The Megyn Kelly Show - August 16, 2026


Claus von Bülow: The FULL MK Confidential Series

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
The Annihilator: The Reckoning — Ep. 5 | MK Confidential - FINAL Episode on the John List Family Murders Jason Arday Found Dead, Mangione Pleads Guilty in Federal Case, USS Lincoln Relief: AM Update 8⧸17

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 57 minutes

Words per minute

153.26

Word count

17,982

Sentence count

1,223

Harmful content

Misogyny

14

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Recently, our company's softball team lost the big game by one run.
00:00:04 Then Dale tried to console us with the quote,
00:00:07 winning isn't everything.
00:00:09 Well, Dale and I are very different.
00:00:12 I get early payout from Bet365.
00:00:14 If my team goes up big, I get paid out instantly,
00:00:17 even if they blow the lead later.
00:00:19 Sound familiar, Dale?
00:00:21 Thanks, Bet365.
00:00:22 Must be 19 or older, Ontario only.
00:00:24 Please play responsibly.
00:00:25 If you have questions or concerns about your gambling
00:00:26 or the gambling of someone close to you,
00:00:27 please go to connexontario.ca TNC Supply.
00:00:30 You've put off that upgrade long enough.
00:00:32 The Hyundai Upgrade Your Ride sales event is on now.
00:00:36 Finance a new Hyundai Elantra from just 0.99%.
00:00:39 Plus, don't pay for 90 days when you finance an Elantra or venue
00:00:44 and receive up to a $1,000 bonus on select models.
00:00:48 Now that's an upgrade.
00:00:50 The Upgrade Your Ride sales event ends August 31st.
00:00:53 Conditions apply.
00:00:55 Visit HyundaiCanada.com or your local dealer for details.
00:01:00 Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, live on Sirius XM Channel 111 every weekday at New East.
00:01:12 Hey everyone, I'm Megyn Kelly. Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show in today's Sunday
00:01:16 mega episode. Today we are bringing you our entire five-part MK Confidential series looking
00:01:22 at the trials of Klaus von Bülow, including an interview with the man who changed the entire
00:01:28 trajectory of this case, and not to mention the life of Von Bulo, and that's Alan Dershowitz.
00:01:33 We are continuing our MK Confidential series tomorrow night and all next week with the DC
00:01:39 Sniper story. You will not want to miss that. Tune in each night. We air them at 9 p.m.
00:01:45 Enjoy, and we'll see you tomorrow.
00:01:51 Order up. Thank you. No, no, no. Oh, come on.
00:01:58 This is not happening.
00:01:59 Turn off the water.
00:02:00 Where's the shuttle?
00:02:01 The pipe.
00:02:02 There, there.
00:02:06 Gosh, it's everywhere.
00:02:07 Are we covered for this?
00:02:09 Don't know?
00:02:10 Don't worry.
00:02:11 A licensed TD insurance advisor can help you get the right insurance coverage to protect your business.
00:02:16 It's how we're making insurance more human.
00:02:19 You've put off that upgrade long enough.
00:02:21 The Hyundai Upgrade Your Ride sales event is on now.
00:02:24 Finance a new Hyundai Elantra from just 0.99%.
00:02:29 Plus, don't pay for 90 days when you finance an Elantra or venue
00:02:33 and receive up to a $1,000 bonus on select models.
00:02:37 Now that's an upgrade.
00:02:39 The Upgrade to Ride sales event ends August 31st.
00:02:42 Conditions apply.
00:02:44 Visit HyundaiCanada.com or your local dealer for details.
00:02:54 clarendon court is one of the grandest houses on one of the grandest streets in america the
00:03:03 mansion's wrought iron gates form the backdrop of grace kelly's final movie before she retires to
00:03:09 become the princess of monaco a beautiful wealthy high-class woman marrying into aristocracy a kind
00:03:17 of modern fairy tale in 1980 the newport rhode island mansion belongs to a real life beautiful
00:03:24 wealthy, high-class woman and her aristocrat husband. But behind those wrought iron gates
00:03:30 and gold inlaid doors, the real tale is grim. It is the morning of December 21st. The winter sun
00:03:39 shines on the sandstone walls of Clarendon Court, an oceanfront property exposed to the bitter wind
00:03:44 off the water. Inside, a 49-year-old woman lies unconscious on the cold marble floor of her
00:03:51 bathroom. She liked to sleep in a cold room, and the night before, she had asked for her
00:03:56 windows to be left open to the Atlantic. With the wind chill well below zero, the room turned
00:04:02 frigid. By morning, she has gone ice cold to the touch. Her body temperature falls into the low
00:04:09 80s. Her heart stops. The paramedics bring her back, but only part of the way. Martha Von Bulow,
00:04:17 the woman everyone calls Sunny, falls into a coma. She will never regain consciousness.
00:04:25 This would be a private tragedy if not for an eerie wrinkle. This exact scene has happened
00:04:30 before. One year earlier, almost to the day, in the same house, in the same wing, the same woman
00:04:38 was found unconscious on the same floor. That time, a doctor reached her in time. That time,
00:04:45 she woke up. One woman, two Christmases, two comas, and in between them a husband, a devoted
00:04:53 maid, a locked closet, and a small black bag that the state of Rhode Island will one day hold up in
00:05:00 a courtroom and call the weapon. The man at the center of it is Sonny's husband, a Danish-born
00:05:07 aristocrat named Klaus von Bülow. Twice a jury will be asked whether he tried to murder his wife.
00:05:15 Twice, the jury will be shown nearly the same evidence.
00:05:19 This is the story of a case that ended and then ended again.
00:05:24 I'm Megan Kelly, and this is MK Confidential.
00:05:30 To understand how two medical emergencies one year apart become allegations of attempted murder,
00:05:37 we have to start with the marriage.
00:05:39 From the beginning, it is a match of opposites.
00:05:43 Klaus von Bülow is not born an aristocrat. 0.67
00:05:46 He is not even born a Bülow.
00:05:48 He comes into the world as Klaus Borberg in Copenhagen in the summer of 1926.
00:05:54 His father, Sven Borberg, is a Danish playwright and drama critic,
00:06:00 a clever, cultured man whose sympathy for Nazi Germany will destroy his life and reputation. 0.56
00:06:06 He admires the Germans, and he goes on admiring them after they occupied Denmark in 1940.
00:06:13 He dines, as his son will one day put it, with the wrong people.
00:06:18 In Klaus's own words, years later, his father, quote, gave a good name to a bad cause.
00:06:24 When the war ends, the reckoning comes.
00:06:27 Sven Borberg is tried as a Nazi collaborator and convicted.
00:06:31 The conviction is later overturned on appeal, but the name Borberg, once perfectly respectable,
00:06:37 has become an embarrassment.
00:06:39 So Klaus escapes it.
00:06:41 He takes the name of his mother's father, Fritz Bulow, a former Danish minister of justice,
00:06:48 a name that stands for precisely the respectability his father's name has lost.
00:06:53 Then there's the Vaughan.
00:06:56 It comes later, and how it got there has fascinated people ever since.
00:07:00 To much of the press, it is an embellishment, a whisper of old German nobility attached to a borrowed name by a man assembling himself for the world.
00:07:11 Klaus tells it differently.
00:07:14 He says the Bulos are entitled to the Vaughan by blood, and that it was Sonny who wanted her second husband to carry one.
00:07:21 Sonny's former in-laws, the von Auerzbergs, say he has no right to it at all. 0.89
00:07:26 What no one disputes is the effect.
00:07:30 By the time he reaches the drawing rooms of London and New York, the aristocrat is, at least in part, a work of his own composition.
00:07:38 He studies law at Cambridge, goes to work as an aide to J. Paul Getty, then the richest man in the world.
00:07:46 He is tall, polished, quick with a dry, cutting wit, the ideal plus one for a dinner party.
00:07:52 In society, they call the Copenhagen native the Great Dane.
00:07:57 Years later, on trial,
00:07:59 Klaus would itemize the ingredients of his own mystique
00:08:02 with the detachment of a collector.
00:08:05 I think there are certain aspects,
00:08:06 like the aura of the name Newport.
00:08:10 My wife's first marriage gives it a certain cutis.
00:08:13 My work years past for Mr. Getty
00:08:17 gives it a certain interest.
00:08:18 One of the lawyers who would eventually represent him,
00:08:21 Alan Dershowitz,
00:08:22 describes the two men inside Klaus.
00:08:25 It's almost as if there are two Klaus von Willow's, and he presses a button when he walks into a room.
00:08:29 There's the public austere Klaus von Willow, which he sits there, as his current woman friend put it,
00:08:36 as if he were a mortician with an umbrella up his back.
00:08:39 And then there's the warm Klaus von Willow, very caring.
00:08:43 Sunny is the money.
00:08:45 She's born Martha Sharp Crawford in 1931, the only child of a utilities magnate who dies when she is only four years old.
00:08:54 and leaves her something on the order of $75 million, a staggering fortune in any era,
00:09:01 and especially in the years this story takes place, an inheritance that would be worth nearly
00:09:06 $2 billion by today's standards. She is shy, private, and happiest out of the spotlight.
00:09:14 The writer Dominic Dunn knew her for years before she was found on that bathroom floor.
00:09:19 Sonny von Beulah was one of America's great heiresses. She was a very beautiful woman.
00:09:23 I had been to Sonny von Bulo's coming-out party when she was a debutante.
00:09:28 In 1957, Sonny marries an Austrian prince, Alfred von Auerzberg,
00:09:34 and has two children, Allah and Alexander.
00:09:37 By the mid-60s, thanks in part to his infidelities and her homesickness,
00:09:43 that marriage is over.
00:09:44 She brings her children to America, and in 1966, marries Klaus.
00:09:50 A year later, they have their own daughter, Cosima,
00:09:53 And away from the gowns and the society columns,
00:09:57 Sunny's days have an ordinary, regular routine to them.
00:10:01 She wakes late, near 11,
00:10:02 and spends the first hour of every morning on the telephone with her mother.
00:10:06 She shops, she lunches, she changes into lounging clothes and watches television.
00:10:12 She keeps to herself.
00:10:14 And at night, she sleeps surrounded by her dogs, a pair of Labradors up on the bed.
00:10:20 The family lives on Sunny's money.
00:10:22 Everyone in Newport understands the arithmetic,
00:10:25 which no one mentions until it is admitted inside a courtroom.
00:10:29 Clarendon Court, the oceanfront mansion, which they call a cottage, is hers.
00:10:36 The 14-room apartment on Fifth Avenue is hers.
00:10:39 The staff, the cars, the season in Newport,
00:10:42 the whole life among princes and industrialists, all of it is hers.
00:10:48 Klaus draws a comfortable income, about $120,000 a year, but it comes out of a trust she sets up for him,
00:10:56 which is another way of saying it is an allowance.
00:10:59 Among the old families, quietly, he is regarded as a kept man,
00:11:03 and there is between them a prenuptial agreement with terms that will one day prove enormously important.
00:11:11 If Klaus and Sonny divorce, Klaus walks away with almost nothing.
00:11:16 If Sonny dies, well, that is another matter entirely.
00:11:19 But if Sonny was dead, then he would have title to a house in Rhode Island,
00:11:25 a wonderful apartment in Manhattan, and a great deal of money.
00:11:31 Sonny's stepfather, the big game hunter Russell Aitken, does not hide his contempt.
00:11:38 He tells Dominic Dunn, on the record,
00:11:40 Klaus is a Cambridge-educated con man with legal training, 0.99
00:11:44 Amoral, greedy as a wolverine, and cold-blooded as a snake. 0.99
00:11:49 And I apologize, Aitken adds, to the snake. 0.91
00:11:53 One friend puts it to Dunn this way, quote,
00:11:55 The problem with Klaus is that he does not dwell in the palace of truth. 0.61
00:12:00 He's a fake. 0.90
00:12:01 Klaus is a Trump loi, a trick of the eye, something painted to look like what it is not. 0.98
00:12:08 One person sees this marriage from the inside every day.
00:12:11 Her name is Maria Schrollhammer, and she is Sonny's personal maid, a small, graying German woman who speaks in heavily accented English and has been at Sonny's side for 23 years.
00:12:25 She is fiercely loyal to Sonny.
00:12:28 So protective is she of Sonny's privacy that she will refuse to tell even Klaus's own lawyers that Sonny once had a facelift because she had promised Sonny she would never tell.
00:12:40 If anyone sees the marriage up close, it's Maria.
00:12:43 I'm not going to answer the question because I promised Mrs. Vombulo.
00:12:47 By the late 1970s, the Vombulo marriage is cold.
00:12:52 Separate bedrooms, separate routines, and Sunny is not well.
00:12:57 Her doctors diagnose reactive hypoglycemia.
00:13:00 Her blood sugar can crash on its own, and when it does, she turns confused and unsteady and slurred,
00:13:06 the way a person does when they've had far too much to drink.
