The Michael Knowles Show - August 17, 2026


Ep. 2039 - Horrifying Organ Harvest Story Goes Viral

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
"Do Catholics Worship Mary?" Cardinal Burke Answers REAL Posts | Off The Clock Ep. 2040 - Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial Debate EXPLAINED in 5 Mins

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

185.35

Word count

8,622

Sentence count

620

Harmful content

Misogyny

21

sentences flagged

Toxicity

39

sentences flagged

Hate speech

48

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 This episode is brought to you by Cardiff, America's favorite small business lender,
00:00:03 with over $12 billion funded since 2004, applying under three minutes for same-day funding,
00:00:07 up to $500,000 at cardiff.co slash Knowles, K-N-W-L-E-S. A new poll out of Michigan has
00:00:14 conservatives blaming immigrants and college-educated white women for all of our country's 0.72
00:00:20 problems. And I'm like the girl in the meme. I say, why not both? Why not both? There's enough
00:00:24 blame to go around. But in fairness, one of those groups actually is more responsible than the
00:00:29 other, we will examine the underlying psychological issues. Then some happy statistics. Vice President
00:00:35 J.D. Vance currently leads not just the Republican field, but all the Democrats in the 2028
00:00:42 presidential prediction markets. That's the real key here. We'll see how the right wing primary
00:00:46 shakes out, but we want to make sure that the Republican beats the Democrats. Strangely,
00:00:52 though, some right wing activists are angrier than ever because of it. Finally, turning back
00:00:56 to Unpleasant News, an Australian woman has become the first person to have her organs
00:01:00 harvested after committing suicide. Welcome to the ethics of our brave new world. I'm Michael 0.57
00:01:06 Knowles. This is The Michael Knowles Show.
00:01:26 Welcome back to the show. Luigi Mangione has just pled guilty to one of the charges that he faces
00:01:33 after the killing of the healthcare CEO, Brian Thompson, in cold blood.
00:01:38 Meanwhile, his supporters are still defending him, and his supporters tend to be the aforementioned
00:01:43 liberal white women. Where are the white women at? They are outside of the courtroom defending 0.86
00:01:47 a murderer. We will explain why. First, though, I want to focus on the ladies in the Michigan
00:01:53 Senate primary. This is a really, really worrisome set of numbers that's just come out. 0.98
00:01:58 So how's the race stand right now? You've got the Democrat, Abdul El-Sayed, who is the woke
00:02:04 DSA socialist candidate who alternately plays jihadi and gay. He's trying to appeal to both 0.89
00:02:12 sections of the Democrat Party. You have the lavender section and you have the green flag
00:02:17 crescent moon section. And the good news is, a new poll just came out from Fox News,
00:02:23 among registered voters, the Republican Mike Rogers is leading.
00:02:27 So this is the gamble right now for the Democrats. If they nominate the radical DSA candidates,
00:02:34 who frankly are not really any more radical than the mainstream Democrats, because the whole
00:02:39 Democrat Party has given way to radicalism and has really embraced the Democrat socialists.
00:02:44 But if they nominate the radical candidate, then it should make it easier for the Republicans to
00:02:50 win in the general election. But this is a midterm election with all the headwinds going
00:02:54 against Republicans. So the Democrats are taking this gamble. They're saying, what if we nominate
00:02:58 the radical candidate and already we're likely to win? It's just how the year is set up. So if we
00:03:04 win with the really radical candidates, then we're going to get even more of what we want.
00:03:07 And the way it's playing out right now among registered voters, they're going to lose that
00:03:12 that. Among registered voters, the Republicans are more attractive than the radical Democrats.
00:03:18 Here's the rub. If you change your lens from registered voters to likely voters,
00:03:25 or you dial it up in further to certain to vote, the people who are just dead set on voting for
00:03:32 their guy in November, the Republican loses. In fact, the numbers precisely flip. Right now,
00:03:37 among registered voters, it's 51 for the Republican, 47 for the Democrat. Among certain
00:03:42 to vote, it's 51 for the Democrat, 47 for the Republican. So who is voting for Abdul El-Sayed,
00:03:48 who is a deeply unattractive candidate? Well, if you look among white voters,
00:03:54 Mike Rogers is way, way up. The Republican's up by 14 points, 56 to 42.
00:03:58 If you look among non-white voters, and non-white voters in Michigan largely means immigrants, 0.56
00:04:04 then you've got Abdul El-Sayed way, way, way, way up. The non-white voters vote much more in
00:04:11 lockstep with their racial and ethnic identity than the white voters do. White voters have 0.80
00:04:15 basically no racial identity. This has been borne out in surveys for many years at this point.
00:04:20 Every other race has very high degrees of racial identity. White people have basically none, 0.91
00:04:25 which is why it's so funny that we constantly hear about white supremacy, 0.98
00:04:29 white identitarianism, white nationalism. That doesn't exist. Just statistically in America,
00:04:34 that does not exist. Black nationalism, Hispanic nationalism, Asian nationalism, all of that
00:04:40 exists to much, much higher degrees. So among non-white voters, Abdul El-Sayed's up 42 points,
00:04:45 70 to 28. If you look at men, men, very reasonable, the Republican runs away with it, 55 to 44. 0.64
00:04:54 If you look at women, women are voting for Abdul El-Sayed, but only by a little bit.
00:04:59 He's only up one point among women generally, but don't forget that includes married women,
00:05:03 that includes all the normal women. Then you get to the white women with the college degree. 1.00
00:05:10 Then you get to the awfuls, they call them, the affluent white female liberals. The awfuls 1.00
00:05:16 are giving it to the Democrat Abdul El-Sayed by 23 points, 60 to 37. So who do we blame?
00:05:24 Do we blame the non-white voters, which in Michigan largely means immigrants,
00:05:27 or do we blame the women? Why not both? Why not both? We could blame both of them. 0.88
00:05:32 this explains these poll numbers explain why abdul al-sayed right now is leaning gay you 0.75
00:05:38 remember he posted that that campaign ad this is from his account where it's him singing you know 0.91
00:05:43 oh i want to dance with somebody and it looks like this really gay high school musical well
