The Megyn Kelly Show - August 17, 2026


Jason Arday Found Dead, Mangione Pleads Guilty in Federal Case, USS Lincoln Relief: AM Update 8⧸17

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Claus von Bülow: The FULL MK Confidential Series The Beltway Snipers: The Invisible Killers — Ep. 1 | MK Confidential

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

154.24

Word count

3,622

Sentence count

192

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Not every game's an all-timer. Sometimes you get a dud.
00:00:03 But at Bet365, boredom is a thing of the past.
00:00:07 Thanks to their early payout, there's always a reason to watch.
00:00:10 And while they can't make games exciting, they can help fans get excited.
00:00:15 Bet365. Download the app and see what early payout's all about.
00:00:18 Must be 19 or older, Ontario only. Please play responsibly.
00:00:21 If you or someone you know has concerns about gambling, visit ConnexOntario.ca.
00:00:26 Terms and conditions apply.
00:00:30 Good morning, everyone. I'm Megan Kelly. It's Monday, August 17th, 2026, and this is your AM
00:00:35 Update. Former Cambridge professor Jason Arde found dead days after resigning amid allegations
00:00:42 of plagiarism and lying. New York law does not permit a person to be prosecuted and punished
00:00:48 twice for the exact same crime. Luigi Mangione pleading guilty in federal court to stalking
00:00:55 charges in the killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, then moving to get his separate
00:01:00 state murder case thrown out. That ship is moving right now, well, very shortly, and it's being
00:01:07 replaced with another very similar ship. The USS George Washington heading to the Middle East to
00:01:12 relieve the USS Abraham Lincoln amid growing scrutiny over conditions aboard the carrier.
00:01:18 And CBS News correspondent Matt Guttman facing workplace harassment allegations in a new wrongful
00:01:24 termination lawsuit. All that and more coming up in just a moment on your AM update.
00:01:33 Cozy Earth has built a massive following for their ultra luxurious sheets. People love them
00:01:39 because they bring a premium five-star resort feeling right into the bedroom. You know what's
00:01:44 weird about Cozy Earth sheets? Everybody asked me about them. Of all the ads that we run,
00:01:49 everyone wants to know whether Cozy Earth sheets really are as great as we say they are. And the
00:01:54 answer is yes, they are. Trust me. Go buy. Try the one pair and see if I'm lying. I'm not. But you
00:02:02 should buy a bunch of pairs on your first order because that's where you get the big discount.
00:02:05 And it's amazing. It's truly like you see that discount kick in. You type it. I myself did. I
00:02:10 typed in Megan. I was like, whoa, I saved myself a lot. OK, but anyway, now you can get that five
00:02:16 star resort feeling at the beach or the pool because Cozy Earth's premium beach towels
00:02:22 completely change the game for summer outings. Unlike your standard scratchy towels that get
00:02:27 stiff after a day in the sun, these are incredibly plush, fast-absorbing, and genuinely elevated
00:02:32 genuinely. They wrap you in luxury after a dip in the water. Plus, for anyone who's not a beach or
00:02:37 a pool person, Cozy Earth has an incredible everyday bath towel line to bring that spa-like
00:02:42 quality right into your home bathroom. They even stand behind everything they make with a 10-year
00:02:47 warranty. Oversized, ultra plush, and completely built for your best summer days. Head to
00:02:54 CozyEarth.com. Use the code Megan AM. Do it. Don't forget. It's important for an exclusive
00:03:00 20% off. That's code Megan AM for an exclusive 20% off. And if you see a post-purchase survey, 1.00
00:03:08 tell them that you heard about Cozy Earth right here.
00:03:10 former cambridge university professor jason arday found dead at his london home friday
00:03:17 little more than a week after resigning amid mounting allegations of plagiarism and
00:03:22 lying about his biography central to the extraordinary personal story that helped
00:03:27 make him famous arday's memoir great and unfortunate things hitting bookstores last
00:03:33 week the 41 year old reportedly found unresponsive at a home in the battersea neighborhood of south
00:03:40 London. Police describing his death as unexpected but saying it is not suspicious, and with no cause
00:03:46 of death publicly announced, it is believed to have been a suicide. Arday becoming an international
00:03:51 academic celebrity in 2023 when, at 37, he was named Cambridge University's youngest ever Black
00:03:58 professor. His rise powered by an extraordinary, unbelievable, alleged life story. The son of
00:04:06 Ghanaian immigrants, Ardeh said he was diagnosed with autism as a child, that he did not speak
00:04:12 until he was almost 12, could not read or write until 18, and nevertheless went on to earn a