00:13:10 She keeps herself going on sweets and aspirin and sedatives like Valium and Seconil,
00:13:16 and on alcohol her body can barely handle.
00:13:20 It is a real and documented illness, 0.57
00:13:22 and it will also one day give the defense a natural explanation for everything that happens to her. 1.00
00:13:29 And there is another woman.
00:13:31 By the late 70s, Klaus is having an affair with Alexandra Isles.
00:13:36 She is not just, as the papers will call her, a soap opera actress,
00:13:40 though she does play one on the gothic serial Dark Shadows.
00:13:44 Alexandra is royalty, the daughter of a countess, schooled alongside Sonny herself.
00:13:51 The family would learn of the affair and testify to how they found out.
00:13:56 Klaus told them.
00:13:57 I then asked him about Alexandra Isles specifically.
00:14:02 He told me that there had been a relationship.
00:14:04 And Isles, by most accounts, was pressing Klaus to make a choice.
00:14:09 I said, would six months be suitable?
00:14:14 He asked me to marry him.
00:14:15 That is the pressure Klaus is under by 1980.
00:14:19 A marriage that has gone cold and a mistress who wants a decision.
00:14:23 Leaving Sonny for another woman would mean leaving the life her money pays for. 0.85
00:14:28 Leaving Sonny dead would not.
00:14:30 Plenty of men have affairs and unhappy marriages and never harm anyone.
00:14:35 That alone proves nothing.
00:14:37 But it is the shape of a situation that investigators years later will recognize as motive.
00:14:44 The first collapse comes at Christmas 1979 at Clarendon Court.
00:14:49 Sunny fades over a long day and Maria, who has cared for her for two decades, can see her lady sinking.
00:14:56 I went to her and I saw that her right arm was hanging out of the bed and I took her arm and the arm was ice cold.
00:15:06 She hardly could breathe anymore and I thought she would stop any minute now.
00:15:13 I got very scared she would die and first I asked Mr. von Willow to help me to put her up and he said he couldn't help me.
00:15:23 So I just picked her up, and I was holding her in my arms until the doctor came.
00:15:30 Here's the chronology that will trouble everyone later.
00:15:33 By Maria's account, she urges Klaus for hours.
00:15:37 He first telephones the doctor only in the early afternoon and leaves a message.
00:15:41 When the doctor calls him back, Klaus tells him only that Sonny is sleeping off a night of drinking and is told to keep watching her.
00:15:49 Not until around six that evening, when her breathing turns to a rattle, does Klaus let
00:15:54 the doctor be called for real.
00:15:56 The local physician who answers, Dr. Janice Galitis, arrives at the same moment as the
00:16:02 ambulance.
00:16:03 Galitis clears Sonny's throat with his fingers, strikes her chest, and does CPR until Sonny's
00:16:09 heart restarts.
00:16:10 He saves her life by a matter of minutes.
00:16:13 Within a day, Sonny is awake and recovering.
00:16:16 And then Klaus does something a little strange.
00:16:19 Weeks later, on January 22nd, 1980, he sits down and writes the doctor a careful letter.
00:16:26 His mother-in-law feels he was slow to get help, so Klaus lays out the timeline his own way
00:16:32 and then asks the doctor two direct questions.
00:16:35 Have I stated everything fairly?
00:16:37 And was I to blame?
00:16:39 Two weeks later, Galetus writes back that the collapse was unpredictable
00:16:44 and that by recognizing the change in Sonny's condition
00:16:47 and calling him, Klaus saved her life.
00:16:51 To investigators who read it later,
00:16:52 this looks like a man collecting protection on paper
00:16:55 the way other men collect receipts.
00:16:58 In February 1980, Maria is cleaning a closet 0.75
00:17:01 in the Fifth Avenue apartment
00:17:03 when she comes across a soft traveling case
00:17:06 that Klaus carries back and forth to Newport each week.
00:17:10 It is open.
00:17:11 Inside it is a smaller case, black vinyl, about six inches long with a zipper around it.
00:17:18 Maria opens it.
00:17:19 Inside is a little pharmacy, pills and vials.
00:17:24 She calls in Sonny's daughter, Ala, and the two women take careful notes.
00:17:29 Prescriptions from a Madison Avenue pharmacy, one bottle made out to a Leslie Baxter,
00:17:35 another one made out to Klaus von Bülow at an address that does not exist.
00:17:39 Maria gets a little of the powder and liquid to Sonny's doctor of nearly 30 years, Dr. Richard Stock.
00:17:46 He identifies them, Valium and a barbiturate, Secobarbital.
00:17:52 In April, Sonny is hospitalized again, weak and disoriented.
00:17:56 The doctors point once more to her blood sugar.
00:17:59 Then on the Sunday after Thanksgiving, Maria goes back into the black bag.
00:18:04 This time, next to the familiar vials, there is something new.
00:18:08 A small bottle labeled insulin.
00:18:12 And syringes.
00:18:13 Neither Klaus nor Sonny is diabetic.
00:18:16 Maria takes the bottle to Sonny's son, Alexander.
00:18:19 There was a bottle of insulin added, a syringe, and needles.
00:18:26 I called Alexander insulin for what insulin?
00:18:30 Insulin is the reason this bag matters.
00:18:33 To the investigators who eventually build the case,
00:18:35 it looks almost ideal for a killer.
00:18:38 A large enough insulin dose can drive a person's blood sugar into a fatal coma.
00:18:44 And once it has done its work, it is very hard to prove after the fact that an injection ever happened.
00:18:50 For now, it is a bottle that has no business in this house,
00:18:54 sitting in the private bag of a man whose wife has already suffered one unexplained collapse that nearly killed her.
00:19:01 The insulin is not the only alarm that winter.
00:19:03 In early December, Sunny takes so much aspirin, she says for a sinus headache,
00:19:08 that she is hospitalized for about a week with aspirin poisoning around the same time there is
00:19:14 a night when klaus knocks on maria's door and tells her not to get excited but that something
00:19:19 has happened maria will later say she entered the room and found sunny in bed full with blood
00:19:27 with a wound at the back of her head and blood on the pillow and the carpet klaus says sunny got 0.77
00:19:32 dizzy and fell. Depending on who's telling it, this is either a woman being harmed inside her
00:19:38 own home or a fragile, sick woman leaning on pills and drink, coming apart on her own.
00:19:45 Then, almost a year to the day later, comes the second coma. December 20, 1980. The family is
00:19:54 together at Clarendon Court. Over dinner, Sonny insists on an ice cream sundae with caramel sauce,
00:20:00 exactly the kind of sugar her doctors have told her to avoid.
00:20:05 Afterward, they go out to the movies to see Dolly Parton in 9 to 5 and then come home.
00:20:11 Klaus goes off to his study.
00:20:13 Sunny stays up with Alexander and Cosima.
00:20:16 As the evening wears on, Sunny's speech starts to slur and thicken.
00:20:22 She can't quite hold a conversation.
00:20:25 Her son helps her up to her bedroom and gets her into bed.
00:20:28 then alexander goes back out to meet friends at a bar when he leaves his mother is unwell but
00:20:34 talking the next morning she does not come down sunny is a late sleeper but after 11 o'clock
00:20:42 klaus goes up to check on her he comes back down a few minutes later and motions to alexander
00:20:47 who follows him upstairs they find her on the marble floor of the bathroom unconscious her
00:20:54 head near the base of the toilet, her lips swollen and bleeding, the sink tap still running.
00:21:01 Klaus puts a finger under her nose and says she is still breathing and goes to call for
00:21:06 help.
00:21:07 Alexander touches his mother's neck, feels that she is ice cold, and covers her with
00:21:12 a fur throw.
00:21:14 The first responders would never forget the scene.
00:21:18 As soon as I walked in the room, knelt beside her.
00:21:21 She was in trouble.
00:21:22 There was no blood anywhere in the bathroom.
00:21:24 Six minutes later, the ambulance arrives and takes her, with Klaus riding along, to the Newport Hospital emergency room.
00:21:32 Sunny's body temperature is 81 degrees, her pulse barely there.
00:21:37 A few minutes after she arrives, her heart stops, and it takes two doctors to bring her back.
00:21:43 From Newport, she is moved to a specialist hospital in Boston, and the scans come back with the answer, no one wants.
00:21:51 What the responders remembered was the husband.
00:21:55 Mr. Von Bulo looked at this person, who he identified as his wife,
00:22:00 with ice-cold blue eyes, and there was absolutely no feeling.
00:22:07 He just sat there.
00:22:08 The doctors can restart Sonny's heart.
00:22:11 They cannot bring back the woman her children knew.
00:22:15 She's alive and breathing and gone.
00:22:18 And this time, there is no letter, no relief, no narrow escape.
00:22:25 There are only questions about what happened in that house the night before.
00:22:30 Sonny's family does not accept this as bad luck.
00:22:34 In the New York hospital where she is moved, a neurologist tells Alexander and Allah
00:22:38 that in his judgment, their mother's coma was caused by injected insulin.
00:22:43 And that winter of 1980 into 1981, their stepfather, Klaus, is on the phone with the two of them almost every day, urging them to agree to take Sonny off the machines, appealing by more than one account to their emotions and their finances.
00:23:02 The calls only stop when Sonny is taken off the respirator and keeps breathing on her own.
00:23:08 So the children decide to act.
00:23:11 It is Alexander who says out loud what the others are thinking.
00:23:14 Their half-sister, Cosima, is a teenager and she is living under the same roof
00:23:19 as the man they now suspect of trying to murder her mother.
00:23:23 Can they leave Cosima there?
00:23:25 My mother is a very trusting person.
00:23:28 I think nobody really could believe that somebody could be plotting to kill you
00:23:33 while at the same time they're being nice to you and telling you they love you.
00:23:39 The family's banker, Morris Gurley, urges caution.
00:23:43 Before anyone accuses anyone, he says,
00:23:45 they should do this quietly and properly and hire a professional.
00:23:49 So they hire Richard Q, a former district attorney of Manhattan.
00:23:54 His job is not to go to the police, not yet, and not to go to the press.
00:24:00 His job is to build the case the family believes is there, statement by statement.
00:24:06 They felt there was the need for somebody who knew something about criminal justice and who could conduct some further investigation and do it discreetly.
00:24:18 They wanted no publicity unless or until ultimately there was proof of Klaus's guilt.
00:24:26 Q sits down first with Alexandra and Ala, and then with Maria, and Maria tells him about that bag, the bottles, the syringes, the insulin with no patient.
00:24:40 Everything the family's suspicion has fastened onto keeps leading back to the same place, the small black case Klaus carries between the houses, and that Maria last saw inside a locked closet at Clarendon Court.
00:24:54 To prove anything, someone is going to have to open that closet.
00:24:58 Alex said he'd go up and look for the bag.
00:25:01 And we had a private investigator, a very skilled one, with whom I'd worked, Eddie Lambert.
00:25:06 And I said, no, we'd send Eddie with him, really to protect Alex in case anything untoward happened.
00:25:14 On a January day in 1981, they do it.
00:25:19 Alexander, the investigator, and a locksmith drive to the shuttered mansion,
00:25:24 and the locksmith opens the locked closet.
00:25:28 Inside is the bag.
00:25:30 In their haste, they take no photographs and lift no fingerprints,
00:25:34 a detail the defense will one day make a great deal of.
00:25:38 But for now, they simply take the black bag.
00:25:40 We knew that there was a pouch and a metal box in my stepfather's closet containing a needle,
00:25:45 which then turned out to have insulin and amobarbital on it there were several other
00:25:51 things that had led to suspicions everything put together made us believe that we had to go to the
00:25:56 police the family's own doctor tests the bag finds insulin on the used needle and tells them plainly
00:26:04 either you take this to the police or i will and so the case passes to the rhode island state police
00:26:10 and to a detective named Jack Reese, who starts over from the beginning.
00:26:16 When he interviews Alexander, one thing lands hard,
00:26:20 the young man's honesty about the limits of what he actually saw.
00:26:24 If he was so determined to build a case against his stepfather,
00:26:29 it would have been very easy for him to say, I saw the insulin.
00:26:32 He did not.
00:26:34 To me, that led to his credibility.
00:26:37 The detective talks to his partner and decides to set a trap for Klaus.
00:26:43 The police already have the black bag with a pharmacy inside.
00:26:47 They have the used needle and they have a husband who may still believe both are locked away inside Clarendon Court.
00:26:54 So Detective Jack Reese and his partner drive to the von Bülow's place in Manhattan and park outside the apartment and wait for Klaus, just watching for their chance.
00:27:06 Reese sits in his car, ready to confront Klaus,
00:27:08 to ask him a question, to push him,
00:27:11 and then watch and see what he does next.
00:27:13 What will Klaus do when he thinks no one is watching?
00:27:17 That's next time on MK Confidential.