00:05:47 a lot of people were scratching their heads why is he playing this way he's playing this way because
00:05:51 his chief base is affluent white liberals specifically white liberal women so he's going 0.97
00:05:59 of play up to their sort of flamboyant gay preferences. He needs to win the non-white 1.00
00:06:07 immigrants. He needs to win 80% of Muslims in Dearborn, Michigan. But he'll get those. 0.99
00:06:13 The non-white voters are voting overwhelmingly for him. They're voting as a bloc.
00:06:18 So the chief reason that we have, the most immediate reason as to why we have all of these 0.83
00:06:24 radical, leftist, socialist, overwhelmingly racial identitarian, increasingly Muslim sort of
00:06:31 candidates rising up throughout the country is because of mass migration. That's full stop. 0.94
00:06:36 If we didn't have mass migration, we would have a lot of normal politicians, relatively normal 0.99
00:06:41 politicians. But I assign more blame here to the liberal white women with the college degrees. 1.00
00:06:46 And I assign more blame because when you look at the non-white voters, by which we mean Muslims 0.93
00:06:51 in Michigan. They're just voting in a very rational way. If you import a bunch of people
00:06:55 who don't assimilate, who come from a radically different culture with a different religion and 0.99
00:06:59 a different language and different customs, and you tell them not to assimilate, guess what?
00:07:04 They're going to vote in the way that benefits their faction, their unassimilated faction.
00:07:11 So what they're doing is not destructive for their own political community.
00:07:16 The voters in Dearborn, Michigan don't view themselves as Americans.
00:07:19 The voters in Dearborn, Michigan, don't aspire to throw away their old foreign customs and become 0.98
00:07:26 as American as apple pie, as you saw with a lot of immigrants in the early 20th century when there
00:07:30 was a very, very serious push for assimilation. They're not doing that. They're voting for the
00:07:34 good of their own political communities. They just don't identify with the political community
00:07:36 of the United States. With the white liberal women with the college degrees, their voting 1.00
00:07:41 habits are purely destructive. They are voting for people who want to ruin their country. 1.00
00:07:47 They are voting for people who campaign with Hassan Piker who says that America deserved 9-11.
00:07:52 They're voting for people who say they want to make America weaker.
00:07:55 They're voting for people who want to bring in foreign customs and destroy the customs of the United States. 1.00
00:07:59 The white liberal women with the college degrees are really proving the idiom true that all of leftism just comes down to screw you, dad. 1.00
00:08:08 That's what's going on here. 1.00
00:08:10 By the numbers, the immigrant problem is worse. 1.00
00:08:12 but by the absurdity, by the perversity, by the pure destructiveness of it, 0.96
00:08:18 it is the white women with the college degree. They will bear the responsibility if Abdul 0.99
00:08:26 al-Said wins, and right now it's anyone's race. Turning to the presidential election,
00:08:29 we do have a little bit of good news. Our sponsor, Kalshi, has just come out looking at not just the
00:08:35 Republican field for 2028 or the Democrat field for 2028, but the whole race. And right now,
00:08:40 J.D. Vance leads the whole pack. J.D. Vance has 20% odds on Calci of winning the whole thing
00:08:46 outright, followed by Marco Rubio, who's at 16%, followed by Gavin Newsom at 11%, followed by AOC
00:08:53 at 9.6%. This is really, really good news. One, it's because you've got two Republicans leading
00:09:01 the two top Democrats. So whether it were J.D. Vance or Marco Rubio, that person would win
00:09:07 according to the prediction markets, which are different from polls, but in some ways,
00:09:11 they're more reliable than the polls. And when you look at the candidates overall,
00:09:15 it's Vance. Now, this backs up what we saw. I think it was a Marquette poll that came out
00:09:19 a couple of weeks ago, which showed that J.D. Vance is the most popular figure in the Trump
00:09:24 administration. Trump's approval among Republican voters is about 76%. So it's lower than guys like
00:09:33 J.D. Vance, Marco Rubio, or Pete Hegseth. Now, I think you got to grade Trump here on a curve
00:09:36 because Trump is the chief. He's the guy. The buck stops with him. So he's taking most of the
00:09:41 attacks, most of the slings and arrows coming his way. No surprise that he's been dinged a little
00:09:46 bit among Republican voters. Hegseth doing very well. Rubio doing even better. But J.D. Vance
00:09:52 leading the pack. And this is a little surprising because J.D. has taken a lot of hits, at least in
00:09:56 the political media, at least among the activist set. He's taken way more hits than Marco Rubio
00:10:01 has, for instance. Marco Rubio has had months of just constantly positive press, and yet J.D. Vance
00:10:08 still has a higher approval rating among Republicans than Rubio does. Rubio's very high, too. Rubio's
00:10:13 doing a great job. But what does this tell us? This tells us that there is a big disconnect
00:10:17 between the political media on the right, the activist groups on the right, the lobbyist groups
00:10:21 on the right, and the actual Republican voters. Even after all those hits, people, I think,
00:10:27 very dishonestly trying to pin the Iran war on J.D. Vance. J.D. Vance, who is not the commander
00:10:35 in chief, not the nation's chief diplomat. He's the vice president, who, according to reports,
00:10:41 was rather skeptical of the Iran war from the beginning. I thought it was very dishonest. I
00:10:45 thought it was just people who were trying to attack Trump, but didn't have the guliuns to
00:10:50 attack Trump. So they attacked Trump's wicked advisors, in particular, their least favorite
00:10:54 one, which is J.D. Vance. But there was a huge chasm between that and the actual Republican
00:10:58 voters. What it tells me is that the anti-Vance discourse that you might have seen on social media
00:11:05 that you've seen coming out of the pundit class, the chattering class, and some of the right-wing
00:11:10 publications, that is totally disconnected from actual voter preferences. And it's totally
00:11:16 disconnected from prediction markets. So not just what people are saying their preferences are when
00:11:20 they talk to pollsters, but even where people are putting the money. I saw this a little bit
00:11:25 firsthand over the weekend. It was kind of funny. I responded to a comment of someone criticizing me
00:11:32 because, I don't know, I wasn't attacking J.D. Vance. And I can't help but notice, I think a lot