00:04:18 doctorate before becoming a professor at one of the world's most prestigious universities.
00:04:24 Over the years, Ardeh claiming he survived a remarkable series of medical and personal
00:04:28 challenges, including epilepsy, cancer, a brain tumor, a stroke, and more, while simultaneously
00:04:35 becoming one of the world's most elite endurance athletes and distance runners, not to mention
00:04:41 prolific charity fundraiser. Then the dam broke. Over the past several weeks, substantial parts
00:04:47 of his origin story beginning to come undone. The controversy initially centering on plagiarism
00:04:53 allegations involving Arde's doctoral dissertation, questions then spreading well beyond his academic
00:04:59 record to virtually every part of his bio. The Washington Free Beacon reporting last week that
00:05:05 several dramatic episodes presented as true in Arde's newly released memoir bear striking
00:05:11 similarities to storylines from movies and television programs he had previously discussed
00:05:16 enjoying. Those disputed accounts reportedly including stories surrounding his childhood
00:05:21 disabilities and an alleged violent attack Arde said left him with epilepsy, but in which
00:05:28 he became the hero, forgiving his attackers and becoming godfather to one of their children.
00:05:34 Cambridge initially defending Arday after saying the plagiarism allegations were for his doctoral
00:05:39 university to handle, before opening a new investigation earlier this month after receiving
00:05:45 what the university described as additional information. Arday resigning that same day
00:05:51 without admitting wrongdoing. In an open resignation letter, Arday writing, quote,
00:05:55 I no longer wish to feel as though I am living under a constant spotlight
00:05:59 where every aspect of my life is subject to public examination and judgment.
00:06:04 In a statement released through Simon & Schuster UK following his death,
00:06:09 his family accusing critics of subjecting Arde to what they called a years-long, quote,
00:06:13 campaign of sustained abuse, arguing a, quote, campaign of misinformation had ultimately become
00:06:20 too much for him. British Prime Minister Andy Burnham reacting to the news of Arde's death.
00:06:25 It's a tragedy on so many levels, but particularly just for everybody who knew Jason, his family, obviously, his friends, we think of them today.
00:06:39 It's not a moment for any rushing to judgment. It's a moment for reflection, I would say.
00:06:44 The university's vice chancellor saying Cambridge is now focused on supporting its community following Arde's death.
00:06:51 Others arguing Arde's death should force scrutiny not just of the accusations against him,
00:06:56 but of Cambridge's decision to elevate him in the first place, making him a target.
00:07:02 We'll have more on this later today on the MK Show.
00:07:06 Luigi Mangione pleading guilty on Friday to federal stalking charges in the killing of
00:07:11 UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, then immediately moving to use that conviction
00:07:16 to try to wipe out the separate murder case against him in New York State Court.
00:07:21 Mangione facing two federal counts of stalking, resulting in death over the December 2024 killing.
00:07:28 Prosecutors accuse him of tracking down Thompson before shooting him outside a Manhattan hotel.
00:07:33 28-year-old Mangione appearing in federal court in Manhattan Friday in a beige prison uniform and
00:07:39 ankle shackles, telling Judge Margaret Garnett his mind was clear and that he understood he
00:07:44 could face as much as life in prison. Mangione entering the guilty plea without any deal in
00:07:50 place with federal prosecutors, leaving his sentence entirely up to the judge. Prosecutors
00:07:55 calculating the federal sentencing guidelines at roughly 24 to 30 years, Judge Garnett saying
00:08:01 she will determine the appropriate sentence herself. Mangione giving the court his own
00:08:06 account of the crime, describing years of back pain, saying he learned UnitedHealthcare would
00:08:11 hold its annual investor conference in Manhattan in December 2024, and that he researched where
00:08:17 it would take place. Mangione telling the judge, quote, in November of 2024, I traveled from
00:08:22 outside of New York State to Manhattan. Mangione adding that he emailed United Healthcare
00:08:28 Leadership, quote, posing as an investor at a firm managing over $50 billion in assets
00:08:34 and requesting information about the conference. Mangione saying he received a response within
00:08:39 an hour, the statement concluding, quote, I shot Mr. Thompson in Manhattan and he died.
00:08:45 I knew what I was doing was illegal. CNN reports Thompson's widow became visibly
00:08:51 emotional as Mangione entered his plea. Mangione's federal sentencing now set for
00:08:55 December 18th. Almost immediately after the proceeding, Mangione's attorneys filing a
