The Matt Walsh Show - Ep. 1359 - Why The Pro-Palestine Campus Protesters Are A Bunch Of Childish Cosplaying Phonies

00:00:00.000 Today on the Matt Wall Show, police finally showed up to throw out the pro-Hamas protesters

00:00:04.140 who had invaded and occupied a building at Columbia University.

00:00:07.060 This was after the protesters demanded concessions from Columbia, including free food deliveries.

00:00:12.500 Also, a bipartisan bill is being pushed by both parties in Congress to fight anti-Semitism,

00:00:17.020 supposedly, but there are some major problems with this legislation, which we'll discuss.

00:00:20.800 And the Supreme Court refuses to block the enforcement of a law in Texas that forces

00:00:24.180 porn companies to verify the ages of their viewers.

00:00:27.080 A lot of creepy weirdos who want kids to be exposed to porn have objected to this law,

00:00:31.000 and they're all wrong.

00:00:32.300 I'll explain why.

00:00:33.020 We'll talk about all that and more today on the Matt Wall Show.

00:00:57.080 If you owe back taxes or still have unfiled returns, they can really weigh on your mind,

00:01:04.560 especially when the IRS has become more determined than ever.

00:01:06.900 Their chief data and analytics officer revealed that the IRS is focused on an enforcement project

00:01:10.680 with an average return on investment of about $6 for every $1 spent.

00:01:14.960 They're targeting individuals and businesses that currently owe back taxes or haven't yet filed the returns.

00:01:19.960 Tax Network USA, the nation's leading tax relief firm, knows the tax code and will fight for you.

00:01:24.940 With a record of negotiating over a billion dollars in tax relief for their clients,

00:01:28.780 their team is knowledgeable in handling any type of tax issue.

00:01:31.700 Whether you owe $10 or $10,000 or $10 million, they can help.

00:01:35.820 Even if you don't have all your personal or business records from over the years,

00:01:39.080 they can get you filed up to date.

00:01:41.260 Facing the IRS without a professional is not a smart move.

00:01:43.860 Contact Tax Network USA for the best strategic advice to help reduce or even eliminate your tax debt.

00:01:49.880 Call today at 1-800-245-6000 or visit their website at TNUSA.com slash Walsh.

00:01:56.040 They'll give you a free private consultation on how you can settle your tax debt today.

00:02:00.820 That's TNUSA.com slash Walsh.

00:02:03.980 Back in late April of 2015, almost exactly nine years ago,

00:02:07.960 riots erupted in Baltimore, Maryland over the demise of a career criminal named Freddie Gray,

00:02:12.640 who died while in police custody.

00:02:13.940 Now, a few people remember his name today, but at the time, he was the most recently canonized BLM saint

00:02:20.600 and the guy whose death everybody was pretending to mourn.

00:02:24.000 The most memorable thing about that moment in history, though, isn't Freddie Gray himself or even the riots,

00:02:29.820 but what the then mayor of the city said the day after, the day after, as the media put it,

00:02:35.480 peaceful protests took a violent turn.

00:02:38.180 Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake stood in front of news cameras

00:02:40.880 and told the world that she had decided to give, quote,

00:02:44.700 those who wish to destroy space to do that as well.

00:02:48.940 Now, by her own testimony, she had instructed law enforcement to stand by

00:02:52.100 and give rioters space to destroy their own community,

00:02:56.440 to let off some steam and vent their frustrations by committing crimes.

00:03:01.380 At the time, it was shocking that a political leader would openly allow that kind of behavior

00:03:05.500 and even admit that she was allowing it.

00:03:07.580 It also cast the riots in an even more bizarrely childish light.

00:03:12.020 The rioters were now like children having a temper tantrum in the grocery store,

00:03:15.640 and the mayor was the overly lenient pushover parent allowing the scene to continue.

00:03:20.740 But as Mayor Rawlings-Blake discovered,

00:03:23.760 the problem with giving space to destroy is that eventually you will want them to stop destroying.

00:03:29.460 And then at that point, you'll have to do exactly the thing that you could have

00:03:32.920 and should have done the moment that the lawlessness started.

00:03:35.640 And when you do that, the rioters will not at that point thank you

00:03:40.320 for having given them more time and space than they ever deserved.

00:03:44.440 You know, whenever you decide to finally enforce the law,

00:03:46.740 they will claim to be oppressed, just as they would have if you had enforced the law from the beginning.

00:03:50.740 So why didn't you just enforce it from the beginning?

00:03:53.580 This is one of the many problems with the space to destroy strategy.

00:03:56.800 And yet, city leaders all across the country in the years since have adopted the same strategy.

00:04:02.960 And in recent weeks, as you've heard, university officials have embraced the space destroy approach as well.

00:04:08.140 And last night, that decision, as it always does, inevitably, came to a head.

00:04:12.320 After allowing leftist pro-Hamas demonstrators to maintain an illegal encampment for many days,

00:04:17.480 Columbia University finally brought in the NYPD to arrest the criminals.

00:04:21.000 A decision that was only made after they broke into and occupied a building on campus.

00:04:27.120 When the police arrived in full force with riot shields and zip ties and buses to arrest and detain the demonstrators,

00:04:33.760 it didn't take very long before the situation was brought under control.

00:04:37.160 And the authorities had wrestled back the property that had been illegally seized.

00:04:41.360 There were many videos of this operation as it unfolded,

00:04:44.720 often posted by leftist groups who expected the public to be shocked and horrified by the images.

00:04:49.500 Here's one example.

00:04:51.340 This is a video posted by a group called National Students for Justice in Palestine.

00:04:55.780 Watch.

00:05:00.260 Back it up.

00:05:00.840 Back it up.

00:05:02.040 That means you.

00:05:02.960 Back up.

00:05:04.400 Back up.

00:05:09.140 Back up.

00:05:11.480 Back up.

00:05:14.060 Get back.

00:05:15.140 Get back.

00:05:16.720 Get arrested.

00:05:18.220 Get back up.

00:05:18.700 Get arrested.

00:05:20.220 Okay, so they posted that along with the caption,

00:05:22.740 SWAT and SRG have invaded Columbia's campus and are entering Hinn's Hall.

00:05:26.960 They have forced out all the press to prevent recordings of their brutality.

00:05:31.580 But as you saw in their own video, there was no brutality.

00:05:35.780 It was literally just the police shouting, get back.

00:05:38.620 That was the brutality.

00:05:40.320 They were raising their voices.

00:05:42.300 Oh, dear God.

00:05:43.640 Really, this was just the police enforcing the law.

00:05:45.680 And they were not invading anything.

00:05:47.500 It's the pro-Hamas protesters that had illegally invaded a building.

00:05:51.120 A building that isn't called Hinn's Hall, by the way, but rather Hamilton Hall, because

00:05:55.680 the protesters had not only burglarized and occupied the building, but also attempted

00:05:59.340 to rename it.

00:06:00.260 They expected us to be deeply disturbed and outraged on their behalf that their act of organized

00:06:06.240 burglary and trespassing is no longer allowed to continue.

00:06:10.040 And indeed, many on the left, including prominent politicians who spoke out, did express outrage.

00:06:14.820 According to them, these protesters should be allowed to do whatever they want indefinitely

00:06:18.480 and break whatever laws they want to break for as long as they want to break them without

00:06:23.200 facing any consequences whatsoever.

00:06:25.500 Like, that is their actual position.

00:06:28.160 Nonetheless, dozens of the criminals were arrested, and now they will face not only criminal

00:06:33.380 charges, but expulsion.

00:06:35.360 They will be then thousands of dollars in debt with no college degree, which means they'll

00:06:41.220 be in only slightly worse shape than the people who are thousands of dollars in debt with

00:06:44.760 a college degree.

00:06:45.380 Meanwhile, on the other side of the country, the illegal encampment on UCLA's campus was

00:06:49.860 also invaded, but not by police.

00:06:52.660 Here's the report from Breitbart.

00:06:54.280 Roughly 100 pro-Israel vigilantes stormed the Palestine Solidarian encampment at the University

00:06:59.540 of California, Los Angeles, late Tuesday night and early Wednesday morning, sparking battles

00:07:03.460 with activists.

00:07:04.460 The raid occurred after nearly a week in which UCLA not only allowed the encampment to occupy

00:07:08.360 the main plaza on campus, but also allowed pro-Palestinian activists to run their own security,

00:07:13.480 barring access to students and the public.

00:07:17.060 Here's what this, quote unquote, raid looked like.

00:07:20.020 What?

00:07:28.460 Hey, Jill, go! 1.00

00:07:36.020 Go Elliot, go Elliot!

00:07:43.880 Okay, so, I mean, not exactly, you know, this is not exactly Braveheart.

00:08:07.120 The battle that we're seeing here is, it sounds a lot worse than it is when you see it on video.

00:08:14.800 But nonetheless, this is what happens when you grant one group special privileges to break the law and all of the rules.

00:08:21.860 Not only break the rules, but come up with their own rules.

00:08:25.100 When you allow them to seize a part of the campus and decide who's allowed to walk through it.

00:08:31.080 That sort of wildly unjust, disproportionate situation can only continue for so long before everybody else, the people expected to abide by the law, have simply had enough of the double standard and decide to take matters into their own hands.

00:08:45.500 If you don't want that to happen, and you definitely shouldn't want it to happen, then enforce the rules equally and hold everyone to the same standard.

00:08:54.140 Which means that not only should, you know, which means that nobody should be allowed to maintain any kind of illegal encampment on the campus at all.

00:09:02.060 Keep this in mind.

00:09:02.940 When pro-life protesters sat peacefully outside of an abortion clinic for a few hours on one single morning, the Biden administration sent armed federal agents to their homes to drag them away in handcuffs.

00:09:16.620 And then convicted them of felonies and now wants to send them to prison for 10 years.

00:09:21.160 When January 6th protesters trespass in the Capitol, the federal government responded by spending the next three years hunting them down one by one and tossing them in prison.

00:09:29.560 So when the left objects to how these pro-Hamas protesters are being treated, it's not because these protesters are being handled harshly.

00:09:37.860 They're being handled with kid gloves, especially compared to what protesters and demonstrators on the right experience.

00:09:46.280 So that's not their problem.

00:09:47.120 Their problem is that the left believes that their protesters, the ones on their side, should be given free reign to do whatever they want.

00:09:56.060 And if they are stopped from doing anything at all, then they are automatically oppressed.

00:10:02.340 This is the sense of entitlement obviously shared by the protesters themselves, which is what led to this unintentionally hilarious moment at Columbia University yesterday afternoon, a few hours before the police raid.

00:10:14.120 An unofficial spokeswoman for the demonstrators gave a press conference where she made a number of demands.

00:10:20.660 Now, according to reporting from Noah Pollack, a contributor to the Free Beacon, this woman's name is Johanna King Slutsky.

00:10:28.180 And according to her bio, Johanna is working on a dissertation on, quote,

00:10:31.500 Now, it's a shame to think that the world will never get to read this full dissertation now that Johanna is probably going to be expelled.

00:10:54.480 We'll have to continue on somehow without the vital information that she was going to provide us about the fantasies of limitless energy or whatever.

00:11:03.620 But in any case, now that you know what sort of person we're talking about, you will not be surprised by the demands that she made during this press conference.

00:11:11.900 Listen.

00:11:12.060 Protesters have voiced their intention to remain at Hint Hall until Columbia concedes to Quad's three demands, which are divestment, financial transparency and amnesty.

00:11:26.160 Resistance is justified in the movement for liberation.

00:11:30.640 Liberators acting in solidarity with Palestine continue to hold themselves to a higher standard than Columbia.

00:11:37.200 I cannot stress this enough. A higher standard than Columbia.

00:11:40.220 This university has repeatedly endangered its students by instituting a police state with military style checkpoints, repressing and isolating students on campus,

00:11:52.880 calling armed riot cops for the largest mass arrests on campus since 1968 and weaponizing food insecurity and houselessness in order to escalate and use as leverage in negotiations.