00:11:38 of the attacks on Vance are astroturfed, and I think a lot of them are foreign. I'll give some 0.98
00:11:43 of my evidence for that in a second. First, though, I want to tell you about Helix. Go to
00:11:46 helixsleep.com slash Knowles. Do you know what I did on Saturday? On Saturday, I go upstairs with
00:11:52 my wife and I open up something that had been sitting in my house for a little bit. It's my
00:11:57 new Helix mattress. Because look, for me, I would have let guests sleep on the floor. But sweet
00:12:03 little Lisa said, we should treat our guests right. We should get them a better mattress.
00:12:06 We should get them a Helix. So I open it up. Even for me, I'm not the biggest, most adonic guy in
00:12:13 the world. Nevertheless, I get the mattress on the bed. You open it up. It's really, really easy.
00:12:17 It comes out, poofs all the way up. Sweet little Lisa and I, we lay down on top, tested it. It is
00:12:22 so magnificent. It's just an incredible mattress brand. And you don't need to get my bed. You can
00:12:29 get the bed that is made for you. You take their quick sleep quiz. You're matched for the perfect
00:12:32 mattress. It's absolutely wonderful. Highly recommend. There is a reason that Helix is the
00:12:37 most awarded mattress brand out there, recognized by experts like Forbes and Wired. They give you
00:12:42 120-night sleep trial, limited lifetime warranty. You're not going to need either of those because
00:12:45 you're going to love it, and you're going to keep buying new Helix mattresses, including for your
00:12:48 guest room. Go to helixsleep.com slash Knowles Canada WLAS. Get 27% off site-wide exclusively
00:12:54 for listeners to this show. Helixsleep.com slash Knowles Canada WLAS. 27% off site-wide exclusively
00:13:00 for listeners of this show. So over the weekend, someone was going after Vance. It was the crazy,
00:13:06 you want to talk about the disconnect between the online discourse and actual voters.
00:13:08 is people going after Vance because they were trying to tie Vance to some academics who appear
00:13:16 at a conference. And the academics read a political philosopher from the 20th century,
00:13:21 this guy, Carl Schmitt. Carl Schmitt, who, while a prominent political philosopher,
00:13:27 was also a Nazi, as were a number of Germans during the mid-20th century.
00:13:31 And so basically what they were trying to say is that Vance is a Nazi. That's what a lot of
00:13:36 the discourse has come down to. And I said, this is totally ridiculous. It's full of non-sequiturs. 0.98
00:13:40 I think this is pretty unfair. Then people were going after Vance for, they said he wanted to
00:13:46 destroy the American hegemony because he raised questions about the global reserve currency
00:13:52 status of the United States. They were calling him some kind of subversive, Catholic, post-liberal.
00:13:59 But then you look, and many of the questions that he was bringing up years ago were also brought up
00:14:03 by Protestant libertarians. So it was all just so in the weeds, and I felt so dishonest. So I
00:14:09 pointed this out, and I get a comment on X from Teacher Julie 08, who was responding, said,
00:14:17 I strongly dislike Michael Knowles more and more each day. Because I was making a comment on a
00:14:25 comment on a political philosopher, on a theological strain, on an academic conference,
00:14:31 on a point about the economy that's somehow vaguely related to Vance's.
00:14:34 I strongly dislike Michael Knowles more and more each day.
00:14:37 And really what this account was upset about
00:14:40 was that I was defending the vice president
00:14:42 against what I thought was a very unfair attack.
00:14:45 So one of the great features that Elon Musk brought to X
00:14:48 is you can tell where the accounts are based.
00:14:50 Let me see where this account is based.
00:14:52 There's no name other than Julie.
00:14:55 There's no face.
00:14:56 There's nothing really identifying this account.
00:14:58 Let me see where that account is based.
00:14:59 So I looked at it.
00:15:01 The account is based in Ghana. In Ghana, accessing Twitter from Ghana. So it's not even like the
00:15:08 account is based in Ghana and accessing it from New York City. It's from Ghana, accessing it from
00:15:14 Ghana. It's either a bot or a foreign operative account. I love my Ghanese audience, my Ghanaian
00:15:20 audience. This show actually does have a pretty big international audience. I love that. I'm all
00:15:25 about that. I love that people are paying attention to the show and the different political and
00:15:29 philosophical, and especially religious currents that we talk about on the show.
00:15:31 But I said, this just doesn't make sense. It is not believable that some ordinary Ghanaian 1.00
00:15:38 citizen is that plugged in with all of the esoteric nuances of the political ideologies
00:15:45 that float atop the intraconservative movement debates that then pertain to the Republican
00:15:50 Party. It's just not believable. This is an op. And of course, all of social media now is
00:15:56 flooded with foreign bots, foreign influence, and activist campaigns here. I mean, look,
00:16:02 if you've ever worked on a political campaign before, I've worked on plenty of them,
00:16:06 you know that this is how political campaigns work. But I found it to be really, really silly. 0.81
00:16:13 And for Republican voters who are trying to ascertain the state of the race, are we really
00:16:17 going to get blown out of the water? Are the Democrats totally going to run away with it in
00:16:19 2028? One, it's a little too early to predict that. But if you want to know the state of the
00:16:24 race, let's look at the polls of actual voters. Let's look at the polls of, let's look at what
00:16:30 the prediction markets are saying. Because I think the vice president is terrific. I'm a big fan of
00:16:35 the vice president. I think Rubio is great too. I think there are even figures who are not in the
00:16:40 Trump administration who could run good campaigns for president. As I've said before, I think there's
00:16:45 a chance that Ron DeSantis could have a lane, depending on how the Iran war works out, depending
00:16:50 on the popularity of the Trump administration, because he's outside of the administration. He
00:16:53 could run in the kind of Trump lane outside of the Trump administration, though that's very
00:16:57 difficult. It didn't work out in 2024. I think Ted Cruz, a lot of people I think are underestimating
00:17:02 Ted Cruz. I think Ted Cruz could have a real lane in 2028. It would again depend on how things work
00:17:08 out with the Trump administration, how tight President Trump's hold is on the Republican
00:17:11 party. I think Rand Paul could have a lane. I don't think a libertarian is going to win, but