00:27:29 Lieutenant Detective Jack Reese of the Rhode Island State Police
00:27:33 and his partner are staking out Klaus von Bülow. They are set up outside the von Bülow's place
00:27:39 in Manhattan. When Klaus finally comes up on the sidewalk outside the couple's Fifth Avenue
00:27:44 apartment, the detective quickly confronts him, questioning him with no warning and no lawyers
00:27:50 around. I didn't want an interview where he had an opportunity to think over what he would say
00:27:57 to us. So I thought that the best way to do that was to take him by surprise. He was obviously very
00:28:03 nervous. Near the end, the detective slips in one more question, almost an afterthought. Whether
00:28:10 Sonny would ever have had a reason to use insulin. Years later, Jack Reese describes the exchange to
00:28:17 journalist Bill Curtis. You know, I asked a kind of a ridiculous question. And I said, you don't 0.90
00:28:23 suppose that your wife uh were using insulin for any reason and he said by god that's the last 0.95
00:28:29 thing she would need that clinched it for the detective i said to my partner mark my way she's
00:28:36 going back for that black bag within three days detective reese's prediction comes true klaus
00:28:43 bombulo drives back up to newport rhode island to clarendon court the shuttered oceanfront mansion
00:28:49 where Sonny collapsed. The state police follow Klaus, this time with a warrant. Reese rings the
00:28:56 bell for a second interview, and while two detectives keep Klaus talking in one room,
00:29:01 other cops go through the house. During the search, officers make several observations.
00:29:07 On the desk in Klaus's study, one of them notices a scratch pad. Two words are written on it,
00:29:13 black box. Then officers come upon Klaus's closet, standing open and unlocked. Inside it,
00:29:21 police find a small black metal box, the one Maria had described, the box that held the little black
00:29:28 bag. Sometime during the police interview, Klaus excuses himself for a few minutes. When the
00:29:34 detectives look again, the closet has been relocked and the scratch pad is gone. But the bag
00:29:42 is not in that box.
00:29:44 It has not been for weeks.
00:29:46 Sonny's grown son from her first marriage,
00:29:48 Alexander, and a locksmith
00:29:50 have already carried it out.
00:29:53 And by now, it is in an evidence room in Providence.
00:29:56 Whatever Klaus went upstairs to do,
00:29:58 he came back down without it.
00:30:01 The way he surmised that he hadn't found the black bag
00:30:04 and he was probably a little concerned
00:30:06 that he may have misplaced it.
00:30:08 The detectives never saw Klaus open that closet,
00:30:11 and they never saw him reach for the bag.
00:30:14 What they had was a relocked door,
00:30:17 a now-missing notepad,
00:30:19 and a man who had driven 90 miles
00:30:21 to a closed-up house in January.
00:30:24 It is not proof,
00:30:26 but it's enough for Detective Jack Reese.
00:30:28 A year before, all the family had
00:30:30 was a maid's bad feeling about a case full of pills.
00:30:34 Now the state of Rhode Island has the bag,
00:30:36 the needle inside it,
00:30:38 and a suspect.
00:30:39 I'm Megan Kelly.
00:30:41 This is MK Confidential.
00:30:45 In July of 1981, a Rhode Island grand jury indicts Klaus von Bülow on two counts of assault with intent to murder.
00:30:54 One count for each of the two comas.
00:30:57 A week later, he surrenders for arraignment, pleads not guilty, and is released on $100,000 bail.
00:31:04 When Klaus is arraigned, he gives the only answer he will give in the entire case.
00:31:09 You are charged with two counts. Count one, assault and attempted murder. Count two, assault and attempted murder. How do you play it? I'm not guilty.
00:31:22 The trial opens in Newport in February of 1982. The state has to prove two separate crimes a year apart. The Christmas Sunny nearly died in 1979 and the Christmas she did not wake up in 1980.
00:31:38 State is ready to proceed?
00:31:39 Yes, Your Honor, the state is ready to proceed.
00:31:41 Been ready to proceed?
00:31:42 Yes, we are, Your Honor.
00:31:43 Rhode Island has just let television cameras into its courtrooms,
00:31:47 so the trial of Klaus von Bülow becomes something the country has never quite seen.
00:31:52 A crime story the whole nation can watch, nearly gavel to gavel, like a soap opera.
00:31:57 A maid, a mistress, a fortune, a needle, and an aristocratic, silent defendant,
00:32:05 The state calls an attempted murderer.
00:32:09 Downtown Newport becomes, in the words of one man who was there, a madhouse.
00:32:14 The old colonial statehouse beside the courthouse is turned into a press center.
00:32:18 Sketch artists and reporters fight for one of the 80 seats inside. 0.81
00:32:22 The jury that files in is not made up of Newport's summer people.
00:32:27 It is drawn from the year-round town, working Rhode Islanders, mostly Catholic.
00:32:32 It's the kind of jury Klaus's own side privately doubts can ever be a jury of his peers.
00:32:39 And at the center of it, ramrod straight and immaculate, sits Klaus von Bülow,
00:32:45 giving the reporters almost nothing, except now and then a dry line about the spectacle he has become.
00:32:53 This simply is the first time I'd ever been exposed to the media.
00:32:57 It was new to me, and I think I belong to the kind of people who like to be in the newspaper the day they are born, the day they get married, and the day they die.
00:33:07 I suddenly realized that this was a futile wish.
00:33:11 For weeks, The Trial is the best show in the country.
00:33:15 The networks carry it.
00:33:17 On CNN, more than 300,000 viewers routinely tune in, a lot for that time.
00:33:21 when actress Alexandra Isles of the hit TV show Dark Shadows takes the stand, the audience climbs
00:33:28 past 600,000. Newspaper artists sketch Klaus in his dark, well-cut suits, and strangers gather
00:33:36 on the courthouse steps, some of them wearing buttons that read, Free Klaus, others just as
00:33:42 sure he is exactly what the state says he is, an attempted murderer. The town of Newport itself
00:33:48 cannot agree. The old families who summer behind the same hedges are split down the middle over
00:33:54 whether the man is a wronged husband or a fortune hunter who finally reached too far, and they say
00:34:01 so, at their dinner tables and to any reporter who will write it down. Klaus has pleaded not guilty.
00:34:08 He makes one more choice that will shape the whole trial. He will never take the stand.
00:34:15 Across the whole trial, the jury, the 12 people deciding his fate,
00:34:19 will not hear a single word from the accused.
00:34:23 Inside the family, the sides are already fixed.
00:34:26 Sonny's two older children brought the case, Ala and Alexander.
00:34:30 The only person in the family standing with Klaus is Kosima,
00:34:34 the daughter he and Sonny had together, still just a teenager.
00:34:38 There was never a time where I doubted it.
00:34:40 And we would always talk openly about what was going on.
00:34:47 And just seeing him go through the anguish of it all and seeing him with the lawyers saying,
00:34:54 you can investigate anything, I really don't have anything to hide, was enough for me to believe it.
00:34:59 Klaus sits through it all with a stillness that unsettles the people around him.
00:35:05 He is unfailingly courteous to the reporters in the hallway.
00:35:09 Dominic Dunn covers the trial for Vanity Fair magazine, whose readers cannot get enough.
00:35:16 He describes a defendant who seems less like a man fighting for his life than a man watching with mild interest a drama about someone else.
00:35:26 The prosecutor is Stephen Famiglietti.
00:35:30 And in his opening, he tells the jury exactly what the state means to prove.
00:35:34 The stable pool was a clandestine, subtle, and ingenious attempt on the part of her husband, Klaus Van Dulo, to terminate her life, to murder her, by secretly injecting her with a drug called insulin.
00:35:49 It is a large promise, and Famiglietti knows the case is harder than it sounds.
00:35:55 No eyewitnesses, no confession, a woman in a coma who cannot testify, and weeks of medical testimony ahead of him.
00:36:03 I thought it was an extremely difficult case, and primarily because it was a circumstantial evidence case, meaning that there were no eyewitnesses to the alleged criminal conduct, and there was so much medical testimony.
00:36:17 The tougher job for the state is the first coma, the one from which Sonny recovered.
00:36:23 To make it a crime and not just a bad night, Famiglietti has to convince the jury that this was a first attempt, a rehearsal for the next Christmas when it worked.
00:36:34 The state's first witness is Sonny's own son, Alexander, who gives the jury the story of the marriage from the inside.
00:36:42 My stepfather said that after my younger sister was born, my mother was unable to have sex, and that he looked towards other women.
00:36:54 Did he mention any other woman, one woman in particular?
00:36:58 Alexandra Isles.
00:37:00 His sister, Allah, takes the stand and tells the jury why her mother had begun talking about a divorce.
00:37:07 She felt he was on the verge of a nervous breakdown, that he was blaming her for the fact that he'd been having no success in his professional life.
00:37:16 Then comes Maria Schralhammer, son he's made of 23 years.
00:37:22 Maria has never once sat in a witness box.
00:37:25 And when she climbs into one now in a Newport courtroom in front of the television cameras and a nation leaning in,
00:37:31 She describes the black bag, the vials, and the small bottle of insulin she says she found
00:37:53 among the belongings of a woman who had low blood sugar, which can be caused by too much
00:37:59 insulin and thus had no use for any more of it. Maria is a small, plain-spoken woman with a heavy
00:38:07 German accent, and by common agreement, she is the most important witness the state has. She does not 0.89
00:38:13 raise her voice. She just tells the jury what she saw. The defense cross-examines her over parts of
00:38:20 two days and does not move her a single inch. Then the doctors, Sonny's own physician of nearly
00:38:27 three decades, Dr. Richard Stock, tells the jury what he believed had been done to her.
00:38:33 It was the surreptitious administration of insulin. One of the country's foremost authorities on
00:38:39 insulin, Dr. George Cahill of Harvard, testifies that the second coma bears the mark of an
00:38:46 injection, one that no illness in Sonny's own body could produce. The state puts the physical
00:38:53 evidence beside him. The used needle from the black bag, which the family's own doctor has found
00:38:59 carried insulin at its tip. And it puts a number in front of the jury. A blood test drawn the
00:39:07 morning Sonny was admitted, showing an insulin level of 216, many times higher than normal,
00:39:14 next to a blood sugar that had crashed toward nothing. Then the family's banker, Morris Gurley,
00:39:21 The trust officer who ran Sonny's fortune gives the jury the arithmetic.
00:39:27 If Sonny dies, Klaus stands to inherit about $14 million.
00:39:32 If they divorce, the prenuptial agreement leaves him with almost nothing.
00:39:37 Sonny alive and divorced from Klaus is worth next to nothing to him.
00:39:42 Sonny dead is worth a fortune.
00:39:45 The black bag itself is entered into evidence.
00:39:48 It's small pharmacy laid out on a table for the jury to look at, the vials, the syringes, and the used needle the state calls the attempted murder weapon.
00:39:58 The medical case runs on for weeks.
00:40:01 Doctors for the state and doctors for the defense take the jury down into blood sugar readings and insulin levels and the exact chemistry of a body shutting down, each side certain of the opposite conclusion.
00:40:13 It is slow, technical, and fiercely disputed.
00:40:18 What the jurors can weigh more plainly is the maid, the money, and the black bag on the table
00:40:24 in front of them. Then the state calls the other woman. Alexandra Isles, the mistress,
00:40:31 takes the stand, and the prosecutor asks her in front of the cameras whether she still thinks
00:40:37 the charges against the man she loved are nonsense. You still think a speck of nonsense?
00:40:43 Don't know.
00:40:44 I didn't hear that answer.
00:40:46 I don't know.
00:40:47 Let me ask you this long last question, Mrs. Isles.
00:40:51 Maybe you can answer, do you still love the defender?
00:40:58 I don't know.
00:41:01 The defense is offered the chance to cross-examine her and turns it down.
00:41:06 Klaus's lead lawyer, Harold Price Ferringer,
00:41:09 tells the court he will not put Mrs. Isles through any more questioning.
00:41:13 The line going around the courthouse is that
00:41:15 a gentleman does not permit the cross-examination of his lover. 0.91
00:41:20 She steps down.
00:41:22 The defense's case is that there was no crime here at all.
00:41:26 That Sonny, with her drinking, her aspirin, her sedatives,
00:41:29 and her failing blood sugar, had done this to herself.
00:41:32 what happened to her was not anyone's fault but her own and that sad fact will emerge in this case
00:41:39 if the truth is to prevail to account for the insulin the defense calls a former exercise
00:41:46 instructor named joy o'neill who testifies that sunny once told her years earlier that she injected
00:41:53 insulin herself to keep her weight down it is the innocent account the defense has been looking for
00:41:59 Then the prosecution produces the exercise studio's own appointment cards.
00:42:05 They show O'Neill had given Sonny a handful of sessions only, not the hundreds she had just described under oath.
00:42:14 Beyond O'Neill, the defense is thin.
00:42:17 Klaus doesn't testify.
00:42:18 His lawyers spend most of their case picking at the state's witnesses rather than putting up their own defense and pressing the single argument they have.