00:12:06.940 Colombia has forced protesters to escalate by contributing to a genocide while refusing to follow the baseline standards of conduct that make negotiations possible.

00:12:19.080 Okay, so those are the demands.

00:12:21.260 They say that they're willing to negotiate.

00:12:22.940 They will enter into negotiations, but only if Columbia University follows the rules that the burglars and trespassers have set out.

00:12:30.500 Now, of course, the problem for the group is that they have absolutely no leverage whatsoever.

00:12:36.000 They can simply be removed from the building and arrested at any time.

00:12:40.440 They have no leverage.

00:12:41.800 They have no power.

00:12:42.540 Nothing but the privilege they've been granted to cosplay as revolutionaries.

00:12:48.400 It can be revoked at any moment.

00:12:50.340 And it was, shortly after these demands were made.

00:12:53.200 But the most striking and hilarious part of this bizarre press conference was when she made a plea for, and I quote, humanitarian aid.

00:13:01.880 Why should the university be obligated to provide food to people who have taken over a building?

00:13:11.080 Well, first of all, we're saying that they're obligated to provide food to students who pay for a meal plan here.

00:13:17.080 But you mentioned that there was a request that food and water be brought in.

00:13:20.460 Unless I misunderstood.

00:13:21.080 To allow it to be brought in.

00:13:22.220 And, I mean, well, I guess it's ultimately a question of what kind of community and obligation Columbia feels it has to its students.

00:13:29.020 Do you want students to die of dehydration and starvation or get severely ill, even if they disagree with you?

00:13:35.680 If the answer is no, then you should allow basic, I mean, it's crazy to say because we're on an Ivy League campus,

00:13:41.260 but this is like basic humanitarian aid we're asking for.

00:13:43.620 Like, could people please have a glass of water?

00:13:45.680 But they did put themselves in that, very deliberately, in that situation and in that position.

00:13:53.000 So it seems like you're sort of saying, we want to be revolutionaries, we want to take over this building.

00:13:58.400 Now would you please bring us food and water?

00:14:00.780 Nobody's asking them to bring anything.

00:14:03.100 We're asking them to not violently stop us from bringing in basic humanitarian aid.

00:14:08.580 So just to be completely clear here, the humanitarian aid they're requesting is Chipotle deliveries.

00:14:14.360 So the next time you order a burrito bowl on DoorDash, remember, you're not ordering lunch.

00:14:19.040 You're requesting humanitarian aid.

00:14:22.020 So these protesters committed burglary and trespassing.

00:14:25.160 They hold themselves up in a building where they didn't belong and had no right to be.

00:14:29.260 They barricaded the doors and refused to come out and then demanded that free food be delivered to them

00:14:34.660 so that they don't, as they claim they're on the verge of doing, starve to death.

00:14:38.780 This is the level of pathological, insane, delusional, narcissistic entitlement that we're dealing with here.

00:14:45.640 It's exactly the mentality that these college campuses intentionally instill and which is now being wielded against them.

00:14:52.120 But most of all, this goes to show just how fake all of this is.

00:14:56.720 I hope that's the first thing you notice when you watch all this.

00:14:58.800 It's just so fake.

00:15:01.180 All this, that person you just saw there on camera, it's just incredibly fake.

00:15:06.840 Now, you could say these kids are radical leftists, and that's certainly true.

00:15:09.860 You can say that they're anti-American, and that's true too, which is why they've taken down American flags,

00:15:14.100 replaced them with Palestinian flags, they've shouted death to America, and so on. 0.82

00:15:17.980 You can say that they're anti-white, and they see Israel as a vehicle of whiteness, and that's why they hate it so much. 0.76

00:15:24.300 That's true. 0.96

00:15:25.280 You could say that some of these protesters actually are anti-Semites who hate Jews as a group.

00:15:29.580 And that's obviously true.

00:15:30.660 We've heard enough from some of them to know that.

00:15:32.600 But before any of that, what we must say about these protesters and their protests is that it is all fake, phony, pretend.

00:15:41.820 It is all one big performance.

00:15:45.200 The average American today, the average American, lives a life of such comfort and luxury that the pharaohs of ancient Egypt would look at them with envy.

00:15:55.680 Ivy League students have lives significantly more luxurious and comfortable than that.

00:15:59.880 You know, it's estimated that about 100 billion humans have lived on Earth since the dawn of the species.

00:16:06.200 Those kids setting up encampments and demanding free Panera bread have more wealth and privilege than almost all of those 100 billion humans.

00:16:15.180 They quite easily have it better than 99.9% of all humans who have ever lived.

00:16:20.580 These kids have never experienced hardship.

00:16:25.440 They've never experienced persecution.

00:16:27.680 They've never experienced suffering or sacrifice.

00:16:30.200 They don't even know what those words mean.

00:16:32.500 Most of them haven't even experienced being told no about anything ever.

00:16:38.380 Like they've never heard the word.

00:16:39.820 And this has made them not only entitled beyond all imagining, but also bored and dull and desperate to find meaning in pretended oppression.

00:16:51.500 They have no religion, most of them, no belief in God, no source of meaning in their lives.

00:16:55.880 And they subscribe to an ideology that paints all the world and all of history as a struggle between persecutor and persecuted.

00:17:02.520 They want to be in the latter group, if only so they can feel better about themselves and also experience some excitement in a life that otherwise consists of sitting around and staring at screens while all of their needs are met at the snap of a finger.

00:17:16.140 Their whole worldview is a part of this game of pretend.

00:17:20.020 It's not just this protest.

00:17:21.280 It's everything.

00:17:23.380 Everything these people say and do. 0.93

00:17:25.320 You know, they walk around every day in a fantasy world, one where they are the revolutionaries fighting back against a racist, white supremacist, handmaid's tale system that seeks to annihilate and enslave them.

00:17:38.700 And they maintain this fantasy and double down on it, even as the system affords them every privilege it possibly can.

00:17:45.620 In fact, the more privileges they're given, the deeper they must immerse themselves into this fantasy role-playing game so that they can maintain the fiction.

00:17:56.500 Now, of course, if they really desire depression and suffering, they could go find it.

00:18:01.580 There's always the option to actually forego their comfortable lives and move to a part of the world where they will experience the sort of deprivation and persecution that they spend their whole lives pretending to struggle against.

00:18:11.540 But they don't want the fantasy to become real any more than, you know, somebody fighting zombies in an arcade game wants to look over and find himself surrounded by the monsters in real life.

00:18:22.920 They want to keep it all inside the game, inside the virtual reality fantasy, which is what all of this really is.

00:18:31.900 Until, eventually, a piece of reality breaks through the barrier and imposes itself on them.

00:18:38.760 And in this case, they find themselves arrested and expelled from school.

00:18:43.160 You know, the good news is that now they have a real misfortune to complain about.

00:18:47.240 The bad news is they brought it on themselves.

00:18:50.220 And the worst news of all is that they will almost certainly learn nothing from the experience.

00:18:58.180 Now let's get to our five headlines.

00:19:01.900 Well, it's 2024, and if you're still spending your money with woke companies, cut it out. 0.95

00:19:09.360 There are a lot of great companies out there that aren't shoving diversity and inclusion initiatives down the throats of their employees or their customers.

00:19:15.960 Maybe you're already doing business with some of these.

00:19:17.820 That's great.

00:19:18.380 Maybe you're boycotting companies who have made headlines by acquiring the latest trans influencer as their spokesperson.

00:19:24.280 That's even better.

00:19:24.960 But have you given much thought to where your money is currently invested?

00:19:28.160 A lot of big wealth management companies make billions of dollars investing your money however they want, wherever they want.

00:19:34.160 Even if that means investing in businesses who don't care about your values or even actively oppose your values.

00:19:39.920 Align your portfolio with your principles today with my friends at Constitution Wealth.

00:19:45.140 Constitution Wealth is the patriot's choice in wealth management.

00:19:47.440 They'll help you build a solid investment plan while reducing your investments in the ESGs and DEIs, companies that care more about global warming and diversity ratios than they do about the return on your investment.

00:19:58.160 And with Constitution Wealth, you can start using your shareholder votes to support conservative action.

00:20:03.780 Fight the culture war with your most valuable weapon, your investments.

00:20:07.460 Help build the parallel economy by working with an investment firm composed of professionals who are patriots like you.

00:20:12.400 Go to ConstitutionWealth.com slash Matt and sign up for a free consultation today.

00:20:17.480 That's ConstitutionWealth.com slash Matt.

00:20:21.120 CNN has this report.

00:20:22.780 The House is expected to vote Wednesday on the Bipartisan Anti-Semitism Awareness Act, a vote that comes amid heightened concerns over anti-Semitism with Israel at war with Hamas.

00:20:32.960 Propel sitting in protests have sprung up across college campuses across the country.

00:20:36.100 Supporters of legislation say it will help combat anti-Semitism on college campuses, but opponents say it overreaches and threatens to chill free speech.

00:20:43.980 The bill would mandate that when the Department of Education enforces federal anti-discrimination laws, it uses a definition of anti-Semitism put forward by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance.

00:20:55.640 New York Republican Mike Lawler, who introduced legislation, said in a statement,

00:20:58.840 It's critical that we crack down on anti-Semitic hate within our own country.

00:21:04.560 The American Civil Literaries Union, however, has called on lawmakers to oppose the bill.

00:21:08.580 In a letter to representatives, the ACLU wrote,

00:21:11.180 Federal law already prohibits anti-Semitic discrimination and harassment by federally funded entities.

00:21:17.080 H.R. 6090 is therefore not needed to protect against anti-Semitic discrimination.

00:21:21.660 Instead, it would likely chill free speech of students on college campuses by incorrectly equating criticism of the Israeli government with anti-Semitism.

00:21:29.660 Okay, so, already I don't really like any of this.

00:21:33.220 I don't like it because, first of all, I oppose anything that even resembles a hate speech law.

00:21:38.300 But then on the other side, we have the ACLU pretending to care about free speech,

00:21:42.340 when in most cases they're diametrically opposed to free speech.

00:21:45.420 And they're even criticizing the bill because it supposedly is redundant.

00:21:49.960 Except, you know, this same organization has come out in favor of all kinds of anti-hate bills and laws

00:21:57.100 that both chill free speech and prohibit things that are already prohibited.

00:22:01.880 So, you know, I don't like the sound of the law.

00:22:04.820 I also don't like, I can't stand the opponents we've heard from so far.

00:22:09.620 So, I don't like anything here.

00:22:10.900 But before I say anything else about it, let's try to get the full story.

00:22:16.880 The bill would mandate the Department of Education use the definition of anti-Semitism

00:22:21.140 provided by something called the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance.

00:22:26.980 Now, why are we adopting a decree from the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance into law?

00:22:35.320 Why should a definition that they came up with be engraved in stone?

00:22:41.300 And what is their definition?

00:22:43.660 Like, I've actually read several different articles about this, including the one from CNN there,

00:22:50.340 about, you know, they're going to have a new definition of anti-Semitism in the law.

00:22:55.420 None of the articles say what that is.

00:22:57.200 Like, how do you report on this bill about the new definition of anti-Semitism

00:23:02.160 without even telling us what it is?

00:23:04.000 Isn't that the main question here?

00:23:06.600 But they don't.

00:23:07.260 So, let's go to the text of the bill and see if we can learn more.

00:23:10.720 I mean, surely the bill itself will tell us what the definition is, right?

00:23:15.400 So, let me read a little bit from the bill.

00:23:19.980 Anti-Semitism is on the rise in the United States as impacting Jewish students in K-12 schools, colleges, and universities.

00:23:26.160 The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance working definition of anti-Semitism

00:23:29.340 is a vital tool which helps individuals understand and identify the various manifestations of anti-Semitism.

00:23:34.480 Now, what is the actual definition of anti-Semitism?

00:23:40.320 I'm still looking for that.

00:23:42.540 I'm skimming through it right now.