00:17:15 he could have a lane to run in that party. I want to make sure that a Republican beats a Democrat.
00:17:21 In other words, I want to focus on the chief threats to my way of life, to American sovereignty.
00:17:28 You've got Democrats running candidates who openly have disdain for the country.
00:17:32 I want to make sure that we keep our eyes on the prize.
00:17:34 But there's a lot of mischief, a lot of silliness going on in the shadow race for 2028. 1.00
00:17:40 A lot of it very silly, and a lot of it coming from overseas. 0.67
00:17:43 So speaking of the vice president, J.D. Vance made a really important point, I think, 0.89
00:17:48 on how we think about socialism.
00:17:49 One of the attacks that you're seeing in the shadow race for 2028 on the GOP side is people are trying to call Vance a socialist, which I think is pretty absurd on its face.
00:18:00 But that's the argument.
00:18:01 They're saying J.D. Vance, he's a socialist.
00:18:04 His economics, his economic policy is no different from what the Democrats are offering.
00:18:09 And Vance addressed this head on on Fox News.
00:18:11 and my warning to my fellow republicans will would be if we don't get this right don't blame
00:18:18 young people for being sympathetic to socialism we've got to blame ourselves and i think what is
00:18:24 so unique and refreshing about donald trump's economic policies is that it's not the same old
00:18:30 economic you know ideas that you would have heard 30 40 years ago he's talking about rebuilding our
00:18:36 industrial base, rebuilding the heartland, making our streets safer, making it possible for young
00:18:42 people to afford to buy a home. This is how you stop socialism. You don't stop socialism by
00:18:48 throwing slogans at people about the free market. As much as I love the free market,
00:18:53 you stop socialism by making people's lives better. And that's what we're trying to do
00:18:57 every single day. I love this point because it's such a political point. People think that J.D.
00:19:02 Vance is making an economic point. He obviously has economic ideas. But what he's being a
00:19:06 attacked for right now, I think is not his economic argument. It's actually his political
00:19:12 argument. What he's saying is we have to stop socialism, but you're not going to stop socialism
00:19:18 by just mindlessly repeating slogans about the free market. You're not going to stop socialism
00:19:24 by regurgitating the same kinds of political tactics that have failed in the past.
00:19:31 What would the opposite of this be? The opposite of speaking to the affordability crisis
00:19:36 would be the sort of thing that we saw during the Tea Party, specifically from Paul Ryan.
00:19:40 I like Paul Ryan. I think Paul Ryan had good intentions. I think he wanted to solve our
00:19:43 fiscal problem. Paul Ryan ran on austerity. The GOP Congress, under his leadership or partial
00:19:51 leadership, ran on austerity. The Mitt Romney campaign ran on austerity and 47% of Americans
00:19:58 being useless leeches and the fact that we need to cut, cut, cut. Ran on reforming entitlements, 0.72
00:20:04 which is to say cutting social security and medicare how did it work out it didn't work
00:20:08 it empowered democrats democrats ran on that forever they persuaded voters they aired
00:20:13 commercials of paul ryan throwing granny off of a cliff and guess what you then had democrat
00:20:19 politicians implementing policies far closer to socialism than anything jd vance is talking about
00:20:25 so advance is saying is you you can't just recite the same old platitudes forever you need to
00:20:31 address people's real circumstances, because politics involves eternal principles, but it
00:20:37 also involves constantly changing circumstances. And there's this temptation among the establishment
00:20:44 Republicans to just go back to what feels safe. In the 1980s, they would talk about the 1950s.
00:20:50 And now, the way that Republicans talked about the 50s and the 80s and 90s is the same way that
00:20:56 establishment Republicans talk about the 90s today. Because it was back a few decades ago,
00:21:03 and we have nice memories of it and nostalgia's history after a few drinks.
00:21:07 But you can't actually return to the past. You can't return to the past, and we shouldn't want
00:21:12 to return to the past because this is the key. The past contained the seeds for the present.
00:21:20 So there are some Republicans who just want to feel safe. The past, it's over and done with.
00:21:24 we all made it through just fine. Many of the people who talked about the wonders of Ronald
00:21:29 Reagan in the 20 teens and 2020s, many of those people probably would have opposed Ronald Reagan
00:21:34 in the 1980s. Many of them probably would have been Bushies rather than Reaganites.
00:21:37 The same attacks that you see lobbied at Donald Trump, now J.D. Vance, those attacks that he was
00:21:44 a cowboy, that he was reckless, that he's uneducated, he's unsophisticated, that he's
00:21:48 Nazi, these insinuations of bigotry. Those were all the same attacks that were lobbied against
00:21:54 Reagan in the 70s and 80s. And so people want to return to the past because it feels kind of safe.
00:22:00 There's something deeply conservative about that, but you're going to lose
00:22:03 because the past contained the seeds of the present. So if we rewind the clock back to 1999,
00:22:10 guess what would happen? If we left everything the same, we would end up exactly right back
00:22:13 you're in the same place. So you need to address people's actual concerns. We're not living in the
00:22:19 same time as the 1990s. We've had decades of outsourcing our jobs, of getting rid of American 1.00
00:22:24 manufacturing. That has brought with it some economic benefits. There are economic benefits 0.84
00:22:29 to free trade. There are economic benefits to being the world's global reserve currency.
00:22:34 But there are some downsides too. So it doesn't mean you throw the baby out with the bathwater,
00:22:37 but it means you have to address those downsides. And if all we do is ossify ourselves and just
00:22:42 turn into Republican chat GOP, where we're just reciting the same slogans of the Reagan campaign
00:22:49 and wondering why they're having diminishing marginal returns, you're going to cede the
00:22:53 political order to the socialists. In your pure fight against socialism, in your own self-conception,
00:23:02 pure fight against socialism, you're going to hasten the advent of socialism. Very,
00:23:06 very important point from the VP. Okay, now speaking of the socialists, a lot of women out 1.00
00:23:12 there outside that courtroom defending Luigi Mangione after he pled guilty to one of the
