The King's Hall - April 22, 2022


Eschatological Pessimism

Careful Christianity SPECIAL: Roe v. Wade

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 12 minutes

Words per minute

191.92

Word count

13,833

Sentence count

836


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00.000 Hey guys, Brian here with a big announcement from New Christendom Press.
00:00:03.860 Possibly our most important book yet is now available for pre-order.
00:00:08.300 It's called The Longhouse, How Feminism Conquered the West and Made Us All Miserable.
00:00:13.400 And in it, Eric and I take you through the dark history of feminism,
00:00:17.240 what it's done to everything from politics to church life to the economy,
00:00:21.220 and what to do about it.
00:00:23.040 Pre-order it today at newchristendompress.com slash longhouse.
00:00:26.600 and as a thank you for pre-ordering you'll get 10 off automatically we'll also be signing the
00:00:32.200 first thousand copies so pick yours up today when he opened the fourth seal i heard the voice of the
00:00:38.240 fourth living creature say come and i looked and behold a pale horse and its rider's name was death
00:00:45.060 and hades followed with him and they were given authority over a fourth of the earth
00:00:50.180 to kill with a sword and with famine and with pestilence and by wild beasts of the earth
00:00:55.780 Revelation chapter 6. The King's Hall podcast exists to make self-ruled men who rule well
00:01:03.080 and win the world. Well, welcome back to the King's Hall podcast. We are excited that you've
00:01:09.100 joined us here. As always, I'm here with my friend, Eric Kahn. Eric, say hi to the great
00:01:14.260 people listening. What's up, my peoples? Dan Burkholder, my brother. Scalant. What did you
00:01:19.960 Say it last time.
00:01:20.920 Scalant.
00:01:21.660 Scalant.
00:01:22.380 Scalant.
00:01:23.320 By the way, my wife listened and she said,
00:01:26.060 slantia technically means, I said cheers.
00:01:28.140 It means to health.
00:01:29.740 To health.
00:01:30.160 To health.
00:01:30.760 To health.
00:01:31.340 It also does not sound Scottish.
00:01:33.520 It's like Gesundheit.
00:01:34.440 I think it's Gaelic.
00:01:35.280 It's Gaelic.
00:01:36.620 Did you say Gaelic?
00:01:38.160 Oh, we're going to get a lot of emails from.
00:01:39.900 Okay.
00:01:40.360 You know what?
00:01:40.840 You know what?
00:01:41.280 This is already off to a great start, you guys.
00:01:42.820 Thanks for listening.
00:01:44.100 We are, in this episode, taking up a topic that really neatly ties into a lot of what
00:01:48.960 we've already covered here.
00:01:49.860 we've been talking in this season, as you already know, about building this great cathedral of
00:01:53.660 Christendom, looking to establishing the doctrinal and cultural distinctives that we believe
00:01:59.360 applied over time will result in the next Christendom. And so we've been clearing our
00:02:05.540 job site where this cathedral needs to go up of all sorts of shantytowns and models that
00:02:09.640 are in the way. Things like Big Fast and famous megachurchianity and all the other things we've
00:02:14.240 covered revivalism here. One of the through lines that cuts through quite a few of these shanty
00:02:20.500 towns is the topic of today's episode. Actually, you'll find that one of the dominant theological
00:02:26.800 through lines that runs through megachurchianity, modernly, that runs through some of the
00:02:31.320 fundamentalism that came out of the 20th century, that runs through revivalism, particularly out of
00:02:35.920 the 19th century, is an extraordinarily pessimistic view of eschatology. An extraordinarily pessimistic
00:02:44.120 view of eschatology, particularly dispensational premillennialism is kind of the big theological
00:02:52.020 category that you could put a lot of this under. And so later we'll make a distinction that we're
00:02:57.520 not talking about all premillennialists. We'll talk about how in a lot of ways it's actually
00:03:02.000 easier. And we found it easy to link arms with dispensationalists as co-belligerents on lots
00:03:07.080 of battlegrounds. And we want, if you're a premillennialist, we don't want you to turn
00:03:10.600 this episode off and be like, well, here you go. We don't want to straw man you. But we do want
00:03:15.460 to make this point that there is a particular kind of pessimism about the future and about
00:03:20.740 the story of the church and where we stand in it today that has functioned to really hinder
00:03:26.880 the growth and progress of the church that has caused us to actually jettison much of the
00:03:32.100 theological legacy that we've gotten from our spiritual forefathers, and that if consistently
00:03:36.780 applied would actually make you look back at the last Christendom with extreme skepticism and say
00:03:42.700 that certainly couldn't have been an actually Christian thing and definitely look forward to
00:03:47.260 the future and without any expectation of there being a future Christendom. And so if I may just
00:03:53.640 really quickly to frame this, give you a brief history, premillennialism from the early church
00:03:59.360 to today, and then tie it into this pessimism that we're rejecting. Then we'll explain why
00:04:04.520 and some of the implications of it. Premillennialism is not the majority view in church history. In
00:04:10.100 fact, there's not really, you could say, a particular dominant view through church history
00:04:14.700 of eschatology. There's a reason why this didn't end up in any of the creeds or confessions as an
00:04:19.740 explicit point, or any of the creeds, particularly in the early church. Premillennialism isn't a
00:04:24.300 majority view in church history. There's no trace of premillennialism, for example, in Clement of
00:04:29.340 Rome, Ignatius, or Polycarp, not in the Apostles' Creed. And in fact, the Apostles' Creed seems to
00:04:35.300 imply resurrection and life everlasting immediately follows the return of Christ to judge the quick
00:04:40.420 and the dead, not after a thousand-year period. But premillennialism rose in popularity in the
00:04:47.680 mid-second century, especially under the persecution of the church. And premillennialism is the idea
00:04:53.440 that history is going to end, essentially, with the return of Christ to the earth physically,
00:05:00.420 where he will establish a thousand-year kingdom, usually it's considered a literally thousand-year
00:05:05.620 kingdom, where he'll rule physically from Jerusalem in Israel, where people will still
00:05:11.520 be dying, people will still be getting married and giving birth, people will still be getting
00:05:15.920 saved in this period, but that during this period, post-return of Christ, there will be essentially
00:05:21.320 like a lot of what we're describing, a golden age, Christendom, you might say, where after the
00:05:26.760 return of Christ, you see a lot of what we're describing. The nations come, most people are
00:05:31.280 Christians, and then there's a final cataclysmic, upheaval, rebellion, followed by the final
00:05:38.120 judgment and the eternal state where death is killed forever. This view rose in popularity
00:05:43.600 in the mid-second century, especially when the church was still heavily influenced by the Jewish
00:05:50.120 faith. And this makes sense. I mean, the Jewish view of the coming of Messiah was much more in
00:05:55.380 alignment with this, that the Christ would come, he'd rule physically from Jerusalem, and that
00:05:59.900 most of the dominant politics would come out of Jerusalem, but it would still be in this part of
00:06:06.760 history. There would still be death and this sort of thing. This view faced stark opposition in the
00:06:11.200 third and fourth centuries of the church, and particularly by Augustine, it was almost a dead
00:06:16.740 idea as far as we can tell in doing the work of historical theology. By the time we get to the
00:06:22.820 reformers, Calvin's treatment of premillennialism is fairly representative of most reformational
00:06:28.840 treatments of this doctrine. He basically said it's too puerile to deserve refutation. He didn't
00:06:34.160 even really deal with it because nobody held it and nobody had held it for something like 1,200
00:06:38.640 years at that time. It started to come back into the fringes of the reformation stream of theology
00:06:45.620 with a group called the Fifth Monarchy Men of the Puritans, which is a very small group,
00:06:50.600 very, very small group. And finally, in the 1800s, we have a guy from the Presbyterian Church in
00:06:55.480 Scotland. His name is Edward Irving. You've probably never heard of Edward Irving. He was
00:07:00.120 influenced by the beginnings of something we've already talked about, the Second Great Awakening,
00:07:04.900 combined with a restoration or with the restoration in England and the politics of
00:07:10.560 England in the 1700s, this idea that things were going to get worse. And so he came up with this
00:07:17.300 idea that there was a decline in the church that was impending, and it was marking the imminent
00:07:22.940 return of Christ. And though he was pretty influential at this time, most folks haven't
00:07:27.720 heard of him, and he probably would have ended up a pretty forgotten footnote in the history of the
00:07:31.220 church, but for another man named John Nelson Darby. In the 1830s, John Nelson Darby became
00:07:36.780 the father of what's now known as dispensationalism. And he came up with this system of reading the
00:07:42.200 Bible, reading prophecy, reading the relationship between the Old and New Testament, between Israel
00:07:48.360 and the church. And he came up with this view that God had essentially governed history through
00:07:54.880 these seven dispensations. There's a lot more work you could read here and invented the doctrine
00:07:59.300 of dispensationalism. Before John Nelson Darby, the idea of something like a pre-tribulational
00:08:05.560 rapture, that the temple would be rebuilt, even ideas that things like the Levites and the
00:08:10.860 sacrifices would be reinstated in this thousand year reign. Those weren't really around until
00:08:15.720 the 1800s and didn't become popular, certainly until John Nelson Darby. Why are we telling you
00:08:20.460 all this? Well, we're telling you all this because one of the main features of this system
00:08:24.580 that Darby invented and that became extremely dominant, we'll talk about this, the Schofield
00:08:29.880 Bible later in the episode. One of the reasons that this matters is because a huge feature of
00:08:34.120 this was an extraordinary degree of pessimism about the future of the church. They believed
00:08:38.640 that the return of Christ was imminent. Any moment Christ was going to return, that there was going
00:08:43.900 to be a massive rebellion and upheaval, the Great Tribulation was going to happen. And so some of
00:08:48.880 the implications of this theological conviction led to things like a hesitance to build for the
00:08:55.680 long haul, a hesitance to do the work of establishing schools and thinking in terms
00:09:00.840 of a thousand generations and our children's children's children. Why? Well, because we
00:09:04.720 didn't really expect for them to be around for this. When you start believing in a dispensational,
00:09:11.000 I'm not even going to tackle the theology at the moment, just the worldview. You're a dispensational
00:09:16.660 premillennialist. You know things are going to go from bad to worse. Every event that happens then,
00:09:22.340 like you read the newspaper and something bad happens, you have confirmation bias. You say,
00:09:26.860 of course it would happen. Of course it's getting worse. Of course we have World War I.