00:23:43.900 For purpose of this act, the term definition of anti-Semitism means the definition of anti-Semitism

00:23:48.700 adopted on May 26th by the IHRA, of which the United States is a member,

00:23:54.840 which definition has been adopted by the Department of State

00:23:57.140 and includes the contemporary examples of anti-Semitism identified in the IHRA definition.

00:24:03.780 Okay, and it's a short bill, and looking through it, that's basically what it says.

00:24:09.580 So, if you perhaps noticed, the bill wants to update the definition of anti-Semitism,

00:24:14.680 but it doesn't actually say what the new definition is.

00:24:19.180 And that's, you can go look for yourself.

00:24:20.500 This is a bill that updates the definition of anti-Semitism,

00:24:23.400 but the bill itself does not tell you what that definition is, which is crazy, right?

00:24:31.040 So, we've now read an article about a bill changing the definition of anti-Semitism,

00:24:36.300 and the bill itself, which does the change,

00:24:41.040 and we still don't know what the definition actually is.

00:24:44.560 They refer to the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance and its definition,

00:24:48.640 as if, like, we all know that off the top of our head,

00:24:51.640 as if they will, as if we're all saying,

00:24:54.000 oh, yeah, oh, yeah, the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance.

00:24:56.680 Sure, I remember that, of course, them.

00:25:00.200 Now, I must admit that I have no idea what this organization is,

00:25:02.960 or what definition they came up with,

00:25:04.460 or why in the hell anything they said should have any legal weight whatsoever.

00:25:09.560 So, let's go to their website to see if we can get more clarity.

00:25:14.440 So, this is the third place we have to go,

00:25:16.260 just to figure out what exactly is happening here.

00:25:18.520 And once we do that, you go to their website,

00:25:21.580 and then you look around, and you'll find a page on anti-Semitism.

00:25:25.640 And that page, and you have to scroll down that page a little bit,

00:25:28.840 and then finally, you'll get to a definition.

00:25:32.060 And here's what it is.

00:25:32.920 Okay, well, actually, as far as definitions go,

00:25:55.080 that seems fine, but why?

00:26:00.020 Yeah, anti-Semitism is hatred towards Jews.

00:26:02.800 And if you hate Jews collectively for being Jews,

00:26:05.400 then you're anti-Semitic.

00:26:08.440 Sure, I think we could all agree with that.

00:26:09.980 I mean, what else would anti-Semitism mean if it doesn't mean that?

00:26:13.400 But why does that need to be clarified?

00:26:16.860 Isn't that we all understand that that's what anti-Semitism is?

00:26:19.640 Why do we need a new law? 1.00

00:26:21.860 And why does the law need to cite this particular group

00:26:24.700 for that very obvious definition?

00:26:29.160 Well, I think it's because, you may recall,

00:26:31.200 the bill also says that the legal definition

00:26:33.720 should include this organization's, quote,

00:26:37.780 contemporary examples of anti-Semitism.

00:26:40.820 So, it's not just, so they have the broad definition.

00:26:43.660 Anti-Semitism is hating Jewish people.

00:26:45.400 Sure, of course, that's what it is.

00:26:46.580 But the bill says part of the definition

00:26:51.340 is the examples that this organization provides.

00:26:56.520 So, we have to scroll down a little bit further to find those.

00:26:59.460 And let's go through some of these.

00:27:02.160 Here are the examples of anti-Semitism.

00:27:05.580 Calling for, aiding, or justifying 0.78

00:27:07.420 the killing or harming of Jews 0.99

00:27:08.700 in the names of a radical ideology 0.99

00:27:10.140 or an extremist view of religion.

00:27:13.220 Sure.

00:27:13.660 Calling for, aiding, and justifying 1.00

00:27:16.140 the killing of Jews. 1.00

00:27:17.360 Anti-Semitic, obviously. 0.99

00:27:21.860 But it continues.

00:27:23.520 Making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, 0.55

00:27:26.180 or stereotypical allegations about Jews

00:27:28.720 as such, as Jews as such, 0.97

00:27:30.440 or the power of Jews as collective,

00:27:33.000 such as, especially but not exclusively,

00:27:35.280 the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy

00:27:37.060 or of Jews controlling the media, economy, 0.92

00:27:39.480 government, or other societal institutions.

00:27:41.100 Accusing Jews as a people of being responsible

00:27:44.240 for real or imagined wrongdoing

00:27:45.960 committed by a single Jewish person or group.

00:27:49.260 Denying the fact, scope, mechanisms,

00:27:51.440 or intentionality of the genocide

00:27:52.880 of the Jewish people by the Nazis.

00:27:55.680 Accusing the Jews as a people or Israel as a state

00:27:57.880 of inventing or exaggerating the Holocaust.

00:28:00.320 Accusing Jewish citizens of being more loyal to Israel

00:28:02.620 or to the alleged priorities of Jews worldwide

00:28:04.560 than to interests of their own nations.

00:28:07.420 Denying the Jewish people their right 1.00

00:28:08.700 to self-determination, e.g. by claiming

00:28:11.300 that the existence of a state of Israel

00:28:12.720 is a racist endeavor.

00:28:14.840 Applying double standards by requiring of it

00:28:16.680 a behavior not expected or demanded

00:28:18.580 of any other democratic nation.

00:28:20.540 Using symbols and images associated

00:28:22.060 with classical anti-Semitism

00:28:23.260 to characterize Israel or Israelis.

00:28:25.920 Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy

00:28:28.140 to that of the Nazis.

00:28:30.300 Holding Jews collectively responsible 1.00

00:28:31.980 for actions of the state of Israel.

00:28:33.880 Okay.

00:28:34.060 And there it is.

00:28:37.660 So, the definition itself seems reasonable.

00:28:41.100 The examples,

00:28:42.960 which are also given the force of law

00:28:45.860 by this legislation,

00:28:47.920 go way, way, way beyond

00:28:50.160 the simple meaning of the definition.

00:28:52.660 And this is where we get to the problems.

00:28:55.200 Because, you know,

00:28:58.100 stereotyping Jews, for example,

00:29:00.480 they say, well, that's anti-Semitic.

00:29:02.360 And they want to put that into law.

00:29:04.460 But it's not.

00:29:05.920 Okay.

00:29:06.120 Not necessarily.

00:29:07.820 There are stereotypes about every group of people.

00:29:10.140 And believing those stereotypes

00:29:11.900 or repeating them

00:29:13.100 is not necessarily hateful towards that group.

00:29:16.640 Okay.

00:29:17.240 To begin with,

00:29:20.360 we all have stereotypical beliefs

00:29:23.380 about groups that are not our own.

00:29:26.740 And we might have stereotypical beliefs

00:29:27.840 about our own groups.

00:29:28.640 But every person on the planet

00:29:30.960 who has ever lived

00:29:31.760 has beliefs about other groups of people,

00:29:35.320 sort of generalities

00:29:36.460 that you believe to be true about that group.

00:29:39.640 That doesn't make you racist, necessarily.

00:29:42.100 It doesn't make you anti-Semitic.

00:29:43.380 It doesn't make you bigoted.

00:29:44.640 It just makes you a person.

00:29:47.000 And even if those stereotypes are wrong,

00:29:50.360 even if they're both wrong and insulting,

00:29:53.180 they're not necessarily bigoted.

00:29:55.220 Because it might just be

00:29:57.600 that you really think that.

00:29:58.780 This might just be a generalization

00:30:00.240 that you personally have observed to be true.

00:30:02.320 And maybe you're wrong.

00:30:03.720 Maybe you're right.

00:30:05.000 Doesn't make you a bigot.

00:30:06.040 So, for example,

00:30:08.100 is it actually true

00:30:10.920 that Asians in general 0.80

00:30:12.420 tend to be bad drivers?

00:30:14.480 That's a stereotype.

00:30:15.640 I actually don't know if it's true.

00:30:17.100 I haven't checked the data.

00:30:18.360 I don't know if there is any data

00:30:20.960 that would confirm or refute that.

00:30:22.760 I don't know.

00:30:24.200 But if you earnestly happen to believe

00:30:26.480 that most Asians 0.73

00:30:27.600 happen to be bad drivers,

00:30:29.860 like maybe in your own life

00:30:31.400 you've observed that anecdotally

00:30:32.920 and you've drawn conclusions

00:30:34.660 based on your anecdotal evidence,

00:30:37.200 that doesn't mean you hate Asians.

00:30:40.260 It could just mean

00:30:41.420 that based on your observations,

00:30:42.860 that claim seems to be true

00:30:44.480 from your perspective,

00:30:46.040 even if it isn't true.

00:30:47.220 You could just think that it is.

00:30:50.740 That still doesn't make you guilty

00:30:52.200 of anti-Asian hate.

00:30:55.380 I'm a person of Irish descent.

00:30:58.120 A stereotype of Irish people

00:30:59.420 is that they have

00:31:00.520 an exorbitant affinity

00:31:03.420 for alcohol,

00:31:05.660 especially whiskey.

00:31:08.220 Well, I mean,

00:31:09.060 that one probably is true.

00:31:11.940 But if you happen to think that

00:31:13.640 about Irish people,

00:31:15.220 I'm not going to accuse you

00:31:16.800 of hating Irish people

00:31:17.980 whether it's true or not.

00:31:21.000 And this logic applies

00:31:22.580 to all groups

00:31:23.340 and Jewish people

00:31:24.860 are included in that.

00:31:27.580 But the most concerning thing here

00:31:29.100 is that the examples

00:31:32.300 of anti-Semitism,

00:31:33.320 which again,

00:31:33.820 this bill wants to codify into law,

00:31:36.400 the examples conflate

00:31:38.140 Jews and Israel.

00:31:40.880 Okay, making certain

00:31:41.740 critical statements about Israel

00:31:43.240 and Israeli policy

00:31:44.140 is anti-Semitic, it says.

00:31:45.600 And that is just wrong.

00:31:47.320 And codifying that into law

00:31:48.620 is pure madness.

00:31:51.380 Codifying into law

00:31:52.260 that you should be able,

00:31:54.840 as an American,

00:31:55.500 to make any critical statement

00:31:56.820 of any government

00:31:57.700 on the planet,

00:31:58.380 including your own,

00:31:59.700 and any foreign government

00:32:01.460 to say any statement you want.

00:32:03.320 Again, even if it's not true.

00:32:04.740 Now, do I think that

00:32:07.140 the Israeli government

00:32:08.140 is akin to the Nazis 0.83

00:32:12.800 carrying out a genocidal agenda?

00:32:16.500 No.

00:32:17.760 Could a person believe that?

00:32:20.120 Could a person come to believe that

00:32:21.380 about the Israeli government 0.63

00:32:22.440 without hating all Jewish people?

00:32:24.800 Yes, of course they could.

00:32:26.160 The government is a political entity.

00:32:27.900 Its policies are products

00:32:29.400 of that political entity.

00:32:30.700 You can have any opinion

00:32:32.380 at all about a government

00:32:34.380 without being a bigot

00:32:35.400 against anybody.

00:32:36.760 The same way that you could

00:32:38.060 make unflattering statements

00:32:41.380 about the government

00:32:42.040 of Uganda

00:32:43.720 without hating Ugandans.

00:32:47.240 Or especially without hating

00:32:48.820 black people in general.

00:32:51.640 So you can think 0.95

00:32:52.800 the Israeli government

00:32:53.580 is completely wrong

00:32:54.520 in everything that it does.

00:32:55.840 And if you think that,

00:32:57.700 then you're certainly

00:32:58.500 anti-Israeli government.

00:33:00.660 You might even be anti-Israel.

00:33:02.500 That doesn't make you

00:33:03.160 anti-Jews in general.

00:33:05.900 Like, you might just happen

00:33:07.240 to believe that

00:33:08.160 Israeli policy is wrong. 0.78

00:33:09.480 Whether you're right or wrong

00:33:10.500 for thinking that,

00:33:11.160 the idea that you can't think it 0.99

00:33:12.820 without also hating Jews 0.77

00:33:14.180 is again simply false.