00:09:01 motion asking a New York state judge to dismiss the separate state charges against him. Defense
00:09:07 attorney Karen Friedman Agnifolo speaking outside court. It was a single tragic event,
00:09:13 yet he's being prosecuted twice for the same conduct.
00:09:17 Despite this being a single isolated event,
00:09:20 Mr. Mangione has been unfairly treated since the outset in every way
00:09:24 and has successfully fought off terrorism charges and the death penalty
00:09:29 while also fighting at the same time two simultaneous prosecutions in two jurisdictions
00:09:35 who are trying to punish him twice for the exact conduct.
00:09:39 New York law does not permit a person to be prosecuted and punished twice for the exact
00:09:45 same crime under a statute that governs successive prosecutions. It's also known as the double
00:09:52 jeopardy law. Today's guilty plea triggers this statute. The Manhattan DA's office sees the
00:09:59 matter very differently, insisting the state murder case can and will move forward. The major
00:10:05 legal question now shifting to whether Mangione's federal guilty plea can actually block New York
00:10:10 from prosecuting him over the same killing. We spoke with the MK True Crime Show co-host Phil
00:10:16 Holloway, who tells us Mangione's attorneys made the strongest move available to them.
00:10:21 I've got to hand it to his lawyers because Mangione's lawyers did probably the best thing
00:10:27 they could have done for their client considering that he gunned someone down in the street right
00:10:33 there in the public for everyone to see. As this plays out, you know, they're trying to get the
00:10:39 federal charges to essentially supersede the state charges. And if the state charges go away,
00:10:45 then he's simply left with federal sentencing, which could be as little as 20 years, but could
00:10:51 also be up to like life in prison. With Mangione now convicted federally, Holloway breaking down
00:10:57 the narrower question facing the state court, whether New York can still prosecute the same
00:11:02 killing under a different charge. New York law basically says if the federal government has
00:11:08 prosecuted someone for a certain crime, then New York will not prosecute them for the same
00:11:14 transaction or occurrence. And that's the key words, transaction or occurrence. Well, clearly,
00:11:21 this is the same criminal transaction. Now, there are a few exceptions that the prosecutors in New
00:11:29 York will say apply to keep the New York case alive. Certain things like if there's a different
00:11:36 element or certain factual differences, different harms that the different criminal statutes are
00:11:43 trying to prevent against, there's an argument to be made that double jeopardy will not apply.
00:11:49 But I think it's an uphill swim for the prosecutors in New York. I think that in all likelihood,
00:11:57 we may very well see the New York case dismissed eventually on double jeopardy ground.
00:12:02 If the state case does survive, Holloway says Mangione's own words in federal court
00:12:07 could become a major problem for his defense.
00:12:10 In the event that the New York state trial does go forward,
00:12:14 every word uttered by Mangione in federal court,
00:12:18 specifically the parts where he admitted to gunning down his victim in cold blood,
00:12:23 Those were his words.
00:12:25 Everything you say in court can and will be used against you, right?
00:12:29 So that's the way that's going to play out.
00:12:31 He absolutely will have his own words used against him.
00:12:35 So I think that the defense, the Mangione defense, is betting the farm on double jeopardy
00:12:41 because at this point, there's really no way unless you get a rogue juror of some kind of stealth juror
00:12:48 who's hell-bent to derail the trial.
00:12:51 There's just no way he can win the New York case now.
00:12:54 Even after the federal case and New York murder case are resolved,
00:12:58 Mangione still has another prosecution waiting for him in Pennsylvania,
00:13:02 stemming from his arrest there five days after Thompson's killing.
00:13:06 Holloway tells us what to expect after the New York case is resolved.
00:13:10 It's important to remember that he's still facing very serious charges in the state of Pennsylvania.
00:13:15 And, of course, there is no double jeopardy considerations with regard to the Pennsylvania charges.
00:13:21 And they're very serious.
00:13:23 He's charged with felony forgery, carrying a firearm without a license, which is also a felony, various misdemeanors, including tampering with records, possessing instruments of a crime, and false identification.
00:13:36 He's facing, theoretically, up to a maximum of 28 years in the Pennsylvania case.
00:13:42 So once New York and the federal courts get finished with Luigi Mangione off to Pennsylvania, he goes for Pennsylvania prosecution.
00:13:53 Coming up, the USS Abraham Lincoln finally heading home after an extended Middle East deployment as sailors and their families speak out about conditions aboard the carrier.