00:09:31.660 And then we have World War II. The whole world is fighting. Atomic bombs are dropped. We find
00:09:37.120 out there are concentration camps. What's happening in Russia with the Cold War? There's
00:09:41.840 no lack of fodder to feed this idea of things steadily declining over time. And so the question
00:09:50.040 I have is, Brian, maybe you could answer this, this idea of decline. Is it actually true or is
00:09:56.100 it a myth? Is it a myth of decline? In 2023, Indigo Sundries became one of our sponsors. At
00:10:08.920 the time, their business was little more than a side hobby generating a couple hundred dollars
00:10:12.980 a month. But because of their partnership with us and because all of you chose to support them,
00:10:16.920 they've grown enough to make it their full-time livelihood. This is what happens when Christians
00:10:20.360 support Christians. Our communities are strengthened and faithful businesses thrive.
00:10:24.140 So if you're a Christian business owner who wants to reach thousands of like-minded people and grow your company, we'd love to partner with you.
00:10:30.720 Email us at advertising at newchristendompress.com.
00:10:38.940 Yeah, it is one of the central threads that you have to deal with in situating yourself in history.
00:10:44.040 I think that, to frame my answer a little bit, one of the issues with the church today is that most Christians don't really self-consciously stand in a historically rooted understanding of their place in history.
00:11:01.020 Things have changed more rapidly in the last 150 years for everybody than in the entire history of humanity combined before that, in many ways, technologically.
00:11:09.400 For much of history, you could say something like, I'm a farmer, like my father was, like his father was, like his father was, like his father was.
00:11:17.440 I'm an Anglican, like my father was, like his father was, like his father was.
00:11:20.840 You could even see the tracing of last names.
00:11:23.700 Yeah.
00:11:24.100 You know, like Cooper we were talking about, you made barrels.
00:11:26.600 Tighter vocation.
00:11:27.740 Yeah.
00:11:28.120 Right.
00:11:28.440 So that was how strongly situated people were in the historic stream.
00:11:33.180 and in many ways the technological advances of the post-industrial world have disrupted that
00:11:39.480 to such a degree that humanity is essentially rootless right now we don't really know where
00:11:44.100 we come from we don't know where we stand and some of that has made us tremendously vulnerable
00:11:49.260 bad readings of history to um novel ideas without knowing that they're novel like radically new
00:11:57.680 ideas without knowing that they're that they are new ideas that we're believing and just assuming
00:12:01.300 isn't this how everybody read the Bible? When you say reading history, what was that
00:12:06.740 that you said? Reading history. They don't know how to read history, where they stand in history,
00:12:10.780 the story of history. And so they start to read history. And I don't mean like read works of
00:12:16.300 history. I mean like think about the story of history, the story of humanity over the last
00:12:20.940 2,000 years or 4,000 years in ways that they don't realize that they're reading this book of history
00:12:26.940 in a way that is very new, and nobody really did. So one of these myths that I think is very
00:12:34.680 prevalent today, partially because of our own modern experiences and rootlessness and what I
00:12:38.780 just said, is this myth of decline, particularly with respect to the Christian church, that the
00:12:44.560 Christian church, the story of the Christian church is fundamentally a story of decline.
00:12:48.480 And you might see this from, through the lens of like, even how Tolkien describes the race of men
00:12:55.620 in Gondor. We kind of think of ourselves like that, where they had the Numenoreans, who were
00:12:59.360 these great lordly men who came from Numenor. They lived for hundreds of years. They were very
00:13:04.580 masterly men. They were very connected to the elves who were immortals. And then the story of
00:13:10.080 Numenor is basically the story of decline until you get to the men of Gondor who no longer live
00:13:13.960 very long. They've mingled with lesser men. And they basically are just like half-breed,
00:13:20.020 decrepit stock of much better forefathers. Well, we tend to think of ourselves like that. You hear
00:13:26.220 this narrative often in the church that what we need is to return to the early church. We need to
00:13:31.960 get back to the early church, to the purity and power of the early church. And a lot of that,
00:13:36.500 they don't understand that the early church was infant and toddler phase of the church,
00:13:41.000 that we've made good progress since then. The early church, the 40 years between the
00:13:45.340 resurrection of Christ and the destruction of Jerusalem, saw one of the greatest apostasies
00:13:49.020 in the history of church. Some of the greatest, in fact, nearly every great heresy finds its
00:13:54.680 origin in that era of the church. And they repeat, they come back in different guises and under
00:14:00.860 different faces, Gnosticism, Judaizing, Stoicism, all sorts of Greek and Roman philosophies
00:14:07.140 syncretizing with Christianity, Hebrew errors shrinking back to Jerusalem and the law.
00:14:12.080 These things come out through history. The early church was battling them in massive ways. We saw
00:14:17.400 huge apostasies. Paul writes, well, I said Paul. I just gave you my position. Whoever wrote the
00:14:23.160 book of Hebrews writes basically to protect this Hebrew church from shrinking back to Jerusalem,
00:14:29.040 going back to the heirs of Judaism, and re-embracing the temple. He's like, don't shrink
00:14:34.100 back and be destroyed. Literally, God's going to nuke Jerusalem. Instead, press on, press forward,
00:14:39.460 stay in the church, don't go back. A lot of Christians today, when they think about where
00:14:44.460 they are in the church. They think of themselves like the men of Gondor when Aragorn shows up
00:14:48.420 in the Lord of the Rings. They think we're at the tail end of 2000 years of decline when the actual
00:14:54.220 facts of history do not bear witness to that narrative. Yeah. And we're not giving a deep
00:15:01.660 theological scriptural treatment of why dispensationalism or even amillennialism is
00:15:08.520 incorrect yeah that's not the goal of the show no so so yeah don't expect like a lot of biblical
00:15:14.040 this isn't a bible study we have other works yeah brian did a sunday school class on this
00:15:19.020 on eschatology that's that's really helpful uh refuge utah or refuge what is our website
00:15:24.340 refuge utah.org and and i do in a moment i want to return to some of the early roots of
00:15:30.240 premillennialism and then the story of of the eschatological development the historical
00:15:35.040 theology of eschatology think is important to this conversation. Maybe we could return to that
00:15:38.560 in a moment. But thinking about that narrative of decline versus progress, most Christians
00:15:45.100 find it shocking to hear that the story of the first four centuries of the church
00:15:52.300 was a story of massive conquest. Massive conquest. I mean, there's a chart. This was published in
00:15:59.780 Christianity today, by the way. This isn't some super post-mill insider baseball chart.
00:16:06.840 In the year 100, we're estimating the population of Christianity, again, as a percentage of Rome,
00:16:12.880 Rome's empire's population. In the year 100, so the church has been established for about 70 years
00:16:17.880 since Christ's crucifixion, estimated that there's just under 10,000 Christians at some point around
00:16:25.080 there, maybe 0.01% of the population of Rome is Christian. By 150, we have tens of thousands
00:16:33.160 of Christians. So 50 years later, which is still 0.07% of the population of Rome, less than 1%.
00:16:39.380 By 200, that has gone up by more than 5x, and we have a couple hundred thousand Christians. And
00:16:45.600 this is now a whopping third of a percent of Rome is Christian. So that's the progress of the church
00:16:50.640 for the first, I don't know, 150 years.
00:16:53.160 By 250, we go up by what?
00:16:56.060 What is this?
00:16:56.560 Over 5X again.
00:16:58.100 Over a million Christians now.
00:16:59.840 Nearly 2% of the population.
00:17:01.800 Massive jump.
00:17:02.620 Now you're talking about exponential growth.
00:17:04.600 Exponential growth.
00:17:05.360 So this growth curve is crazy.
00:17:07.340 By 300, it's 5X again,
00:17:09.440 and there's more than 6 million Christians,
00:17:10.860 which is now 10% plus of the population of Rome.
00:17:14.380 Now this is the craziest jump,
00:17:15.920 and some of you know the historical roots
00:17:17.360 of the guy named Constantine
00:17:18.280 and some of the things that happen in the next 50 years.
00:17:20.640 By the time you hit the year 350 and beyond, now you've surpassed something like 30 plus
00:17:26.940 million Christians, and more than half of the Roman Empire professes Christ as Lord.
00:17:31.840 And now I'm not trying to read how many of those people were regenerate.
00:17:35.840 You know, obviously, it'd be difficult to get regeneration statistics.
00:17:40.360 It's difficult enough in any modern church, much less historical.
00:17:45.000 So 350 years, we see Rome go from 0.1%,
00:17:49.280 one hundredth of one percent of the population
00:17:51.240 within the first generation or two of the Christian church being founded
00:17:54.280 to more than half of the population professing Christ as Lord.
00:17:58.840 And guys, it continues.
00:18:00.960 If you follow the world Christian population
00:18:04.820 against the world population chart for the last 2,000 years,
00:18:08.480 even projected into the future,
00:18:10.160 one of the charts I'm looking at right now,
00:18:11.760 you see that this blue line on the chart I'm looking at goes up. It's the population of
00:18:17.840 the Christian population. And then there's a green line that's the population of the world.
00:18:22.620 And both of them go up exponentially until you get to the point where today, even more than
00:18:28.280 2 billion people profess to worship Christ as Lord. And so this idea that Christianity has
00:18:37.840 been a story of decline from its founding where we had the purity and power of the early church
00:18:42.200 that has declined like the Numenoreans down to this time where we're just lesser sires
00:18:47.120 of lesser, you know, we're lesser sons of greater sires, is a tremendously misleading reading of
00:18:54.140 history. And it's not the way that Christians would have read history until at least the 19th
00:19:00.340 century. This episode of the King's Hall podcast is brought to you by our sponsor,
00:19:05.520 Reformation Heritage Books. And this is a sponsor that we are very glad to partner with
00:19:10.660 in this. And let me explain why we're so excited to partner with them.