00:33:15.620 And enshrining that into law

00:33:16.840 is just crazy.

00:33:19.760 It is just crazy.

00:33:21.900 But it gets worse

00:33:23.000 because the final example

00:33:24.280 says this.

00:33:24.820 Holding Jews collectively 0.98

00:33:26.340 responsible for actions

00:33:27.460 of the state of Israel.

00:33:29.880 That's also anti-Semitism.

00:33:31.320 Well, wait a second.

00:33:32.760 So now we can't conflate

00:33:34.260 Jews and Israel,

00:33:35.120 but half of these examples

00:33:36.360 do exactly that.

00:33:38.860 So to hold Jews responsible 0.99

00:33:40.240 for the actions

00:33:40.760 of the state of Israel

00:33:41.300 is anti-Semitic.

00:33:42.760 But at the same time,

00:33:44.080 if you are critical

00:33:45.200 of the actions

00:33:45.600 of the state of Israel, 0.99

00:33:46.540 you hate all Jews. 0.99

00:33:47.920 So you can't conflate 0.99

00:33:49.340 them this way,

00:33:49.780 but you can conflate

00:33:50.400 them that way.

00:33:51.020 Doesn't make any sense.

00:33:52.060 One minute we're told

00:33:52.840 that if we criticize

00:33:53.580 Israeli policy,

00:33:54.360 we're Jew haters,

00:33:55.080 the next minute we're told

00:33:55.940 that if we conflate Jews

00:33:57.100 and Israel,

00:33:57.560 we're Jew haters.

00:33:58.160 Like, which is it?

00:33:59.960 How can it be both?

00:34:01.500 It can't be.

00:34:04.080 And all of this

00:34:05.920 is just so,

00:34:06.880 it's so unnecessary.

00:34:12.140 A total unforced error

00:34:13.660 by any Republican

00:34:14.580 involving themselves in this.

00:34:15.760 none of it is needed.

00:34:18.840 We don't need any new

00:34:19.960 special anti-Semitism laws.

00:34:21.800 We don't need anything

00:34:22.380 like that.

00:34:23.100 We don't need to expand

00:34:24.500 the definition of anti-Semitism.

00:34:25.860 We don't need to change it.

00:34:26.660 We don't need anything like that.

00:34:28.620 Because if what you're worried

00:34:30.300 about primarily

00:34:30.980 is what's happening

00:34:31.780 on college campuses,

00:34:33.920 well, guess what?

00:34:34.840 As we saw at Columbia,

00:34:36.280 you can just enforce

00:34:37.720 the actual laws

00:34:39.060 that already exist.

00:34:41.340 Laws that have nothing 0.84

00:34:42.100 to do with ideologies,

00:34:43.820 worldviews, bigotry, anything.

00:34:46.580 You can just enforce

00:34:47.220 the actual laws.

00:34:48.400 Laws against burglary.

00:34:50.040 Laws against trespassing.

00:34:51.500 Laws against vandalism.

00:34:52.840 Laws against loitering.

00:34:54.440 Laws against setting up

00:34:55.240 illegal encampments.

00:34:56.560 Laws against inciting violence.

00:34:58.580 Laws against making

00:34:59.240 direct physical threats

00:35:00.500 against people.

00:35:02.360 Those are all laws that exist.

00:35:03.980 You enforce all of those laws

00:35:05.660 and there is no problem.

00:35:08.220 We wouldn't even be talking

00:35:09.360 about what's happening

00:35:10.000 at college campuses.

00:35:10.580 The most you would see

00:35:11.480 is you would have

00:35:11.880 college kids out on campus

00:35:13.600 like holding signs

00:35:14.620 and then going home at night.

00:35:17.060 And that's not a problem.

00:35:18.540 Who cares if they do that?

00:35:20.780 It only becomes a problem

00:35:22.280 when you add in

00:35:23.200 all of the criminal activity

00:35:24.860 on top of it.

00:35:27.560 But you can crack down

00:35:29.480 on that criminal activity

00:35:30.340 without any new piece

00:35:31.440 of legislation.

00:35:32.180 There's no new piece

00:35:32.960 of legislation that we need

00:35:34.640 to enable you to do that.

00:35:37.840 So I find this

00:35:38.760 very frustrating.

00:35:41.040 Okay.

00:35:43.560 Reuters says this.

00:35:44.700 The U.S. Supreme Court

00:35:45.380 declined on Tuesday

00:35:46.240 to block a Texas law

00:35:47.340 requiring online age verification

00:35:49.100 in order to access

00:35:50.000 pornographic websites

00:35:51.000 in a case pitting

00:35:51.800 the Republican-led state's

00:35:53.100 effort to keep adult content

00:35:54.800 away from minors

00:35:55.660 against constitutional

00:35:56.500 free speech protections.

00:35:57.960 With no publicly

00:35:59.020 noted dissents,

00:35:59.940 the justice denied

00:36:00.720 a request by a trade group

00:36:01.940 representing adult

00:36:02.680 entertainment performers

00:36:03.640 and other challengers

00:36:04.720 to the law

00:36:05.100 to put on hold

00:36:05.800 a lower court's ruling

00:36:06.800 that the measure

00:36:07.920 likely did not violate

00:36:08.940 the U.S. Constitution's

00:36:09.840 First Amendment safeguards

00:36:10.740 against government

00:36:11.280 interference with freedom

00:36:12.080 of speech.

00:36:12.460 The 2023 law

00:36:13.660 requires any website

00:36:14.640 whose content is more

00:36:15.760 than a third sexual material

00:36:16.940 harmful to minors

00:36:17.660 to require all users

00:36:18.700 including adults

00:36:19.300 to submit personally

00:36:20.360 identifying information

00:36:21.220 verifying that they're

00:36:21.900 at least 18 years old

00:36:22.840 to gain access.

00:36:23.920 several other states

00:36:26.560 have enacted

00:36:26.920 similar legislation.

00:36:30.060 This was challenged

00:36:30.900 of course by the ACLU

00:36:31.940 and others

00:36:32.420 including Pornhub

00:36:34.640 and XNXX.com

00:36:37.340 are also among the plaintiffs.

00:36:42.860 So, you know,

00:36:45.180 speaking of contradictions,

00:36:46.420 I love this move

00:36:47.400 from the defenders

00:36:48.060 of the porn industry.

00:36:49.360 On the one hand,

00:36:50.700 they tell us that

00:36:51.560 laws protecting children

00:36:53.140 from porn

00:36:53.740 will be totally ineffective.

00:36:55.460 That's also in this article.

00:36:56.640 They say that

00:36:57.080 it's not effective

00:37:01.600 because it can be bypassed

00:37:03.460 and so it doesn't do anything.

00:37:04.760 So, on one hand,

00:37:05.500 they say that

00:37:06.160 these laws are ineffective

00:37:10.020 and won't actually prevent

00:37:11.900 anyone from accessing porn.

00:37:13.200 On the other hand,

00:37:13.720 they tell us

00:37:14.180 that it's a draconian assault

00:37:16.020 on free speech

00:37:16.880 and will stifle free expression.

00:37:20.400 Like,

00:37:21.020 if the first claim is true,

00:37:23.140 then what's even the problem?

00:37:25.720 What's the problem?

00:37:26.320 From your perspective,

00:37:27.160 what's the problem?

00:37:28.560 If it's having no effect

00:37:29.720 on free speech anyway,

00:37:31.380 then what do you care?

00:37:32.960 But in fact,

00:37:33.620 these laws do have an effect.

00:37:35.900 The porn industry

00:37:36.900 does take a hit

00:37:37.920 when underage children

00:37:39.460 are prevented

00:37:40.040 or at least hindered

00:37:40.980 from accessing pornography.

00:37:43.320 So what does that tell you?

00:37:44.640 Pornhub has disabled,

00:37:46.380 they've disabled

00:37:47.060 all access to their site

00:37:48.520 in Texas

00:37:49.180 over this law.

00:37:50.140 And again,

00:37:51.980 what does that tell you?

00:37:52.880 I mean,

00:37:53.100 if they can't,

00:37:54.140 if they cannot,

00:37:55.260 what they're saying

00:37:55.800 is that if they can't

00:37:56.580 allow children on the site,

00:37:58.440 then they figure

00:37:59.460 they might as well

00:37:59.980 just shut down business

00:38:00.840 completely in the state.

00:38:02.580 So what do we glean from that?

00:38:04.800 Well, I'll tell you what.

00:38:06.200 The porn industry

00:38:07.440 has made a lot of money,

00:38:08.980 a lot,

00:38:10.680 a lot of money,

00:38:11.740 by distributing

00:38:13.100 this kind of content

00:38:14.080 to minors.

00:38:14.640 That's a huge part

00:38:15.400 of their customer base.

00:38:16.260 It's part of their business model,

00:38:17.300 and they know it.

00:38:18.560 And that's why

00:38:19.080 they oppose these laws

00:38:20.160 so stridently.

00:38:21.440 And it's why

00:38:22.760 they'll even shut down

00:38:23.980 operation in the state

00:38:25.040 if you prevent them

00:38:25.740 from distributing

00:38:26.940 content to minors

00:38:27.840 because it's like

00:38:29.140 such a major part

00:38:30.480 of their customer base,

00:38:31.080 there's no point

00:38:31.640 of even being

00:38:33.300 in business anymore.

00:38:35.360 It's like if you

00:38:36.460 passed a law

00:38:37.120 saying that Fox News

00:38:38.140 is not allowed to,

00:38:39.780 you know,

00:38:40.060 that you're not allowed,

00:38:41.780 Fox News has to cut off

00:38:42.820 access to boomers.

00:38:44.420 Like no more boomers 1.00

00:38:45.280 are allowed to watch Fox News.

00:38:46.580 Well, if you do that,

00:38:47.940 then Fox News

00:38:48.460 is just going to shut down

00:38:49.220 because they say,

00:38:49.680 well, what's the point?

00:38:50.260 That's like my whole

00:38:50.880 customer base.

00:38:51.780 There's no one else

00:38:52.420 to talk to.

00:38:53.300 That's it.

00:38:54.760 And it's a similar thing

00:38:55.800 with the porn industry

00:38:57.140 and underage kids

00:38:58.900 that, you know,

00:39:00.080 as much as they claim otherwise

00:39:01.900 is a major part

00:39:04.220 of their customer base.

00:39:05.820 And if you take that away,

00:39:07.520 then they might as well

00:39:10.100 not even be in business.

00:39:11.060 So just to reiterate

00:39:15.460 some points I made

00:39:16.320 before about this,

00:39:17.160 first of all,

00:39:18.580 we already require

00:39:19.980 age verification

00:39:20.900 for every other

00:39:22.480 adult-oriented product

00:39:24.120 and nobody objects

00:39:26.340 to any of that.

00:39:28.040 Nobody objects

00:39:29.040 to the idea

00:39:29.720 that you should have

00:39:30.560 to show an ID

00:39:31.300 to purchase alcohol

00:39:32.260 or to gamble

00:39:33.460 in person

00:39:34.100 or online

00:39:34.960 or to buy

00:39:37.160 or consume

00:39:37.920 anything else

00:39:39.000 that's supposed to be

00:39:39.600 for adults only.

00:39:41.100 Nobody objects.

00:39:43.160 These laws are

00:39:44.120 not singling

00:39:45.680 the porn industry out.

00:39:47.620 They aren't treating

00:39:48.460 the porn industry

00:39:49.040 any differently.

00:39:51.720 You know?

00:39:52.560 Now, I personally think

00:39:53.600 that we should treat

00:39:54.300 the porn industry differently.

00:39:56.020 I think the porn industry

00:39:57.120 shouldn't even exist

00:39:58.340 in my estimation.

00:40:01.180 But that's my personal view.

00:40:03.580 And that's not

00:40:04.300 what these laws are doing.

00:40:05.180 These laws are simply

00:40:05.840 bringing the porn industry

00:40:06.980 into line

00:40:08.220 with every other industry.

