subtle.
01:21:27 It's very subtle.
01:21:28 But there are things like the boy character won't allow the girl character
01:21:31 to go into battle.
01:21:33 He's like always taking the lead.
01:21:34 That's the subtle.
01:21:36 That's the subtle thing.
01:21:37 Because if he was, anyway.
01:21:39 So that's, yeah, the subtlety.
01:21:40 Slow march.
01:21:42 Just get your finger, you know, in there.
01:21:44 Yeah, and it's helpful.
01:21:44 I don't think anyone is necessarily like you have to take this one.
01:21:48 Strategy number two, this is the Torba, I think a little bit of Lore TV,
01:21:52 Canon Press, which is that you build adjacent or parallel media.
01:21:56 Yeah.
01:21:57 Right?
01:21:57 you can't impress you've mentioned them um they've done a really good job uh building media where
01:22:02 it's like you know i have uh pretty much can consume on the canon press app kind of all day
01:22:07 long yep listen to books podcasts pretty much all edifying yep um and you're gonna find a lot
01:22:13 of good content there yeah i haven't dabbled as much with lore tv brian i know i've been on there
01:22:18 yeah i watched a little bit dark hauler um some of them i ended up uh like skipping through a few
01:22:24 of the episodes and things like that. There's another one, the post-mill documentary that they
01:22:29 make. I love the concept of what they're aiming for though. I love the idea of building a platform
01:22:35 that's unapologetically Christians being Christians, but also making, like, I think it was pretty cool 0.86
01:22:41 that one of the first things they did was make a paranormal adjacent show, which is not what you'd 0.51
01:22:46 think a Christian would be doing, but understanding that actually the popularity of the paranormal
01:22:52 genre shows the spirit, like the innate spirituality of the world and of man. And so absolutely
01:22:57 Christians should go in there and say, we actually know what's happening in this world.
01:23:01 Yeah. And we know, like when you see old aunt Muriel's ghost, I'm sorry, it's a demon and we 0.92
01:23:07 can explain it to you. Like we should be the ones who are providing the substance in some of these
01:23:12 14 genres without being overly obsessed with demons. Yeah. So I think, honestly, I think a
01:23:20 lot of christianity like we're sort of in our infancy with that stuff yeah that would be you
01:23:25 know my estimation of it gab is another one uh huge powerful but yeah like we're kind of all
01:23:30 finding out like if you want to start your own banking network and your own platform andrew
01:23:35 doing great work but you're kind of starting from zero you're like 15 years behind facebook and so
01:23:41 very difficult it's a challenge yeah it's a real challenge there's a reason facebook has an army
01:23:47 of hundreds and possibly thousands of software engineers coding their system because people
01:23:52 don't understand how immensely complex it is to make something like a social media platform
01:23:58 that's available across the world to tens of millions of people simultaneously well even
01:24:04 very difficult even in salt lake of millions salt lake city uh there's a facebook building here
01:24:09 I knew a gal who was worked at the, whatever it is, Salt Lake Power and Light or whatever.
01:24:16 And she spent two years putting in an extra power grid for Facebook.
01:24:21 Yeah, it's just a power grid for one of their buildings.
01:24:23 Yes.
01:24:24 So when you look at what Torba and Gab is doing, opening server rooms, because they are 100% doing their thing.
01:24:30 Think about the scale.
01:24:32 Think about the scale.
01:24:33 Absolutely Chad King impressive what they're doing, to be honest.
01:24:36 when you look at the fact that for 99.9% of Christian entrepreneurs would have been done
01:24:43 when Amazon shut their service off. And instead they said, we're going to build our own fricking 0.78
01:24:48 servers. And then they did it. Like, I don't know. I think that's pretty wildly. That's pretty
01:24:54 impressive. That's pretty amazing. We need Christians with that kind of, like, if you're
01:24:58 going to go do these sorts of things, you have to understand you're going to face rampant opposition.
01:25:02 go look at the tomato what what is it rotten tomatoes yeah go look at the reviews the critic
01:25:07 reviews from movies that are made by christians that are actually really good i can't think of
01:25:11 one but i know they exist like movies that tell stories about natural families and things like
01:25:17 that and then they'll have 20 critic reviews 98 audience reviews like you have to understand
01:25:22 you're going to be at war with the entire industry with the gatekeepers the priests
01:25:28 Even think about people like Mel Gibson.
01:25:31 His films do really well.
01:25:32 Oh, yeah.
01:25:33 And he is absolutely hated by the establishment.
01:25:35 Yeah, absolutely.
01:25:37 Even Torba faces death threats regularly.
01:25:40 Yeah.
01:25:40 Like, can't freely go out in public all the time.