00:23:18 charges against him for murdering the UnitedHealthcare CEO, Brian Thompson. We'll get to
00:23:21 that in a moment. First, I want to tell you about Pure Talk. Go to puretalk.com slash Knowles,
00:23:24 K-N-W-L-E-S. There are certain things worth spending money on. A good suit, prime steak,
00:23:30 a well-crafted mattress, cell phone service, not quite. Your text message does not arrive
00:23:36 more elegantly because you paid $120 for it. I strongly recommend you check out PureTalk. I've
00:23:41 had my PureTalk phone in service for six years now. It's incredible. It's the best towers. I
00:23:46 know you heard like, oh, it's good towers. No, it's the best towers. It's the best service. It's
00:23:50 the best customer service because they're American and they speak English. You get reliable talk,
00:23:54 text, and data without paying an absurd premium for the privilege of sending your family the
00:23:59 same memes. PureTalk is veteran-led, 100% U.S.-based customer service. Makes switching super
00:24:04 simple. Take five minutes, look at what you're currently paying for in wireless, and prepare to
00:24:09 become mildly irritated by your current bill. But don't worry, there's an answer, and the answer is
00:24:13 Pure Talk. Go to puretalk.com slash Knowles, K-N-O-W-L-E-S, to make the switch today to Pure
00:24:20 Talk. Do it right now. You will not regret it. Go to puretalk.com slash Knowles, K-N-O-W-L-E-S,
00:24:28 to start saving. So Luigi Mangione has pled guilty to a federal charge. He didn't plead
00:24:34 guilty to the state charge of murdering Brian Thompson, the UnitedHealthcare CEO. He pled
00:24:38 guilty to the federal charge of interstate stalking. The reason he pled guilty to that
00:24:43 is to try to get out of the state murder charge because we have a principle in American
00:24:49 jurisprudence against double jeopardy about being tried for the same crime twice. It comes from the
00:24:54 Fifth Amendment. However, certain states beef up the double jeopardy protections,
00:25:00 including New York State, where Luigi Mangione is facing charges. So what the Mangione defense
00:25:07 is hoping, I don't think they're going to succeed, but what they're hoping is, okay,
00:25:11 plead guilty to the federal charge, the lesser charge of interstate stalking to try to get out
00:25:18 of the tougher charge, which is the state murder charge. Now you would say, okay, you got all of
00:25:22 Mangione's supporters, all these crazy women standing outside the classroom, outside of the 0.99
00:25:25 courtroom. And you'd think, okay, well, now that he's pled guilty to one of the charges,
00:25:29 surely they're going to give up, right? Surely they're going to recant of their support for
00:25:33 Luigi. Not so. Here's what one of them says. Do you think it's wrong that he murdered someone
00:25:40 regardless of why he did it? Everyone has a different opinion. And I'm not going to say
00:25:46 it was wrong or right, because I do think I exist within a gray area of the opinions around this
00:25:51 case but I see it more as a revolutionary act of protest of the likes of which we haven't seen
00:25:55 since the civil rights era. My reactions in court? Relief I guess is the word. I think for a very
00:26:03 long time people have ascribed this idea that supporters are painting him out to be guilty by
00:26:09 having conversations about the health care industry so to no longer have to fight that battle
00:26:14 is satisfying and relieving. He has a lot of battles to fight. I want him to be happy and
00:26:20 healthy. But I want America to continue questioning our current predicaments and why we allow our
00:26:26 futures to be stolen away by oligarchs. The online bros who campaign for repeal of the 19th
00:26:31 Amendment, they have met their spokeswoman. Here she is. This is it. The face of 19th Amendment
00:26:37 repeal. And there are a bunch of women like her outside the courtroom. I was a little tough on the 1.00
00:26:42 white liberal women earlier. I can't tell. She's white-ish. I can't quite. Maybe has a hint of 1.00
00:26:46 Persian to her. But I think she passes. She's probably got lighter skin than I do. She says, 0.93
00:26:51 no, no, no. Just because he pled guilty, no, that doesn't mean I don't support him anymore.
00:26:56 And she makes a point that actually goes deeper than the psychological irritations of unhinged 0.99
00:27:03 women. She makes a point that actually goes down to leftist philosophy. This isn't just for the 0.96
00:27:09 women. This is the most ardent revolutionary communist man. Hassan Piker would make the
00:27:14 same argument and has made the same argument, which is, no, no, no. I support him because
00:27:20 he pled guilty. I support him because he committed the crime. I don't think in my delusions that he's
00:27:26 being framed or something. I like that he killed the innocent healthcare CEO. I like that. That's
00:27:32 a revolutionary act of protest. That's not just some frivolous, hysterical woman that you can 1.00
00:27:39 write off. One, those people vote. But two, that is what the leaders of the American left are 1.00
00:27:46 openly saying. When Hassan Piker comes out and says, we need to murder Republican senators 0.94
00:27:51 because they're Republicans. We need the blood to run red with, sorry, we need the streets to 0.98
00:27:56 run red with capitalist blood. America deserved 9-11. When Hassan Piker says that, Hassan Piker
00:28:01 is campaigning with all these prominent Democrat politicians right now, who is effectively the
00:28:06 thought leader of the democrat party in the american left when when they say that they mean
00:28:12 it and it's it's not you can't i don't think it's unfair to just point to hassan piker we saw this
00:28:18 after the murder of charlie kirk after the murder of charlie kirk you saw huge swaths of the democrat
00:28:23 party justifying and celebrating political violence and you saw it i'm not even yes we saw
00:28:28 it when the democrat strategist on tv was blaming charlie for his own murder before his body was
00:28:32 cold. We saw that on MSNBC. Yes, we've seen politicians and activists all justifying,
00:28:39 excusing, minimizing the murder of Charlie. But you saw it because that lady who sits next to
00:28:44 you at work, she posted about it on Facebook. You saw it because those kids in your classroom,
00:28:49 they defended the murder of Charlie. You saw it because you saw it reflected in the public
00:28:54 opinion polls that showed that something like 28% of young Democrats, young leftists,
00:28:58 justified the murder. That's what we're up against. It's why I lose a little bit of patience
00:29:04 with the kind of absurd activist attacks. Mostly J.D. Vance is getting it right now,