00:14:03 and a former ABC News producer accusing now CBS News correspondent Matt Guttman
00:14:10 of workplace harassment in a new lawsuit.
00:14:20 Our sponsor, the Electronic Payments Coalition, says Washington politicians are always getting
00:14:25 into your wallet and that now they're messing with your credit card. They say your credit card
00:14:29 and the security it offers are under attack and that Senators Dick Durbin and Roger Marshall
00:14:35 want to change the nation's payment system to benefit corporate megastores like Walmart and
00:14:40 Target at the expense of everyday Americans. Credit cards can keep your payments secure
00:14:45 and provide rewards that families use to help make everyday purchases more affordable.
00:14:49 The Electronic Payments Coalition says the Durbin-Marshall mandates would let corporate
00:14:54 megastores cut corners on credit card processing, routing transactions
00:14:59 over cheaper, untested networks with weaker security and fewer protections.
00:15:04 Find out more at GuardYourCard.com and consider telling Congress to guard your card.
00:15:11 The USS George Washington aircraft carrier now heading to the Middle East
00:15:16 to relieve the USS Abraham Lincoln, ending an unusually long wartime stretch for the Lincoln
00:15:22 amid growing scrutiny over conditions aboard the carrier. U.S. officials telling the Wall
00:15:27 Street Journal, the rotation was already planned before those concerns began drawing widespread
00:15:32 attention. The Lincoln leaving San Diego for what was initially expected to be a roughly
00:15:37 seven-month deployment last November to the Pacific, before being redirected to the Middle
00:15:42 East in January ahead of the war with Iran. The carrier playing a major role in Operation Epic
00:15:49 Fury and remaining in the region to support the ongoing blockade of Iranian ports. The ship now
00:15:55 deployed for more than 250 days, including more than 200 days without a port call, according to
00:16:01 Democrat Senator Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut. That extended stretch at sea, increasingly
00:16:07 becoming the focus of reports about conditions aboard the Lincoln. Earlier this month, MSNOW
00:16:12 reporting that a dozen family members described shortages of fresh food and basic hygiene supplies,
00:16:18 along with plumbing problems, mold, and growing concern about the strain on sailors.
00:16:24 CNN reporting one sailor went overboard August 3rd, wearing a life vest.
00:16:30 That sailor rescued, medically evaluated, and later taken off the ship for additional care.
00:16:36 The Navy reportedly treating the incident as a mental health incident.
00:16:40 Military Times separately reporting, based on accounts from family members,
00:16:44 that multiple sailors have attempted to go overboard during the extended deployment.
00:16:49 President Trump addressing the controversy on Friday,
00:16:51 confirming to reporters the Lincoln would soon be replaced.
00:16:56 Family members of U.S. service members are concerned about the conditions on war
00:17:00 as Lincoln.
00:17:01 Well, no, that ship is moving. No, they're not.
00:17:03 That ship is moving right now, or very shortly, and it's being replaced with another very
00:17:09 similar ship.
00:17:09 Have the deployment gone off too long?
00:17:11 No, no, no. Not nearly long enough. Thank you, everybody.
00:17:16 Secretary of War Pete Hegseth calling the reports, quote,
00:17:19 completely misrepresented.
00:17:21 one wife of a service member aboard the Lincoln,
00:17:24 telling CNN on Friday she believes the administration is dismissing
00:17:28 legitimate concerns from sailors and their families.
00:17:32 Have some sympathy, some empathy, take some accountability
00:17:35 for what's going on with your military, your ships, in your war, in your war.
00:17:43 It's infuriating.
00:17:44 I mean, we heard what Hegseth said yesterday,
00:17:48 What the president is saying today, it's infuriating, essentially saying that families are lying and service members are lying, even though the proof is right here on my phone.
00:17:58 It is not fabricated. Nobody is lying.
00:18:02 Everybody is infuriating that they're not taking accountability and not having any sort of sympathy for our service members.
00:18:12 Although some of the most dramatic reports have focused on food, supplies, and plumbing,
00:18:18 CNN's Pamela Brown describing a more nuanced picture after she spent several days aboard the Lincoln last month.
00:18:25 Brown speaking with sailors who openly described low morale and the strain of the extended deployment,
00:18:31 while also hearing from crew members who spoke positively about their shipmates and their work.
00:18:36 In a text to Brown, one sailor writing, quote,
00:18:38 Yeah, we have days where it was bad, but I feel like they're showing all the bad and no good.
00:18:44 But another sailor telling Brown the bigger frustration was the repeated extension of a