00:42:26 that a secretive, self-medicating woman who drank and swallowed aspirin by the fistful
00:42:32 was the only person who ever did Sonny von Bülow any harm.
00:42:37 In his closing, defense attorney Faringer goes after the way the black bag was found,
00:42:43 a private search run by a family that already believed Klaus guilty,
00:42:48 with no police in the room and no fingerprints ever lifted.
00:42:51 Had fingerprints been taken off of that bag, off of those vials, off of those needles,
00:43:00 and Martha von Bülow's fingerprints were on those vials and on those needles,
00:43:04 wouldn't that be important to you?
00:43:06 It's a fair question, and it is the one the defense will build an entire second trial around.
00:43:12 But in this courtroom, the prosecutor answers it and gets the last word.
00:43:16 In his summation, Famiglietti reduces the case to one question.
00:43:35 Not a menu of innocent explanations, he tells the jurors.
00:43:39 One thing, true or false.
00:43:42 Did Klaus von Bülow try to murder his wife?
00:43:45 The jury goes out.
00:43:47 One day passes, then a second.
00:43:51 Outside the courthouse, the two camps sit.
00:43:53 Sonny's grown children wait on one side,
00:43:56 while Klaus's loyalists and the reporters who have covered every hour of the trial on the other.
00:44:02 No one can read the silence coming out of the jury room.
00:44:05 A third day, a fourth.
00:44:08 The longer it runs, the more the whispers start.
00:44:11 That the jury is divided.
00:44:12 That the case could end in a hung jury.
00:44:15 that after everything the state may not have convinced all 12 jurors a fifth day comes and
00:44:21 goes then on the sixth day a verdict the courtroom fills fast klaus in his usual chair his daughter
00:44:30 cosima not far away the camera's running it is the morning of march 16th 1982 the jury finds that
00:44:39 The defendant, Klaus van Buur, guilty.
00:44:42 Guilty on both counts.
00:44:45 There are audible gasps in the courtroom.
00:44:48 Klaus does not move.
00:44:50 The cameras catch only a flicker across his face, a small twitch, there and gone.
00:44:57 Weeks later, a judge will sentence him to 30 years, 10 for the 1979 coma and 20 for 1980,
00:45:04 and lets him stay free on a million-dollar bail while he appeals.
00:45:09 Outside the courthouse, Sonny's children say what they have believed from the start.
00:45:14 We feel very strongly that he tried twice to murder our mother.
00:45:19 We believe that he deprived her of life as we know it, deprived her of many years of happiness.
00:45:26 And that is the story.
00:45:29 A cash-poor Danish aristocrat marries a wealthy heiress, lives lavishly on her fortune,
00:45:34 falls in love with another woman and stands to inherit 14 million dollars if his wife
00:45:39 dies. Twice at Christmas in the same house, the state says he tried to collect. A maid
00:45:47 noticed the bottle that did not belong. The woman's children refused to let it go. And 0.59
00:45:53 12 ordinary people from Rhode Island looked past the title and the accent and convicted
00:45:59 him. The system worked. A rich man tried to murder his wife, and he was caught. Case closed.
00:46:07 Except it isn't, because the case does not end here. Not by a long shot. Everything the first
00:46:16 jury believed, the maid's memory, the needle, the blood test, the $14 million, is about to be
00:46:22 examined again, only this time by a Harvard law professor and 18 of his best and brightest
00:46:29 students. And they are going to find questions no one in that first courtroom even thought to ask.
00:46:37 Just over two weeks after the guilty verdict, before Klaus has even been sentenced,
00:46:42 the phone rings in the professor's office on April Fool's Day. The man on the line says
00:46:48 he has just been convicted of trying to murder his wife
00:46:51 and he wants the professor to take his case.
00:46:55 The professor is certain it is a prank.
00:46:58 He almost hangs up the phone.
00:47:01 But then?
00:47:03 That's next time on MK Confidential,
00:47:06 where we speak to the professor directly.
00:47:08 it is april 1st 1982 april fool's day the phone rings in the office of a harvard law professor
00:47:23 on the other end is a man the entire country has just watched get convicted of attempted murder
00:47:29 asking the professor to take his case the harvard man thinks it's a prank very nearly hangs up
00:47:36 but he doesn't. Over the next three years, that professor and 18 law students will take the most
00:47:44 famous conviction in America and turn it completely inside out. The professor's name
00:47:50 is Alan Dershowitz, a kid from Brooklyn, a graduate of Yale Law with a reputation as
00:47:56 the top lawyer of last resort and a friend of mine. So rather than tell you what happened
00:48:03 with Alan Dershowitz and his students, we decided to ask him directly. Coming up, Alan breaks it
00:48:09 down in his own words, the notes, the needle, the science, and any doubt he still carries.
00:48:16 I'm Megan Kelly, and this is MK Confidential.
00:48:22 A quick word about this episode. Most of what you're going to hear is a conversation. Yours
00:48:28 Truly and Alan Dershowitz, the man who engineered one of the most stunning reversals in American
00:48:34 legal history. You will also hear a few moments from the 1990 Oscar-winning film made based on
00:48:40 Alan's book, Reversal of Fortune, starring Jeremy Irons and Glenn Close. So let's start at the
00:48:47 beginning with your relationship with Klaus. He called you for the first time on April Fool's Day.
00:48:54 you did not believe it was actually Klaus von Bülow.
00:48:58 So what actually made you take Klaus von Bülow's case?
00:49:02 Well, first of all, my son, I thought it was him who called me.
00:49:06 My son, Ilan, always was calling me, pretending to be famous people.
00:49:10 He called me, pretending to be Michael Jackson.
00:49:12 I believed him.
00:49:13 And so I thought he was Klaus von Bülow.
00:49:16 But then when he told me, everybody thinks I'm guilty,
00:49:20 I said, that's my kind of case.
00:49:22 I'm going to do it.
00:49:23 And everybody said, there's no way you would win the appeal.
00:49:25 There's no way you'd win a retrial.
00:49:27 So it was a challenge, and I love challenges.
00:49:30 And this was not, to him, an ordinary appeal.
00:49:34 So what was at stake for Klaus?
00:49:37 Allen spoke to that.
00:49:38 He said, Allen, this is a capital case.
00:49:40 I said, but you haven't been sentenced to death.
00:49:42 You've been sentenced to 30 years.
00:49:43 He said, Allen, I'm not going into prison.
00:49:46 I'm going to do what a gentleman does.
00:49:48 if you don't reverse my conviction, I'm not going to prison. He was going to kill himself.
00:49:55 And so we did regard the case as a capital case because I know he meant it.
00:49:59 Allen has said that he would never even have been allowed into Newport, into Clarendon Court,
00:50:04 with all its glitz and glamour. But Klaus is the ultimate insider. The accent, the title,
00:50:11 the Fifth Avenue apartment. So why does Klaus von Bulow call a kid from Brooklyn to help him?
00:50:17 He was the man who recommended me to be his lawyer. I didn't know Klaus Rambiola, he didn't know me, but he sought a recommendation from a former Supreme Court justice of the United States, who was then retired.
00:50:33 And the justice said, I can't do it. I'm retired. But Dershowitz is a really good appellate lawyer. Hire him. And so actually the justice took notes on the side of the briefs. And I used some of his notes in my argument.
00:50:50 There's a famous scene in Reversal of Fortune where your character says to him something like,
00:50:57 you're very odd, Klaus.
00:50:59 And Jeremy Irons playing Klaus responds, you have no idea.
00:51:04 No idea.
00:51:05 Was he odd?
00:51:05 He was odd, but my son Elon wrote that line.
00:51:09 You're a very strange man.
00:51:12 You have no idea.
00:51:14 I had told my son Elon was one of the producers of the movie, and of course he knew me very well.
00:51:19 And I told him about my actual encounter with Klaus and that I said to him, you know, Klaus, I don't understand you.
00:51:27 You're I just we are totally different.
00:51:31 You seem so so weird and strange.
00:51:34 And he said back, yeah, but you don't really have any idea about how strange I am.
00:51:40 And then Ilan wrote it into you have no idea.
00:51:43 And they use that in The Lion King as well.
00:51:45 And it became kind of a famous line in motion picture.
00:51:49 But it was a very important line in the movie.
00:51:52 So you, like everybody else, when you'd been looking at it from the outside, thought for sure this guy is guilty.
00:51:57 Oh, of course.
00:51:58 Then you get on the inside.
00:52:00 And did you change your mind about his almost certain guilt?
00:52:05 Yeah, I changed it first from almost certain guilt to I'm not sure to finally there was no crime there.
00:52:13 There was just no crime.
00:52:15 She did it to herself.
00:52:16 we found all the evidence that she was self-destructive
00:52:20 and she was drinking and eating things
00:52:23 she wasn't supposed to drink and eat.
00:52:25 And then we were able to prove scientifically 0.84
00:52:27 that there was never any insulin
00:52:28 and the government's entire theory collapsed.
00:52:32 And at that point, I was fairly confident
00:52:35 that we'd win the appeal.
00:52:36 So you decide to assemble a dream team of lawyers
00:52:40 and lawyers in training from Harvard Law School,
00:52:43 where you have been a professor at that point
00:52:46 for years and ultimately for 50 years. It was it was a dream team, right? Am I right that
00:52:52 some of the people helping you have household names today?
00:52:56 Oh, yeah. You know, it was a real dream team, unlike the OJ case, which was a nightmare team.
00:53:02 Everybody fought with each other in the OJ case because they were trying to become the one who
00:53:07 got credit for the result. In the Ivan Bulow case, we all worked together very, very nicely.
00:53:13 I worked with Susan Estridge. I worked with some other professors. And then, of course, I assembled a group of great students, not only from the law school, but from the medical school as well, because this was very much a scientific case, a medical case.
00:53:27 I had been teaching for years the issue of law and science, how students, if they want to become really great criminal lawyers, have to really immerse themselves in science and technology and medicine.
00:53:38 And this was the perfect case to illustrate that.
00:53:40 all right so you've got your dream team uh assembled what what was the room actually like
00:53:45 because you broke them out into teams well i had a very large harvard house back in the day with
00:53:50 the basketball court in the backyard and the big yard and about i don't know 10 rooms and i would
00:53:57 divide the team into rooms this was the insulin room um this was the room for search and seizure
00:54:04 This was the case where they found the case.
00:54:09 So everybody was divided into a team.
00:54:11 And I was kind of the general.
00:54:14 And I would go from room to room asking them about their progress.
00:54:18 But the principle Dershowitz says pulled him in was bigger than one wealthy man's freedom.
00:54:23 In his telling years ago, it was about how this case had been built in the first place.
00:54:28 Here's Alan talking with journalist Bill Curtis in 1997.
00:54:31 They had paid for private prosecutors and private investigators and had circumvented the strictures of the Constitution, had done things that private people could do, but that public police and prosecutors could never do, withheld evidence, possibly planted evidence.
00:54:52 And it sounded intriguing to me.
00:54:54 But there is an obvious contradiction.
00:54:57 Dershowitz says a wealthy family had effectively built a private prosecution.
00:55:02 Klaus von Bülow was also wealthy and now buying the best defense money could buy.
00:55:07 Harvard students, expert witnesses, and one of the country's top appellate lawyers.
00:55:12 Dershowitz said years ago, that's not a defense of the system.
00:55:15 It is an indictment of it.
00:55:17 If Klaus von Bülow had been a poor butler charged with putting his wife into two comas, he would be in jail today.
00:55:26 There is no question in my mind that it took a lot of money paid to scientific experts, particularly, to be able to get justice in this case.
00:55:36 This is a terrible commentary on the American system of justice.
00:55:40 You knew early on that this case could turn on the notes of a man named Richard Q.
00:55:47 Right.
00:55:48 Who is Richard Q and why were you so sure that his notes were going to be so important?
00:55:53 Because I knew Dick Q. He was a friend of mine.
00:55:55 I actually supported him when he ran for district attorney against Bob Morgan, who ultimately became a close friend of mine years later.
00:56:01 But at the time, I supported Richard Q.
00:56:04 I liked him and I knew he was a good lawyer.
00:56:06 So I knew he was going to take very, very careful notes of what was said to him by the children and by others.
00:56:14 And I had a strong suspicion that these notes would show that there was no insult.
00:56:22 He didn't want to turn those notes over to you.
00:56:24 So as a lawyer, did your spidey sense go up as soon as he refused?
00:56:28 Oh, of course.
00:56:29 I mean, if there was nothing in the notes, he would have, of course, turned them over.
00:56:33 And once he said, I'm not turning over those notes, they're lawyer-client privilege.
00:56:36 They weren't lawyer-client privilege.
00:56:38 And we were entitled to those notes.
00:56:40 And under the Sixth Amendment, we're entitled to all exculpatory evidence.
00:56:45 And the court so ruled when we got the notes, we said, Eureka, you know, we now have the proof we needed.