00:19:15.080 If you're going to see the new Christendom go up, you're going to need a lot of theologically
00:19:18.740 robust resources that specifically come out of the great river of Reformed theology. And these
00:19:24.840 guys have it. They've got great works that cover everything from really high theology to devotional
00:19:30.040 literature, marriage and family, history and biography, and more. They have titles from
00:19:36.300 Banner of Truth, PNR, all sorts of great resources. We believe that if you head to
00:19:41.700 their website, heritagebooks.org, that you'll find something for just about everybody who's
00:19:47.020 listening here, whether you're a theology nerd with a really well-stocked bookshelf or you're
00:19:51.600 a mom just looking for something to read to the kids during breaks on homeschooling. There's
00:19:56.520 something for everybody here. Our family has benefited tremendously from several of their
00:20:01.600 works, and we'll talk about those in future episodes as well. But we'd encourage you to
00:20:06.140 head to heritagebooks.org, scroll around, find something for yourself today. We're glad to
00:20:11.420 partner with these guys, and we would want you to actually help support the show by supporting them.
00:20:16.820 They've been really generous in helping us, and so we'd encourage you to do that. Head to
00:20:21.560 heritagebooks.org or see the link in the show notes and pick up a book for yourself or your
00:20:27.820 family today. Can you imagine how incoherent it would be to a Christian in Central Europe
00:20:33.280 in 1650 to go up and say, yeah, Christianity is basically a loser religion. Hardly anybody's
00:20:38.440 Christian. No, everybody. They would have been like, actually, everybody is Christian.
00:20:41.980 Everyone, because we burn the atheists. And by the way, this is not just Europe. You can do this
00:20:47.000 Egypt. Until Islam takes over radically in the last couple hundred years. Yeah, Asia Minor.
00:20:52.580 Asia Minor. Today, Africa, I have another chart that traces percentage of the world's Christians
00:20:57.080 in each continent. Africa is going up tremendously. It's over 50% today, while other nations stagnate
00:21:02.620 and decline even. You see nations like Africa with lots of the world's population radically
00:21:07.040 increasing. Asia, South America. And so I'm curious. I think it's an interesting question.
00:21:13.880 is that it's just a question why if you ask the american christian how are we doing most of them
00:21:19.680 would be like oh well any day now and i think a lot of it is so you have a couple factors one
00:21:25.100 is dispensationalism but you also have things like communism yeah so the the desire to undermine
00:21:30.760 everything that the west is built on you know i was thinking of a book uh that i read somebody
00:21:36.120 had recommended i read this maybe five or seven years ago but it's called how christianity changed
00:21:40.600 the world by alvin schmidt i've heard of this book i've read it yeah it's fantastic book but
00:21:45.320 really what it goes through is like what we don't give credit to is all the ways in which christianity
00:21:49.900 really did shape the world today that we just don't recognize right so things like hospitals
00:21:54.120 well the hospitalers were a basically like a monastery type part of the church that was our
00:21:59.560 that was our thing yeah you're welcome and they were like oh well we need to show charity so long
00:22:03.860 before there was a welfare state the church was saying that's our responsibility yeah you're
00:22:08.060 welcome pagans that was our thing um the treatment of women uh drastically you're welcome feminists
00:22:13.120 went up with christianity and so i think today we live in such an age where you know we're
00:22:17.760 deconstructionist which is a violation of the fifth commandment that's right we want to tear
00:22:21.700 down everything that our fathers built i was reading robert bly on this subject and he said
00:22:26.080 deconstruction this is early 90s but robert bly said deconstruction is like taking the handmade
00:22:31.400 guitars our great great grandfathers built for us and spent 50 years building and just smashing
00:22:36.240 them against the wall or even worse putting justed bieber stickers on them where's the where's the
00:22:41.960 throw up sound effect oh my gosh what do i do yeah i need to work on that one so i think a lot of it
00:22:49.880 is that's the zeitgeist of our culture is to hate our fathers that's right it's to hate everything
00:22:54.400 that they built we sort of have this notion that i was listening to a podcast and i'd love to find
00:22:59.600 it if i could again but but i i was road tripping i was listening to a podcast with jordan peterson
00:23:03.940 And he's talking to a very elite Harvard scholar, right?
00:23:07.620 And the guy said, well, look, Christianity's been bad for the world.
00:23:10.560 It's been wicked.
00:23:11.340 And Jordan said, well, let me just cut in here.
00:23:13.820 He goes, you're flat wrong.
00:23:15.380 Yeah, first of all.
00:23:16.060 And Jordan, at this time, was like an avowed atheist.
00:23:18.800 But he was like, you can't look at the facts of history and say that Christianity has done more harm than good.
00:23:24.360 It's, in fact, the opposite.
00:23:26.280 And even now, like you look at the world, the Western Christianized, colonized world.
00:23:31.160 Were there evils?
00:23:31.980 Yes.
00:23:32.420 Yeah.
00:23:32.640 And we don't support those evils.
00:23:33.920 Of course not.
00:23:34.480 On the whole, Christendom has been a marvelous thing for culture.
00:23:38.240 It's like, would you rather, ask any feminists,
00:23:40.680 would you rather live in a world that is dominated,
00:23:43.240 in a culture that has been dominated for several centuries,
00:23:45.620 by Islam, by Hinduism, or by Christianity?
00:23:48.980 Or by secularism?
00:23:50.180 Yeah, what is it like to live in Delhi right now?
00:23:52.120 Yeah, guess how women and children are doing in Delhi.
00:23:54.920 Not so good.
00:23:55.500 Guess how the economy is doing in Delhi.
00:23:57.420 Guess how women and children are doing in Saudi Arabia or in Iran.
00:24:01.320 Yeah, but like the Native Americans in America, they were such peace-loving.
00:24:04.340 Oh, yeah.
00:24:04.680 Would you, like my people?
00:24:07.220 Would you rather, like, would you like to live?
00:24:10.300 I was trying to, that was a softball for Brian.
00:24:12.980 I forgot the word for vision quest in Ojibwe, but that's a great point.
00:24:18.260 Like we have this, or Columbus coming to, you know, or the Spanish conquistadors coming
00:24:23.340 and they find these South American cultures that are dripping with blood.
00:24:27.280 They're almost as bad as we are.
00:24:29.460 The human sacrifice is untold. But I think, too, the other thing I just want to interject is when you look at this, so the church is in retreat mode because we believe in this vision of decline. And so to summarize everything to Dan's question, is there a myth of decline? Summarize everything we've said. And Brian said the answer is yes. Yes.
00:24:47.400 but then you look at it and you're like okay biggest problem why is the left why are the
00:24:52.020 pagans winning because they believe in the infinite progress of evolutionary theory
00:24:56.000 they're they're sitting there believing that the state will transform the world
00:24:59.600 believing it they go and they do yep christians are sitting on their hands saying well we lose
00:25:04.140 anyway so what does it matter yeah look at look at the uh transhumanist liberal post-millennialism
00:25:11.160 for lack of a better words and dominion theology of someone like elon musk who believes that we
00:25:15.060 are going to successfully link human beings to technology such that we might even be able to
00:25:19.540 achieve something akin to immortality that we're arc of the beast chip in the head yeah continue
00:25:24.000 that we're going to become uh an interplanetary species this is his whole point of spacex it's
00:25:28.860 all about ai artificial intelligence plus neural link technology plus interplanetary
00:25:33.220 humanity plus evolution equals an enlightened basically a a dominionist mentality of human
00:25:38.700 history so the liberals playing for keeps and they're not dispensate they're not they don't
00:25:43.440 have a myth of decline they really believe they're going to win even the lgbtq alphabet i mean that
00:25:48.640 they made such a small minority of the u.s population and they've been radically successful
00:25:54.960 in pushing their agenda because they think they're going to win and they are winning
00:25:59.080 yeah and a lot of this i think is is fundamental so the you know dispensationalism is part of this
00:26:04.700 you know marxism critical race theory all of it but it all comes back to the practical issue of
00:26:10.340 what do you do with your kids so the left for a long time since the at least the 50s said we're
00:26:15.720 going to make a long slow march through the institutions and we're just going to relentlessly
00:26:19.740 teach these things meanwhile i think as christians we were pretty much seeding the ground there were
00:26:24.600 some fights along the way it would be you know we've been seeding the ground on it yeah and so
00:26:29.160 this is why i think in in our day there's actually been a revival of post-mill thought part of it i
00:26:34.660 do think dan is because we see the way the left is going hard in the paint we see that but we also
00:26:40.260 So, Brian, you mentioned this earlier, maybe we should talk about some of the historical roots.
00:26:45.280 Definitely.
00:26:46.280 Everything in modern history, it comes back to historical revisionism versus real history.
00:26:51.460 Yeah.
00:26:52.120 A great book on this is Ken Gentry, He Shall Have Dominion.
00:26:55.660 And he traces the historical roots.
00:26:57.720 And a couple points I would make.
00:26:58.780 Number one, dispensationalists claim, like many people, well, we're the true vision.
00:27:04.440 We're the true ideal from the beginning.
00:27:07.560 And Gentry goes through and he's like, that's actually just a lie.
00:27:10.260 that that's not true at all and he he cites resources and stuff like that so that's really
00:27:15.120 important but the other thing historically i think is really important we're huge on postmill
00:27:19.740 we love it however even gentry who's making the case for postmill theology says there's a reason
00:27:26.240 eschatology was never part of the creeds because it was not something that that the early church
00:27:31.080 believed was essential to orthodoxy and therefore that we should divide over i feel like that's an
00:27:36.600 important thing to Brian's point of, hey, we can link arms with pre-mill, historic pre-mill guys,
00:27:41.180 A-mill. Absolutely. And we can push the ball for it. That's great. Even if you're dispensationalist
00:27:45.980 and you're like, look, I'm convinced my hermeneutic, a lot of this has to do with your
00:27:50.140 hermeneutics. How do you read prophecy? How do you interpret scripture? And you say, look,
00:27:54.960 I'm still convinced of the system of dispensationalism. And yet I believe in the
00:27:59.840 moral imperative of Christians to behave as if post-millennialism is true. I've heard people
00:28:04.060 say this. To that person, I would say, hey, let's grab a beer and talk about your hermeneutic,
00:28:10.840 and let's talk about scriptures. Let's open some passages. But I would also want to say,
00:28:14.920 yeah, brother, let's build together. Let's go. In our church, we have, just for the record,
00:28:19.920 in our membership, and certainly in attendance, we have dispensational premillennialists,
00:28:24.280 probably more historic premillennialists, some leaky disbies, probably like MacArthur.