00:40:10.480 All that the law

00:40:11.380 is saying

00:40:11.840 to the porn industry

00:40:12.540 is you aren't special.

00:40:14.580 You have to abide

00:40:15.280 by the same rules

00:40:15.900 as everybody else.

00:40:17.200 You have an adult-oriented product

00:40:18.500 and so you have to make sure

00:40:19.300 that the people

00:40:19.740 consuming your product

00:40:20.420 are actually adults.

00:40:21.620 That's all it's doing.

00:40:23.540 And this has nothing

00:40:24.420 to do with free speech also.

00:40:26.160 Like, you don't have

00:40:27.280 the free speech right

00:40:29.000 to distribute porn

00:40:30.060 to children.

00:40:31.400 That part shouldn't

00:40:32.240 need to be explained.

00:40:32.960 And porn in general

00:40:37.620 has nothing to do

00:40:38.600 with free speech.

00:40:40.320 And why is that?

00:40:41.220 Because speech

00:40:41.800 is a form of communication.

00:40:43.780 That's what speech is.

00:40:45.200 It's not that hard.

00:40:46.020 We act like

00:40:46.500 defining a word

00:40:47.660 like speech

00:40:48.220 is so difficult.

00:40:49.560 We've had to debate it

00:40:50.600 for decades.

00:40:51.460 What is speech?

00:40:52.280 How do you define speech?

00:40:53.560 It's actually not hard.

00:40:54.900 Speech is communication.

00:40:55.880 That's what speech is.

00:40:57.080 If you're communicating something,

00:40:58.500 then you're engaging

00:40:59.040 in speech.

00:41:01.480 Okay, now there are

00:41:02.000 some forms of speech,

00:41:02.960 even things that qualify

00:41:03.940 as speech

00:41:04.440 that shouldn't be allowed,

00:41:05.220 like threatening violence

00:41:06.600 against somebody,

00:41:07.180 but that is speech.

00:41:08.960 Okay, so

00:41:09.300 if you're communicating something,

00:41:12.280 if you're conveying

00:41:12.940 a message of some kind,

00:41:14.780 then you are engaged

00:41:16.000 in speech.

00:41:17.780 Talking is communication.

00:41:20.120 Singing

00:41:20.400 is communication.

00:41:23.080 Writing,

00:41:24.560 putting a statement

00:41:25.320 on a picket sign.

00:41:27.720 Art communicates.

00:41:30.240 Right, but

00:41:30.600 porn 0.99

00:41:32.220 is sex 0.99

00:41:33.500 on camera.

00:41:35.060 It does not

00:41:35.680 convey meaning.

00:41:38.180 If something

00:41:38.840 is not designed

00:41:39.460 to convey meaning,

00:41:40.180 then it's not speech.

00:41:42.580 Nobody watches porn

00:41:43.980 and says to themselves,

00:41:44.980 hmm,

00:41:45.720 what are the artists

00:41:46.600 trying to say

00:41:47.440 to us here?

00:41:48.760 What are they conveying?

00:41:50.940 What are they trying

00:41:51.760 to say?

00:41:52.240 Nobody does that.

00:41:54.080 Okay,

00:41:54.560 nobody in the history

00:41:55.460 of porn consumption

00:41:56.160 has ever consumed

00:41:56.860 porn that way.

00:41:58.500 Nobody's ever watched

00:41:59.420 a porn and said,

00:42:00.280 what are they,

00:42:01.080 what's the message?

00:42:03.080 What are they,

00:42:03.440 what are they communicating?

00:42:06.980 No one has looked

00:42:07.880 at a,

00:42:08.220 you know,

00:42:08.760 a woman,

00:42:10.600 you know, 0.83

00:42:10.960 in porn and said,

00:42:12.260 look, 0.94

00:42:13.280 she's trying to

00:42:13.840 communicate with me.

00:42:15.120 It's never happened.

00:42:17.500 And again,

00:42:18.460 everyone,

00:42:18.860 this is,

00:42:19.080 this is the kind 1.00

00:42:19.600 of playing dumb, 0.99

00:42:20.520 you know, 1.00

00:42:20.620 the defenders of porn

00:42:21.620 are constantly playing 1.00

00:42:22.520 dumb about everything 0.99

00:42:23.300 and they know 1.00

00:42:24.340 that they are.

00:42:25.820 You know,

00:42:26.340 all of their objections

00:42:27.720 to having age verification,

00:42:30.560 all of that 0.97

00:42:30.980 is playing dumb. 0.99

00:42:32.620 They understand everything. 1.00

00:42:33.680 They understand

00:42:34.480 that this is,

00:42:35.160 that it's,

00:42:35.500 that obviously

00:42:36.480 they should be required

00:42:37.640 to verify ages.

00:42:38.920 The only reason

00:42:39.820 why adults

00:42:42.000 don't want that

00:42:43.040 is because

00:42:44.620 they don't care

00:42:45.060 about the kids

00:42:45.660 in the first place,

00:42:46.520 but mainly it's because

00:42:47.620 they want to have

00:42:48.900 a cheap,

00:42:50.640 well,

00:42:50.860 not even cheap

00:42:51.300 because this wouldn't

00:42:52.080 cost anything.

00:42:52.520 they want to have

00:42:53.220 immediate access

00:42:54.220 to porn

00:42:54.760 without being inconvenienced

00:42:56.220 in their pursuit 0.67

00:42:57.280 of masturbatory material. 0.95

00:42:59.300 And also, 0.96

00:43:00.000 they don't want

00:43:00.460 to be embarrassed.

00:43:01.120 Like,

00:43:01.300 they don't want

00:43:01.720 the embarrassment

00:43:02.260 of having to give

00:43:03.860 an ID

00:43:04.180 or having to give

00:43:04.900 a credit card

00:43:05.760 or whatever.

00:43:07.580 But,

00:43:08.420 you know,

00:43:09.560 your desire

00:43:10.560 to find 0.94

00:43:11.440 masturbation material 0.90

00:43:13.100 that,

00:43:15.240 in a way

00:43:15.940 that is quick

00:43:17.160 and easy

00:43:17.620 and doesn't embarrass you,

00:43:18.580 like,

00:43:18.840 that is not,

00:43:19.480 that is not

00:43:21.580 a concern

00:43:23.320 that overrides

00:43:24.920 the concern

00:43:25.520 of protecting

00:43:26.220 children from

00:43:26.800 this material.

00:43:27.880 Sorry.

00:43:29.900 You're going to be

00:43:30.400 a little embarrassed?

00:43:31.540 Well,

00:43:31.940 you should be

00:43:32.360 because it's,

00:43:33.220 you know,

00:43:33.420 you should be embarrassed.

00:43:33.840 It's an embarrassing thing.

00:43:35.160 And before internet

00:43:35.760 pornography existed,

00:43:37.880 like,

00:43:38.120 if you wanted

00:43:38.540 to obtain porn, 0.99

00:43:39.880 you had to be embarrassed. 0.98

00:43:41.500 Like,

00:43:41.800 you've got to go

00:43:42.320 to the gas station

00:43:43.380 and be one of the guys

00:43:44.280 that gets the magazine

00:43:45.780 that used to be

00:43:46.340 in plastic,

00:43:47.040 you know,

00:43:47.240 behind all the other magazines

00:43:48.380 and you have to actually,

00:43:48.980 reach over

00:43:50.540 and grab that magazine

00:43:51.460 and go to the counter

00:43:52.520 and pay for it

00:43:53.180 and feel like 0.99

00:43:54.280 a kind of pathetic, 1.00

00:43:55.280 dirty person 1.00

00:43:55.900 doing it. 0.98

00:43:56.840 And,

00:43:57.100 you know,

00:43:57.720 that's,

00:43:58.440 and that's how you feel,

00:43:59.480 you should feel

00:43:59.820 because it's like 0.98

00:44:00.280 a pathetic thing. 0.80

00:44:01.940 But anyway, 1.00

00:44:02.840 that's all playing dumb. 0.98

00:44:05.680 And then on the 0.99

00:44:06.360 free speech thing too,

00:44:07.400 like,

00:44:07.620 everyone who claims,

00:44:10.960 well, 0.73

00:44:11.080 porn is art.

00:44:11.920 It communicates.

00:44:12.620 Oh, 1.00

00:44:12.700 shut up. 1.00

00:44:13.540 Shut up. 1.00

00:44:14.740 You don't think that. 1.00

00:44:16.240 Nobody does.

00:44:16.820 that's not what it is. 0.94

00:44:19.560 Porn is prostitution. 0.98

00:44:22.220 It's sex for money. 1.00

00:44:23.280 That's what it is. 0.73

00:44:24.740 And it's not speech

00:44:25.980 and should not enjoy

00:44:28.160 any of the protections

00:44:28.940 that speech enjoys.

00:44:29.820 Who doesn't love

00:44:40.360 a good comeback story,

00:44:41.340 especially when it's

00:44:41.960 my favorite meat company

00:44:43.400 bringing back

00:44:44.160 their Price Lock Guarantee.

00:44:45.960 Yes,

00:44:46.160 it's true.

00:44:46.880 Good Rancher's 0.72

00:44:47.500 Price Lock Guarantee

00:44:48.320 is back offering

00:44:49.380 exclusive Price Lock

00:44:50.640 on 100% American meat.

00:44:52.760 This is your last chance

00:44:54.160 to subscribe

00:44:54.660 and have Good Rancher

00:44:55.560 secure your pricing,

00:44:57.060 shielding you from inflation

00:44:58.020 until 2026.

00:44:58.900 Subscribe to any

00:45:00.040 of their meat boxes

00:45:00.740 and secure your price

00:45:01.740 against inflation

00:45:02.500 for the next 18 months.

00:45:04.240 Goodranchers.com

00:45:05.040 is where I get

00:45:05.780 the most tender,

00:45:06.960 flavorful meat

00:45:07.640 with options like

00:45:08.600 beef, chicken, pork,

00:45:09.660 and wild-caught seafood.

00:45:10.960 They have something

00:45:11.500 for even the pickiest

00:45:12.520 of eaters.

00:45:13.360 What I really love

00:45:13.840 about Good Ranchers

00:45:14.500 is their commitment

00:45:15.820 to transparency.

00:45:16.800 They believe that you

00:45:17.340 have the right to know

00:45:18.080 exactly what's in your food.

00:45:19.680 They're amazing supporters

00:45:20.620 of this show,

00:45:21.300 so go support them.

00:45:22.660 Take the mystery

00:45:23.440 out of all the meat

00:45:24.440 you buy.

00:45:25.100 Right now,

00:45:25.780 when you go to

00:45:26.120 GoodRanchers.com,

00:45:26.960 use promo code WALSH,

00:45:27.760 you'll get their exclusive

00:45:28.600 price shield

00:45:29.300 and an additional

00:45:29.880 10% off your order.

00:45:31.560 This is the last week

00:45:33.000 to secure the best price

00:45:34.180 on meat until 2026,

00:45:36.080 so you gotta go

00:45:36.500 to GoodRanchers.com

00:45:38.200 and use my code WALSH.

00:45:39.260 That's GoodRanchers.com

00:45:40.640 with promo code WALSH today.

00:45:43.140 First comment says,

00:45:43.900 Matt, you sweet summer child,

00:45:45.400 I guarantee your dad 0.99

00:45:46.580 had porn mags. 0.96

00:45:47.660 Maybe you just weren't 0.95

00:45:48.620 smart enough to find them.

00:45:51.840 Well, sorry,

00:45:52.480 I don't know what to tell you,

00:45:53.240 but we didn't have

00:45:53.780 porn magazines

00:45:54.320 in the house

00:45:54.880 growing up.

00:45:57.440 We just didn't.

00:45:59.280 Sorry,

00:45:59.980 I don't know

00:46:01.800 what else to say.

00:46:03.360 And I love

00:46:04.660 these responses

00:46:05.300 from men like this.

00:46:08.140 And anytime

00:46:08.620 the subject of porn

00:46:09.280 comes up,

00:46:09.640 you always get

00:46:10.000 these responses.