00:29:10 but the intra-Republican party firing squad here. It's why I lose a little patience with it because
00:29:16 people just have totally lost a conception of where the enemy really lies, where the real
00:29:21 threat to our way of life really lies. Now, speaking of death, this is kind of a depressing
00:29:28 show, isn't it? Well, this one should really make us rethink how we think about ethics more
00:29:33 generally. This is a story that occurred months ago, eight or nine months ago. But it's starting
00:29:40 to get a little of attention right now. This is from Australia. LifeSite News is reporting on it.
00:29:45 And what LifeSite News is reporting, where is it? Here we go. Is that for the first time ever,
00:29:51 doctors have harvested a woman's organs after they killed her in an assisted suicide.
00:29:58 So we have organ harvesting based on the dubious medical concept of brain death.
00:30:04 Brain death, which is not the same as death.
00:30:06 Brain death is a kind of political term that emerged in the 1960s
00:30:13 to solve a problem that certain unethical doctors were contemplating in the 1960s.
00:30:20 With the advent of technology that could allow us to transfer organs from one person to another,
00:30:24 with the widespread use of this technology, there came this question, well, okay, when can we bring
00:30:28 the organs to the new person, to the person who needs them? Because once a person dies,
00:30:34 the organs very quickly lose their vitality. So the best way to transfer an organ is from a living
00:30:39 person, but it would be unethical to harvest the organs from a living person. So what can we do?
00:30:45 okay, well, we'll declare the person dead before the person actually meets the criteria of death.
00:30:50 In other words, we'll redefine death. When it comes to organ harvesting, organ transplants,
00:30:56 when it comes to the case of brain death, what actually kills the patients in brain death is not
00:31:01 their brains. It's not some natural phenomenon. It is the harvesting of organs. It's when the
00:31:07 doctors either pull the plug or when they start to harvest the organs. And there have been really
00:31:11 scary stories that have come out of this. People waking up, you know, people who are showing signs
00:31:15 of life while their organs are being harvested. Fair bit of evidence that they feel some pain
00:31:19 while this is happening. Really ghastly stuff that requires a serious ethical review. But you
00:31:23 got that on the one hand, the organ harvesting. Then you have this other just absolutely hellish
00:31:29 medical innovation, which is assisted suicide, where doctors who take a Hippocratic oath first
00:31:34 to do no harm are actually the ones who are helping to kill the patients. This is a complete
00:31:39 inversion, a satanic inversion of the medical field. And now it's very widespread. America's
00:31:43 evil top hat Canada practices it all the time. It's why now 5% plus of Canadians each year die
00:31:49 of a doctor-assisted suicide. So this is combining the two. In Australia, I think this was in January.
00:31:57 In Australia, a woman says she's going to kill herself. The justice system, which should prevent
00:32:05 from doing that because it is totally contrary to the natural law. It is totally contrary to
00:32:10 civil statutes in all civilized societies. Nevertheless, the government says, okay,
00:32:14 we'll help you kill yourself. And then they say, oh, you know what? We need some of those organs. 0.99
00:32:18 Those organs could be put to good use. They might even have good intentions, but they say,
00:32:21 oh, you know what we're going to do? We're going to kill this person and then harvest her organs 1.00
00:32:24 and give them to other people. And I think most people realize there's something wrong with this, 1.00
00:32:31 isn't it? First of all, there's probably a reason this is the first time that this has ever happened.
00:32:35 as a matter of policy. And you say, why hasn't anyone ever thought of this before? Oh,
00:32:38 because it's obviously evil. Okay. Even people who are not particularly religious,
00:32:42 who don't care that much about bioethics, everyone feels a little squeamish about this,
00:32:45 right? We just depressed people come into the doctor instead of helping the person.
00:32:48 We just say, okay, we're going to kill you. And ooh, look at all those good organs. And 0.97
00:32:52 if you're the doctor here, think about it from their perspective. Think about it with a little
00:32:57 sympathy. You say, well, there's no use in letting all these good organs go to waste.
00:33:01 We're either going to throw them into the dirt or we're going to help people who are sick,
00:33:04 who need new organs. So what would be so wrong about harvesting these organs? We don't want
00:33:10 them to go to waste anyway. This is, to me, the perfect example of the ghastliness of consequentialist
00:33:16 ethics, the kind of ethics that says that the ends justify the means, that good ends justify
00:33:22 evil means. Well, look, I mean, yeah, I don't know. Look, I mean, it's probably not good to
00:33:27 kill yourself, but look, it's a liberal society. This is a liberalism. You get to do what you want
00:33:32 to do. Consent is the only thing that matters. All that we aim at is maximizing individual autonomy.
00:33:37 So if you want to kill yourself, by golly, that's your right. That's your natural right to kill 0.99
00:33:42 yourself. Of course it's not. That would be totally contrary to anything serious natural 1.00
00:33:46 law theorists, the developers of natural rights and philosophy, the framers of the constitution,
00:33:52 any serious person would ever think there's no natural right to kill yourself. They say, well,
00:33:56 look, liberalism tells us autonomy is all that matters. So you're going to kill yourself. 1.00
00:33:59 And that's kind of, maybe we say that's bad, but can't legislate morality, except all the time 0.98
00:34:05 because we necessarily legislate morality. But in this case, we're going to go hands off. We're
00:34:09 going to pretend to be neutral. And oh, you know what? Some good can come out of that evil.
00:34:14 And maybe even we're going to start committing evil. You know, these old people who they don't 1.00
00:34:18 have much longer to live anyway, these sick people, these depressed people who were just 1.00
00:34:21 a leech on society, these mentally deficient people, these disabled people, you know what? 1.00
00:34:26 they're not living great lives. From my perspective, they're not living great lives. 1.00
00:34:30 The guy, he's missing a limb. That guy, he's got a little touch of dementia. His life isn't really
00:34:35 worth it. His organs would be put to much better use in the body of that young person who got into