00:18:49 deployment that was never expected to become a months-long combat mission. Officials telling
00:18:54 the Wall Street Journal the conditions described aboard the Lincoln are not necessarily unusual
00:18:59 during wartime, while acknowledging that going months without a port call can take a significant
00:19:04 toll on a crew. CENTCOM Commander Admiral Brad Cooper releasing a statement yesterday following
00:19:11 a trip aboard the Lincoln on Saturday, writing in part, quote, of the U.S. Navy's 11 active
00:19:16 aircraft carriers, the Lincoln currently has among the lowest number of cases related to
00:19:21 mental health. Admiral Cooper continuing, quote, this does not mean that all is perfect. Find any
00:19:27 of the nearly 4 million Navy veterans in America today and they will likely tell you that service
00:19:32 at sea for long periods is not for everyone. The CENTCOM commander adding that mental health
00:19:38 is another aspect of health, just like physical and spiritual health, and that it is a leadership
00:19:43 priority. CBS News correspondent Matt Guttman facing allegations of workplace harassment from
00:19:52 his old job brought by a former ABC News producer in a wrongful termination hostile work environment
00:19:58 lawsuit filed against Guttman, ABC News, and its parent company, Disney. Guttman now works at CBS
00:20:05 News after nearly two decades at ABC, joining CBS in January as one of the first major on-air
00:20:11 hires under editor-in-chief Barry Weiss. According to The Hollywood Reporter, now former ABC News
00:20:18 field producer Sumira Saeed, alleges Guttman created a hostile work environment during two
00:20:25 incidents while they worked together at the network. Saeed working at ABC from 2021 until
00:20:30 she was fired in March of 2025, with the lawsuit reportedly alleging that during one assignment,
00:20:36 she was the only woman on a team of men when Gutman began discussing the appearance of a
00:20:41 female correspondent. According to the suit, Gutman allegedly began rating the women's looks
00:20:46 numerically, with other male members of the crew joining in and discussing her body and appearance.
00:20:52 The lawsuit claiming the men then tried to bring Saeed into the conversation,
00:20:56 though she reportedly refused and told them the discussion was not appropriate.
00:21:00 Saeed alleging a second incident while she and Gutman were covering a press event for a movie
00:21:06 release, apparently in New York City. According to the lawsuit, the two disagreed over whether
00:21:11 the crew should leave the location when Gutman allegedly suggested Saeed must have a date in the
00:21:17 city, and that was why she wanted to stay. From the lawsuit, quote, the remark made audibly to
00:21:22 others demeaned Saeed and reduced her professional judgment to a sexualized stereotype. The lawsuit
00:21:29 now bringing renewed attention to Gutman's previous controversies during his years at ABC.
00:21:35 Last year, Gutman facing widespread backlash while covering the assassination of Charlie Kirk
00:21:40 after describing text messages between accused killer Tyler Robinson and his romantic partner,
00:21:46 furry trans person lance twiggs as follows it was very touching in a way that i think many of us
00:21:52 didn't expect a very intimate portrait into this relationship between the suspect's roommate and
00:21:59 the suspect himself with him repeatedly calling his roommate who was transitioning uh calling him
00:22:05 my love and i want to protect you my love um so it was this duality of someone who the attorney said
00:22:11 not only jeopardized the life of charlie kirk and the crowd but was doing it in front of children
00:22:15 which is one of the aggravating circumstances of this case.
00:22:18 And on the other hand, he was, you know, speaking so lovingly about his partner.
00:22:22 Gutman apologizing for those remarks the following day.
00:22:26 Saeed now seeking compensatory and punitive damages as well as attorney's fees.
00:22:31 CBS News declining to comment to The Hollywood Reporter,
00:22:34 while the outlet reports representatives for ABC News and Gutman also did not respond.
00:22:40 We will have legal analysis today on The MK Show.
00:22:43 and that'll do it for your am update i'm megan kelly join me back here for the mk show live on
00:22:49 sirius xm's the megan kelly channel 111 at new east on youtube.com slash megan kelly and on all
00:22:55 podcast platforms you've put off that upgrade long enough the hyundai upgrade your ride sales event
00:23:05 is on now finance a new hyundai elantra from just 0.99 percent plus don't pay for 90 days
00:23:13 when you finance an Elantra or Venue
00:23:15 and receive up to a $1,000 bonus on select models.
00:23:19 Now that's an upgrade.
00:23:21 The Upgrade to Ride sales event ends August 31st.
00:23:24 Conditions apply.
00:23:26 Visit HyundaiCanada.com or your local dealer for details.