00:46:10.760 They simply refuse

00:46:11.640 to believe

00:46:12.260 that there could be

00:46:13.240 any man 0.95

00:46:13.900 who doesn't watch porn. 0.65

00:46:16.160 They refuse to believe it.

00:46:17.480 They really cannot

00:46:19.060 believe it.

00:46:20.180 They can't wrap

00:46:20.900 their minds around it.

00:46:21.620 It is inconceivable

00:46:23.000 that anyone

00:46:24.040 could accomplish

00:46:25.720 not watching porn.

00:46:26.840 They cannot

00:46:27.360 understand it.

00:46:29.800 And so,

00:46:30.720 if you claim,

00:46:31.920 if you make that claim,

00:46:33.020 they see it as,

00:46:34.620 yeah,

00:46:34.880 it's like you might

00:46:35.600 as well claim

00:46:36.140 that you can fly.

00:46:37.780 You might as well claim

00:46:38.980 that you've been,

00:46:40.600 you've stepped

00:46:41.500 on the surface

00:46:42.600 of Mars.

00:46:43.580 That is honest

00:46:44.600 to God

00:46:45.020 how they see it.

00:46:46.880 And look,

00:46:47.860 you can tell yourself

00:46:50.100 that to make yourself

00:46:51.040 feel better.

00:46:51.500 that's fine.

00:46:54.360 But that's a you problem.

00:46:55.940 That is a reflection

00:46:56.840 of you.

00:46:59.600 I'm sorry to inform you.

00:47:01.220 It is actually,

00:47:02.880 although I'm not actually

00:47:03.640 sorry to inform you,

00:47:05.580 it is actually

00:47:08.200 extremely possible

00:47:09.340 to not watch

00:47:10.480 or consume porn.

00:47:13.760 I don't.

00:47:15.440 Okay?

00:47:15.840 It is,

00:47:16.280 it's not only possible,

00:47:17.080 it's actually,

00:47:18.080 it's

00:47:20.380 really not that

00:47:22.860 difficult.

00:47:23.640 Now,

00:47:23.880 if you're,

00:47:24.200 if you're stuck in,

00:47:25.560 if you're in the midst

00:47:26.380 of the compulsion,

00:47:27.680 and I,

00:47:28.760 I hesitate to call it

00:47:29.660 an addiction for,

00:47:30.400 I'm not going to open

00:47:31.100 that can of worms again,

00:47:31.900 although I guess I just did.

00:47:33.580 But,

00:47:34.300 if you're in the midst

00:47:36.220 of what I would call

00:47:36.920 a compulsion,

00:47:38.080 to break free of that

00:47:39.620 can be difficult.

00:47:40.520 I'm not minimizing that.

00:47:41.540 But,

00:47:43.960 if you are outside

00:47:46.420 of that compulsion,

00:47:48.540 living a lifestyle

00:47:51.060 free of that kind

00:47:52.360 of smut,

00:47:52.960 it's not

00:47:53.740 that difficult.

00:47:56.680 It isn't.

00:47:58.780 And,

00:47:59.420 so it really

00:48:00.520 isn't like

00:48:01.340 this,

00:48:03.660 if you hear from a man

00:48:04.840 who says,

00:48:05.240 yeah,

00:48:05.340 I don't,

00:48:05.620 I don't watch porn,

00:48:07.500 you might think

00:48:09.020 it sounds like

00:48:09.380 he's bragging about it.

00:48:10.580 Not only is he making

00:48:11.700 some sort of wild claim,

00:48:12.940 but if it's,

00:48:13.600 if it's even true

00:48:14.500 that he's bragging

00:48:15.760 about some major

00:48:16.680 accomplishment,

00:48:17.720 but,

00:48:19.220 it's not a major

00:48:20.320 accomplishment.

00:48:22.580 And I think that it's

00:48:23.860 important to say that

00:48:25.500 because,

00:48:26.540 although if you're

00:48:27.320 in the midst

00:48:27.840 of the compulsion

00:48:28.500 and looking at porn

00:48:29.120 all the time,

00:48:30.360 to hear another man say,

00:48:31.780 like,

00:48:32.060 I don't watch it.

00:48:33.280 It's just not a part

00:48:34.240 of my life.

00:48:34.760 It's not.

00:48:37.520 To hear that

00:48:38.340 might make you feel bad.

00:48:39.180 Might make you,

00:48:40.840 might make you feel worse.

00:48:43.740 It's not meant to make you

00:48:44.840 feel bad

00:48:45.420 or make you feel worse,

00:48:46.380 but,

00:48:47.100 it's good to hear it.

00:48:49.100 I think it's actually

00:48:49.820 encouraging and empowering

00:48:50.620 because you know

00:48:51.200 that it is possible.

00:48:53.840 And,

00:48:54.360 it's,

00:48:54.920 it's maybe not

00:48:55.620 all that different

00:48:57.040 from

00:48:57.680 someone who lives

00:49:00.300 a physically healthy life.

00:49:02.860 Like,

00:49:03.260 being free of porn,

00:49:04.400 that means you're living

00:49:05.100 a mentally and spiritually

00:49:06.140 healthy life.

00:49:06.740 let's say you're

00:49:08.480 someone who's very fit

00:49:10.060 and you go to the gym a lot

00:49:11.080 and you eat healthy.

00:49:12.420 You live a physically

00:49:13.080 healthy life.

00:49:13.900 And,

00:49:14.300 living a physically,

00:49:15.240 mentally and spiritually

00:49:15.900 healthy life,

00:49:16.480 like that's,

00:49:16.960 obviously all that together

00:49:17.760 is the ideal

00:49:18.380 and they do kind of

00:49:19.020 go hand in hand.

00:49:20.420 But,

00:49:20.780 someone who's living

00:49:22.720 a life like that

00:49:24.300 can say

00:49:27.860 that,

00:49:29.340 you know,

00:49:29.680 if you're in that habit

00:49:31.080 and you're living

00:49:31.640 that lifestyle

00:49:32.260 and that's how you live

00:49:33.100 and that's what you do

00:49:33.840 and it's just part of your life,

00:49:35.080 it's actually not that hard.

00:49:36.060 Not only is it not hard,

00:49:37.060 but it's,

00:49:38.380 you enjoy living that way.

00:49:40.560 You wouldn't want,

00:49:41.220 you couldn't,

00:49:41.640 you wouldn't want to live

00:49:42.240 any other way.

00:49:43.700 Now,

00:49:43.900 on the other hand,

00:49:44.440 if you're in the habit

00:49:45.600 of overeating

00:49:46.260 and you're kind of living

00:49:48.080 a slovenly lazy life

00:49:49.800 and you have a bad diet

00:49:53.220 and you're overweight

00:49:54.360 and all that

00:49:55.020 and you have this compulsion

00:49:55.780 to overeat,

00:49:56.680 to break free of that,

00:49:57.900 getting out of that

00:49:58.780 can be difficult.

00:49:59.800 But once you get out of it

00:50:01.160 and you develop

00:50:03.940 better habits,

00:50:04.860 it's not

00:50:06.540 so difficult anymore

00:50:08.900 and that is,

00:50:09.780 and I think to know that

00:50:11.380 is a,

00:50:12.540 should be a source

00:50:13.180 of inspiration,

00:50:14.360 not something

00:50:15.760 that makes you feel defeated,

00:50:16.820 but quite the opposite.

00:50:19.180 All right.

00:50:21.420 Emerald says, 0.59

00:50:22.320 I hate the blaming

00:50:23.180 the parents bit.

00:50:25.000 From a parent

00:50:25.500 that tried everything

00:50:26.280 to help his child,

00:50:27.280 the one thing

00:50:27.940 that you cannot do

00:50:29.080 is keep your eyes

00:50:29.860 on them 100%.

00:50:30.860 Children sometimes

00:50:31.920 will do what they

00:50:32.560 want to do

00:50:33.060 knowing that if they

00:50:34.360 get caught,

00:50:34.980 there are consequences.

00:50:36.340 They're willing

00:50:36.720 to take the chance

00:50:37.560 or do not care

00:50:38.380 if they are caught.

00:50:41.860 That's true,

00:50:43.920 you know,

00:50:44.120 but there's a certain,

00:50:44.940 here's the thing,

00:50:45.760 there's a,

00:50:46.220 and we talked yesterday

00:50:46.920 about the kids,

00:50:48.380 four teenagers

00:50:49.320 who were killed

00:50:49.940 in a car accident

00:50:51.520 after stealing a car

00:50:53.960 and getting in

00:50:54.520 a high-speed police chase

00:50:55.440 and then crashing the car

00:50:56.480 while the cops

00:50:56.980 were trying to stop them.

00:50:59.020 And then it turns out

00:50:59.780 that three of the kids

00:51:00.940 have active arrest warrants,

00:51:03.040 two of them

00:51:03.700 have ankle monitors

00:51:04.980 on already.

00:51:06.660 And I said that this is,

00:51:08.480 that is a reflection

00:51:09.280 of poor parents.

00:51:09.920 Like,

00:51:10.060 don't blame the cops,

00:51:10.820 obviously,

00:51:11.300 if you've got to blame anybody

00:51:12.120 aside from the kids themselves

00:51:13.300 who engage in this

00:51:14.060 reckless behavior,

00:51:14.820 blame the parents.

00:51:16.100 Now,

00:51:16.480 you're right,

00:51:17.020 I agree with you

00:51:17.840 that blaming the parents

00:51:20.180 for everything

00:51:20.840 isn't valid.

00:51:22.120 Sometimes it's kind of

00:51:22.840 a lazy way out.

00:51:24.000 It's like the easy answer

00:51:25.100 for everything.

00:51:25.620 It's just,

00:51:25.780 well,

00:51:25.920 I blame the parents.

00:51:28.020 But,

00:51:29.480 and it's true

00:51:30.820 that you can raise your kid,

00:51:32.940 well,

00:51:33.100 you can't raise your kid perfectly,

00:51:34.120 nobody does,

00:51:34.620 because none of us are perfect,

00:51:35.360 but you can raise your kid well,

00:51:37.920 if imperfectly,

00:51:39.280 and they can still turn out poorly,

00:51:41.420 because they can still

00:51:42.040 make bad choices.

00:51:43.100 They are conscious human beings

00:51:44.760 that have their own agency

00:51:47.440 and their own willpower.

00:51:49.180 But I would say

00:51:50.040 there's a certain level

00:51:50.980 of rebellion

00:51:51.720 where it becomes obvious

00:51:54.040 that it's not,

00:51:56.520 it's not actually

00:51:57.360 rebellion at all

00:51:58.220 because the kid

00:51:58.940 has no rules

00:51:59.720 or standards

00:52:00.240 to rebel against.

00:52:02.060 Right?

00:52:02.620 That the risk

00:52:04.380 or the fear

00:52:05.080 or to some extent

00:52:07.420 the inevitable reality

00:52:08.440 is that if you set

00:52:09.500 rules and standards,

00:52:10.680 your kid will want

00:52:11.340 to rebel.

00:52:12.360 Every kid has,

00:52:13.200 every kid will rebel

00:52:14.260 to some extent.

00:52:15.180 But if,

00:52:20.600 when you see behavior

00:52:21.660 like this,

00:52:23.740 like 15 years old,

00:52:25.860 already with an ankle monitor,

00:52:28.320 in an active arrest warrant,

00:52:30.460 with a ski mask on,

00:52:32.760 stealing a car,

00:52:34.820 fleeing from the police

00:52:35.920 at 111 miles an hour,

00:52:37.200 that's the kind of thing

00:52:38.720 where, okay,

00:52:39.140 this is not

00:52:39.920 teenage rebellion anymore.

00:52:41.660 This is not,

00:52:42.020 this is not a kid

00:52:42.800 rebelling against rules

00:52:43.900 and standards

00:52:44.360 that were put in place.

00:52:45.340 This is a kid

00:52:45.800 who has never had

00:52:46.460 rules and standards.