00:34:42 a car accident. So you know what we're going to do? We're going to maybe encourage you a little
00:34:45 bit to kill yourself. We're going to help you kill yourself. Then we're going to take your organs and 1.00
00:34:48 put it into someone who we deem more worthy of them. You see how that works. So what is the
00:34:54 answer to that. What the leftists say, and what some of the confused people on the right would
00:34:59 say is, well, we just need more regulations around this. Well, we just need to make sure
00:35:02 there are guardrails. There never are guardrails. Look at how assisted suicide has worked in Europe.
00:35:07 It started out with, it's only going to be the very eldest people in the most pain
00:35:10 with seconds to live. We're going to give them a little extra morphine. Now they're killing
00:35:15 young people who are simply depressed. They're killing elderly people against their will, 0.72
00:35:19 having to hold them down while they kill them in the Netherlands. It's a horrible case in Belgium.
00:35:24 uh, the slippery slope, you just slip down that slope immediately. So what's the answer? The
00:35:29 answer is you need a different ethical system. This consequentialist idea, which you see in
00:35:36 utilitarianism, which you see in just trying to calculate the greatest good for the greatest
00:35:40 number of people, forgetting about the actual morality of any actions or the moral character
00:35:44 of the people who perform the actions, that has failed. That has led us to this. We're not going
00:35:50 to rewind the clock 30 years and fix all the problems because the seeds of this destruction
00:35:53 were already present 30 years ago.
00:35:55 Frankly, the seeds of this destruction
00:35:56 were present 200 years ago.
00:35:59 What is necessary is a re-examination
00:36:02 of our moral calculus.
00:36:04 It relates exactly what J.D. Vance
00:36:06 is talking about on economics.
00:36:08 We don't want to rewind the clock.
00:36:09 We don't want to give up
00:36:11 and adopt the opinions of our opponents,
00:36:12 God forbid.
00:36:13 We just want to recognize
00:36:15 we may have made some mistakes here.
00:36:17 It's a fallen world.
00:36:18 We all make mistakes
00:36:18 and we need to correct those mistakes.
00:36:20 And in this case, the mistake is
00:36:22 So, assisted suicide, to some degree, organ harvesting, there you have to really, really draw a firm line on what the ethical, what the line of transgression would be.
00:36:37 It's not just putting up guardrails, it's actually determining what is death, how do we protect life, which leads into all sorts of other questions like abortion, which leads into IVF, because IVF almost always entails abortion.
00:36:49 It requires a total revolution in ethical thought, and ultimately, it probably means returning to some of the wisdom of the past.
00:36:59 There's a lot of talk right now in the American right about this horrible idea of post-liberalism or a return.
00:37:05 What that really means is a return to the classical political tradition.
00:37:08 What it ultimately means is just saying like, huh, maybe Aristotle had a point.
00:37:12 Maybe Aristotle, Cicero, maybe Thomas Aquinas, St. Augustine, maybe the founding fathers and the framers.
00:37:19 to a large degree, had a point, and we shouldn't have thrown out all of their wisdom.
00:37:24 Well, what's the alternative? The alternative is you're going to keep getting this.
00:37:27 Get ready for granny to get her organs harvested. Get ready for your cousin to get her organs 0.99
00:37:31 harvested if she feels a little depressed. Okay, now speaking of violence, I do want to get back
00:37:35 to Hassan Piker because the left is doubling down on its support of Hassan Piker, and I couldn't be
00:37:40 happier about it. First, though, do Catholics worship Mary? Does the church believe that the 0.68
00:37:47 Old Testament prophets were frauds. Could God make a burrito so expensive that even he couldn't
00:37:51 afford it? Almost always going to X for those answers is a bad idea, unless you were discussing
00:37:57 those questions with his eminence, Cardinal Burke, one of the great men of the church,
00:38:02 over a 15-year-old scotch. Now, coincidentally, that's exactly what we did in the latest episode
00:38:06 of Off the Clock. Real posts from X, your actual questions answered by one of the most important
00:38:11 leaders in the Catholic Church. Check out this teaser. Could God make a burrito so expensive
00:38:16 that he could not buy it.
00:38:18 I think there actually is a serious theological question hidden in there.
00:38:22 They say, can God make a square or circle? 0.98
00:38:24 Well, it's a ridiculous question. 0.86
00:38:26 A circle is a circle and a square is a square. 0.95
00:38:28 God doesn't contradict himself.
00:38:30 See, this is evidence as to why I want to ask my questions
00:38:32 instead of taking them from Twitter.
00:38:46 from internet trolls to serious theological questions from people like ruslan kd cardinal
00:38:53 burke responds to a wide range of questions alongside michael knowles watch full episode
00:38:57 now on the michael knowles youtube channel my favorite comment yesterday is from hard-boiled
00:39:02 entertainment the fact that jd vance has anticipated aoc being the democrat candidate
00:39:06 should tell us he's preparing to face her properly yeah i hope that's what it means i suspect that is
00:39:10 what it means. I was actually, I was really impressed with Vance's call on the AOC thing,
00:39:16 because I was surprised. I thought he, when I asked Vance, who do you think the leading
00:39:20 candidate is? I thought he'd say Gavin Newsom or somebody. When he said AOC, I said, are you sure?
00:39:24 I don't know about, I don't know if that's true. Are you, is that a little too online? Is that,
00:39:28 and then sure enough, within a couple of weeks, you see polls come out, AOC was leading the pack.
00:39:32 It was impressive. Sure, he's got a pretty good political gut, which I guess you would expect as
00:39:37 a guy who came from absolutely nothing and then rose up the ranks and made a huge name for himself
00:39:44 became a U.S. senator and vice president. Yeah, you'd expect he'd have a pretty good political
00:39:48 gut, but the AOC call was an impressive one. Okay. Hassan Piker, getting back to Hassan Piker.
00:39:55 Hassan Piker is this left-wing, very, very radical provocateur who has called for violence
00:40:00 against conservatives repeatedly and said America deserves 9-11. Now, he has been, he's campaigned
00:40:06 Democrat candidates, and he has been identified as one of the real leaders of the Democrat party,
00:40:10 perhaps the thought leader on the Democrat side. Now, if I were a Democrat consultant,