00:28:29.560 We've got amillennialists who are optimistic and pessimistic, and we've got postmillennialists
00:28:33.880 who are of various stripes. So it's like, we get along and we build together.
00:28:38.160 Yeah. And it's funny because I know that predominantly American Christians are
00:28:42.500 dispensationalists. And so this is anecdotal. So take it for what it's worth. In my experience,
00:28:48.980 it's been easier to link arms with you dispensationalists than it even has been to
00:28:54.080 those that are essentially a subset of post-millennialism with all millennialists.
00:28:58.900 and particularly particularly those of a like a modern two kingdoms sort of over spiritualization
00:29:06.860 of everything all the old testament readings and and everything that would say that post
00:29:12.820 millennialism is an over-realized eschatology and you're actually doing harm whereas right
00:29:18.460 whereas the dispensationalist is like hey i'm not sure about where you guys are coming from
00:29:23.300 i think we're gonna lose but i mean i want to fight with you guys like i'm on your your side
00:29:28.080 And so even though those two theological viewpoints of the end times seem to be polar opposites, in my experience, it has been easier to link arms with you dispensationalists than it has been to the all-male guys.
00:29:41.180 So I would say all-male guys, just be a little bit more friendly.
00:29:43.820 Yeah, a certain stripe for sure. A certain stripe that has, like we've made some criticisms of certain forms of radical two kingdom theory and things like that, that would relegate much of human life to the common kingdom that's not governed or regulated by scripture in the same way.
00:29:58.520 And so it's actually actively harmful, they would say, to attempt to get Christians, Christians and non-Christians, to obey Christ in these areas.
00:30:08.160 And that to me is, I think, Dan, that's a great point.
00:30:11.400 That's actually much harder to link arms with than the dispensationalist who says, yeah, I think the Antichrist is going to show up any minute.
00:30:17.740 But in the meantime, he's going to find, when I get raptured, I'm going to get raptured with a trowel in one hand and a sword in the other.
00:30:24.000 And that guy, I go, amen, brother.
00:30:26.420 Let's put some bricks in the wall.
00:30:28.520 And if your clothes drop to the floor and your rat, your trowel rattles on the, on the stones
00:30:34.320 and I'm still standing there, then I'll start praying really hard and repenting because
00:30:39.200 apparently every, every nineties kids were straight at the risk of being a flatterer
00:30:46.000 to the disbies, which is really strange.
00:30:48.140 Wow.
00:30:48.900 But there is a laudable characteristic that is, that was a keynote or like a defining
00:30:54.580 characteristic of dispensationalism.
00:30:56.200 And that was a desire to read the scriptures literally, saturated in the scriptures. And I think it gets wrong, the reading of prophecy and all of that. But I will say it makes it a lot easier to partner with someone who takes the Bible very seriously, even if I think that at the core, the way that they're reading the scriptures is not necessarily the most faithful to the text as a whole.
00:31:20.020 But I will say that I definitely respect that. But you can see, as I tie it back to the fundamentalist movement, during that same time period, the literal reading, the high view of Scripture, the inerrancy of Scripture, where you could see this took root.
00:31:34.880 As far as the myth of decline, you can see where Christianity has really lost a lot of ground in the 19th century. And actually, some of the most horrible human atrocities of mass scale happened during that same time period, which gave it a lot of footing.
00:31:54.580 But in a way, you could even say that it was amplified by the retreat of Christianity from things like schools.
00:32:02.580 You know, people have essentially relegated their children to being taught by pagans and instructed by pagans because you're going to lose anyway.
00:32:11.520 You know, so maybe that's not a fair characteristic or criticism, but I wanted to, you know, make a sandwich that where I complimented and then I gave a critique.
00:32:19.780 And then you ended with a compliment.
00:32:21.080 Yeah. And I like you guys.
00:32:22.700 There's the last one.
00:32:24.920 Winsome and nuance.
00:32:25.900 I love that.
00:32:26.560 One of the things that I want to say, this is just from a business perspective.
00:32:30.560 One of the things that I've realized is there's people, like if you're a good business leader,
00:32:35.000 if you have vision and resources and you start building, people will come.
00:32:40.300 Like, you know, this is the old field of dreams thing, like build it and they will come.
00:32:44.020 Well, I'm kind of saying like if you have vision and resources, and listen, if God is the one
00:32:47.520 doing the building, be about the work and people will flock to it.
00:32:50.440 Because one of the things about this is we've gotten so hyper-rationalistic in our culture
00:32:55.280 where we're like, oh, everybody is operating on a very precise eschatological viewpoint.
00:33:01.340 And the reality is they're not.
00:33:02.740 When you see cultural momentum happening, it's magnetic and you want to be a part of it.
00:33:07.420 And so I would just encourage people as leaders, just start building, just start praying,
00:33:11.640 just start asking God to bless the building and people show up and come.
00:33:15.440 And what you'll find is there's a lot of people on your team that you wouldn't have thought
00:33:18.420 would have been on your team.
00:33:19.300 That's right.
00:33:19.660 There's guys that listen to this podcast, the Hard Men podcast.
00:33:22.840 We'll talk about building culture, and they're like, yes and amen, and then I'll come to
00:33:26.620 find out they're hardcore, fundy Baptist disbies.
00:33:29.460 And I'm like, you know what?
00:33:30.240 Praise God.
00:33:31.000 They want to build.
00:33:31.800 They're excited about the building.
00:33:33.020 Let's do it.
00:33:33.500 Yeah, that's right.
00:33:34.080 I think there's a theological eggheadery that can go on and operate, particularly in those
00:33:39.980 who are influential in the church, pastor types.
00:33:42.620 Because pastor types tend to be passionate about theology and theological precision,
00:33:46.780 And so they can actually come to believe they get enough theological precision, everything will
00:33:51.940 follow. And that's not actually the case. In fact, you can have all prophetic powers and have all
00:33:56.940 knowledge, but if you have not love you, it's worthless. So right there in principle, knowledge
00:34:00.800 is not enough. Theological precision is not enough. You actually have to win people to a holistic,
00:34:07.120 totalizing view of humanity and demonstrate that to them. And then they'll come. And a lot of times
00:34:12.340 what we've seen is that rather than trying to lead them by convincing their mind first,
00:34:17.740 exact theological positions, and obviously correct error, heresy, that sort of thing,
00:34:22.140 I'm not talking about, I'm talking about intramural debates. If you just say, whatever
00:34:25.780 your eschatology, can we agree that our goal is to make disciples of the nations and teach them to
00:34:31.120 obey all that Jesus commanded? Now, let's put aside the question of how successful we expect
00:34:34.760 to be. It's like, let's put aside the question of how successful we think we're going to be in
00:34:38.480 cleaning the room. Do we all agree that mom told us to clean our room? Okay, yes. Well,
00:34:42.360 why don't we start putting the toys away? It's a really terrible analogy. But you know what I mean?
00:34:46.340 You know what I mean? Get to work. Get to work. And what will happen, I think, is that you start
00:34:51.740 to see that sometimes the theological understanding follows, follows the hands and follows the feet
00:34:57.580 instead of the other way around. Yeah. So maybe you guys could kind of paint a little bit of a
00:35:01.600 picture. I don't want to overstep the subject matter of the podcast, but what changes when
00:35:06.600 you have an optimistic theology? What does the landscape look like? So then we can kind of back
00:35:11.080 up then and say, why is this pessimistic view actually harmful? Yeah, I think it's given me
00:35:15.800 a different view. Number one of things like education for children, but thinking about
00:35:19.540 education in terms of like a legacy project, because really when you think about it, I had,
00:35:23.940 you know, very like I was like 18. It wasn't helpful. I was reading like Kant and Nietzsche
00:35:28.540 and I was like, man, this like this is really depressing. And, you know, this is pre-Christian.
00:35:33.400 Why am I sad all the time?
00:35:34.200 Yeah. Why am I sad all the time? Like you kind of have this like suicidal nihilism and you start
00:35:38.440 looking at things and you're like, well, I'm really not actually going to live very long.
00:35:41.620 And what could actually be accomplished in my lifetime? Well, actually not very much.
00:35:45.180 And so I started thinking about that, but then like adjacent to it, I saw these guys in
00:35:50.220 Christendom, people like Doug Wilson, who were like, they see the same realities, but they're
00:35:54.100 building fearlessly. And the culture that came out of their camp was like joy, right? They're not
00:35:59.100 like stodgy angry grumpy people like you know you you read like the vice article about doug wilson
00:36:04.340 you're like man he must just be like a human piece of trash a rage monster yeah like angry
00:36:08.460 all the time then you meet doug and you're like why is this guy so jovial like grandpa and why
00:36:12.780 is he so happy and also behind closed doors you meet people that because because there's like a
00:36:17.160 you see mark driscoll's an example yeah someone who on stage is very funny and magnetic and you
00:36:23.280 know sometimes very angry looking but behind closed doors testimony of men who served with
00:36:28.760 him was a lot of the time he was a rage monster. It was my way or the highway, instant rage. Do
00:36:33.780 what I say. Doug's not like that. People who serve with him are like, no, he's jovial. He
00:36:38.380 chuckles a lot. Humble guy. Yeah. That's actually a pretty common trait with, you see it in the
00:36:42.500 business world, but with visionaries, they're typically pretty controlling. A lot of times
00:36:46.940 not well organized. And so when that guy finds his way into a church, like Mark, yeah, you're
00:36:50.280 going to get that. So I think that was a big part of it, connecting like children, rearing, legacy,
00:36:54.400 having actually a hope that goes beyond just my lifetime.