00:52:47.880 It just,

00:52:48.180 there's nothing for him

00:52:49.200 to rebel against.

00:52:49.840 It's not there

00:52:50.400 to begin with.

00:52:50.920 There are no,

00:52:51.440 he's not,

00:52:52.220 you know,

00:52:52.440 he's not jumping over

00:52:54.760 some sort of barrier

00:52:55.600 that has been,

00:52:56.360 has been put in place

00:52:57.220 or crossing lines

00:52:58.880 that have been drawn.

00:53:00.100 There are no lines,

00:53:01.440 no barriers,

00:53:02.140 no standards,

00:53:02.720 no rules.

00:53:04.300 And,

00:53:04.780 and the kid is just

00:53:06.020 sort of flailing about.

00:53:11.160 And that's what you see here.

00:53:12.620 And when that happens,

00:53:14.740 who do you blame first?

00:53:16.280 Yes,

00:53:16.520 you blame the parents.

00:53:18.080 You know,

00:53:18.360 men's health products 1.00

00:53:19.320 kind of suck. 0.99

00:53:20.120 Let's be honest. 1.00

00:53:20.800 They're either too woke,

00:53:21.900 too bro,

00:53:22.420 or they were made

00:53:23.000 for your grandpa.

00:53:24.080 What you need

00:53:24.700 is the new Emerson

00:53:25.880 multivitamin

00:53:26.980 from Responsible Man.

00:53:29.080 Responsible Man

00:53:29.580 is a new company

00:53:30.200 from Daily Wire Ventures

00:53:31.280 dedicated to bringing you

00:53:32.720 the best high quality

00:53:33.900 men's health products.

00:53:35.200 Your modern diet

00:53:35.760 is often deficient

00:53:36.640 in key vitamins and minerals

00:53:37.680 leaving you weakened

00:53:38.480 and diminished,

00:53:39.500 unable to reach

00:53:40.120 your full potential.

00:53:40.760 That's why we created

00:53:41.820 the Emerson,

00:53:43.560 oh,

00:53:44.400 there's the front,

00:53:45.080 the Emerson multivitamin.

00:53:46.440 The Emerson multivitamin

00:53:47.200 is a physician-formulated

00:53:48.440 robust supplement

00:53:49.360 made up of 33

00:53:50.800 key premium ingredients

00:53:51.960 that helps fill

00:53:53.120 nutrient gaps

00:53:53.840 to support your immune system,

00:53:55.320 maintain energy production,

00:53:56.680 sharpen brain cognition,

00:53:57.760 and support the health

00:53:58.740 of your heart and muscles.

00:54:00.220 Emerson comes in

00:54:01.060 in exceptional

00:54:02.140 matte black aluminum tin,

00:54:04.520 which I am now

00:54:05.500 holding in my hand

00:54:06.580 as you can see.

00:54:07.380 The manly green

00:54:08.600 vitamin capsules

00:54:09.360 are smooth,

00:54:10.240 easy to take,

00:54:11.000 and the best part,

00:54:11.800 they are mint essence

00:54:12.860 for a great smell and taste.

00:54:14.300 As a man,

00:54:15.340 you have people relying on you

00:54:16.420 and the world conspires

00:54:17.420 to see you fail

00:54:18.260 with so much chaos

00:54:19.380 and uncertainty.

00:54:20.260 It's crucial to take charge

00:54:21.360 of your life

00:54:21.840 and your responsibilities,

00:54:22.900 and that starts

00:54:23.700 with the Emerson multivitamin,

00:54:25.740 simple daily discipline

00:54:26.840 to make the most of yourself,

00:54:29.100 live up to your responsibilities,

00:54:30.360 and exceed the expectations

00:54:31.520 of others.

00:54:32.200 As part of this exclusive

00:54:32.980 Daily Wire launch,

00:54:33.760 you can save 30% off

00:54:35.000 by visiting responsibleman.com.

00:54:37.740 Emerson multivitamin

00:54:38.440 is currently in stock

00:54:39.420 and ships immediately.

00:54:40.560 There's a limited number available,

00:54:41.760 so take advantage today

00:54:43.000 and save 30%.

00:54:44.140 That's responsibleman.com

00:54:45.800 to take responsibility today.

00:54:47.540 Now let's get to

00:54:48.100 our Daily Cancellation.

00:54:55.160 One of the most common refrains

00:54:56.720 of this era

00:54:57.560 of so-called racial equity

00:54:58.900 is that diversity, equity,

00:55:00.440 and inclusion policies

00:55:01.420 actually help the bottom lines

00:55:03.100 of companies that adopt them.

00:55:04.320 It's not just a moral imperative,

00:55:06.240 we've been told.

00:55:06.640 It's also supposedly good for business

00:55:08.100 as a practical matter.

00:55:09.640 This reasoning explains

00:55:10.540 why ESG,

00:55:11.420 or environmental, social,

00:55:12.540 and governance,

00:55:13.200 is dominant right now

00:55:15.260 in the financial industry.

00:55:16.420 If you want a score,

00:55:17.420 you know,

00:55:17.600 if you want a high ESG score,

00:55:18.920 which helps get more attention

00:55:20.200 from big investment funds

00:55:21.380 and governments

00:55:22.360 all over the world,

00:55:23.020 then your corporation

00:55:23.920 needs to have a DEI program.

00:55:25.920 When investors

00:55:26.720 ask any questions about this,

00:55:28.420 they're instructed

00:55:28.920 that this mandate

00:55:29.640 has nothing to do

00:55:30.300 with ideology

00:55:30.820 or left-wing politics.

00:55:31.700 Instead,

00:55:32.180 it's all about generating

00:55:33.040 value for shareholders.

00:55:34.960 That's how the DEI takeover

00:55:36.320 was sold to Wall Street,

00:55:37.400 and it was an extremely

00:55:38.580 aggressive pitch.

00:55:40.160 Pretty much every executive

00:55:41.120 of every major company,

00:55:42.100 except for Tesla,

00:55:43.440 has parroted that talking point

00:55:44.900 religiously for years.

00:55:46.700 Here's a line

00:55:47.180 from the former

00:55:47.860 president of Intel,

00:55:49.640 for example,

00:55:50.140 quote,

00:55:51.060 there's a huge business case

00:55:52.340 for diversity.

00:55:54.540 Mark Cuban has said

00:55:55.360 the same thing,

00:55:55.880 quote,

00:55:56.040 I own or invest

00:55:57.200 in hundreds of companies.

00:55:57.940 I know hashtag DEI

00:55:59.640 is a positive

00:56:00.280 because I see its impact

00:56:01.880 on bottom lines.

00:56:04.080 But intuitively,

00:56:04.820 no matter how many times

00:56:05.760 various executives

00:56:06.500 repeat this mantra,

00:56:08.220 it's never made

00:56:08.720 a lot of sense

00:56:09.400 because DEI is about

00:56:11.060 lowering or eliminating

00:56:11.980 relevant standards

00:56:12.740 in order to hire

00:56:13.340 more people based

00:56:14.100 on irrelevant characteristics

00:56:15.480 that they can't control

00:56:16.560 like their gender

00:56:17.260 or skin color.

00:56:18.380 So how could companies

00:56:19.180 possibly make more money

00:56:20.620 by lowering

00:56:22.900 their standards

00:56:23.820 at scale?

00:56:25.520 Nine years ago,

00:56:26.400 it fell on the

00:56:26.980 consulting firm McKinsey,

00:56:28.420 who's Pete Buttigieg's

00:56:29.400 alma mater,

00:56:30.380 to come up with

00:56:31.020 an answer to that question.

00:56:32.300 They know exactly

00:56:33.000 what conclusion

00:56:33.600 they had to reach

00:56:34.540 and dutifully,

00:56:37.240 they reached it.

00:56:38.100 In 2015,

00:56:38.720 McKinsey released

00:56:39.280 its first study

00:56:40.040 finding that

00:56:40.660 more diverse companies

00:56:41.960 tended to have

00:56:42.720 higher earnings.

00:56:43.620 Quoting from the study,

00:56:44.380 quote,

00:56:45.060 our latest research

00:56:45.880 finds that companies

00:56:46.800 in the top quartile

00:56:48.160 for gender and racial

00:56:49.260 and ethnic diversity

00:56:50.020 are more likely

00:56:50.700 to have financial returns

00:56:51.640 above their national

00:56:52.780 industry medians.

00:56:54.140 Companies in the

00:56:54.660 bottom quartile

00:56:55.560 in these dimensions

00:56:56.700 are statistically

00:56:57.340 less likely

00:56:58.200 to achieve

00:56:58.820 above-average returns.

00:57:00.160 While correlation

00:57:00.660 does not equal causation,

00:57:01.740 the correlation

00:57:02.120 does indicate

00:57:02.840 that when companies

00:57:03.500 commit themselves

00:57:04.160 to diverse leadership,

00:57:05.360 they are more successful.

00:57:07.340 In 2018,

00:57:08.420 2020,

00:57:08.780 and 2023,

00:57:09.660 McKinsey released

00:57:10.160 similar reports

00:57:10.860 reiterating this

00:57:11.560 same finding

00:57:12.180 and expanding on it

00:57:13.580 to include other avenues

00:57:14.680 of diversity,

00:57:15.480 including transgenderism.

00:57:16.720 McKinsey also put on

00:57:17.520 a whole speaker series

00:57:19.120 featuring activists

00:57:19.980 who say that

00:57:20.760 DEI helps businesses

00:57:22.380 make more money.

00:57:23.120 here's just one

00:57:24.800 of them

00:57:25.080 from a couple

00:57:25.620 of years ago.

00:57:26.140 Watch.

00:57:32.760 In the case

00:57:33.820 of organizations,

00:57:35.380 diversity and inclusion

00:57:36.680 foster better

00:57:37.640 employment,

00:57:38.780 employee engagement

00:57:40.440 and productivity,

00:57:42.460 as you mentioned,

00:57:43.800 and allow for greater

00:57:44.760 levels of innovation.

00:57:46.820 Also,

00:57:47.580 and this is very

00:57:48.520 relevant

00:57:49.240 given the COVID-19

00:57:50.760 crisis,

00:57:51.980 some studies

00:57:52.960 found that companies

00:57:54.900 with pro-diversity

00:57:57.260 policies

00:57:58.100 were more resilient

00:58:00.160 during past crisis,

00:58:02.200 such as the 2008

00:58:04.300 financial crisis.

00:58:06.040 So it should be

00:58:07.040 very obvious

00:58:07.960 that a broader range

00:58:10.080 of people

00:58:10.980 have a broader range

00:58:13.060 of interests,

00:58:14.440 experiences,

00:58:15.480 and backgrounds

00:58:16.100 to draw upon.

00:58:17.600 They can better

00:58:18.480 understand

00:58:19.160 what the people

00:58:20.140 I mean users,

00:58:22.340 consumers,

00:58:23.600 citizens,

00:58:24.320 et cetera,

00:58:25.260 are asking for

00:58:26.460 or looking for.

00:58:27.820 The woman on the left

00:58:29.040 who's nodding along

00:58:29.940 throughout the lecture

00:58:30.620 is apparently some

00:58:31.480 McKinsey DEI expert,

00:58:33.040 and the woman who's

00:58:33.620 talking is evidently

00:58:34.460 a former president

00:58:35.180 of Costa Rica.

00:58:36.020 So this is a relatively

00:58:36.680 high-powered interview

00:58:37.600 that McKinsey is putting

00:58:38.520 on the internet,

00:58:40.800 all for the benefit

00:58:41.640 of about 662 viewers.

00:58:44.220 In any event,

00:58:44.680 we're told that DEI

00:58:45.680 helps productivity

00:58:46.960 and innovation.

00:58:47.880 And DEI even

00:58:49.260 helped companies

00:58:49.880 respond to the

00:58:50.960 2008 financial crisis

00:58:52.120 somehow.

00:58:53.680 Because, of course,

00:58:54.380 that was the issue

00:58:55.520 with companies

00:58:55.980 like Bear Stearns.