00:40:17 what I would do as Republicans are making that accusation, what I would do is say, 0.98
00:40:22 no way, that's ridiculous. You guys are making a boogeyman. We don't care that much about Hassan 0.98
00:40:26 Piker. He's an edgy streamer. He's got his little place in the entertainment field,
00:40:32 but he's not really helping to lead the party.
00:40:34 You guys are attacking a straw man.
00:40:37 But that's not what the Democrats are doing.
00:40:40 They're embracing him.
00:40:43 Mamdani embraces him.
00:40:44 Abdul El-Sayed embraces him.
00:40:47 All of these candidates, AOC, embrace him.
00:40:48 They all embrace him.
00:40:50 Now you have Mehdi Hassan,
00:40:52 my former debate opponent from Dartmouth.
00:40:54 If you want to check out that debate,
00:40:55 I think it's on the Dartmouth Political Union YouTube page.
00:40:58 Mehdi is the author of a book.
00:41:00 I think the title is How to Win Every Debate or something like that. And so you can check out our
00:41:05 debate from Dartmouth, which you might recall I did win. They scored it at the end. And anyway,
00:41:11 no, there's no reason to bring that up. I did in fact win the debate against the guy who wrote
00:41:15 the book about how to win every debate. But anyway, Mehdi Hassan, he's had a TV show.
00:41:19 He's a prominent voice on the left. Mehdi Hassan brings Hassan Piker. There are a lot of Hassans
00:41:24 on the left these days. 1.00
00:41:25 Mehdi Hassan brings Hassan Piker onto his show
00:41:29 not to create distance
00:41:32 between the mainstream Democrats and Hassan Piker,
00:41:35 but to launder Hassan Piker's views.
00:41:41 Classic one they throw at you.
00:41:42 America deserved 9-11.
00:41:44 You've withdrawn that comment, I believe.
00:41:46 Yeah, I said it in 2019.
00:41:48 And if you listen to the full conversation,
00:41:51 you very quickly understand what I'm talking about.
00:41:53 you're talking about foreign policy blowback yeah we're talking about foreign policy blowback 0.92
00:41:57 you could have phrased it better because it sounds like you're saying people deserve to die
00:42:00 of course we don't believe that again in 2019 and then immediately i'm i'm uh you know all over
00:42:05 fox news and and getting you know an unbelievable amount of death threats i'm a big boy i can handle
00:42:10 it it is what it is but uh i i you know went on the young turks and famously was like i should
00:42:15 have phrased things uh better i apologize for those who i've offended and i most importantly
00:42:20 apologize uh for for giving an opportunity the right to just like use this this is a seven-year-old
00:42:26 clip that you've already explained disowned i i have the same issue there clips of me that i've
00:42:29 had to talk about yeah oh my goodness it couldn't be a worse response good for us but it couldn't
00:42:36 be a worse response from the left mediasan brings mediasan who you know he's an educated guy he's
00:42:41 well-spoken guy he's pretty radical but he's i don't know he is mainstream by the standards of
00:42:46 the left. I guess so is Sasan Piker. So he brings him on. He says, now, come on. Come on. You just
00:42:51 said, I know it's this old clip. There's no evidence you've changed your views, but it's
00:42:55 an old clip where you say America deserved 9-11. Now, come on. I mean, what'd you really mean by 0.68
00:42:59 that? And what does Sasan Piker say? He says, I meant America deserved 9-11. That's what I meant.
00:43:06 I mean, yeah, maybe I shouldn't have said it that way, but the only reason I shouldn't have
00:43:09 said it that way is because it gave an opening for the right to attack me.
00:43:11 and he doesn't say i shouldn't have said it because it was wrong to say i didn't i shouldn't
00:43:17 have said it because america doesn't deserve 9-11 no no i shouldn't have said it because
00:43:21 i was being too honest i let the right attack me and then his interlocutor the much more moderate
00:43:28 mainstream media son says yeah yeah you're right yeah you probably shouldn't have said it that i
00:43:32 did that did give an opening oh wait anyway never mind
00:43:34 the party that we are running against in the midterms the party of the mainstream nominees 0.99
00:43:43 and the candidates and all that is happy that 3 000 american civilians were murdered by muslim 0.98
00:43:51 terrorists they're happy about it that's not an exaggeration as long as sarum piker doesn't
00:43:59 doesn't doesn't recant his views by the way he doubled down on his views like a month ago
00:44:04 remember this like a month ago his son piker goes on his show and says he's just framed
00:44:08 a newspaper cover of the day after 9 11 also you might have noticed something some changes behind
00:44:17 me um i finally framed the cutie cinderella a newspaper from 9 11 the morning of 9 12 the
00:44:26 newspaper right there um the newspaper that covered 9-11 um it's now officially sitting
00:44:34 behind me and i moved the north korean uh poster up uh in in place of the fan art
00:44:43 we're celebrating 9-11 on my show that's what he's saying he's saying yeah i'm so i got you
00:44:51 got a lot of fan art here i love north korea i got my north korea poster and you know what else
00:44:55 You know what else I love? You know what else I think was awesome? 9-11. That was a month ago. And the Democrats keep campaigning with him. So the people we're running against, whatever your quibbles about, I don't like tariffs that much, and I think they should only be implemented sometimes, and I don't know, I think we need to give more support overseas for foreign interventions, or I need a little bit less, or I need your domestic political opponents.
00:45:25 are happy about 9-11. Can you get it together? Can you focus? Sorry, it's not you. I mean,
00:45:34 I'm preaching to the choir, but can we focus? Can we get it together? That's what we're up against.
00:45:43 We want to murder Republican senators. We are going to cheer when your activists are murdered 1.00
00:45:49 for having open exchanges on college campus. And we're thrilled that thousands of Americans
00:45:54 were killed by terrorists on 9-11 that's what they're openly saying and their views
00:46:01 that the views of those honest leftists are being accepted kind of chuckled at by all the other ones
00:46:11 okay there's so much more I want to get to uh Zoran Mamdani was just babbling in Chinese
00:46:16 uh the left is having another another complete freak out over Trump's ballroom they really hate
00:46:22 the ballroom, but they don't even understand what the ballroom is. It's Music Monday, though.
00:46:26 The rest of the show continues now. You do not want to miss it. Become a member. Use
00:46:28 code Knowles Canada. WLES to check out for two months free on all annual plans.