00:36:59.260 Because I think one of the things you have to face with all of this eschatology
00:37:02.060 is how do you fulfill, if you believe in the Abrahamic promise,
00:37:05.740 which is going through Christ to this day, to a thousand generations,
00:37:09.420 Dan prays for that.
00:37:10.860 You know, every time we eat, we pray for our children to a thousand generations.
00:37:14.300 But if you believe that, like who's guiding history?
00:37:17.320 Who's working this thing out?
00:37:18.740 Well, my hope's in God.
00:37:19.660 It's not ultimately in me.
00:37:21.240 So then that starts being, I mean, that just totally grounds you
00:37:23.820 a different way in the way that you would educate your children. Yeah. It's like, if you really
00:37:28.760 believe that the Great Commission will be successful, and the Great Commission has two
00:37:33.560 basic parts, conversion and baptizing, this entrance into the church, and discipleship,
00:37:40.200 teaching them to obey all that Christ commanded to the nations. When you believe that that will
00:37:44.640 be successful and that the nations will stream to Mount Zion for instruction in God's law, Isaiah 2,
00:37:49.560 When you believe that, when you believe Psalm 22, 27, and 28, that all the families of the earth will turn to the Lord, when you believe Psalm 2, that as for me, I have set my king on the throne, and he will ask for the nations as his heritage, and I will give them to him.
00:38:06.040 When you believe that, then you actually have to have something to say about every aspect of human life.
00:38:14.480 Because if you really believe that all of that is going to happen in history and you believe that that's the case, then you also have to believe that, well, we're going to have to disciple all these people to figure out things like politics, economics, arts, music, agriculture, city planning.
00:38:31.520 because we're going to have a lot of Christians, and they're going to have to know what to do
00:38:35.020 about all these different areas of life. And so it really does change your mindset from
00:38:39.140 a fundamentally dispensational mindset. Essentially, what we're trying to do is
00:38:44.700 convince people to get on the helicopter that's leaving the roof in Saigon, in Vietnam.
00:38:51.560 Not Saigon. In Vietnam. The last helicopter out before the Viet Cong stormed the compound.
00:38:57.200 Get on the helicopter. Get on the helicopter. Get on the helicopter. No one's really worried about
00:39:01.240 education that much. You're not like, you know, you should really have a theory. You should really
00:39:05.420 have a philosophy and theology of the education of children. They're like the Viet Cong are coming,
00:39:10.200 get on the helicopter. And so you're going to be obsessed with evangelism only. You're going to be
00:39:14.780 extremely imbalanced in that. And you're not going to be thinking as much about covenant
00:39:19.140 succession in the normative means of families, tribes, nations, instruction. You know, you
00:39:23.740 actually have to have something to say. Yeah. And I think I was talking to a friend about this the
00:39:27.260 other day. So his dad, mom and dad were missionaries in China. And so he grew up in that world. Him and
00:39:34.940 his brother, I said, well, what was your childhood like? And he said, literally, my brother and I
00:39:38.860 are doing lines of cocaine on the table and we're fornicating, we're doing all this. And my parents
00:39:44.000 are missionaries to China. I asked him, what was that environment like? And he said, well, my
00:39:49.460 parents were godly, devout people, but their focus was clearly outside of the home. And so a lot of
00:39:55.360 times like these missionary kids would be left in the states to like be raised by somebody else
00:39:59.380 yeah so i think that's one element of it because if you think hey the helicopters are coming we
00:40:04.140 need to get everybody we can to the top of the building you're not thinking long term about your
00:40:08.020 children i've gotten them to pray the sinner's prayer and they've been baptized and so they're
00:40:12.380 good i'm gonna move on their eternity is secure that yeah there's the rest of this life that
00:40:16.340 they're gonna but you know once saved always saved so they're fine we got to get people on
00:40:20.300 the helicopter yeah yeah and absolutely i mean the one thing you'll never get out of a culture
00:40:24.200 like that is culture well you get a culture but it's not a self-replicating yeah yeah you know
00:40:30.640 robust culture durable it's a culture that's one generation it fizzes it gets one then it's gone
00:40:35.940 because those children are vulnerable to the discipleship of somebody with a radical long-term
00:40:40.100 post-millennial type view which is right now currently ascendant secular humanists yeah and
00:40:44.540 there definitely are periods like that you can think of people who are like you know bent on
00:40:48.420 surviving the holocaust and and so you're in survival mode yeah and you find your way out
00:40:53.040 Well, it's like the whole point of survival is so that you can go and build a culture once you've gotten out of that situation.
00:40:58.380 This is something like Jordan Peterson has talked about.
00:41:00.520 He said one of the problems with evolutionary theory is we're looking at humans in a survival situation as that's the best of humanity.
00:41:08.320 And in really a survival situation, that's kind of like humanity at its worst.
00:41:12.400 That's where you see the worst parts of people.
00:41:14.900 And again, I would say this is the beauty of Western Christendom.
00:41:17.380 Like we've built a culture where you have, in the Greek sense, leisure.
00:41:21.120 You know, you have time to do art and be creative and think about the music.
00:41:25.780 The flowering of humanity.
00:41:27.140 Yeah, if literally like all our pastors are being put in jail and we're being shot in the streets, we're probably less concerned with psalm writing or have time for it.
00:41:35.120 Or oil painting.
00:41:36.000 Yes.
00:41:36.400 Or cathedral building, right?
00:41:38.780 So, Dan, you asked what changes in your worldview would an optimistic versus pessimistic eschatology produce.
00:41:46.360 And I think one of the things that we're circling around here a lot that's essential to this is that if you actually have an optimistic eschatology, you will believe in the normativity of progress through covenant succession in families, tribes, and nations.
00:42:02.900 And I'll explain what I mean, and then I want you guys' thoughts to see, is this true or not?
00:42:05.740 So when I say covenant succession, I mean that one of the means through which God has appointed for the covenant to continue being handed on is not just evangelism, but it's also very blue-collar normal things like having children, raising them to be Christians, teaching them how to be humans in all aspects of life, the paideia, new thesia of the Lord, to use Paul's terminology in Ephesians 6, and that you actually expect for that to work.
00:42:29.480 Like you have kids with the expectation. God intends to say this because he said he loves to show his faithfulness to a thousand generations, to those who love him. He said, raise a child up in the way you should go. And then when they're old, they won't depart from it. And even though that's a proverb and we want to qualify it to death until it actually means raise your child up in the way that he should go. And there's a good chance. Flip, you know, flip a coin. That's not what it means, right? If that passage means anything, it doesn't mean that.
00:42:50.920 So when you have an optimistic eschatology, one of the things that follows is that you don't necessarily just have this glorious view of charging the gate as like this battle mentality.
00:43:03.060 You also come with a plodding God working through normative, boring means over long periods of time through ordinary things like the family, tribes, nations, culture, politics, all that kind of stuff.
00:43:14.860 Yeah. And I've heard this argument from atheists and maybe you guys have heard this before. It's like, you wouldn't be a Christian if you weren't born a Christian, if you weren't born into this house or into America. And a lot of times you have the heads, you know, like, oh, I don't backpedal. Oh man, they got caught out. No, the answer is yes. Yeah. God meant it. Yeah. If I was born in the Middle East to an Islamic family, I would not be Christian. And God has blessed me in that.
00:43:41.700 Yeah, it's like saying you would not be a fruitful apple tree branch on this apple tree if it wasn't for the stump.
00:43:48.660 And you're like, well, you see the roots and the apple tree that was planted there.
00:43:53.140 When the apple tree fell down from the tree and the seeds went into the ground, it grew another apple tree.
00:43:57.820 And it's like, I do think that's one of the problems in a lot of the dyspe type, that type of, we've called it loser eschatology.
00:44:07.140 But it's one of the problems.
00:44:08.940 Ouch is right.
00:44:09.680 If you have to start over every generation and you don't genuinely believe that God is actually going to do something through your children, it makes the work like monumentally harder than I think it needs to be in what scripture commends to us.
00:44:23.460 So one quote I was thinking of was Herman Bavink, and he said,
00:44:26.960 The covenant of grace does not randomly jump to and from one individual to the next, but is maintained through families, generations, and nations in an organic fashion.
00:44:37.400 Yes, that's exactly what I'm talking about.
00:44:39.100 Yes.
00:44:39.860 Yes to Bavink.
00:44:40.460 Well, Bavink said it.
00:44:41.100 He said it better.
00:44:41.880 I didn't even know Bavink had said it.
00:44:43.660 So there you go.
00:44:45.080 Me and Bavink, we're on the same wavelength.
00:44:47.000 So let's compare that.
00:44:48.360 I have another one from Hal Lindsey here.
00:44:50.680 Okay, I'm ready.
00:44:51.700 I'm ready for the pain, Eric.
00:44:53.580 I'm ready to get hurt again.
00:44:55.000 The anti-Bavink.
00:44:56.200 But he says, we should be living, Dan.
00:44:58.120 We should be living like persons who don't expect to be around much longer.
00:45:02.520 And my question to that quote is, I actually think that's how most Christians live.
00:45:06.080 Did he have advanced like diabetes or something?
00:45:08.020 I don't know.
00:45:09.100 Do you have heart disease?
00:45:09.940 I don't know.
00:45:10.380 With rough living in my diet, it might be true.
00:45:14.040 But it's funny.
00:45:14.960 He meant to universalize that principle.
00:45:16.820 Everybody should be living this way.
00:45:18.260 All Christians.
00:45:19.540 Yeah, I want to contrast it with what I think has been really helpful for me with having
00:45:24.120 an optimistic eschatology, because I think it's right.
00:45:27.020 I think it's true, first of all.
00:45:28.880 Right.
00:45:29.140 That being said, the most quoted Old Testament passage in the New Testament is Psalm 110.