01:25:43 Because people are trying to kill him.
01:25:45 Yeah.
01:25:45 They hate him that bad because he's making a...
01:25:47 Like, when they say, go make your own social media platform if you don't like it. 0.98
01:25:50 Well, if you actually do it, they'll try to kill you. 0.84
01:25:52 Yeah. 0.99
01:25:53 You have to...
01:25:54 You kind of have to realize that.
01:25:56 The stakes are high.
01:25:57 Guys, by the way, I would totally not be surprised
01:25:58 if one day they kicked us off all this stuff.
01:26:01 Kings Hall.
01:26:02 I'm actually surprised that they haven't.
01:26:04 Right, Hearth?
01:26:04 We're not...
01:26:05 That actually brings me to the third strategy.
01:26:07 Uh-huh.
01:26:08 Because I think this is probably where we are right now.
01:26:12 Guys, by the way, there's only two strategies
01:26:13 written down in our notes.
01:26:15 But I'm on the third.
01:26:16 We're about to hear Eric going off the reservation.
01:26:19 Hot take.
01:26:19 Here we go.
01:26:21 Third strategy, work within the system
01:26:22 with tools available to get our message out.
01:26:24 I actually think we're sort of straddling
01:26:27 so you know we're on Gab
01:26:28 we have some good relationships
01:26:31 there yeah with the Gab
01:26:33 people we love them the Gabbers
01:26:34 they're amazing but I think what we've
01:26:37 also done is said like you know and I
01:26:39 know a lot of people have disagreed with this
01:26:40 we're on like
01:26:42 you know LGBT
01:26:44 homo supporting platforms
01:26:47 oh yeah yeah we use
01:26:49 tools that are built by pagans all over
01:26:51 the web I like the way you said it better
01:26:52 than the way that Eric said.
01:26:53 But we repeat ourselves.
01:26:55 I mean, that's what the pagans are doing.
01:26:56 That's their relationship.
01:26:57 You actually liked Brian's better.
01:26:59 Well, yeah, yeah.
01:27:00 We're on the pagans platforms
01:27:01 versus like it sounded like
01:27:02 we're directly supporting the gays. 1.00
01:27:04 Oh, I'm not supporting them. 1.00
01:27:06 It's like this.
01:27:07 You can't avoid,
01:27:08 you have to understand
01:27:09 that when you spend a dollar,
01:27:11 it is inevitable
01:27:11 that you're supporting sodomy somewhere.
01:27:13 I mean, I don't care what you're buying.
01:27:14 It's almost impossible
01:27:15 for you to remove yourself
01:27:17 from the chain of injustices somewhere
01:27:19 where the world is so tainted by sin
01:27:22 that whatever you buy,
01:27:25 even if you buy the unlocked Android phone
01:27:26 that you're going to put your Linux system on
01:27:28 and run Gab only or something like that,
01:27:30 which is great, good for you to go do that,
01:27:32 you're still going to buy software chips
01:27:33 that are made by pagans 0.80
01:27:34 that are going to support sodomy somewhere. 0.78
01:27:37 We don't win by attempting to remain pure
01:27:41 and in this completely separated state. 1.00
01:27:46 Like an Anabaptist is what you're saying?
01:27:47 We do not win by Anabaptism.
01:27:49 I think it's being cognizant of that fact
01:27:50 that in the marketplace
01:27:53 there's going to be meat sacrificed to idols.
01:27:54 Eat anything in the meat market without questions of
01:27:56 conscience, Paul said. I went through this whole shtick
01:27:58 where I was like, no, I reject Apple.
01:28:01 I'm only using Samsung.
01:28:02 And then my dad, who was a Samsung
01:28:04 user, he was like,
01:28:06 have you read the history of Samsung? You do know that
01:28:08 they're just communists too.
01:28:10 It's not better.
01:28:13 Yeah, and I know
01:28:14 people will disagree on some of those
01:28:16 things, and we have as well with other people.
01:28:19 But I think fundamentally,
01:28:20 the whole point of this show
01:28:22 if we could distill it down to one thing
01:28:24 is look Christians need to be thinking
01:28:26 about leveraging 0.95
01:28:27 sometimes it's going to be for guerrilla tactics
01:28:29 sometimes it's going to be all that warfare
01:28:31 we need to be thinking about how we use media
01:28:33 I think that there's a lot of people
01:28:36 that need to be making the long slow march
01:28:38 through the institutions 1.00
01:28:39 we've got Christians in the FBI 0.70
01:28:42 we've got Christians in the New York Times
01:28:44 and we do need them there 1.00
01:28:46 and we need parallel
01:28:49 outlets too. We want to be strategic. Yes. We want to be strategic. We want to operate as if
01:28:55 they should be scared of us, not the other way around. Too often Christians operate as if we 1.00
01:28:59 should be so scared of them. Well, this is what Chuck Knox said, right? The gospel is the contagion. 1.00
01:29:04 Yeah. Like we're going to get the cooties on us. No, no, no, no, no, no. They're going to get our
01:29:08 cooties on them. I mean, let me come up with something better. They're going to get the
01:29:12 contagion of the gospel is going to infect, and it is going to spread like leavened till it's all
01:29:17 leavened. That's what Jesus says the gospel of the kingdom is like, or the kingdom of God is like.