00:58:57.060 The problem wasn't

00:58:57.760 all those asset-backed

00:58:59.060 securities they issued.

00:58:59.980 No, Bear Stearns failed

00:59:01.300 because they didn't have

00:59:02.020 a non-binary CEO,

00:59:03.540 apparently.

00:59:04.640 A lack of transgender 1.00

00:59:05.800 representation,

00:59:06.720 that was the problem.

00:59:07.980 Could have avoided

00:59:08.500 the whole thing

00:59:08.940 if they'd had more of that.

00:59:10.780 Now, these kinds of platitudes

00:59:11.700 have kept piling up

00:59:12.780 unchallenged for the better

00:59:13.840 part of a decade.

00:59:15.000 As recently as the end

00:59:15.860 of last year,

00:59:16.400 McKinsey once again

00:59:17.360 wrote in a report

00:59:18.060 that the business argument

00:59:20.600 for DEI was more compelling

00:59:22.260 than it had ever been before.

00:59:24.680 But it wasn't until

00:59:25.480 March of this year

00:59:26.380 that a scholarly publication

00:59:27.700 like Econ Journal Watch

00:59:29.140 decided to check McKinsey's work

00:59:30.840 and try to confirm

00:59:33.180 all of this.

00:59:34.360 A professor at Texas A&M's

00:59:35.620 business school,

00:59:36.240 along with a senior professor

00:59:37.320 at UNC's business school,

00:59:38.940 they were the primary authors

00:59:39.940 and they tried to duplicate

00:59:40.880 McKinsey's methods

00:59:41.680 to ensure they got

00:59:42.700 the same results.

00:59:43.780 Remember,

00:59:44.040 this is one of the many ways

00:59:45.600 that ex-Harvard president

00:59:47.200 Claudine Gay

00:59:47.840 was exposed as a fraud.

00:59:49.680 None of her work

00:59:50.340 was capable of being duplicated,

00:59:52.740 which means that,

00:59:53.640 you know,

00:59:53.760 that's a good indication

00:59:54.820 that there's a problem here

00:59:56.440 and that's because

00:59:57.280 she hid all of her data.

00:59:58.720 So,

00:59:59.740 what happened

01:00:00.720 when Econ Journal Watch

01:00:01.900 re-ran McKinsey's numbers?

01:00:04.040 Here's our top line conclusion.

01:00:05.360 Quote,

01:00:05.520 when we revisit McKinsey's tests

01:00:08.040 using data for firms

01:00:09.380 in the publicly observable

01:00:10.340 S&P 500

01:00:11.160 as of 12-31-2019,

01:00:13.680 we do not find

01:00:14.400 statistically significant relations

01:00:15.760 between McKinsey's measures

01:00:16.820 of executive racial-ethnic diversity

01:00:19.000 at mid-2020

01:00:19.840 and either industry-adjusted earnings

01:00:21.900 before interest and taxes,

01:00:23.480 margin or industry-adjusted sales growth,

01:00:25.320 gross margin,

01:00:25.980 return on assets,

01:00:26.880 return on equity,

01:00:27.800 and total shareholder return

01:00:29.080 over the prior five years,

01:00:30.740 2015 to 2019.

01:00:32.380 The researchers concluded,

01:00:33.560 quote,

01:00:34.280 our inability to quasi-replicate

01:00:36.360 their results

01:00:36.900 suggests that

01:00:37.700 despite the imprimatur

01:00:39.020 given to McKinsey's studies,

01:00:42.120 they should not be relied on

01:00:43.960 to support the view

01:00:44.700 that U.S. publicly traded firms

01:00:46.200 can expect to deliver

01:00:47.280 improved financial performance

01:00:48.740 if they increase

01:00:50.260 the racial-ethnic diversity

01:00:51.820 of their executives.

01:00:53.980 Now, as of now,

01:00:54.920 McKinsey hasn't responded

01:00:56.020 to this debunking,

01:00:57.480 which tells you a lot,

01:00:59.180 because if you have

01:00:59.780 a decade's worth of research

01:01:01.420 showing something

01:01:02.800 and then some academics

01:01:04.540 come along

01:01:05.260 and they say

01:01:05.860 that it's all fraudulent,

01:01:07.700 you'd think you'd want

01:01:08.620 to respond in some way.

01:01:10.400 But McKinsey hasn't

01:01:11.400 because, of course,

01:01:12.400 all of their research

01:01:13.100 on this topic is fake.

01:01:14.920 So, that raises

01:01:16.380 a few obvious questions.

01:01:17.420 One of them is,

01:01:18.460 how many other things

01:01:19.360 we've been told to believe

01:01:21.020 are actually completely fake

01:01:22.340 and invented?

01:01:23.340 What else are they lying about?

01:01:25.460 If they can get away

01:01:26.320 with bad data for nine years

01:01:27.980 before someone thinks

01:01:28.680 to check them on it?

01:01:29.580 And more to the point,

01:01:31.960 how could McKinsey

01:01:32.920 have gotten all of this

01:01:34.480 so wrong?

01:01:35.760 Like, why would they have

01:01:36.580 sacrificed their integrity

01:01:37.960 so publicly

01:01:38.880 to promote DEI?

01:01:40.800 Alex Edmonds,

01:01:41.640 a finance professor

01:01:42.360 at London Business School,

01:01:43.800 has one theory.

01:01:44.560 On his blog,

01:01:45.100 he wrote,

01:01:45.480 quote,

01:01:45.800 another aspect of diversity

01:01:47.020 is to form diverse teams

01:01:49.140 that can bring

01:01:49.680 dissenting perspectives.

01:01:51.240 But the six-person research team

01:01:52.780 at McKinsey

01:01:53.280 was composed solely of women,

01:01:55.540 the majority of whom

01:01:56.200 are also ethnic minorities.

01:01:57.460 Due to confirmation bias,

01:01:59.460 they might want to find

01:02:00.400 that diversity matters

01:02:01.480 and thus turn a blind eye

01:02:03.160 to the glaring errors.

01:02:04.300 In addition,

01:02:05.260 none has a PhD

01:02:06.020 in economics, finance,

01:02:07.040 or any business discipline,

01:02:08.320 which is a basic qualification

01:02:09.500 to do research.

01:02:10.700 McKinsey is a premier

01:02:11.540 consulting firm,

01:02:12.620 but that is very different

01:02:13.500 from having expertise

01:02:14.320 in scientific research.

01:02:16.020 The team composition

01:02:16.680 makes it more likely

01:02:17.580 that the study is advocacy

01:02:18.900 rather than research.

01:02:20.920 In other words,

01:02:22.280 the McKinsey study

01:02:23.080 saying that diversity

01:02:23.940 is essential,

01:02:24.580 the study itself

01:02:27.160 could have benefited

01:02:28.140 from some more diversity.

01:02:30.480 That's one of the many ironies

01:02:31.640 that was highlighted

01:02:32.520 by Edmonds,

01:02:33.360 who, by the way,

01:02:34.160 doesn't appear to be

01:02:34.840 particularly political

01:02:35.600 in his leanings.

01:02:37.500 He's lectured extensively

01:02:38.600 about business

01:02:39.360 and their social responsibilities.

01:02:41.380 He strikes me

01:02:41.740 as a down-the-middle

01:02:42.760 kind of apolitical

01:02:44.040 academic type of guy.

01:02:45.680 Not a lot of them left,

01:02:46.580 but there's a few.

01:02:47.960 And he's calling out

01:02:48.680 this McKinsey study

01:02:49.420 for what it is.

01:02:51.020 The whole debacle

01:02:51.740 was covered at length

01:02:52.500 in a recent article

01:02:53.340 in American Conservative Magazine.

01:02:55.020 And the author

01:02:55.480 of that article,

01:02:56.600 Chris Brunet,

01:02:57.700 makes the important point

01:02:59.300 that what McKinsey

01:03:00.020 pushed for

01:03:00.620 is actually evil.

01:03:02.200 You know,

01:03:02.340 it wasn't some innocent lie.

01:03:03.860 It wasn't some noble lie.

01:03:06.040 It wasn't something

01:03:06.620 where they had

01:03:07.060 the best of intentions

01:03:08.060 and it went wrong.

01:03:09.520 It damaged the lives

01:03:10.700 of a lot of people.

01:03:11.500 Quote,

01:03:12.080 the premise

01:03:12.440 that racial composition

01:03:13.300 inherently boosts

01:03:14.200 economic performance

01:03:14.900 is morally repugnant

01:03:16.460 race science.

01:03:17.780 What if McKinsey

01:03:18.400 had found

01:03:19.280 that a homogenous

01:03:20.020 racial composition,

01:03:21.140 say all Caucasian,

01:03:22.140 all Asian or all male 0.75

01:03:23.480 were more profitable?

01:03:25.140 Would Mark Cuban 0.95

01:03:25.860 and McKinsey

01:03:26.560 then be entitled

01:03:27.640 to preach racial purity

01:03:28.960 for profit's sake?

01:03:29.900 Of course not.

01:03:31.020 This was never

01:03:31.480 about profitability.

01:03:32.640 DEI was always

01:03:33.400 a smokescreen

01:03:34.160 for something

01:03:34.820 far more sinister,

01:03:35.860 a subversive embrace

01:03:36.820 of Marxist equalitarianism

01:03:38.840 under the thin veneer

01:03:40.160 of fiduciary duty.

01:03:42.420 And that thin veneer

01:03:43.220 is exactly what McKinsey

01:03:44.280 was expected to provide

01:03:45.300 when they first pretended

01:03:46.560 to look into

01:03:47.160 the impact of DEI.

01:03:48.780 They did what

01:03:49.460 most consultants do,

01:03:50.460 which is tell their clients,

01:03:52.140 what they want to hear.

01:03:54.220 McKinsey would have faced

01:03:54.880 a lot of backlash

01:03:55.500 if they had told the truth.

01:03:58.600 It's impossible to imagine

01:03:59.900 that they would come out

01:04:00.800 and say,

01:04:01.540 oh, you know,

01:04:01.840 actually diversity

01:04:02.340 doesn't matter.

01:04:03.060 It doesn't affect

01:04:03.960 your business at all.

01:04:04.780 Never mind.

01:04:06.000 They weren't going to say that,

01:04:06.840 so they simply lied.

01:04:08.620 And because they lied,

01:04:09.460 a lot of people in this country

01:04:10.320 have lost job opportunities

01:04:11.420 on the basis of characteristics

01:04:12.580 that they can't control.

01:04:14.560 Many companies

01:04:15.160 have become less efficient.

01:04:17.480 And now finally,

01:04:19.080 the fraud is officially exposed,

01:04:20.500 thanks to the work

01:04:21.440 of a couple of

01:04:22.080 business school professors

01:04:23.060 who were brave enough

01:04:23.840 to do their jobs,

01:04:25.280 which is extremely rare now

01:04:27.720 in academia.

01:04:29.660 It's also apparently

01:04:30.640 extremely rare

01:04:31.200 in the consulting world,

01:04:31.960 which isn't a surprise.

01:04:33.220 And that's why McKinsey

01:04:34.120 and every corporation

01:04:34.980 that relied on

01:04:35.640 its obviously cooked data

01:04:36.860 is today canceled.

01:04:40.120 That'll do it for the show today.

01:04:40.840 Thanks for watching.

01:04:41.360 Thanks for listening.

01:04:42.040 Talk to you tomorrow.

01:04:43.100 Have a great day.

01:04:43.660 Godspeed.

01:04:45.080 We'll see you tomorrowén.

01:04:47.600 .

01:05:08.020 Bye and see you tomorrowén.

01:05:09.800 Bye.

01:05:10.040 Bye.

01:05:11.360 Bye.

01:05:11.560 Bye.

01:05:12.180 Bye.

The Matt Walsh Show - May 01, 2024

Ep. 1359 - Why The Pro-Palestine Campus Protesters Are A Bunch Of Childish Cosplaying Phonies

Episode Stats

Summary

Transcript