00:56:52 And so, you know, it was a combination of using law and using science together.
00:56:59 And, you know, one reason why I was a successful teacher is because I brought the courtroom into the classroom.
00:57:06 And one reason I was a successful litigator is I brought the classroom into the courtroom.
00:57:11 And the von Bülow case was a perfect example of both.
00:57:15 I taught the case in class.
00:57:17 I got student input from brilliant, brilliant Harvard students who gave me advice about how to handle it and do things.
00:57:24 And I take the advice of students and we were able to use the classroom and bring it into the courtroom.
00:57:30 But Q had told you that there wasn't a scrap of paper in his possession that was exculpatory, so he didn't have to turn these notes over.
00:57:38 Then finally, he was ordered to turn them over to you.
00:57:42 And did your jaw drop when you read them explain what was so explosive about what was in those notes?
00:57:48 Well, the notes proved that there was no insulin and that there never was insulin.
00:57:52 How?
00:57:53 They had descriptions of what was found every time the maid looked into the little case.
00:58:01 And there was no mention of anything even resembling insulin.
00:58:04 Now, you know, I can't really blame Dick Q.
00:58:07 I think he honestly believed, because he believed that Bob Buehler was guilty, he honestly believed that it wasn't exculpatory.
00:58:14 But to a defense attorney, which I am, and by the way, Dick Q was at that point in his life, too.
00:58:20 He had been a prosecutor.
00:58:22 He would realize that even if you don't think it's exculpatory, you can use it in a way that raises doubts.
00:58:28 Remember, criminal defense lawyers don't have to prove anybody's innocence.
00:58:32 All they have to do is raise a reasonable doubt.
00:58:35 So in other words, if the children had genuinely believed that they found insulin in this bag and that it was used by Klaus to inject Sunny, causing her coma, one would think they would have mentioned that in their sit down with Q.
00:58:48 But that's not what happened.
00:58:49 Of course, that's exactly what we discovered. And the Court of Appeals agreed with us.
00:58:55 The Supreme Court of Rhode Island agreed with us and said, you know, turn over the material.
00:58:58 I don't know whether at the time they told them to turn over the material.
00:59:02 They knew how explosive the material was.
00:59:05 But as soon as we saw it, we realized that this was, you know, our ticket.
00:59:10 This was his get out of jail free card.
00:59:12 Q has always said that proves nothing.
00:59:15 Here he is.
00:59:16 What things I put in my notes of the original interview really have nothing to do with it.
00:59:22 If Alex and Ella had told me, as I'm sure they did, when preliminarily I interviewed them that this insulin was found,
00:59:31 the fact that in my notes of the first interview with Marianne, there were several, I didn't put down.
00:59:37 Maria says she saw insulin. No need to put it down. I'd already heard that.
00:59:43 Alan has said that looking at the state's evidence, the blood, the needle, the bag, he too would have voted to convict.
00:59:50 So we asked him to explain how he got from there to ultimately believing Klaus may have been innocent.
00:59:56 He started with the needle, whose tip the prosecution said was encrusted with insulin.
01:00:02 They had a needle, which they said had insulin on it.
01:00:07 And we were able to show that if that needle had been injected into a human body,
01:00:13 the body would act as a swab and the insulin would not be encrusted on the bottom,
01:00:18 but it would be encrusted near the top.
01:00:20 And we were able to prove that the insulin was at the very bottom,
01:00:24 showing that that needle had never been injected into any human being,
01:00:28 but that it had been dipped into insulin in order to create the impression
01:00:32 that this was an insulin-coated needle that Klaus von Bülow had injected his wife with.
01:00:36 The jury was very impressed with that demonstration.
01:00:40 Alan, what was the 216 insulin reading?
01:00:43 Do you remember that?
01:00:44 It sent a man to prison.
01:00:45 what was actually wrong with that number, 216 insulin?
01:00:48 Well, there were three readings
01:00:49 and they suppressed the most exculpatory reading
01:00:53 and just allowed the two readings,
01:00:56 both of which were consistent with guilt.
01:00:58 Once we were able to get at all the readings,
01:01:01 we were able to show that they were inconsistent readings.
01:01:04 Again, that doesn't prove his innocence.
01:01:06 That just raises a reasonable doubt.
01:01:08 And that's what we have to...
01:01:09 Of what the level of insulin was inside of Sonny von Buhler.
01:01:12 That's right.
01:01:13 And remember, everybody has some level of almost every chemical, so it's always a matter of how much and a matter of degree.
01:01:21 Dershowitz's team did not stop there.
01:01:24 They tested the laboratory itself, sending in needles containing different substances to see whether the lab could reliably identify insulin.
01:01:33 What we did is we sent them several needles.
01:01:37 One had insulin, one had saline solution, one had barbiturates, one had combinations.
01:01:44 And we wanted to see what the test results would be.
01:01:47 And they came back.
01:01:49 And many of them came back saying insulin when there was no insulin.
01:01:53 So there were false positives.
01:01:55 There was a second story about Sonny herself, the first jury, never really heard.
01:02:00 Not Sonny the victim, but Sonny the patient.
01:02:03 In the film that was based on Dershowitz's book, Reversal of Fortune, that other Sonny narrates the whole case from inside her coma.
01:02:12 On December 27th, 1979, I lay in bed all day.
01:02:19 Whether I was asleep or in a coma, later became a subject of dispute.
01:02:26 Do you believe that she injected herself with insulin or that there was no insulin in Sonny at all?
01:02:31 There was no insulin. But I have to tell you, Truman Capote told me that he gave her insulin and told her how to inject it as a kind of weight loss or something.
01:02:43 I don't know. But I never knew whether to believe Truman Capote. He invited me to his home.
01:02:49 He showed me a book he had given her. And he told me that he taught her how to self-inject.
01:02:55 We know she injected herself with B12 vitamins,
01:03:00 but he told me that she also injected herself with insulin.
01:03:03 But we had no proof of that.
01:03:04 We never found any evidence that there was ever any insulin
01:03:08 beyond the normal that's found in her body.
01:03:12 So what was the defense's theory about what actually put Sunny into a coma?
01:03:16 We asked the professor.
01:03:18 She was told she had reactive hypoglycemia
01:03:23 and she shouldn't be drinking sweet drinks and on Christmas Eve she was having one after the other
01:03:30 of these very very sweet Christmas drinks and we were convinced that she put herself into a coma.
01:03:37 Remember this was her second coma. She had one a year earlier and then they found her even though
01:03:42 she had been in a coma and told that she shouldn't smoke and she had oxygen around her they found her
01:03:48 smoking cigarettes right near the oxygen. She was self-destructed. She was an extraordinarily
01:03:54 unhappy woman. And I don't blame her. If I were married to Klaus von Bülow, I'd be a very unhappy
01:03:59 woman, too. He was a runaround and he had mistresses and weird tastes. But she was very, 0.98
01:04:08 very unhappy. He obviously married her for money, not for love. Not the first time that's ever
01:04:13 happened, but he was not a good husband. And she was very depressed and very, perhaps even
01:04:19 suicidal. We're not sure about that. Again, we don't have to prove anything. It's the government
01:04:25 that has the burden of proving everything. There was also a very public front to this case.
01:04:30 The trial was televised, and a reversal in a courtroom might not be enough to change the
01:04:35 public's mind. Waging that media war was a glamorous, relentless, Hungarian-born force of 1.00
01:04:41 nature named Andrea Reynolds. Reynolds worked the press like a switchboard. She phoned reporters who 0.96
01:04:48 covered the trial in a way she didn't like, and when that failed, she went over their heads to
01:04:53 their editors. While Dershowitz was in a library dismantling the evidence, Andrea Reynolds ran a
01:04:59 whole other campaign out in the open. Not a lawyer, but a fixer and a general. Access, energy, total 1.00
01:05:06 belief a woman who refused to let a guilty verdict be the last word. Allen has accused the children
01:05:13 of a, quote, benevolent frame up. We asked him to explain. Absolutely believe that Klaus Rambula
01:05:20 was guilty, but that he was too smart to be convicted. So they tampered with the evidence
01:05:24 and they allowed evidence to be submitted to the jury, which was not authentic. And we were able
01:05:34 to disprove that scientifically. There is a catch, he concedes. You can frame
01:05:41 a guilty man. A frame up would not mean Klaus von Bülow was innocent, which is why the blunt
01:05:47 question still has to be asked. But sitting here today, thinking back to your comment at the top
01:05:54 of the interview, you don't believe that Klaus von Bülow committed this crime. I don't. Is it
01:06:00 possible? It is. I don't believe it. The evidence points away from it. The evidence points very
01:06:06 strongly to a self-inflicted coma. That's the balance of evidence. So even if this were a civil
01:06:13 case, not a criminal case, I would say that you couldn't prove even civil liability by a
01:06:19 preponderance of the evidence. The preponderance favors innocence. That doesn't mean he's innocent.
01:06:24 that means the evidence isn't there to convict.
01:06:28 I don't know whether he's guilty,
01:06:30 and that's true of many of my clients.
01:06:33 When all was said and done,
01:06:35 there's a scene where you pull Klaus aside
01:06:38 after you've gotten his convictions overturned,
01:06:42 and you say...
01:06:43 One thing, Klaus.
01:06:45 Legally, this was an important victory.
01:06:47 Morally, you're on your own.
01:06:50 Did that happen?
01:06:51 And if so, why did you say that to him?
01:06:53 I did.
01:06:53 And because he wanted me to go on television and proclaim my absolute certainty in his innocence, and I couldn't do that.
01:07:03 I mean, there were many, many possible theories.
01:07:05 One possible theory that a lot of people who knew them told me, it's just a possible theory, is that she went into a coma.
01:07:14 He saw her, and he could easily have called the ambulance, and he didn't, because he was perfectly happy to have her die.
01:07:21 Now, that would be morally horrible, but legally not culpable.
01:07:27 Now, I didn't know what happened.
01:07:29 I almost never know what happens with my clients, because the first thing you know as a criminal defense lawyer is they all lie to you all the time.
01:07:36 You know, my first meeting with most of my defendants, the first meeting they say, oh, I didn't do anything.
01:07:42 I'm perfectly innocent and I should win the Nobel Prize.
01:07:46 Second meeting, they take the Nobel Prize off the table.
01:07:49 I didn't do anything.
01:07:50 Third meeting, well, I did a lot of bad things, but I didn't do this. The fourth meeting is I did this, but they can't prove it. So, you know, you have to know when you're dealing with these people and when you're a criminal defense lawyer, you're dealing 90 percent with guilty people. That's why the conviction rate is so high.
01:08:08 You know, I've been very, very lucky. I've won like 30 of my 32 or three homicide homicide related cases. But most of these cases result in in convictions and in many of the cases in justifiable convictions.
01:08:23 But the criminal defense lawyer has to do everything in their power,
01:08:27 ethically and morally, to bring about a reversal or an acquittal
01:08:32 of the best possible deal you can.
01:08:34 And a lot of people don't understand that.
01:08:36 And they think my job is to be his rabbi, his priest, his minister, his mother.
01:08:40 No, I'm his defense lawyer. That's all I do.
01:08:44 But the family has never wavered on their belief about Klaus's guilt.
01:08:49 Here is Sonny's son from her first marriage, Alexander.
01:08:52 Klaus von Bülow only succeeded in depriving our mother of meaningful life, and now he's gotten away with it. 0.58
01:08:59 In 1983, Dershowitz stood in front of the Rhode Island Supreme Court in the first appellate argument that state ever put on live television and asked five justices to do the most unpopular thing they could, erase a conviction the public strongly supported.
01:09:17 We argued it in front of the Supreme Court of Rhode Island, which was a very tough court.
01:09:25 And people told me that we would never win in front of that court.
01:09:29 Years after the trial, Dershowitz says he and his team realized the legal violation alone would not be enough to get a reversal.
01:09:37 We had to persuade them there had really been a miscarriage of justice, not merely a violation of the Constitution.
01:09:43 In April of 1984, the court gave its answer. Both counts reversed. On two grounds. First,
01:09:52 those Q notes. The family's lawyer could not hand pieces of his file to the state police
01:09:58 and attorney general and then hide the rest from Klaus's defense team behind assertions of
01:10:04 privilege. And second, the black bag. At the end of our previous episode, Sonny's son, Alexander,
01:10:11 Q, and a locksmith go to Clarendon Court. The locksmith opens Klaus's locked closet,
01:10:19 and inside is Klaus's black bag. They simply take it. The contents of that bag are then tested
01:10:25 by the von Oersberg's family doctor, and he finds insulin. The bag and its contents are then given
01:10:32 by the family to the Rhode Island State Police. The state police send all the bag's contents to
01:10:38 a lab for testing without getting a warrant. That gave the defense an opening. Dershowitz
01:10:45 had built the whole appeal on state law, Rhode Island's own constitution, which put the reversal
01:10:51 beyond the reach of the U.S. Supreme Court. The only question left was whether prosecutors would
01:10:58 seek a retrial. Because a reversal is not an acquittal. It doesn't send you home for good.