01:29:22 So be crafty as serpents and innocent as doves. So Paul wrote, greet those in Caesar's household.
01:29:29 Think about that. Caesar's household. Think about John the Baptist giving advice to the
01:29:34 tax collectors and the soldiers. Nero. By the way, Dan, you're doing church history. Who was 0.89
01:29:39 Caesar at that time? It was Nero. It was Nero. So when Paul was writing that in the household of
01:29:44 Caesar. There were Christians in Nero's house. In the beast of Revelation's house. Which is why 0.74
01:29:48 I have no qualms about Christians going and teaching in public schools subversively as long 1.00
01:29:52 as their kids aren't in them. It's a different ballgame. Different ballgame. Like, which is why 1.00
01:29:57 for us, strategically, we're going to pick certain things, you know, to the, especially as it's local
01:30:03 to me and I have opportunity, I'm going to bless Christians doing Christian things, even if it
01:30:06 costs me a little bit more, et cetera, when they're doing a good job, I'm going to say, yeah.
01:30:09 and i'm also without shame going to use an apple phone or computer or whatnot and i'm not going to
01:30:15 be scared of that because i'm going to use those tools i'm going to take that tool and i'm going
01:30:20 to use it to publish to the world the most app the content they are absolutely terrified of
01:30:25 so terrified of that they try to cancel it everywhere they get every gatekeeper's intent
01:30:30 on keeping us out and we're like we're there baby it's like buying a sword from the enemy
01:30:36 and then and then stabbing it you know hype you know censors we're actually not promoting violence
01:30:41 spiritually of course yeah the sword that comes from his mouth metaphorically speaking
01:30:45 yeah absolutely so so i think summing it up christian arts and media is a meet our mediums
01:30:51 by which we tell the truth yeah we tell the truth about what the world is like where it's gone wrong
01:30:56 and what the only thing that will change it and and wherein we aim to win the whole person
01:31:01 understanding who they are, how God created them, and also the means by which God has appointed for
01:31:08 people to be influenced, which is more than the mere transfer of information. It's also the
01:31:13 capturing of people's hearts through beauty and also through properly showing ugliness. 1.00
01:31:18 And so Christians ought to be in the business of excellently invading and creating media to 1.00
01:31:24 the glory of God, not just in these Christian ghettos, but in every aspect of what it means 0.99
01:31:29 to be human. I think that's a
01:31:31 phenomenal place to end. In the words of
01:31:33 Brian Sauvé, that was glorious.
01:31:35 Ooh, I like it. You know what, Eric?
01:31:36 In the words of Eric, not a Jew. 0.99
01:31:39 Oh, here we go. That's huge. 1.00
01:31:41 That's huge, Eric. Not a Jew. 1.00
01:31:43 And I would also say, we'd like to give a special 1.00
01:31:45 shout-out to our sponsors, Christendom
01:31:47 Bible College and
01:31:49 Reformation Heritage Books. We appreciate them.
01:31:51 A lot of sales running on Reformation Heritage Books.
01:31:53 Right now, they had a sale on the Puritans.
01:31:55 So definitely check that out, heritagebooks.org.
01:31:58 check that in the show notes
01:31:59 and be sure to support them
01:32:01 they're supporting us
01:32:02 and we really appreciate
01:32:03 that
01:32:04 until next time
01:32:05 gentlemen
01:32:06 Festa Nolente
01:32:07 make haste
01:32:09 slowly
01:32:09 Amen
01:32:10 Well in case you didn't know
01:32:22 we have another Kings Hall show
01:32:23 called The After Hours
01:32:25 and it's available
01:32:25 only to our patrons
01:32:27 We have a great time in the after hours.
01:32:29 I play hype songs, which Brian loves.
01:32:31 Sometimes we even talk about Brian's cut.
01:32:33 We talk about recent news on X and answer listener questions.
01:32:36 Overall, it's a great time.
01:32:37 So I'd encourage you to head over to patreon.com slash the King's Hall.
01:32:42 If you'd like to support the show and get some extra content.