00:45:36.280 10, one. And it says, the Lord said unto my Lord, come and sit at my right hand until I make the
00:45:43.060 nations your footstool. Put all of your enemies under your feet. That's what it is. That is the
00:45:47.680 most quoted passage in the Old Testament by the New Testament writers. By far. And so that being
00:45:54.320 said, along with, in Daniel, is it chapter two with the Nebuchadnezzar, his, no, it's not chapter
00:46:00.840 two. Is it chapter six with Nebuchadnezzar and his dream and the statue and the small stone that
00:46:05.840 was thrown at it and blew the statue up. And I can't remember the passage, but we know what you
00:46:11.200 mean. Anyway, there are many, many passages that essentially give the inevitable slow victory of
00:46:18.440 Christ over the whole earth. Even in Zechariah, I read this in church on Sunday, this last Sunday,
00:46:25.920 and it's talking about Christ coming into Jerusalem on a donkey. It's the prophecy that
00:46:31.360 he's fulfilled in this on Palm Sunday. And part of it says, keep going, keep going. He, he shall
00:46:38.980 rule and his rule shall be from sea to sea, from the river to the ends of the earth. Quote in Psalm
00:46:45.680 72 right there. So I mean, so, so then application, right? So if these things are true, Christ is
00:46:52.760 seated at the right hand of God, putting all enemies under his feet. He will have dominion
00:46:57.200 from sea to sea, from the river to the ends of the earth. You know what that means for me is that I
00:47:01.720 look at the enemies that are coming against God and his anointed one, like Psalm two, and he
00:47:07.620 laughs. He holds them in derision. Do I worry? Do I worry about that? No, I look at my children and
00:47:14.440 I'm like, this is my first responsibility. They're the closest to me. I have to make sure that I'm
00:47:19.180 faithful and diligent in my discipleship and training, instruction, and discipline of my
00:47:26.060 children. That's what I want to make sure of. But these other things, they can come against God.
00:47:30.640 He is seated on the throne. He is the king of the cosmos, the king of kings, the Lord of lords.
00:47:37.060 All of these things are futile. I love that you brought up Constantine earlier in the show,
00:47:41.540 because that's one of my favorite stories. You have this massive turning in the world where you
00:47:46.360 have people that suffered persecution just 15 years earlier. They're sitting in an ecumenical
00:47:51.580 council in Rome with Constantine, trying to figure out what is true and what is heresy,
00:47:57.180 what is orthodoxy. And the saints, the bishops there had scars from being persecuted.
00:48:03.080 It would be like if 15 years from now, the president of the United States of America
00:48:08.620 radically converted to Christianity and called a council and said, American Christians,
00:48:13.600 we got to figure some of these things out. And he sat in a council and called a bunch of theologians
00:48:18.640 and they all got together and they started correcting the errors of the church and errors
00:48:22.600 to the culture of the world and, and, and the politics. And that's literally what happened
00:48:26.420 in human history. God appointed for that to happen. Yeah. It's absolutely insane. And, and so,
00:48:30.700 and this is the way that God works, right? He stacks the cards against him. And then he has
00:48:35.380 this like overwhelming victory through crazy means, like weak men that have small churches
00:48:41.720 in rural towns. I mean, it's, it's, it is wild. So, so having an, uh, an optimistic view of the
00:48:49.340 end times of where we are going, even if, I mean, I'm under no delusions that the president is going
00:48:54.780 to bend the knee to Christ, you know, anytime soon, we're going to achieve world peace in my
00:48:59.640 lifetime. Yeah. But I know that we're winning. We are going to win. What you're saying, what
00:49:05.460 you're saying then? No, I'm just kidding. It's, it does. Like what you're saying is that if you
00:49:09.140 of an optimistic eschatology. Basically, you will go from reading the story of history as the story
00:49:14.800 of the apparent defeat of God and his people, followed by the snatching of victory from the
00:49:20.640 jaws of defeat at the very last second, and you will instead read history as the story of God's
00:49:26.140 unfolding conquest, God's unfolding inevitable, inexorable, where it does go. I mean, some moments
00:49:33.160 it seems like everything's going to fail and there's a decline, but then there's some eucatastrophe
00:49:39.100 moment or some historical turn where things go back and God continues to expand his kingdom.
00:49:44.800 And that things like Daniel, when you talk about the stone that was cut out by no human hands,
00:49:49.900 comes and strikes the feet of empire, the statue that represents empires, and that stone becomes
00:49:54.980 a mountain that covers the earth. You actually believe that the striking of the stone was Christ's
00:50:00.040 coming, crucifixion, resurrection, ascension, and that subsequently the story of history is the
00:50:05.880 expansion of this mountain rather than the stone continuing to be a pebble until at the very last
00:50:12.760 second, the whole mountain comes down. Right. Exactly. And even if you back out from
00:50:17.780 being a Christian for a moment and just examine it as a movement, as an ideology, and you look
00:50:25.600 at it in history. So it's been left alone in the Middle Ages. It's been left alone. And what do you
00:50:30.680 see. You see cathedrals being built, human flourishing, art, music. You see Christianity
00:50:38.040 just blossoming, right? For hundreds and hundreds of years. The dark ages. I'm sorry. They were the
00:50:43.820 bright ages. We could talk about that another episode maybe, but like total myth, another myth.
00:50:48.600 And so you see when the church is left alone, it flourishes, it explodes. And then when the church
00:50:55.000 is persecuted. Like I read in the last cold opening about Latimer and Ridley, you have the
00:51:02.560 persecution of the saints and their blood is spilled. What happens to the church? It flourishes,
00:51:09.060 it explodes, it grows. That's what's happening right now in our day in the Middle East and in
00:51:14.140 Africa and in Asia is that the persecuted saints, the church is growing. And so just examining it
00:51:20.460 from the outside you look at at christianity and it grows no matter what you do yeah no it's
00:51:26.740 inevitable and why because the lord is seated at the lord's right hand putting all of his enemies
00:51:32.440 under his feet that is why that is why i i'm convinced yeah it's kind of i was going to say
00:51:37.320 it's kind of ironic you're mentioning like africa is a good example so the methodist church in
00:51:41.820 america votes to accept pretty much full-blown homosexuality and then the africans are like
00:51:47.540 Mr?
00:51:48.440 Should I call you Mr?
00:51:49.540 Why are you gay?
00:51:50.140 Are you gay?
00:51:50.780 Should I call you Bishop?
00:51:51.780 I mean, literally, the Africans were the ones that saved the whole denomination.
00:51:56.460 Now, here's the deal.
00:51:58.280 Americans, American Christians spent so much time and money over the last 40 years discipling Africa
00:52:04.040 that now they're like based in Christian.
00:52:06.960 They're Christ-pilled.
00:52:08.120 We are saying no to homosexuality.
00:52:10.540 Even animals don't do it.
00:52:11.680 Why should we be forced to do it?
00:52:12.640 If we would have just done that with our own kids, it would have been a totally different story.
00:52:16.780 I remember same thing. Obama went to Kenya when he was president. He's speaking to like their
00:52:20.980 prime minister or whatever. He's like, you know, you're very intolerant. You need to accept
00:52:24.520 homosexuality. And he said, let me cut you off. We don't do that here. And I was like, whoa,
00:52:30.500 mister. Yeah. And that is all because, you know, faithful Christian witness. The other thing I
00:52:36.420 wanted to say real quick, we were talking about practical implications. So one of the things that
00:52:40.600 I noticed pastorally studying and preaching the Psalms over the years, we have these amazing Bible
00:52:46.520 commentators, Willem
00:52:48.400 Van Gemmeren is one of them,
00:52:50.440 all these great guys, Derek Kidner,
00:52:53.120 where I noticed Postmill
00:52:54.480 running into, you know, this whole
00:52:56.600 eschatology running into problems with the
00:52:58.540 Psalms. Even solid reformed
00:53:00.580 guys, when they get to the imprecatory Psalms,
00:53:03.000 they're kind of like, yeah,
00:53:04.420 that was their prayer, but
00:53:06.200 I don't know. That was for
00:53:08.200 an older dispensation. Yeah,
00:53:10.380 let's not, let's just, I mean, there's a
00:53:12.480 real discomfort. Whereas what I noticed
00:53:14.440 with the Postmill guys, they're like, pray
00:53:16.360 it. God gave us that psalm. We need that one, particularly for such a time as this. Pray them
00:53:21.980 all. Pray them wholeheartedly without all these weird gymnastics. Here's the thing, too. This is
00:53:28.740 going to be a super smooth transition. You mentioned the psalms. Dan talked about Psalm 110.
00:53:32.340 I want to talk about Psalm 2 a little bit more. I want to talk about my music. No, I'm just kidding.
00:53:36.720 Actually, no. There is a great setting of Psalm 2 that has recently been put out. It's
00:53:41.480 Why do the heathen nations vainly rage by Douglas Wilson?
00:53:44.220 Okay, anyway.
00:53:45.760 Psalm 2.
00:53:46.600 One of the things that modern Christians tend to miss is that the New Testament...
00:53:51.660 Here's a question.
00:53:53.160 Imagine that you had a divinely inspired and inerrant commentary on the Old Testament.
00:53:59.300 Wouldn't that be helpful?
00:54:00.080 Wouldn't that be great?
00:54:00.880 Yeah, that'd be helpful.
00:54:01.520 Tell me more.
00:54:02.200 Guess what you do.
00:54:03.140 Guess what you do.
00:54:03.840 It's called the New Testament.
00:54:05.060 Well, and I just want to interject.
00:54:06.800 Yeah, go ahead.
00:54:07.480 One thing and then continue because you got me all excited.
00:54:09.860 So one of the things, I was reading a James Hamilton.
00:54:12.960 Oh yeah, God's glory and salvation through judgment.
00:54:14.760 Commentary on Psalm 137 in Precatory.
00:54:17.240 But so he points out at the end of the Psalm,
00:54:19.500 you've got the prayer for the Hebrew word is shattered,
00:54:21.960 that the infants of the enemy would be shattered.
00:54:24.300 And they said there's only one other place in all the scripture
00:54:27.780 where the word for shattered appears.
00:54:30.120 Guess where? Psalm 2.
00:54:31.520 So James makes a great point.