01:11:04 It sends you back to the starting line.
01:11:07 Klaus von Bülow was not a free man in the spring of 1984.
01:11:11 He was an unconvicted one.
01:11:14 And the state of Rhode Island still believed he was a would-be murderer and still intended to try him again.
01:11:21 Dershowitz says the greatest compliment he's received about this case actually came from the movie Reversal of Fortune, on which his own son was a producer.
01:11:29 What I loved about the movie, which my son helped to produce, was when we went to see it a few times in the theater, people would walk out arguing with each other as to whether he did it or not.
01:11:41 And that was the brilliance of the movie, I thought, that it didn't give you an absolute final resolution.
01:11:48 It lets you decide what you think.
01:11:51 So the case that ended restarts.
01:11:55 The trial moves from Newport to Providence.
01:11:58 Bambulo's defense changes hands.
01:12:00 And a reversal, remember, is not the same as proving a man innocent.
01:12:05 That distinction runs through this whole story.
01:12:09 This time, though, the Dream Team will not just play defense.
01:12:13 This time, they will try to prove there was never a crime at all.
01:12:17 That's next time on MK Confidential.
01:12:19 it is the spring of 1985 in a hospital bed in new york a woman named sunny von bulow has been
01:12:33 unconscious for more than four years and she is never going to wake up 90 miles away in rhode
01:12:41 island the man a jury once said put her in that coma is preparing to stand trial for a second time
01:12:47 Sonny's children speak as she cannot.
01:12:51 She's serving a life sentence.
01:12:53 She'll never open her eyes again or recognize anybody.
01:12:57 She'll never talk to her children.
01:12:58 She'll never see her grandchildren.
01:13:00 Three years ago, a Rhode Island jury found Klaus von Bülow guilty of trying to murder his wife.
01:13:07 A year ago, a higher court threw out that verdict.
01:13:11 Klaus, now free on bail, his first conviction erased,
01:13:15 wants one thing and says so to anyone with a camera.
01:13:19 Here he talks to Kiro Eyewitness News.
01:13:22 I admit to great fatigue and suffering during the last three years
01:13:27 and there are moments when I just wish it would go away.
01:13:30 So there's a dichotomy, but I want to get exonerated.
01:13:36 Exonerated is the word he keeps using.
01:13:38 not released on a technicality but rather cleared by a jury out loud. Now Klaus is back where he
01:13:46 started facing the same two counts of attempted murder but with a new direction for the defense
01:13:52 courtesy of the Dershowitz team in a new courthouse in Providence with a jury that has never heard the
01:13:59 case. If this jury convicts the appeal that freed him will have bought him nothing and he will likely
01:14:05 spend the rest of his life in prison. This time, the defense will not just argue that the state
01:14:11 cannot prove its case, but that there was never any crime at all. I'm Megan Kelly, and this is MK
01:14:20 Confidential. For the retrial, Klaus von Bülow has a new lead lawyer, and he is nothing like the
01:14:29 elegant defendant he represents. His name is Thomas Puccio. He made his reputation as a
01:14:35 federal prosecutor who ran the FBI sting operation Abscam, in which agents posed as wealthy Arab
01:14:41 businessmen to expose political corruption and put multiple congressmen in prison. He is not
01:14:48 a society lawyer. He is blunt and combative, a street fighter. Puccio takes over the courtroom
01:14:55 and Alan Dershowitz, who won the appeal, moves into the background. Puccio's plan is the opposite
01:15:02 of the first trial, the one that had been about money, a mistress, and an oceanfront mansion.
01:15:10 Puccio strips all of it away and tries the case as a single question of medicine. What actually
01:15:17 put Sonny von Bülow into a coma? And as before, Klaus von Bülow will not take the stand.
01:15:25 But moving into the background is not the same as stepping away.
01:15:30 Years later, Dershowitz would describe just how much of the second trial ran on the work he and his students had already done.
01:15:38 The whole retrial was based on our work.
01:15:42 In fact, my two main research assistants from the law school, Joanne Crispy and a guy from the medical school,
01:15:50 they sat with the trial lawyer and fed him all the information.
01:15:54 So I was very centrally involved in the trial.
01:15:58 I spoke to the legal team every single day.
01:16:01 And out of the courtroom, another figure is fighting for Klaus von Bülow and fighting the loudest.
01:16:08 Her name is Andrea Reynolds.
01:16:10 She's Hungarian-born and glamorous and still married to her television producer husband.
01:16:17 Andrea has known Klaus and Sonny socially for years,
01:16:19 but she and Klaus did not become lovers until after his first trial had ended.
01:16:24 That timing matters. The mistress the state built its motive around at the first trial was a different woman, the actress Alexandra Isles. Reynolds entered the story only afterward, so the companion the cameras now catch at Klaus's side was never part of the love and money case Rhode Island prosecutors once put to a jury.
01:16:46 Andrea Reynolds does not do subtle. 1.00
01:16:49 She courts the reporters covering the case, dines with them, drives them around and calls their editors when the coverage displeases her. 1.00
01:16:57 Barred from the courtroom, she watches the live feed from inside the CNN truck and slowly takes over the booth until the network finally asks her to leave.
01:17:07 It is Reynolds who decides Klaus needs a warmer face for the retrial.
01:17:12 That the cold, aristocratic figure the first jury saw was half the reason they convicted him.
01:17:18 She runs the campaign to clear his name like a military operation.
01:17:23 Andrea's own husband, watching all of it from the outside, offers the driest verdict of the whole affair.
01:17:30 If Klaus has to marry Andrea, he will wish he had been convicted.
01:17:34 On April 7th, Bombulo, his daughter Cosima, and his girlfriend Andrea Reynolds arrived at the Biltmore Hotel.
01:17:42 The next day, when Bombulo showed up at the courthouse for the first day of jury selection,
01:17:47 a small army of print and broadcast journalists from around the world surrounded him as he made his way into the building.
01:17:54 It takes nine days just to seat a jury, eight women and four men.
01:17:58 and Judge Corinne Grand orders them sequestered, kept together in a hotel, cut off from the outside
01:18:05 for the length of the trial. Before a word of testimony, they are loaded onto a bus and driven
01:18:11 to Newport, Rhode Island, to walk through Clarendon Court itself, the oceanfront mansion
01:18:17 where both comas happened. The press follows, filming the entire thing, rising above the
01:18:23 grounds in bucket trucks while helicopters circle overhead. And Klaus, who has not set foot in the
01:18:31 house in more than four years, steps onto the grounds, sees the dogs he used to walk, and for
01:18:37 a moment his composure breaks. He weeps briefly, then he collects himself and goes inside with the
01:18:46 jury. To see what Puccio is up against, remember what convinced the first jury. The state's medical
01:18:53 case rested on a simple, powerful chain. When Sunny was admitted for her comas, her blood sugar
01:19:00 was dangerously low. And after her final coma, the lab reported an enormous amount of insulin in her
01:19:08 blood. Low sugar, high insulin, which the state said could only mean insulin from outside her body.
01:19:16 from a needle. To get there in the first trial, the prosecution had called Dr. George Cahill of
01:19:22 Harvard, the man other doctors called the experts expert on blood sugar. Cahill told the jury that
01:19:29 only injected insulin could explain what the lab found. Doctor, do you have an opinion based upon
01:19:36 your review of the records and based upon your experience in your training and based upon a
01:19:40 reasonable degree of medical certainty as to whether or not the insulin was endogenous or
01:19:46 exogenous. Like all the data that I've looked at, it would be exogenous. And when the defense
01:19:52 suggested Sonny's barbiturates and drinking might have caused a coma on their own, Cahill did not
01:19:58 give an inch. Asked whether barbiturates can cause a coma, he answered they certainly can,
01:20:04 but not with a blood sugar of 29, sir. It was clean. It was confident. And the first time
01:20:11 around, it helped produce a sentence of 30 years in prison for Klaus von Bülow. Puccio's team goes
01:20:19 after that chain, one link at a time, starting with the image everyone carried out of the first
01:20:24 trial, the small black bag from von Bülow's closet and the used needle inside. It looked
01:20:32 like a murder weapon. But one of the young lawyers Dershowitz recruited, a Harvard law graduate
01:20:38 named Joanne Crispy, says the bag was never really the heart of the case. Here she is with
01:20:44 journalist Bill Curtis on American Justice. Well, a lot of people, you know, outside the case think
01:20:52 of the encrusted needles in the black bag or the black bag itself as the smoking gun. The black bag
01:20:59 was not the smoking gun in this case.
01:21:01 The smoking gun in this case
01:21:02 was the 216 insulin level
01:21:05 in Sonny von Buehler's blood.
01:21:09 216.
01:21:10 That's the number
01:21:11 on which this entire case rests.
01:21:14 An insulin reading so high,
01:21:16 the state's doctors said
01:21:18 it could only mean insulin
01:21:19 from outside her body,
01:21:21 from a needle.
01:21:23 Hold on to that 216 number, though,
01:21:26 because the defense will.
01:21:28 When Dershowitz,
01:21:29 Crispy and the team pull the laboratory's own records, they find something the first jury
01:21:34 never heard. The lab had run that same blood sample for insulin more than once and had gotten
01:21:40 wildly different answers. One reading came back at 216. Another came back at zero. A third at 350.
01:21:50 One sample tested again and again three vastly different results. To the defense, a number that
01:21:57 cannot be reproduced is not evidence of anything and should never have gone to a jury as the truth.
01:22:04 Then there is the needle itself, its tip encrusted with insulin. The prosecution in trial one said
01:22:12 that residue tied the weapon to the crime. The defense now says the residue tells the opposite
01:22:18 story. Dershowitz would later illustrate the argument on television with a glass of soda.
01:22:24 We did it with a turkey skewer and a glass of milk, but you can do it with anything.
01:22:30 If you stick something in a liquid, like my finger in this glass of soda,
01:22:35 and you just let it dry, you see the liquid goes to the very tip and is encrusted in that way.
01:22:44 And that's the way the insulin was found on the needle in this case.
01:22:48 If, on the other hand, what you were to do was to take a needle and inject it,
01:22:53 the liquid would spread all throughout. A needle pushed through skin wipes clean as it goes in,
01:23:00 the defense argues. A needle dipped in insulin and left dry collects it at the very tip. To the
01:23:08 defense, the incrustation is not proof the needle was used on Sunny. It's a sign the needle was
01:23:15 dipped, staged, to look like a weapon. And the team goes one step further. They put the testing
01:23:22 itself to the test. Labs are just people, and scientists are just people, and people make
01:23:29 mistakes all the time. So we decided, first of all, to test the lab. What we did is we sent them
01:23:35 several needles. One had insulin, one had saline solution, one had barbiturates, one had
01:23:44 combinations, and we wanted to see what the test results would be. And they came back,
01:23:49 And many of them came back saying insulin when there was no insulin.
01:23:54 So there were false positives.
01:23:56 Then the defense calls a witness who had testified for the prosecution the first time around.
01:24:01 Dr. Janice Galitis, the Newport physician who saved Sonny's life during her first coma back in 1979.
01:24:09 This time, Galitis tells the jury that in his own judgment, that first coma was not caused by insulin at all,
01:24:17 but by Sonny's airway closing and her aspirating while unconscious.
01:24:22 And the doctor testifies to something even more damaging,
01:24:26 that before the first trial, he had given the prosecutors that very opinion
01:24:30 and that they told him not to volunteer it on the stand.
01:24:35 If even one of Sonny's two comas was not an insulin injection,
01:24:40 the state's elegant chain begins to come apart.
01:24:44 This second jury also never hears the prosecution's clearest motive.
01:24:49 At the first trial, the state told a story of love and money.
01:24:54 First and foremost, a mistress pressing Klaus to marry her.
01:24:58 More on that in a minute.
01:24:59 Klaus's other alleged motive?
01:25:02 The roughly $14 million, equivalent to about $48 million today.
01:25:07 He stood to inherit under Sonny's will versus what he would get if he divorced her.
01:25:14 This time, Judge Grand bars the family's banker, Morris Gurley, from telling the jury about the money at all.
01:25:20 Her ruling is narrow, and at the time, it is one of the most criticized decisions of the trial.