00:54:33.480 He says Psalm 137 is the prayer that Psalm 2 would be fulfilled.
00:54:38.260 Exactly.
00:54:38.740 Exactly. And James Hamilton also has great work that the Proverbs are Solomon's obeying
00:54:45.300 Deuteronomy 6. James Hamilton also has great work on the biblical theology of the transposition or
00:54:53.000 the reversal of the curse where the woman's desire in Genesis 3 part of the curse is that
00:54:59.000 her desire would be for her husband is the literal Hebrew word. And in the ESV translated
00:55:03.680 said like over or against, like her desire will be to rule over her husband. Because it's the same
00:55:07.980 word in genesis 4 that uh god uses to describe the sin sin is crouching at the door cain its
00:55:14.880 desire is to rule over you its desire is for you what else do you find in any eric do you find
00:55:19.380 anything else interesting that's not relevant to our topic no this is relevant in song of solomon
00:55:23.940 then uh-huh the bride's love for the davidic king for the solomonic davidic king is heard that she
00:55:30.620 it's used as the same word for it says her desire is for him but now it's been restored in christ
00:55:35.500 And so the woman's desire to rule over her husband becomes, through the resurrection and through the work of Christ, it becomes actually now properly for her husband in love.
00:55:46.720 And so instead of desiring to be autonomous and rule over him, she desires to actually have him as her Lord and her husband.
00:55:52.800 And so it's just glorious, like all these threads.
00:55:55.240 Now I'm going to connect this perfectly so that Dan will see the connection that's actually what really was.
00:55:59.460 Blow my mind.
00:56:00.020 You've got to help Dan out here.
00:56:01.480 Yeah, I'm dim-witted.
00:56:02.920 Back to Psalm 2.
00:56:04.940 Allegedly.
00:56:05.500 We have a divinely inspired, inerrant commentary of the New Testament on the Old.
00:56:12.760 And one of the places where I really saw the last vestiges of my opposition to post-millennialism fall
00:56:19.600 was in seeing this in the way that the New Testament authors interpret Psalm 2.
00:56:25.480 Because ranging from the book of Acts to the book of Hebrews to the book of Revelation,
00:56:30.220 we have quotations of at least 60% of Psalm 2 directly and allusions as well
00:56:34.640 that give us basically an interpretation of what that psalm is saying. In the first part of Psalm
00:56:40.040 2, we see the psalm open with the nations say that they're going to cast off their cords and
00:56:45.860 his restraint from them and basically do their own thing. New Testament authors in Acts 4 quote that
00:56:51.300 and they say this is exactly what happened when Pontius Pilate, the Jews, conspired together
00:56:57.760 against Christ. There we have the nations, the Gentiles and the Jewish people, conspiring against
00:57:02.700 Christ, Acts 4, 25 to 28. Then in Acts 2, 36, we see that the next part of the psalm is actually
00:57:08.900 referenced, that as for me, I've set my king on Zion's hill. Okay, who is that? Christ. Christ
00:57:16.080 is anointed the king, according to Acts 2, 36. It uses the psalm there to establish that. And then
00:57:21.560 finally, Acts 13 and Hebrews 1, 5 tells us that when it says, you are my son, today I have begotten
00:57:28.020 you? A lot of Christians think, oh yeah, that's obviously about Jesus. It's about the incarnation,
00:57:33.620 like I've begotten the son. No, no, no, no, no. That's not what it's about. It is about the
00:57:38.500 resurrection. Acts 13, 33, go read it. Hebrews 1, 5. The New Testament authors show us that that
00:57:44.980 verse is actually referring to the begetting of Christ from the dead, the resurrection. And the
00:57:49.520 reason this all matters is because when you understand what happens next in the psalm,
00:57:53.620 you see something glorious because the very next thing that happens in the psalm,
00:57:56.680 You are my son. Today I've begotten you. Ask of me and I will make the nations your inheritance.
00:58:01.340 Oh, but they're part of the common kingdom. Somebody reminded me of that.
00:58:04.740 Dang it. No, it's glorious because what that Psalm teaches us is that though the nations
00:58:09.180 conspired against the anointed king who's seated on Zion's hill, though they even crushed him and
00:58:13.760 crucified him, the father begot him from the dead and told him, ask me this question, son,
00:58:19.960 ask for the nations for your inheritance and I'll give it to you. So therefore, this is the message
00:58:24.760 for the ongoing portion of history we're in today.
00:58:26.640 It's kiss the son, lest he be angry
00:58:28.480 and you perish along the way.
00:58:29.720 Why?
00:58:30.380 Because he's seated and Psalm 110 is true
00:58:32.520 and his enemies are being made a footstool.
00:58:34.480 Whether those enemies are made a footstool
00:58:36.140 by their conversion or their destruction is up to them.
00:58:38.900 So his desire will be for the woman?
00:58:41.600 Dang it, he brought it back.
00:58:43.380 He showed the paucity of my connection.
00:58:46.300 No, I guess all I was saying is that
00:58:48.100 the Bible is glorious when you read it
00:58:50.860 the way that the apostles read the Bible.
00:58:53.160 That was a tapestry, Dan.
00:58:54.580 It was a tapestry.
00:58:55.580 I was lost in it.
00:58:56.440 See my threads.
00:58:56.840 Quite literally lost.
00:58:58.000 It was so glorious.
00:58:59.040 No, no, no, no.
00:58:59.800 No, it was glorious.
00:59:00.260 Follow my threads, Dan.
00:59:01.580 Yeah, so the main idea is the imprecatory Psalms.
00:59:06.100 Which I brought up, by the way.
00:59:06.800 And the inevitable victory of Christ.
00:59:08.840 Well, yeah, you did bring that up.
00:59:10.900 Yeah, just-
00:59:11.460 Like 10 minutes ago, probably.
00:59:13.020 Specifically-
00:59:13.500 I'm just kidding.
00:59:14.080 That was great.
00:59:14.680 Specifically, it is that if you read the Psalms, especially through the lens of the
00:59:19.700 apostles' interpretation of them, you will come to the conclusion that Christ is ruling and the
00:59:24.260 nations are being made his inheritance. So not in the millennium. Well, yes, in the millennium.
00:59:28.840 Oh, but not like after the tribulation. In the millennium. Well, yes, after the tribulation.
00:59:32.660 Oh, but at like the seven-year, are you pre-trib? Mid-trib? Post-trib? What I'm saying, Dan,
00:59:38.640 is that there was a great tribulation, as Christ said there would be within one generation that
00:59:43.600 would come upon Israel. 8070. And that from then, as Christ was seated, the sign of the Son of Man
00:59:50.600 seated in the heavens, as Christ says in Matthew 24, that from that moment on, the millennium has
00:59:56.060 been established. Christ has been ruling. And what we're seeing now is the subsequent expansion of
01:00:01.440 the kingdom of God through normal covenant succession and through the great sweeps of
01:00:05.060 history as God writes this story. He's conquering. So if there was one main area, because I'm sure
01:00:11.420 that we've upset some of our listeners and we want you to know that we're for you changing your mind
01:00:16.580 um if you were to push them on a point to give them like some fodder like this is this is one
01:00:22.860 area where i think you should look at in your eschatology pessimistic eschatology obviously
01:00:27.800 we would love for everybody to be post mill because we think it's right i mean once you
01:00:32.080 want everybody to be convinced for your position if you thought it was the right one if you think
01:00:35.560 it's right you want everybody to think yeah right so of course so if there's something that i don't
01:00:39.140 know, you could leave them with that would be convincing as like, this is one area where I
01:00:43.220 think you should definitely push your, challenge your own theology to think about it. That might
01:00:47.440 change your mind, at least to, to be more open to the idea that these guys on the King's Hall
01:00:52.100 podcast actually know what they're talking about. As far as like Christ swallowing up the whole
01:00:57.460 world in his kingdom, where would that be? Well, mine, I would say for sure is read David
01:01:03.100 Chilton Paradise Restored. Yes, definitely. So I was, and let me just preface where,
01:01:08.160 where i've come from like i went to the southern baptist seminary um you had a mix of guys who
01:01:12.940 were historic pre-mill and a-mill i thought i remember reading some stuff about postmill and
01:01:17.840 thinking no and i heard doug wilson was postmill and i was like okay whatever and and then i read
01:01:24.200 david chilton and it's one of the most convincing moving arguments oh yeah i mean because you know
01:01:30.760 like many other things that have changed my position i'm looking at it and i'm saying i
01:01:35.500 don't care what your view is. I want to know what the Bible says. Right. And Chilton just walks you
01:01:40.880 through it in such a way that it's like, this is what scripture teaches. That was my conviction.
01:01:46.440 I have a funny story about this that I'll tell that makes me look bad and Dan look good,
01:01:50.320 which is, you know, honestly. Oh, I wasn't going to bring up that story. I thought you were talking
01:01:53.860 about a different one, but yeah. Oh, I'm going to bring this story up, Dan, because you deserve it.
01:01:57.080 You deserve it. So Dan read that book first. Dan read it before me. And I was amillennial at that
01:02:01.780 point. I had been dispensationalist. I actually had serious, this is the thing, God uses crazy
01:02:06.960 things. God brought me to repentance in my teen years and to a renewal of my faith through the
01:02:15.560 left behind books. I'm not even kidding. That's wild. I got to the last book, which is Glorious
01:02:20.000 Appearing, and it was this scene in heaven, and it was so deeply moving to me. It was like,
01:02:26.340 I believe that Christ is going to win. I believe he's going to, it's funny that I say that from
01:02:30.940 that book, but that was like, it was, so I was really Disby. I went to a Disby college, Bible
01:02:35.400 college. I even taught a class on it at Bible college once and Disby to the core, then read
01:02:41.060 some Sam Storms, became a millennial or has actually read some James Hamilton, dropped the
01:02:45.680 Disby part, became historic pre-mill, then was convinced of a millennialism slash post-millennialism
01:02:50.520 of some sort by Sam Storms and his article, particularly that was like things you must
01:02:55.500 believe to be pre-millennialists of any type, which you should check out. And then I became
01:02:59.120 post-millennial, but between the on-mill and post-mill, Dan got there first and he was reading
01:03:03.640 the Chilton book. And I remember he came in and he was like, this is wild. Chilton is explaining
01:03:08.140 how to understand Isaiah. And I won't get into the details, but basically I heard what he said
01:03:13.800 and I was like, that sounds like a heresy, Dan. I think you're totally wrong. That's crazy.
01:03:17.700 He called me a heretic.
01:03:18.640 I was like, I think you'd be a heretic if you believed that. And then I read the book and I
01:03:22.660 was like, Dan, I'm so sorry. This is actually absolutely correct. And it's not heretical at
01:03:26.420 all and uh please forgive me this is why dan by the way by one of our reviewers got reviewed as
01:03:31.820 the number one host of this show i was third what the heck yeah you but here's the problem
01:03:36.320 you're first in my heart oh the problem i was in the middle and whether you go by the world
01:03:42.640 standard where dan is first or jesus standard where the first shall be last so you were actually
01:03:46.560 first by that i'm in the middle either way the number two spot still stays the number two first
01:03:50.980 loser. So I was sad. I would 100% second Chilton. And to me, adding to it, and this would come
01:03:58.940 through Chilton and reading Gentry and some of these other guys, is that I think if you start
01:04:03.440 singing the Psalms and being serious about being in the Psalms and wait 10 years, you'll find that
01:04:08.260 your expectations are so shaped by them that you would have a hard time explaining the simple
01:04:15.140 expectations of the Psalms away, either through over-spiritualizing or pushing them into a
01:04:20.840 millennium after Christ comes back. And that's kind of what I was saying. The plain reading
01:04:24.960 of the Psalms is an expectation of the post-millenial dominionist hope.
01:04:28.920 Yeah. I think what an optimistic eschatology, post-millennialism, allows you to have,
01:04:33.540 particularly a covenantal, reformed post-millennial that's deeply rooted in the
01:04:40.660 reformed tradition and the reformed faith allows you to do not just post-millennialism but all of
01:04:46.260 that is to read the scriptures without falling into the ditch of either wooden literalism that
01:04:51.940 that reads the the scriptures the way a six-year-old would read love poetry they just don't
01:04:56.340 get the metaphor they don't get the prophecy they don't understand it god says that he owns a cattle
01:05:00.180 on a thousand hills yeah but what about the thousandth and first no he only owns them to
01:05:04.900 the thousand that one that nobody reads it that way i think it's uh monsanto after that but he
01:05:09.640 doesn't own the sheep, just the cattle. Well, actually, it's Bill Gates at this point.
01:05:13.240 Bill Gates, yeah, that's right. He's buying everything.
01:05:14.660 And at the same time, though, I think that you also get protection from the other ditch,
01:05:19.620 which is a radically over-spiritualizing of the text, that some flavors of, in my opinion,
01:05:25.680 again, love you, Amillennial Brothers, I think some Amillennialist hermeneutics come to passages
01:05:30.480 in the Psalms, like Psalm 22, that all the families of the earth will turn and worship
01:05:34.320 the Lord, and he'll have dominion from sea to sea, and they're like, yeah, that's talking
01:05:37.700 about the expansion of the spiritual kingdom alongside of the common kingdom and the natural
01:05:41.440 kingdom and and they'll basically be in opposition forever and neither will have dominion it's
01:05:47.060 nonsense wait a second well it's certainly and that's what i would say it's certainly not
01:05:50.580 plain reading of the text and i think that it it helps you not to hit either of those ditches
01:05:56.760 because there's wooden literalism there's over spiritualism and we don't want to be in either
01:06:00.700 of those we want to read the scriptures the way the apostles did we're going to read the scriptures
01:06:05.000 the way the apostles did.
01:06:05.860 So that's what I would say.
01:06:06.880 What was most convincing to me,
01:06:08.600 I was reading Sam Storm's book,
01:06:10.640 Kingdom Come, A Case for All Millennialism,
01:06:13.820 and he overshot his target.
01:06:15.920 He convinced me so much of partial preterism
01:06:19.120 and he gave such a charitable argument.
01:06:24.160 Presentation.
01:06:24.940 Yeah, presentation.
01:06:25.840 He definitely steel-manned his opponents
01:06:27.800 in premillennialism and in postmillennialism
01:06:32.120 postmillennialism yes that i became utterly convinced of postmillennialism in an all
01:06:37.300 millennial all millennialness book boy that's a hard word to say and it's because he he's like
01:06:43.880 hey if postmillennialism is right here are all the relevant passages and it is you're like i
01:06:49.100 actually agree with it was like four pages like i love those pages those pages are right inerrant
01:06:54.820 those verses are great and then he gave three critiques and and they were lame he it was
01:07:00.220 actually self-defeating in his book because he had just set up why. Those aren't actually
01:07:04.220 objections. So Sam Storms, in a book trying to convince me
01:07:08.300 of all millennialism, convinced me of post-millennialism. And so
01:07:12.320 the sticking point, I would just, good listener that is not
01:07:16.000 post-mill, I'm speaking to you at this moment, take a look at the relevant
01:07:20.320 passages that a post-millennialist would cite and say
01:07:24.400 examine them. What does this mean? What does this mean?
01:07:27.820 I think you will be absolutely astounded.
01:07:30.940 And add to that, every passage that comes to mind is an objection, like, the way is narrow and few will find it.
01:07:37.140 Go read what postmillennialists say about those passages.
01:07:40.300 They're best answers.
01:07:41.560 That's the other thing, and that's why I was saying no straw manning.
01:07:44.340 Yeah.
01:07:44.700 So, you know, something like 2 Peter 3, you know, what's the answer?
01:07:49.800 Well, you know, somebody asked me that question, I type it in, a few people I know, I ask Gary DeMar, you get an answer.
01:07:55.040 it's like okay there is an answer but then you look at like what the disbies say we say and it's
01:07:59.880 not the same thing no what do they say i i don't remember exactly on that one i know that the post
01:08:05.360 mill to like second peter three is what we're talking about the fall of uh jerusalem it's using
01:08:09.980 similar language to what the old testament prophets used for the destruction of assyria
01:08:14.280 yeah and you can check out like peter lightheart's got a commentary on it uh gary damar has some great
01:08:19.940 stuff on American Vision on that. And what you'll find, like this really helped me because I was so
01:08:25.700 steeped in dispensationalism, and I was taught that dispensationalists love the Bible, and they
01:08:30.960 just let the Bible talk, and that these other folks all spiritualize the Bible. And I found
01:08:36.060 some of that to be true about certain non-millennialist interpretations, but man,
01:08:39.560 post-millennial theologians bleed bibline, you know, like the Spurgeon quote. They bleed bibline.
01:08:44.760 When you talk to a James Jordan or a Gary DeMar or a Kenneth Gentry or a Douglas Wilson about these things, they are rattling off passages like a machine gun.
01:08:56.980 I mean, they're just like, well, it's like this psalm and this biblical theological connection, this historical theological connection, and this New Testament interpretation of this psalm.
01:09:03.840 And then, oh, did you see the way that this was quoted by Hosea?
01:09:05.980 And it's like they deeply love and appreciate the tapestry of the Bible as a whole work.
01:09:12.820 And even to Baptists, if you don't want to listen to any of those guys, you can look at Jeff Durbin.
01:09:17.960 He has some good videos on the YouTubes if you're curious about that.
01:09:21.840 Yeah, that's very good.
01:09:22.800 And so in conclusion, I think that when what we're posing is that the pessimistic view of the church and of Christ's reign is not only unhelpful, but is also incorrect and it's actually doing harm.
01:09:37.700 So the way forward is to actually believe the scriptures, Jesus' rule and reign will be from sea to sea, from the river to the ends of the earth.
01:09:45.900 And next time, I'm going to drop a teaser for our next episode, we have a very special guest that is going to be talking specifically about post-millennialism.
01:09:56.920 And so that's going to be with you, Eric.
01:09:58.680 Man, I can't wait to figure out who this is.
01:10:00.600 Yeah.
01:10:01.060 Oh, man.
01:10:01.880 Are we going to say or are we going to?
01:10:04.380 It rhymes.
01:10:05.940 Chocolate Fox.
01:10:06.880 wait yeah chocolate and hugs oh yeah no way the man the myth the legend go baptize your kids if
01:10:15.160 you have children david shannon that's right we're going to be talking with david shannon about
01:10:19.380 post-mill theology of course he spent a lot of time under some really great teachers doug wilson
01:10:23.940 around toby sumter and uh and uncle gary uncle gary demar i think that's going to be exciting
01:10:30.820 he knows a ton about it really exciting guest so everybody thanks for listening in to this episode
01:10:35.080 of the King's Hall podcast.
01:10:36.880 We are so glad that you've given us this time
01:10:38.600 and entrusted it to us.
01:10:39.720 We hope it's been helpful.
01:10:41.120 We would encourage you to head over to kingshall.org
01:10:43.920 to check out some of the ways
01:10:45.680 that you can support the show.
01:10:46.840 You can become a patron
01:10:47.740 and gain access to a weekly patron-exclusive show
01:10:51.080 called After Hours.
01:10:52.140 We record after every main episode.
01:10:54.060 We have some great merch
01:10:56.040 that will identify you as not just a Christian,
01:10:59.920 but the type of Christian
01:11:00.940 who would wear a shirt
01:11:02.820 wherein a man named Boniface is chopping down a tree that is rainbow colored and that sort of
01:11:08.300 thing. So you can head there. And we do want to thank our sponsor for this episode, Reformation
01:11:13.640 Heritage Books, for the ways that they've supported the show and invite you to go check out their
01:11:17.460 website that's in the description and pick up some great resources there to catechize your kids and
01:11:22.740 disciple your family, learn biblical theology, historical theology. Man, they've got a great
01:11:26.560 library over there. I think it's heritagebooks.com. But if I'm wrong about that, it's in the
01:11:31.100 description. So thanks for listening, guys. And we'll see you next time in the Kings Hall.
01:12:01.100 Kings Hall, if you'd like to support the show and get some extra content.