01:25:27 Grand finds there is no foundation connecting financial gain to the specific acts the state alleges,
01:25:33 that, in her words, there is not a suggestion anywhere that financial gain drove the defendant
01:25:39 to do what the state says he did. To let a jury hear the $14 million anyway, she reasons,
01:25:46 would invite them to convict on a motive rather than on evidence. And because Klaus again does
01:25:52 not testify, the prosecution never gets another opportunity to introduce the inheritance evidence
01:25:59 in rebuttal. The motive that anchored the whole first trial, the idea that Sonny's fortune gave
01:26:06 Klaus a reason to want her dead, is a story this second jury simply never hears. And now the jury
01:26:14 hears about the Q notes. In our last episode, Alan Dershowitz pried loose the interview notes
01:26:21 that the family's own lawyer, the former Manhattan prosecutor Richard Q, had kept from the defense
01:26:27 for years by claiming they were privileged. At this trial, those notes finally come out
01:26:32 in open court. The defense argues that in the earliest interviews taken within days
01:26:38 of Sonny's coma, the insulin that would become the center of this entire case went unmentioned
01:26:45 and that the account changed over time, hardening into the version eventually presented to the
01:26:52 first jury. Q has always answered that omission means nothing, that he simply did not write down
01:26:59 everything he was told. This jury gets to weigh both. To Dershowitz, the notes were the entire
01:27:06 case. The notes proved that there was no insulin and that there never was insulin. And look, I
01:27:13 don't... How? They had descriptions of what was found every time the maid looked into the little
01:27:21 case, and there was no mention of anything even resembling insulin. The prosecution's other pillar
01:27:28 was the mistress, Alexandra Isles, the soap opera actress the state had cast as Von Bulo's reason
01:27:34 to kill in the first trial. She has fled the United States rather than face a second trial,
01:27:41 purportedly to visit her mother in Ireland, telling a former lover of hers that she has
01:27:45 no intention of returning to testify. For most of the second trial, Sonny's children remain
01:27:52 remote figures, staying out of sight. But upon hearing this news, that their stepfather's
01:27:58 former mistress is not coming back to testify, Alexander and Allah step forward in a blaze of
01:28:04 publicity. At a New York news conference, they appeal for Alexandra Isles to return and testify,
01:28:10 and they speak as they have all along
01:28:13 for the mother who cannot speak for herself.
01:28:16 Klaus von Hulow as a defender
01:28:18 is entitled to a fair trial.
01:28:20 But as a victim, so is our mother.
01:28:24 Our mother has been deprived in effect of her life.
01:28:28 Please don't let our mother be deprived of justice.
01:28:31 Alexandra Isles realizes
01:28:33 that her greatest star turn is upon her.
01:28:37 She ends her months of European seclusion
01:28:39 and returns to Rhode Island to take the stand against her former lover.
01:28:44 Even when Alexandra was starring on the TV show Dark Shadows,
01:28:48 she never made such a dramatic entrance.
01:28:52 Demurely yet firmly, she takes the stand at the second trial
01:28:56 and describes a 1980 phone call in which Klaus von Bülow confides in her
01:29:01 that he stood by and watched as his wife slipped deep into a coma.
01:29:06 He watched her, knowing that she was in a bad way all day, and watched her and watched her, and finally, when she was on the point of dying, he said that he couldn't go through with it, and he called and saved her life.
01:29:25 It is testimony that cuts both ways. In the same account, Klaus watches his wife
01:29:32 sink toward death and does nothing, and then at the last moment calls the help that saves Sonny's
01:29:38 life. The prosecution hears a near confession. The defense hears the opposite. A man who could
01:29:45 have a woman who tried to kill herself die and instead rescues her. But Puccio is not satisfied
01:29:54 with turning Alexandra's account into a rescue.
01:29:57 On cross-examination, he turns it back on her.
01:30:01 Well, you're saying that you wrote a letter
01:30:03 saying that you wanted a continue relationship.
01:30:05 Have you ever been in love?
01:30:07 I doubt it, but you do some crazy things.
01:30:11 Iles concedes that even after the first trial,
01:30:13 she had written to Klaus asking to continue the relationship.
01:30:18 That's Puccio's point.
01:30:20 A woman who truly believed this man had tried to murder his wife
01:30:24 would not have kept writing to him, wanting to be with him, asking him back.
01:30:29 After weeks of experts and lab reports and blood chemistry, the lawyers sum up.
01:30:35 Puccio zeroes in on the heart of the prosecution's case, the maid.
01:30:40 He turns the jury back to Maria Schralhammer, Sonny's devoted maid of 23 years
01:30:46 and the state's star witness in both trials.
01:30:51 Puccio argues that if Maria had really seen what she later swore she saw,
01:30:56 she would not have stayed quiet about it.
01:30:59 If, in fact, she saw, as she says she did,
01:31:03 a lot of it said insulin, needles, and syringes,
01:31:06 bells would have gone off.
01:31:09 Bells would have gone off,
01:31:10 and the whole world would have gone at that very moment.
01:31:14 The prosecutor, Mark DeSisto, gives the jury the other picture,
01:31:18 the one the state has believed from the start.
01:31:48 The case goes to the jury, and the waiting begins.
01:31:54 These 12 people have now been sequestered for roughly eight weeks,
01:31:59 kept together in a Providence Holiday Inn,
01:32:01 apart from husbands and wives and children, the entire time.
01:32:06 By now, the trial has disrupted not only their lives,
01:32:09 but the lives of the people waiting for them back at home.
01:32:11 We've been married 36 years, and I don't think we've ever been separated, what, five days.
01:32:16 So it's been a long while.
01:32:18 On June 10th, 1985, after roughly eight weeks of testimony and four days of deliberation,
01:32:25 the jury comes back into courtroom number eight in Providence, Rhode Island, and the clerk reads the two charges.
01:32:33 I see power on the charge of the defendant committed on December 27th, 1979.
01:32:39 The crime of assault and tension in that body of crime, guilty or not guilty?
01:32:43 Not guilty.
01:32:43 I actually count you on the charge of the Federal Committee on December 21st, 19-8,
01:32:52 the crime of assault, extension of it. How do you find it? Guilty or not guilty?
01:32:56 Not guilty.
01:33:01 Not guilty on both counts. Andrea Reynolds, the woman who spent three years fighting to free him,
01:33:08 begins to cry. Klaus von Bülow, convicted three years earlier and sentenced to 30 years in prison,
01:33:17 walks out of the courthouse a free man. That evening, Klaus sits down with Newswatch 10
01:33:22 for his first interview since the acquittal. When he is asked what he thinks actually happened to
01:33:28 his wife, his answer is not triumphant. I don't know. I know that I'm totally convinced by the
01:33:38 medical picture i know i didn't do anything an acquittal is not the same as innocence
01:33:45 a jury has found only that the state did not prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt
01:33:50 it has not found that no one harmed sonny von bulow and it answers none of the questions at
01:33:57 the center of this case dennis roberts the rhode island attorney general who prosecuted the first
01:34:03 trial, makes this distinction. It's important, I think, for our viewers to note that being found
01:34:10 not guilty because there is a reasonable doubt is a long way from being found innocent.
01:34:15 The trial judge, Corinne Grand, will say privately that in her view, it was not even a close case,
01:34:21 that Klaus simply did not try to kill Sonny. Sonny's children see it the other way around.
01:34:28 The day of the verdict, they step up to a bank of microphones.
01:34:32 We are disappointed with the jury's verdict, but we know that this jury was not permitted to hear all of the evidence that was admitted at the first trial.
01:34:39 At the start of the second trial, the jury had toured the darkened halls of Clarendon Court, walking the layout of the alleged crime scenes.
01:34:48 While that jury is out deliberating, Sonny's children, Ala and Alexander, invite journalist Dominic Dunn, who had known Sonny since she was a debutante and has covered the whole affair, to spend the night at Clarendon Court.
01:35:04 He finds Sonny's bedroom kept exactly as it was the night of the second coma.
01:35:09 He finds the twin beds pushed together and made up with Sonny's porto sheets.
01:35:14 An old photograph of Klaus looking almost noble in a silver frame on his side of the bed and in a closet beside her evening gowns, the Christmas presents from 1980, still wrapped, the festive paper gone faded and limp.
01:35:33 One from Sonny's oldest friend, one from her dead mother.
01:35:37 On Klaus's bedside table, there is a handsome box.
01:35:42 Dominic Dunn opens it.
01:35:45 Inside are cartridge shells, and underneath the shells, a used syringe.
01:35:52 Dunn thinks about that box for a long time afterward.
01:35:56 Twelve strangers saw Clarendon Court for an afternoon as evidence.
01:36:01 A reporter sees what it has truly become.
01:36:04 The night of the verdict, Klaus von Bülow can go anywhere he likes.
01:36:09 He's a free man, acquitted of the crime that made him famous.
01:36:14 Ninety miles away, in a room on the 10th floor of a New York hospital,
01:36:19 his wife Sunny lies exactly as she has since that second Christmas in 1980.
01:36:24 Her hair washed and set twice a week, and she will stay that way for the next 23 years,
01:36:31 like a doll, primped and perfectly coiffed, well-looked after, and all but dead,
01:36:40 confined to a life of no mobility nor consciousness. She is the silent center of a case the jury just
01:36:48 decided, without deciding anything about how she, in fact, got there. Next time, Sonny's children
01:36:56 have one more arrow in their quiver, and Klaus von Bülow begins his next life an ocean away.
01:37:05 I'm Megan Kelly, and this is MK Confidential.
01:37:13 June 1985. On the 10th floor of the Harkness Pavilion inside Columbia Presbyterian Medical
01:37:20 Center in New York, a woman lies in a private room she will never leave on her own. She's
01:37:26 not on a respirator. She breathes without help. A tube feeds her through her nose. Private nurses
01:37:33 watch her around the clock, and twice a week someone washes and sets her hair. There are
01:37:38 scented flowers on the table and music playing softly in the room. Her name is Martha Von Bulow.
01:37:46 Everyone who loves her calls her Sunny, and she has not spoken a word since the winter of 1980.
01:37:53 Ninety miles away in Providence, a jury has just told the world that the man accused of putting her in that bed is not guilty.
01:38:02 The Kloss von Bülow trial is finally over, and he is not guilty.
01:38:06 Von Bülow was tried twice in a soap opera setting for the attempted murder of his wealthy wife.
01:38:11 The first jury found him guilty, but he won a new trial, and this time he was cleared.
01:38:15 How do you find guilty or not guilty?
01:38:18 Not guilty.
01:38:18 so ended the second trial of klaus von bulow accused of trying to murder his wife
01:38:25 longer but not as dramatic as the first trial three years ago tonight klaus von bulow can go
01:38:31 anywhere he likes sunny cannot turn her head the murder trials are the part of this story that
01:38:37 ends relatively quickly hers is the part that does not her two children from her first marriage
01:38:45 alexander and ala von hoursberg turn their grief into something that will outlast the case
01:38:51 in 1985 they helped found a national organization for the victims of crime and they name it for
01:38:57 their mother the sunny von bulow national victim advocacy center in time it drops her name but it
01:39:04 grows into one of the largest victims rights groups in america known today as the national
01:39:09 Center for Victims of Crime. That becomes the legacy of Sonny von Bulow. That and the belief
01:39:15 that whatever a Rhode Island jury says, someone put her there, condemned her to unconscious bedrest
01:39:22 for the rest of her life. But Klaus does not walk away scot-free. I'm Megan Kelly,
01:39:30 and this is MK Confidential. Klaus von Bulow's acquittal ends the state's case. It does not end
01:39:38 his stepchildren's. Alexander and Allah cannot put him on trial for the crime again, so they do the 0.97
01:39:44 one thing the law still allows. They sue him in federal court in Manhattan in a civil case. 0.68
01:39:51 The number they seek is enormous, $56 million, and the claim behind it is the one the prosecution
01:39:57 made twice, that he tried to kill their mother for her money. The man who has just cleared his
01:40:03 name in a criminal court, now has to defend it again in a civil one. His appellate lawyer,
01:40:09 Alan Dershowitz, laid out the stakes back in 1986. Yeah, we see each other all the time. We
01:40:15 talk about his ongoing case. He's being sued by his stepchildren for $56 million. The case is
01:40:21 not over. And indeed, the American public still remains undecided. One of the reasons I wrote
01:40:26 this book is Klaus von Bülow not only wanted to be acquitted, he wanted to be vindicated.
01:40:30 In time, the civil case settles, and the settlement reads like a verdict of its own.
01:40:38 Under its reported terms, Klaus gives up every claim to Sonny's fortune, and agrees to divorce
01:40:44 his wife, who will never know she has been divorced. In exchange, the lawsuit against him
01:40:50 is dropped. He keeps his freedom, he gives up the money the state always said was his motive.
01:40:57 One person is caught between the two sides of the family,
01:41:01 Cosima, the only child of Klaus and Sonny,
01:41:04 who stood by her father through both trials, and it cost her.
01:41:09 Sonny's mother, Cosima's grandmother, Annie Laurie Aitken,
01:41:14 cuts Cosima out of her will,
01:41:16 an estate valued between $50 and more than $110 million.
01:41:21 Cosima lost a share worth about $25 million.
01:41:25 The exact figure was never the point.
01:41:28 The rift was about a daughter's loyalty to a man the rest of the family believed had tried to kill her mother.
01:41:35 The estrangement is real, and for years it holds.
01:41:39 Through both trials, Cosima and her half-sister, Ala, are not on speaking terms.
01:41:43 On the last day of the second trial, Dominic Dunn watches the two of them pass in a courthouse corridor,
01:41:50 the first time the two women have laid eyes on each other in three years and neither one says
01:41:56 a word later Allah tells him she's gotten so beautiful my mother would be very proud of her
01:42:03 the affection is still there the rupture is over money and loyalty and a father the rest of the
01:42:11 family cannot forgive what finally closes the rift is not a scene of forgiveness it's a legal
01:42:18 document. In December 1987, the same settlement that ends the $56 million lawsuit against Klaus
01:42:25 reinstates Cosima's inheritance. The grandmother who had cut Cosima out was dead and her will
01:42:33 stood. Ala and Alexander say they have no quarrel with Cosima at this point, and they agreed to
01:42:40 restore her to the one-third share their grandmother had first intended all three of them
01:42:45 to have. The thing that had split the three of them, Klaus's treatment of Sonny and her money,
01:42:51 is no longer a concern. The deeper reconciliation comes the way everything in this family finally
01:42:58 does, through Sonny. Whatever the three of them feel about Klaus, they are bound to the silent
01:43:04 woman in the hospital bed. And over the years, all three keep coming back to her room. When she dies
01:43:11 in 2008 after 28 years in that bed. Her children come together to bury her. Cosima would also spend
01:43:20 years caring for her own father, financing and following him when he moves out of the country.
01:43:26 She stays close to Klaus for the rest of his life. So what becomes of Klaus von Bülow? Free
01:43:33 and stripped of the fortune that made him who he wanted to be, he does not retreat. He gives
01:43:41 interviews, he goes to parties. He lets the notoriety settle over him and carries it almost
01:43:47 with relish. The image that fixes him in the public mind comes from the trial itself.
01:43:54 All through the second trial, while a jury is weighing whether or not he tried to murder his
01:43:59 wife, Klaus spends his weekends back in New York. There, his lover and public relations strategist,
01:44:06 Andrea Reynolds, has moved into Sonny's own 14-room apartment on Fifth Avenue.
01:44:12 There, in rooms still full of Sonny's things, the couple entertains. Dominic Dunn, who travels in
01:44:19 the same circles, sees what goes on inside. He described it in an interview with the Television
01:44:24 Academy Foundation. She had moved into Sonny Vambula's apartment on Fifth Avenue, one of the
01:44:31 most beautiful apartments and they gave a lunch party this is during a murder trial
01:44:38 with butlers with white gloves and and all this kind of stuff well i mean that's right up my alley
01:44:45 i have to tell you i mean and they and helmet newton the great photographer a wonderful man
01:44:54 genius i think and a great friend of mine he photographed klaus and andrea in black leather
01:45:01 I don't know if you remember those famous photographs he had during the trial.
01:45:07 The audacity is the point.
01:45:10 While on trial for trying to murder his wife, Klaus hosts a lunch party in her apartment
01:45:15 with white-gloved butlers serving the guests,
01:45:19 then poses in black leather for one of the world's most famous photographers.
01:45:25 And when the acquittal comes, society does not shut its doors to him.
01:45:30 In fact, it opens them.
01:45:32 Klaus and Andrea make one of their first appearances at a party given by Lady Jean Campbell,
01:45:38 a Duke's daughter and a former wife of Norman Mailer.
01:45:41 They take a box at the Metropolitan Opera on Monday nights,
01:45:45 the house's old society night, where white tie is still the custom,
01:45:50 and the same families fill the same boxes they always have.
01:45:54 Klaus and Andrea turn up at Mortimer's,
01:45:56 the restaurant where Manhattan goes to be seen. Not everyone will have him. At one dinner,
01:46:03 a magazine editor says she will walk out if she is seated at his table. But most of the
01:46:08 charmed circle takes him back. Dominic Dunn would write that Vambulo's dark and spacious
01:46:14 place in social history has been assured. It is Reynolds who has stage managed this whole
01:46:22 comeback. She's the one who decided that the cold, aristocratic figure the first jury saw
01:46:27 needed softening, and she remade his public image for the retrial. She calls their courtship a ballet
01:46:34 of seduction and says he needs a witness to account for his every move. But the romance
01:46:40 does not last. Within a few years of the verdict, Reynolds and Klaus quietly part ways. She goes on
01:46:47 to marry an English aristocrat, the Honorable Sean Plunkett. Klaus does not stay in New York
01:46:54 to be talked about. Dominic Dunn watches Klaus return to society and remains convinced the jury
01:46:59 got it wrong. Here he is again with the Television Academy Foundation. In your opinion, guilty? Oh,
01:47:06 yes, I felt so. And he hates me a lot the way I wrote about him. So Klaus moves to London,
01:47:14 the city where he first made his name, and settles back into its dinner parties and its
01:47:20 opera boxes, as though the last five years had been a long, unpleasant weekend. He takes a job
01:47:26 reviewing plays for a Catholic newspaper. He never again mounts a public campaign to prove his
01:47:32 innocence, and by all appearances, he never needs to. He has his verdict, and he is received in the
01:47:39 drawing rooms of London again, if not on the scale Sonny's money once paid for. He lives out
01:47:44 his years quietly and comfortably on Cosima's support. He follows the advice of his lawyer,
01:47:50 Alan Dershowitz, the same advice Alan's given every client who wins a case the public
01:47:55 desperately wants them to lose. Alan told me this when we spoke.
01:48:00 I gave him advice, the same advice I gave O.J. Simpson when we won both cases. I said,
01:48:06 disappear. Nobody wants to see your face. They hate your guts. Go away. And Klaus took my advice,
01:48:14 went to England, stayed out of the public light. Through it all, Klaus's reinvention and interviews
01:48:21 and parties, Sonny von Bulow does not change at all other than to age. While Klaus dines out first
01:48:29 in New York and then in London, his wife lies in the same hospital bed. And the argument over what
01:48:35 she was and what was done to her carries on above her head and she cannot say a word. Her care costs
01:48:43 a fortune, more than half a million dollars a year. Dr. Richard Stock, who has been her physician
01:48:50 for nearly 30 years, comes to see her several times a week. Her room is kept as for a wife
01:48:57 being welcomed home. Her own nightgowns, her own skin creams, music in the air, and her children
01:49:03 keep watch. Alexander and Allah visit their mother often. When Allah's own daughter is small,
01:49:10 she brings the little girl named Sunny for her grandmother into the room so that Sunny might 0.55
01:49:16 somehow know she has a granddaughter. They talk to her. They touch her. They tell her about their
01:49:22 lives. The years pass, far more of them than anyone imagined. In 1998, at age 67, Sunny is
01:49:32 moved to a Manhattan nursing home, her hair still set, her nightgowns still her own, fresh flowers
01:49:39 still by the bed. And on December 6, 2008, Sunny dies there without ever having woken up. She is
01:49:47 76. Her children release a short statement calling her a woman of grace and dignity and the most
01:49:54 loving mother imaginable. A woman lost 28 years of her life. Whoever decided to hurt Sunny von
01:50:02 Bulo that day in 1980, this can't possibly have been the desired outcome. As for the public
01:50:09 relations around her case, long before Sonny died, the case had already split into competing stories.
01:50:16 Alan Dershowitz wrote the defense account in a book called Reversal of Fortune. Reporters like
01:50:23 Dominic Dunn wrote the skeptical ones, among them Dunn's own fatal charm. And then came the version
01:50:30 most people would remember a hollywood movie the film also called reversal of fortune arrives in
01:50:37 1990 it does the one thing neither trial could it gives sonny a voice the filmmakers let her
01:50:45 narrate the story from inside the coma that silenced her this was my body on december 27
01:50:54 7th, 1979, I lay in bed all day. Whether I was asleep or in a coma, later became a subject of
01:51:05 dispute. Jeremy Irons plays Klaus and wins the Academy Award for it. He almost turned down the
01:51:13 part. He explained why to the Hudson Union Society in 2009. When the movie Reversal Fortune was
01:51:21 offered to me, I thought it was a very tasteless idea, because most of the family was still alive
01:51:26 and had been through a very difficult, awful time. And I thought to have a film made about that
01:51:34 is sort of a nightmare. So I passed on it a few times. And then my friend Glenn Close persuaded
01:51:41 me, she said quite rightly, if I didn't do it, someone else would.
01:51:44 Irons would go on to win the Oscar for Best Actor in a leading role in 1991.
01:51:49 This is great. Thank you, my co-stars, Ron Silver and Glenn, for finally persuading me to do it.
01:52:03 And lastly, if I may cut the call of a telephone to London, where my wife is trying to keep awake in a hotel bedroom,
01:52:14 I wish you were here to help me carry this, because you helped me win it. Thank you all.
01:52:19 The movie becomes the definitive version of the Von Bulow case.
01:52:24 It makes Sonny famous all over again and dramatizes the doubt at the heart of everything,
01:52:30 conveniently avoiding some of the more troubling facts for Klaus,
01:52:34 like his quick return to the Newport home three days after Detective Reese asks him about insulin.
01:52:40 What the movie fails to do is settle the doubt.
01:52:44 No film could possibly answer what two juries could not.
01:52:49 Those two juries did not judge the same case.
01:52:52 The first heard the state's motive, the mistress, and the $14 million Klaus stood to inherit.
01:52:58 The second jury heard none of that.
01:53:01 The judge in the second trial barred testimony from the family banker about the will,
01:53:06 citing a lack of foundation.
01:53:08 She said there was insufficient evidence that Klaus's potential financial gain
01:53:12 quote, impelled him to allegedly harm Sonny.
01:53:16 The move was widely criticized at the time.
01:53:19 The second jury did hear a medical defense the first jury never did, that the science behind
01:53:25 the insulin reading was not reliable, that one of Sonny's comas may not have involved insulin at
01:53:31 all, and that the needle with insulin found in the infamous black bag looked like it had been
01:53:38 dipped in insulin, not used to inject an actual person. One jury convicted Klaus von Bülow,
01:53:45 a higher court, threw out that conviction. A second jury acquitted him, and that verdict
01:53:51 was final. Two juries, two opposite conclusions, and in the end, only the acquittal stood.
01:54:00 Both were asked the same question. Did Klaus von Bülow try to kill his wife?
01:54:05 Beneath that question, a harder one. Was either coma caused intentionally at all?
01:54:12 Alan Dershowitz has never claimed to know the answer.
01:54:15 The evidence points very strongly to a self-inflicted coma.
01:54:21 That's the balance of evidence.
01:54:22 Even if this were a civil case, not a criminal case,
01:54:25 I would say that you couldn't prove even civil liability by a preponderance of the evidence.
01:54:31 The preponderance favors innocence.
01:54:34 That doesn't mean he's innocent.
01:54:35 That means the evidence isn't there to convict.
01:54:38 I don't know whether he's guilty.
01:54:41 Sonny von Bülow knew.
01:54:43 She was in the room both times.
01:54:46 The one witness who knew everything was unable to tell any of it.
01:54:50 Frozen instead in an unreachable state.
01:54:54 This is all you can know.
01:54:58 All you can be told.
01:55:00 When you get where I am, you will know the rest.
01:55:05 More than a century ago, an American writer published a story called The Lady or the Tiger.
01:55:13 In the tale, a barbaric king decides guilt or innocence through a public spectacle.
01:55:19 An accused person must choose between two identical doors.
01:55:23 Behind one waits a tiger that would kill him.
01:55:26 Behind the other, a woman he must immediately marry.
01:55:29 When the king discovers that his daughter is secretly in love with a young man on the royal court,
01:55:35 He sends the man into the arena to choose between a tiger and a beautiful woman his daughter deeply
01:55:41 resents. The princess learns which door is which. From inside the arena, her lover looks to her for
01:55:49 guidance. She signals toward the door on the right, and he opens it without hesitation.
01:55:55 The story ends without showing what lies beyond that open door. Did the princess save the man
01:56:02 she loved, knowing he would marry another woman, or did jealousy cause her to send him to the 0.89
01:56:08 tiger? The writer never tells us. Was it the lady or the tiger? The reader is left to decide.
01:56:17 The Von Bulow case has its own two doors. Behind one is the defense's version, an unhappy,
01:56:25 self-destructive woman whose medical crises became a murder case through fear, unreliable 0.86
01:56:31 memory and flawed science. Behind the prosecution's door, a husband who twice tried to kill his wife
01:56:38 and whose money built a defense powerful enough to escape a second conviction. The two juries in
01:56:45 this case opened two different doors, but neither could say what actually happened inside Clarendon
01:56:51 Court. The answer stayed forever with Sonny and Klaus, who died in London in 2019. Of course,
01:57:00 we all have our opinions. I have mine. What do you think happened to Sonny Von Bulow?
01:57:07 Send me an email at megan at megankelly.com. We'll be back Monday evening with another case,
01:57:14 this one out of the nation's capital. For MK Confidential, I'm Megan Kelly.